Cost Behavior 1 The term “cost behavior” refers to how a cost responds to activity level changes. Understanding how costs behave is important for evaluating alternatives and making decisions. It is also important when it comes to planning and developing budgets. There are three different cost behavior patterns: Variable Cost, where the total level of cost changes in direct proportion to changes in activity. Fixed Cost, which remains the same as activity levels increase or decrease and Mixed Cost, which has a fixed and variable component. This type of cost is greater than zero when there is no activity and rises in proportion to increases in activity. We will discuss each of these cost types in more detail in a few moments. A company’s “cost structure” refers to the relative mix of cost types that it incurs in its operations. We will discuss in another lecture the benefits and risks associated with cost structures that include more or less of fixed costs relative to variable costs. An important aspect of understanding cost behavior is referred to as the relevant range. This is the range of activity for which a fixed cost or variable unit cost is assumed to be stable or constant. As an example, the fixed cost associated with renting a building for manufacturing products would be assumed to be relevant over the range of production capacity that the building is capable of. 2 As discussed a moment ago, a variable cost changes in total in direct proportion to changes in the activity level. It is important to note that variable costs remain constant on a per unit basis. As an example, if a unit of direct material has a cost of $5, and 100 units are used, total variable cost will be $500. If 1,000 units are used, total variable cost will be $5,000. In both cases, however, the variable unit cost is $5 and will remain so as long as the volume of units remains within the relevant range. As we discussed in an earlier lecture, an activity base or cost driver is the measure of what causes the incurrence of a variable cost, such as the miles driven in a truck, the units of product produced, the number of machine hours used or the direct labor hours worked by employees. The number and type of variable costs incurred by a particular company depends on the purpose and structure of the company. Total variable costs can be calculated with the equation: Variable cost per unit times the volume of related activity. 3 As we saw a moment ago, total variable costs can be expressed using the formula Variable Cost per Unit times the Volume of Activity. We will now this formula to create a graph that identifies the variable costs incurred by a bicycle manufacturer to purchase chains for the bicycles it produces. Each chain has unit cost of $8. Let’s assume that the company purchases 50 chains for use in production. This yields a total cost of $400. After plotting this point on our graph, with total variable cost being on the vertical, or “Y”, axis and activity volume being on the horizontal, or “X”, axis, we can draw a trend line for the cost of bicycle chains. We do so by starting at the X and Y axis origins, which relates to zero units produced and zero cost, and drawing a straight line from that point through the data point for 50 units of production and continuing on, on the same trajectory or slope. We can use the formula to estimate total variable cost for other levels of production. If the company produces 100 bicycles, it will incur total variable cost of $800 for chains. We can confirm this level of cost using our graph. As long as the level of activity remains in the relevant range associated with the $8 per unit cost for bicycle chains, our cost formula should provide a reliable and accurate estimate of total variable costs for this component of the company’s product. 4 Economists correctly point out that many variable costs actually behave in a curvilinear fashion. A curvilinear cost exhibits a linear behavior in a small band of activity or volume known as the relevant range. Within the relevant range, assumptions made about cost behavior are thought to be reasonably valid. It is this segment of the curve that we saw depicted a moment ago for the cost of bicycle chains. To the left of the range, variable unit costs are higher due to inefficiencies associated with acquiring resources and producing products in small quantities. To the right of the relevant range, variable unit costs are also higher due to the stress associated with acquiring inputs and producing products at or near capacity. As the demand for resources increases, costs increase as well. Costs also increase as companies stretch to produce at the upper end of their productive capacity as, for example, overtime and shift premiums are paid to achieve higher output volumes. It is important for managers to know that these cost behaviors exist outside of the relevant range as they plan for significant increases or decreases in activity levels. 5 Fixed costs remain constant in total throughout a wide range of activity levels. However, they vary on a per unit basis as activity levels change. As an example, if a company rents a building to manufacture its product in for $20,000 per month, and produces 1 unit of product, the rent would have a per unit cost of $20,000. If production is increased to 2 units, rent would be $10,000 per unit. As production increases, the per unit cost for rent would continue to decrease. The rent would, however, continue to be $20,000 in total as long as the activity level remains in the relevant range, which in this example would be the production capacity of the building. Fixed costs are often referred to as “capacity costs” as they are expenditures for buildings, equipment and professional staff which provide a company with its ability to produce products and services for its customers. Fixed costs are viewed as either committed or discretionary costs. 