Born This Way?
Ideologies of eros in Plato’s
Symposium
Journal Prompt
Does Plato's Symposium seem to validate
or to undercut Foucault and/or Halperin
Discussion
the aristoph myth
implies an essentialist
view of sexuality
 they all have different
views
 male biased



heavenly – nothing
female
earthly aphrod
2013-09-26
Ancient Sexuality and Gender
3
Agenda

Writer’s Corner …


Name That Mistake
Recap and Update

Sexual “Codes” & Sexualities in Aeschines and
Plato
2013-09-26
Ancient Sexuality and Gender
4
Writer’s Corner …
Name That Mistake
Plagiarism!
wordy
ital
The Ancient Grecian play Medea caused a
tremendous stir when it was first performed.
The evil that I do, I understand full well,
But a passion drives me greater than my will.
dropped quote, MLA citation issues
unsubstantiated claim
Recap and Update
Sexual “Codes” & Sexualities in Aeschines and
Plato
Is ____ gay?
Misgolas
“He is bent on that sort of thing
[pederasty] like one possessed,
and is accustomed always to have
about him [male] singers or
cithara-players” (41)
Timarchus
“Timarchus was … just the person for the
thing that Misgolas wanted to do, and
Timarchus wanted to have done.” (41)
“What shall we say when a young man …
keeps the most expensive flutegirls and
harlots? When he gambles and pays
nothing himself but another man always
pays for him?” (75)
Plato’s Symposium …
Symposium: Erotic Dichotomies
male
Uranian (“Heavenly”)
spiritual
male-pederastic
female
Pandemian (“Vulgar”)
carnal
“other” (lesbian, heteroerotic)
temperate
intemperate
asymmetrical
symmetrical
Symposium: Interlocking Arguments
Speaker
Phaedrus
Pausanias
Eryximachus
Aristophanes
Agathon
Socrates
Alcibiades
Speech
Eros the Ancient
the two loves
[ditto]
“my other half”
Eros the Youthful
Eros the daimōn
Socrates’ temperate
intemperance
Erotic Law Codes? (Pausanias’ Speech)

Nomos =
“Law”
 “Convention”


“Law Codes”

Elsewhere
Elis, Boeotia
 Ionia


“Here”
2013-09-26
Ancient Sexuality and Gender
16
Aristophanes’ Myth
Essentialist or Constructionist?
Is Diotimian erōs Pederasty?
And is it honorable?