Session 6 Assessing Communication Skills, Social Skills & Assistive Technology Needs Article Review# 2 Due Today Assessment Tool Box Project & Presentations Due Next Week: August 11th Right now I am going to give you 30 minutes to work with your group on this to work out logistics and I will answer questions within each group. We may have more time at end of class. Outcomes for today Discuss Readings as a class! Lecture on Communication Assessment Activities on Communication Assessment Lecture on Assistive Technology Assessment • Social Skills Assessment • • • • Discussion on Readings 1. Teaching Communication Skills (Ch 11) 2. Sigafoos et al. Ch 3-5 3. Using Technology to Enhance Teaching & Learning (Ch 19) “If I could not express myself, I would become like the tree in the forest—the one for which it does not matter if it makes a sound when it comes crashing down, because there is no one around to hear it. Unfortunately, there are still many silent fallen trees all around us if we stop and look.” Bob Williams, AAC user with complex communication needs (Williams, 2000, p. 250) Communication Bill of Rights Each person has a right to: Request desired objects, actions, events, & people Refuse undesired objects, etc. Express personal preferences & feelings. Be offered choices & alternatives. Reject offered choices & alternatives. Request & receive another person’s attention/interaction • Ask for & receive info about changes in routine & environment. • Receive intervention to improve communication From the National Joint Committee for the skills Communicative Needs of Persons with Severe • • • • • • Disabilities. (1992). Guidelines for meeting the communication needs of persons with severe disabilities. ASHA, 34(Suppl. 7), 2–3. Communication Bill of Rights Each person has a right to: • Receive a response to any communication, whether or not the responder can fill the request. • Have access to augmentative and alternative communication and other assistive technology services & devices at all times. • Be in environments that promote one’s communication as a full partner with other people, including peers. • Be spoken to with respect & courtesy. • Be spoken to directly and not spoken for or talked about in 3rd person while present. • Have clear, meaningful, and culturally & linguistically appropriate communication. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhLATQX4Ow&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fAdEOXD9T vk&feature=related “Communicative competence implies the ability to meet the demands of participation and communication within the culture” (p. 55). The adequacy of one’s communication is based on having sufficient knowledge, judgment, & skills needed to convey a message to a communicative partner. This complex behavior is learned within a cultural environment 1. 2. 3. 4. Linguistic Competence Operational Competence Social Competence Strategic Competence AAC user needs to perform in at least two environments -Both native language & AAC codes need to be mastered -represent two different cultures -AAC user by default is bicultural and has to learn to function adequately in at least two environments. Technical skills needed to operate systems used by AAC users. Skills include: Mastery level may differ in different cultures ◦ Access, transmission, and operational skills needed to reach mastery level in accuracy and speed in using a given system. Evaluation of preferred operational methods and transmission modes within a culture should occur within an AAC assessment for a student These preferences may be evaluated while assessing student strengths (e.g., person/family-centered planning) Achieved when the user has the knowledge, judgment, and skill to understand and adequately function within their cultural community Relates to knowledge of how to use language (i.e., what terminology and forms are used, at what times, and with what people) ◦ What behaviors are expected (at what times, with whom, for what purposes) ◦ What is considered appropriate decorum and dress in public & home ◦ How the culture perceives the world AAC users must learn to use specific systems or strategies of communication that often differ from the verbal communication systems of the family or community AAC users may be highly dependent on communication partners to infer meanings of messages. Strategies for communicating AND the technology of communicating make up a communication system AAC users must achieve competence in both Communication strategies are often developed by the practitioners without adequate knowledge of the AAC user’s culture. Providing a culturally acceptable strategic system may enhance the strategic competence while enabling the user appropriate use of the chosen technology. What can you do to ensure a student’s culture is considered in the development of a communication system? Involve the student & family every step of the way Don’t think of assessment “on” a student, but rather “with” a student Essential to understand student’s unique physical and sensory skills ◦ How they see, hear, move E.g., if a student has no functional vision and does not use speech, then an alternate form of expressive communication will probably involve…..???? Use of objects, parts