1. Evaluate the attractiveness of the concentrate production industry.
Analyzing the concentrate producer (CP) through Porter’s Five Forces reveals why this
industry has historically been one of the most profitable, categorized in the sources as a
"benign" environment for incumbents.
1. Threat of New Entrants: Very Low
The barriers to entering the concentrate production market are exceptionally high, protecting
the dominant positions of Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
Massive Brand Equity: CPs invest heavily in trademarks and sophisticated
advertising, creating "demand-side benefits of scale" where consumers trust and
prefer established brands.
Capital Requirements for Marketing: While the physical plant for concentrate is
relatively inexpensive ($25M–$50M), the capital required for global brand promotion
and market research is astronomical.
Control Over Distribution: Existing CPs have "clout with distribution channels"
through exclusive franchised bottling networks. A new entrant would find it nearly
impossible to secure a comparable national delivery system.
2. Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Low
Concentrate producers maintain a dominant position over their suppliers.
Commodity Inputs: The raw materials for concentrate (caramel coloring, citric acid,
caffeine) are basic and widely available.
Negotiating Leverage: CPs negotiate directly with the suppliers of
their bottlers (such as sweetener and packaging companies), using their massive
collective volume to force down prices.
Excess Supply: In industries like metal cans, there is chronic overcapacity, allowing
CPs to play two or three manufacturers against each other for a single contract.
3. Bargaining Power of Buyers: Low to Moderate
The "buyers" of concentrate are the bottlers, while the "downstream" buyers are retail
channels like supermarkets.
Limited Bottler Power: Through Master Bottler Contracts, CPs like Coca-Cola
have the right to unilaterally determine concentrate prices and terms of sale.
Branding Clout: CPs use "pull" marketing to create consumer demand.
Supermarkets view CSDs as one of their largest selling product lines and a major
traffic draw, which limits their ability to bargain aggressively against the brands
consumers demand.
Fragmented vs. Consolidated: While retail consolidation (e.g., big-box retailers) has
increased buyer power, the CPs still manage the most critical brand assets, keeping
the balance of power in their favor.
4. Threat of Substitutes: Moderate to High (Growing)
This is the most significant threat to the long-term profitability of the cola industry.
Diverse Options: Consumers have many alternatives, including bottled water, juices,
coffee, tea, and sports drinks.
Changing Tastes: As domestic cola consumption plateaus, "non-carbs" have become
the primary engine of growth.
Strategic Response: CPs have mitigated this threat by backward integrating into
the substitutes themselves, acquiring brands like Tropicana, Gatorade, and SoBe to
maintain their "share of stomach".
5. Rivalry Among Existing Competitors: Disciplined/High
While the "Cola Wars" are famous, the rivalry is characterized more by brand competition
than destructive price-cutting at the CP level.
Duopoly Structure: Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola claim a combined 76% of the U.S.
market, which often allows for more predictable competition than a fragmented
industry.
Basis of Competition: Rivalry focuses on advertising and new product
introductions rather than price. Non-price rivalry is less likely to erode profitability
because it improves customer value and can support higher prices.
"Warfare Without Blood": Both giants recognize that their success is
interdependent; as one CEO noted, "If the Coca-Cola company didn’t exist, we’d pray
for someone to invent them".
Overall Structural Attractiveness
The combination of high entry barriers, low supplier power, and disciplined
rivalry explains why soft drinks have historically achieved an average Return on Invested
Capital (ROIC) of 37.6%, nearly six times that of "challenging" industries like airlines.
How attractive is the bottling industry compared to the concentrate production
industry? Why?
Evaluating the bottling industry in terms of Porter’s 5 forces, in order of decreasing impact –
Bargaining Power of Suppliers (High) – the industry shares long terms contracts with the
concentrate producers which are designed to give the producer’s much greater power. The
contract vests in the producers the power to take unilateral decisions on prices and terms of
sale, and even prohibit the bottlers from carrying other brands. All this increases the
bargaining power of the producers and negatively impacts the profitability of the bottling
industry. The producers have also been known to enter the industry, further increasing their
threat.
Bargaining Power of Buyers (High) – bottlers sell to retailers such as supermarkets and
mass merchandisers who buy in bulk. The high volume of sale gives them significant power
over pricing. Control over shelf space also adds to the power of the suppliers - since bottlers
rely on shelf space to grab consumer attention, they have no choice but to give in to pressures
from retailers. Discount retailers and warehouse clubs often have their own private label or
generic CSDs, which provide substitutes to consumers further increasing competition.
Rivalry Among Competitors (High, Destructive) –While territorial contracts prevented
intra-brand competition to some extent, there continued to be competition in terms of cross
brand contracts and the desire to win contract over others. The entry of the CPs into the
bottling industry further adds to competition. Moreover, competitors in the bottling industry
produce highly undifferentiated products and therefore compete solely on price. Such
competition is highly destructive to profitability.
Threat of Substitutes (Moderate) – presence of substitutes to cola, each with its own type
of packaging, exerted pressure on the bottlers since they were unable to cater to multiple
formats at once.
Threat of New Entrants – given the capital intensive nature of the industry and the supply
side economies of scale, there exist considerable barriers to entry of new firms. Entry is also
prevented by the exclusive territorial contracts held by incumbents, which are often in
perpetuity and held up by federal law.
Thus, the bottling industry is capital intensive, highly competitive, and subject to external
pressures. All this makes it extremely challenging to operate in. This is in sharp contrast to
the CP industry, where the producers do not face as many external pressures from buyers,
suppliers, or new entrants. While both industries are competitive, CPs enjoy non destructive
competition while bottlers are caught up in destructive price wars. Therefore, when compared
to the CP industry, the bottling industry holds little appeal.