Paper 2 Practice: Q: Discuss how two works you have studied make the reader question preconceived ideas and how this is achieved by the writer A: Both Cormac McCarthy’s No Country for Old Men (2005) and Patrick Susskind’s Perfume (1985) feature antagonists that, through relationships and interactions with other characters, make readers question preconceived ideas about the society that the story takes hold in. No Country for Old Men is a neo western thriller that examines the erosion of moral order, the futility of human endeavors, and the dichotomy of good and evil. It follows Llewelyn Moss, who stumbles upon a drug deal gone wrong, and decides to take the money left behind, inciting a chase by the ruthless hitman Anton Chigurh. As Chigurh chases Moss across Texas, he encounters various characters that symbolize archetypal western tropes from old America, which he then systematically eliminates and kills through his otherworldly nihilistic philosophy. The deaths of these characters acts as McCarthy’s indirect criticism of these tropes, and his lament of how they are no longer present in the modern world. Similarly, Perfume is a subverted Kunstlerroman that follows Grenouille, a young artist that is endowed with a supernatural sense of smell, and a penchant for murdering young women. As he develops as an artist, Grenouille encounters various characters that attempt to exploit and use his talents, acting out the dark side of Enlightenment era Paris. Like Chigurh, Grenouille systematically eliminates these characters with his presence, causing unfortunate events to happen when he’s there. This “invisible force” channels Susskind’s satirisation of the Enlightenment and it’s superficial nature. Both texts are similar in that they feature antagonists that kill off minor, stereotypical characters that channel the dark attributes of a particular society, conveying the authorial attitudes towards these landscapes. By the notion that characters can function as vehicles for ideas, both authors employ a multitude of literary devices such as polysyndeton, anaphora, and hyperbole to suggest that the Enlightenment and Old America depicted in media are not as fruitful and fantastic as people perceive them to be. Near the beginning of both texts, both villains encounter characters that embody the virtues of incompetence and passiveness in society. In No Country for Old Men, this is seen from the character of the proprietor, who is an antithesis of the “self reliant” American archetype that was expected out of every man. For his whole life, the proprietor has struggled with making an active decision regarding his own fate, and has on all occasions left it to the control of other beings. A stellar example of this is when he marries into ownership of a gas station, a feat that exemplifies weakness. Chigurh catches this immediately, and calls him out for it: “You married into it.” The parataxis highlights this fundamental truth about the proprietor’s timid nature. Chigurh then challenges the proprietor to a coin toss, and this frightens him immensely, as it forces him to make a choice of his own volition. This fright can be seen in his trembling hands, as he asks Chigurh: “What exactly is it that I stand to win?” Chigurh’s taut response: “Everything.” exacerbates the stakes of this moral confrontation. The proprietor yields to the challenge and wins it, calling the correct side. Ironically, the proprietor does not seem to attribute his success to his own luck, but instead blesses Chigurh for his mercy: “He [the proprietor] laid the coin on the counter and just stood leaning there. He put both hands on the counter and just stood leaning there with his head bowed.” The imagery of one leaning on the counter with his head bowed connotes prayer or worship towards a higher deity. In this parodic replication, the proprietor worships Chigurh, showing how consensual he is with letting his own fate to the whim of others, effectively eliminating the “self reliant” American archetype from McCarthy’s worldview, and making readers question the idea of self-reliance and whether it functions in today’s world. The idea of incompetence can also be seen in Perfume from the character of Baldini, representative of the Enlightenment notion for procedural based art, an idea that fails to acknowledge the key ingredient of artistic intuition. Baldini’s superficial obsession with procedure can be seen from the description of his perfumery: “He had thousands of them. His stock was full of essences absolues – floral oils, tinctures, extracts, resins, and other drugs stored in dry, liquid, or waxy form.” The hyperbolic polysyndeton makes clear to the reader Baldini’s crucial flaw: although he has a lavish inventory, he cannot make anything with it, simply because he does not have artistic intuition of his own, and relies on other people’s formulae and the talents of others. Unsurprisingly, given his high social ranking in Enlightenment Paris, he denies this weakness in a conversation with his assistant: “As you know, I take my inspiration from no one. As you know, I make my own Perfumes.” The anaphoric repetition is ironic because despite Baldini’s standing as one of the best Perfumers in the nation, he still needs to affirm his “talent” to his assistant, a man who probably understands that Baldini is not all that he is advertised to be, thus making this confession to self an exposure of Baldini’s individual insecurity. Susskind’s exposure of Baldini’s initial weakness primes his confrontation with Grenouille, an artist that relies on intuition, does not need a scrap of formula, and just does things without procedure. Grenouille’s first encounter with Baldini occurs when he is but a boy, and Grenouille, in desperation of securing a job as a Perfumer, challenges Baldini to allow him to make a Perfume using his ingredients. Similar to the Proprietor’s resistance to change, Baldini is afraid of exposure, exposure of his ersatz nature, and is incredibly hesitant on allowing Grenouille to experiment. Nevertheless, he does it anyway, and understandably, is appalled by Grenouille’s methodology: “He was like a child cooking up a new breed of water, grass, and mud, which he then asserts to be soup.” The use of the simile demonstrates primitive and intuitive knowledge unhindered by the mannerisms of logical thinking, which goes against Enlightenment doctrine. The resulting fact that Grenouille’s Perfume brought “tears to his [Baldini]’s eyes” makes readers question the true practical advantage of logic and reasoning in a medium that requires emotion, love and intuition most of all. Near the middle of both novels, both antagonists encounter characters that embody the notions of false altruism. In No Country for Old Men, this can be seen from the character of Carson Wells, representative of the “morally ambiguous bounty hunter” archetype seen in old American movies. Carson Wells is an old colleague of Chigurh’s, and has been hired by another company to deal with Chigurh’s killings, by killing him. For someone that knows Chigurh and his ruthless calculating nature, Wells is surprisingly aloof, and he even states to his employer: “Compared to what? The Bubonic Plague? He’s bad enough that you called me here. He’s a psychopathic killer but so what? There’s plenty of them around.” Although the allusion to the bubonic plague is made in parodic humor, it truly provides credence to Chigurh’s social reputation, and Wells’ mockery only exposes him as a false “hero” that has not encountered true danger in the span of his career. It seems that other characters are also under the impression that Wells has lived a false life, and one instance of this can be seen from a second conversation between Wells and his employer, where the employer asks him a tantalizing question: “You’ve lived a pretty charmed life, haven’t you Mr. Wells?” The imagery of one living a charmed life goes against the image that Wells has established for himself as the ragged hero that puts his life on the line for the wellbeing of others, and further exposes him as laughingstock. When Wells eventually meets Chigurh at the aftermath of a shootout, Chigurh greets him cordially, then proceeds to psychologically beat him, tearing into his motivation with one crude question: “If the rule you followed led you to this, of what use was the rule?”. This rhetorical question connotes that Wells has not done anything of meaning, as his efforts have led to a society that is still plagued by a force like Chigurh, and his efforts have led him to face his own untimely death. Chigurh’s subsequent killing of Wells makes readers question the essence of heroism, what it entails, and whether modern depictions of altruism and heroism are done with ulterior motives. False altruism in Perfume can be seen from the character of the Marquis, a self-proclaimed scientist that has claimed to have found the secret to eternal life. He marks himself as a literary emblem for rapid scientific advancement, and the idea of rapid social climbing, and the desire for ascension through the social hierarchy. This can be seen from the Marquis’ introduction, where Susskind lays out his theories such as “fluidum vitale” and “white talcum” that are created for the sake of impressing others. This paints an image in the readers’ mind of the Marquis being quite like a forlorn child trying to gain favor of the parents’ by constructing lies. This aspect of the Marquis’ character is further exposed when he encounters Grenouille following his 7 years of self-imposed isolation. Bearing a ragged physical appearance, the Marquis latches onto the opportunity to diagnose Grenouille and exploit his circumstance to leverage his own way into the field of scientific glory: “One could see the pustules and scars caused by the red corrosive gas. There on his breast lay a giant cancer showing general deformation of the skin; there was clear evidence of fluidal deformation of the skin.” The grotesque imagery underlies Susskind’s ironic satire of the Marquis and ambitious scientific thinkers like him, as the Marquis is effectively diagnosing nothing. Had he actually had a scientific mind, he would have noticed that Grenouille simply looks sick, but is not actually suffering from any ailment. Later in the novel, after “treating” Grenouille and becoming popular as a result, his ambition reaches its zenith when he decides to venture to the top of the mountain peaks during the cold winter season in pursuit of eternal life, and unsurprisingly he dies. “Soon rumours were abroad that there on the mountain peaks the Marquis had wedded himself with the fluidum vitale, merging with it and it with him.” This quote parodies the concept of mythic ascension, and not only does the Marquis’ death eliminate this virtue of scientific advancement and altruism forever, but it also makes readers question the true value of scientific ambition and the dangers of it. Near the end of both novels, both antagonists encounter characters that actively challenge the status quo; that is, they challenge their status and power, which hitherto that point was unprecedented. These characters are special, because although they still represent flawed ideas, their act of challenging the opposition further denounces the ideas, and further highlights the power of the antagonists in questioning these ideas. In No Country for Old Men, this can be seen from the challenge of Carla Jean Moss, the wife of Llewelyn Moss, emblematic of the “good woman” trope seen in old America. To tie up loose ends, Chigurh decides to kill Carla Jean to ensure his anonymity, and when he arrives the Moss house, he challenges Carla Jean to a coin toss, similar to that of the proprietor. Unfortunately, Carla Jean loses, and this is when she challenges Chigurh’s nihilistic philosophy by saying: “The coin don’t have no say. It was just you.” This blatant vernacular diction, and the use of antithesis sets the inert coin against the agential “you” figure, effectively pinning the blame on Chigurh. Nevertheless, Chigurh’s killing of Carla Jean soon after proving that concepts such as love and choice are worthless in a world where modernity and practicality beat superficial rules. In Perfume, one challenges authority by deciphering the true nature of Grenouille. The only character that comes remotely close to doing this is Antoine Richis, the father of Laure Richis, the final ingredient for Grenouille’s master perfume that allows him to successfully integrate himself into society. Richis seems to possess some supernatural awareness of Grenouille’s doings, and he is the first to decipher that Grenouille is an atypical serial killer: “It seems, as absurd as it seemed to be, that the murderer was not a psychopathic killer, but rather a careful collector.” The use juxtaposition here creates a paradoxical concept of a killer being someone other than sadistic but calculating. It also gives credit to Richis’ cognitive abilities as he acts as an emblem for Enlightenment logic. Next, Richis proceeds to challenge Grenouille’s supernatural sense of smell, in a foolish attempt to visually mislead him to another destination to get him away from Laure: “The path was an arduous one, but it allowed them to circumvent Grasse in a giant arc and allowed them to land on the coast without being recognized.” The logical syntax in this sentence highlights Richis’ tendency to use logic, even in desperate situations such as the predicament that he is in. However, the fact that Richis, like Baldini, ignores intuition as a vessel for action, makes all his efforts amount to nil, as Grenouille finds them again in an instant: “In a city of olfactory activity, the city of a thousand threads, the golden thread was missing.” The metaphor of the golden thread highlights Grenouille’s acute perception and gets readers to question the true ability of intuition as a vessel for action. In conclusion, both No Country for Old Men and Perfume get readers to question fundamental ideas and archetypes of their respective literary societies, and this is done by introducing antagonists that are radically different from the secondary characters, and having the former eliminate the latter, demonstrating the authorial intent of satirisation or lamentation. Near the beginning of the novel, the idea of self reliance is destroyed when Chigurh encounters the proprietor, a man that cannot make choices for himself, and when Grenouille encounters Baldini, a perfumer that steals other people’s formulae for himself. Both Chigurh and Grenouille also encounter characters that embody the virtue of false altruism, and this can be seen when Chigurh’s interactions and subsequent killing of Wells, and Grenouille’s unintentional “curing” by the Marquis. Finally, the villains finally encounter characters that challenge their authority, with Chigurh meeting Carla Jean, a woman who exposes his nihilistic philosophy to just be a mask for social delusion, and Richis that is the first external character that uncovers Grenouille’s motive. However, both of these characters fail to acknowledge that the power of practicality and genius overpower the need for rules and systematic workings. Overall, the dismantling of these ideas have gotten readers to question them, and question the meaning of the characters they read.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )