Public Health Principles and Practices: A Platform for College Health Edward P. Ehlinger, MD, MSPH Director and Chief Health Officer Boynton Health Service University of Minnesota June 4, 2010 eehlinger@bhs.umn.edu Ruth Westheimer born Karola Ruth Siegel on June 4, 1928 • "Talking from morning to night about sex has helped my skiing, because I talk about movement, about looking good, about taking risks." Rosalind Russell born on June 4, 1911 • “Flops are a part of life's menu and I've never been a girl to miss out on any of the courses.” Ruth Westheimer born Karola Ruth Siegel on June 4, 1928 • “Don't stint on foreplay -- or afterplay. Be inventive!” Dik Browne American cartoonist died on June 4, 1989 He wrote and illustrated Hagar the Horrible and illustrated Hi and Lois Examples of strips of his published on June 4th Dik Browne American cartoonist died on June 4, 1989 Financial pressures Healthcare reform The future of College Health is uncertain • Healthcare reform will raise questions that will threaten the existence of college health – “Everyone will have insurance so why have a health service?” – “Everyone will have insurance so what is the need for a health service fee?” • Some entrepreneurs may see healthcare reform as an opportunity to gain some college health business. • Some in college health may see healthcare reform as an opportunity to change the model of college health. Rosalind Russell born on June 4, 1911 • "When something happens to you, you either let it defeat you, or you defeat it.“ How will you respond to those questions and challenges? How will you convince your college/university that what you provide is unique and best meets the needs of students (and others) on your campus and the needs of your institution? Health is essential to the mission of Post-Secondary Education • “When health is absent, wisdom cannot reveal itself, art cannot become manifest, strength cannot fight, wealth becomes useless, and intelligence cannot be applied.” • Herophilus of Chalcedon, 335-280 BCE • Physician to Alexander the Great No one provides the constellation of services offered by college health • On-campus location • Interest in serving a unique population with unique needs • Expertise in serving college students • Provides a constellation of services not provided by any other provider – Services that meet the needs of students and the campus – Services that help meet the needs of the broader community College Health Services Service – Teaching - Research • Medical Care/Primary Care (broadly defined) • Dental Care • Occupational Health • Health Promotion/Wellness • Health Education • Student Development • Environmental Health and Safety • Public Health Today is a BIG day in Public Health June 4, 1912 June 4, 1919 June 4, 1912 • Massachusetts became the first state in the US to set a minimum wage. Income Deaths per 1,000 12.5 10 7.5 5 2.5 0 0 lowest 1 2 Income Groups 3 4 5 highest June 4, 1919 Thursday, June 5, 1919 Suffrage Wins in Senate; Now Goes to States Constitutional Amendment Is Passed, 56 to 25, or Two More Than Two-thirds Women May Vote In 1920 Leaders Start Fight to Get Ratification by Three-fourths of States in Time Debate Precedes Vote Wadsworth Explains His Attitude In Opposition - Resolution Signed with Ceremony 19th Amendment • The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation. 19th amendment to the U. S. Constitution Dates of Ratification by States • • • • • • • • • • • Illinois, June 10, 1919 Michigan, June 10, 1919 Wisconsin, June 10, 1919 Kansas, June 16, 1919; New York, June 16, 1919 Ohio, June 16, 1919 Pennsylvania, June 24 Massachusetts, June 25 Texas, June 28, 1919 Iowa, July 2, 1919; Missouri, July 3, 1919 • • • • • • • • • • • Arkansas, July 28, 1919 Montana, August 2, 1919 Nebraska, August 2, 1919 Minnesota, September 8, 1919 New Hampshire, September 10 Utah, October 2, 1919 California, November 1, 1919 Maine, November 5, 1919 North Dakota, December 1, 1919 South Dakota, December 4, 1919 Colorado, December 15, 1919 19th amendment to the U. S. Constitution Dates of Ratification by States • Kentucky, January 6, 1920 • Rhode Island, January 6 • Oregon, January 13, 1920 • Arizona, February 12, 1920 • New Mexico, February 21 • Oklahoma, February 28 • West Virginia, March 10 • Indiana, January 16, 1920 • Washington, March 22, 1920 • Wyoming, January 27, 1920 • Tennessee, August 18, 1920. • Nevada, February 7, 1920 • Became National Law August 26, 1920 • New Jersey, February 9, 1920 • November 2, 1920 – Presidential election • Idaho, February 11, 1920 – Warren Harding and Calvin Coolidge elected 1921- The Shepherd-Towner Maternity and Infant Protection Act • Authorized grants for state programs of maternal and children's services Sheppard Towner Act (Maternity and Infancy Care Act) 1921-1929 • First public grants-in-aid program in U.S. • Developed MCH units in state Health Depts • Birth registration (30 - 46 states) • Increased Public Health Nursing • Partnership of federal and state government • Not continued because of fear of socialism • Basis for Title V of Social Security Act Core