Bioethics Case Studies
Direct-to-consumer Tests in College: Case Example
• “Bring your genes to Cal” was launched as a common
educational experience for incoming freshmen at UC
Berkeley.
• Freshmen received testing kits and were invited to
voluntarily submit DNA samples for testing of genes
involved in folate metabolism, lactose tolerance, and
alcohol metabolism.
• The testing was to be offered without genetic
counseling.
• After a state Public Health ruling, the University has
decided to proceed with the testing but not provide
students with their individual results.
Atlas Sports Genetics: Case Example
• Atlas Sports Genetics offered direct-to-consumer genetic
tests for the ACTN3 actin gene
• The test cost $169 and includes analysis of a single
genotype plus advice on which sports the individual is best
suited for genetically:
• 2 copies of variant R577X → endurance events
• 1 copy of variant R577X → endurance or sprint/power
events
• 0 copies of variant R577X → sprint/power events
• 25% of elite (Olympic level) endurance athletes had 2
copies of the X variant; 50% of elite sprinters had 2 copies
of the R variant
Nash Family: Case Example
• Molly Nash was a six-year old with Fanconi anemia (an
inherited anemia that leads to bone marrow failure)
• Bone marrow transplant from a matched sibling can cure
85% of these cases
• Molly did not have a sibling, so her parents decided to have
a second child who underwent preimplantation genetic
diagnosis to ensure his health
• Baby Adam donated stem cells from his umbilical cord and
placenta to his sister.
• The transplant cured Molly’s bone marrow failure, but she
is still at risk for life-threatening complications from
infections and for solid tumor cancers.
Newborn Sequencing: Case Example
• The BabySeq project aims to sequence the exomes of
healthy and very sick infants and follow their medical
outcomes.
• In the process, early findings have included:
• Identification of carrier status for recessive disorders
• Pharmacogenetic variants
• Mutations associated with heart conditions
• BRCA2 cancer-predisposing mutation
• Notably, the BRCA status was disclosed to the family,
even though adult-onset conditions were initially to be
excluded from this.