EMILE DURKHEIM = CULTURE HAS THE POWER OVER INDIVIDUALS TO CREATE BELIEFS, SUCH AS BELIEF
IN GOD
EDWARD TYLOR = CULTURE IS THE WAY OF LIFE OF A GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT “INCLUDES THEIR
KNOWLEDGE, BELIEF, ART, MORALS, LAW, CUSTOMS, AND ANY OTHER CAPABILITIES AND HABITS
ACQUIRED BY MAN AS A MEMBER OF SOCIETY.
-
CULTURE CONTAINS ALL ASPECTS OF SHARED HUMAN EXPERIENCES.
• FRANZ BOAZ (1887)= “…CIVILIZATION IS NOT SOMETHING ABSOLUTE, BUT…IS RELATIVE, AND … OUR
IDEAS AND CONCEPTIONS ARE TRUE ONLY SO FAR AS OUR CIVILIZATION GOES.”
• ALAIN LOCKE (1924) = “CULTURAL RELATIVISM” EXPLAINS WHY ONE BEHAVIOR OR PRACTICE IS
COMPLETELY ACCEPTABLE BY A PARTICULAR GROUP OF PEOPLE, WHILE IT IS TABOO IN ANOTHER.
• VALUES, KNOWLEDGE, AND BEHAVIOR OF PEOPLE MUST BE UNDERSTOOD WITHIN ITS OWN
CULTURAL CONTEXT, AND NOT BY THE STANDARDS OF OTHER CULTURES.
CULTURAL RELATIVISM
•THE THEORY THAT HOLDS THAT MORALITY IS RELATIVE TO THE NORMS OF ONE'S CULTURE. THAT IS,
WHETHER AN ACTION IS RIGHT OR WRONG DEPENDS ON THE MORAL NORMS OF THE SOCIETY IN
WHICH IT IS PRACTICED. THE SAME ACTION MAY BE MORALLY RIGHT IN ONE SOCIETY BUT BE MORALLY
WRONG IN ANOTHER.
•ETHNOCENTRISM USING YOUR OWN CULTURE AS THE NORM, CRITERIA OR CENTER AND EVALUATE
OTHER CULTURES BASED ON IT.
5 CLAIMS OF CULTURAL RELATIVISTS
• 1. DIFFERENT SOCIETIES HAVE DIFFERENT MORAL CODES
• 2. THE MORAL CODE OF A SOCIETY DETERMINES WHAT IS RIGHT OR WRONG. THERE IS NO OBJECTIVE
STANDARD CONSIDERED BETTER THAN OTHERS.
• 3. THERE ARE NO UNIVERSAL MORAL TRUTHS
• 4. THE MORAL CODE OF A PARTICULAR SOCIETY HAS NO SPECIAL STATUS. IT IS BUT ONE AMONG THE
MANY
• 5. IT IS ARROGANT FOR ONE CULTURE TO JUDGE ANOTHER CULTURE. THERE SHOULD BE TOLERANCE
AMONG CULTURES
ADVANTAGES AND DANGERS OF CULTURAL RELATIVISM
• ADVANTAGES:
• 1. IT WARNS US FROM ASSUMING THAT OUR PREFERENCES ARE THE ABSOLUTE RATIONAL STANDARD
• 2. IT TEACHES US TO KEEP AN OPEN MIND AND TO BE MORE AMENABLE IN DISCOVERING THE TRUTH
• DANGERS:
• 1. WE CANNOT CALL OUT SOCIETAL PRACTICES THAT PROMOTE HARM
• 2. WE CANNOT JUSTIFIABLY CRITICIZE OUR OWN CULTURE’S HARMFUL PRACTICES
• 3. THE IDEA OF SOCIAL PROGRESS BECOMES DOUBTFU
EMOTIVISM
•MORAL STATEMENTS ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE PEOPLE
•EMOTIVISM TAUGHT THAT IT WAS ABOUT MORE THAN JUST AN EXPRESSION OF EMOTION - THE
SPEAKER IS ALSO TRYING TO HAVE AN EFFECT ON THE PERSON THEY'RE TALKING TO.
BE CAREFUL RELYING SOLELY ON FEELINGS/EMOTIONS CAN BE DANGEROUS AND RISKY. EMOTIONS CAN
SOMETIMES BE UNRELIABLE.
• 1. EMOTIONS SHOW PARTIALITY. IT IS DIFFICULT TO DECIDE OBJECTIVELY IF ONE RELIES SOLELY ON
EMOTIONS.
• 2. EMOTIONS DRAW OUR PERSPECTIVE AWAY. IN SOME CASES, FEELINGS PROVIDE MORE CONFUSION
THAN CLARITY. IT DISTRACTS YOU FROM OBJECTIVELY ASSESSING THE SITUATION.
• 3. EMOTIONS ARE CAPRICIOUS. FEELINGS CHANGE FROM TIME TO TIME, AND SOMETIMES INSTANTLY.
HENCE, MORAL JUDGMENTS THAT ARE ANCHORED ON FEELINGS ARE UNRELIABLE.
SOME BENEFITS OF CULTURAL RELATIVISM
• IT HELPS PEOPLE TO BE CULTURALLY SENSITIVE.
• UNDERSTANDING OTHER PEOPLE’S CULTURE PREVENTS US FROM BEING DISCRIMINATORY, RACIST
AND ETHNOCENTRIC.
• IT ENCOURAGES US TO IMMERSE OURSELVES TO A COMMUNITY TO UNDERSTAND THEIR CULTURE
FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE LOCAL/INSIDER.
• IT EMPHASIZES THAT MORALITY IS INDEED EVOLVING.
• IT EMPOWERS CULTURAL MINORITY GROUPS (EX. INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, LUMADS).
• IT ENCOURAGES DIVERSITY AND MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACHES AMONG INSTITUTIONS
BE CAREFUL, CULTURAL RELATIVISM CAN BLIND YOU
• IT ENCOURAGES BLIND OBEDIENCE AND BLIND FOLLOWING. WE CANNOT CRITIQUE OUR OWN
CULTURE.
• WE CANNOT ALSO CORRECT THE WRONG PRACTICES OF OTHER CULTURES.
• SOMETIMES, CULTURAL RELATIVISM MAKES US INDIFFERENT TOWARDS OTHER SOCIETIES.
• IT CAUSES DIVISIONS AND XENOPHOBIA (FEAR OR DISLIKE TOWARDS FOREIGNERS OR “THE OTHERS”.
IT CAN LEAD TO “OTHERING” OF PEOPLE AND COMMUNITIES).
• WE SHOULD NOT EXCLUDE OTHERS ON THE BASIS OF CULTURE. AS HUMAN BEINGS WE SHARE SO
MANY COMMONALITIES (PAIN, SUFFERING, HUNGER, POVERTY, JOY, HAPPINESS, ASPIRATIONS, HOPES, A
BETTER AND BRIGHT FUTURE, ETC.)
ETHICAL THEORIES THAT CENTER ON THE SELF
• 1. SUBJECTIVISM = THE INDIVIDUAL THINKING PERSON IS THE HEART OF ALL MORAL VALUATIONS.
• HE/SHE IS THE ONE WHO IS CONFRONTED WITH THE SITUATION AND IS BURDENED WITH THE
NEED TO MAKE A DECISION OR JUDGMENT.
• THEREFORE HE/SHE MAKES THE RADICAL CLAIM THAT THE INDIVIDUAL IS THE SOLE
DETERMINANT OF WHAT IS MORALLY GOOD OR BAD, RIGHT OR WRONG
• 2. PSYCHOLOGICAL EGOISM = “HUMAN BEINGS ARE NATURALLY SELF-CENTERED, SO ALL OUR ACTIONS
ARE ALWAYS MOTIVATED BY SELF-INTEREST.”
• ALL ACTIONS ARE GEARED TOWARDS THE SATISFACTION OF OUR EGO, AND SELF-SERVING
INTEREST • DOG-EAT-DOG MENTALITY
• 3. ETHICAL EGOISM = WE MAY ACT IN SUCH A WAY THAT IS BENEFICIAL TO OTHERS, BUT WE SHOULD
DO THAT ONLY IF IT ULTIMATELY BENEFITS US.
THE MORAL AGENT
NATURAL LAW ETHICS (THOMAS AQUINAS)
ST. THOMAS AQUINAS
▪St. Thomas Aquinas, born 1224/25 in Sicily—died March 7, 1274
▪Italian Dominican theologian, the foremost medieval Scholastic. He developed his own conclusions from
Aristotelian philosophy
▪his two masterpieces: the Summa theologiae and the Summa contra gentiles
▪recognized by the Roman Catholic Church as its foremost Western philosopher and theologian.
ARISTOTLE’S INFLUENCE ON AQUINAS’S ETHICS
▪Aquinas developed his ethics largely due to his in-depth reading and analysis of Aristotle’s Nicomachean
Ethics
▪Aquinas’s approach to ethics is anchored on the question of human happiness (eudaimonia) patterned
after Aristotle
IN ETHICA I, NO. 3, ST. THOMAS PROVIDES A SYNTHESIS OF HIS MORAL PHILOSOPHY. the object of ethics
“…is the study of human actions, insofar as they are reciprocally ordered to an end. By human actions I
intend those actions which proceed from the will of man according to the order of reason… so the object
of moral philosophy is the human action ordered to an end and man insofar as he acts voluntarily for an
end.
▪Following the footsteps of Aristotle, St. Thomas asserted that the first task of moral philosophy “is to
discover the ultimate end to which the acts of man must be ordered (designed).”
ESSENCE
▪1. something that makes a thing what it is,
▪2. based on its intended purpose or end,
▪3. as designed by its creator or maker
THOMAS AQUINAS ON THE ESSENCE OF MAN
▪Aquinas emphasized the capacity for reason as what is essential to our human nature
▪Understanding of human nature must be anchored on our capacity for reason which is the essence of
the human person
▪Mans’ end can be understood in relation to eternal law and natural law
ETERNAL LAW
Eternal law = highest kind of law
Eternal law = eternal plan of order in the mind of God for the whole universe
Eternal law (plan/design of God) is in the creatures that God created so that they have an inclination or
tendency to their own proper acts and ends according to how they fit in this vast and beautiful divine
plan.
This eternal law (plan of God) is implanted on all creatures. However, the eternal law is implanted on
rational creatures (human beings) in a special way. Aquinas calls this the natural law Natural law = the
rational creature’s participation in eternal law.
POTENTIALITY AND ACTUALITY
▪a pair of closely connected principles which Aristotle used to analyze motion, change, and actuality
▪The concept of potentiality generally refers to any "possibility" that a thing can be said to have.
▪Actuality is the motion, change or activity that represents an exercise or fulfillment of a possibility,
when a possibility becomes real in the fullest sense
ETERNAL LAW AND NATURAL LAW
Man participates in God’s eternal law in and through natural law
▪More specifically by following man’s 5 principal natural inclinations
5 PRINCIPAL NATURAL INCLINATIONS/TENDENCIES OF MAN
▪Our characteristics in common with other beings (plants and animals)
▪1. natural inclination to preserve life
▪Self-preservation
-sexual intercourse (procreation) and to care for one’s offspring -we are sexual animals. it
is natural for us to experience “heat” which leads us to do sexual intercourse –
2. natural inclination to engage in sexual act and to reproduce
▪3. natural inclination to do good and avoid evil according to the nature of our reason ▪
4. natural inclination to know the truth (and to shun ignorance)
▪5. natural inclination to live in society. ▪we are rational and social animals ▪social concern: we know we
live in relation to others. Justice and common good
▪ As a rational being, man is “naturally good”, or to put it in another way, man is inclined to do the good
since reason instructs man to do good and to avoid evil.
▪1. natural tendency to preserve life ▪2. natural tendency to procreate and care for offsprings ▪3. natural
tendency to do good and avoid evil ▪4. natural inclination to know the truth ▪5. natural inclination to live
in society.
BEING AND BECOMING ▪Aquinas borrowed from Aristotle’s discussion on the nature of beings. ▪A being
is anything that exists. A being may have a physical (corporeal) existence (chair, table, book, human
beings, dogs, etc.) or it can have a metaphysical (beyond physical) existence (truth, love, justice,
freedom, God). ▪For Aristotle, any being have four causes.
4 CAUSES
▪Corporeal, tangible beings, or things that we see and touch around us possess a certain kind of
materiality.
▪A chair or a dog, for example has a material or physical body (the “stuff” a thing is made of). ▪Aristotle
refers the physical characteristic of being as (1.) material cause.
▪When referring to material cause, we can ask the question “what is it made of?” For example, the
material cause of a house is wood, cement, sand, gravel, etc.
▪A being is unique precisely because of its materiality. It is for this reason that we can easily distinguish a
dog from a cat because of its unique physical features.
▪The distinguishing feature of being (the “form” or “shape”) is the (2.) formal cause.
▪the formal cause of a house is its blueprint, or the “idea” or “design” as conceived by the carpenter or
architect before its construction.
▪When referring to the formal cause, a carpenter or architect will ask “what will be the design of the
house?” The “design” which is in the mind of the carpenter will serve as his guide when he starts
building the house
▪A house will not exist, unless it is created or constructed by a carpenter. The agent that brings into
existence another being (from wood to house) is the (3.) efficient cause. Hence, the efficient cause of a
house is the carpenter or construction worker
▪Lastly, a being is created for a specific purpose, end or goal. Again, going back to our example, a house is
built primarily for shelter. This apparent purpose or end is what Aristotle calls (4.) final cause
WHAT ARE MAN’S FOUR CAUSES ▪Material cause: ▪Formal cause: ▪Efficient cause: ▪Final cause