The Ten Criteria for Evaluating Places (World Geography Lens)
Use the following list to move beyond description and toward critical geographic
thinking—seeing places as dynamic, unequal, and deeply interconnected within global
environmental and political systems.
Additionally the following tools from Human Geography urge us to consider the following:
● Compare regions across the globe
● Analyze case studies (cities, rural areas, ecosystems)
● Evaluate development, environmental policy, or land-use decisions
1. Global Location & Positionality
Where is this place situated within global systems? Consider not just coordinates, but its
position in relation to trade routes, borders, and centers of power.
2. Connectivity & Unequal Access
How is the place connected to flows of people, goods, and information—and who
benefits or is excluded? Attend to infrastructure, digital divides, and mobility constraints.
3. Scale & Power Relations
At what scales (local, national, global) are decisions made, and how do power dynamics
shift across them? Link local outcomes to global processes like trade, migration, or
climate policy.
4. Spatial Patterns & Inequality
What spatial patterns (segregation, clustering, uneven development) are visible? How
do these reflect historical and ongoing inequalities?
5. Environmental Conditions & Change
What are the key physical characteristics (climate, water, soils), and how are they
changing under climate stress? Identify vulnerabilities and resilience factors.
6. People, Culture & Lived Experience
Who lives here, and how do culture, identity, and everyday practices shape the
landscape? Center lived experience, especially of marginalized communities.
7. Political Ecology & Resource Governance
How are land, water, and resources controlled, used, and contested? Analyze conflicts,
stewardship practices, and the role of institutions through Political Ecology.
8. Historical Processes & Legacies
How have histories of colonization, industrialization, or displacement shaped the
present? Connect past decisions to current spatial and environmental outcomes.
9. Climate Justice & Sustainability
Who is most impacted by climate change, and who is responsible? Evaluate mitigation
and adaptation strategies through the lens of equity and justice, drawing on Climate
Justice.
10.Future Pathways & Transformative Possibilities
What sustainable and just futures are possible here? Consider alternative development
models, community-led solutions, and pathways toward resilience.