Physics 235 : Problem Set 1
Carlos Wagner, Spring 2026
Due Friday, April 3, 11:59 PM
1. In class we discuss the possible states of a system of two particles with arbitrary spins s1
s1 s2 s
,
and s2 , and presented a method to obtain the so-called Clebsch Gordan coefficients Cm
1 m2 m
defining the amplitude of each particular tensor product of the spins states of the two particles
in the sate |sm >, namely
|s m >=
X
s1 s2 s
Cm
|s1 m1 > |s2 m2 > .
1 m2 m
(1)
m1 ,m2
The metod we used was based on writing all the possible tensor products that satisfy the
~ 2 applied to the state leads to
constraint m1 + m2 = m and demand that the spin operator S
~ 2 in terms
h̄2 s(s + 1) times the same state. In order to do this, we wrote the spin operator S
of the spin operators acting on each particle, namely
~2 = S
~12 + S
~22 + 2Sz1 Sz2 + S+1 S−2 + S−1 S+2
S
(2)
where S± are raising and lowering operators such that
q
S±i |si mi >= h̄ si (si + 1) − mi (mi ± 1)|si (mi ± 1) >
(3)
In particular, we describe the states |0 0 > |1 0 > as tensor products of states of two particles
with spin s = 1/2.
a. What values of s can you obtain when considering systems of two particles of spin
s1 = 2 and s2 = 1 ?
b. Using the method described above, obtain the Clebsch Gordan coefficients associated
with all the possible states with m = 0 and m = 2. Hint : For m = 0, look at the lecture
notes posted in Canvas, and proceed in analogous way for m = 2.
c. Are the three (two) states of m = 0 (m = 2) orthogonal to each other ? What is the
probability of finding the particle of spin s1 = 2 in a state with m1 = 1 in each of the states
with m = 0 ? Is it different from the one of finding the particle of spin s2 = 1 in a state
with m2 = −1 in each of these states ? Explain why this happens.
1
2. Imagine now that we have two identical fermions of spin 1/2 in a sate with s = m = 0.
Since the particles are fermions, the total wave function must be antisymmetric under the
interchange of the two particles.
a. What can you say about the properties of the state |0 0 > under the interchange of the
two particle spins ? What can you say about the properties of the spatial wave function
describing these two particles in the spin state |0 0 > ?
b. Now, imagine that the spatial wave function is build up from products of two states ψa (x)
and ψb (x), with ψa (x) and ψb (x) being two wave packets with no overlap with each other.
and that, unknown to the observer B measuring the properties of the fermion localized in
the state ψb , another observer A measures that the fermion described by the state ψa has
spin in the z-direction equal to h̄/2. Before this measurement, what would you say about the
probabilities of observer B of measuring the spin in the z-direction equal to h̄/2 and −h̄/2 ?
What would you say these probabilities are after the measurement by observer A ?
c. How can you nterpret the results of d. ? Can observer A use the above properties to
control in a non-causal way the spin direction of the particle measured by observer B ?
3. Assume a system of two identical particles, so that the Hamiltonian
H(~r1 , p~1 , ~s1 , ~r2 , p~2 , ~s2 ) =
X
H(~ri , p~i , ~si ).
(4)
i=1,2
Let’s for simplicity ignore the spin dependence and assume the wave function
Ψ(~r1 , ~r2 ) =
X
anm ψn (~r1 )ψm (~r2 ),
(5)
n,m
where ψn (~r) form a complete and orthonormal set of eigenfunctions of H(~r, p~). The example
is what happens with electrons in an atom.
a. What conditions you need impose on anm if the particles are fermions ? What if the
particles are bosons ? What is the normalization condition on these coefficients ?
b. What is the probability density of finding a particle at ~r1 and the other particle at ~r2 ?
Compute the probability density of finding the particle 1 at ~r1 , by integrating over ~r2 . If the
particles are identical, is it different from the one of finding the particle 2 at ~r2 (integrating
over ~r1 ) ? Use the result of point a.
c. Consider the formal expression for the mean value of the Hamiltonian H(~r1 , p~1 , ~s1 , ~r2 , p~2 , ~s2 ).
How can you interpret the result ?
2
4. A half baked problem based on Bell’s inequalities : Imagine that I try to simulate
quantum mechanics by a clever hidden variable theory, such that the function A(~a, λ) is a
step function.
1 + cos θ
2
1 + cos θ
A(~vθ , λ) = −h̄/2 for λ ≥
2
A(~vθ , λ) = h̄/2 for λ ≤
(6)
where 0 ≤ λ ≤ 1 while ρ(λ) = 1, and ~vθ is an arbitrary vector forming an angle θ with
respect to the z direction. In this way,
P (0, ~vθ ) = −
Z 1
0
A(0, λ)A(~vθ , λ)dλ = −
h̄2
cos(θ)
4
(7)
that is the quantum mechanical value. Can you compute the Bell’s inequality in such a case,
taking the three directions to be θ = 0, θ = π/4 and θ = π/2 ? Discuss the result of this
computation, and compare it with the quantum mechanical case.
3