LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY CHAPTER 5 5.1 – PUBLIC TRANSPORT ISSUES AND PROBLEMS Public Transport Issues/Problems The poor state of the city’s urban transport system ranked third in the infrastructural sectoral issues as reflected in the City Development Plan 2020-2022. Public transport issues/problems hound the development of a proper urban transport system that is aligned to the city’s development aspirations and frameworks. These may be categorized into Policies and Plans, Infrastructure Facilities, and Transport Services. Policies and Plans The Road Network Master Plan for the city is already outdated. In updating the Master Plan, it should be aligned with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan (CLUP), Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP), and the Local Public Transport Route Plan (LPTRP). The Master Plan will then serve as guide in identifying, prioritizing, design, budgeting, and decision making among policy makers. Interventions in the form of bypass roads and urban roads improvement projects- road widening and construction of interchanges at crucial intersections can improve traffic flow in urban areas and mitigate the negative effects brought about by traffic congestion. Absence of a Comprehensive Urban Traffic Management System. Traffic congestion within the urban city streets especially during peak hours is highly increasing. This is caused by the increased volume of vehicles, narrow roads in the old district area and limited alternate routes. The upgrading of traffic signaling system is necessary to improve traffic flow and safety for both motorists and pedestrian. New intersections should be identified and established to decongest heavy traffic corridors. Moreover, interventions using new technology can help in the traffic impact analysis, which in turn can help decision makers in solving traffic issues. A traffic control center should be established as soon as possible to manage the city’s traffic system. Local Public Transportation Route Plan (LPTRP) is not yet institutionalized. The LPTRP will rationalize existing public transportation routes and develop new routes aligned with the city’s development plan. Once approved, the city ordinances pertaining to traffic routes will now be updated to suit the needs of the riding public. Moreover, in compliance with the PUV Modernization Program, re-fleeting of dilapidated and environmentally unsustainable public utility vehicles (PUV) will be possible once the LPTRP is approved and implemented and will afford the public with reliable, environment-friendly safe, secure and efficient public transportation. Lax implementation of DILG Road Clearing Policies. Highways and other road networks are often used as parking for trucks, cars and other vehicles that has led to limited use of these roads for transportation and may even lead to accidents. Some of these major road networks are being used for drying of palay and corn, and vending. Road clearing should be regularly undertaken to reduce congestion and accidents. Page 179 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY Over release of tricycle franchises. Since there has been no study in the past pertaining to actual demand for tricycles and route planning, this has led to the over release of franchises, especially the Orange tricycles. The Tricycle Route Plan (TRP), which will be formulated after the LTPRP will endeavor to correct this. Tricycles should act as feeders to public utility vehicles following the hierarchy of road functions and not overlap with the operations of PUVs. Infrastructure Facilities A considerable length of road networks remains unpaved. From the total road length of 584.3 kilometers, around 326.7 kilometers or 56% of roads are unpaved. Of the total unpaved roads, 95% or 311 kilometers are barangay roads. This situation affects people’s mobility and movement of goods. Road Right of Way Problems. Road-Right-of Way issues contribute to the nonimplementation as well as the non-completion of different infrastructure projects. Houses and other establishments in Butuan City are still within the construction limit. There is also an experience of delay in compensation on the affected property. Incomplete submission of require documents will cause the delay of payments for all claimants and unacceptable assessment value of property. Lack of Integrated Terminal Exchange (ITX). Currently there is one bus terminal, a sub-terminal for buses and UVE vans, a PUJ terminal, and a UVE terminal that is being used by tricycles. The bus, jeepney, and UVE terminals are located in Langihan District, where the markets are and in itself a congested area, which became much worse because of the presence of these terminals. There is a need to build an ITX, which is an integrated and multi-modal terminal, that should be located in an area outside of the downtown area, or anywhere else that it is not already congested as it would only lead to more problems. This ITX should be state-of-the-art, with computerized ticketing/booking system, dispatch system that results to reliable and efficient travel, and other amenities. The ITX will serve as a hub for various public transport such as PUBs, UVE, and PUJs and Taxis that can take passengers to the city proper. It is where people can seamlessly transfer from one denomination to another within the same facility for security and convenience. The ITX will help ease traffic congestion in the city proper as these inter-provincial and inter-regional transport unit will no longer enter it. No properly-designated loading/unloading areas and signages. One of the major contributors to traffic congestion in the city is the indiscriminate loading/unloading of passengers wherever and whenever the driver or passenger wants. The LPTRP seeks to address this by identifying designated loading/unloading areas based on actual study. Preferably, and based on the criteria in the LPTRP Manual, loading/unloading areas must at least 50 meters away from any intersection, and preferably an off-street lay-by area at the side of the road similar to SM and Robinsons. Lack of Parking Spaces for establishments especially in the Poblacion Area. Another contributor to traffic congestion is the lack of parking spaces leading to Page 180 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY indiscriminate parking that constricts the already narrow streets in the Poblacion area. Although there is an ordinance prohibiting parking in these streets and to some extent allow parallel parking only in one lane, the lack of infrastructures has led to rampant violations of the ordinance. It is highly suggested that a multi-level parking be built in the downtown area, which could be through a PPP mode. Further, legislation should be in place requiring would-be constructed establishments to have ample provision for parking. No off-street terminals at various route end points. Inrta City PUJs are operating on a loop without a designated end-point, which is a very unreliable and antiquated manner to operate PUVs since there is no proper fleet management. The LPTRP will be addressing this problem. However, infrastructures should also support this through off-street terminals, like in Barangays Dumalagan, Ampayon, Sto.Niño, De Oro, Tungao, and Maguinda. Off-street terminals will ensure the safety of passengers and the reliability of public services. This will ensure that drivers will ferry the passenger to the end point instead of cutting their trips. Defective traffic lights and lack of traffic lights in other high traffic corridors. Traffic lights are very important in ensuring smooth traffic flow and reduce incidents of car crashes and collisions especially in intersections. No bike lanes. Active transport should be encouraged in the city. Not only does it promote healthy lifestyle, but it can also help decongesting the city thoroughfares by encouraging workers and students to use bikes to and from their destinations. To support this endeavour, bike lanes must be integrated into city thoroughfares to keep cyclists safe from accidents. Transport Services Trip cutting by Intracity PUJs. Various endpoints are unserved by intracity PUJs due to trip cutting. This is prevalent in Dumalagan, Sto. Niño, and De Oro. R1, R2, R4, and R10 are supposed to ferry passengers up to Dumalagan. However, PUJ drivers tend to cut their trip up to Libertad or Bancasi only, leaving residents in Dumalagan with no choice but to patronize habal-habal which is not a legal public conveyance or tricycles, which are not supposed to traverse in the national highway. On the other hand, R8 PUJs are supposed to go all the way to Sto. Niño, and De Oro for R7 PUJs, but drivers usually cut their trip up to Ampayon only. The LTFRB and the LTTMO must work hand in hand in ensuring that violators are apprehended and penalized. No service plan and fleet management plan. Intra city PUJs are operating on a loop system, without definite origin and end point. This results to a very inefficient system, wherein drivers just operate whenever they want to and where they want. With a service plan and fleet management plan, reliability of public transportation service is ensured, so that there is always available service from the time passengers usually take a ride towards work, school, and other destinations, up to night time when workers and students usually go home. Old and dilapidated PUVs. Majority of intra city PUJs are using surplus jeepneys which are environmentally unsustainable, and unsafe. Part of the component of the Page 181 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY PUV Modernization Program is fleet substitution from traditional jeepneys to modern PUJs that have bodies that are wider, and have more comfortable interiors, and which have safety and security equipment, with cashless system. Local legislation may be passed to support this endeavor so that a precondition for the issuance of mayor’s or business permit is a fleet modernization plan. Lax implementation of tricycle ban on highways. Under DILG Memorandum Circular No. 2020-036, tricycles are not allowed to operate on national highways used by 4-wheel vehicles greater than 4 tons and where normal speed exceeds 40 kph. This is a very prudent guideline from the DILG to ensure less accidents in the highways. Tricycles are slow moving vehicles and oftentimes occupy fast lanes, which have resulted to accidents. Moreover, based on feedback from PUJ operators, one major reason that they are hesitant to invest in modern units is the presence of tricycles competing in their operations. The LTTMO must be firm in enforcing this ban. However, a long-term solution is the Tricycle Route Plan (TRP) that would, among others, identify the various zones that tricycles can operate in, as feeder to the PUV routes. Other issues/problems. Some of the other issues/problems identified are arrogant behavior of drivers, conductors, and dispatchers, lack of public transport vehicles and long waiting time, overcharging of fares, lack of discipline of drivers, traffic code not properly implemented, commuters and drivers are not aware of city traffic ordinances, and decrease in transportation cost due to the presence of dispatchers and canvassers. 5.2 Development Constraints The city’s development is being hampered by various constraints, which are identified below: Terrain conditions and Unpaved Roads. As mentioned above, from the total road length of 584.3 kilometers, around 326.7 kilometers or 56% of roads are still unpaved, 95% of which are in barangay roads. 306.3 kilometers of barangay roads are graveled and 4.8 kilometers are still earth surfaces. Unpaved roads limit development in the area since it would also affect public transportation and movement of goods. Paved roads attract more residential, commercial, and industrial relocators because of the ease in transportation. Limited connectivity of rural barangays. Far-flung barangays have limited connectivity to the downtown area where most of government transactions and commercial establishments are located. Development routes under the LPTRP will ensure the mobility and access to services in these areas. Rapid urbanization. As earlier discussed, the city’s level of urbanization is at 69% as of 2020, or 256,045 of its total population lived in areas classified as urban areas. Moreover, five additional barangays will most likely to be classified as urban barangays by 2025 and will likely push the urban population to 311,219, and increase the city’s level of urbanization to more than 75%. Page 182 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY Population growth is now spilling over into what was used to be classified as rural areas of the city outing pressure on the city’s services and utilities, and a swelling of informal settlers and doubled up housings or dwellings shared by two or more families. However, with the implementation of the city’s development plans and the identification of development areas and special development areas, this will generate job opportunities even in rural areas so that development will be spread out and those living in rural areas don’t need to live in urban barangays as they seek employment there. Limited access to water supply and sanitation. There is limited access of households to potable water. Based on BCWD data, only 59 out of the 86 barangays are served, and out of this 71% are served with potable water. However, of the 71%, only 86.48% are served with Level III quality of water. There is also no centralized wastewater collection, treatment and disposal, and there is no existing sewerage and septage treatment facilities in the city. Water infrastructures are also vulnerable to various hazards such as soil erosion, earthquake-induced landslides, rain-induced landslides, and flooding. Climate and Disaster Risks. Based on the city’s CLUP, various hazards were identified such as flooding, rain-induced landslides, storm surges, ground rupture, and earthquake- induced landslides. Butuan City experience flooding especially in the low-lying barangays and near the Agusan River, which sometimes swells and overflows. Of the 86 barangays, 71 are identified as highly vulnerable to flooding. Moreover, 12,895 hectares of land, 44,673 people, 25 barangay centers, 24 bridges, 1 cell site, 64 health facilities, 130 schools, 56 water infrastructures, and 25,258.48 kms of roads are highly vulnerable to floods. Another problem is the presence of residential houses and buildings on riverbanks and easements. For other types of hazards, 27 barangays were identified to be highly susceptible to rain-induced landslides, 10 barangays are highly vulnerable to storm surges, 11 barangays along the fault line for ground rupture, and 5 barangays in active fault lines are highly at risk to earthquake-induced landslides. Lack or limited TelCo/ISP interconnections and unstable broadband connectivity. There is poor, limited, intermitted signal in some remote areas. Particularly, there are 17 barangays identified with poor signal. Poor Solid Waste Management. There is limited waste collection coverage, handling and processing, and inadequate waste disposal facilities. There is lack of solid waste management technologies in the city. Moreover, there is limited coverage of waste collection because only 50 of the 86 barangays are covered. Waste minimization strategies are not also fully implemented and the MRFs are not functional. Additionally, 32.69% of the households in the city do not have water sealed sewer with exclusive septic tank. Page 183 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY CHAPTER 6 6.1 – PUBLIC TRANSPORT DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES AND STRATEGIES Socio-Economic Development Goals Butuan City’s overall development framework is anchored on the nation’s Ambisyon Natin 2040, and Caraga Region’s vision of FAmE. Under its CLUP for 2019-2048, the following vision and mission statements are stated: VISION STATEMENT: “a great hub city of opportunities for all that spurs and supports Caraga’s sustainable growth and development” MISSION STATEMENT: “Butuan City will strive to achieve a vibrant, smart eco-city that is sustainable, livable, resilient and competitive” In support of these, the city intends to push for Sustainable Growth and Development, and Resiliency. It also developed a spatial development strategy that seeks to decentralize growth and development nodes with specialized roles outside of the Poblacion area. On the other hand, under the city’s Comprehensive Development Plan(CDC), its sectoral goals were identified as follows: To become a secure, empowered, and culture-oriented citizenry as well as achieve disaster-resilient, climate change adaptive, inclusive, and sustainable social development. To improve the economic wellbeing and quality of life of Butuanons, promote a robust industry and tourism, develop a sustainable agri-fishery sector, and foster an ascending, competitive and inclusive local economy. To have climate-adaptive, innovative, and safe infrastructure. To ensure a sustainable (green), clever (smart) and resilient environment To have an inclusive, efficient, effective, transparent, accountable, and gender responsive governance. Page 184 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY Figure 59. Butuan City’s Strategic Framework 6.2 Transport Development Plan A sound Public Transport Plan is needed as it lowers the costs of moving people and goods, which in turn increases economic productivity, which would consequently lead to a higher standard of living. An efficient transport system allows easier movement of workers from households to their workplace, especially in the development areas already identified, and access to public services and commercial establishments where they get their foods and other essential needs. Improving public transportation is key to development as it is essential to economic growth and good quality of life. This is why if we look at the National Spatial Strategy (NSS) for 2015-2045, one of the key principles of spatial development that was identified was the integration of leading and lagging areas and urban-rural linkages through transportation. This clearly underscores the role of transportation in national development. The NSS provides the geographic development challenges and opportunities in population and economic growth. The NSS has identified Butuan City as one of the major growth centers, and the main regional center that serves as the major trading, processing, commercial and Page 185 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY service center of the region, as well as, the show window of history and culture in Mindanao, to achieve Caraga Region’s goal to become the Fishery, Agro-Forestry, Mineral and Ecotourism (FAmE) Center of the country. In support of the city’s goals, the Master Plan for Sustainable Urban Infrastructure Development (MPSUID) was commissioned by the National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) in 2019. Sustainable infrastructure will ensure access to economic and social services and opportunities through various projects that incorporate environmentally-friendly structures and systems. This