Cloud Consumer Banking Point of View Institute for Business Value Partner’s Name, Partner’s Title DD Month YYYY © 2014 IBM Corporation Executive summary Cloud computing offers potential to redefine customer relationships, transform banking operations and expand business potential and capabilities Although slow to initially embrace cloud computing due to privacy and security concerns, banking industry has now adopted cloud starting with private clouds based on its requirements Leading banks have leveraged cloud for • Business model / ecosystem innovation • Revenue model innovation • Operational innovation A structured risk assessment and mitigation strategy will help address security and data privacy concerns as well as compliance issues that may arise due to cloud adoption. Regulatory authorities, recognizing cloud’s potential in banking transformation and enhancing operational efficiencies, are providing guidance to banks in many countries for cloud adoption Banks should have a clear business-linked Cloud strategy that not only transforms its IT function but evaluates new business opportunities leveraging cloud’s potential IBM, with significant experience in helping several banking clients to adopt cloud, is uniquely positioned to help you with innovative cloud based solutions 2 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation 1 Cloud is transforming the business of banking 2 Charting the path for cloud adoption 3 IBM and cloud 3 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Market forces are characterized by headwinds that challenge growth Driving volatile earnings… Turbulent economic conditions 1993 – 2006 average 14.4% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% $ Decreasing returns on equity Need to optimize use of capital Shrinking operating margins Increasing regulations and oversight Rebuild customer trust & marketplace confidence Source: Capital IQ (Top 250 banks), Banker Database, FDIC, Comments from Analyst Reports 4 2013 2012 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 1995 -15% 1994 Evolving consumer expectations 1993 -10% 2011 2Q 2013 10.6% -5% 2009 2010 Intense competition Non-traditional entrants …and increasing operating costs Operating Expenses ($B) 1,821.8 1,850 1,800 1,750 1,700 1,650 1,600 1,550 1,816.5 1,665.9 2008 IBM Institute for Business Value 1,710.6 1,701.0 2009 1,660.6 2010 2011 2012 2013 © 2014 IBM Corporation To overcome these challenges industry leaders must deliver on four key imperatives Create a customer focused enterprise Increase flexibility and streamline operations Drive innovation while managing cost Optimize enterprise risk management Optimize data and leverage analytics to adapt to new behaviors, cultivate trust, and drive profitable growth Improve operating leverage with variable cost structures that increase flexibility and reduce risk Deliver new services quickly that decrease cost per transaction and drive competitive differentiation Maximize return on equity, combat fraud and mitigate operational risk while achieving compliance objectives Cloud computing improves efficiency, expands innovation potential and drives revenue growth 5 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Business is being transformed on three technology enabled dimensions Data The new natural resource Cloud Systems of Engagement Enables new business models Redefines customer relationships Sophisticated analytics across disparate data sources will drive business outcomes Cloud’s “game changing” attributes revolutionize industry value chains, forcing companies to embrace new business models Mobile connectivity, access and participation are growing rapidly Time value of data will enable “speed of insight” and “speed of action” as core differentiators Cloud is enabling transformation of IT and business processes into digital services Data is the new basis of competitive advantage 6 IBM Institute for Business Value Social media is quickly becoming the primary communication & collaboration format Mobile and social enhance speed of responsiveness and personalization © 2014 IBM Corporation There are numerous examples across the industry where cloud has enabled business and operating model innovation • Barclays1 “Pingit” cloud based mobile payment platform and service launched in seven months • A private cloud helps Pingit deploy features 12x faster • Pingit puts Barclays 2 years ahead of other UK bank cashless capabilities with 2.5M downloads and a rich set of features and functions for consumers, small business and corporate clients • Fidor2 is a “cloud native” bank built on a cloud ecosystem of financial product providers • The bank built it’s own API centric core bank platform • Social media is used exclusively for acquisition, retention, cross sell, R&D • Fidor has a community of 300k+ users and 65k+ customers (Aug 2014) • IT cost per user is $15US, average CpC is $32US (Aug 2014) • Crédit Agricole3 created a platform that allows 3rd parties to co-create apps with CA customers. • Customers that want to use the apps are charged $1 a month to secure their data. • There are 20+ apps and the majority of fees go to the developers. • Customers are getting the latest technology and the bank is tapping into open innovation. Source: See speaker notes 7 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud fosters capabilities that traditional computing can’t… Cloud characteristics and technologies Essential characteristics of cloud 1 Broad network access Rapid elasticity On-demand self service Measured service Resource pooling Technologies enabling cloud Virtualization Provisioning and Orchestration Service automation Usage tracking Web 2.0 / SOA Expands business capabilities Cost flexibility Business Scalability Market adaptability Masked complexity Context-driven variability Ecosystem connectivity Enabling Industry / Business model innovation – create new industry ecosystem or disintermediate an existing value chain Revenue model innovation – create new products and services or utilize new channels or payment models Operational innovation – maintain competitive parity and place in existing value chain Source: [1] National Institute for Standards and Technology, US 8 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud adoption by banks delivers efficiencies, growth and competitive advantage Business model innovation Third-party services can be extended into bank ecosystem Open collaboration and sharing can be expanded Innovation can be introduced across systemically Revenue model innovation Operational innovation Customer relationships can be more readily monetized Simple and faster processes drive internal efficiency Time to market can be enhanced Reduced complexity enables more data to manage risk Value-added services from partners can be more easily introduced IT capacity can be readily aligned to business volumes Cloud enables individual bank integrated, compelling customer experiences…….in so doing, first mover banks are more likely to lock-in customers impeding foothold for new entrants 9 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM helps leading banks capture the benefits of cloud Business model innovation 180 Countries connected enabling trade Eurobank1, a large Greek bank created a Cloud-based multi-lateral trade offering between Greek businesses & their international trading counterparts across 180 countries. Revenue model innovation and % US$30k more volume 34 per month Signature Mortgage Corporation2 implemented a cloud-based integrated collaboration mortgage solution, so customers can apply and complete loans electronically. Operational innovation reduction % Cost and faster time 35 to market A large bank implemented a cloud environment that delivers personalized product offers across multiple channels to customers in real-time. Source: See speaker notes 10 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud accelerates time to market, enhancing customer experience Using a combination of cloud delivered services, can create “as a service” components to analyze data from social media SaaS: Enterprisegrade business apps to accelerate innovation IaaS: Self-service configurable IT infrastructure resources 1. Define development environment The bank partnered with IBM to quickly develop, test and deploy applications using IBM PureApplication System, MobileFirst, Bluemix and API catalog 2. Add database service Bank was able to Reduce development provisioning from days to less than 30 minutes Shorten development cycles from 6 weeks to 2 Deliver innovative customer service tools 3. Extract & feed social media data into database 4. Add social analytics service 5. Add Monitoring service instance 6. Provision resources and secure the service Iterate PaaS: Rapid app development through composable services and APIs IBM is helping Tangerine Bank, the leading digital bank in Canada operate a device agnostic Mobile Bank, allowing freedom of choice for their customers We give our customers what they need and are challenging the status quo And we’re challenging the banking industry through our innovation and technology Peter Aceto, Chief Executive, Tangerine Bank Source: See speaker notes 11 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation As banks evolve with cloud adoption, business users will be able to design and prototype applications quickly Organizations are benefiting from new user-driven, mobile and cloud-centric IT Cloud is transforming Enterprise IT functions, roles and responsibilities Business Managers are increasingly using cloud for application development to enhance agility IT departments need to • be “Managers” of Corporate information assets spread across different suppliers and multi-tenant ecosystem • facilitate and broker the sources of IT resources that enhance business value without loss of control Cloud enables collaboration with business users, developers, architects, and designers Vendors / CSPs provide no-code or low-code alternatives to compose / build apps Cloud speeds up prototyping and testing the application with internal business users or a select set of customers Business Manager Finalize requirements Design Develop / compose application Test application Deploy application Cloud service provider (CSP) Source: See speaker notes 12 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation 1 Cloud is transforming the business of banking 2 Charting the path for cloud adoption 3 IBM and cloud 13 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Enterprise Cloud Adoption Structured process helps banks to determine how to adopt cloud Selection – Prioritization – Quantification – Migration Cloud First New project New project Replace existing app / infra BPaaS PaaS SaaS IaaS Business case Migrate existing workloads Select Prioritize Workload analysis 14 Evaluate a blend of cloud options that best suit the project requirements IBM Institute for Business Value Quantify Migrate Migration Plan Wave 1 Wave 2 Wave 3 © 2014 IBM Corporation Banks can start cloud adoption with quick wins Selection – Prioritization – Quantification – Migration Total addressable market (TAM) for cloud computing software Application category TAM $ bn Collaboration $30.7 Email & Office Productivity $20.7 CRM $16.4 Security $9.9 HCM $8.2 Supply chain management $7.1 Travel & Expense Management $2.7 IT Service Management $3.0 Analytics $2.9 Finance & Accounting $1.4 Digital Marketing Total Addressable Market (TAM) Banks can look at these application categories for cloud adoption where Deployment ease is higher Security and data privacy issues are lower A variety of Software as a Service (SaaS) offerings are available in the market Banks can start realizing business benefits through these quick wins while planning for industry applications that may require significant efforts for cloud migration $21.0 $124.0 Source: BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research 2013 15 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Selection – Banks leverage born-on-cloud solutions to quickly realize business benefits and gain momentum in cloud adoption Customer relationship management Enterprise risk management (ERM) Sourcing and Contract Management RCI Banque Spain1 works with IBM to implement Oracle CRM software as a Software-as-a-Service solution. Today, the company can identify customers whose loans and similar financial contracts are coming to an end, and make timely, personalized offers, greatly reducing the threat of competitors stealing their clients and increasing renewals and new business. Wind Info2 will incorporate IBM's cloud-based risk management software, IBM Algo Risk Service on Cloud, and the locally installed IBM Algo One Risk Aggregator directly into its Trading Terminals. This hybrid solution will conduct sophisticated risk data processing in the cloud while keeping all client position data protected and confidential within the boundaries of China, an important requirement of Chinese law. A Swiss investment banking client3 implemented IBM’s Cloud-enabled Emptoris SaaS solution to streamline and automate their sourcing, contracting, risk & compliance processes. The client is expecting a savings of $159M as a result of adopting SaaS solution Source: See speaker notes 16 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Selection – A bank has a set of services, functions and processes across six domains to run and manage a bank Strategy & Insight Strategy & Governance Business Strategy & Resource Planning Front office and Channel Management Management Sales & Servicing Distribution Planning Relationship Oversight & Management Channel Operations Strategic Change Governance Marketing Customer Insight Customer Analysis & Models Customer Profile Contact / Event History Customer Probity Check Trading Brand & Segment Management Proposition Development Product Development Product Catalogue Channel Planning & Development Product Operations Planning & Development Processing / Back office Common Application Processing Statements & Correspondence Document Management Customer Fulfilment Product Accounting Transactions Market Info Collections & recovery Underlying Asset Procurement & Management Complaint & Exception Handling Customer Maint Ops Mgmnt Specific Cheque Processing Reconciliation Card Processing Cash Inventory Transaction Execution Merchant Operations Payments Transaction Authorization Treasury back office Trade Finance specific Processing Billing Fraud / AML Detection Cash Managmnt Clearing & Settlement Custody & Other specific processing Helpdesk Services Human Resource Management Risk Risk Portfolio Management Lending Policy & Planning Finance Financial Control & Consolidation Performance Management & Reporting Finance Policies Fixed Asset Register Accounting / GL Treasury Compliance Support Services Systems Development & Operations Risk & Financial Management Asset / Liability Policy & Planning Product Factory Campaign Execution Campaign Management Market Insight Segment Analysis Transaction Capture Services Corresponde nt Banking Brand & Product Management Public Relations