MODULE 1: RATES
AND RETURNS
9
[LOS 1.b] Calculate and interpret different approaches to return
measurement over time and describe their appropriate uses
2. Multiple-period return measurements
Formula
Holding period return
R = 1+R1 1+R2 …(1+Rn ) − 1
Arithmetic mean return
(R + R + R3+ …+ Rn )
R= 1 2
n
Geometric mean return
RG =
n 1+R 1+R …(1+R ) − 1
n
1
2
Harmonic mean
XH =
n
1
i=1 Xi
∑n
Harmonic mean return
n
XH =
−1
1
∑n
i=1 1+Ri
Application
The return earned from holding an asset
for a period longer than one year.
• Simple average of a series of HPRs.
• Assume that the amount invested at
the beginning of each period is the
same.
• Unbiased estimator of true mean.
• Compound periodic rate of return.
• RG < R if the periodic HPRs vary from
period to period.
• It is used as a measure of central
tendency in the presence of outliers.
• It is used most often when the data
consist of rates and ratios (i.e., P/Es).
• A well-known application of harmonic
mean in the investment strategy is
known as cost averaging.
Student’s notes
MODULE 1: RATES
AND RETURNS
10
[LOS 1.b] Calculate and interpret different approaches to return
measurement over time and describe their appropriate uses
Example 1: Return measures
An investor purchased $1,000 of a mutual fund’s shares. The fund had the
following total returns over a 3-year period: +5%, +8%, +12%. Calculate the
value at the end of the 3-year period, the holding period return, the mean
annual return, and the geometric mean annual return.
Answer:
Fill in the blank.
• Holding period return over 3 years:
HPR = (1 + ____) × (1 + ____) × (1 + ____) − 1 = ____
• Arithmetic mean return:
R=
____+____+____
= ____
____
• Geometric mean return:
3
RG =
____ ____ ____ − 1 =____
• Harmonic mean return:
____
XH = 1
1 + 1 − 1 = ____
+
____ ____ ____
Student’s notes
MODULE 1: RATES
AND RETURNS
11
[LOS 1.b] Calculate and interpret different approaches to return
measurement over time and describe their appropriate uses
Example 1: Return measures
An investor purchased $1,000 of a mutual fund’s shares. The fund had the
following total returns over a 3-year period: +5%, +8%, +12%. Calculate the
value at the end of the 3-year period, the holding period return, the mean
annual return, and the geometric mean annual return.
Answer:
• Holding period return over 3 years:
HPR = (1 + 0.05) × (1 + 0.08) × (1 + 0.12) − 1 = 27%
• Arithmetic mean return:
R=
5% + 8% + 12%
= 8.33%
3
• Geometric mean return:
3
RG =
1.05 1.08 1.12 − 1 = 8.29%
3
3
which can also be calculated as RG = 1 + HPR = 1.27 − 1 = 8.29%
• Harmonic mean return:
3
XH = 1
− 1 = 8.26%
+ 1 + 1
1.05 1.08 1.12
Student’s notes
MODULE 1: RATES
AND RETURNS
12
[LOS 1.b] Calculate and interpret different approaches to return
measurement over time and describe their appropriate uses
Example 2: Calculating the Harmonic mean for P/Es
Each year in December, a securities analyst selects her 10 favorite stocks for
the next year. The table presents the P/Es, the ratio of share price to
projected earnings per share (EPS), for her top 10 stock picks for the next
year.
Stock
P/E
Stock 1
22.29
Stock 2
15.54
Stock 3
9.38
Stock 4
15.12
Stock 5
10.72
Stock 6
14.57
Stock 7
7.20
Stock 8
7.97
Stock 9
10.34
Stock 10
8.35
Calculate the harmonic mean for P/Es.
Harmonic mean =
____
1 + 1 +…
1 = ____
____ ____
____
Student’s notes
MODULE 1: RATES
AND RETURNS
13
[LOS 1.b] Calculate and interpret different approaches to return
measurement over time and describe their appropriate uses
Example 2: Calculating the Harmonic mean for P/Es
Each year in December, a securities analyst selects her 10 favorite stocks for
the next year. The table presents the P/Es, the ratio of share price to
projected earnings per share (EPS), for her top 10 stock picks for the next
year.
Stock
P/E
1/(P/E)
Stock 1
22.29
1/22.29 ≈ 0.045
Stock 2
15.54
1/15.54 ≈ 0.064
Stock 3
9.38
1/9.38 ≈ 0.107
Stock 4
15.12
1/15.12 ≈ 0.066
Stock 5
10.72
1/10.72 ≈ 0.093
Stock 6
14.57
1/14.57 ≈ 0.067
Stock 7
7.20
1/7.20 ≈ 0.139
Stock 8
7.97
1/7.97 ≈ 0.125
Stock 9
10.34
1/10.34 ≈ 0.097
Stock 10
8.35
1/8.35 ≈ 0.120
Total
0.924
Harmonic mean =
10
10
1 + 1 +…
1 = 0.923 = 10.82
22.29 15.54
8.35
In this case P/E > 0, which satisfies the Harmonic mean formula.
Student’s notes