Ethical Clinical Report Writing Workshop Karen M. Nielsen, Ph.D., RSW (Clinical) Ann Marie Dewhurst, M.A., Reg. Psych. (AB & NWT) Assumptions Feminist view Hope-based view Reports have power that may live beyond the writer. Reports are part of clinical connection. Reports have the potential for growth or injury. Approaching Report Writing Consider Who is your audience • Tone, structure, language What is your purpose What application your report may have after it leaves your hands. • Focus, goals, Structuring of Reports Standard information Title Date of report Purpose of report Relevant referral or client data • Birthdates, age, referral agents, etc. Request for service statement Treatment goals for this reporting period. Statement of limitation All reports have limits related to: • • • Validity of data • Self-report, limited range of sources Reliability of data • Test results have limited life-span Generalization of data Therefore, it is important to note this in a report. Application Write your own statement of limitations as it applies to a specific report you might write. Confidentiality Include where relevant: Confirmation that issue was addressed How it was addressed Cautions issued Limits of confidentiality Distribution of report Ownership of report Application Write your own statement of confidentiality as it applies to a specific report you might write. Ethics • Does your client recognize him/her self in the report? • Can your client comprehend your report? • Consistency with spirit of FOIP/PIPA • Is your report consistent with the clinical style your client has come to expect? • Does your report reflect your professional ethics? Reporting Data Sources Indicate where you got your data from: Interviews (with whom, roles, date) Documents reviewed and source (including that provided by referral source) Data requested but unavailable Testing results and authors of other reports to which you have referred Cite your references when referring to outside sources Application Write your own template for inclusion of data sources as it applies to a specific reports you may write. Evidenced-Based Reporting Link your findings to your data • Conclusions must be based solely on evidence presented in your report. Link your findings to the specific research literature • Situate your findings in the professional literature where appropriate. Cite references for all tools used. Integration of data and analysis Have an introduction to complex reports. Have a structure that follows a logical flow. Connect themes. Limit discussion to issues relevant to the purpose of the report. Omit data irrelevant to the purpose of the report Ethics Check your report for personal bias • Frustration with client • Hostility toward client • Judgements of client • Disrespectful language • Preferential treatment • Minimization of issues, omissions of data or exaggeration of gains due to feelings about client Ethical Statements of Risk about a client Clear, deliberate opinion Specific type of behaviour and likely vulnerable populations Evidence based estimates Specific context Clear circumstances / risk factors Time limitations of rating Analysis and Summary Statement Have a summary statement that includes your: • Clinical opinion • Summary of key issues • Summarize treatment gains related to specific goals Avoiding Legal Pitfalls Stay within your area of expertise. Stay within the confines of your data. Own your own opinions. Stay with the expressed purpose of the report – avoid two birds with one report unless this is your mandate. Say what you mean and mean what you say. Avoid ambiguity. Important Stuff Avoid passive language • E.g. it is suggested that… vs. Dr. Ralph wrote in his risk assessment dated 4/5/6 that… Use simple sentences wherever possible. Use headings and bullets. Write in first person. Write from a clear outline. Progress Report Outline Standard Information • • • • • • • Title Date of report Purpose of report Relevant referral or client data • Birthdates, age, referral agents, etc. Request for service statement Limits of confidentiality Limits of progress report Treatment Goals • • clinical formulation agreed to with client Progress toward goals Clinical formulation or analysis • your understanding of what your observations mean. Summary Recommendations Assessment Outline Standard Information • Title • Date of report • Purpose of report • Relevant referral or client data • • Birthdates, age, referral agents, etc. Request for service statement Defining the assessment process • • • • • Limits of Confidentiality Distribution of report Dates of assessment sessions Tools and strategies used Data sources and documentation reviewed Assessment data and findings Static and dynamic risk variables (if appropriate) Statement of risk or summary of findings Clinical formulation/ clinical opinion Recommendations Appropriate Recommendations Realistic (client, system, resources available) Specific to presenting issue Flow from analysis presented Direct future interventions where appropriate Include need for referrals to other service providers where appropriate Valerian Consulting Ltd. Karen Nielsen & Ann Marie Dewhurst 9412 91st Street Edmonton, Alberta T6C 3P4 Phone: 780-485-5119 Fax: 780-485-5191 valerian@telus.net