Functions of Public Health • Assessment • Policy Development • Assurance – Institute of Medicine, Future of Public Health John Sundwall, MD, Ph.D. • Director of University of Minnesota Health Service 1918-1921 University of Michigan Division of Hygiene and Public Health 1921-1941 • “Unfortunately, parents, students, and faculty regard a health service as little more than a clinic or hospital concerned only with illness and injuries, their diagnosis and treatment; and regard the health fee paid directly or indirectly by students as sickness insurance.” John Sundwall, MD, Ph.D. • “Obviously, the best scientific treatment and care of illness and injuries must be one of the major concerns of the Health Service, but, in addition, a health service must be, as the term signifies, a health service. It bears something of the same relation to the university community that a public health department bears to a municipality or county, however in a more progressive and advanced state, in the vanguard of the public health movement.” C. E. A. Winslow Dean, Yale School of Pubic Health • “a university health service can realize its possibilities of leadership only if it visualizes public health in the broadest terms.” • 1929 Prevailing View of U. S. Health Care System Health Care System Public Health System Medical Care System Health Care System = Public Health Subsystem + Medical Care Subsystem College Health/Public Health View of Health System HEALTH of the PUBLIC Core Functions Assessment Policy Development Assurance Health Care Medical Care Clinical Community Preventive Health Services Services Approaches Health Promotion Health Protection Disease/Injury Prevention Treatment/rehabilitation Other Influences Public policies - Education - Economy Scientific advances - Housing Knowledge - Social norms Recreation - Transportation Media/Entertainment - Religion Income inequality - Sense of community Many more Factors Influencing Health Status Scope of Public Health Healthy Public Policy & Public Work General protection Society's Health Response Targeted protection Primary prevention Medical and Public Health Policy Secondary prevention Tertiary prevention Becoming no longer vulnerable Safer, Healthier Population Becoming Vulnerable Vulnerable Population Becoming Afflicted Afflicted without Complications Developing Complications Afflicted with Complications Dying from Complications Adverse Living Conditions DEMOCRATIC SELF-GOVERNANCE World of Transforming… By Strengthening… • Deprivation • Dependency • Violence • Disconnection • Environmental decay • Stress • Insecurity • Etc… • Leaders and institutions • Foresight and precaution • The meaning of work • Mutual accountability • Plurality • Democracy • Freedom • Etc… DISEASE AND RISK MANAGEMENT World of Providing… • Education • Screening • Disease management • Pharmaceuticals • Clinical services • Physical and financial access • Etc… Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Bobby Milstein Guiding principles: Prevailing View/College Health View Public Health/College Health Science-based Medical Care • Science-based Data are important! Basic and clinical research are important in medical care. Surveillance, monitoring, and epidemiology are important in college health/public health. Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual NIAAA - College Drinking Prevention 4 Tiers of Effectiveness • Tier 1: Evidence of Effectiveness Among College Students • Tier 2: Evidence of Success With General Populations That Could Be Applied to College Environments • Tier 3: Evidence of Logical and Theoretical Promise, But Require More Comprehensive Evaluation • Tier 4: Evidence of Ineffectiveness College Drinking Prevention NIAAA 4 Tiers of Effectiveness • Tier 1: Evidence of Effectiveness Among College Students – Strategy: Combining cognitive-behavioral skills with norms clarification and motivational enhancement interventions. – Strategy: Offering brief motivational enhancement interventions. – Strategy: Challenging alcohol expectancies. • We should implement these strategies as part of our clinical role. College Drinking Prevention NIAAA 4 Tiers of Effectiveness • Tier 2: Evidence of Success With General Populations That Could Be Applied to College Environments – Strategy: Implementation, increased publicity, and enforcement of laws to reduce alcohol-impaired driving. – Strategy: Restrictions on alcohol retail outlet density – Strategy: Increased prices and excise taxes on alcoholic beverages. – Strategy: The formation of a campus and community coalition involving all major stakeholders may be critical to implement these strategies effectively. College Drinking Prevention NIAAA 4 Tiers of Effectiveness • Tier 3: Evidence of Logical and Theoretical Promise, But Require More Comprehensive Evaluation – Strategy: Increasing publicity about and enforcement of underage drinking laws on campus and eliminating "mixed messages." – Strategy: Conducting marketing campaigns to correct student misperceptions about alcohol use. – Strategy: Regulation of happy hours and sales. • We should implement Tier 2 and Tier 3 strategies as part of our public health role. Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility responsibility The Ecosystem of an Individual Norms multinational corporations Culture government health care violence friends providers crime grandparents child parents work care Laws ...isms Individual relatives courts peers sibs FAMILY schools movies Attitudes COMMUNITY SOCIETY T.V. police immigrants Values Health Promotion Healthy People 2000 • Personal choices have powerful influence over one’s health. While health behaviors are personal, choices are made in a broader social context that is difficult to separate from the psychology of the individual. So while the choice may be individual, the locus of intervention needs to be wide enough to incorporate the environment that will either support or undermine personal choice. Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility Broad definition of health responsibility • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases College Health View of Health System HEALTH of the PUBLIC Core Functions Assessment Policy Development Assurance Health Care Medical Care Clinical Community Preventive Health Services Services Approaches Health Promotion Health Protection Disease/Injury Prevention Treatment/rehabilitation Other Influences Public policies - Education - Economy Scientific advances - Housing Knowledge - Social norms Recreation - Transportation Media/Entertainment - Religion Income inequality - Sense of community Many more Did women’s suffrage affect health? U of MN Student Health Advisory Committee • • • • • • • • • Smoke-free campus Bicycle trails Farmers Market Menu labeling Year-round fees Extended hours of operation Insurance RFP Late night transportation FDA blood donation policy Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility Broad definition of health Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary responsibility • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases • Specialization Scope of Clinical Specialists, Clinical Generalists, and Public Health Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Bobby Milstein Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility responsibility Broad definition of health Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ • Specialization Cooperation/Integration • Competitive • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases Public Health • What we, as a society, do collectively to assure the conditions in which people can be healthy. – Institute of Medicine College Health View of Health System HEALTH of the PUBLIC Core Functions Assessment Policy Development Assurance Health Care Medical Care Clinical Community Preventive Health Services Services Approaches Health Promotion Health Protection Disease/Injury Prevention Treatment/rehabilitation Other Influences Public policies - Education - Economy Scientific advances - Housing Knowledge - Social norms Recreation - Transportation Media/Entertainment - Religion Income inequality - Sense of community Many more Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility responsibility Broad definition of health • Focus on specific illnesses Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ Cooperation • Specialization Prevention/Promotion/Protection • Competitive or diseases • Treatment Real Leading Causes of Death • Tobacco 400,000 • Diet/inactivity 300,000 • Alcohol 100,000 • Microbial agents 90,000 • Toxic agents 60,000 • Firearms 35,000 • Sexual behavior 30,000 • Motor vehicles 25,000 • Illicit drug use 20,000 Leading Causes of Death • Heart disease 725,790 • Cancer 537,390 • Stroke 159,877 • Lung diseases 110,637 • Injuries 92,191 • Pn/influenza 88,383 • Diabetes 62,332 • Suicide 29,725 • Kidney disease 25,570 • Cirrhosis 24,765 Factors Influencing Health Status Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility responsibility Broad definition of health • Focus on specific illnesses Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ Cooperation • Specialization Prevention/Promotion/Protection • Competitive Long-term responsibility • Treatment or diseases • Short term responsibility Death Early Death Disease, Disability and Social Problems Adoption of Health-risk Behaviors Social, Emotional, & Cognitive Impairment Adverse Childhood Experiences Conception Adverse Childhood Experiences: childhood abuse and neglect growing up with domestic violence, substance abuse or mental illness in the home, parental discord, crime ACE Score and Alcoholism, Suicide Attempts, or Sexual Assault Percent With Health Problem (%) 35 30 Number of adverse factors: 25 0 1 2 3 4 or more 20 15 10 5 0 Considers self an alcoholic Ever attempted suicide Sexually assaulted as an adult (women) College Students Should Be A Long-term Public Health Priority Group • Numbers are large and increasing – Can be targeted – Last time we have relatively easy access to them • Establishing lifestyle and behaviors • Role models for younger individuals • Set norms of behavior • Leaders of the future Robert Fulgum born June 4, 1937 • “Don't worry that children never listen to you; worry that they are always watching you.” Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Medical Care Science-based • Science-based Population-based • Focus on individual Health an individual and societal • Health an individual responsibility Broad definition of health Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ Cooperation Prevention/Promotion/Protection Long-term responsibility Social responsibility responsibility • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases • Specialization • Competitive • Treatment • Short term responsibility • Reimbursement driven How our healthcare money is spent 5% Medical Care Public Health 95% Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Science-based Population-based Health an individual and societal responsibility Broad definition of health Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ Cooperation Prevention/Promotion/Protection Long-term responsibility Social responsibility Social justice Medical Care • Science-based • Focus on individual • Health an individual responsibility • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases • Specialization • Competitive • Treatment • Short term responsibility • Reimbursement driven • Market justice Market Justice and US Health Care • In the United States, health care competes for consumers with other items in the marketplace. Individual resources and choices determine the distribution of health care, with little sense of collective obligation or a role for government. Known as market justice, this approach derives from principles of individualism, selfinterest, personal effort, and voluntary behavior. • The contrasting approach, social justice, allocates goods and services according to the individual's needs. It stems from principles of shared responsibility and concern for the communal well-being, with government as the vehicle for ensuring equity. • Peter P. Budetti, MD, JD, JAMA. 2008;299(1):92-94. • Market Justice: You get what you want and what you can pay for. • Social Justice: Everyone gets basic needs met and no one benefits at the expense of someone else. Public Health Geoffrey Vickers - 1957 • The constant redefinition of the unacceptable. “The philosophy of science is to discover truth. The philosophy of medicine is to use truth to treat individuals. The philosophy of public health is social justice.” William Foege, M.D. Guiding Principles Public Health/College Health Science-based Population-based Health an individual and societal responsibility Broad definition of health Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary Collaboration/ Cooperation Prevention/Promotion/Protection Long-term responsibility Social responsibility Social justice Medical Care • Science-based • Focus on individual • Health an individual responsibility • Focus on specific illnesses or diseases • Specialization • Competitive • Treatment • Short term responsibility • Reimbursement driven • Market justice C.E. A. Winslow Dean, Yale School of Pubic Health • “a university health service can realize its possibilities of leadership only if it visualizes public health in the broadest terms.” • 1929 Public Health on College Campuses The Role of College Health in Shaping the Future of Health Care Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors Real Leading Causes of Death • Tobacco 400,000 • Diet/inactivity 300,000 • Alcohol 100,000 • Microbial agents 90,000 • Toxic agents 60,000 • Firearms 35,000 • Sexual behavior 30,000 • Motor vehicles 25,000 • Illicit drug use 20,000 Leading Causes of Death • Heart disease 725,790 • Cancer 537,390 • Stroke 159,877 • Lung diseases 110,637 • Injuries 92,191 • Pn/influenza 88,383 • Diabetes 62,332 • Suicide 29,725 • Kidney disease 25,570 • Cirrhosis 24,765 Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors – Particularly important for young adults • From treatment to prevention Factors Influencing Health Status Need for treatment and prevention In tobacco control Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors • From treatment to prevention – From a population perspective, the younger the population, the more important the prevention efforts. • From short-term to long-term perspective Cycle of Development Non-child bearing Parenting Environmental and Social Influences: Parents/extended family Culture/Media Roles of men/women/children Norms/Policies Economy Community Education Multiple other influences Health Care Influences: Health Promotion Disease Prevention Health Protection Medical Care ( 10, 20 , 30) Surveillance and data Adult Preconception Prenatal Adolescent Health Care Influences Child Intrapartum Infant Environmental and Social Influences Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors • From treatment to prevention • From short-term to long-term perspective – Modifying risk-factors and seeing effects of prevention require long-term perspective • From individual to population Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors • From treatment to prevention • From short-term to long-term perspective • From individual to population – College health is one of few fields responsible for both individual and population-based outcomes • From population to context The Ecosystem of a Population College Health Focuses on Context Norms multinational corporations Culture government health care violence friends providers crime Laws parents STUDENTS courts peers sibs FAMILIES relatives schools movies Attitudes COMMUNITY SOCIETY ...isms work T.V. police immigration Values Evolving View of Health and Health Care • From disease to risk factors • From treatment to prevention • From short-term to long-term perspective • From individual to population • From population to context • From individual population problems to syndemic context Context is the Community • Whereas the usual public health approach begins by defining the disease and the population in question, a syndemic orientation first defines the community in question. Syndemic Contextual View of Health • A syndemic is two or more afflictions, interacting synergistically, contributing to excess burden of disease in a population. – Synergistic epidemics – Syndrome of epidemics Bobby Milstein • Syndemics occur when health-related problems cluster by person, place, or time Syndemics • The word syndemic was coined by anthropologist Merrill Singer and first published in 1992 to convey what he saw as inextricable and mutually reinforcing connections between health problems such as substance abuse, violence, and AIDS among urban women in the US. • Singer, 1994; 1996; Singer M and Snipes C, 1992; Singer M and Romero-Daza N, 1997 SAVA Syndemic ** Adapted from Singer M, 1996 SAVA Syndemic • "Commonly, violence, substance abuse, and AIDS have been described as concurrent epidemics among innercity populations. However, the term epidemic fails to adequately describe the true nature of the contemporary inner city health crisis, which is characterized by a set of closely interrelated, endemic and epidemic conditions, all of which are strongly influenced by a broader array of political-economic and social factors, including high rates of unemployment, poverty, homelessness and residential overcrowding, substandard nutrition, infrastructural deterioration and loss of quality housing stock, forced geographic mobility, family breakup and disruption of social support networks, youth gang formation, and health care inequality • (Wallace R, 1988; 1990; Wallace D, 1990). DAT Syndemic Depression Alcohol Tobacco Syndemic Contextual View of Health Problems are important but the ties between them are often even more important. Pay attention to confounding factors – that’s where the issues are most intense. To Understand Syndemics… •"You think that if you understand one, you understand two-because one and one are two. But you must also understand 'and'." Sufi saying Contextual/Syndemic View of Health among College Students Tobacco Violence Alcohol Depression Obesity Stress Health System Dynamics Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Bobby Milstein Syndemic Context Healthy Public Policy & Public Work General protection Society's Health Response Targeted protection Medical and Public Health Policy Primary prevention Secondary prevention Tertiary prevention Becoming no longer vulnerable Safer, Healthier Population Becoming Vulnerable Vulnerable Population Becoming Afflicted Afflicted without Complications Developing Complications Afflicted with Complications Dying from Complications Adverse Living Conditions DEMOCRATIC SELF-GOVERNANCE World of Transforming… By Strengthening… • Deprivation • Dependency • Violence • Disconnection • Environmental decay • Stress • Insecurity • Etc… • Leaders and institutions • Foresight and precaution • The meaning of work • Mutual accountability • Plurality • Democracy • Freedom • Etc… DISEASE AND RISK MANAGEMENT World of Providing… An involved population • Education • Screening • Disease management • Pharmaceuticals • Clinical services • Physical and financial access • Etc… Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Bobby Milstein Change is coming! • “Willed change” the Sufi say, “is not real. Only unwilled change is real.” Only unwilled change catapults us into what we did not plan to do. Only unwilled change really matters to the molding of the soul, to the stretching of the self beyond the self, in other words. And matter it does. Deeply. Willed change is what I seek and shape. Unwilled change is what seeks and reshapes me.” – From “The Story of Ruth” by Joan Chittester Robert Fulgum born June 4, 1937 • Author of “All I Really Need to Know, I Learned in Kindergarten.” • “The world does not need tourists who ride by in a bus clucking their tongues. The world as it is needs those who will love it enough to change it, with what they have, where they are.” C. E. A. Winslow at the 1929 dedication of University Health Service University of Minnesota “…a university health service …can realize its possibilities of leadership only if it visualizes public health in the broadest terms. Public health is concerned with the prevention of disease and the promotion of health in the widest sense…”