6 Committed fixed costs relate to investments in facilities, equipment and organizational infrastructure. These types of expenditures result from long-term planning decisions that cannot be reduced in the near term without making fundamental changes to the company’s operations, such as closing a plant and selling the related buildings and production machinery. Discretionary fixed costs arise from decisions typically made during the annual budgeting process, where expenditure levels are established for activities such as advertising and product promotion, research and development, and employee training. The planning horizon for these types of expenditures is relatively short and they can be reduced for short periods of time with minimal impact to an organization. Obviously a company would not want to curtail its advertising, research and development, and training activities for an extended period of time as it would likely prove to be detrimental to its long-term success. 7 Next we will look at an example related to fixed costs. Let’s assume that a photographer rents studio space for $50,000 per year and measures their activity in terms of photo sessions. Unlike the upward sloping trend line associated with variable costs, the trend line for a fixed cost is flat, starting where it intersects with the Y axis and extending across its relevant range. As discussed a moment ago, while fixed costs remain the same in total, their cost per unit varies as activity levels change. If in this example the photographer has 500 sessions in a particular year the rent cost per session is equal to $100. If they have 1,000 sessions, the rent cost per session drops to $50. 8 In many industries, tasks once performed by labor are now performed by machines to gain or maintain a competitive advantage. As automation and information technology use has intensified, demand for knowledge workers, such as production engineers, has increased. This has dramatically shifted labor costs from being variable to being fairly fixed and committed. Companies are using significantly fewer hourly-paid workers and have become more reliant on highly skilled, salaried employees. 9 There are several other factors that may cause direct labor costs, traditionally considered to be variable, to behave more like fixed costs. Cultural norms and regulatory requirements in some countries require that employees be allowed to work for a minimum number of hours each week regardless of a company’s production needs. From a management perspective, companies are reluctant to reduce staff when activity levels wane for fear of losing valuable knowledge and skills that will be needed when demand for the company’s products and services recover. Managers are often reluctant to add staff during times of increased activity for fear that that they will have to lay off employees during economic downturns. 10 Not all variable costs have exactly the same cost behavior pattern. Truly variable costs vary in direct proportion to the level of cost driver activity. Step-variable costs: • Are incurred for resources that can only be obtained in large chunks. An example would be the cost incurred for customer service representatives in a call center. Once the center’s call capacity is reached at a particular level of staffing, handling one additional call will require the center to hire another service representative. The representative would likely have to be hired to work for more time than is required to simply answer one phone call. In this regard, a “chunk” of additional capacity must be added. • Step-variable costs increase or decrease only in response to fairly wide changes in activity. As an example, the rental of an additional warehouse will add storage capacity for a considerable amount of growth in a company’s sales. It would require an even greater increase in sales to prompt the rental of yet another warehouse. • Step variable costs can be avoided by “stretching” resources to absorb small changes in activity level. Continuing with the call center example, representatives could be required to work slightly longer shifts and reduce the average time spent on each call to increase capacity during busy seasons without hiring additional representatives. 11 If we look at the cost pattern associated with step-variable costs, we see that obtaining a chunk of additional resource or capacity, in this case an additional customer service representative, results in a stable level of cost for a range of volume. Once activity volume increases beyond the level of capacity added by the previous step, another representative is added and the total cost of wages increases. Each step essentially represents a fixed cost with a relatively short relevant range. 12 There are costs that companies incur that have both fixed and variable elements. These costs are referred to as mixed costs and are quite common. An example of a mixed cost is the amount paid for electricity in a manufacturing environment. There is a certain amount of electricity consumed to simply have the plant up and ready for production. Lights are on, the climate control system is running, etcetera. As production occurs, electricity consumption will increase from the base level in proportion to the volume of units produced. This type of cost is also referred to being semi-variable and can be represented by the equation Y = a + bx. Y is the total mixed cost and is derived by adding the fixed portion of the cost, represented by the letter “a”, to the total variable cost, which is determined by multiplying the variable cost per unit, “b”, by the level of activity “X”. As we can see in the graph, the trend line intercepts the “Y” axis at a cost that is greater than zero. This tells us that costs are incurred even when there is no activity taking place. As the activity level increases, costs increase as well, as a function of the variable cost component of the mixed cost. 13 Let’s look at an example of a mixed cost. We will assume that the photographer from an earlier example has leased an automated photo developer for $2,500 per year plus an additional cost of 2¢ per photo developed. We can see on the cost graph that the trend line intercepts the Y axis at $2,500 which represents the fixed portion of this mixed cost. The slope of the line reflects the variable cost component of 2¢ per unit of activity, which in this case is photos developed. If we want to know what the cost will be if 10,000 photos are developed in the upcoming year, we can calculate the amount by adding the fixed cost component of $2,500 to the variable component, which is calculated by multiplying 2¢ per photo developed by 10,000 photos. This yields a total mixed cost of $2,700. We can see that when plotted on the cost graph, the cost of $2,700 falls on the trend line. We can also see the fixed and variable components of the mixed cost clearly delineated. The fixed cost component is represented by the area between the “X” axis and the “Y” axis intercept horizontal reference line extending across the graph. The variable portion of the cost is represented by the area between the horizontal fixed cost reference line and the total cost trend line. 14 The fixed portion of a mixed cost represents the minimum cost incurred to have the related service or capability ready and available for use. The variable portion of a mixed cost is the amount incurred for actual consumption of a service, which varies in proportion to the level of activity. In order to understand and reliably predict mixed costs, their fixed and variable components must be identified. This is accomplished through account analysis, the engineering approach, scatter plots, the high-low method, and regression analysis. 15 The account analysis approach identifies costs accumulated in a company’s accounting system as either being variable, such as direct materials, or as fixed, such as building rent. Classifications are based on historical cost information and the general knowledge a manager has about the costs being evaluated. Once the accounts within a company’s accounting system have been classified as being fixed or variable, total fixed and variable costs can be determined by simply aggregating the respective account balances. This method of cost analysis works best when costs are fairly segregated between fixed and variable in a company’s general ledger. The weakness of this approach is that it does not recognize that some accounts may contain both fixed and variable or “mixed” costs. 16 The engineering approach is used to estimate the behavior of costs associated with producing a product or service by evaluating production methods, materials used, labor requirements, equipment usage and production efficiency. This method is particularly useful in situations where new products or services are going to be produced for which there is no historical cost data available for analysis. 17 Scatter plot analysis is a rather simplistic approach used to evaluate mixed cost behavior. This method encourages an analyst to visually inspect cost data to identify nonlinear relationships, where it appears that the level of activity does not affect the amount of cost incurred. It also affords an opportunity to identify and filter outliers, such as unusually high water costs that were due to a pipe breaking instead of high activity levels. When using the scatter plot method, data should be collected for several periods and checked for errors. The data should be based on accrual accounting, not cash flows, for proper association of costs to activity levels. Cost is considered the dependent variable, since the amount that is incurred depends on the level of activity. Activity level is the independent variable, since it causes variations in the level of cost incurred. The dependent variable, cost, is represented on the ‘Y” or vertical axis and the independent variable, activity, is represented on the “X” or horizontal axis. 18 Scatter Plots reveal linear cost behavior whenever a straight line reasonably approximates the relation between cost and activity. The trend line is drawn through one known data point to facilitate a quick and dirty estimate of variable and fixed costs. In using this approach to analyze a mixed cost, the vertical intercept is a rough estimate of the fixed cost component. The variable component’s unit cost can be calculated by subtracting the estimated fixed cost from the total cost for the known data point and then dividing the result by the activity level for that point. 19 Now, let’s look at an example of the scatter plot analysis method. We will assume that Piedmont Wholesale Florists has the following data regarding the number of orders processed, and related billing costs, in each quarter over the past several years. 20 The first step in the scatter plot method is to plot all of the data points and evaluate the pattern that emerges. The relationship between the number of orders and the billing cost is approximately linear, since a straight line that seems to reflect the basic relation can be drawn through the field of data points. Notice that the trend line is drawn through at least one known data point to facilitate estimating the variable component of the mixed cost in a subsequent step. The vertical intercept of the trend line, approximately $30,000 in this case, is a rough estimate of the fixed cost component. The slope of the straight line is an estimate of the variable cost per unit. Using the data point that the trend line passes through, we will calculate the variable cost per unit for billing customers. The total billing cost for 2,000 orders is $48,000. From this amount we subtract the fixed cost element, or “Y” axis intercept, of $30,000. This yields a variable cost element for 2,000 orders of $18,000. Dividing this amount by 2,000 orders yields a variable cost per unit of $9 per order. This gives us a formula for billing costs of $30,000 per quarter plus $9 per order or: Y = $30,000 + $9X, where X is the number of orders. 21 This formula can now be used to predict billing costs associated with different levels of activity. If a manager wants to know the level of cost to expect when 3,000 orders are processed, the assumption can be plugged into the formula to derive an estimate of $57,000. The scatter plot method of estimating fixed and variable costs is seldom used in practice because of its imprecision. The more precise high-low and least-squares regression methods are more commonly used and are covered next. 22 The high-low method is based on the rise-over-run formula for the slope of a straight-line. As we saw a moment ago with the scatter plot method, if the relationship between cost and activity can be represented by a straight line, the slope of the line is equal to the variable cost per unit for the activity. The slope of the cost line is calculated by dividing the “rise” of the cost line, which represents the change in cost between two different levels of activity, by the “run” of the cost line, which represents the change in the activity level for the different levels of cost. The result of this calculation is the variable cost incurred for each unit of activity. The two data points used in the calculation are the points associated with the highest level of activity and the lowest level of activity in the data set. Once the variable cost component is determined, the fixed cost component can be derived. 23 As discussed a moment ago, the first step in applying the high-low method is to review the data set and identify the periods with the lowest and highest levels of activity. This information is used to calculate the slope of the cost line which represents the variable cost per unit of activity. The fixed cost component is identified by taking the total cost associated with either the high or low activity data point and subtracting the variable cost component. The variable cost component is calculated by multiplying the volume for the data point by the variable cost per unit, calculated in the previous step. 24 Once the variable and fixed cost elements are identified, total cost for the mixed cost activity can be expressed as Y = a + bX where “Y” equals the total mixed cost, “a” equals the fixed cost element, “b” equals the cost per unit of activity and “X” equals the assumed level of activity. Note that this is the same cost formula derived when using the scatter plot method and the regression analysis technique, which will cover in a few moments. What is important to understand is that while the format of the formula is the same for each of these methods, the fixed and variable cost elements will vary depending on which one is used to determine them. We started with the least precise approach, the scatter plot method, and are working our way to the most precise, regression analysis. 25 Now we will look at an example of the high-low method. The Kohlson Company incurred the following shipping costs over the past eight months. After scanning the data, we identify February as the month with the lowest activity level and July as the month with the highest level of activity. These two data points will be used to calculate the slope of the cost line. 26 Unlike the scatter plot method and regression analysis, the high low method only uses two data points to estimate the variable and fixed components of a mixed cost. Using the high and low activity data points from the previous slide, we calculate the change in units sold, which is the run of our cost line, and the change in shipping costs, which is the rise of our cost line. The variable cost per unit is now calculated by dividing the change in cost by the change in activity, rise over run. This yields a per unit cost of $5. Next, we calculate the fixed cost component of the mixed cost by subtracting the variable cost element from total cost. To do this, we can use either the high or low data point, as both will yield the same result. For this example, the high data point is used. We subtract 12,000 units times $5 per unit from the total cost of $100,000. This yields a fixed cost component of $40,000. Therefore, our formula for predicting shipping cost is $40,000 of fixed cost plus $5 times the number of units sold. This formula can now be used to predict shipping costs for expected levels of activity in the future. As an example, if the company expects to sell 8,500 units in a future period, they would anticipate incurring shipping costs of $82,500. 27 While easy to use, the high-low method suffers from two major defects. It throws out all but two data points when determining the fixed and variable components of a mixed cost. Compounding this issue is the tendency for periods with the highest and lowest levels of activity to be unusual and not entirely representative of the other data points. We can see this in the data used in this example, where all of the observations for shipping costs fall below the cost line derived using the high-low method except for the high and low activity data points. This often occurs because of inefficiency associated with low activity levels, such as employees not producing as many products in the related period compared to when the pace of production must be faster to meet demand in periods of higher activity. During high activity periods, unit costs are often higher due to the stress of meeting greater demand, such as when employees are paid overtime to work additional hours to increase production capacity. Basing the derivation of the cost formula on these two data points often results in a somewhat distorted assignment of fixed and variable cost components, which ultimately leads to less precision in predicting future costs. 28 Next we will look at regression analysis. Unlike the high-low method, it uses all available data points to separate a mixed cost into its fixed and variable components. The regression method computationally identifies a trend line that has the least deviation from the actual data points. Because of this, it is often referred to as the “line of best fit”. Performing regression analysis by hand can be a rather tedious process, however, software such as Excel makes it very easy to use this highly effective approach to determine the fixed and variable components of a mixed cost. 29 In this example, we have the output from using Excel’s regression analysis tool to evaluate the data we worked with a few moments ago in the high-low method example. While there is a lot of data provided in the report, we will only focus on three important elements of the results; the R-square, the intercept coefficient and the X variable coefficient. The R Square is referred to as the “goodness of fit” statistic. It tells us how well the regression line fits the data points. The R-square can range from zero to 1. A value of zero indicates that there is no relationship between the X and Y variables, while an R-square of 1 indicates that there is a perfect linear relationship between the variables with all of the data points falling on the regression line. Therefore, the closer the R-square is to 1, the stronger the relationship is between cost and volume. In our example, the R-square of 0.941656 indicates our regression line fits the data quite well and should provide a reliable means of predicting shipping costs for the Kohlson Company. The intercept coefficient is the Y axis intercept of the regression line and represents the fixed cost component of the mixed cost. Using regression analysis, the fixed cost component is estimated to be $38,902,compared to $40,000 using the high-low method. The X variable coefficient represents the regression line’s slope or the variable cost per unit of activity. Using regression analysis, the variable cost per unit was determined to be $4.69, compared to $5.00 per unit using the high-low method. The regression approach yields a shipping cost formula of $38,902 of fixed cost plus variable cost of $4.69 times the number 30 of sales orders. Using the formula to predict the shipping costs Kohlson Company would incur when sales are equal to 8,500 units, we derive $78,767. This compares to estimated shipping costs of $82,500 calculated using the formula derived with the high-low method. This is not to say that the regression analysis approach will save the company money. Instead, it is likely that the amount calculated with the regression analysis cost formula will prove to be a more accurate prediction of future shipping costs. 30 In your financial accounting course you learned how to construct and interpret a traditional income statement used for external reporting purposes. Managers often use a contribution margin income statement that clearly distinguishes between fixed and variable costs to better facilitate planning, control and decision making. This type of income statement is created for internal use and emphasizes a company’s contribution margin, which is the portion of sales revenue that contributes to covering fixed expenses and providing profits for the period. 31 Recall that a traditional income statement reports sales revenue from which cost of goods sold is subtracted to derive gross profit. Also recall that cost of goods sold includes fixed and variable costs. Operating expenses, which also include fixed and variable costs, are subtracted from gross profit to derive operating income. This format makes it virtually impossible to predict future levels of expenses and income when it is assumed that activity levels will differ from the current period’s. In a contribution margin income statement, variable expenses are subtracted from sales revenue to derive the contribution margin. It is from the contribution margin that the company covers its fixed expenses and hopefully has a profit left over. Having the income statement reported in this format allows managers to readily determine the affect an increase in sales volume will have on the company’s operating income. 32 To demonstrate, let’s assume that XYZ’s managers want to know by how much the company’s contribution margin and operating income will increase if sales volume increases by 20%. Sales revenue would increase 20% from $100,000 to $120,000. Variable expenses would increase by 20% as well from $63,000 to $75,600. The contribution margin would increase by 20% from $37,000 to $44,400. Fixed costs do not change as a result of changes in activity level and therefore remain at $21,000. Operating income increases from $16,000 to $23,400. This represents a 46% increase in operating income, which is significantly higher than the 20% increase in sales volume. This occurs because of the fixed costs present in XYZ’s cost structure. Because these costs do not increase when sales increase, it allows all of the increase in contribution margin to flow to operating income. This is referred to as operating leverage and will be discussed in more detail in a future lecture. 33 This concludes the Cost Behavior lecture. 34
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )