BUSINESS, ETHICS AND
SOCIETY – MGT104
Week 3 – Worker exploitation…
and resistance
Fall 2026
Professor : Hatim Fassi Fihri
On LMS
Updated Team list
Smith and the positive
effects of the division
of labor
At the individual level, the person
gains dexterity.
At the organizational level, the
organization gains productivity.
At the national level, the nation
gains a competitive advantage.
Friedman : The (Only) Social
Responsibility of Business Is
therefore to Increase Its Profits
1) The manager is at the
service of the shareholders/
stockholders only.
2) Social responsibility is
the responsibility of the
government.
3) If given to businesses,
social responsibility will be
reduced to social washing.
Friedreich Taylor and
Taylorism
Founded scientific management, a
management practice mainly based on the
division of labor.
Used historically in the automotive
industry.
But…
Alienation and exploitation of
the workers.
Is the research for profit or
the division of labor
exploitative, alienating ?
Modern Times (film) - Wikipedia
Quiz rules
1. No phones or laptops from the beginning
to the end.
2. Wait until everyone has received their
copy before turning your sheet over and
starting the quiz.
3. Don’t forget your name + ERP
4. The quiz lasts 5 minutes.
5. At the end of the 5 minutes. Turn your
copy and stop writing.
Reminder of class
rules
1. No phones or laptops during the class.
2. Late arrival : Until the quiz ends. If
you arrive after the quiz ends, you
will not be accepted in class.
3. The quizzes are used to mark absences.
Per IBA rules, you can miss up to 3
absences.
4. If you need to leave the class for any
reason, ask permission first.
Who is Karl Marx ?
Who is Karl Marx?
Born in a bourgeois family. His father was
a liberal lawyer from a Jewish family who
converted to Protestantism.
He had multiple lives : journalist,
economist, sociologist, philosopher,
activist.
Engels : a friend, a collaborator.
One of the founders of sociology... but
also one of the inspirations of socialism
and communism.
Main books : Das Kapital ; The communist
manifesto
Most famous work
"CAPITAL" (KARL MARX, 1867)
“THE COMMUNIST MANIFES TO”
(MARX AN D ENGE LS, 1848 )
In what context did
Marx write Das Kapital?
Work conditions in the middle of the
nineteenth century:
- 12 to 16 hours of daily work, 6 days a
week…
- Child labour (forbidden under 8 years of
age, from 1842...)
- No health insurance, no unemployment
insurance, no pension, no paid holidays...
- No unions.
Etc.
What is the implicit
question of the text?
What does it mean to be a
capitalist?
What does it mean
to be a capitalist?
Making money with money.
By making humans produce
goods, forced to live by
selling their labour power
for a wage.Then by reselling
these goods at a profit (M-CM')
Marxist theory at three levels
1st level : Relation and means of production
2nd level : Dialectical materialism
3rd level : Historical Materialism
1st level : Relation and means of
production
RELATIONS
OF
PRODUCTION
BETWEEN TWO CLASSES : THE
PROLETARIAT, WHO SELLS ITS
LABOUR
POWER
(THE
ONLY
COMMODITY IT OWNS) TO THE
BOURGEOISIE IN EXCHANGE OF
A WAGE.
MEANS OF PRODUCTION
(MACHINERY, TOOLS, LAND,
ETC.) OWNED BY THE
BOURGEOISIE (ONLY) AND
PROTECTED BY PRIVATE
PROPERTY
2nd level : Dialectical
materialism
We say that Marx is a
materialist philosopher
because his theory is a loop
that starts with tangible
aspects of life
(substructures)… and
ideas/values/laws
(superstructures) follow.
The state is
here to
protect the
interest of
the dominant
class (the
bourgeoisie)
How to break the
loop ?
One and only
possible way
according to Marx :
the revolution
In the Communist
Manifesto :
How can the working class
liberate themselves from the
exploitative
nature
of
capitalism?
Ex : In the slavery
system, the class in
struggle are the slaves
and the masters
Ex : The Bolshevik revolution (1918) is
an example of a moment in history when
the bourgeois state was seized by
proletarian forces and replaced by a
socialist state
For Marx, communism is
the “end of history”
(no class, no class
struggle, no more
revolution)
rd
3 level : Historical Materialism
For Marx, the ”motor of history” is class struggle. Every system has its
respective dominant and exploited class. It eventually leads to a
political revolution when a system and the state that governs it are
replaced by a a new one.
The Bolshevic
Revolution
Historical video here :
A black text on a white background
AI-generated content may be incorrect.
What link with Smith ?
What link with Smith ?
Both authors are concerned with the idea
of social justice.
BUT
Unlike Smith, Marx underlined the
injustice of capitalism.
He also disputes
its "natural"
character.
« Economists have a singular
(strange) way of proceeding.
For them there are only two
kinds of institutions, those of
art and those of nature. The
institutions of feudalism are
artificial institutions, those
of the bourgeoisie are natural
institutions…»
Karl Marx, The poverty of
philosophy, 1847
What about
Marx and
Friedman ?
What about Marx and
Friedman ?
If Friedman says that the firm should not be
concerned by social responsibility, Marx would
probably agree but for a different reason.
For Marx, any social “reforms” would probably
just be considered as a way for the system to
adapt to social pressures, diminish the “anger”
of the exploited class and, essentially, delay
the revolution.
Is Marx critic still
relevant today ?
Capital in the 21st century
Piketty is an economist who has
done a historical study of
inequality from the 18th
century to the present day.
His book "Capital in the 21st
Century" has been used in some
social movements.
Current Critique of
Capitalism
A black text on a white background
AI-generated content may be incorrect.
Example : the Occupy Wall
Street movement, which emerged
in New York in 2011 and has
spread widely and rapidly
around the globe.
The movement is known for
denouncing the 1%.
The 1%
What do you
think about
these numbers ?
The 1%
Share of the 1% in the national income of Anglo-Saxon countries.
E.g. In 2010, the richest 1% held 18% of the national income in the USA.
Income inequality vs.
wealth inequality
The rate of 18% (last slide) seems
low compared to what we can hear in
the news.
This is because the past figure only
shows the share of the richest 1% in
national income. What is not
considered earlier is the
accumulation of assets/ real wealth
(example : inheritage).
In this new figure, we can read that,
in USA, the share of the « 1% » in
2010 is closer to 35%.
How can the
debate be brought
back to the
business world?
Have work relations changed since
Marx?
Work and labour
power.
Of course, labor power is
always traded through the
wage standard.
But the workers have
obtained social gains.
So no change in the
relations of production
but a change in the work
conditions.
How can we defend the interests of
the working class?
Unions
A union is an organized
association of workers formed to
protect and advance their
collective interests.
It gives employees a unified
voice in negotiating wages,
working conditions, and benefits
with employers.
Cooperativism, a type of
organization where the worker’s
labor is not “alienated”
Cooperativism promotes worker-owned
businesses where profits and decisionmaking power are shared equally among
employees.
A black text on a white background
AI-generated content may be incorrect.
Next class : Week 4
The cultural and religious
origins of Capitalism
"T H E P RO T ESTA N T ET HI C AN D
T H E SP I RI T OF CAP ITAL I SM "
(MAX WEBER, 1904)
+ FIRST TEAM PRESENTATION