include transportation systems as a sub-sector, in which it was emphasized that “Transportation development should promote efficient access to economic and social services through seamless connectivity between different modes of transportation, which are convenient, reliable and safe.” One of the six foundational projects of the city under the MPSUID is an Integrated Transport System. According to the NEDA Master Plan, “Foundational projects are generally those that are essential to the enhanced operation of the city and the achievement of its vision. These have far-reaching impact, implemented over the long-term and consist of multiple sub-projects and components. It covers transport and utilities as well as economic zone development which is seen as an important economic driver in the future. The foundational projects will solidify Butuan City’s role as Caraga Region’s center of business, commerce, and industry. Butuan City will support the Caraga Region’s goal to become the FAmE Center of the Philippines.” In line with the above and based on the public transport issues/problems identified in the preceding chapter, the city government shall adopt the following Transport Development Plan to be implemented within the period from 2022 to 2025: Table 86. Proposed Transport Development Plan PROBLEMS/ISSUES GOALS Outdated Road Network Well-planned road Master Plan network for seamless mobility of people and goods PLANS/PROGRAMS - Revision of Road Network Master Plan - Updating of Local Tourism Master Plan Absence of Lessen travel time Comprehensive Urban resulting to seamless Traffic Management Plan mobility of people and goods - Formulation of SMART Traffic Management Plan - Revision of Transport and Traffic Code of Butuan City Unpaved Roads, and poor Improved mobility conditions of road and people and goods bridges - Roads and Bridges Construction Program - Roads and Bridges Improvement Program - Roads and Bridges Maintenance Program of Page 186 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY - Tourism Road Infrastructure Program (TRIP) Insufficient infrastructures facilities transport Safe, secure, reliable, and and seamless mobility for people and goods Environmentally unstainable, poorlymaintained, unsafe, not secure. And limited supply of public utility vehicles - Establishment of ITX, and off-street subterminals at end points such as in Barangays Dumalagan, Sto. Nino, De Oro, Tungao, and Florida - City-wide Traffic Lights and CCTV Installation Program connected to the City Central Command Center - Passenger Loading and Unloading Facilities Construction Program Adequate, safe, reliable, efficient, and environmentfriendly public transportation for seamless mobility of people and goods - Adoption of Fleet Modernization Program of the DOTr and LTFRB - Imposition of Mandatory on-board Safety and Security, such as GPS, Dashcam and CCTV, which should be linked to the City’s Command Center - Adoption of the DOTrLTFRB Policy on Automated Fare Collection System (AFCS) in all PUVs for cashless fare transactions. Proliferation of tricycles Safe, Secure, Reliable, (including Bajaj) in primary and Environment-Friendly and secondary highways Public Transportation - Tricycle Route Plan, which shall establish alternate roads for tricycle operations considering the hierarchy of road Page 187 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY functions, and consistent with the Tricycle Modernization Program - Strict implementation of DILG MC No. 2020035 on the tricycle ban on highways through regular enforcement activities Poor and unsafe first and Safe and Secure First and last mile access for Last Mile Access for commuters improved people mobility; Walkable/Bikeable communities; Improved Air Quality and Reduced Carbon Footprint 6.3 - Active Transportation Road Infrastructure and Promotion Program Proposed Transport Projects In line with the preceding section, the following are the identified projects and activities to be implemented within the period from 2022 to 2025: Table 87. Proposed Transportation Projects PLANS/PROGRAMS Revision of Road Network Master Plan Updating of Local Tourism Master Plan Formulation of SMART Traffic Management Plan Revision of Transport and Traffic Code of Butuan City Roads and Bridges Construction Program PROJECTS/ACTIVITIES Revisit and Revise the Road Network Master Plan Revisit and Update the Local Tourism Master Plan Traffic Impact Analysis Smart Traffic Management System Project Revisit and Revise the Transport and Traffic Code of Butuan City - Completion of East-West Lateral Roads - Completion of Butuan City-Magallanes Road - Completion of Butuan-Tandag Road - TRIP Road Projects - Roads Leading to Conflict-Affected Areas (CAAs) Construction Project - Completion of Taguibo Bridge - Completion of Dulag Bridge Roads and Bridges Improvement Program - Concreting of 56% of unpaved roads - Concreting of Mahay, Camayahan, Lemon, Masao, and Pigdaulan Steel Page 188 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY Bridges - Concreting of Babag Timber Bridge Roads and Bridges Maintenance Program - Regular Maintenance Project of 44% Paved Roads - Regular Maintenance Project of 16 concrete bridges Tourism Road Program (TRIP) Infrastructure - Revisit and Update TRIP and align with CLUP and CDC Establishment of ITX, and off-street sub-terminals at end points such as in Barangays Dumalagan, Sto. Nino, De Oro, Tungao, and Florida City-wide Traffic Lights and CCTV Installation Program connected to the City Central Command Center Passenger Loading and Unloading Facilities Construction Program Construction of ITX and Off-Street Subterminals Installation of city-wide traffic light system and CCTV system Construction of passenger loading and unloading facilities with electronic route information, roofs, benches and lighting (See Chapter 8 for details) Adoption of Fleet Modernization Policy issuance Program of the DOTr and LTFRB Imposition of Mandatory on-board Policy issuance Safety and Security, such as GPS, Dashcam and CCTV, which should be linked to the City’s Command Center Adoption of the DOTr-LTFRB Policy Policy issuance on Automated Fare Collection System (AFCS) in all PUVs for cashless fare transactions. Tricycle Route Plan, which shall Formulation of Tricycle Route Plan which establish alternate roads for tricycle should be consistent with the Tricycle operations considering the hierarchy Modernization Program of road functions Strict implementation of DILG MC Regular conduct of enforcement activities by No. 2020-035 on the tricycle ban on the LTTMO, in coordination with the PNPhighways through regular Traffic Enforcement Unit. enforcement activities Active Transportation Road - Pedestrianization of identified streets for Infrastructure and Promotion walkable community Program - Construction of bike lanes - Park and Bike Facilities Construction Project - Park and Walk Facilities Construction Project Page 189 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY 6.4 Public Transport Improvement Objectives The city’s public transport improvement objectives are classified into Policies and Plans, Infrastructure Facilities, and Transport Services: 1. Policies and Plans: a. Enable transformational change through comprehensive policy and support mechanisms for local public transportation; b. Integrate local transport planning with land use and the environment to support more sustainable travel choices. and 2. Infrastructure Facilities a. Improve accessibility and mobility of people and goods; and b. Establish appropriate locations for loading/unloading points with easy transfer facilities through ITX, sub-terminals and stops; 3. Transport Services a. Ensure demand-based public transport network for seamless mobility of people and goods; b. Improve transport economic efficiency for transport providers and users; c. Ensure safe, secure, reliable, efficient, comfortable, and environmentfriendly public transportation; d. Establish adequate supply of PUVs serving the riding public with reasonable frequency and headway; e. Ensure reasonable waiting time at loading/unloading points; f. Ensure minimum accident rate for safety of passengers and other rad users; and g. Ensure safe and secure active transport; 6.5 Public Transport Development Strategies As with the preceding section, the strategies are classified into Policies and Plans, Infrastructure Facilities, and Transport Services: 1. Policies and Plans: a. Improve policy and regulatory framework for local public transport; b. Establish local transportation office to realize state-of-the-art transport planning, regulation, and monitoring; c. Ensure demand-based route planning considering road hierarchy functions; and d. Promote and sustain active transportation to improve air quality and reduce carbon footprint. Page 190 of 767 LOCAL PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ROUTE PLAN – BUTUAN CITY 2. Infrastructure facilities a. Improve road network in the city to accommodate traffic volume and ensure access and mobility of people and goods; b. Ensure passenger comfort, convenience, and safety; and c. Inclusion of Active Transportation Facilities in Road and Bridges Projects (protected lanes for pedestrians and bicycles), as well as Park and Walk and Park and Bike Facilities. 3. Transport Services a. Implement proper fleet management system; b. Establish appropriate safety measures; c. Ensure profitability of operations for transport providers with passenger service efficiency; d. Establish efficient monitoring system; and e. Fleet modernization. Page 191 of 767
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )