Chapter 18 BJU Text The Progressive Era (1900-1920) Tragedy and the Passing of the Guard September 6, 1901 was just another public reception for the president, this time at the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, New York. Then from a line of well wishers, an assailant shot William McKinley twice. He died eight days later. The conservative, quiet president who took the pro-business Republican line was replaced by the brash, energetic political President Theodore Roosevelt progressive man who favored governmental action to curb abuses and secure justice for all Americans, Theodore Roosevelt. Progressivism is defined as an ideology that favors political and social reform through education. It calls for a wider political participation from all classes of society. The direct action of government to regulate and enforce the laws on the books is stressed. Progressivism had its origins The Roots and Principles of Progressivism in Populism, in the pro-reform wings of the Republican party, the Halfbreeds and the “Mugwumps”. Many progressives were just concerned Americans tired of corruption and the unchecked business dominance of society. Many like Lester Frank Ward believed that true progress was a process of the natural order that could be aided by government intervention – reform Darwinism. Christians held to Biblical principles and saw reform as “opportunity … [to] do good unto all men” (Gal. 6:10). Three progressive tactics Direct Democracy included : the promotion of direct democracy, increasing the efficiency of government, advocating government intervention. “The cure for the ills of democracy was more democracy.” (historian George Brown Tindall) With an inherent belief in the goodness of man, progressives held that placing more power in the hands of the people would result in better government. William Jennings Bryan Direct Democracy always campaigned for the people having more control over government. There were several reformist tools advocated by the progressives. One was the secret ballot for elections. Before this was introduced, voters had to request a specific ballot for the candidate of their choice or sign under the candidate’s name posing the threat of intimidation for the vote they cast. Direct primaries were a method to nominate party The Initiative, Referendum, Recall by popular vote and take the process from the party bosses in conventions, caucuses, and back rooms. The initiative is the voters presenting petitions to legislators requiring some action. This process allows the people to initiate legislation. A referendum allows voters to vote yes or no in a regular election to determine if a law is to be passed or rejected. The recall is where voters petition to call a special election to remove an official from office. Recalls can also be used to reverse specific legislation and even judicial decisions. The national government only accepted the secret ballot, but many municipal and state governments use these progressive instruments. Government Efficiency/Intervention • Progressives believed that putting educated qualified experts in government would lead to improvements in governance and society. Many cities replaced old mayoral/city council forms to adopt city commissions. The old functions were replaced by five or more city commissioners. (e.g. Galveston, TX.) Another popular municipal reform device was the city manager. City councils would hire a qualified city manager to run the city administration. Government Intervenes • Most progressives were united in direct action to stem the power of the “trusts” and large monopolies. There were differences in which direct government actions would work. Some progressives urged “trust-busting” or breaking up the trusts and restoring competition to the marketplace. Others favored leaving the trusts alone but placing more stringent regulations on them. The Socialists and Other Progressives • For many progressives, government ownership of businesses was the answer. The most extreme position was taken by the socialists who advocated government ownership of all business. Most wanted limited government ownership and control such as “gas and water socialism” which gave governments control of necessary utilities and their prices. (usually state and local governments) using the argument that a monopoly was the efficient way to operate a utility, and the safest monopoly is operated by the government. Progressives began to argue for laws allowing labor Progressive Actions to organize and to force business to negotiate fairly with unions. This, in theory would make labor a check to the power of big business. Direct laws were sponsored that would set minimum wage levels, prohibition of child labor, the number of hours in a work day, and basic minimum safety standards in the factories. After government had grown, Americans realized that it could become the ultimate monopoly. The “Progressive” Constitution • Four progressive measures found their way into the U.S. Constitution. • 16th Amendment (1913) – the federal income tax. Provided the government with revenue to initiate reforms and provide the social services Americans wanted. It was a graduated tax which taxes higher incomes at a higher percentage. • 17th Amendment (1913) – Established the direct election of senators. It took the selection away from state legislatures The “Progressive” Constitution • 17th Amendment – This was intended to remove corruption but it replaced true republicanism with a more direct democracy contrary to the ideas and safeguards of the Founding Fathers. • 18th Amendment (1919) – Prohibition banning the manufacture, sale, and transportation of alcoholic beverages. (ultimately repealed by the 21st Amendment (1933). The “Progressive” Constitution • 19th Amendment (1920) – Women’s suffrage. In a movement that was almost as old as the abolition