SMSDTWC
1
Social Media Self-Discrepancy Theory with Comparison and the Effect it has on the Self
Daniel Yedrysek
Florida International University
SMSDTWC
2
Methods Study Two
Participants
In this study, there were 240 participants selected online by Qualtrics. Participants ranged
in age from 18 to 63 years (M = 27.60, SD = 10.58). The sample included 111 men (46.2%) and
129 women (53.8%). With race and ethnicity, this sample included White (n= 49), Latino/a (n=
154), Indigenous (n= 1), Black (n= 21), Asian (n= 4), Middle East and North African (MENA)
(n= 4), and Others (n= 7). See Table 5 for the full demographic summary.
Table 5
SMSDTWC
3
Materials and Procedure
After providing informed consent via Qualtrics, participants completed a survey given to
them online, also through Qualtrics. They were then randomly assigned to one of four
conditions, with one variable removed from study one and two being added. The one removed
from study one was the Opposite Self profile condition. The first independent variable was
which profile they created for the social media self-discrepancy theory (SMSDT). The two main
IVs participants were placed in were an Actual Self profile and an Ideal Self profile. With the
Actual Self condition, participants created a profile intended to reflect who they believed they
truly were. This would be how the participants personally saw themselves. With the Ideal Self
condition, participants created a profile intended to reflect an idealized version of themselves.
This would what they saw or felt was the best possible version of themselves. The second
independent variable was the two that were added, social comparison, which included an
Upward Comparison profile and a Downward Comparison profile. To manage this manipulation,
the researchers varied the way Jordan Avery’s profile was presented so that Jordan appeared
either more successful than the average person or less successful than the average person. More
successful would be considered having more money, taking trips, physical prowess, etc. Less
successful would be considered being poor or jobless, homeless or in below average living
conditions, etc.
In study two, the participants were randomly placed into one of four conditions, these
were Actual Self with Upward Comparison, Actual Self with Downward Comparison, Ideal Self
with Upward Comparison, and Ideal Self with Downward Comparison. After completing the first
part, profile creation task, participants took a survey online to measure our dependent variables
on a 6-point scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 6 (agree). Here we will focus primarily
SMSDTWC
4
on two dependent variables, these were, level of agreement with the statements “I feel more
negative about myself after creating the profile” and “I would feel comfortable sharing this
profile publicly.”
Participants also completed a manipulation check for the social comparison variable by
indicating whether Jordan Avery seemed more successful than the average person or less
successful than the average person. Finally, participants reported their demographic information,
such as age, gender, and race, and they were then debriefed after completing the survey.
Results
A chi-square test examined whether participants correctly identified the social
comparison manipulation. The manipulation check was significant, χ²(1, N = 240) = 109.62, p <
.001. Most participants that were given the Upward Comparison condition identified Jordan
Avery as more successful than the average person (n = 104, 86.7%), whereas most participants
that were given the Downward Comparison condition identified Jordan Avery as less successful
than the average person (n = 98, 81.7%). These findings aligned with the projected hypothesis
and showed that the social comparison manipulation worked as intended. See Table 6 for the
findings.
Table 6
SMSDTWC
5
We used a 2 × 2 factorial ANOVA to examine the effects that SMSDT (Actual Self vs.
Ideal Self) and social comparison (Upward vs. Downward) had on agreeing with the statement “I
SMSDTWC
6
feel more negative about myself after creating the profile.” There was a significant result for
SMSDT, F(1, 236) = 7.31, p = .007. Participants in the Ideal Self condition (M = 2.37, SD =
1.59) reported feeling more negative than participants in the Actual Self condition (M = 1.93, SD
= 1.26). There was no significant result for social comparison, F(1, 236) = 2.71, p = .101, and the
SMSDT × Social Comparison interaction was not significant either, F(1, 236) = 2.25, p = .135.
See Table 7 for more information.
Table 7
SMSDTWC
7
Next, we ran a second 2 × 2 factorial ANOVA that examined the effects of SMSDT and
social comparison on the agreement with “I would feel comfortable sharing this profile
publicly.” There was a significant result for SMSDT, F(1, 236) = 49.82, p < .001. Participants in
the Actual Self condition (M = 5.06, SD = 1.23) reported having a greater willingness to share
the profile they created more than participants in the Ideal Self condition (M = 4.05, SD = 1.79).
There were no significant results for social comparison, F(1, 236) = 0.09, p = .763. However,
these manipulations were significant with the SMSDT × Social Comparison interaction, F(1,
236) = 19.57, p < .001. Within the Actual Self condition, the willingness to share did not differ
much between Upward Comparison (M = 5.10, SD = 1.24) and Downward Comparison (M =
5.02, SD = 1.24), F(1, 118) = 0.12, p = .725. However, within the Ideal Self condition,
participants with the Downward Comparison condition (M = 4.81, SD = 1.60) reported greater
willingness to share their profile than with participants in the Upward Comparison condition (M
= 3.24, SD = 1.64), F(1, 118) = 28.09, p < .001. Within the Upward Comparison condition,
participants in the Actual Self condition (M = 5.10, SD = 1.24) reported greater willingness to
share their profile than with participants in the Ideal Self condition (M = 3.24, SD = 1.64), F(1,
118) = 49.48, p < .001. Within the Downward Comparison condition, willingness to share did
not differ much between the Actual Self condition (M = 5.02, SD = 1.24) and the Ideal Self
condition (M = 4.81, SD = 1.60), F(1, 118) = 0.65, p = .423. Overall, the participants were least
comfortable sharing the profile when they created an idealized profile while also making an
upward comparison. See Table 8.
Table 8
SMSDTWC
8
SMSDTWC
9
Discussion Study Two
It was hypothesized that creating an Ideal self profile and comparing the self to a more
successful individual would produce more negative reactions than creating an Actual self profile
or making a downward comparison. The results partially supported these expectations.
Participants in the Ideal Self condition reported feeling more negative about themselves
after creating the profile than participants in the Actual Self condition, suggesting that an
idealized version of self profiles may have been more emotionally negative or may have felt less
consistent with their everyday self.
The strongest effect was visible with the willingness to share the profile publicly after the
downward comparison. The participants were especially reluctant to share their profile when
they created an idealized profile with the Upward Comparison condition. Whereas their
willingness to share stayed high across both Actual self conditions and remained relatively high
in the Ideal self condition when the comparison profile was less successful.
SMSDTWC
10
One possible explanation could be that with the upward comparison, the idealized profile
felt harder to own or defend. On the other side, the Actual self profiles may have felt more
authentic and therefore easier to share regardless of the comparison condition. Future studies
could test whether these effects are driven by authenticity concerns, self-evaluation, discomfort,
or pressure to present the self in a socially desirable way. No study is perfect and there may be
gaps in our perspective of the gathered data, but further studies will have to be done to find the
full effect that SMSDT has on the self.