of objects, gestures, & manual signs Downing, J.E. (2005)Teaching Communication Soto, G. & Zangari, C. (2009). Practically Skills to Students with Severe Disabilities Speaking: Language, Literacy, & Academic Development for Students with AAC Needs. Competence in a symbolic and language system (e.g., spoken English, manual ASL)? Formalized rules of word representation, production, & use? Breathing is the only real pre-requisite (Mirenda, 1993) Necessary to define oneself Share ideas, feelings Demonstrate knowledge & skills Socialize Perform job & daily tasks Allows control over physical & social environment Allows for acquiring new skills (strong correlation between literacy & communication skill development for students with severe disabilities; Beukelman & Mirenda, 2005) Allows for socially acceptable way to express feelings of frustration Allows for development of friendships Better to err on the side of assuming competence even if it is not there, rather than err on the side of assuming incompetence when competence is the case. All individuals need to communicate Students who demonstrate minimal communication skills and are not adequately expressing themselves. Cognitive Referencing---Many professionals still believe that for children with severe intellectual challenges communication services are irrelevant (Downing, 2005)— Question should not be whether students will benefit from communication intervention, but how best to provide support At least 2 people who understand each other Form (i.e. a way to send the message) Content (i.e., something to talk about) Function: Reason/Purpose to communicate Educational team members must ensure these are addressed Students in special education classrooms tend to have interactions with adults but limited interaction with other students (Foreman et al., 2004) What affects does this have on: learning communication, and making friends? Foreman et al., found that students with disabilities in general education were involved in significantly higher levels of communication interactions than their matched pair in special education classrooms (2004). Receptive Language: ◦ Understanding what people mean when they speak to you. Expressive Language ◦ Being able to speak/communicate so that others understand you. No one form of communication will meet all needs or all social situations Teaching a combination of different modes is necessary ◦ Examples: Vocalization, body movements, pointing, facial expressions, nodding, gestures, use of object symbols, picture symbols, manual signs Request Initiate/greeting Terminate Attention Naming Accept/Reject ◦ Protesting situations ◦ Affirming situations Expressing choices or preferences When there is nothing to say, there is no communication (i.e. the awkward pause when run out of things to say) Individuals with severe disabilities need to have access to a variety of objects, pictures, and photos Speech ◦ Articulation, Resonance, Voice, Fluency Language ◦ Phonology, Syntax, Semantics, Pragmatics Conversation Skills ◦ Turn taking, content, initiation, closure Receptive language deficits ◦ Cannot recall sequences of ideas presented orally ◦ Difficulty understanding humor, sarcasm, figurative language ◦ May not understand questions ◦ Trouble following directions ◦ Cannot retain information presented orally ◦ Difficulty understanding compound and complex sentences Expressive Deficits ◦ Spoken language may include incorrect grammar or syntax ◦ Limited use of vocabulary ◦ Frequent hesitations/can’t find right words ◦ Difficulty discussing abstract, temporal or spatial concepts ◦ Jumps from topic to topic ◦ Afraid to ask questions, does not know what questions to ask, does not no how to ask questions. Standardized Tests will not provide the information you need Assessment driven by questions that need to be answered to help benefit from communication intervention—Team Effort Interviews with Significant Others & EcologicalFunctional Assessment Process •Person/family-centered planning •Summarize student life/learning/cultural background Individual •Identify preferences Student Yearly Functional Assessment/ Ecological Inventory Planning Meeting (MDT) Monthly/ Quarterly •Select Instructional Procedures •Create opportunities for comm. •Implement relevant procedures •Program generalization & •Graph learner progress •Modify procedures as necessary •Expand plan as necessary Verify communicative functions, Co-Plan/ Design Instructional Plan Instruction/ Collect Data Daily/ Weekly Identify Potential Communicative Acts Analyze environmental demands •Review Assessment Info •Select appropriate interventions •Write communication goals Steps in Ecological Assessment Process Step 1: Plan with Student & Family Step 2: Summarize what is known about the student Step 3: Encourage Self-Determination/ Assess Student Preferences Step 4: Assess student’s instructional program Step 5: Develop ecological assessment report Current communication Environmental conditions Motor capabilities Cognitive/linguistic capacities Language capacities Literacy capacities Sensory/perceptual capacities Receptive skills for a specific activity need to be identified What does the student do to demonstrate that the message has been received and understood? Document what forms of communication seem to be best understood Any attempt by the student to start, maintain, or end a communicative exchange should be noted. How the students communicates (the form)—Skill level? Why the student is communicating (function/intent)— different forms of communication for different purposes? What the student talks about (content)—information on breadth of skills and accessibility? See Communication Style Assessment— handout Interview questions for professionals---handout Practice using these interviews with a partner based on your case study OR you may use a student that you have or are working with. Note your evaluation of using these interview questions. Communication Matrix by Charity Rowland http://www.communicationmatrix.org (designs to learn website) Organized by communication function List of behaviors Not used, emerging or mastered Uses observational techniques to analyze skill demands of the natural environment and determine how the student performs within the environment Leads directly to intervention plan (Snell, 2002) 1. List Domains 2. List environments 3. List subenvironments 4. List activities associated with each sub environment 5. Task analyze each activity to identify skills 6. Observe the performance of the activity to identify needs 1. Ask: Where does the student spend time? (environment, sub-environment, activities) 2. Select Activity: (e.g., ordering food) 3. Observe: (for vocabulary used in activity) List Expressive Vocabulary used in the activity List Receptive Vocabulary used in the activity 4. Review listed words and determine which words & skills need to be taught to the student. Where does the student spend time? ◦ Environment: Community: McDonald’s ◦ Subenvironment: McDonald’s counter area ◦ Activities: Ordering food, waiting in line, socializing in line Select activity: Ordering Food Observe vocabulary used in activity ◦ Expressive: “I want, hamburger, fish sandwich, small, medium, large, coke, milkshake, yes/no, that’s all, thank you, my order is wrong, I need, extra ketchup, for here, please repeat that, how much?” ◦ Receptive: “May I help you?, Is that all?, Here or to go?, Your order will be ready soon?, I don’t understand, Your total is_____” Review listed words: which are above, below, and at the student’s level. Which are within or outside student’s experience, which are necessary for the task Complete the communication ecological worksheet on your in-class activity. Use only one activity in the school environment (e.g., asking to play a game at recess, participating in writing activity in language arts class) Steps in Activity Natural Cues Comm. Skills Needed Student Discrepancy Interv. Performance Analysis Plan Receptive + or or Expressive Why sug student gest isn’t ions doing the step Significant other interviews Ecological Assessment Direct observation in natural environments Interrupted chain procedures ◦ Interrupt a routine that student has to complete and see how student communicates Assess student in interactions with other students Provide direct assessments to determine if student understands words, pictures, symbols, etc. As we talked about last class, take an inventory of the vocabulary used in the settings student’s are in or will be going to. Conversation inventories with same age peers Could use audio recorder if allowed. Standardized Tests may provide ageequivalencies in receptive & expressive language, but often fail to recognize the unique characteristics of students with severe disabilities (Cress, 2002; Ross & Cress, 2006; Snell, 2002). Recommendation is interviewing significant others (Bailey, Stoner, Parrette, & Angelo, 2006) Analyze Communication Environment (Blackstone & Hunt Bert, 2003; Downing, 2005); Use of Video recordings (Suarez & Daniels, 2009) http://www.wati.org/?pageLoad=content/sup ports/free/index.php Number of free publications WATI Assessment- provides an overview of the assistive technology consideration, assessment and planning process WATI AT Checklist in your book pg. 514-515 Framework The SETT Framework, developed by Joy Zabala (2005), is an organizational instrument to help collaborative teams create student-centered, environmentally useful, and tasks-focused tool systems that foster the educational success of students with disabilities. SETT is an acronym for Student, Environment, Task and Tools. Key questions are asked in each area to in order to guide teams in gathering data and information to support the consideration and implementation of appropriate inclusive technologies. These questions provide a framework and not a protocol, as they guide the discussion and provide a vehicle for the team to collaborate and form a consensus on ‘where to from here’. TOOLS ENVIRONMENT STUDENT TASK STUDENT – Examples of guiding questions concerning inclusive technologies: •What are the student’s current abilities? •What are the student’s special needs? •What are the functional areas of concern? •What are the other students doing that this student needs to be able to do? •What does the student need to be able to do that is difficult or impossible to accomplish independently at this time? A useful resource to support these questions from a student point of view is Bowser, G., & Reed, P. (2001). Hey Can I Try That? A Student Handbook for Choosing and Using Assistive Technology. This is available from www.educationtechpoints.org/manuals-materials/hey-can-i-try-that • ENVIRONMENTS – Examples of guiding questions concerning inclusive technologies: • What activities take place in the environment? • Where will the student participate—classroom, home, community, therapy? • What is the physical arrangement? • What activities do other students do that this student cannot currently participate in? • What assistive technology does the student have access to or currently use? Environments Work Recreation Community Education Home Sensory Considerations (new) New section as a subset of Student & Environment – Does this student have sensory deficits or sensitivities that will impact his/her ability to …. ? – Do the learning environment(s) impact the sensory issues of the student? Sensory Considerations • • • • • STUDENT Visual (glare, color vs. black & white, white space between symbols, etc.) Auditory (voice, volume, button click) Tactile (velcro, weight) Personal space Student specific ENVIRONMENT • Background noise • Lighting (full spectrum vs. flourescent) • Physical space • TASKS – Examples of guiding questions concerning inclusive technologies: • What specific tasks occur in the environment? • What activities is the student expected to do? • What does success look like? Tasks Access to standard apps Education/Rehab Alternative Writing Recreation Organization Internet • TOOLS – Examples of guiding questions concerning inclusive technologies: • Tools are devices and services—anything that is needed to help the student participate and access learning programs. • Are the tools being considered on a continuum from no/low to hightech? • Are the tools student centered and task oriented and reflect the student’s current needs? • Are tools being considered because of their features that are needed rather than brand names? • What is the cognitive load required by the student to use the tool? • What are the training requirements for the student, family and staff? Tools Access to – – – – – Keyboards Mouse Monitor Drives/Storage Printer AT Continuum • Follow the progression of low tech, through mid tech to high tech when selecting assistive technology tools Assistive Technology for Communication Low Tech Tools AT Communication Continuum Low Tech Concrete Representations Real Objects – Calendar box – Tangible Symbols – Miniatures – TOBIs (true object based icon) AT Communication Continuum Low Tech Communication system with pictures, symbols, letters &/or words Assistive Technology for Communication Mid Tech Tools AT Communication Continuum Mid Tech Simple Voice Output Devices Step-by-step BIGmack CheapTalk Hip Talk AT Communication Continuum Mid Tech Speech Generating Device with levels Leo Tech series Bluebird II Message Mate 7 Level Communication Builder Assistive Technology for Communication High Tech Tools AT Communication Continuum High Tech Speech Generating Devices with icon sequencing OR Vantage Plus Pathfinder Plus SpringBoard Lite AT Communication Continuum High Tech Speech Generating Devices with a Dynamic Display Eyegaze System Dynavox V series & V-Max M3 Tango! ChatPC AT Communication Continuum High Tech Text based device with speech synthesis DynaWrite LightWriter SL40 Freedom LITE PolyTABLET with Persona Solution Selection: Tools & Strategies • Review the list of potential tools – Now is the time to evaluate for a match with: • Student (abilities, difficulties, likes/dislikes) • Environment (supports, obstacles) • Tasks (what 1-2 things do you want the student to do?) – Prioritize selections SETT- similar to ecological inventory Student S Environment E Task Tools T T •Are the tools being considered on a continuum from no/low to high-tech? •What are the student’s current abilities? •What activities take place in the environment? •What specific tasks occur in the environment? •What are the student’s special needs? •What activities do other students do that this student cannot currently participate in? •What activities is the student expected to do? •What are the functional areas of concern? •What assistive technology does the student have access to or currently use? •Are the tools student centered and task oriented and reflect the student’s current •What does success look like? needs? •What are the training requirements for the student, family and staff? ◦ This may mean that the device/system is not meaningful or does not meet a communicative need (OR BOTH) ◦ Re-evaluate student’s opportunities to communicate. ◦ May need to manipulate the environment in such a way that necessitates the student use the device/system (Reichle, 1997; Snell, 2002) ◦ May be too difficult in comparison to other communicative means…think of some unaided means of communication (facial expressions, gestures, etc.) OR different symbols, colors, etc. Conduct person-centered ecological assessment on communication Team approach- teacher, SLP, parents Consider contextual-fit Consider: durability, ease of use, transportability, flexibility, cultural sensitivity, cost of device, & quality of speech (McCord & Soto, 2004; Mirenda, 1999). Ability of student to access an AAC system need to be assessed prior to purchasing system Consider their home-language, culture, and long-term vision for the student’s communication. Want to build system so that you can bridge home and school vocabulary, language, etc. May be an issue when device is not allowed to go home. Try to work with school to allow device to go home. Parents may need to sign responsibility for device. http://www.aacfundinghelp.com/ Low-incidence funding ◦ (property of school) Health Insurance (property of student) Medicare (property of student) Department of Rehabilitation ◦ Dependent on potential for employability w/ device In Oregon, Educational Service District (ESD) may have guidelines for this. Developmental Vocabulary ◦ To encourage language & vocabulary growth ◦ Should include words or messages that encourage students to use various language structures and combinations E.g., more, no, there ◦ Variety of nouns, verbs, & adjectives to support word combinations E.g., more car, OR no eat ◦ As vocabulary expands encourage use of combinations of 2,3,4, or more Substantive words (i.e., people, places, things) Relational words (e.g., big, little) Generic verbs (e.g., give, get, make) Specific verbs (e.g., eat, drink, sleep) Emotional state words (e.g., happy, scared) Affirmation/negation words (e.g., yes, no, not) Recurrence/discontinuation words (e.g., more, all gone) Proper names for people first (Mike) and personal pronouns (his) later Single adjectives first (e.g., hot, dirty) & polar opposites later (e.g., cold, clean) Relevant colors Relevant prepositions (e.g., on, over) If limited sight word recognition… Messages chosen from a functional rather than developmental perspective Single words or whole messages are selected to meet individual communication needs. ◦ One or more symbols to represent messages ◦ Age/context/culturally appropriate. Include some developmental vocabulary in AAC systems ◦ Added whenever new environments or participation opportunities are included Words & messages that are commonly used by a variety of individuals and occur very frequently. Sources to identify core vocabulary items ◦ 1. Word lists based on the vocabulary-use patterns of other individuals who successfully use AAC systems (http://aac.unl.edu/vocabulary.html) ◦ 2. Word lists based on the use patterns of the specific individual ◦ 3. Word lists based on the performance of natural speakers or writers in similar contexts. ◦ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vib2__BDCXc Single-level Devices: deliver a limited number of messages (about 20), simple to program & operate (e.g. BIGmack) Multi-level Devices: Up to thousands of messages, more difficult to program, multiple symbol displays to program messages on two or more levels. Comprehensive Devices: “dynamic display” technology Greetings & Farewells ◦ Age-appropriate vocabulary, mannerisms ◦ May not necessarily need a Speech Generated Device (SGD) Asking for Attention/Help Comments of Approval & Rejection Social Closeness ◦ Observe what typical students do to achieve this ◦ E.g., admiring another’s hairstyle, telling secrets Communicative Skills specific to a class or an activity [to Bobby] “You don't have what they call "the social skills." That's why you never have any friends, 'cept fo' yo' mama.” From Waterboy, 1998 starring Adam Sandler Besides communication skills, what other factors affect a student’s development of social skills? Based on what we have talked about in this class thus far, how would you go about assessing the social skills of a student with significant disabilities? What types of interactions do they engage in? (e.g., academic, social) How do they establish relationships/friendships? How do they gain membership & belonging? What about romantic relationships? What about relationships with adults? 7th grade at Chavez Middle School Spanish is his first/home language Can be quite shy when meeting someone for the first time & it takes him a while to feel comfortable around new people. Has autism & tends to repeat a few favorite phrases, avoids making eye contact, & holds fast to specific routines. When topics of video games, movies, or comic books are brought up his entire demeanor changes What are Esaul’s strengths? What are (or can) be barriers to Esaul developing positive social relationships? What process would you use to assess these barriers? 4th grader at North Elementary School. Only knows a few of her classmates and often feels alone at school. Has moderate intellectual disabilities, a mild hearing impairment, and a severe physical disability for which she uses an electric wheelchair. Alexis discovered she has a knack for abstract painting that features vibrant colors and bold lines. What are Alexis’ strengths? What are or can be barriers to Alexis developing positive social relationships? Rating scales- from those in environment Teacher nomination & ranking◦ List of students who demonstrate a specific behavioral characteristic to the greatest or least extent in comparison to classmates Self-report- student’s subjective perceptions about own social competence Direct behavioral observation- Contextual approach◦ Assess the skills of students within the environment. ◦ Identify skills that need to be taught ◦ Ensures meaningful social development ◦ Ensures the identification of skills that are relevant to the student’s culture. Easy answers: It’s obvious….we all have them and know what they are. Defining social relationships is like defining the meaning of life…it’s relative to the individual. More useful understanding of social relationships, focused on interrelated aspects of our social lives: ◦ Patterns of contact ◦ Subjective satisfaction Social relationships are based on contact patterns between two people Example: 2 students might see each other in class on a regular basis, or that contact might be intermittent such as 2 students getting together for lunch once a week. Contact does not need to be direct for a social relationship to exist (e.g., email) Student’s social life can be understood as a collection of interactions with other people. Social Networks Social Relationships based on: how often 2 students interact, how long, what days, etc. Different patterns of interaction among students Social contacts Social Support Behaviors What occurs between students when they interact Variation among students regarding what constitutes a desirable social life. Some individuals prefer to interact with a small number of people, but interact frequently Large number of people, but interact less frequently There is no metric for what constitutes a “good social life” What would be the best way to define a “good social life” for a student? Social support- behaviors that are a part of social interactions ◦ Emotional support, companionship, access to others, information, material aid, decision making ◦ Goal should be to increase a student’s access to social support & improve student’s ability to provide social support to others Membership/belonging- sense of “connectedness” with others ◦ Stable and something shared by individuals involved ◦ Circle of friends (Haring & Breen, 1992) ◦ Part of their school/community Personal happiness-be aware of student’s perception of the adequacy of his or her relationships (Strully & Strully, 1985) What makes social relationships develop? Still not specifically identified in research General areas we will discuss relating to social relationship development & maintenance ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ How relationships develop? Balancing independence and interdependence? Types of social interactions? Variables that influence the course of a relationship? Predictable pattern (Goldstein et al., 2001), 3 phases: 1- Initial social encounters ◦ Introduced to students ◦ 55% of peers who are initially met go on to second stage 2-Preferred interaction contexts 3- Durable relationships ◦ Try out different activities with one another ◦ Make decisions of what form relationship will take ◦ Majority of relationships do not extend beyond this ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Described as friendships Most satisfactory of relationships Sustained social interaction Routine develops Social relationships influenced by social competence ◦ Student’s ability to effectively interact and maintain social interactions Independently engage in set of behaviors= social skills More independent students are in initiating, taking turns, and providing reciprocal social support= more likely to self-determine a happy social life Caution: No “readiness” prerequisite to developing relationships Balance with interdependence: able to work collaboratively with others to accomplish a common goal (e.g., finding a role within a class activity/situation…determine what to search, controlling the mouse, etc. when searching the net) Where we interact & what we do are closely linked Schools have 3 broad contexts: class, break/mealtimes, & brief interactions in other settings Think about what types of social interactions are “appropriate” during these times. 1. 2. Identify the times & settings to be assessed. Identify what aspects of a person’s social life you want to assess. Formal & informal information gathering Increasing number of people that student meets? Maintaining already established social relationships? 3. Summarize info & make recommendations List the people with whom you interact What areas of your social life could be improved? ◦ Is each person a friend or an acquaintance? ◦ How many times per week do you interact with each person? ◦ In what settings do you interact with each person? ◦ Does this person know any of the other people you interact with? ◦ Would you person? ◦ Would you settings? ◦ Would you ◦ Would you ◦ Would you like more interactions with a particular like to interact with this person in new like to do different activities with this person? prefer individual or group activities? like to meet new people? Barriers to Social Interact/Relationships Suggested strategies Access to general education (GE) settings Facilitating inclusive placements Access to peers without disabilities Peer supports in GE settings Classroom participation Access to GE curriculum Adaptations/modifications Skills for facilitating interactions Pivotal activity skills Reciprocity skills Teaching interdependence Access to peers over time Class scheduling Alternative school interaction opportunities Afterschool interaction opportunities