INDE 301 - Engineering Economy
Chapter 1Foundations of Engineering Economy
Spring 2025-2026
INDE301- Chapter 1
Introduction
What is Engineering Economy?
➢
It involves estimating, formulating and evaluating the financial outcomes of alternatives
➢
It is a collection of mathematical techniques that simplify economic comparison
➢
It provides a criteria for decision making
Steps of a decision-making process
Understand the problem and define the objectives
2. Collect relevant information
3. Define alternatives and estimate relevant costs
4. Identify the criteria
5. Evaluate each alternative
6. Select the best alternative
7. Implement the solution
8. Monitor the results
9. Refine the solution (go back to 3)
1.
2
Operations Research (OR)
➢
OR is also concerned with scientific decision making.
➢
It utilizes advanced math, stats, algorithms, software, and other tools, for rigorous
analysis.
3
➢
It is suited for complex systems and critical decisions.
➢
Engineering economy concepts are at the heart of the OR analysis.
➢
INDE 302, 303 and many of the INDE and ENMG courses fall under the wide
umbrella of OR.
➢
A modern and highly popular paradigm data analytics or business analytics.
➢
Data analytics rely heavily on statistics and software, and interfaces with OR and
engineering economy in what’s called prescriptive analytics.
➢
Prescriptive analytics essentially utilizing big data sets to come-up (prescribe)
with business solution.
➢
Two steps that come before are descriptive and predictive analytics. (look themup if you are interested.)
Why Engineering Economy is important
to engineers?
➢
Engineers “design” and create/ involves economic decisions
➢
Engineers must be able to incorporate economic analysis into their creative efforts
➢
Often engineers must select and execute from multiple alternatives
➢
A proper economic analysis for selection and execution is a fundamental
Examples of questions Engineering Economy can answer
4
➢
Take on a new project?
➢
Replace an old equipment?
➢
Introduce a new product?
➢
Build a new plant?
➢
Invest in project A or in project B?
➢
Any ideas (What else?) …..
Engineering Economy and Economic
Feasibility Analysis
➢
Economic feasibility study is the first step to embarking on new business (e.g.
opening-up a new restaurant or launching a start-up) – needed to justify the
profitability.
➢
Engineering economy tools allow you to do full-blown economic feasibility for
projects/endeavors at your company\ business\personal matters
➢
Personal economic feasibility business examples- taking a loan, buying a car or an
apartment, investing money, etc.
➢
You need to connect the dots and keep what you learn in this course at the back of
your mind when you face tough decisions with economic/financial implication.
5
Time Value of Money
➢
$1 today is not “equivalent” to $1 a year later. Worst alternative is to deposit
(invest) the $1 in a bank and gain “interest” (or dividend)
6
➢
Money makes money --
➢
All firms make use of investment of funds
➢
Investments are expected to earn a return
➢
Investment involves money
➢
Money possesses a “time value”
Interest
➢
Interest is the manifestation of the time value of money
➢
Rental fee that one pays to use someone else’s money
➢
Difference between an ending amount of money and a beginning amount of
money
➢
Interest rate = (interest accrued per time unit) / (original amount)
➢
From the lender perspective, the “earned” interest rate is a “rate of return” (ROR)
➢
For a simple loan (investment) consisting of borrowing (lending) money now and
returning (retrieving) it after one year, the annual interest rate (ROR) is given by
Final loan amount − Original amount borrowed
100
Original amount
Final investment value − Original amount invested
=
100
Original amount
Interest rate (%) =
ROR (%)
7
Example
➢
The Oracle investment group invested $200,000 on May 1 and withdrew a total of
$220,000 exactly one year later
o
Interest earned = $220,000 – $200, 000 = $20,000
o
ROR = ($20,000 / $200,000) × 100 = 10%
➢
Another Oracle group borrowed $100,000 on May 1 and paid a total of $105,000
exactly one year later
8
o
Interest paid = $105,000 – $100, 000 = $5,000
o
Interest rate = ($5,000 / $100,000) × 100 = 5%
Equivalence
➢
Different sums of money at different times may be “equivalent” in economic value.
➢
For the Oracle group doing the investment, $200 K now are equivalent to $220 K a
$220 K
year later
one
year from
now
0
1
Interest rate = 10 % per
year
$200 K
now
Example: You want to replace your study desk. The new desk is now $125 and
estimated to be worth $135 for the next year. Suppose you are going to finance the desk
purchase from your saving account earning an annual interest rate of 12%. Would you
replace the desk now or next year?
9
➢
$135 next year are equivalent to 135/1.12 = $120.54 < $125 (present worth analysis )
➢
Then, it’s better to buy the desk next year because this saves you around $5.
Simple and Compound Interest
➢
Interest can be either simple or compound.
➢
With simple interest, in each period a borrower pays interest on the principal (the
amount borrowed) itself only
➢
With compound interest, in each period, a borrower pays interest on the principal
and on the interest accumulated from previous periods (pays “interest on interest.”)
➢
Unless otherwise noted, we adopt compound interest in this class.
Suppose you borrow an amount P and pay interest for n years at a rate of i per year.
Then, the amount, F, you pay back n years later is
o With simple interest, F = P + iP +
+ iP = P + niP. Then,
F = P(1 + ni)
o With compound interest, F = P(1 + i )(1 + i )
F = P (1 + i ) n
10
(1 + i). Then,
Example
Suppose you deposit $10,000 into a saving account at 5% per year for 3 years.
➢
If it is a 5% simple interest rate, the interest you earn each year is $10,000 (0.05)=
500$ for each year or $1500 for 3 years. The total you will have at end of year 3:
F=$10,000 +$1,500 = $11,500
➢
If it is a 5% annually compounded interest rate, you will earn:
Year 1 = $10,000 (0.05)= $500$ → Total end of year 1: $10,500
Year 2= $10,500 (0.05) = $525 → Total end of year 2: $11,025
Year 3= $11,025 (0.05)= $551.25 → Total end of year 3: $11,576.25
Interest earned over 3 years = $500+$525+$551.25 = $1576.25
11
Rule of 72
This rule (approximately) estimates the number of time periods (years), n, it takes for
an amount of money to double under a ROR of i (%) under compound interest,
n
➢
72
.
i
So, money invested at 8% interest doubles (approximately) every 9 years. Money
invested at 12% doubles every 6 years, etc.
➢
This rule is useful for doing compounding “mentally,” e.g. when negotiating or
during a job interview, or when your phone battery dies and it becomes hard to
calculate 1.126?
12
Rule of 72
Future value of $100 invested at 10% for n years.
n
72
.
i
➢
Using simple interest, an initial $100 that will become $400 after 30 years.
➢
Using compounding ($200 after 7.2 years, $400 after 14.4 years, $800 after 21.6
years, and more than $1600 after 30 years!)
➢
Better to use 72 rule to estimate compound interest than estimating by simple
interest (Cautious in projects that extend over long n and have high interest rates.
13
Cash Flows
➢
Cash Inflows - amount of funds flowing into the firm
o
Sales Revenue/ Asset salvage value/ Borrowed money/ Income tax savings
➢
Cash Outflows – amount of funds flowing out of the firm
o
Paybacks/ Labor cost/ Maintenance and operating costs/ Loans /Income taxes
➢
Past cash flows are summarized in an accounting statement called the “statement of
cash flow.” (More on this later.)
14
➢
We are looking into the future, “project” (i.e. estimate or forecast) future cash flows.
➢
Estimating future cash flows is an art (relying on experience) and a science.
Cash Flows
➢
A cash flow diagram (essential tool in engineering economy) looks as follows:
Always assume end-of-period
cash flows!
0
n
1
2
… … …
Cash flows are shown as directed arrows (+ for up or – for down) --(+) inflow; (-) outflow
➢
End of year assumption
➢
Use a reasonable period (semi-annually, quarterly, monthly, weekly,…) to net the
cash flow and apply them at the end of the period.
15
n─1
Cash Flow- Example
An electrical engineer wants to deposit an amount P now such that she can withdraw an
equal annual amount of A1 $2000 per year for the first 5 years, starting 1 year after the
deposit, and a different annual withdrawal of A2 $3000 per year for the following 3
years. How would the cash flow diagram appear if i =8.5% per year?
16
&
z
Minimum Attractive Rate of Return(MARR)
➢
Investors expect to earn a return on their investment (commitment of funds) over time.
➢
Economic projects should earn a reasonable return, which is termed (MARR).
➢
The company management establishes the MARR.
➢
MARR is estimated based on the weighted average of the “cost of capital” (WACC) of
sources of funding.
o
Equity financing – the firm uses its own assets to finance often through issuing stocks or can be
from cash on hand or retained earnings.
o
Debt financing –the firm borrows money from outside sources and repays the principal and
interest according to some schedule. Common sources of debt include bonds, loans, mortgages.
17
➢
MARR is set in such a way that MARR > cost of capital (WACC).
➢
A “risk” margin / “profit” margin are added on top of the WACC to get the MARR.
➢
These margins depend on economic environment/ type of business/ market conditions
MARR-Example
Suppose you are investing in new sound and light equipment for your event planning
business. The new equipment cost $7000. To buy the equipment you decided to follow the
following finance plan: Use $5000 from your savings account at a rate of 4% per year and
$2000 from your credit card at a rate of 12%. Calculate the cost of capital and establish
your company’s MARR.
WACC= (5000/7000)*(4%)+(2000/7000)*(12%)=6.28%
Decide on risk margin to add (example between 2% -3%)
Decide on profit margin to add (example between 3%-4%)
For example, you can set MARR at 12%
To decide to accept or reject a new project (an event) you will have to estimate the cash
flows from the project (inflows/outflows) and do a present worth (PW) analysis for
example at the MARR of 12%. If PW (MARR) is positive then accept the new event,
otherwise reject.
18
Minimum Attractive Rate of Return(MARR)
➢
To be considered financially viable, a project’s expected ROR must meet or exceed the
MARR. That is, a project should be undertaken only if
ROR ≥ MARR>WACC
➢
I can use PW(MARR) >=0 (If present worth is positive → project feasible)
.
present worth
19
Example of Time Value of Money: Cranes
➢
The civil engineer at Tallco is considering renting one of two tower cranes for a 5-year
construction project.
➢
Crane 1 has an initial installment cost of $60,000, an annual rental fee of $180,000,
and a dismantling fee of $10,000.
20
➢
These costs are respectively $25,000, $190,000, and $5,000 for Crane 2.
➢
Which crane should Tallco rent?
Example of Time Value of Money: Cranes
21
➢
Tallco MARR is estimated at 15%.
➢
Undiscounted amount: 60+180(5)+10= $970 K (Misleading!)
➢
Crane 1 cash flow diagram
➢
Equivalent “present value” of Crane 1 costs
Example of Time Value of Money: Cranes
➢
Undiscounted amount: 25+190(5)+5= $980 K
(Misleading! more costly than Crane 1 → rent Crane 1…what about time value of money?)
22
➢
Crane 2 cash flow diagram
➢
Equivalent “present value” of Crane 2 costs
➢
Tallco should rent Crane 2!
Summing it up..
By estimating future cash flows, the MARR, and
utilizing equivalence (time value of money) , we can
make sound engineering economic analysis.
23