1
Aaron Zhu
Proffesor Schendan
Political Thought and Theory
05 July 2025
Reflection: How Society Corrupts My Soul
Societal values have corrupted my soul by encouraging me to prioritize earthly goals like
wealth and reputation rather than living a good, honest, and just life.
In The Apology written by Plato, a faithful follower of Socrates, Socrates is put on trial
for not believing in the gods and corrupting the youth by Meletus, his accuser. (Plato, Apology
(Grube), pg. 28, Line 24b). In his defense, he discusses how people dislike him because he
questions whether they lead good lives. He says, “are you not ashamed of your eagerness to
possess as much wealth, reputation, and honors as possible, while you do not care for nor give
thought to wisdom or truth, or the best possible state of your soul?” Plato, Apology (Grube), pg.
34, Line 29e. Socrates is calling out Athenians for their “eagerness to possess as much wealth,
reputation, and honors” while “not car[ing] for nor giv[ing] thought to wisdom or truth”. In the
same way, I also care more about living an easy, popular life rather than living a life with
wisdom or truth. Societal values have encouraged me to seek popularity or “possess …
reputation” rather than to live a just life. Despite his honest speech and defense, the jury finds
him guilty. Meletus, his accuser, asks for the death penalty, but Socrates can also suggest a
penalty for himself((Plato, Apology (Grube), pg. 39, Line 35e). Instead of pleading for mercy, he
reaffirms his stance and beliefs. He says he has done nothing wrong((Plato, Apology (Grube),
2
pg. 40, Line 37a-b). He says, “if I say that it is the greatest good for a man to discuss virtue every
day and those other things about which you hear me conversing and testing myself and others,
for the unexamined life is not worth living for men, you will believe me even less.” Plato,
Apology (Grube), pg. 41, Line 38a. According to Socrates, one way to start living a more just
life is by discussing virtue. Societal values like living a carefree life discourage us from talking
about serious topics like mental health or morality. However, there are many opportunities to
start learning about virtue. As a Catholic, I believe I can learn virtue by reading the Bible.
Furthermore, I believe studying philosophy and political theory is also virtuous because I’m
learning ideas like liberty.
Furthermore, society has encouraged me to do wrong when I have been wronged and to
be worried about others’ opinions of me.
In Crito by Plato, Crito, one of Socrates’s followers, tries to convince Socrates to escape
from prison. Crito suggests that everyone will think his followers as stupid for not trying to help
Socrates escape(Plato, The Crito (Tredennick), pg. 2, Line 44c). Socrates says this about people's
opinions: “In that case, my dear fellow, what we ought to consider is not so much what people in
general will say about us but how we stand with the expert in right and wrong, the one authority
who represents the actual truth. ”Plato, The Crito (Tredennick), pg. 4, Line 48a. Socrates points
out that Crito shouldn’t care about “what people in general will say about” them, but instead,
consider if they are acting in a just manner with “the actual truth”. Therefore, Crito shouldn’t be
worried about what people think as long as he knows they’re acting justly. In the same way,
people and society will often have unhelpful advice for me, such as staying up late at night to do
homework. Furthermore, society promotes unhealthy habits, like eating at McDonald's or
3
drinking Coca-Cola. Instead, I should listen to those that speak honestly with me such as my
parents and close friends I can trust. They will encourage me to explore my talents and point out
shortcomings I can’t see in myself. Socrates next discusses with Crito whether his action of
knowingly breaking the law by escaping prison is justifiable. First, Socrates argues: “the fact
remains that to do wrong is in every sense bad and dishonorable for the person who does it…In
that case one must not even do wrong, when one is wronged, which most people regard as the
natural course” Plato, The Crito (Tredennick), pg. 5, Line 49b. Socrates doesn’t want to do
wrong by escaping prison, even though he has been wrongly accused, convicted, and sentenced
to death. Socrates concludes that he would be undermining the law by escaping from prison,
which would destroy the Athenian state. Plato, The Crito (Tredennick), pg. 6, Line 50b. After
concluding his argument, he tells Crito he will stay in prison and not escape(Plato, The Crito
(Tredennick), pg. 9, Line 54d). Nowadays, angry people cause damage. Such as in 2020, when
the George Floyd protests caused 19-20 additional deaths, hundreds of civilians’ and police
officers' injuries, and 1-2 billion dollars in property damage. George Floyd’s death was terrible,
but protesters caused even more violence, which was wrong. In my life, when I get wronged, like
my parents yell at me, I often yell back which isn’t constructive. Therefore, society has
encouraged me to do wrong, when I’ve been wronged.
4
Works Cited
Plato. Crito in The Last Days of Socrates, trans. Hugh Tredennick. Harmondsworth, Middlesex:
Penguin Classics, 1954
Plato. Five Dialogues: Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Meno, Phaedo. Translated by G. M.
A. Grube, Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Company, Inc., 2002.