19/4/26 Chapter 2 - Opportunity Identification and Selection Opportunity Identification and Selection: Strategic Planning for New Products 1 Figure 1.1: Opportunity Identification and Selection • Access the text alternative for slide images. 2 2 1 19/4/26 The Strategic Elements • Chapters 1 and 2 introduced the new products process. • This chapter presents both the product innovation charter (PIC) and the product portfolio management. • The PIC is a strategic plan for new products. • The portfolio is strategically important. 3 3 The “Company Within A Company” • This describes a new products team as they do everything a firm does – develop a budget, do financial analyses, assign tasks and responsibilities, and so on. • They need strategic direction on where they must and must not go. • Product innovation managers ask, “What sandbox should I be playing in?” – before beginning to think of specific products. 4 4 2 19/4/26 The PIC: Why Does a Firm Need a New Products Strategy? • To chart the new product team’s direction. • To set the team’s goals and objectives. • To provide some guiding principles. 5 5 Corporate Strengths Provide Direction for the Team • • • • • • • • • • • New products in this firm will: Use our fine furniture designers (Herman Miller). Utilize innovative design in every product (Braun). Gain value by being bottled in our bottling system (Coca-Cola). Be for babies and only babies (Gerber). Be for all sports and not just shoes (Nike). Be for all people in computers, not just techie types (IBM). Meet the needs of Ford engineers (Budd). Offer genuine value (Lexus). Use only internal R&D (Bausch & Lomb). Offer more protection with less material (Sealed Air). • Note that some of these involve technologies, some markets, and some company guidelines. 6 6 3 19/4/26 Product Platform Planning 1 • Many firms find that it is not efficient to develop a single product. • Platform: Product families that share similarities in design, development, or production process. • Car industry: Cost on a new car platform is spread out over several models (example: Chrysler, Dodge, and Jeep). • Google, Amazon, and Apple expanded from an early product to a full platform of products. • P&G: Liquid Ariel for European market, Liquid Tide for the United States, and Liquid Cheer for Japanese market. • Honda’s World Car Platform is used to make Accords for the North American, European, and Japanese markets, all different according to market preferences. 7 7 Product Platform Planning 2 • Platforms are a possibility in service industries and for manufactured goods. • Brand platforms can be strategically important and are widely used. • Brands can serve as the launching pad for scores of products, all having in common the brand and any strategies applying to that brand. • Brand equity: Value of an established brand. • Category platforms can be organized based on either product types or customer segments. • Any strategic change in one of those areas influences all new products developed under that umbrella. 8 8 4 19/4/26 Jobs-To-Be-Done • Creates customer value by focusing on what the customer wants to accomplish by using the product or service. • Example: Process steps applied to the job of “listening to music.” • Define: Decide to listen to desired music. • Locate: Find the desired music. • Prepare: Get the music into a desired play order (create playlist). • Confirm: Ensure the music is in the correct order and ready to play. • Execute: Enjoy music. • Monitor: Make changes during the experience (skip or add songs). • Modify: Make changes in music selections and playlist for future. • Conclude: Assess the overall listening experience. 9 9 Noncorporate Strategic Planning and Miscellaneous Sources • Strategic planning also originates from marketing, technical, manufacturing, and finance functions, as well as from suppliers, customers, and others. • These groups often have the power to influence new product development. • Some inputs can start at the lower activity level and influence corporate strategy upward. • A successful new product can be so impactful that it reshapes corporate strategy. • Incremental changes in business practices can subtly and gradually influence new product strategies. 10 10 5 19/4/26 What is the Product Innovation Charter (PIC)? • Typically, it is a document prepared by senior management designed to provide guidance to the business units on the role of innovation. • It is for products, not processes. • It is for innovation. • It is a charter (a document specifying the conditions under which a firm will operate). 11 11 Do Many Firms Have a PIC? • Most do, according to research, even if they do not call it by that name. • PDMA study: • About three-fourths of firms have a formal new product policy of some type (a partial PIC). • 29% have a formal, written PIC. • 86% of the “Best” firms had a PIC and only 69% of the “Rest.” • 80% of firms have formalized at least a few of the phases in the new products process. • According to an independent study: • The more detailed and specific the PIC, the higher the firm’s innovation rates. • The more specific the corporate mission and senior management direction is spelled out in the PIC, the better the performance of the firm’s new products. 12 12 6 19/4/26 Figure 3.4: The Product Innovation Charter • Background Key ideas from the situation analysis; special forces such as managerial dicta; reasons for preparing a new PIC at this time. • • At least one clear technology dimension and one clear market dimension. They match and have good potential. • • • Focus Goals and Objectives What the project will accomplish, either short-term as objectives or longer-term as goals. Evaluation measurements. • • Guidelines Any "rules of the road," requirements imposed by the situation or by upper management. Innovativeness, order of market entry, time/quality/cost, miscellaneous. 13 13 An Illustrative PIC for Orosound 1 • Background: There is an opportunity in the marketplace due to noise pollution that constantly surrounds us. Companies are especially concerned about the health and well-being of their employees and reduction of ambient noise can lead to higher workplace satisfaction. While there are competitive headphones, there is none that offers all of the benefits that the Tilde provides. • Focus: Orosound has technology and R&D strength and owns several patents in acoustics that led to the development of the Tilde. On the marketing side, the Tilde satisfies an unmet need in the workplace – for effective, yet controllable and selective, sound filtering which improves the well-being of workers. Given the growth of workplace collaboration, the ability to filter out ambient noise and still carry on a conversation is a definite plus. 14 14 7 19/4/26 An Illustrative PIC for Orosound 2 • Goals and objectives: Due to intense interest in France and Japan, Orosound targeted those two countries at first, allowing for an assessment of marketplace acceptance and some accurate sales forecasting for future global targets. The individual consumer market is a secondary target for the moment. • Guidelines: Orosound wants to take advantage of the growth in workplace collaboration, for which the Tilde is ideally suited. The product should make the workplace a more productive and happier place. The Tilde should be an 15 indispensable part of any workplace environment. 15 Purposes of PIC • Focus and integrate team effort. • Permit delegation. • Establish the size and range of the “sandbox.” 16 16 8 19/4/26 Risks of Poor PIC Development • Scope creep: Product definition keeps changing. • Who is the customer? Is it a standalone product or a platform? • Unstable product specifications: Required performance level keeps changing. • Both of these risks are elusive targets (“moving goalposts”) that occur because the sandbox was never defined, or vaguely defined. 17 17 PIC Steps: Background, Focus, and Goals • Background: “Why did we develop this strategy?” • Focus, or area: Technology and market drivers that fit and have good potential. • Goals and objectives: Profit, growth, and market status. 18 18 9 19/4/26 Dual-Drive Strategy: Technology and Market • Relying solely on technology is risky. • Letting customers’ stated needs drive product innovation rarely works well. • The best solution is a balanced or dual-drive strategy. • Hewlett-Packard requires a strong market commitment behind every new product program. • Frito-Lay, P&G have major research facilities to address market needs. • T-P-M Linkage: Converting technical specifications to product features and market needs. 19 19 PIC Steps: Special Guidelines • Degree of innovativeness: • First-to-market. • Adaptive product. • Imitation (emulation). • Miscellaneous: • Following fast-follower strategy. • Recognition of weaknesses. • Patentability. • Product integrity. 20 20 10 19/4/26 PIC Development Process • Identifying opportunities inside the firm or outside it. • Evaluating, rating, and ranking the opportunities. • Filling out the PIC form—focus, goals, and guidelines. 21 21 Product Portfolio: The New Product’s Strategic Fit • Strategic goals (defending current base of products versus extending the base). • Project types (balancing fundamental research, process improvements, or maintenance projects). • Short-term versus long-term projects. • High-risk versus low-risk projects. • Market familiarity (existing markets, extensions of current ones, or totally new ones). • Technology familiarity (existing platforms, 22 extensions of current ones, or totally new ones). • Geographical markets (balancing sales or profits in North America, Europe, and Asia). 22 11 19/4/26 Objectives of Product Portfolio Development • Strategic alignment: Mix of products reflects the PIC; new products are “on strategy.” • Assessing portfolio value: Commercial value of products in pipeline is maximized. • Project balance: Select products that balance the existing product line. • Number of projects: In line with resource requirements; avoid underfunding. 23 23 Portfolio Management: How To Assess a Proposed Project • Strategic fit: Does it fit with the technology and/or market focus of the PIC? • Strategic contribution: Does it help achieve any of the strategic criteria (extends base of products, enters into new markets, or develops a new technology platform)? • Strategic priorities: Does it live up to the guidelines of the PIC (does it fit with technological leader or fast follower)? 24 24 12 19/4/26 Figure 3.7: Strategic Portfolio Model for One SBU in Exxon Chemical Low Market Newness High Market Newness Improvements to Existing Products (35%) Additions to Existing Product Lines (20%) Medium Product Newness Cost Reductions (20%) New Product Lines (15%) High Product Newness Repositioning (6%) New-to-the-World Products (4%) Low Product Newness • Source: Adapted from Robert G. Cooper, Scott J. Edgett, and Elko J. Kleinschmidt, Portfolio Management for New Products, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, 1997, p. 63. 25 25 Figure 3.8: A Sample Bubble Diagram • Source: Adapted from a real bubble diagram used by a division of Hewlett-Packard, as reported in Randall L. Englund and Robert J. Graham, “From Experience: Linking Projects to Strategy,” Journal of Product Innovation Management 16, no. 1,January 1999, pp. 52–64. • Access the text alternative for slide images. 26 26 13 19/4/26 Figure 3.9: Strategic Decision Group Portfolio Evaluation Model • Source: Robert G. Cooper, Winning at New Products: Accelerating the Process from Idea to Launch, second edition. Reading, M A: Addison-Wesley, 1993, p. 185. • Access the text alternative for slide images. 27 27 Figure 3.10: Portfolio of Product Types DISRUPTIVE INNOVATION (New-to-world or new-to-firm) TECHNOLOGY UPGRADE (Next-generation) PRODUCT LINE EXTENSION (Additions to product line) INCREMENTAL INNOVATION (Improvements to existing products) Number of Projects 10% 12% 32% 46% Resource Allocation 18% 22% 25% 35% Incremental Sales 22% 40% 15% 23% • Source: Adapted from Scott Edgett, “Portfolio Management for Product Innovation,” in K. B. Kahn, S. E. Kay, R. J. Slotegraaf, and S. Uban (Eds.), The PDMA Handbook of New Product Development (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley, 2013), Chapter 9, p. 162. 28 28 14 19/4/26 Chapter 3 Summary • Product platform planning. • Opportunity identification. • The Product Innovation Charter (PIC). • Dual-drive strategy. • Product portfolio analysis. 29 29 15
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )