Effective Questionnaire Design Craig Parylo & Annette Lee What is a questionnaire? An effective questionnaire… Asks relevant questions Question 1 • Questions that will provide the answers to the research topic in question Food Gets valid responses • Responses given reflect the respondent’s actual opinions Gets a representative response • Makes it more reliable to infer the findings to wider population Question 2 Question 3 Introduction Anyone can design a questionnaire. An effective questionnaire requires planning and an appreciation of the psychology of respondents: Filling in a questionnaire is a complex process. • The job of a questionnaire designer is to make it easy to respond. Complex cognitive process 1. Identify subject Food 4. Decodes 5. Collects info Question 1 6. Share? 2. Phrase as question 3. Reads 7. Encode 9. Respond 8. Option No I prefer tea Exercise: responding to questions 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. What is the colour of your car? What do you usually have for breakfast? What did you have for breakfast last Friday? Have you ever not left a tip at a restaurant? What is your sexuality? What is the biggest regret in your life? Choosing the right approach Photo by Ronit Geller (http://www.sxc.hu/profile/Rogel) Types of questionnaire No method consistently outperforms others Considerations Your approach should take consideration of: • Your topic • Who you want survey • The type of information you want • Your budget • How quickly you need the information Sample size vs Depth of info • Better response rates from interviewer-led surveys than from self-response surveys. • Self-response surveys are usually cheaper. • Interviewer-led surveys can produce richer information. • Self-response surveys can reach more people. Don’t confuse quantity for quality. Children Is it pitched at the right age group? Timing and convenience • Will it be completed right after the event, or sometime after? • Will it be completed in front of other people or in private? • Many people are poor at estimating numerical info about their lives. • The more common the event the shorter a person’s window of recall is. Question types Question types • Open / closed • Single / multiple response • Attitudinal / opinion questions • Filtering / routing Attitude/opinion • Can be difficult to get the phrasing of the question right so it means the same thing to all people. • Can be tempting to put lots of explanation into the question – but sometimes this just confuses things further. • Use clear, simple English/ language and avoid being too general. • Try not to ask ‘Iceberg’ questions. Mid-point / neutral opinions Use mid-points in questions on attitude. Strongly disagree Strongly agree • Historically controversial as it was thought that respondents chose a neutral option to avoid thinking about a question. • Now shown that including a mid-point increases reliability and validity ‘How important?’ Following your visit to the clinic today, please rate the following – first based on your experience and second how important this is to you? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Waiting time Very poor Excellent How important is the length of waiting time to you? Not important Very important Quality of magazines in waiting room Very poor Excellent How important is the quality of magazines in waiting room to you? Not important Very important 17 Common mistakes What might be wrong with this question? Need to cover all options Common mistakes What might be wrong with this question? Options should be mutually exclusive. What is your age group? 0-18 18-30 30-45 45+ 0-18 19-30 31-45 46+ Common mistakes What might be wrong with this question? Options should be balanced What did you think about the waiting time? Excellent Very Good Average Poor good ‘Good’ responses ‘Bad’ response Common mistakes What might be wrong with this question? How would you rate the appointment booking service using the: Good Average Poor Website Use opt-out responses appropriately Phone Reception N/A Increasing clarity 22 Question wording • Keep questions as short as possible – Max 16 words. • Consider providing medium length (30 word) introductions to groups of related questions (context is vital!) • Use open-ended questions sparingly 23 Double questions If a question can be broken down into parts then it should be? Double negatives Do you think that it is an unwise policy to continue sending food aid to Africa. ☐ Yes ☐ No • If the respondent has to tick ‘No’ to give a positive response then this can be considered a double negative. • Try and phrase questions with a positive slant so that the positive response is ‘Yes’ rather than ‘No’. 25 Style, appearance and layout Design • Use booklet format with double-sided printing – A4 folded to A5, or, A3 folded to A4 • Front cover: – The title of the questionnaire – Identity of the organisation carrying it out – Clearly explain the purpose of the questionnaire – Keep graphics neutral Aesthetics • Arial font, size 12 point or larger • Questionnaire length – Shorter is generally better – Also keep plenty of ‘whitespace’ • Be consistent in the use of colour, shapes and location in order to guide the respondent through the questionnaire Other elements to remember • Make it look professional. • Give an estimated completion time. • Put the deadline for return at the beginning and end of the questionnaire. • Provide a return address – on the questionnaire. • Say ‘Thank you’. Ordering your questionnaire • Place easy, non-challenging questions first • Key filter questions should go in early. • Use a funnel structure – Go from basic to more in depth. – General questions before specific questions. – Go from the least sensitive to the most sensitive questions. – But – try and put important questions in before the end. Ordering your questions • Ask for suggestions for improvement at the end. • Check for leading questions. • Add prompts where required. • Order of questions can impact heavily on the amount of time it takes for the respondent to complete the questionnaire. Filtering • Filtering (or routing) helps identify which respondents should answer a detailed set of questions about a certain aspect of the topic. • Can be difficult to achieve – should be VERY CLEARLY signposted Filtering Example About our new website 1. Did you visit our website today? Yes No ✓ (If yes please answer questions 2-4, if no go to question 5) 2. Did you like the new look? 3. Did you find it easy to navigate? 4. Would you recommend the site to others? 5. Did you pick up a copy of our latest leaflet? ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Filtering Example About our new website 1. Did you visit our website today? 1a. Did you like the new look? 1b. Did you find it easy to navigate? 1c. Would you recommend the site to others? 2. Did you pick up a copy of our latest leaflet? Yes No Please continue with Q1a Please go to Q2 Tips for increasing response rate Photos by Sarah Williams & Davide Guglielmo (http://www.sxc.hu/profile/MeHere) (http://www.sxc.hu/profile/brokenarts) Improving the response rate (1) • Shorter questionnaires • Good communication – Contact the respondents beforehand – Follow-up contact with non-responders • Monetary incentives • Personal touch – Handwritten address – Including respondent’s name in cover letter Improving the response rate (2) • Method of delivery – Include a stamped return envelope – Send by first class or recorded delivery – University sponsorship can add credibility • Assure confidentiality Key take-home message Pilot your tool • This is the MOST IMPORTANT part. • If a range of respondents from different backgrounds will be using the questionnaire make sure you use as many of these different groups as possible in the trial. • Go back to your objectives – does the data help you fulfil your objectives and measure against the standards you set? 39