UTILIZATION OF BOOSTER FANS IN UNDERGROUND COAL MINES Felipe Calizaya Michael G. Nelson Jessica Wempen Randy Peterson University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT 2011 INTRODUCTION Booster Fan: 1) An underground fan installed in the main air stream to handle the quantity of air circulated through a section 2) Installed in a permanent bulkhead and equipped with a set of airlock doors and fan monitors 3) A properly sized and sited booster fan can be used to create safer work conditions and allow the extraction of minerals from great depths Daw Mill Colliery 3 Daw Mill Colliery is the most significant coal mine in the UK producing 3 million tonnes per year The mine is deep and extensive with a depth over 850 m and over 7.5 km of workings A retreating longwall is used as the primary means of production Longwall panels are developed with a single entry. Panels are 2,500 m long and 350 m wide Isolation pillars from 90 to 180 m wide are left between each panel Daw Mill Colliery Ventilation 4 One intake shaft and one exhaust shaft A surface drift used to transport coal provides 20 m3/s of intake air Two exhausting centrifugal surface fans are installed on the surface. One fan is active and one fan is redundant Both surface fans are capable of operating at 169 m3/s with a pressure of 2.8 kPa Production headings are ventilated with at least 6.5 m3/s, this is driven by a 90 kW auxiliary fan operating at 3.5 kPa Daw Mill Colliery Ventilation 5 One booster fan site that consists of four 2 m axial booster fans with a combined capacity of 120 m3/s with a pressure of 3.5 kPa Outlet Inlet a) Inlet Side F S a) Cross-section View F S b) Long -section View Daw Mill Colliery Ventilation 6 Booster fans are located in the return and the motors are enclosed in flame proof housing Because of the risk of spontaneous combustion booster fans were installed in rock above the coal seam Booster fans are sited inby the current neutral ventilation point so there is a small amount of air recirculation (less than 10%) Booster fans are essential to provide adequate air volume and control heat. The fans increase the volume of air at the longwall face by 50% Daw Mill Colliery Ventilation 7 Ventilation challenges include: Methane – 2 m3 of methane per ton of coal Spontaneous combustion – can occur regularly during development and salvage operations Daw Mill Colliery Ventilation 8 Methane and carbon monoxide levels are measured throughout the mine At the booster fans airflow, pressure, vibration, bearing temperature, methane, and carbon monoxide are constantly monitored In addition to electronic monitoring, a tube bundle system is used to monitor air quality Because of the high risk of spontaneous combustion a nitrogen system is used Maltby Colliery 9 Maltby Colliery produces 3 million tons per year ROM and 1 million tons per year clean coal A retreating longwall is used as the primary means of production and is supported by four development sections Longwall panels are developed with a single entry system The mine is deep and extensive with a depth over 960 m and over 8 km of workings Maltby Colliery 1911-1972 SEAM EXHAUSTED AFTER 61 YEARS No.1 SHAFT No.2 SHAFT No.3 SHAFT. DEPTH IN METRES. BARNSLEY SEAM WORK BEGAN 1970 SEAM ABANDONED 1993. 812m SWALLOW WOOD SEAM 822m HAIGH MOOR SEAM SEAM PARTIALLY WORKED LATER ABANDONED. CURRENT WORKINGS 960m PARKGATE SEAM THORNCLIFFE SEAM 982m Maltby Colliery Ventilation 12 Two intake shafts and one exhaust shaft Two 5.3 m centrifugal exhaust fans are installed on the surface. One fan is active and one fan is redundant Both fans are capable of operating at 280m3/s with a pressure of 5.5 kPa. Maltby Colliery Ventilation 13 One 2.05 m axial booster fan operating at 140 m3/s with a pressure of 7.4 kPa Bulkhead Screen Impeller Airflow Motor Diffuser Section View Drift Floor Maltby Colliery Ventilation 14 Maltby Colliery Ventilation 15 Ventilation challenges include: Heat – Virgin rock temperature is near 42⁰C and air picks up an additional 7 ⁰C across the booster fan Humidity – High water usage for dust control and machine cooling Methane – 25 m3 of methane produced per ton of coal Frictional Ignition Maltby Colliery Ventilation 16 Booster fan is located in the return and the motor is enclosed in flame proof housing Booster fans are essential to provide adequate air volume and control heat Booster fan is sited inby the current neutral ventilation point so there is some air recirculation Methane drainage system is used to control excess methane Maltby Colliery Ventilation 17 Booster fan installation includes four airlock doors between the intake and the return. Three airlock doors are used in the fan bulk head A manometer and a digital pressure gauge are used to measure pressure across the bulk head The installation includes a water barrier to control fire that may occur at the fan Maltby Colliery Ventilation 18 Methane is monitored in the intake and in the return upstream and downstream from the fan Carbon monoxide and smoke detectors are located downstream A tube bundle system is also used to monitor the air quality Maltby Colliery Ventilation To Tail Gate Bulkhead Man Doors Return Booster Fan Airlock Doors Intake Fan and Environmental Monitors Tube Bundle Methane Carbon Monoxide Manometer Smoke Delta Press Kellingley Colliery 20 Kellingley Colliery produces 2.3 million tons per year A retreating longwall is used as the primary means of production and is supported by four development sections Longwall panels are developed with a single entry system The mine is deep and extensive with a depth over 800 m and over 9 km of workings Kellingley Colliery Ventilation 21 One intake shaft and one exhaust shaft Two 4.14 m centrifugal blowing fans are installed on the surface. One fan is active and one fan is redundant Both fans are capable of operating at 290 m3/s with a pressure of 2.5 kPa. Kellingley Colliery Ventilation 22 Three booster fan sites all located in the return Single 1.6 m double inlet centrifugal fan operating at 290 m3/s and7 kPa Four 1.2 m axial fans operating at 68 m3/s and 2.5 kPa, two installations one in the return and one in intake Kellingley Colliery Ventilation 23 Bulkhead Diffuser Discharge Casing Inlet Centrifugal Booster Fan Kellingley Colliery Ventilation Intake Bulkhead Booster Fan Return Airlock Doors Airlock Doors Fan and Environmental Monitors 25 Methane Delta Press Carbon Monoxide Temperature 2 x 2 Booster Fans Intake Airlock Doors Bulkhead Return 26 Kellingley Colliery Ventilation 27 Ventilation challenges include: Methane, Heat, and Dust Booster fans are essential to provide adequate air volume and control heat There is a small amount of air recirculation (less than 10%) Turbulence around the multi-fan installation can be a problem Significant Differences in Ventilation Practices Between the UK and the US 28 Booster fan installations are common and are accepted as a safe and effective means of ventilating sections Booster fans are often viewed as the only option for providing adequate ventilation underground Booster fans are most commonly axial fans installed in clusters with up to four-two stage fans per site and all fans were installed in concrete bulk heads Booster fans were selected based on each mines pressure and quantity requirements Significant Differences in Ventilation Practices Between the UK and the US 29 Two types of parameters were monitored at each fan: fan parameters and environmental parameters Fan parameters included differential pressure, motor and bearing temperatures, and air velocity Environmental parameters included methane, carbon monoxide, and smoke. Atmospheric monitoring systems were extensive and robust Booster fans were most often located in the returns in series with the main fans Motors and electrical components were located in the return but were contained in flame proof housing Significant Differences in Ventilation Practices Between the UK and the US 30 There was no electrical interlocking between the main fans and the booster fans at any of the mines All of the coal mines were using single entry systems with barrier pillars between the longwall panels No neutral entry for the conveyor belts were used. Belts were used in both intake and in return airways Recirculation and series ventilation are not strictly prohibited. Most mines using booster fans were recirculation about 10% of the air Booster fan model for Highland 9 Mine 31 Unit 3: 9.4 cms Unit 5: 9.4 cms North Mains Highland Mine projected ventilation network using only a main fan Summary of Results: West Mains Unit 1: 9.4 cms Main fan duty: Total airpower: East Mains Unit 2: 9.4 cms Legend Main Fan North Unit 4: 9.4 cms 200 m3/s at 2.24 kPa 440 kW Highland Mine projected ventilation network using one booster fan Unit 3: 9.4 cms Unit 5: 9.4 cms North Mains West Mains Summary of Results: 180 m3/s at 1.37 kPa Booster fan duty: 150 m3/s at 0.57 kPa Total airpower: 330 kW Main fan duty: Unit 1: 9.4 cms East Mains Unit 2: 9.4 cms Legend Main Fan North Booster Fan Unit 4: 9.4 cms Highland Mine projected ventilation network using two booster fans Unit 3: 9.4 cms Unit 5: 9.4 cms North Mains West Mains Unit 1: 9.4 cms East Mains Summary of results: Main fan duty: 150 m3/s at 1 kPa Booster fan 1 95 m3/s at duty 0.5 kPa Booster fan 2 : 65 m3/s at duty 0.5 kPa Total airpower: 230 kW Unit 2: 9.4 cms Legend Main Fan North Booster Fan 1 Booster Fan 2 Unit 4: 9.4 cms