movement, the prize was finally attained with the vote for women. This was an integral part of a crusade for women’s rights led by pioneers such as Lucretia Mott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and Susan B. Anthony. Prohibition’s Social Aims • Alcoholism had been a persistent social problem throughout American history. Social workers were witnessing alcohol abuse contributing to child neglect, hungry families, and to crime. Christian leaders joined progressives in temperance then prohibition. Billy Sunday, the noted evangelist, railed against the iniquitous liquor business. Businessmen saw productivity loss due to lost man hours and alcohol. Shortages of grain leading to WW I made its use for distilleries seem wasteful. “Muckrakers” • Roosevelt named the literary leaders of the progressive movement, “muckrakers” after the man in John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. These social critics and writers from books, magazines, and newspapers were out to expose corruption and abuses in American society. Lincoln Steffen’s 1902 series of exposes in McClure’s magazine that later became Shame of the Cities. The History of the Standard Oil Company (1904) by Ida Tarbell was a scathing portrait of a ruthless John D. Rockefeller. Political Progressives • William Jennings Bryan turned from populism to a new progressive wing of the Democratic party. Republican progressive, Robert La Follette turned his native Wisconsin into what Roosevelt called the “laboratory of democracy”. The extreme wing of the progressivism was the socialists who called for all government ownership of the means of production. Eugene Debs, former head of the American Railway Union ran for president five times. President Theodore Roosevelt • One of the most aristocratic presidents since John Adams, and one of the most intelligent since Jefferson, T.R. (Roosevelt) used life adventures and experience to shed his upper-class origins to appeal to the common American as a Republican progressive. T.R. embodied progressivism. With many stints from the New York legislature, a U.S. Civil Service, and New York City police commissioner, Roosevelt had built a reputation for progressive action. The T. Roosevelt Administration • With a zealous approach to governing, T.R. took the lead instead of deferring to Congress. By persuasion, intimidation, and blunt force of his personality, he set forth his “Square Deal”. This program sought fair treatment and opportunity for every American man and woman. T.R. set after his trust-busting by reviving the Sherman Antitrust Act. The government charged the Northern Securities Company and filed a lawsuit to break it up. Northern Securities (which owned the Great Northern and Northern Pacific railroads) fought it all the way to the Supreme Court where the government won the Northern Securities case. Regulatory Activity of the T.R. Administration High railroad rates led to the Hepburn Act (1906) which strengthened the Interstate Commerce Commission’s (ICC) ability to set rates and mandate standard bookkeeping which enabled consumers and clients to compare rates. Many railroads followed the law and its orders rather than protracted litigation. T.R. next spearheaded regulation with the Regulatory Activity of the T.R. Administration Pure Food and Drug Act (1906) which forbade the interstate sale of impure food and drugs and honest and accurate labeling of such products. The Meat Inspection Act (1906) required the Department of Agriculture to oversee the preparation and packaging of meat as well as monitoring the health of animals prior to slaughter. Passage of these two acts was greatly aided by the public uproar initiated by Jungle (1906) by Upton Sinclair. Strikes and the “Square Deal” • T.R.’s pledge to be fair to both labor and business was sorely tested by the coal miner’s strike of 1902. Coal was crucial for steam-operated transportation as well as heating in the U.S. Winter was drawing near and T.R. had to find a way to break the stalemate and ordered leaders from both sides to convene at the White House. When business declined, Roosevelt threatened to use federal troops to operate the mines. For the first time, government had backed labor. Conservation, T.R.’s Passion mine owners reluctantly agreed to a 10% pay raise and a nine hour work day for the coal miners. T.R. had triumphed politically over big business once again and won popular support for his actions. Conservation of natural resources and preservation of wild places led Roosevelt to urge passing of the Reclamation Act (1902). The law set aside over 100 million acres of western land to be controlled by the federal government and many more million acres of national forest. Conservation, T.R.’s Passion Progressivism and Its Failures • Race relations and the continuing injustice of unenforced civil rights was a blight on the progressive ledger. Asian students were segregated in a school in San Francisco in 1906 causing the Japanese government to lodge a formal complaint. T.R. got the school board to reverse the decision on the Japanese pledge of voluntary U.S. immigration of its nationals. Progressivism and Its Failures • Redeemer governments in the South gave token political vote and voice to blacks after Reconstruction, mainly trying to lure their votes into the Democratic party. The 1890s saw the onerous “Jim Crow Laws” (Jim Crow was a popular black character in a 19th century minstrel song) forcing segregation and separation of the races in all public places and social settings. Literacy tests for voting and the infamous “poll tax” caused black voting to plummet ( La. 1896 -130,000 ; 1904 – 1,300 black voters) Submission to “Jim Crow” • How did this failure come about? 1. Reform “redeemers” succumbing to radical racist politicians. 2. Populism alienated white powerful political support within the Democratic party. 3. the national government lost interest for black civil rights and the Supreme Court gutted Reconstruction gains by cases such as Plessey v. Ferguson which decreed “separate but equal” constitutional. Black Reaction to “Jim Crow” • Booker T. Washington’s Up From Slavery told of his rise from slave to the president of the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. Washington favored education and economic ascendency to lead to political power instead of the risk of confrontation by open political agitation. • W.E.B. Du Bois and his National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) (1909) disagreed with Washington. They advocated full citizenship first before any true chance for equal educational and economic opportunities could exist. The NAACP promoted all education, not just technical and industrial education be pursued by blacks to avoid be second class laborers. “Teddy” and His “Big Stick” If the “square deal” wasn’t realized for other races in Roosevelt domestic policy, progressivism fell to imperialism in foreign policy. “Speak softly and carry a big stick; you will go far” was a favorite saying for T.R. and he pursued an expansive U.S. presence in international affairs. He rationalized his imperialism by likening it to a crusade to spread American power to be “a victory for law, order and righteousness”. Philippines and the Panama Canal • Even after the surrender of Emilio Aquinaldo, and the initial suppression of the Filipino insurrection, the people of the Philippines resisted American rule. T.R.’s friend and adviser, the governor of the islands, William Howard Taft gradually ceded Filipino control just short of complete independence. Fearing Japan’s imperial designs, the U.S. finally gave independence to the Philippines in 1946 after WW II. Columbia and T.R.’s Panama Dream • T.R. had a vision to complete the failed private French plan to connect the Atlantic and the Pacific. Philippe BunauVarilla sold the French rights to the canal for $40 million and Congress authorized the purchase. A treaty was negotiated with Columbia to pay $10 million with annual payments of $250,000 and passed by the Senate. Columbia rejected the deal seeking more money. Columbia and T.R.’s Panama Dream • T.R. lambasted the Columbians for attempting “blackmail” and listened to Bunau-Varilla advice to back a Panamanian rebels in the revolt for independence while T.R. blocked any Columbian troops from entering Panama to suppress the rebellion. Three days after Panama’s independence, the U.S. recognized the new nation. Bunau-Varilla and Sec. of State John Hay negotiated the same deal for the canal zone. Critics and Success • International critics decried the “Colossus of the North” especially other Latin American countries. After ten years of incredible challenges met over engineering from disease, the canal was a $400 million dollar success was open in time for WW I’s outbreak. • The Roosevelt Corollary put the police power of the U.S. behind the Monroe Doctrine in 1904 to stave off European intervention in the Western Hemisphere. Actions in Haiti, Honduras, Nicaragua, and the Dominican Republic tested the “Corollary” in future years. • U.s. battleships Prestige as a Peace Broker • Roosevelt brokered the Treaty of Portsmouth, 1905 between Russia and Japan who were at war over Manchuria. Roosevelt won the Nobel Peace Prize for his sponsorship, but the treaty soured relations between the U.S. and the two signing nations. • The “Great White Fleet” was enthusiastically welcomed by the Japanese in its circumnavigation of the world. The Root-Takahira Agreement between the U.S. and Japan engendered mutual respect for Pacific holdings and reaffirmed the “Open Door” in China. • Roosevelt Nobel • Great White Fleet The Taft Administration • Roosevelt blundered at an open political event pledging to honor the Washingtonian two-term traditional stay in the presidency. He did have the power even as lame duck to name his handpicked successor, William Howard Taft. Taft easily defeated William Jennings Bryan in 1908. His legal mind and reserved cautious attitude led him to battle with the progressives in the Republican party which ultimately resulted in a split between him and Roosevelt. Taft’s Mistake and “Uncle Joe” Cannon • Taft was criticized by progressives for not vetoing a pro-business watered-down low-rate tariff by the Senate. He then was not active enough in trimming the committee power of dictatorial Speaker of the House, Joseph “Uncle Joe” Cannon. Taft had a public feud over conservation and opening federal lands with Roosevelt’s close friend, Gifford Pinchot, the head of the U.S. Forest Service. A deal with U.S. Steel that T.R. had approved was openly prosecuted as anti-trust by Taft angering T.R. Taft’s “Dollar Diplomacy” • Instead of military posturing, Taft preferred U.S. investment in foreign nations to extend American influence. The investments still put the U.S. military in harm’s way to protect American assets abroad, and gained mixed results for Taft’s policy strategy. The Election of 1912 • T.R. tried for the Republican nomination in 1912, won all the primary states, but Taft held control of all of the others and won the nomination. Roosevelt formed the third party, the Progressive party (“Bull Moose”) running on a platform of the “New Nationalism”. The democrats had their own progressive, Governor of New Jersey, Woodrow Wilson. A historian, and ex-president of Princeton University, was a zealous progressive with a solid list of accomplishments with his “New Freedom” plan for the country. The Election of 1912 Wilson and the “New Freedom” • Wilson’s 1st term in office was the culmination of the progressive movement. Three of the four “Progressive” Amendments were ratified during Wilson’s stay in the White House. The Underwood Tariff Act 1913 was the 1st major reform and lowering of the tariff (by a third) since the Civil War. The income tax made up for the loss of government revenue (1% on incomes > $3000. $4000. for married couples, rising to 6% for incomes over $500,000). Federal Reserve Act (1913) • Business had long yearned for a Bank of the United States to regulate currency and shore up banking practices. Wilson and the progressives came up with the Federal Reserve Act dividing up the nation into twelve districts with its own regional reserve bank. The Federal Reserve Board oversaw the operation of the system with Federal Reserve Notes as new currency. Business and Labor Reform • Labor’s “Magna Carta” (Samuel Gompers), the Clayton Antitrust Act (1914) beefed up the Sherman Antitrust Act by adding more prohibitions on corporations such as legalized strikes, picketing, and boycotts along with an antitrust exemption for labor unions. The Federal Trade Commission Act (1914) put five commissioners in place to define and stop unfair business practices. Much of the enforcement was taken out of Congress and the courts. Government was becoming the solution to society’s problems. Transportation Transformation • Two inventions highlighted the progressive era- the heavier-than-air fixed wing airplane, and the internal combustionpowered automobile. These transportation marvels afforded speed, power, and flexibility to travel. The automobile allowed a mobility to the average American that was unheard of in the past. Transportation Transformation • The 1st functional automobiles were crafted by Germans, Gottfried Daimler and Otto Benz. Henry Ford’s 1896 “horseless carriage” had a mechanical simplicity and dependability that allowed investors to help Ford start the Ford Motor Company in 1903. The 1908 Model T was a marvel of industrial assembly line manufacturing using standard interchangeable parts. Efficiency allowed a car that was affordable to the masses. Ford’s Model T and Some Noteworthy Bicycle Makers • The price of the Model T dropped from $800. in 1908 to $260. by 1925. By the 1920s, half of all vehicles on American roads were Model T’s. • Orville and Wilbur Wright, two bicycle designers and entrepreneurs from Dayton, Ohio, always had aeronautical dreams. Working with bicycle profits and the theoretical work on air foils of German, Otto Lilienthal, they perfected and engineered a heavier-than- air plane that was an outgrowth of experimental kites and gliders. The Wright Flyer At Kitty Hawk • On wind-swept dunes in North Carolina, aviation history was made on December 17, 1903 with a 12 second 120 foot powered and sustained flight under control. The ultimate speed machine was under development. The “Golden Age” of American Agriculture • The development of the tractor provided more power and speed to sow, cultivate, and harvest crops. There was a market in the populated cities for all of the agricultural output. Improvements in hygiene and veterinary science led to healthier and more numerous salable livestock. Improvements in transportation made it efficient to get products to market. Medicine in the Progressive Era • The Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota (1901) developed private group medicine a center for research and practice that involved a team of doctors. In 1893, the Johns Hopkins Medical School was opened in Baltimore “embodying the best features of medical education from France, England, and Germany. The battle won over the pathogen yellow fever was impressive in Cuba and the Panama canal zone. Army doctors such as Walter Reed using the research of Carlos Juan Finlay to prevent mosquito transmission of the disease. Progressive Education Leads to Secular Humanism • Progressives stressed that they were teaching students not subjects. Education should be based on experience rather than simple memorization. Vocational education became a component of American education. Links to actual understanding as the core of learning were stressed. Secular humanism was an outgrowth of progressive education. John Dewey • Dewey not only spearheaded educational theory and reform, but secular humanism as well. The denial of the existence of God and the notion that man can be perfect replaces absolute truths with relative, conditional, pragmatic standards based on human experience. “Progressive Religion” • The theological movement that tried to reconcile Darwinism and historical proofs to the Bible was called modernism. It viewed scripture not as God’s revealed word, but a collection of theological ideas within Jewish and Christian traditions. It sought to take the supernatural out of the Bible. With origins in colleges and seminaries, modernism found its way into churches. • Another progressive movement was the social gospel. Applying the primacy of social reform to religion at the expense of “regeneration” of the individual through salvation, many modernists fell away from orthodox Christianity. Walter Rauschenbusch, Baptist minister was a leader of the social gospel movement. “Orthodoxy” Answers Challenges • The Princeton Theological Seminary was a hotbed of Christian apology especially Benjamin Warfield, a professor there. Warfield was a staunch defender of the faith and the perfection of Holy Scripture. D.L. Moody’s Bible Institutes and conferences were arenas for scholarship and defense of Christian orthodoxy. William “Billy” Sunday • Urban revivals energized the church in the Moody tradition carried on by the leading evangelist, “Billy” Sunday. Sunday, an ex-professional baseball player “hit the sawdust trail” and preached in Tabernacles constructed for the revival tour. Energetic preaching climaxed in a 1917 New York City revival . (1.5 million in 10 weeks) William “Billy” Sunday • Sunday was so effective in his popular evangelism that the press criticized and persecuted him openly.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )