ECOR 3800B: Engineering Economics Week 9 – Replacement Decisions Based on Chapter 7, “Engineering Economics: Financial Decision Making for Engineers” (8th Ed.) by Fraser and Schmitt Cara Lozinsky, PhD, P.Eng. Assistant Professor November 10/12, 2025 1 Announcements • Assignment #3 (Depreciation, Taxes, Inflation) is due next Wednesday, Nov. 19, 11:59pm (late assignments will not be accepted) • Next class (Wednesday, Nov. 12) will start at 9:00am • CSES Referendum (Nov. 12 – 13) 2 Agenda • Reasons for replacement or retirement (§7.2) • Capital costs and other costs (§7.3) • Replacement Scenarios • Scenario 1: Defender and challenger are identical (§7.4) • Scenario 2: Challenger is different from defender; challenger repeats indefinitely (§7.5) • The irrelevance of sunk costs (§7.6) • When capital or operating costs are non-monotonic (§7.7) • Scenario 3: Challenger is different from defender; challenger does not repeat (§7.8) 4 Learning Objectives • Describe the difference between a challenger and a defender, and outline the principle of equivalent annual cost. • Understand what would cause an asset to be replaced or retired. • Recognize the difference between capital costs and installation costs, and between fixed costs and variable costs. • Determine the economic life of an asset when the defender and the challenger are the same. • Calculate whether to replace an asset when it can be assumed that the challenger will not change in the future. • Recognize that past costs do not matter when considering replacement today. • Know how to make replacement decisions when costs do not uniformly increase or decrease. • Know how to make replacement decisions when information about future challengers is available. 5 Introduction • When an asset is evaluated, there are one of four mutually exclusive choices to make: 1. Keep the asset in use without change (i.e., do nothing) 2. Overhaul the asset to improve its performance 3. Remove it from use without replacement 4. Replace the current asset with a new asset 6 Introduction • We discussed replacement decisions (in simple terms) in Weeks 4 and 5 (comparison methods) • In reality, replacement decisions are more complicated and are not always obvious 1. Service life needs to be calculated (we previously assumed a value) 2. Assumptions about how an asset may be replaced in the future can affect a current decision 7 Reasons for Replacement or Retirement • Replacement becomes necessary if there is a cheaper way to provide a service/complete a task (e.g., asset deterioration, technological improvements, insufficient system capacity) • Retirement occurs when an existing asset is removed from use without being replaced • Replacement/retirement decisions consider the equivalent annual cost (EAC) of the asset (goal = minimize EAC) 8 Reasons for Replacement or Retirement • When considering replacement or retirement decisions: • The existing physical asset is called the defender • The potential replacement is called the challenger • Scenarios that need to be considered for replacement decisions: 1. The defender and challenger are identical and the need for the asset repeats indefinitely 2. Challenger repeats indefinitely, but is different from the defender 3. Defender and challenger are different and do not repeat 9 Cash Flow Terminology for Replacement Decision Calculations • Types of cash flows: • Capital cost (the sum of the the initial purchase price, installation costs, and the salvage value) • Installation costs (the cost required to install the equipment; typically occurs at the beginning of the asset service life and is not reversable) • Operation and maintenance costs (O&M) (includes all costs associated with operating and maintaining the equipment, often reported on an annual basis) • Salvage cost (asset value at the end of its service life; dependent on depreciation) 10 Scenario 1: Defender and Challenger are Identical • The replacement decision is modelled as if the replacement takes place indefinitely (i.e., cyclic replacement) • From here, we determine the minimum-cost lifetime of the assets • Over time…. • Capital costs (initial purchase price + installation costs) decrease per period • Operation and maintenance costs (O&M) increase per period • These two sets of costs work in opposite directions • Lifetime that minimizes the EAC = economic life of the asset 11 Scenario 1: Defender and Challenger are Identical 12 Identical Defender and Challenger Example: The Jiffy Printer Company produces printers for home use. Jiffy is considering installing an automated plastic moulding system to produce parts for the printers. The moulder itself costs $200,000 and the installation costs are estimated to be $50,000. Operating and maintenance costs are expected to be $300,000 in the first year and rise at a rate of 5% per year. Jiffy estimates depreciation with a declining-balance model using a rate of 40%, and it uses an MARR of 15% for capital investments. Assuming there will be an ongoing need for the moulder and that the technology does not change (i.e., no cheaper or better method will arise), how long should Jiffy keep a moulder before replacing it with a new model? In other words, what is the economic life of the automated moulding system? 13 EAC for Purchase Price + Installation Replacement Period (years) Purchase Price + Installation) Annual Repair Costs ($300k*(1.05)n-1) 1 -$250,000 -$300,000 2 -$250,000 -$315,000 3 -$250,000 -$330,750 4 -$250,000 -$347,288 5 -$250,000 -$364,652 6 -$250,000 -$382,884 7 -$250,000 -$402,029 8 -$250,000 -$422,130 9 -$250,000 -$443,237 10 -$250,000 -$465,398 14 EAC for Repair Costs Salvage Value (S) ($200k*(1 - 0.4)n) EAC for Salvage EAC(total) EAC for 1-year economic life: 15 EAC for 3-year economic life: 17 EAC for 3-year economic life: 18 EAC for 5-year economic life: 19 EAC for 5-year economic life: 20 Replacement Period (years) Purchase Price + Installation EAC for Purchase Price + Installation Annual Repair Costs EAC for Repair Costs Salvage Value (S) EAC for Salvage EAC(total) 1 -$250,000.00 -$287,500 -$300,000 -$300,000 $120,000 $120,000 -$467,500 2 -$250,000.00 -$153,779 -$315,000 -$306,977 $72,000 $33,488 -$427,268 3 -$250,000.00 -$109,494 -$330,750 -$313,823 $43,200 $12,441 -$410,877 4 -$250,000.00 -$87,566 -$347,288 -$320,525 $25,920 $5,191 -$402,900 5 -$250,000.00 -$74,579 -$364,652 -$327,069 $15,552 $2,307 -$399,341 6 -$250,000.00 -$66,059 -$382,884 -$333,446 $9,331 $1,066 -$398,439 7 -$250,000.00 -$60,090 -$402,029 -$339,643 $5,599 $506 -$399,227 8 -$250,000.00 -$55,713 -$422,130 -$345,652 $3,359 $245 -$401,120 9 -$250,000.00 -$52,394 -$443,237 -$351,466 $2,016 $120 -$403,739 10 -$250,000.00 -$49,813 -$465,398 -$357,077 $1,209 $60 -$406,830 21 Scenario 2: Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Repeats Indefinitely) • Decision rule to minimize costs for Scenario 2 replacement decisions: 1. Determine the economic life of the challenger and its associated EAC 2. Determine the remaining economic life of the defender and its associated EAC • EAC(defender) > EAC(challenger) → replace now • EAC(defender) < EAC(challenger) → do not replace now 22 Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Repeats Indefinitely) Example: Coming back to the Jiffy Printing Company. Jiffy pays a custom moulder $2.50 per piece (excluding material costs) to produce parts for its printers. Demand is forecast to be 200,000 parts per year. Jiffy is considering installing the automated plastic moulding system described in the previous example to produce the parts. Should it do so now? Defender: existing technology (sub-contractor) Challenger: automated moulding machine 23 24 Scenario 2: Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Repeats Indefinitely) • For assets that have been in use for many years: • Annual capital costs will be low, compared to O&M costs • EAC(total) will increase with each period • Use the one-year principle: • When the above scenario exists and the annual operating costs are monotonically increasing (either stays the same or increases with increasing periods), the economic life of the defender is one year and its total EAC is the cost of using the defender for one more year 25 One-Year Principle Example: An asset is three years old. Yearly operating and maintenance costs are currently $5,000 per year, increasing by 10% per year. The salvage value for the asset is currently $60,000 and is expected to be $50,000 one year from now. Can the one-year principle be used? One-Year Principle Example: An asset is 10 years old. Yearly operating and maintenance costs are currently $5,000 per year, increasing by 10% per year. The salvage value of the asset is currently $8,000 and is expected to be $7,000 one year from now. Can the one-year principle be used? 26 The Irrelevance of Sunk Costs • Once an asset has been installed and has been operating for some time, the costs of installation (and all costs incurred up to that point) are no longer relevant to any replacement decision • These costs are called sunk costs • Only costs associated with keeping and operating the asset from this point forward are relevant 27 Sunk Costs Example: Two years have passed since the Jiffy Printer Company installed an automated moulding system to produce parts for its printers. At the time of installation, it expected to be producing about 200,000 pieces per year, which justified the investment. However, its actual production has turned out to be only about 150,000 pieces per year. Its unit cost is $2.656 rather than the $1.992 it had expected. It estimates the current market value of the moulder at $72,000. In this case, maintenance costs do not depend on the actual production rate. Should Jiffy sell the moulding system and go back to buying from the custom moulder at $2.50 per piece? Defender: automated moulding machine (to-date EAC = $2.656/unit, EAC(year 3) = ?) Challenger: returning to sub-contractor (EAC = $2.50) 28 Replacement Period (years) Purchase Price + Installation EAC for Purchase Price + Installation Annual Repair Costs EAC for Repair Costs Salvage Value (S) EAC for Salvage EAC(total) 1 -$250,000.00 -$287,500 -$300,000 -$300,000 $120,000 $120,000 -$467,500 2 -$250,000.00 -$153,779 -$315,000 -$306,977 $72,000 $33,488 -$427,268 3 -$250,000.00 -$109,494 -$330,750 -$313,823 $43,200 $12,441 -$410,877 29 30 Final Thoughts on Sunk Costs • Sunk costs can lead to inefficient choices • Example: • There is the mentality that an asset needs to be kept for a certain amount of time to “pay off” the capital costs • In reality, a viable challenger could arise at any time • Depending on the scenario, it may be better to abandon the defender early, in favour of a superior challenger (despite substantial sunk costs) 31 Non-Monotonic Capital or Operating Costs • Sometimes operating and/or capital costs do not increase smoothly (monotonically) over time • If costs are not monotonic, the one-year principle does not apply (there may be one-time or periodic costs that occur over the course of the next year) • These one-time or periodic costs might make the challenger economically superior to the defender 32 Non-Monotonic Cost Example: The Colossal Construction Company uses a generator to produce power at remote sites. The existing generator is now three years old. It cost $110,000 when purchased. Its current salvage value of $24,000 is expected to fall to $14,000 next year and to $9,800 the year after, and to continue declining at 30% of the current value per year. Its ordinary operating and maintenance costs are now $10,000 per year and are expected to rise by $5,000 per year. There is also a requirement to do an overhaul that will cost $10,000 this year and every third year thereafter. New fuel-efficient generators have been developed, and Colossal is thinking of replacing its existing generator. It is expected that the new generator technology will be the best available for the foreseeable future. The new generator sells for $95,000. Installation costs are negligible. Other data for the new generator are summarized in the table on the next slide. Assuming MARR = 12%, should Colossal replace the existing generator with the new type? 33 EAC(total) for the new generator: End of Year Purchase Price 0 Salvage Value Operating Costs EAC(total) $95,000 1 -$95,000 $80,000 -$10,000 -$36,400 2 -$95,000 $70,000 -$10,000 -$33,193 3 -$95,000 $60,000 -$12,000 -$32,365 4 -$95,000 $50,000 -$15,000 -$32,331 5 -$95,000 $40,000 -$20,000 -$32,908 6 -$95,000 $30,000 -$20,000 -$33,142 7 -$95,000 $20,000 -$20,000 -$33,187 8 -$95,000 $10,000 -$30,000 -$33,935 34 EAC(total) for the defender (existing generator) for one more year: 35 EAC(total) for defender, for multiple economic lives: End of Year Salvage Value Operating Costs EAC(total) 0 $24,000 1 $14,000 -$20,000 -$32,880 2 $9,800 -$15,000 -$27,220 3 $6,860 -$20,000 -$26,300 4 $4,802 -$35,000 -$28,723 5 $3,361 -$30,000 -$29,242 6 $2,353 -$35,000 -$30,125 36 Scenario 3: Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Does Not Repeat) • Assumptions: • Challengers are not the same • Future challengers will be available (and we expect them to be better than the current challenger) • Question: • Should the current challenger replace the defender? If so, when? 37 Scenario 3: Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Does Not Repeat) • Normally, we expect the future challengers to be better than the current challenger • Should we skip over the current challenger and wait for the next “new and improved” challenger? • Scenario 3 requires us to evaluate all possible combinations of replacement options • EAC for each combination must be calculated • The number of combinations increases very quickly • Typically, very little information is available on the costs and benefits of the challengers 38 An Illustrative Example - Challenger is Different from Defender (Challenger Does Not Repeat): the Burnaby Insulators Plant (BIP) is thinking of replacing the kiln controllers. BIP has knowledge of the existing controllers and of the best replacement on the market. BIP also has information about a new controller design that will be available in three years. BIP has a five-year time horizon for the problem. What replacement alternatives should they consider? **For this problem let’s assume there is one defender (the current kiln controller) and two challengers** 39 Decision Alternative Defender Life in Years First Challenger Life in Years Second Challenger Life in Years 1 5 0 0 2 4 1 0 3 4 0 1 4 3 2 0 5 3 1 1 6 3 0 2 7 2 3 0 8 2 2 1 9 2 1 2 10 1 4 0 11 1 3 1 12 1 2 2 13 0 5 0 14 0 4 1 15 0 3 2 Things to consider: • To fully evaluate this problem, we need to consider every permutation of the defender and challengers for a 5-year study period • This is a lot of alternatives to evaluate! • To choose the best alternative, we need accurate information about: 1. Capital costs for all three kiln controllers 2. Salvage values for all three kiln controllers, for all service lives considered 3. O&M costs for all possible ages for all three controllers • If we had all of this information, we could run a comparison using one of the comparison methods from Weeks 4 and 5 (PW, AW, IRR) to choose the best option • Again, this is a lot of work!! 40 Summary • Assets will need to be replaced and/or retired over the course of their life • We can use comparison methods (learned in Weeks 4 and 5) to evaluate replacement decisions • Replacement decisions consider capital costs (initial purchase and installation costs), O&M costs, and salvage costs • Comparison methods compare the existing asset (defender) against possible replacements (challengers) • In all cases, we want to minimize the equivalent annual cost (EAC) 41 Summary • Possible scenarios when evaluating replacement decisions: 1. The defender and challenger are identical and the need for the asset repeats indefinitely 2. Challenger repeats indefinitely, but is different from the defender 3. Defender and challenger are different and do not repeat 42
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )