Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 1 S1 Role Peloton Interactive, Inc. (Peloton) has seen substantial growth through the years since its foundation in 2014. The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated this growth as the company reported a revenue increase of 232 percent at the end of 2020 from the same period the previous year. This growth carried into the 2021 fiscal year, however, the company was unable to keep up with demand which resulted in delivery delays and unsatisfied customers. Therefore, in May 2021, Peloton announced its plans to build its first United States (US) factory to address this supply chain issue. This report advises Peloton’s chief executive officer (CEO), John Foley, regarding the long-term financial implications of the supply chain growth decisions and how Peloton can fulfil its goals of market leadership in scale, cost, quality, and speed-to-market. S2 Organizational Performance Exhibit 1 highlights the key financial metrics of Peloton’s financial statements. Although there has been a constant growth in revenue and gross profit, due to the relatively high operating expenses, the company has recorded negative operating and profit margins between 2018 to 2020. Meanwhile, Peloton’s competitor, Nautilus, Inc. (Nautilus), reported an 11 percent profit margin in 2020, an increase from 4 percent in 2018, despite it relatively lower revenue growth rate of 79 percent between 2019 and 2020. Furthermore, Peloton’s high current ratio of 2.80 compared to Nautilus’s ratio of 2 in 2020 implies that Peloton may not be making efficient use of its cash as it had a closing cash and cash equivalent account of over US$1 million. The company recorded a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.78 in 2020, which is a significant increase from -0.86 in 2019. This is attributable to the influx of share capital and increase in outstanding common shares. This is also relatively good compared to Nautilus’s ratio of 1.08 in 2020. Exhibit 2 shows that Peloton’s fitness subscriptions and revenue growth rates have been on a positive trend since the 2019 fiscal year end. The company saw its largest growth in the second quarter of the 2020 fiscal year with a 26.5 percent and 105 percent increase in fitness subscriptions and total revenue respectively. This can be attributed to closures of gyms during the first lockdown of the pandemic. Although the following periods have since a constant growth above 22 percent, total revenue has not grown at the same rate. For these reasons, Peloton’s organizational performance would rank 7 out of 10. S3 Organizational Health Employee & Customer satisfaction – The revenue boom experienced during the pandemic came with some issues that Peloton was unprepared for at the time. Due to the soar in demand, the company was unable to satisfy its delivery commitment to customers which resulted in lower customer satisfaction due to the frustrated customers. It can be implied that as a result of this, Peloton employees would have to work harder to meet this demand and appease to customer complaints which may decrease employee enthusiasm and satisfaction at work. Learning – Peloton is able to learn from its experience and build upon it. As a response to the delays in deliveries, the company invested over $100 million to solve its delivery issues. It also expanded its campus to increase member support, sales, and corporate functions. This can mitigate the lowered employee satisfaction. Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 2 Problem Solving – Peloton has had a fundamental ability to identify and create solutions to customers unmet wants. They have also been able to create new markets by tapping creating demand for niche products. From the company’s creation of its bike which combined exercise, fitness tracking and entertainment, it was able to satisfy customer needs. Furthermore, after the pandemic, the company was again quick to identify and solve an issue that most of its customers faced due to the lockdown which resulted in a deep and loyal Peloton community. Therefore, Peloton’s organizational health scores a 9 out of 10. S4 Performance Matrix Peloton’s organizational performance and health are well above the 5 mark which places the company in the desired state quadrant of the performance matrix as of 2021. The analysis performed suggest that the company has been making an upwards diagonal trend in quadrant 1 of the matrix for the past three years. To continue on this trajectory, Peloton should constantly adapt to evolving customer needs and improve operational efficiencies. S5 Strategy Triangle Peloton builds on it competitive advantages to sustain its market leadership position in scale, cost, quality, and speed-to-market in the industry. This is successful due to the company’s fast market reaction and through understanding of customer wants. S6 Goals Some of Peloton’s identified hard goals include to increase its Asian manufacturing footprint, increase its US manufacturing facilities to produce connected fitness products in the United Sates by year-end 2021, build a new US factory to begin operations by 2023, improve quality and achieve economies of scale in bike and tread product lines, increase sales by extending its reach to its addressable US market, penetrate the commercial fitness market, reduce delivery times to improve customer satisfaction and boost research and development (R&D) capabilities. These goals are realistic and necessary for the company to main market leadership. Additionally, an identified soft goal for the company is to increase campus by more than 9,000 square metres to allow an expansion to member support, sales, field operations, and corporate functions. As mentioned, this can potentially improve employee satisfaction and efficiency. S7 Ansoff Matrix Peloton has focused on a market penetration strategy as it continues to offer existing products in its current markets. This is ideal for the company as it is still in its early stages and still has potential market share to gain from its competitors in the current market. The company’s current market is the United States which has the highest fitness market size of US$37 billions. As of July 2020, data showed that the company’s US total addressable market continued to expand. Therefore, the US fitness market, although it is very competitive, it is growing at a fast rate and currently unsaturated. Peloton should focus on maintaining market leadership though market penetration strategies to increase its market share position. Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 3 S8 Value Proposition Peloton competes to lead in scale, cost, quality, and speed-to-market. It offers fitness equipment’s in two different price ranges of $1,995 and $2,495 for its Bike and Bike+ products respectively. This is within the industry range of $999 to $2,995 of competitor product pricing. It is important to note that Peloton’s cheaper alternative is still more expensive than most of its competitors’ products. However, its monthly subscription is in line with industry average of $39 per month with only Echelon offering a cheaper alternative. Peloton’s product features are limited to its cardio options, live classes offering and 10-watt (w) stereo speakers on its bikes. Whereas some of its competitors offer extensive product features such as built-in electromagnetic arms, boxing, training bands, dumbbells, and stereo speakers with up to 60w. However, a product feature that helps the company stand out is its live classes that are available on demand. When examining Peloton’s execution, as previously stated, it was unable to keep its delivery commitments to customers during the pandemic, therefore, lacked availability and reliability. S9 Core Activities Peloton’s initial core activity is research and development. Following the acquisition of Precor, manufacturing of fitness equipment by the end of 2021 will also become a core activity of the company. The company aims to continue this backward integration by building a new US factory to improve its supply chain control. Forward vertical integration possibilities for Peloton include increase the number of brick-and-mortar stores to carry its products and increase availability. E10 Porter’s Five Forces Threat of new entrants – This is ranked LOW because entry into the industry requires extensive capital and customer trust. Although Peloton’s products are not inimitable, the company is heavily investing capital to maintain its customer loyalty and improve technology advancements. Bargaining power of buyers – Buyers have a MEDIUM bargaining power. Consumers have a number of alternatives to choose from in terms of the fitness equipment where there is a range of price. However, the monthly subscription cost is fairly uniform amongst the competitors. Moreover, once a consumer acquires a fitness equipment from one company, it is highly probable they will subscribe to the same company rather than a competitor. This locks the consumers into only purchasing additional features from the same company in order to enjoy the full consumer experience offered by the company. Threat of substitutes – This is HIGH because Peloton competes in a highly competitive market with competitors offering similar products. Peloton’s products are relatively high and offer less product features compared to its counterparts. Furthermore, as the pandemic restrictions are limited, consumers may opt for cheaper fitness activities such as outdoor running, returning to the gym or working out without equipment. Bargaining power of suppliers – This is MEDIUM as Peloton still relies on its third-party manufacturers within its supply chain. However, Peloton’s push to integrate backward and increase its manufacturing capabilities, especially will reduce the power of suppliers in the future. Intensity of rivalry – This is HIGH as Peloton currently competes with multiple other businesses with lower priced products and a number of product features. Although these competitors lag behind Peloton in customer loyalty and brand awareness, they have the capital and resources to Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 4 copy and improve Peloton’s products. Overall, the fitness industry is unattractive due to the high starting capital demand and intensive competitive landscape. E11 PEEST Political – The pandemic led to national lockdowns imposed by governments which forced many gyms into bankruptcy. This, on the other hand, benefitted the virtual fitness industry as many people pivoted to a virtual environment. Economic – The fitness industry has been seen to match the business cycle. This is evident during the pandemic when all the industry was impacted severely. As the industry is dependent of consumers disposable income, when the economy improves, the industry will tend to see an expansion. Peloton reported its largest revenue growth during this stage. Environmental – Climate change and pollution has become a heightened topic of debate in recent times. The pandemic resulted in people working and working out from home, which led to a decrease in driving and pollution to the environment contributed by commutes to the gym. Social – The US fitness market has grown since 2016 due to public health initiatives that highlighted the role of exercise in preventing health issues. Due to the pandemic restrictions, people have less opportunities for social interactions and seek innovative virtual alternatives. Peloton addresses this by creating a community for its users through its features. Technological – The industry continues to innovate new products and features and increase automation in production. Peloton targets to increase its production automation and R&D to improve its technological advancements. E12 Stakeholder Key stakeholders to the company include its customers, employees, and shareholders. The customers’ primary interest is for Peloton to offer quality products at a low cost and meet their delivery