Market Research Deal Structuring (Securitization / Syndication) Servicing Routing & Tracking Business & IT Architecture Acquisition & Alliance Planning Sales Customer Information Management Distribution Performance Management Distribution Support Audit/QA/Legal Facilities Operation & Maintenance Procurement Business Policies & Procedures Source: IBM’s Component Business Model for Banking 17 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Selection – Of the dozens of business services essential to financial organizations today… Strategy & Insight Strategy & Governance Business Strategy & Resource Planning Front office and Channel Management Management Relationship Oversight & Management Channel Operations Sales & Servicing Distribution Planning Distribution Performance Management Business & IT Architecture Acquisition & Alliance Planning Strategic Change Governance Servicing Routing & Tracking Transaction Capture Services Marketing Brand & Segment Management Campaign Management Proposition Development Market Research Application Statements & Market Info Processing Correspondence Document Product Collections & Management Accounting recovery Customer Underlying Asset Procurement & Fulfilment Management Complaint & Customer Ops Mgmnt Exception Handling Maint Customer Profile Contact / Event History Corresponde nt Banking Trading Customer Probity Check Product Development Product Catalogue Channel Planning & Development Transactions Cheque Processing Cash Inventory Product Operations Planning & Development Payments Billing Specific Reconciliation Transaction Execution Transaction Authorization Fraud / AML Detection Card Processing Merchant Operations Treasury back office Cash Managmnt Custody & Other specific processing Helpdesk Services Human Resource Management Risk Risk Portfolio Management Lending Policy & Planning Finance Financial Control & Consolidation Performance Management & Reporting Finance Policies Campaign Management = Cloudable / yes, 100%, cost savings 30% to 80% Fixed Asset Register Trade Finance specific Processing Accounting / GL Clearing & Settlement Treasury Compliance Support Services Systems Development & Operations Risk & Financial Management Asset / Liability Policy & Planning Processing / Back office Market Insight Customer Analysis & Models Deal Structuring (Securitization / Syndication) Product Factory Campaign Execution Common Customer Insight Sales Customer Information Management Brand & Product Management Public Relations Segment Analysis Distribution Support Audit/QA/Legal Facilities Operation & Maintenance Procurement Business Policies & Procedures …IBM can help you identify those that can be delivered and consumed most efficiently, effectively and securely over the cloud. 18 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Selection – Cloud workload analysis helps banks determine cloudable functions and processes High-level representative view of banking functions and processes Strategy & Insight Front office and Channel Management Bank provides the following inputs Servers and Operating systems Location distribution Overall storage Non functional requirements (NFR) Application and workload data Current costs Input/output, disk and utilization mapping 19 Brand & Product Management Processing / Back office Risk & Financial Management Support Services Cloud service provider can provide the following inputs Target cloud configuration Target cloud NFR Historical data Cloud workload analysis NFRs examination Target cloud cost Operating system and software compatibility IBM Institute for Business Value Migration difficulty © 2014 IBM Corporation Prioritization – Some banking functions and activities are more conducive to cloud than others CATEGORY 1 – READY FOR CLOUD CATEGORY 2 – NOT READY FOR CLOUD Characteristics A third category relates to workloads that require individual analysis and may be ready for cloud Standardized applications Apps that require on-premise data (that cannot be migrated to cloud) Self-contained workloads High degree of customization Example workloads are Applications developed using Service oriented architecture Legacy systems Isolated workloads Complex application integration Apps that need high performance Preproduction systems Batch processing Example workloads Analytics Sensitive data Collaboration Highly customized Infrastructure compute & storage Not yet virtualized third-party software Workplace desktop and devices Complex processes and transactions Business processes Regulation sensitive Disaster recovery Legacy industry applications Development and test Source: IBM cloud implementation projects and analysis 20 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Prioritization – A cloud readiness assessment shows 35% of existing workloads can be moved to cloud More ready for cloud Front office and Channel Management Strategy & Insight Strategy & Governance Business Strategy & Resource Planning Management Sales & Servicing Distribution Planning Relationship Oversight & Management Distribution Performance Management Channel Operations Business & IT Architecture Acquisition & Alliance Planning Strategic Change Governance Customer Insight Customer Analysis & Models Customer Profile Contact / Event History Sales Customer Information Management Servicing Routing & Tracking Transaction Capture Services Marketing Deal Structuring (Securitization / Syndication) Corresponde nt Banking Trading Customer Probity Check Proposition Development Product Development Product Catalogue Channel Planning & Development Product Operations Planning & Development Processing / Back office Common Application Processing Document Management Customer Fulfilment Statements & Correspondence Transactions Market Info Product Accounting Collections & recovery Underlying Asset Procurement & Management Complaint & Exception Handling Customer Maint Ops Mgmnt Not ready for cloud Risk & Financial Management Risk Risk Portfolio Management Lending Policy & Planning Asset / Liability Policy & Planning Product Factory Campaign Execution Campaign Management Brand & Segment Management Market Insight Segment Analysis Distribution Support Brand & Product Management Public Relations Market Research May be ready for cloud Specific Cheque Processing Reconciliation Card Processing Cash Inventory Transaction Execution Merchant Operations Payments Transaction Authorization Treasury back office Trade Finance specific Processing Billing Fraud / AML Detection Cash Managmnt Clearing & Settlement Custody & Other specific processing Finance Financial Control & Consolidation Performance Management & Reporting Finance Policies Fixed Asset Register Accounting / GL Treasury Compliance Support Services Audit/QA/Legal Systems Development & Operations Helpdesk Services Human Resource Management Facilities Operation & Maintenance Procurement Business Policies & Procedures NOTE: The above is a representative example only 21 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Quantification – A 35% partial workload migration to cloud helps bank improve its profits and reduce costs 16,000 15,843 9,105 A representative bank’s financials overview (to illustrate impact of cloud migration) 9,325 14,000 12,000 $ million 10,000 8,000 6,000 5,693 1,045 366 220 825 5693 Op. Costs (excl IT costs) **IT Costs Current Costs for cloudable workloads Projected Savings Projected IT Costs Projected Op. Costs (excl IT Costs) 4,000 2,000 0 Revenue PBIT Projected PBIT Improvements in banking operations Enhanced customer centric operations Increased collaboration, capability & reach Focused selling Increased efficiency with rapid turnaround time Shorter time to market Enhanced service orientation ** IT Costs is estimated at 6.6% of revenue using Gartner’s IT Key Metrics data Note: The above is a representative example only 22 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Migration – Cloud migration from architecture through implementation 1 Create Cloud strategy, architecture and plans Determine the organization goals, platform requirements & complexity associated Develop enterprise cloud strategy, options available and roadmap Envision the cloud architecture that will support cloud initiatives Update IT Strategy and IT plans to align them with cloud strategy 2 Identify and prioritize workloads 3 Determine cloud deployment options 4 Develop Cloud business case Define business drivers to prioritize use cases for cloud Define multi-sourcing models and cloud vendor selection criteria Develop cloud cost models including transition Implement a CloudFirst strategy to evaluate right blend of cloud options for new projects Assess and determine how to best leverage the options of private, public and hybrid delivery models Finalize a cloud business case and examine its ROI including time required for initial payback Assess and evaluate from the current applications, the best candidates for cloud Develop Cloud Service Catalog, SLAs and KPIs 5 Prepare for implementation Prepare infrastructure for cloud Develop Cloud Risk Management plan and policies Security and Compliance plan and processes Transition plan including workforce transition Assess impact on operating model; identify and plan changes required Determine the applications to be moved to cloud Cloud planning should result in accelerated migration, quick wins and mitigated risks Note: The above shows an overall plan and will include aspects of workload prioritization and migration discussed in other slides 23 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A defined approach and accelerators speed up cloud adoption Strategy 1 2 3 4 Actions for migration Create Cloud strategy, architecture and plans Identify and prioritize workloads Accelerators Develop a vision for cloud, align business – IT objectives & goals Identify changes in Enterprise Architecture and IT plans Use assessment & decision framework as a tool for prioritization Identify bank’s functions, processes and applications that can be moved to cloud Determine cloud deployment options Assess workloads, data, impact on security and compliance Rapidly assess and determine optimal option from private, public and hybrid models Develop Cloud business case Determine models for business case Identify business functions / processes impacted by cloud, business benefits, overall costs, and risks Prepare for implementation 24 5 Acquire / prepare cloud infrastructure Develop Cloud Risk Management plan Develop transition plan including workforce transition Assess impact of cloud on current operating model IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud strategy comprises four elements Strategy 1 2 3 4 5 APPLICATION AND DELIVERY PLATFORMS BUSINESS MODELS ENABLED BY CLOUD Driving agility and productivity for the enterprise; tested strategies to improve life cycle performance Promoting highly competitive initiatives at the enterprise and Industry level INFRASTRUCTURE PLATFORMS DATA PLATFORMS Instantiating well-integrated business intelligence to manage the enterprise Delivering consumable, secure and readily available resources to enable agile execution 25 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Enterprise innovation is realized by integrating new technologies with existing core systems Strategy 1 2 3 4 5 Systems of insight Advanced analytics and cognitive computing systems that harness big data enabling competitive advantage for banks Systems of engagement Leverage mobile and social to transform relationships with customers, employees & citizens Systems of Systems of Insight Insight Systems of record The traditional core systems such as accounting applications and product systems that record key internal data Enterprise Enterprise Innovation Innovatio Systems of Systems Record of Record n Systems of Systems of Engagement Engagement Pervasive Security Intelligence A dynamic approach to threat reduction through a life cycle of prevention, detection and response. Enabled by Cloud Pervasive Security Intelligence 26 Cloud enables leaders to take a systematic approach to integrate these capabilities to drive enterprise innovation IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A phased migration to cloud helps manage risks Prioritization 1 2 3 4 5 Potential migration risks Incorrect analysis and identification of workloads Phased migration approach Discovery Phase Inability to meet non-functional requirements Discover Analyze Incorrect ROI analysis current assets and usage cloud feature / fit topologies & dependencies cloud providers Inadequate preparation of infrastructure / apps for cloud Complex applications’ interoperability & integration platforms and licenses Failure to comply with security, privacy & regulatory requirements SLA’s, security & compliance Management complexity as resources get distributed in a virtualized environment 27 Analysis Phase Migration & Validation Phase Establish the Migration Toolkit Cloud-enable infrastructure & applications contract models Migrate resource sizing Applications, Platforms and Data workloads Infrastructure Operations Services Validate Migration IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Banks can adopt type of cloud that best meets their requirements Deployment options 1 2 3 4 Private cloud 28 5 Hybrid cloud Public cloud Software, hardware and platforms are hosted in a data center owned by a retailer and used by different departments / units inside of the retailer Software, hardware and platforms are hosted both in third party data centers, as well as inside of a retail organization Software, hardware and platforms are hosted externally by a third party vendor who manages all aspects of the services for the organization Value drivers … Value drivers … Value drivers … .… Customization, efficiency, availability, resiliency, security and privacy …… Flexibility and benefits of private and public cloud while addressing data security, governance, compliance and budgetary challenges .…Standardization, capital preservation, flexibility and time to deploy IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Private cloud can help bank reduce its technology spend and Capex Business Case 2 3 4 5 Bank’s total Operating System Image (OSI) requirements Mission critical, 1% Business important, 16% A. Impact on spend Cost comparison chart Cost in USD mn 1 (including 10% YoY increase in OSI images) 20 100% 15 75% 10 5 - 47% 49% 48% 47% 13% Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 50% Traditional computing 25% Private cloud costs 0% % reduction Year 5 ~50% savings from year 2 can be used for strategic initiatives Utility, 61% Development & Test, 21% Source: The above is based on actual business case developed for an IBM banking client and is used here as a representative example. Actual results for other banks will vary 29 Capex / Opex% B. Impact on Opex profile OSI Opex profile 100% 100% 75% 80% 80% 80% 80% 50% 50% 25% 0% 75% 0% 30% Current Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 status Based on agreed workload transition plan IBM Institute for Business Value 25% 0% Capex Opex Opex improvement © 2014 IBM Corporation Security, privacy and compliance concerns can be addressed with cloud Implementation 1 2 3 4 5 Critical elements to address security, privacy and compliance concerns As banks start planning to adopt cloud, key questions come up about their data & apps: Where is our data stored? What about data sovereignty? How does cloud affect our regulatory compliance? BANKS How do we protect our customers’ privacy? IT Strategy Is a business continuity plan available for cloud? Risk Management Plan Monitoring & Auditing CLOUD SERVICE PROVIDER 30 Cloud requirements IBM Institute for Business Value Cloud SLA Risk & Security Management processes Physical & Logical controls implementation Audits & reports © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud is driving a new operating model aligned to business strategy Implementation 1 2 3 4 5 An operating model is a framework for formulating an operations strategy that best deploys and determine the explicit choices needed to achieve business goals BUSINESS GOALS AND STRATEGY Target Operating Model Market shifts in the digital economy necessitate banks to adopt new technologies like cloud, mobile, social media and analytics To succeed with cloud, banks have to assess the impact of cloud on the operating model and all its dimensions and determine what actions are required to make cloud adoption smoother and more successful Customer Experience Sourcing & Alliances Assets & Locations CULTURE Technology TOM Skills & Capabilities Processes Organization & Governance Performance Metrics ROADMAP FOR CHANGE 31 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation 1 Cloud is transforming the business of banking 2 Charting the path for cloud adoption 3 IBM and cloud 32 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Banks are looking for “solutions as a service” – solutions that go way beyond the “software as a service” model The IBM Payments-as-a-Service solution is a cloud based alternative to the expensive option of banks running and maintaining a complex payments engine in house IBM® and Fundtech have partnered to provide such a solution, called Global PAYplus Services Platform™ It represents a collection of rules-driven payment services designed to allow the orchestration of end-toend payment processing, data management, and integration across all channels through back-office systems and clearing and settlement systems, using industry standard interfaces. Fundtech’s Global PAYplus–Services Platform is a shared service framework that includes payments, cash and liquidity management, financial messaging, the financial supply chain Back End Applications Customer Information Systems IBMs FTM product is the orchestration and integration layer, and therefore works with the Fundtech product in this solution. It runs on IBM Power® Systems supported by AIX®, Oracle Java, and Microsoft SQL Server. 33 Accounting System Other • Data Warehouse • Investigations MQ Web Service AML ESB – Routing & Transportation MQ Built on the industry-leading ISV application from Fundtech, hosted on SoftLayer with GBS services wrapped around it Pay-per-use, with guaranteed minimum volumes Customer Balance Checking System FX Engine Capture Pre-processing Files & Payments Bank Operators across different countries Direct Access To GPP IBM Institute for Business Value Payment Processing Engine AT DE Analysis — Validation, matching GPP IT Payments Between multiple countries Decisions — Which clearing to use Fees, FX, balance checks Completion — Accounting, advices © 2014 IBM Corporation SoftLayer has designed and deployed a global, interconnected platform to meet key operational and economic requirements Flexibility, Performance and Automation – Globalization, Transparency and Control. SOFTLAYER CLOUD ARCHITECTURE On demand compute with consumptive billing Common user interface and APIs across a unified platform. Customers can mix and match dedicated, public and private clouds, and manage them from a single control panel Private network provides seamless integration across architectures with low latency Scalable computing with fast provisioning BARE METAL SERVERS PUBLIC (VIRTUALIZED MULTITENANT) CLOUD Better I/O performance (e.g., no “hypervisor tax”) and network Select virtualization of choice Customized configuration allowed Provisioned in minutes Open API standards Higher degree of customization possible for hardware, network, security Direct VPN to private network created instantly Based upon enterprise Citrix Xenserver Lower cost for workloads with high server utilization Better security possible than multi-tenant cloud Lower cost for burst workloads 21,000+ customers in 140 countries 34 PRIVATE (VIRTUALIZED SINGLETENANT) CLOUD 22,000,000 domains IBM Institute for Business Value Customer can select DC / POD 100,000+ devices 34 © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM is serving the cloud computing imperatives in banking Strategize how to use cloud to drive savings and revenue growth. 35 Build and run your private or hybrid cloud. Utilize cloud services delivered from IBM Cloud. Cloud Strategy and Design Expert Integrated Systems Business Process as a Service Cloud Implementation Cloud Platform Technologies Software as a Service Cloud Migration Services Cloud Infrastructure Technologies Platform as a Service Cloud Security Services Hybrid Cloud Technologies Infrastructure as a Service IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM is helping our clients achieve compelling business outcomes, no matter where the entry point is 36 BUSINESS PROCESS SOFTWARE PLATFORM INFRASTRUCTURE as a Service as a Service as a Service as a Service Automating Business Innovation Marketplace of High Value Consumable Business Applications Rapid App Development through Composable and Integrated Platform built using open standards Enterprise Class, Optimized Infrastructure built using open standards Business Process: Marketing Mobile Compute Recruiting Commerce Security Networking Accounting Supply Chain Big Data & Analytics Storage Procurement Talent Management Development & DevOps Payment Processing Analytics Integration Help Desk Collaboration Integration/ API Mgmt. IT Management Traditional Workloads IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM cloud marketplace provides easy access to our as-a-service portfolio IBM CLOUD MARKETPLACE Your gateway to cloud innovation Explore hundreds of IBM and Business Partner services from across the cloud spectrum. Sign up to offer your cloud services in the marketplace today. Enterprise-grade business apps to accelerate innovation (SaaS) Powerful services and APIs via an integrated cloud platform (PaaS) Self-service IT infrastructure configurable to your needs (IaaS) Biz Dev Ops Over 200 IBM and Third-Party Software and Services Leverage world-class IBM partner ecosystem Curated solution pages with IBM expertise Easy access to build, consume, deploy and purchase services ibm.com/cloud/marketplace 37 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM can support you locally and globally … Banking Regional Contacts 38 [FACE PIC] Jon O’Donnell jon.odonnell@uk.ibm.com Vice President, Europe GBS Banking & Financial Markets Leader [FACE PIC] Greg Sarafin greg.sarafin@us.ibm.com US GBS Banking and Financial Markets Industry Leader [FACE PIC] Yoshiki Minowa YMINOWA@jp.ibm.com Vice President, Japan Financial Solutions and Consulting Services [FACE PIC] Steve Bingham steve.bingham@au1.ibm.com Managing Partner & Global FSS Leader Asia Pacific [FACE PIC] Luis Loleo loleo@ar.ibm.com Vice President & Managing Partner FSS LA Sector Leader [FACE PIC] Likhit Wagle Likhit.Wagle@uk.ibm.com Vice President - Global Industry Leader: Banking & Financial Markets IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM can support you locally and globally … Banking Regional Contacts [FACE PIC] [FACE PIC] Banking Global Contacts Robert (Bob) Hoey rjhoey@us.ibm.com Vice President, Financial Services Sector, North America R P (Raoul) Engelshoven Van raoul_engelshoven-van@nl.ibm.com Vice President, Banking and Financial Markets, Europe [FACE PIC] [FACE PIC] [FACE PIC] 39 IBM Institute for Business Value David K Zimmerman davidzim@us.ibm.com Global Solutions Executive and Worldwide Cloud Leader, IBM Global Banking & Financial Markets Anthony J Lipp anthony.lipp@us.ibm.com Global Strategy Leader Banking & Financial Markets Boxley C Llewellyn llew@us.ibm.com Global Retail Banking Director © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM can support you locally and globally … IBM Cloud CoC Advisory Leaders IBM Cloud CoC Advisory Leaders Cindy Warner – Managing Partner Global Cloud Advisory cindywarner@us.ibm.com 313.903.8787 Mike Owens – Associate Partner Cloud Advisory mike.owens@us.ibm.com 951.375.9588 Nathan Herber – Associate Partner Cloud Advisory nlherber@us.ibm.com 916.616.5350 IBM Cloud Category Leaders Nancy Agosta – Cloud Industry Leader Cloud Category nagosta@us.ibm.com 919.481.3233 Becky Carroll – Associate Partner Cloud Advisory rlcarroll@us.ibm.com 858.204.6723 40 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM can support you locally and globally … IBM Institute for Business Value Contacts Nicholas Mark Drury Global Banking Leader - IBM Institute for Business Value Nickd@sg.ibm.com 65-9840-6874 Anthony E Marshall Global CEO Study Program Director, Strategy and Analytics Leader, IBM Institute for Business Value anthony2@us.ibm.com 1-720-395-0506 Surendra Ramaiah Senior Managing Consultant – Strategy & Analytics rsurendra@ae.ibm.com 971-50900-1372 41 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation 42 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation APPENDIX Target Operating Model IBM Cloud implementation examples Additional slides 43 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Target Operating Model 44 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud is helping banks evolve a new operating model tightly aligned to business strategy Implementation 1 2 3 4 5 An operating model is a framework for formulating an operations strategy that best deploys and determine the explicit choices needed to achieve business goals BUSINESS GOALS AND STRATEGY Target Operating Model Market shifts in the digital economy necessitate banks to adopt new technologies like cloud, mobile, social media and analytics To succeed with cloud, banks have to assess the impact of cloud on the operating model and all its dimensions and determine what actions are required to make cloud adoption smoother and more successful Customer Experience Sourcing & Alliances Assets & Locations CULTURE Technology TOM Skills & Capabilities Processes Organization & Governance Performance Metrics ROADMAP FOR CHANGE 45 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Customer experience with banking will drastically change CUSTOMER JOURNEY 46 1 2 3 Robert, an young Manager in an IT company, is traveling overseas for a project. He completes a video conference on mobile Skype with his bank’s Relationship Manager (RM) to finalize purchase of property and mortgage. He submits the loan application to the bank on his mobile. Bank processes the loan quickly. It also contacts one of its partners for home insurance. All documents are sent electronically, the insurer completes it without Robert visiting their office. Robert is happy that his bank handled all formalities and was able to complete the property purchase before his travel. He checks his account and confirms that his RM has setup electronic debit for his loan deductions in the first week of every month. 4 5 6 The first weekend in his travel, Robert logs into his bank account using his glasses. He checks the balance on his glasses and issues voice instruction to transfer money to his father’s account. He calls his father to inform him who confirms he has received it. Robert steps out for checking out the new city. As he enters a shopping mall, his banking app picks up two offers from electronics shops (based on his previous searches for iPad Pro). His bank offers him a loan option based on his profile. Robert visits the electronics shop and tries out the new iPad Pro. His bank also offers him enhanced benefits on his loyalty program due to local festivities. He opts for a personal loan and transfers it to his mobile wallet through which he pays for the new iPad Pro. IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation New partnerships and alliances can speed and harden cloud adoption SOURCING & ALLIANCES IMPACT IMPLICATIONS Organizations will have more partners and alliances through “Services” being offered by outside organizations Procurement and sourcing functions will need to be automated and have shortened cycles Complexity will increase in service contracts due to consumption-based billing Vendor and service management will be an integral part of the Procurement function Service quality and availability need more focus as they are managed through relationships and agreements with diverse third party ecosystem Service level agreements to be defined clearly and governed by the need to secure and protect customer data in a shared environment Service adoption to meet benefits realization needs to be included in the negotiating process 47 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Business leaders redesign business architecture and processes to leverage cloud PROCESSES IMPACT IMPLICATIONS The cloud strategy and technologies will require a shift from systems-based processes to services-based processes Traditional legacy processes to be decommissioned or integrated into the new cloud-enabled processes Cloud’s speed of service delivery impacts current processes as they need to match and deliver at the same speed Banks will need control over the continued availability, reliability and utility of the cloud based processes and the platforms underpinning them Process framework will migrate from functional silos to an integrated set of processes spanning organizational boundaries Dynamic processes for billing and allocation of resources are required to not be an impediment in achieving value Cloud’s service composition model provides freedom to engage/disengage functions as needed 48 Processes to be made simpler and faster IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud will promote change in organization design and governance ORGANIZATION & GOVERNANCE IMPACT IMPLICATIONS Major shift in how the new environment is managed and operated will have significant impact on the optimum organizational structure required in the future Organizations will become more flexible, managing a fluid set of internal / external resources and service providers Organizations and functions will no longer be constrained by the physical location of data centers, hosting providers and hardware platforms As products and services become more ‘composable’, Governance across the ecosystem will become critical Governance becomes more centrally defined with decentralized execution Cloud service selection should follow the overall enterprise cloud governance standards Strong risk management systems are critical to manage increasing risks arising out of broader cloud deployment Current organization need to evolve • Organization Design, roles and responsibilities • Management systems 49 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Organizations will overhaul performance management to optimize value from cloud PERFORMANCE METRICS IMPACT IMPLICATIONS Cloud requires a dynamic financial model that measures consumption Performance management strategy introduces new levels of complexity in management reporting With the change in business model, new metrics that measure service availability, service quality, responsiveness, ability to change will gain more importance Performance metrics are built into third party and service management contracts for all vendors delivering the cloud based service Dynamic metrics tied back to SLAs will be critical for measuring success for cloud based services 50 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud will drive rapid change in enterprise skills and capabilities SKILLS & CAPABILITIES IMPACT IMPLICATIONS Cloud brings customer centricity to focus which makes customer and service orientation skills critical within the bank Deeper data analytics and customer insight capabilities will be the norm Vendor management, contracting and relationship management skills will be critical to manage all the vendors and alliances Training of staff on new skills required related to new and innovative services Existing IT and other functional staff will likely need to be retrained or redeployed Legal / operational support skills will be key to manage partnership agreements Skills shift to managing vendor contracts and relationships of many vendors 51 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Banks will benefit from cloud most when they accelerate adoption of other emerging technologies TECHNOLOGY IMPACT IMPLICATIONS The technology function will be leaner with a more strategic focus rather than operational IT Strategy, Architecture and IT Plans to be reviewed and updated to reflect changes in business strategy and cloud-enabled future bank Cloud’s big impact on Technology will be to move on-premise technology deployment to cloud As more services migrate to cloud, Service Management, IT Vendor management and IT Quality management will become key differentiators IT teams need to be retrained and redeployed Budget for the maintenance of legacy systems may reside, so they need to be budgeted and worked into the overall costs An IT services catalog needs to be dynamic globally and be applicable for each market A DevOps approach will be required to get the cloud service delivered faster to achieve value 52 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud enables more efficient location strategies ASSETS & LOCATIONS IMPACT IMPLICATIONS Migration to the cloud will require decommissioning and consolidation of technology assets Decommissioned technology assets may still book value and impact the existing operating budget Decommissioned assets and locations will be a factor in the future state financial model One-time financial write-offs will need to be factored into the overall business case Removal of physical / technology assets will reduce the quantity of needed remote offices and data centers Excess data centers and remote locations will have to be repurposed or sold / leased to recoup cost Role of branches need to be redefined and enhanced to provide a much better customer experience 53 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud-enabled organizations will rethink and recalibrate organization culture CULTURE IMPACT IMPLICATIONS The shift to a cloud-based environment will also require changes in long-held organizational beliefs and cultural norms Need to address perceived loss of control / potential resistance by existing IT and other functions whose processes will move to cloud Banks as a whole need service-orientation, with a shift in mindset toward valuing the customer experience above all else Open and collaborative reporting and management across organizational functions and units facilitates faster customer response Need to educate employees on this shift: How will our culture change, and why? What is the risk if we do not make this change? What would be the consequences of continuing as is? Requires reinforcement of expected behaviors through formal and informal mechanisms and interventions Requires changes in Leadership Behaviors People practices Regular communications on changes 54 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM cloud implementation examples 55 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A bank in Japan uses customer analytics to enable more personalized engagement and more effective campaigns This bank in Japan operates nearly 200 branches in Japan and other areas in Asia CHALLENGE When this bank saw deeper customer engagement as essential to its growth and profitability, it knew that having solid, data-driven insights on customer behavior and preferences was the foundation. The real key, it recognized, was to infuse these insights into customer touch points such as outbound campaigns and inbound calls. SOLUTION The bank is using cloud-based behavioral modeling to find service propensity patterns across its customer segments. And it’s incorporating those insights directly into its campaign management and inbound customer interactions to deliver a more personalized experience across all channels. Effectiveness – 20% increase in conversion rates for marketing campaigns expected Customer satisfaction – Improves satisfaction by providing customers with a more personalized and relevant experience Efficiency – Increases efficiency of marketing operations by significantly shortening the marketing campaign cycle Source: http://w3-01.ibm.com/sales/ssi/cgi-bin/ssialias?infotype=CR&subtype=NA&htmlfid=0CRDD-9KJ6QW&appname=crmd 56 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Bank significantly reduces deployment time and achieves optimized resource use by implementing virtualization and cloud computing One leading Chinese commercial bank is constantly seeking ways to set itself apart from its competitors and boost profitability CHALLENGE A leading Chinese commercial bank wanted to boost the flexibility and efficiency of its operations in order to better react to customer demands, and stay ahead of competitors. SOLUTION Partnered with IBM to launch a virtualization strategy, supported by servers with IBM® POWER7® processors and IBM PowerVM® technology, as well as the IBM SmartCloud™ Entry solution. Flexibility – 99% increase in flexibility & workload deployment by implementing a virtualized computing environment Resource utilization – Optimized resource use, helping to cut costs and complexity. Source: http://www-03.ibm.com/software/businesscasestudies/us/en/corp?synkey=Y901642O93237U20 57 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A leading Card Management System vendor now offers its system as Software as a Service based on an IBM PCI DSS Cloud Platform A global provider of card payment solutions and IT consultancy to 120 international and domestic banks, service providers and retailers to enable 7 mn transactions per hour, 1 mn merchants & over 60 mn cards CHALLENGE The client were looking for a resilient and PCI DSS compliant infrastructure in continental EU to start offering its card solution using a private cloud. SOLUTION The client deployed a private cloud architecture hosted at a pair of data centers and designed to feature numerous physical and logical security measures. IBM manages this environment around the clock. Availability – High availability (99.999%) in a PCI Compliant multisite data center scenario in Europe with disaster recovery between data centers Enabling a CSP – Flexible pricing and architecture to let the client became a Cloud Service Provider Time-to-market – Fast time-to-market avoiding to buy assets & breaking barriers at customers. Source: https://w3-03.sso.ibm.com/sales/support/ShowDoc.wss?docid=0CRDD-8ZMP4Q&appname=w3skm 58 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A bank in the US protects retail and commercial customers from cybercrime with advanced cloud-based fraud prevention solution This bank in the United States provides a full line of retail and commercial banking products through 13 full-service branch offices in a large metropolitan area CHALLENGE This bank saw many security risks targeted at both commercial & retail customers. Despite having numerous fraud-prevention solutions, the bank sought to implement an extra level of security that would be easy to maintain while keeping costs under control. SOLUTION A cloud-based security solution facilitates clientless detection of malware attacks and infected devices. Using over 40 million endpoints worldwide, the software collects intelligence on active phishing and malware attacks, then applies behavioral algorithms to detect, block and remove security threats, including new variants. Speed – 72 infections detected and removed from customer devices in the first month of implementation Resolution –helps prevent potential losses by detecting and resolving malware infections Customer loyalty – Increases loyalty from customers through proactive efforts to resolve security issues Source: http://w3-01.ibm.com/sales/ssi/cgi-bin/ssialias?infotype=CR&subtype=NA&htmlfid=0CRDD-9LDLLH&appname=crmd 59 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Additional slides 60 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM has helped banks in cloud-enabled business and operating model innovation GE Capital1, using IBM’s BlueMix, built a cloudbased DevOps platform to accelerate software delivery and time to market Built software and apps, including the award winning GE Capital Bank, from the scratch in weeks rather than years DevOps capability provides GE Capital Bank with the agility of a startup and the resources of a large enterprise Sun Trust Bank2 implemented IBM WebSphere Cast Iron cloud integration to connect back-end enterprise applications, the company’s shared services, and the cloud Integration enhances the way relationship managers work with customers, even when they are not directly connected to bank’s back-end systems Commercial bank in Nigeria3 captures market share of first-time bankers when it deployed a private cloud environment based on IBM Power Systems technology New solution enables the bank to save an additional 30 percent of its mobile banking revenue, previously forfeited Provides access to accurate information, reducing delivery times for customers Source: See speaker notes 61 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM is helping leading banks capture the financial and strategic benefits of cloud Operating Efficiency Operating Efficiency Revenue Growth 40% reduction in total cost of ownership Improve the advice & experience delivered to customers¹ Single view of customer drives new revenue BUSINESS SERVICES A major bank in Brazil1 COGNITIVE BANKING DBS Bank Singapore2 ANALYTICS A leading Polish bank1 The bank reduced total cost of ownership by 40% by creating an inter-site cloud to host previously existing physical servers. DBS is using Watson’s cloud based service to "redefine" how voluminous amount of data, structured and unstructured, can be analyzed to provide intelligence that was previously not "humanly" possible. Data can now be entered into the system once, giving the bank a 360-degree view of customer data—which embedded analytics can use to help generate more sales. Source: See speaker notes 62 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Cloud has helped early-adopters motivate new forms of innovation and collaboration Cloud promotes standardization, supporting flexibility and agility Cloud supports refocus on customer experiences, integrating disparate set of processes designed and engineered to provide customer value Cloud supports next generation marketing and omni-channel interactions that are of interest to customers where, when and how they want to be engaged Cloud is transferring various functions such as IT, from fixed cost centers to variable cost structures Under Cloud Cover survey: How leaders are accelerating competitive differentiation 69% achieved rapid innovation of novel products and services 56% reinvented their customer relationships in response to changing dynamics 51% increased engagement and collaboration across organization and ecosystem (colleagues, partners, customers) of the banks of the banks of the banks Source: IBM Center for Applied Insights Under cloud cover: How leaders are accelerating competitive differentiation. For more info, visit: ibm.com/ibmcai/globalcloudstudy 63 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation A 35% partial workload migration to cloud helps bank improve its profits and reduce costs A representative bank’s financials overview (to illustrate impact of cloud migration) $ million 16,000 15,843 Comparative view of costs for Traditional IT & Cloud Computing 60% 9,105 42.5% 41.1% 45% 14,000 30% 12,000 15% 10,000 0% 8,000 1,045 366 6.6% 5.2% IT costs as a % of Revenue 220 5,693 6,000 52.9% 54.3% Bank's operating costs as a % of Revenue Traditional IT PBIT as a % of Revenue Cloud Computing 4,000 2,000 0 Revenue PBIT Op. Costs (excl IT Costs) **IT Current Projected Costs Costs for Savings cloudable due to workloads 35% migration ** IT Costs is estimated at 6.6% of revenue using Gartner’s IT Key Metrics data Note: The above is a representative example only 64 Improvements in banking operations Enhanced customer centric operations Increased collaboration, capability & reach Focused selling Increased efficiency with rapid turnaround time Shorter time to market Enhanced service orientation IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation Regulatory authorities are actively monitoring and supporting cloud adoption in banks Regulatory authorities have recognized cloud’s role in banks’ business transformation, operational efficiency and innovation…….they are in various stages of evaluation to provide necessary guidelines in cloud usage 1 De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB), the Netherlands’ national banking regulator, has approved use of cloud in the country’s financial sector subject to its guidelines 3 Monetary Authority of Singapore has approved use of cloud subject to completion and approval of Technology Checklist and rights to conduct its own audit 2 Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the Indian banking regulatory authority, has recommended an approach for cloud computing for Urban Cooperative Banks IDRBT has established an Indian Banking Community Cloud IDRBT has developed a Cloud Security Framework for banking industry IDRBT - Institute for Development and Research in Banking Technology (established by RBI) Source: See speaker notes 65 IBM Institute for Business Value © 2014 IBM Corporation IBM Institute For Business Value Cloud Consumer Banking Point of View Thank You © 2014 IBM Corporation