THE DOCUMENT BASED QUESTION (DBQ) DOCUMENT BASED QUESTION (DBQ) Are provided with a essay prompt as well as several primary documents to use as RESOURCES for writing the essay. Same requirements as an FRQ in that looking for a solid thesis, analysis, and substantial support. DBQs are NOT essays about the documents – focus on answering the question. Think of them as FRQs but with some extra help… you still need the basic ingredients for a cake, but now you can add sprinkles and icing GENERIC RUBRIC FOR DBQ Contains a clear and well-developed thesis Understands complexity of question; analyzes rather than describes Supports thesis with substantial and relevant information Shows superior analysis; displays wellreasoned cause and effect; evaluates historical change; reaches fully supported conclusions May contain minor errors Analytical use of at least half the documents; balances documents with outside information STEPS TO A SOLID DBQ 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Understand the question Brainstorm relevant outside information Take a look at the documents – what do you know, what can you infer Make connections between the documents and the outside information (Doc. A relates to…) Write a thesis – with clear categories and “so what” Organize your essay; determine what outside information and documents will be used in each paragraph Write EXAMINING THE DBQ Analyze the ways in which technology, government policy, and economic conditions changed American agriculture in the period 1865-1900. Provided Documents A. B. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J. Chart of Agricultural Prices Map of Railroad growth Excerpt from The Prairie Farmer Photograph “The Wheat Harvest” Excerpt of sharecropping contract Excerpt from Harper’s Magazine Excerpt from speech by Mary Elizabeth Lease Excerpt from personal communication Excerpt from Oklahoma Magazine Excerpt from William Jennings Bryan’s Cross of Gold speech THINKING ABOUT THE DOCUMENTS EVALUATING BODY PARAGRAPHS Analyze the ways in which technology, government policy, and economic conditions changed American agriculture in the period 1865-1900. Category: Technology Read each sample – What are your observations? Which do you consider the strongest sample and why? How does each sample utilize the documents? How does each sample incorporate outside information? Where do you see examples of analysis in each sample? EVALUATING BODY PARAGRAPHS Analyze the ways in which technology, government policy, and economic conditions changed American agriculture in the period 1865-1900. Category: Government Policy Read each sample – What are your observations? Which do you consider the strongest sample and why? How does each sample utilize the documents? How does each sample incorporate outside information? Where do you see examples of analysis in each sample? DBQ TIPS CONTINUED NEVER quote a document. The reader knows what it says, they’re looking for how you can use it -- so focus on including inferences derived from the document Citing Documents It is best to parenthetically cite after using the document You can also make quick reference to the document in the actual sentence blah blah blah (Doc A). As argued in Document A, blah blah blah John Smith captured the feelings of many colonists when he blah blah blah Pay attention to document information author, date, type of document can assist with assessing potential bias, placing in historical context, and determining purpose documents are always provided in chronological order, which is particularly helpful if essay asks you to contrast and/or evaluate change over time …TO CLOSE: SYNTHESIS PARAGRAPH Read the provided documents. Use at least two documents in a paragraph that responds to the following question: Should the federal government pass a law that bans all cell phone use while driving?