Workgroup 1: Organizational structure & design
Mechanic Organization:
- Stable environment
- Highly specialized jobs
- Centralized jobs
- Centralized authority
- Narrow span of control (Tall hierarchy)
Organic organization:
- Unpredictable environment
- De-specialized jobs, high professional autonomy
- Decentralization
- Wide span of control (flat hierarchy)
→ Organisational redesign is possible without increasing resources
→ Different design parameters affect each other
Memory:
VERTICAL DIFFERENTIATION = The number of authority levels in an organization. The
more authority levels an organization has, the more complex the organization.
FUNCTIONAL STRUCTURE = A structure in which an organization is separated into
divisions based on necessary organizational functions (incl. production, marketing, finance,
human resources.
NARROW SPAN OF CONTROL = Organistations that are very hierarchical and have a
‘steep organisational pyramid’.
MATRIX ORGANIZATION = An organizational design that superimposes a product design
on an existing function-based design.
FLAT ORGANIZATION = An organisation that has relatively few managerial layers.
Employees mostly govern their own work
(HIGH) AUTONOMY = Organisations in which employees govern their own work and can
make decisions without needing approval.
PRODUCT/SERVICE LINE ORGANIZATION = A structure in which an organization is
separated into divisions that each control their own resources: jobs (skills/specialties) are
grouped on the basis of a product or service.
DECENTRALISATION = An organization in which decision-making power is dispersed
throughout layers of the organization. Employees can make decisions quite autonomously.
HORIZONTAL DIFFERENTATION = The number of different units existing at the same level
in an organization. The greater the horizontal differentiation, the more complex the
organization is.
CENTRALISATION = A dimension of organizational structure that refers to the extent to
which authority to make decisions is retained in top management.
----
Workgroup 2: Root cause analysis
Recap:
Organisational structure:
There is no universally best organizational design or structure
● Depends on environment, work/task, technology, strategy
● Must fit organizational strategy and contribute to performance
● Can vary between departments(e.g., R&D, Sales, Cleaning services etc.)
● It involves balancing opposing forces, needs and goals
→ The reason why we should act (X)
→ The things we actually need to tackle/change (Y)
Organisational learning
- Tackling symptoms(also referred to as ‘single-loop learning’ or ‘first-order learning’)
- In order to learn and effectively tackle issues, you sometimes need to:
- Delve deeper to the organisational causes
Leadership
Structure/design
Styles of communication
Culture
….
→ ROOT-CAUSE ANALYSIS
Example of a root cause analysis (RCA) regarding deforestation
- You start with the problem
- Ask yourself ‘WHY’ and continue your line of argumentation to reach the more
underlying causes
- One could have multiple causes
- The symptoms are on the top (what you actually see)
- Where can you intervene to target the problem?
Some final notes on root-cause analysis (RCA)
→ An RCA is a helpful tool to understand at what point interventions should be targeted:
● If interventions are directed at the top level, they often address only symptomatic
barriers and thus achieve little effect
● If interventions are directed at the bottom level, they may be difficult to implement,
since they tackle fundamental problems embedded in institutions, systems and
values
● If interventions address a cause for multiple symptomatic challenges, they can
solve several challenges at once, potentially generating fast results.
Workgroup 3: Transdisciplinarity in COM
Multi-level perspective
Learning objectives
1. Identify the elements of the multi-level perspective: landscape, regime, niche
innovations
2. Identify the elements of the constellation/regime of St. Athenius and the
constellation/regime in which it operates
3. Learn about the paradox between the need for organizational change(to respond to
changing needs within the system) and the difficulty of changing an organization
caused by the system in which it operates
Culture (thinking): a set of values, norms, and
perceptions that are shared by most of the
actors involved, influencing the behaviour of
actors in practice.
Structure (organising): how the system is
organised in terms of the physical structures
and resources, regulations and legal rights, and
other material elements or aspects structuring
the behaviour of actors in practices.
Practice (doing) : actors’ routines and actions
in their context, which is influenced or inhibited
by the structure and culture.
Actors
-1. Identify the culture: a set of values, norms,
and perceptions that are shared by most of the
actors involved, influencing the behaviour of
actors in practice.
2. Identify the structure: how the system is
organised in terms of the physical structures and resources, regulations and legal rights, and
other material elements or aspects structuring the behaviour of actors in practices.
3. Identify the practice: actors’ routines and actions in their context, which is influenced or
inhibited by the structure and culture.
4. Identify the actors: who is involved/affected by the constellation?
Incumbency →
Workgroup 4: Motivation & (Inter)personal skills development
Four tendencies →
COOPERATION
Upholders → motivated by both structure
and self-direction
Questioners → motivated by understanding
and logic
Obligers → motivated by outer accountability
Rebels → motivated by autonomy and
identity
Understanding these motivations helps avoid
misunderstandings like:
● Thinking a Questioner’s questions
mean resistance
● Interpreting a Rebel’s autonomy as
defiance
● Assuming an Obliger will “speak up”
when overwhelmed (they won’t)
COMMUNICATION
Upholder: “Here’s what’s expected and when.”
Questioner: “Here’s why this matters and the reasoning behind it.”
Obliger: “We’re counting on you, and here’s the structure/support.”
Rebel: “You can do this in your own way; here are your options.”
UNDERSTANDING CONFLICT
● Upholders/Rebels clash over structure vs freedom
● Questioners/Upholders disagree over “why” vs “just follow the plan”
● Obligers may quietly take on too much until burned out
● Rebels may resist processes meant to help others stay consistent
Motivational theories:
Hierarchy of Needs →
ERG Theory:
Dual-Factor Theory:
Theory X Theory Y:
→ Avoidance behaviour vs. Approach behaviour?
→ Role of the manager/communication style?
MccLelland Learned motives/needs →
Expectancy Theory:
Workgroup 5: Conflict & deliberative democracy
Learning objectives:
● To understand the value of deliberative democracy:
○ To gain insights in and being open to different perspectives
○ To understand the value of a broadly supported decision
● To understand the value of including citizens/patients in decision-making
● To appreciate the value of experiential knowledge (knowledge other than scientific
knowledge
What is deliberative democracy?
→ A model of democracy that emphasizes discussion, reflection, and reason-giving as
the basis for legitimate political decisions.
● Placing people closer to affairs of decision-makers
● Alternative approach to ‘ask people what they think’
● Seeks to elicit informed, quality and meaningful outputs
● Groups of participants considering facts from multiple points of view & enlarging
their perspectives
Examples: citizens’ juries, deliberative forums & citizens’ assemblies
Key principles of deliberative democracy:
● Presence of clear remit (with dilemma)
● Participants have access to relevant and neutral information in order to have
in-depth conversation
● Participants are representative
● Participants are given time to deliberate
● Participants have influence over decisions
● Participants start with ‘blank page’ report
Key points of deliberative democracy:
Via mutual learning…
● Unravel and understand the complexity of a dilemma
● Appreciate ‘lay-perspectives’
● Achieve output that is well- considered/substantiated from multiple perspectives and
understood
● Make justifiable decisions for society in the face of (fundamental) disagreements
● Increase trust in government/policy
→ not per se consensus (agreement on non-agreement)
Why do we learn about deliberative democracy?
Requirements for taking good decisions
● Involvement of those who are affected by the decisions taken, including patients and
their relatives
● Openness towards each others' perspectives
● Mutual learning
● Safe and neutral environment
Many different ways…
→ Deliberative democracy
Workgroup 6: Management & Leadership
Learning goals:
● To understand the chronological development of perspectives on leadership
● To recognize different leadership styles
● The student understands the pros and cons of different leadership styles
● The student can argue when specific leadership styles are/aren't effective
● The student can apply the situational leadership model
Perspectives on leadership
1. Trait
2. Style (Kopapske, et al., -> ‘leader behavior’)
3. Skills
4. Transformational or transactional
5. Situational leadership
1. Traits
→ Built on notion of ‘Inborn Traits’ that cannot be taught in a formal way
● Energy,
● Appearance
● Confidence
● Intelligence
● Integrity
● Personality traits (aggressiveness, enthusiasm)
2. Style
→‘How do leaders behave in order to influence subordinates in their effort to reach a goal
(Lewin, 1930)
X as: Task-oriented behaviour
(initiating structure)
● Goal accomplishment and
help group members to
achieve their objective
Y as: Relationship-oriented
behaviour (showing
consideration)
● Building friendship, mutual
trust, respect
3. Skills
→ ‘The knowledge and abilities that the leader has”(Katz, 1955)
Technical Skills - ‘The ability to work with things’
● Proficiency based on specific knowledge, in a particular area of work
Human Skills - ‘The ability to work with people’
● Being aware of one's own perspective as well as the openness to hear and
appreciate inputs of others and incorporate those to achieve organizational goals
Conceptual Skills - ‘The ability to work with ideas and concepts’
● Creating visions, strategic plans and setting direction
4. Transactional / Transformational
Transactional - ‘Keep things the way they are’
● Status quo
● Maintaining routine by managing individual performance and facilitating group
performance (rewards and penalties)
● Get things done through people: get employees to do what the leader wants in order
to achieve organizational goals
● Problem solver (more short term focus) and implementer
Transformational - ‘’ I have a dream’ (vision)
● They create a vision to define better future directions (e.g. revitalize an organization
in an enduring crisis).
● Mobilize commitment
● They institutionalize change: system-wide shifts in problem-solving and
decision-making
5. Situational leadership style
→ “There is no best leadership style: successful leaders adapt their style to fit the
requirements of the situation” (Hersey & Blanchard, 1969).
→ Performance readiness of the employee:
1. Competencies (task readiness)
Unable - employee lacks skills/knowledge to perform task
Able - employee has sufficient skills/knowledge to perform task
2. Commitment (psychological readiness)
Unwilling - employee lacks self-confidence to perform task
Willing - employee is motivated to attempt/perform the task
How leader acts based on commitment and competencies of employees
● D1: Enthusiastic beginner
→ employee is unable but willing
● D2: Disillusioned learner
→ employee is unable and unwilling
● D3: Capable but cautious performer
→ employee is able but unwilling
● D4: The self-reliant achiever
→ employee is able and willing
Directing - the leader defines the role needed to do
the job and tells followers what, where, and when to
do tasks
Coaching - the leader provides followers with
structured instructions, but is also supportive
Supporting - the leader and followers share in
decisions about how best to complete a high-quality
job
Delegating - the leader provides little specific, close
direction or personal support to followers
Contingency
→ Leadership effectiveness depends on the
interaction between a leader’s style and a specific
situation or context
→ The optimal approach varies depending on the circumstances
Development of leadership models
Trait → Behavioral (skills/style) → Contingency (situational)
Recap:
● Ideas on leadership have developed over time. While newer perspectives might
seem to provide more insight, older perspectives are still relevant.
● There are different leadership models to represent different leadership styles, which
is best depends on other factors such as: structure/culture of the organization but
also employee readiness (commitment and competencies), etc.
● Relevant for the exam and assignment: you should be able to substantiate why a
certain model is more applicable in specific situations.
Workgroup 7: Feedback draft report