Davis Baker Case Studies Master List There is more to know than the case studies listed below, but below is a good start as far as examples go. Below does not cover the theory behind a lot of these topics, but Mr. Ogren covered that fairly in-depth. When choosing case studies and examples to research - if not otherwise prescribed by your teacher keep the following in mind: ❏ Choose local examples related to your surrounding area whenever possible ❏ Choose places or incidents that are interesting to you - you’re more likely to remember them ❏ Choose case studies that overlap with multiple topics to minimise the work you have to do ❏ Example of an effective, efficient case study: The Great Barrier Reef. This case study streamlines the studying process for exams, as it applies to… ❏ Area of biological significance (Topic 2) ❏ The importance of tropical biomes, endemic species/evolution(Topic 3) ❏ Aquatic food production & societies (Topic 4) ❏ Impacts of climate change (Topic 7) Unit Required Case Studies/Detailed Examples Topic 1 Foundations 1.1 Environmental Value Systems ❏ At least three detailed examples of how historical influences have shaped the development of the modern environmental movement (eg. Earth Day, Silent Spring, Chernobyl, Minamata disaster) ● Minamata ○ Environmental health crisis in Japan caused by Chisso Corporation releasing methylmercury into Minamata bay ○ Industrial waste bioaccumulated in seafood, leading to chronic mercury poisoning in local communities ○ Early example of catastrophic industrial pollution ● Silent Spring ○ Book by Rachel Carson that exposed the detrimental effects of pesticides, particularly DDT, on the environment ○ Argued that pesticides contaminated the entire food chain, killing wildlife and causing cancer ○ Argued that the pesticide treadmill meant that these pesticides were already becoming ineffective ○ Sparked a massive public outcry, leading to stricter environmental regulations and the creation of the EPA ○ Lead to nationwide ban on DDT for agricultural use in the United States ● Chernobyl ○ Catastrophic nuclear accident in 1986 in Ukraine ○ During a flawed safety test, a reactor suffered a power surge and Davis Baker ○ ○ ○ ○ explosions, causing a core meltdown and released massive amounts of radioactive material Considered the worst nuclear accident in history Now contained with a structure around the whole plant Highlighted risks of nuclear energy, forced international transparency on environmental health, and catalyzed the growth of green political movements Shifted environmentalism from local concerns to transnational efforts around food and ecological safety 1.4 Sustainability ❏ Brief examples of the following types of natural capital: renewable, replenishable and non-renewable) ● Renewable: fish stocks, water, solar/wind energy ● Replenishable: groundwater, ozone, timber (forests) ● Nonrenewable: fossil fuels, minerals, non-renewable groundwater ❏ An understanding of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment and its findings ● Landmark UN study analyzing how human actions have altered ecosystems and how that has impacted human wellbeing ● Found that a substantial portion of ecosystem services (freshwater, fishery supply) are being degraded or used unsustainably ● Ecosystem changes are increasing the likelihood of abrupt, nonlinear changes ● Recommended reversing degradation (would require significant policy changes) ● Provides a baseline for sustainable management of our natural resources 1.5 Pollution ❏ An understanding of the origins, uses and consequences of DDT for ecosystems and human systems ● Synthetic organochlorine pesticide developed to combat Malaria and Typhus (insect borne diseases) ● Banned in 1972 for its catastrophic consequences (bioaccumulation, thinning bird eggshells, and potential carcinogenicity in humans) ● Widely used in 1950s-60s on cotton, soybeans, peanuts, and tomatoes ● Highly persistent, breaking down slowly and accumulating in fatty tissues ● Considered an endocrine disruptor, causes cancer, and can be passed to infants through breastmilk ● Restricted almost everywhere but allowed in specific regions to control malaria ● Many insects have developed resistance due to indiscriminate use Topic 2 Ecosystems & ecology 2.1 Species and Populations ❏ Example of fundamental niche vs. realised niche ● Chthalamus is a barnacle that is physically capable of living across the entire rock face in the intertidal zone. If it’s the only species it occupies Davis Baker everything ● Balanus gulanda is a larger barnacle that outcompetes Chthamalus in the low tide zone, so Chthalamus is forced to live only in the high tide zone ❏ Examples with named species of each of the following population interactions: predation, herbivory, parasitism, mutualism, disease, competition ● Predation: lynx hunting snowshoe hares in the arctic, wolves hunting moose, and bears consuming salmon ● Herbivory: bison eating grass (grazing), giraffes eating tree leaves (browsing) ● Parasitism: ticks feeding on mammals, tapeworms in digestive tracts, aphids eating plant sap ● Mutualism: bees and flowers (bees gain food (nectar/pollen) and flowers get pollinated), clownfish and sea anemones (clownfish are protected and anemones get cleaned) ● Disease: canine distemper virus in African wild dogs. Transmitted from surrounding populations of domesticated dogs, decimated wild dogs in the Serengeti from 1991-1992 ● Cheetahs and Lions in Africa compete for the same food source (gazelle) and Lions may kill Cheetahs for the food (interspecific competition), Male elephant seals battle for dominance and breeding rights (intraspecific competition) 2.2 Communities and Ecosystems ❏ Named examples of a food chain involving: producers, consumers and decomposers ● Savannah grass --> zebra --> lion --> fungi/bacteria/earthworms ❏ Named example(s) to explain bioaccumulation and biomagnification ● Mercury in aquatic food chains (mercury enters from pollution, plankton/bacteria convert it into methylmercury, which are then eaten by small fish, and apex predators like tuna, swordfish, and sharks have high levels of mercury). Mercury then biomagnifies in the tuna, swordfish, and sharks ● DDT in birds of prey (insects and small organisms consume DDT, small fish eat the insects, DDT accumulates in their fatty tissues, bald eagles, ospreys, and peregrine falcons eat contaminated fish accumulating high levels of DDT, causing them to lay eggs with dangerously thin shells) 2.3 Flows of Energy and Matter ❏ One detailed example of how human activities impact energy flows and matter cycling (eg. deforestation, combustion of fossil fuels) ● Deforestation (replacing tropical rainforest with low-productivity cattle pasture) removes producers, reducing NPP, less solar energy is converted into biomass ● Burning fossil fuels (transfers carbon from long term underground storage into the atmosphere as CO2, driving climate change). Deforestation reduces photosynthesis, removing CO2. Ocean acidification leads to excess Davis Baker CO2 absorption, disrupting carbon cycling by marine organisms that need carbonate to build shells (ex coral reefs) ● Use of nitrogen/phosphorus fertilizers leads to eutrophication (massive algal blooms that die, decompose, and create hypoxic dead zones with O2 depletion). The Haber-Bosch process fixes atmospheric nitrogen into usable compounds, doubling the amount of nitrogen entering the biosphere. Livestock waste is high nitrogen which enters water systems causing eutrophication ● Dam construction disrupts flow rates and storage, often drying up wetlands, reducing water cycling capacity and lowering groundwater levels (aquifer completion). Urbanization replaces natural soil with concrete and other impervious surfaces reducing infiltration, increasing runoff, and altering local transpiration rates. 2.4 Biomes, Zonation, Succession ❏ One case study of zonation ● Rocky shore intertidal zonation ○ Splash Zone: Top area, barely submerged; inhabitants like lichens and small snails. ○ High Tide Zone: Frequently exposed to air; dominated by barnacles, limpets, and mussels. ○ Middle Tide Zone: Submerged and exposed alternately; covered by seaweed and chitons. ○ Low Tide Zone: Almost always submerged; home to sea stars, anemones, and kelp. ● Mountain altitude zonation: as altitude increases, temperature decreases and moisture changes, creating bands of vegetation. Deciduous trees are at the base and alpine tundra is at the peak ❏ One case study with named pioneer, intermediate and climax species for primary succession ● Surtsey Island, Iceland ○ Underwater volcanic eruption forms new island. Surface was pure sterile volcanic rock ○ Pioneer species like bacteria, fungi, lichens, mosses, and mold established in tiny cracks, weathering the rock ○ Intermediate species such as sea rocket, plants die and contribute their organic matter to create shallow soil. Sea grasses and small shrubs like dwarf willows start to arrive ○ Trending towards stable maritime grassland community, birds like seagulls are there ❏ One case study with named pioneer, intermediate and climax species for secondary succession ● Yellowstone national park after the fire ○ Pioneer species: fast growing grasses, weeds, and fireweed stabilize the soil which was still there after the fire ○ Intermediate species like small shrubs, aspen trees, and lodgepole pine Davis Baker ○ Climax species: spruce, fir and pine forest is re-established ❏ Named species for compare and contrast between r- and k-strategists ● R-strategists: bacteria, flies, mosquitoes, locusts, dandelions, mice, rabbits, rats, oysters ● K-strategists: large mammals (african elephants, humans), whales, trees, eagles ❏ Explain the distributions, structure, biodiversity and relative productivity of two pairs of contrasting biomes (eg. tropical vs. temperate forest, desert vs. tundra) 1.Tropical Rainforest ● Distribution: Equatorial (0-10° N/S), e.g., Amazon, Congo Basin. ● Structure: High, dense, multi-layered canopy (4–5 layers). Large trees, buttress roots, lianas, and epiphytes. ● Biodiversity: Extremely high (highest on Earth). ● Productivity: Extremely high Net Primary Productivity ( ● ). Rapid growth year-round. ● Nutrients: Rapid decomposition means most nutrients are held in biomass, not the soil. 2. Desert ● Distribution: 30° N/S of the equator (sinking air). e.g., Sahara, Kalahari. ● Structure: Sparse, specialized vegetation (xerophytes). Succulents (store water), deep roots, or short life cycles. ● Biodiversity: Low; specialized to survive extreme heat and drought. ● Productivity: Very low ● . Limited by lack of water. ● Nutrients: Mostly found in the soil, low decomposition rates. 3. Tundra ● Distribution: High latitudes (Arctic circles), high altitude. ● Structure: Treeless, dominated by mosses, lichens, and low shrubs. Permafrost (frozen subsoil) prevents deep root growth. ● Biodiversity: Low; few species are adapted to cold/short growing season. ● Productivity: Low ● . Growth is limited to a few summer weeks. ● Nutrients: Low decomposition rates due to cold, resulting in large amounts of stored organic matter (peat). 4. Temperate Deciduous Forest ● Distribution: Mid-latitudes (30-50° N/S), e.g., Western Europe, Eastern US. ● Structure: Distinct layers (canopy, understory, shrub, ground). Broad-leaved trees that shed leaves in winter. ● Biodiversity: Moderate to High. ● Productivity: Moderate to High; seasonal growth. ● Nutrients: High rates of decomposition in autumn lead to deep, nutrient-rich soils. 2.5 Investigating Ecosystems ❏ Understanding of minimum five abiotic components of ecosystems and their corresponding evaluating measures Davis Baker Topic 3 Biodiversity & conservation 3.2 Origins of Biodiversity ❏ Examples of the causes of the five major extinctions ● End-Ordovician caused by intense glaciation (global cooling), leading to dramatic fall in sea levels, destroying marine organism habitat ● Late Devonian caused by severe climate change, widespread ocean anoxia (lack of oxygen), potential impact of volcanic activity ● Permian-Triassic caused by massive volcanic eruptions in Siberia resulting in extreme global warming, ocean acidification, and ocean anoxia ● Triassic-Jurassic triggered by massive sustained volcanic eruptions that broke apart Pangea, causing climate change and ocean acidification ● Cretaceous-Paleogene caused by massive asteroid impact which caused immediate destruction followed by long-term cooling from dust and debris blocking the sun 3.3 Threats to Biodiversity ❏ Three detailed case studies of three different species: one that has become extinct due to human activity, another that is critically endangered, and a third species whose conservation status has been improved by intervention ❏ Include information about the species ecological role, the pressures on the species, consequences of extinction and species restoration strategies ● Passenger Pigeon: once most abundant bird in North America, mass hunting for cheap food in late 19th century, habitat loss from massive deforestation for agriculture destroyed breeding grounds, population was easy to locate and destroy because they nested in massive colonies ● Sumatran Orangutan: indonesian island of sumatra, habitat loss of tropical forests into palm oil plantations, agriculture, and mining. Illegal trade and capture of infants for pet trade, slow reproduction rates make recovery difficult. Created national parks to protect remaining forests, rehabilitation centers rescuing captive orangutans and releasing them back into the wild, protection against hunting and trading under CITES and national laws ● Bald Eagle - 1972 ban on DDT which caused thin eggshells and passage of Bald Eagle Protection Act, highlights importance of legislation and pollution control on species survival ● Giant Panda, Southern White Rhinoceros ● Arabian Oryx (medium sized antelope) - ex situ conservation (breeding at Phoenix zoo) in 1960s, followed by reintroduction into protected habitats in Oman and Saudi Arabia ❏ Example of a conflict between exploitation, sustainable development and conservation (eg. CAMPFIRE initiative in Zimbabwe) ● Initiative that empowers rural communities to manage their resources for economic gain. Provides tangible financial benefits for sustainable utilization like trophy hunting of elephants. Has faced criticism regarding reliance on hunting and experienced issues with benefit distribution. ❏ One detailed case study of the threats to biodiversity from human Davis Baker activity in a given natural area of biological significance or conservation area (can be a tropical ecosystem like the Great Barrier Reef to apply to the following bullet point as well) ● The Great Barrier Reef ○ 1500+ fish species, 400+ coral species and high productivity ○ Rising sea temperatures cause mass bleaching with 50% coral loss since 1990s ○ Ocean acidification inhibits coral skeleton growth ○ Pollution and nitrogen rich runoff increase outbreaks of crown-of-thorns starfish which eat coral ○ Coastal development and overfishing damages ecosystem resilience ○ Great barrier reef marine park authority manages park establishing zones to restrict fishing and industrial activity ○ Project focuses on breeding heat-tolerant corals and managing starfish populations ○ Limited by global carbon emissions causing ocean warming ❏ One detailed case study of the impact of human activity on the biodiversity of tropical biomes and the conflict between exploitation, sustainable development and conservation in tropical biomes. 3.4 Conservation of Biodiversity ❏ One detailed case study evaluating the success of a protected area ● Chitwan National Park in Nepal ○ Local communities are involved in conservation management, turning them into partners ○ Buffer zone exists to provide communities with resources (timber) which reduces pressure on protected core habitat ○ Funding from international organizations and income from ecotourism provides sustained resources for management ○ Successful protection has allowed significant recovery of tiger and rhino populations ● Yellowstone National Park ○ In-situ conservation, protecting entire ecosystems ○ Protects iconic species like grizzly bears and wolves, demonstrating value of large-scale habitat management ❏ Examples of named keystone and charismatic species ● Keystone species: sea otters (keeps sea urchin population in check, keeps kelp forests healthy). African elephants (prevent savannah from becoming a dense woodland, allows grass eating herbivores to thrive). Gray Wolves (keep elk population in check, reduced grazing pressure allows willow and aspen trees to regrow along riverbanks, which returns beaver populations and increases biodiversity) ● Charismatic species: giant panda, tiger, african elephant, mountain gorilla, polar bear, gray wolf, koala Topic 4 - Water 4.1 Introduction to Water Systems Davis Baker ❏ One detailed example of human influence on the hydrological cycle with regards to agriculture, deforestation and/or urbanisation (eg. the Colorado River and agriculture) ● Colorado River System ○ Depleted surface water and zero flow to sea: Hoover Dam and all american canal divert water to california and arizona for irrigation, river frequently fails to reach its natural delta in the gulf of california ○ Huge storage lakes (Lake Mead and Lake Powell) created by damming have increased surface water area, leading to massive losses via evaporation, reducing total available water ○ Surface water is over allocated, so agriculture relies heavily on groundwater, meaning groundwater is being depleted ○ Dams prevent natural seasonal flooding, trapping sediment and preventing the river from replenishing ecosystems downstream 4.2 Access to Freshwater ❏ One detailed case study of how shared freshwater resources have given rise to international conflict (eg. the Nile Basin conflict) ● Nile Basin Conflict ○ Dispute focuses on Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD), a multi-billion dollar hydroelectric dam ○ Ethiopian view: they generate 85% of the nile’s flow, GERD is vital for energy independence, they have a right to economic development ○ Egyptian view: egypt relies on the nile for 95% of its freshwater needs, GERD is an existential threat, they fear it will reduce water flow and cripple agriculture and population centers ○ Sudanese position: middle ground, faces potential risks from dam failure, benefits from controlled floods and sedimentation for its own dams ○ 1929/1959 agreements give Egypt power over Nile water and give veto rights to any upstream projects ○ Ethiopia thinks these agreements are unfair and neocolonial ○ Ethiopia began construction without an agreed upon management plan causing mass panic in Egypt ○ All basin countries have fast growing populations placing strain on limited water resources ○ Climate change is affecting Nile flow rate leading to uncertainty ○ Egypt states that reductions in water share are a direct threat to national security ○ Core dispute over how fast the dam is filled, faster filling means less water for Egypt ○ Binding agreement has not been found yet ○ Rapid filling could cut Egypt’s water supply significantly, forcing up to 24% unemployment Davis Baker 4.3 Aquatic Food Production Systems ❏ One detailed case study of the controversial harvesting of a named species (eg. whales and Inuit hunting) Whales and Inuit hunting ● Tradition ○ Inuit have been hunting whales for a long time ○ They usually use traditional methods (harpoons) ○ Central to Inuit identity and social cohesion ● Why it’s controversial ○ IWC enforced a whaling moratorium in 1986 banning all whaling to help population recovery ○ Hunts can be considered inhumane ○ Using modern technology and selling whale products blurs the line between traditional subsistence and commercial harvesting ○ Many whales are often struck by harpoons but die elsewhere ● 1977 Bowhead Controversy ○ IWC called for total ban to save the species ○ Inuit argued that the survey of population was faulty, losing the hunt would destroy their culture ○ IWC backed down, permitted a restricted, quota-based hunt ● Currently right to harvest is acknowledged but is heavily restricted ❏ One detailed case study of unsustainable fishing and associated fishery management strategies (eg. Bluefin Tuna) Bluefin Tuna ● Why Bluefin? ○ Highly sought after for high end sushi and sashimi markets ○ Highly vulnerable to overfishing as organisms that mature late and spawn in specific areas ○ Modernization of fishing technology allowed for massive extinction ● Unsustainable fishing from 1980-2000s ○ Catch limits set higher than recommended by scientists ○ Illegal and unreported catches ○ Stock biomass had declined dramatically by 2007, poster child for consequences of overfishing ● Fishery recovery strategies ○ Drastic reduction in quotas ○ Increasing minimum size limits for caught fish ○ Spatial and temporal closures (shrinking fishing season) ○ Aerial spotter technology to locate tuna schools was banned ○ Mandatory observers on large vessels ○ Satellite monitoring to catch vessels ❏ One detailed case study of the impacts of aquaculture (eg. shrimp farming in Thailand) Shrimp Farming in Thailand ● Shrimp aquaculture has grown rapidly, using lots of modern technology ● Contributed to destruction of mangrove biomes, removing crucial habitats and coastal protection Davis Baker ● Discharge of effluent from farms has degraded water quality and caused eutrophication ● Intensive operations use chemicals and antibiotics which pollute groundwater and surrounding ecosystems ● Lead to major disease outbreaks within the population (Yellow Head Virus and White Spot Syndrome Virus) ● Saltwater farms seep into surrounding land, causing soil degradation and restricting agricultural use ● Adoption of closed loop systems and water treatment protocols along with regulation has helped to make these more sustainable 4.4 Water Pollution ❏ Examples of both freshwater and marine pollution Freshwater ● Nutrient pollution (eutrophication): runoff containing fertilizers (nitrates and phosphates) from farms into the Ganges River (India) leading to algal blooms and oxygen depletion ● Sewage and pathogens in untreated domestic wastewater is discharged into the Nile River introducing coliform bacteria ● Minamata Bay and release of toxic metals ● Mining activity (acid mine drainage): acidic water, high in heavy metals, drains from abandoned coal mines into local streams in Appalachia ● Thermal pollution: heated water discharged from nuclear power plants into Germany’s Rhine River, reducing water’s ability to hold dissolved oxygen Marine ● Oil Spills (deepwater horizon oil spill released 4.9 million barrels of crude oil into the gulf of mexico, harming seabirds, mammals, and coral reefs) ● Plastic pollution (great pacific garbage patch where currents accumulate high concentrations of floating plastic, causing entanglement and ingestion issues for turtles and seabirds) ● Aquaculture pollution (salmon cages in Chile’s coastal waters) nutrient enrichment causing eutrophication ● Noise pollution (high intensity sonar from military vessels or shipping traffic) disrupting communication and migration of whales and dolphins in Atlantic ocean ● Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) PCBs accumulate in the blubber of marine mammals like killer whales, causing infertility and immune system suppression ❏ One example explaining the process and impacts eutrophication (eg. the eutrophication of Lake Erie) Eutrophication of Lake Erie ● Excessive phosphorus and nitrogen enter lake erie (mainly from agricultural runoff), sewage treatment plants, and fertilizer use. Maumee river is a major contributor, draining 4 million acres of cropland into western basin ● Algal bloom growth occurs in the summer months when high phosphorus Davis Baker ● ● ● ● ● ● Topic 5 - Soils levels combine with calm warm water to create ideal conditions for cyanobacteria to multiply rapidly When massive algal blooms die they sink to the bottom. Bacteria decompose the dead algae, a process that consumes massive amounts of dissolved oxygen, leading to hypoxia or anoxia at the lake bottom In oxygen deprived conditions chemical reactions in the sediment release phosphorus previously stored in the mud, causing further self-sustaining algae growth even if external nutrients are gone Causes drinking water contamination (Toledo, Ohio people didn’t have tap water for 3 days) Bottom hypoxia kills benthic organisms creating a dead zone in the central basin Negatively impacts the tourism industry ($12.9 billion dollars) causing beach closures, reducing property values, and forcing millions of dollars to be spent on water treatment Return of algal blooms since 1990s indicates that agricultural practices and climate change are creating new challenges for the lake 5.2 Terrestrial Food Production Systems and Food Choices ❏ Two detailed case studies of contrasting food production systems comparing the inputs, outputs, system characteristics, environmental impacts, and socio-cultural systems (eg. industrial beef farming vs. traditional Maasai livestock) Industrial Beef Farming (USA) ● Inputs: high fossil fuel energy, imported grain feed (corn), antibiotics, growth hormones, veterinary care, heavy machinery, intensive irrigation for feed crops ● Outputs: large quantities of beef, low unit price, high methane and CO2 emissions, significant water pollution (nitrogen/phosphorus), antimicrobial resistance risks, high fat content meet ● Characteristics: sedentary/confined (feedlots/CAFOs), high stocking density, short animal lifespan ● Environmental impacts: high greenhouse gas footprint, deforestation for feed, soil compaction from animals, excessive water use for irrigation ● Socio-cultural systems: market driven, specialized labor, disconnect between consumers and production, focused on fast profit Traditional Maasai Livestock (East Africa) ● Inputs: nature pasture (grazing) water from local sources, family labor, limited veterinary support, hardy indigenous breeds ● Outputs: meat, milk, blood (food), manure (fertilizer), hides, high social value, low environmental pollution ● Characteristics: nomadic (transhumance), extensive land use, low stocking density, longer animal lifespan ● Environmental impacts: potential for localized overgrazing during droughts, generally carbon neutral or positive through soil carbon sequestration ● Socio-cultural systems: subsistence/cultural value, cattle as wealth and Davis Baker status, community-managed land, gender-defined roles 5.3 Soil Degradation and Conservation ❏ Examples of the differences between industrial and subsistence farming systems ● Industrial systems degrade soil faster through intensive methods ● Subsistence systems have lower, more localized impacts, may suffer from nutrient depletion over time Topic 6 Atmosphere 6.2 Stratospheric Ozone ❏ One detailed case study evaluating the role of national and international organizations in reducing the emissions of ozone-depleting substances (eg. the Montreal Protocol) The Montreal Protocol ● In 1970s and 80s they discovered that CFCs (refrigeration, air conditioning, aerosols) were destroying stratospheric ozone, leading to increased UV radiation ● UN Environmental Programme (UNEP) facilitated negotiations and implemented the precautionary principle (idea that we’re going to act to prevent harm despite some scientific uncertainty) ● EPA advocated for strong controls, regulated chemical companies, created licensing system for imports/exports, and implemented bans on venting ODS during servicing ● Countries had different phase out programs (Japan used producer responsibility programs, Canada decreased production) ● Included trade restrictions against non-parties, creating strong incentive for nations to join ● Industry produced alternatives like HCFCs and HFCs ● US promoted commercialization of energy-efficient refrigerators, creating demand for alternatives ● Environmental success, ozone is expected to recover by 2040 ● Significantly mitigated climate change since many ODSs are also potent greenhouse gases ● Extended to phase out HFCs (powerful greenhouse gases) 6.4 Acid Deposition ❏ Examples of the impacts of acid deposition on aquatic, terrestrial and human systems Aquatic systems ● Low pH kills fish and inhibits hatching. Leached aluminum from the soil clogs fish gills, causing asphyxiation ● Sensitive species like Mayflies and crayfish disappear first, breaking food chain for trout, bass, and loons ● High elevation lakes (Adirondacks, NY) often suffer chronic acidity. Rapid snowmelt can cause acid shocks that kill organisms rapidly ● Increased acidity can clear water but cause a shift towards acid tolerant species like Sphagnum moss, leading to simpler, less resilient ecosystems Davis Baker Terrestrial systems ● Leaches essential nutrients like calcium and magnesium from the soil ● Unlocks toxic aluminum from soil particles, damaging tree root systems and preventing water uptake ● High elevation spruce and fir forests (Green Mountains, VT) are affected by acid fog, which strips nutrients directly from needles and leaves ● Weakened trees become more susceptible to insects, diseases, and extreme winter cold Human systems ● Acid rain dissolves limestone and marble, destroying details on monuments and statues (Taj Mahal). Accelerates rusting of steel bridges and structures ● SO2 and NOx form fine sulfate/nitrate particles. When inhaled, these cause heart attacks, asthma, and chronic bronchitis ● Particles and gases create haze that reduces visibility in national parks (Shenandoah, Great Smoky Mountains) ● Acidification can leach heavy metals (lead or copper) from old pipes into drinking water Topic 7 Climate change & energy 7.1 Energy Sources and Security ❏ Detailed examples of the advantages and disadvantages of various energy sources, including: non-renewables (oil, coal, gas, nuclear) and renewables (solar, wind, hydro, tidal, biomass, geothermal) Renewable Coal Oil Natural Gas Nuclear Pros Abundant supply globally, low cost per kWh, reliable base-load power Highly versatile (fuel, plastics, heating), easy to transport and store Cleaner burning than coal/oil, flexible, reliable High energy density, zero-carbon electricity production, reliable baseload power Cons Highest carbon emissions, mining ruins landscapes, emits mercury/sulfur, causes severe air pollution Major source of greenhouse gases, oil spills damage marine life, volatile pricing, finite Methane leakage, fracking causes water pollution and earthquakes, finite High capital cost, radioactive waste storage risks, risk of meltdowns, uranium is non-renewable Example Coal fired powerplant in India providing cheap electricity to a city while causing local air pollution Gasoline used in cars contributes to CO2 emissions and urban smog Natural gas fired “peaker” plant ramping up power on a cloudy day to supplement solar France using nuclear power for >70% of its electricity with low carbon emissions Non-Renewable Davis Baker Pros Cons Example Solar Abundant, lowest operating costs, reduces utility bills, silent Intermittent (none at night), high initial panel cost, requires large space for farms Residential rooftops in Arizona supplying power to homes and feeding excess energy back to the grid Wind Cleanest source (no waste/emissions), low operating costs, sustainable Intermittent, noise/visual pollution Massive offshore wind farms in the North Sea producing significant power for European countries Hydro Highly reliable/predictable, fast response to demand, long-lived infrastructure, creates reservoirs for water Massive environmental impact on river ecosystems, displaces human communities, dependent on rainfall Three gorges dam in China providing massive amounts of renewable energy Tidal Highly predictable, immense power potential, no carbon emissions Extremely high installation costs, limited suitable sites, marine environment corrosion La Rance tidal plant in France operating for decades Biomass Can be carbon neutral if managed, uses waste products, provides reliable power High land use, can cause deforestation, burning releases pollution Burning wood pellets or waste agricultural materials to heat buildings Geothermal Extremely reliable and consistent, small footprint on land, high efficiency Geographically limited (works best near tectonic plate boundaries), high upfront costs, potential for minor earthquakes Iceland uses geothermal energy for home heating and electricity needs ❏ One detailed case study of the energy security and strategies of a given country (eg. Ethiopia, Denmark) Denmark ● Context and evolution ○ 1973 oil crisis where 90% of Denmark’s energy was imported ○ Country implemented systematic overall ○ Pivoted from centralized fossil fuel plants to decentralized energy, over 4000 small-scale generators today ○ Renewable generation (wind and solar) met national demand at nearly all times for a month (March 2025) ○ Significantly reduced coal consumption, last remaining coal plant scheduled to cease operations by 2029 ● Key strategies Davis Baker ○ Pioneer in offshore wind (1,000 MW Thor wind farm). Use energy islands in North and Baltic seas to aggregate wind energy and send it across europe ○ More than 60% of Danish homes are connected to district heating, which uses waste heat from electricity production ○ Denmark has high taxes on fossil fuels that send money into renewable research ○ Balances variable wind power with exporting excess electricity and importing during low-production periods through connections with Germany, Sweden, and Norway ● Future goals ○ 70% reduction in greenhouse gas levels since 1990 by 2030 ○ Climate neutrality by 2045 ○ Strategic focus on using surplus electricity to produce green hydrogen and fuels for shipping and aviation that are hard to electrify ○ Investing in physical protection and cybersecurity for the national grid ● Challenges and lessons ○ Increased turbine size led to social pushback ○ Rapid expansion in offshore wind faces challenges in supply chains for parts ○ Wind energy is high, wind produces intermittently and requires investment in storage solutions 7.2 Climate Change Causes & Impacts ❏ Two detailed examples of the impacts of climate change (whether beneficial/adverse) in different countries, including: changes in water availability, distribution of biomes and crop growing areas, loss of biodiversity and ecosystem services, coastal inundation, ocean acidification, and damage to human health. Brazil (amazon basin and agriculture) ● Severe droughts have reduced major reservoir capacities below 20%, reducing hydroelectric energy generation and irrigation systems ● Warmer climates are probably going to replace tropical forests with savannah in eastern Amazonia. Threatens habitat of Royal Bengal Tiger in the Sunderbans and other endemic species ● Coffee maize and cocoa yields are declining due to heat stress and erratic rainfall (economic losses exceeded $74 billion between 2013 and 2023) ● Rising sea levels threaten coastal cities like Recife and Rio de Janeiro, risking saltwater intrusion into drinking water and infrastructure damage ● Wildfire smoke in the amazon causes severe respiratory issues. Warm humid conditions are also expanding range of vector-borne illnesses like Zika and Chikungunya Australia (marine ecosystems and arid lands) ● 1/3 of the great barrier reef has died from mass bleaching from ocean warming. Acidification has weakened calcium carbonate shells Davis Baker ● 2019/20 bushfires affected nearly 3 billion animals, pushing some species towards extinction ● Southwestern Australia is experiencing a shift in growing seasons with wheat barley and fruit crops becoming vulnerable to prolonged dry spells ● Sea level rise and frequent storm surges threaten low-lying coastal real estate and critical infrastructure ● Extreme heatwaves pose lethal risks. Increased particulate matter from massive bushfires has caused significant respiratory health crises in Sydney and Melbourne and other major cities ❏ Two detailed examples of contrasting viewpoints on climate change, namely Al Gore, The Stern Report Al Gore (An Inconvenient Truth) ● Climate change is a moral imperative and planetary emergency requiring urgent action ● Collusion between earth and us is accelerating driven by population growth and a way of thinking that disregards long term consequences ● Focuses on moral duty to future generations ● Emphasized massive melting in greenland/antarctica, species extinction, extreme weather ● Advocated for carbon emission cap, tax pollution rather than labor, bypass diplomatic delays, inspire individual actions (recycling) Stern Review: Climate Change as Market Failure ● Positioned climate change as the greatest market failure ever ● Benefits of strong early action to cut emissions far outweigh the costs of inaction, delaying action is more expensive than acting now ● Focused on economic risk management rather than moral obligation ● Establish global carbon price, technology policies, energy efficiency laws ● Rigorous economic analysis 7.3 Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation ❏ Examples of carbon dioxide removal techniques (UN-REDD, biomass, CSS) ● UN-REDD and Ecosystems ○ Planting trees in new areas (aforestation) or degraded areas (reforestation) to help capture CO2 as they grow ○ “Reducing emissions from deforestaton and forest degredation” (UN-REDD) incentivizees developing countries to conserve forests, protecting stored carbon from being released ○ No till farming, cover cropping, and rotating crops to increase carbon stored in soil organic matter ○ Restoring coastal ecosystems (mangroves, seagrass meadows, and tidal marshes) highly efficient at trapping carbon in waterlogged soils ○ Re-wetting drained peatlands to stop them from decomposing and releasing massive amounts of stored carbon ● Biomass based solutions ○ Cultivating fast growing plants that capture CO2 through Davis Baker photosynthesis, burning them for electricity, capturing the emissions to store underground ○ Heating biomass in low-oxygen environments to create stable charcoal-like materials that can be added to soil for long-term sequestration and soil improvement ○ Using sustainably harvested wood for construction to store carbon for decades rather than letting it decompose ○ Growing seaweed in the ocean and sinking it into the deep sea, where the carbon stays locked away for centuries ○ Collecting agricultural residues or dead wood and burying them under impermeable clay to prevent decomposition and CO2 release ● CSS and Engineered solutions ○ DACCS (Direct Air Carbon Capture and Storage): Using massive fans with chemical sorbents or solvents to capture CO2 directly from ambient air, then storing it in underground geological formations. ○ Enhanced Rock Weathering (Mineralization): Spreading finely crushed rocks (like basalt or olivine) over land, which react with atmospheric CO2 to convert it into stable carbonate minerals. ○ Carbonated Materials: Reacting captured CO2 with industrial waste (such as steel slag or concrete waste) to create solid, stable materials for use in construction. ○ Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement: Adding alkaline materials to the ocean to counteract acidification and enable the ocean to absorb more CO2 from the atmosphere. ❏ Two detailed examples of mitigation AND adaptation strategies in a named city/country (eg. the Thames Barrier in London) Thames Barrier ● Built to protect 1.3 million people from sea-level rise and storm surges ● Barrier is 10 movable gates spanning the Thames, when closed during high surges it prevents flooding, can be opened to allow river traffic and natural flow ● Has been closed over 220 times, protecting London from extreme tidal surge Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ) ● Part of London’s commitment to reduce greenhouse gases ● Requires vehicles to meet strict emissions standards to pay a daily charge to travel within the central area, encouraging the use of public transport, electric vehicles, and cycling ● Directly curbs CO2 emissions and improves air quality by reducing pollutants like NO2 ❏ Detailed examples of international efforts to address climate change, including: the Kyoto Protocol, the Paris Agreement, the IPCC IPCC ● Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ● Reviews scientific research papers Davis Baker ● Confirmed with high confidence that human activities have unquevocally caused global warming Kyoto Protocol (1997) ● First major international agreement to mandate legally binding emission reductions for industrialized nations ● Only wealthy industrialized countries were required to cut emissions ● Created carbon markets, allowing countries to trade emission credits ● Global emissions continued to rise as China and India (developing countries when ratified) and the US (never ratified) were not bound by the cuts Paris Agreement (2015) ● Replaced Kyoto and shifted to universal model where all countries commit to action ● Each country submits Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) which are individual self made plans for climate action updated every five years ● Wealthier nations committed to using $100 billion to help developing countries transition to clean energy and adapt to climate impacts Topic 8 - Human 8.1 Human Population Dynamics systems ❏ Brief examples of HICs/LICs and countries at each stage of the demographic transition model (country names will suffice) ● HICs: USA, UK, Japan, Germany, Singapore ● LICs: Afghanistan, Niger, Somalia, Central African Republic, Yemen ● Stage 1 ○ Remote tribes pre 1750 ● Stage 2 ○ Niger, Afghanistan, Yemen, DR Congo ● Stage 3 ○ India, Brazil, Mexico, Kenya, Colombia ● Stage 4 ○ USA, UK, China, Canada Australia ● Stage 5 ○ Japan, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Croatia Davis Baker ❏ 2 case studies on population policies (pro-natalist & anti-natalist) and the impact they had on human population dynamics and growth (eg. China, Singapore) Antinatalist: China one child policy ● Government instituted strict restrictions, offering incentives for one child and severe fines penalties and forced sterilization for having more ● Estimated to have prevented 400 million births, significantly slowing population growth ● High elderly dependency ratio as fewer people were being born to replace the current workforce ● High male based sex ratio at birth because of a cultural preference for boys ● Policy was phased out (two child policy in 2016, three child policy in 2021), fertility rates still remain low Pronatalist: Singapore (marriage and parenthood package) ● Encouraging couples to have three or more children ● Significant cash bonuses, extended maternity/paternity leave, tax rebates ● Limited impact on fertility, dropping to 1.1 or lower ● Not been able to fix impending labor shortage or aging population problems ● Struggles against cultural shifts favoring smaller families and lower marriage rates 8.2 Resource Use in Society ❏ Brief examples of the four types of ecosystem services (supporting, Davis Baker regulating, provisioning, cultural) with a basic understanding of their importance Provisioning (tangible products) ● Food (fish, crops, wild berries), fresh water, timber, fiber (cotton wool), medicinal plants, wood fuel ● Form basis of economy, diet and shelter, could not survive Regulating (natural processes) ● Pollination of crops, water purification by wetlands, carbon storage in forests, flood control by mangroves, pest control by birds/bats ● Keep ecosystems functional, clean, and safe, reducing hazards like floods and diseases, help to mitigate climate change Cultural (non material benefits) ● Hiking swimming, aesthetic appreciation of landscapes, spiritual/sacred sites, ecotourism, mental health benefits of nature ● Provide mental wellness, cultural identity, and educational opportunities Supporting (fundamental processes) ● Photosynthesis, nutrient cycling, soil formation, habitat provision for biodiversity, water cycling ● Foundation of all ecosystems, without supporting services the other services would not exist ❏ 1 case study each of a non-renewable and renewable resource & how it is dynamic and has changed over time Crude Oil in the US ● Between 1970 and 2008, US crude oil production fell as conventional wells were depleted. Technological innovations like horizontal drilling and fracking turned the US into the world’s leading oil producer by 2014 ● Petroleum consumption peaked in US in 2004-05. By 2014 it was slightly below 1997 levels due to increased fuel efficiency standards and cleaner alternatives ● Changed the US from major importer to a net exporter of petroleum products by 2020 (still net importer of crude oil) ● Industry has moved to deeper offshore drilling and harder to extract sources like oil sands, increasing environmental risks and carbon emissions Solar Energy in the US ● Technology has evolved from rare high cost cells to mainstream energy source ● Shift from niche applications to utility-scale ● Advancements in technology have improved efficiency, moving from older poly-crystalline cells to mono-crystalline and developing flexibile thin-film options ● Industry is moving from just providing energy to including battery storage as standard, reducing intermittency issue ● Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 drastically increased investment in solar 8.3 Solid Domestic Waste ❏ Detailed examples of the pros & cons of the 4 main types of solid Davis Baker domestic waste disposal options (landfills, incinerators, composting, the 6Rs) Pros Cons Landfills Cheap to build and operate compared to incineration, high capacity, methane captured from landfills can be converted into renewable energy, closed landfills can be repurposed into parks, golf courses, or recreational areas Leachate can leak and contaminate groundwater, organic waste decomposes w/o oxygen, producing methane, require large amounts of land, materials can take decades or centuries to decompose Incinerators Reduces volume of waste needing landfill space, produces electricity/steam for local communities, ideal for disposing of hazardous, clinical, or toxic chemical waste (destroys them, releases pollution), not weather dependent and less odor than landfills Releases harmful pollutants (NOx and toxins) if not properly filtered, expensive to build and operate, leftover ash is toxic and must go to special landfills, need a steady supply of waste which can deter recycling efforts Composting Turns waste into valuable fertilizer, reduces landfill burden and methane emissions, does not release toxic fumes Can only handle organic materails, can attract rodents and produce odors if mismanaged, requires space and consistent maintenance (turning the compost) The 6Rs Reduces environmental footprint by reducing need for raw materials, saves energy and natural resources, creates more jobs than landfills or incinerators Requires changes in consumer habits, some materials are expensive and technically difficult, improperly separated recycling can result in materials still being sent to landfills 8.4 Carrying Capacity & Ecological Footprints ❏ Examples of ecological footprints in one named HIC and one named LIC and reasoning for why they differ HIC: United States ● High meat consumption, large dependence on fossil fuels for transport and electricity, high consumer waste, and large energy intensive housing ● About 5 earths would be needed LIC: Malawi ● Diet based largely on local unprocessed food, minimal transportation ownership, low electricity consumption, and traditional low energy housing. ● Ecological footprint is far within Earth’s sustainable biocapacity
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )