Questions:
• I used the same data but altered the display: the y-axis was modified to a
very narrow range (around 178.5–180.5 cm instead of starting at 0), and the
chart was made tall and skinny. I still showed only grade means, which
hides the spread. These choices inflate tiny differences so bars look
dramatically different.
• The misleading version suggests big height gaps among grades (for
example, that seniors “tower” over others). In reality, the average difference
is only about 1–2 cm, and the distributions overlap heavily (most students
fall in a similar range). The truthful graph (full y-axis) shows the grades are
much more alike than different.
• Graph design can decieve perception without changing any numbers.
Uneven scales, 3D effects, odd bin widths, and bold titles can exaggerate or
minimize patterns. Always check axes limits, units, sample sizes (n), and
variability, and read the source and caption before trusting the message.
Sources, ETC.
• I surveyed dorm students, asked for one height in cm, 19/1/2026.
• Data was grouped by grade; participation anonymous; means were used for
the graphs.