UnderCover Boss Assignment
Script
(1)
Poor employee motivation is a significant challenge at Cooke Aquaculture. In this
episode of Undercover Boss, we are introduced to employees who encounters
difficulties in their respective roles within the company. We will first present the
relevant video clips for you.
18:04
34:10
(2)
First, we have James, working as a Cooke’s marine mechanics. He highlights the
issue of understaffing, expressing that he feels overwhelmed by being responsible
for multiple physically demanding tasks.
Secondly, he explains that, given his low wages, he is only able to cover his most
essential expenses and is unable to afford and pay for anything else.
He also conveys a sense of demotivation regarding his continued employment at
the company, because despite having worked there for five years, he feels that his
career progression has been minimal.
Furthermore, James points out that although he is considered one of the most
skilled marine mechanics in the company, he has never received formal training.
He believes that given the proper, certified training, it would significantly enhance
his prospects for advancement, only if the company were to grant him such an
opportunity.
UnderCover Boss Assignment
1
Next, we have Elvie, who works at Cooke’s packaging factory and their net
mending facility. Like James, Elvie faces long working hours and financial
hardship.
She works around 100 hours a week, trying to support her children and pay off a
large amount of unpaid bills following her husband’s passing. Despite her tireless
efforts and minimal personal spending, making ends meet remains a constant
struggle.
Due to her low wages and other expenses, Elvie is also unable to visit her parents
back home in the Philippines.
(3)
Now, we will go more in-depth on the challenges faced by James and Elvie,
identifying the cause of their demotivation and how it relates to key management
theories.
James and Elvie both bare tremendous responsibilities in their position and work
long hours. But despite their efforts, their wages only cover the most essential
expenses, leaving no room for other recreational activities. According to Maslow’s
Hierarchy of Needs, this means that only their physiological and safety needs are
met, but their higher-level needs such as social belongingness remains unmet.
Both employees also express feelings of being stuck in their roles. James, who
was with the company for five years, and Elvie, who consistently works long hour
sees very progress or wage growth. This lack of advancement relates to
Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory, where hygiene factors such as pay, and motivator
factors such as opportunities for growth and feelings of achievement are not met,
leading to dissatisfaction and lack of motivation.
From the perspective of the Equity Theory, both James and Elvie may experience
feelings of under-reward given the outcome they receive despite the input they
UnderCover Boss Assignment
2
offered. Due to this imbalance, it may ultimately decrease their motivation and
engagement.
Expectancy Theory can also explain a decrease in their motivation, if they
perceive that their hard work will not lead to meaningful rewards or career growth,
their effort diminishes.
(4)
The management theories that are challenged at Cooke Aquaculture must also be
addressed at other organization to
First, in regards to the Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, organizations must strive to
address employee’s higher level needs to fully engage them in the company.
Next, it is crucial to address Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory, since failure to
recognize motivating and hygiene factors such as opportunity for growth and job
salary will lead to employee’s dissatisfaction.
Additionally, from the perspective of the equity and expectancy theory, if
employees experiences continuous under-rewarding and perceives their efforts to
be redundant, it will ultimately decrease organizational productivity and increasing
turnover.
(5)
It is crucial for organizations to apply and consider these management theories to
effectively design a more positive and supportive environment for employees.
Both James and Elvie faces financial struggles, which makes increasing their
wages the obvious solution. Increasing salary would increase the hygiene factor
according to the two factor theory, leading to higher employee satisfaction and
motivation. However, as specified by the CEO in the episode, increasing wages
may not be viable due to the state of the job market, but there are other options.
UnderCover Boss Assignment
3
Such that companies can offer more comprehensive training which can give
employees more opportunity for advancement and growth.
They can also decrease current employee’s workload by hiring more talents,
allowing them to have more rest to avoid burn-outs and time with family, which
can help satisfy their higher Maslow of Hierarchy needs.
UnderCover Boss Assignment
4