commitment. Meanwhile, employees including management want high salaries and optimal working conditions. These stakeholders interest conflict with the shareholders’ key interest of a high return on their investment. These stakeholders want the highest profit margins which would require higher sale prices and low expenses including salary expense. E13 Industry Structure The industry is oligopolistic in nature as there exist a few numbers of large companies that offer similar products with unique features to differentiate them. Based on the porters five analysis, the high barriers to entries indicate that the industry is unlikely to change in the near future. E14 Genealogy The interactive fitness industry stemmed from the idea of bringing the gym experience to the home of every consumer. Although the market had existed for a few years, it was the pandemic that accelerated the growth and demand for this market. E15 Business Model Peloton’s two main revenue stream are its monthly subscription fees and equipment sales. Product features is the main driving factor for the subscription revenue as consumers need to be satisfied with the offering to justify continual with the program. Because there is seldom repeat Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 5 purchase of fitness products, new customers drive the equipment sales. Meanwhile, Peloton’s expenses are primarily related to manufacturing, R&D, and marketing costs. These costs are driven by company goals to ensure high quality and speed-to-market leadership. As of 2020, Peloton’s expenses are greater than its revenues resulting in a net loss. R16 Resource Analysis (VRIO – value rare Inimitable organized) Marketing – Peloton’s reputation is superior in the industry. This is evident as the company has been described as “the Apple of fitness” and “as much a media company or a software play as it is a gym or equipment maker.” The company also carries out R&D operations, it should have patents that protect its technology which is a competitive advantage. Operations – As the company continues to expand its manufacturing capacity, it is reducing its reliance on external manufactures in order to improve supply chain operations efficiencies. Peloton currently operates in the same markets as its main competitors which gives them a competitive parity. The organization is not flexible or organized enough to meet the changing customer demand. This is especially shown by the large customer deposits and deferred revenue account on the Peloton’s 2020 balance sheet with a closing balance of US$364 million, a 300 percent increase from US$91 million in the prior year. This shows that the company is struggling with its operations and not getting products to customers. This can lead to increased returns which hurts the company’s bottom line and market share. Development – The planned investment in R&D capabilities shows the company’s effort to lead the industry in product and technology expertise. The acquisition of Precor came with the company’s exiting expertise as a leading global commercial fitness equipment provider which will add to Peloton’s operations. Financial – Despite the negative gross and profit margins, Peloton has shown that it has the vast capacity to raise capital when needed. This is seen in 2020 when the weighted-average common shares outstanding increased from 23 to 221 million from the previous year. This translated to an additional paid-in capital of US$2.4 billion. As previously mentioned, the company has strong revenue figures but fails to limit its expenses resulting in negative margins as shown in exhibit 1. Human Resources – Peloton is implied to have the necessary workforce with the desired skillset to flourish as an organization. This is apparent in the company’s success to identify and quickly address market needs as well as successful research outcomes. Corporation Reputation – Observed from the aforementioned acquisition of Precor, Peloton has a good corporate reputation in the business community. R17 Gap Analysis The identified major gaps for Peloton are its operational and financial inefficiencies. Peloton is currently operating at a net loss which indicates that its expenses are not fully covered by the earned revenue. The company will benefit from reducing its cost of revenue by sourcing cheaper materials while keeping quality stable. The company should also aim to maximize sales and marketing expenditures. The company should also consider partnerships with retailers to carry their products and increase customer accessibility as this strategy is done by most of the other competitors. Furthermore, the company is to create a solution for its current supply chain weakness that resulted in delivery delays. Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 6 M18 Management Preference Management’s initial decisions leaned towards organic growth strategies such as increasing sales revenue and product development. Following the pandemic and the surge in revenue, management’s decision follow more inorganic growth strategies such as raising external capital and investment in vertical integration. However, management decisions have consistently been consumer centric. This is shown when the company made the decision to forgo near-term profitability over unsatisfied customers due to the delivery delays. O19 Organization Peloton operates as a functional organization as it has a CEO and chief membership officer. This structure divides the corporation based on its business functions such as R&D, productions, sales, and finance. The managers of these business units ultimately report to the CEO who is accountable to the board of directors of the company. This is an ideal structure for Peloton as it has only a few product lines and this allows for increased flexibility of resource allocation and activity coordination in each business function. 20 Change Agenda A primary change that should be implemented for Peloton is to improve its operations and cost structure. This can be done by developing new resources to improve efficiencies. Furthermore, there is a large unaddressed market that Peloton has not tapped into which can be reached with the proper marketing strategy and products. The first issue to be addressed is the aforementioned supply chain weakness the company is facing. Peloton is unable to maintain its delivery commitment to customers and due to the backorder, the company may lose a high number of potential revenues. The next identified issue that the company has not addressed is its plan following the pandemic. The pandemic spurred the expansion of the company, however, the company should prepare for evolving customer preference post-pandemic as gyms will begin to reopen when health restrictions ease down. 21 Crisis Curve To implement strategic change in this span of time would be an act of reactive change for Peloton. It is imperative that Peloton take immediate action as the end of the pandemic is in the foreseeable future and exhibit 2 shows the inconsistent revenue growth rate each quarter following the second quarter of the 2020 fiscal year. Therefore, management needs to react to the dynamic environmental changes and pressure to close the performance gap. 22 Alternatives Build Ohio Factory – The first strategic alternative is for Peloton to build the Ohio factory. The primary advantage of this alternative is that it provides a solution to the company’s supply issue and improves the company’s speed-to-market leadership. This strategy allows the company to manufacture directly in US where its main target market resides to decrease delivery lead time. Therefore, this can lead to improved customer satisfaction which is important as it is a driving factor of the company’s revenues. However, the disadvantages of this alternative include the high cost and time to implement. The cost of the factory is estimated at US$400 million which is about 39% and 19% of Peloton’s 2020 cash and total current assets balance respectively. Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 7 Furthermore, the factory will not be ready to produce Peloton products until 2023. This two-year timeline is detrimental as the company will have to continuously incur high expenses to meet delivery expectations. During this time, the effect of the pandemic may have been completely eliminated leading to changed consumer preference and a decrease in demand. Should this be the case, the company will be investing in a capital-intensive project for unnecessary capacity. Partnership with Retailers – The second alternative is for Peloton to have its products carried by third party retailers. Some of the company’s competitors currently do this including Echelon whose products are carried by Walmart, Costco, and Amazon. The key advantage of this is that it helps build customer accessibility to the products and gives customers access to test drive some products in store before purchase. Customers will also be able to easily compare products and identify Peloton’s unique features. Additionally, this will cost less to implement than the first strategy and will also take less time to implement. However, the main disadvantage is that it does not solve the issue of delivery times for the company. New Product Development – This third alternative centers around the development of a new product to be sold to the existing Peloton market. The new product line will include cheaper alternative for the bike and tread product lines. As mentioned in the analysis above, Peloton’s current products are priced higher than most of its competitors and is not a cost leader. The company already has the manufacturing and technology capabilities and would require less skill and cost to product a cheaper alternative to its existing product lines. This will decrease lead time for product manufacturing, resulting in faster deliveries and increased customer satisfaction. The company will also be able reach price sensitive consumers if they offer products with a lower price tag. However, this alternative is relatively costly and will take some time to implement. Do Nothing – The last alternative is to continue operation without any change. Although this is the most cost and time effective strategy, the analysis conducted indicates that Peloton is in the reactive section of the crisis curve. This means the company cannot afford to not act. As shown in exhibit 3, the alternatives are evaluated on four important criteria. Customer satisfaction is weighted 30 because it is the main driving factor of the company’s revenue. Improve speed-to-market is weighted 20 because this is one of the main goals of Peloton and needs to be addressed to solve the current delivery issues facing the company. Impact on market share is an important criterion weighted at 20 due to the highly competitive nature of the industry. Finally, cost and time to implement are both weighted at 15 because they impact the company’s financial position, and the company is under time pressure to implement new change. 23 Action Plan Based on the decision matrix in exhibit 3, the new product development strategy is the recommended alternative. In the short term, the company should redesign its current products to reduce material costs while maintaining the basic features. In the medium term, Peloton should aim to partner with retailers to carry the new products as most price sensitive customers can be accessed. In the long term, the company should begin production and distribution of the new products. The pricing should aim to be competitive with that of Echelon who is currently a cost leader in the industry. The key performance indicators include sales Name: Stu Dent Student #: 987654321 Section: CXX 8 increase of over 30 percent each quarter and a decrease in operating cost of 5 percent. The main identified risk is the potential continuation of the supply chain issue. This can be mitigated by investing in automation to improve the manufacturing efficiencies.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )