1. Understanding the Author and Context (Expanded)
Margaret Atwood’s Personal Work and Themes:
Margaret Atwood’s writing is a tapestry of recurring themes—many of which we find
echoed in The City Planners. As an environmentalist, feminist, and cultural critic,
Atwood frequently challenges the interactions between humanity and the
environment, as well as society's structures of power, control, and conformity. In The
City Planners, she critiques the sanitized, regimented, and ultimately unsustainable
nature of suburban life. However, these themes—control, decay, and the fragility of
human constructs—appear throughout her broader literary corpus.
1.
Environmental Criticism: Atwood’s environmental consciousness is perhaps
best encapsulated in her MaddAddam Trilogy (which includes Oryx and Crake,
The Year of the Flood, and MaddAddam), where she explores the
consequences of humanity’s exploitation of the natural world. The City
Planners fits squarely within Atwood’s environmental critique. The suburb
described in The City Planners symbolizes an artificial attempt to control the
natural world, an issue Atwood returns to in her novels dealing with ecological
collapse. The apocalyptic tone of The City Planners, where humanity’s efforts
at control are undermined by nature, mirrors the dystopian futures of the
MaddAddam series, where humanity faces the consequences of its hubris.
Atwood’s early experiences in the Canadian wilderness gave her a first-hand view of
the delicate balance between human society and nature. The suburb in The City
Planners is the antithesis of the natural world she values; it is sterile, controlled, and
devoid of the chaotic beauty that nature holds. Just as in Oryx and Crake, where the
environmental collapse is tied to unchecked genetic manipulation, the suburban
sprawl in The City Planners is an emblem of humanity's attempt to dominate and
sanitize nature. The uniformity of the houses in this poem reflects a dangerous belief
that nature can be neatly packaged and controlled.
2. The Theme of Hubris: Atwood’s fascination with hubris—human pride and
arrogance in thinking we can master and reshape the world—is a key theme in
much of her work, particularly in her poems. The City Planners are portrayed
with the same inflated sense of self-importance that Atwood explores in her
novel The Handmaid's Tale. In that dystopia, theocratic rulers impose rigid
control over women’s bodies, attempting to manipulate and standardize life.
Similarly, the city planners in The City Planners seek to impose order on the
chaos of nature, and their actions are just as misguided. Atwood’s portrayal of
these planners as “insane faces of political conspirators” echoes the ways in
which the arrogance of power can lead to disastrous outcomes.
In her earlier poetry, particularly in collections like The Circle Game and The Animals
in That Country, Atwood explores the tension between human civilization and the
uncontrollable forces of nature. The idea of humankind’s “unnatural” attempts to
impose structure and order is a recurring theme in these works. Atwood’s critique in
The City Planners extends this concept, showing that, while human beings may
impose their will on nature, they are ultimately powerless against it.
3. Feminism and Social Control: Atwood's feminist sensibilities are evident in her
critique of the suburban ideal in The City Planners. The sterile, controlled
nature of suburbia can be seen as a metaphor for the ways in which society
attempts to control women—through prescribed roles, behaviors, and
expectations. The suburb is a place where everything is "neat," "tidy," and
devoid of life—much like the roles women were often expected to play in
mid-20th-century society. The stifling uniformity of suburban life mirrors the
restrictions imposed on women, and Atwood’s critique in the poem extends to
the imposed roles and expectations of women during this era.
This theme of control versus freedom also permeates Atwood’s work in novels like
The Handmaid’s Tale and Alias Grace, where women struggle against oppressive
structures that seek to restrict their agency. In The City Planners, the critique of
suburbia serves as an extension of Atwood’s feminist critique, suggesting that efforts
to control the world—whether through urban planning or gender roles—are
ultimately doomed to fail, as they cannot suppress the inherent chaos and complexity
of human nature.
Historical and Social Context (Expanded)
1.
Post-World War II Suburban Expansion: The City Planners was written during a
period of significant suburban growth in North America, particularly in the
post-World War II era. This was a time when cities were expanding rapidly, and
suburban developments sprang up as a response to the economic boom, the
increasing demand for housing, and the shift in American culture toward the
ideal of homeownership. The suburban landscape was constructed with
efficiency in mind, reflecting a desire for order, safety, and predictability.
Suburbs were marketed as havens from the chaos and uncertainty of the
urban world, promising peace, stability, and comfort.
However, these suburban ideals of perfection are sharply criticized in Atwood’s poem.
The poem critiques the artificiality of these developments, with their uniform rows of
houses, controlled lawns, and manicured trees—suggesting that this idealized
suburban life is devoid of authentic human experiences and connection to the natural
world. Atwood emphasizes that the controlled order of suburbia is fragile and
unsustainable, a sentiment echoed by the environmental concerns that arose in the
1960s. This period also saw the publication of works like Rachel Carson's Silent Spring
(1962), which raised public awareness about the damaging effects of pesticides and
other human activities on the environment. Atwood’s poem can be seen as a poetic
reflection of these broader cultural anxieties about the consequences of suburban
expansion and the neglect of nature.
2. The Rise of Environmentalism: The post-war era also marked the rise of
environmentalism as a political and cultural force, as growing concerns about
pollution, deforestation, and the degradation of the natural world began to
capture public attention. Atwood, as a committed environmentalist, was
keenly aware of these issues and frequently used her platform to critique the
exploitation of the environment. The City Planners serves as an early example
of Atwood’s engagement with ecological issues, particularly the idea that
human progress—in the form of suburban development—often comes at the
expense of the environment.
The ecological critique in The City Planners is not merely about the destruction of
nature but about human arrogance in thinking that nature can be tamed and
controlled. The city planners in the poem, with their meticulous design of
neighborhoods, symbolize the human desire to control everything, even the forces of
nature. Atwood uses natural imagery (e.g., the “bruise” of the paint, the “vicious coil”
of the hose) to suggest that, no matter how tightly humans try to control their
environment, nature will always push back. In this way, the poem aligns with the
growing environmental consciousness of the time, echoing concerns about the
unsustainable nature of industrial expansion and its impact on the planet.
3. Cultural Shift and Suburban Ideals: In the mid-20th century, the American
Dream became synonymous with suburban life: a perfect home, a
well-manicured lawn, and a stable family life. This idyllic vision of suburban life
promised a kind of safety, security, and control, but Atwood critiques this ideal
by exposing the emptiness and artificiality of such a world. The suburbs, while
superficially peaceful, are presented in the poem as unnatural and devoid of
life. Atwood’s critique here ties into the growing recognition during this time
that the conformity and uniformity promoted by suburban life stifled
individual creativity and expression.
Atwood’s exploration of the disjunction between human-made order and the chaos of
the natural world in The City Planners reflects a broader cultural awareness that the
ideals of suburban life—though cherished by many—came at a cost: the cost of a
deeper connection with the natural world and the loss of a more authentic existence.
Conclusion
Through a deep exploration of Atwood’s background, her literary influences, and the
historical and social context surrounding The City Planners, we gain a fuller
understanding of the themes that shape the poem. Atwood's lifelong concern with
the environment, her critique of human hubris, and her critique of suburban life
converge in this powerful work. Atwood not only reflects on the growing
suburbanization of post-WWII North America but also warns against the dangers of
trying to control the uncontrollable natural world. Through her vivid imagery and
stark metaphors, Atwood critiques the artificiality and the ultimate fragility of a world
built on control, while hinting at the apocalyptic consequences of our neglect of the
natural world. This early poem lays the foundation for the more expansive ecological
critiques that would emerge in her later work, tying together Atwood’s personal
beliefs, literary traditions, and social concerns in a profound and visionary way.
1. Psychological Insights
Atwood’s psychological exploration in The City Planners offers a rich layer of complexity
that further deepens the critique of suburban life. The discomfort the speaker feels when
confronted with the ordered, controlled suburban world can be read as a psychological
response to repression. The poem portrays a world in which human beings attempt to
control not only their external environments but their internal ones as well, aiming for the
idealized state of order and uniformity. However, this repression of chaos is
psychologically unhealthy, and the speaker’s discomfort may reflect a rejection of
societal norms that seek to repress individuality and the chaotic beauty of life.
The concept of hysteria in the poem is particularly poignant here. The speaker notes how
the driveways “neatly sidestep hysteria by being even.” The use of the word “hysteria”
evokes an association with mental illness, historically tied to repression and
control—especially in women. In this context, the suburban landscape can be interpreted
as a manifestation of society’s collective hysteria—the effort to tame the natural,
emotional, and irrational forces of human existence. The sanitized, orderly world of
suburbia is a psychological defense mechanism, an attempt to keep chaos and disorder
at bay, but this attempt comes with psychic costs. The tension between the ordered
world of the planners and the inherent messiness of life creates a disconnect between
the human psyche and the natural world, ultimately leading to disillusionment.
In this way, Atwood presents suburbia as a space where human desires for control (over
both external surroundings and internal emotions) are pushed to an extreme, leading to
a form of psychological dissonance. The imperfection that the planner’s world seeks to
eliminate—the dent in the car door, the splash of paint on the brick—is precisely what
makes life meaningful. By erasing this, the planners (and by extension, the social system)
cause a psychic imbalance, one that the speaker feels intensely.
2. Historical Allusions
In expanding the historical allusions in the poem, we can position Atwood’s critique within
the larger context of 1960s suburbanization. The post-World War II boom in suburban
housing development was not only a physical expansion of urban landscapes but also a
reflection of cultural ideals of stability, safety, and conformity. Suburbs became
synonymous with the American Dream—homes that offered a predictable, orderly way of
life. The American Dream emphasized individual success, but this success was often tied
to conformity—to owning a house, maintaining a perfect lawn, and living a life free of
conflict or complexity.
Atwood critiques this suburban ideal as an illusion of perfection that hides the chaos of
the real world. Her description of the houses in “pedantic rows” and the “sanitary trees” is
a direct comment on the banality and artificiality of suburban construction. This
mirrored the larger societal trend of trying to normalize and sanitize societal experiences.
In the 1960s, many people felt that conformity was a refuge from the uncertainty of
modern life. Atwood, however, sees the need for order as an unsustainable denial of
deeper truths about life and nature.
Atwood also reflects on the Canadian context during the post-war period. Canada, like
the United States, witnessed a wave of suburban growth during this period, especially in
cities like Toronto and Vancouver, where sprawl replaced much of the natural landscape.
The cultural shift from rural to urban, from wilderness to manicured suburban spaces,
was something that Atwood would have been keenly aware of, particularly as she
observed the flattening of the Canadian wilderness by urban development. The poem
implicitly critiques this shift, not just as a critique of suburbia, but as part of a larger
existential crisis about human’s disconnect from the natural world.
3. Atwood’s Use of Form and Free Verse
The free verse structure of The City Planners is a pivotal choice, aligning with the poem’s
thematic focus on the disorder of nature and human resistance to it. The irregularity of
the stanza lengths, from the twelve lines of the first stanza to the two lines of the final
stanza, mirrors the disintegration of human control. The fluidity of free verse—with its
enjambment, lack of regular meter, and broken rhythms—contrasts sharply with the
pedantic, controlled environment of suburbia described in the poem.
Atwood’s choice to use free verse is not just stylistic; it is structural commentary. The
structured, regular rows of houses in the suburban setting serve as a symbol of rigid,
human imposition on the natural world. However, the lack of formal structure in the
poem suggests that nature itself is resistant to this imposition. In the poem, nature is not
something to be controlled; it is something to be respected and left to exist freely. The
irregular structure of the poem reflects the reality that the planners’ efforts to impose
order will be eventually undone by the chaos of nature.
In addition, the enjambment in many lines of the poem—where one line flows into the
next without punctuation—creates a sense of continuity, suggesting the uncontainable
movement of nature. Where the planners use rigid lines to impose order, Atwood’s
enjambed lines suggest that human boundaries are always permeable and ultimately
unsustainable.
4. Mythological Connections and Themes of Hubris
In examining hubris—the overweening pride and arrogance of the city planners—we can
draw mythological parallels that deepen Atwood's critique of human attempts to control
nature. The planners, with their "insane faces of political conspirators," invoke images of
Narcissus—a figure who becomes so consumed by his own reflection that he loses touch
with the world around him. Similarly, the planners are so fixated on their control over the
suburban landscape that they lose sight of the underlying chaos and unpredictability of
nature. The planners, in their quest for perfection, embody the tragic flaw of hubris that
leads to their inevitable downfall, much like Icarus, who flew too close to the sun in
defiance of nature’s limits.
The arrogance of the planners, as they try to impose rigid boundaries on a naturally
chaotic world, mirrors the ancient mythological figures who tried to assert human will
over the gods, nature, or fate. The planners' “guessing directions” while “scattered over
unsurveyed territories” evokes a sense of delusion and folly, much like the myth of King
Midas, whose greed for control ultimately led to his own destruction. This link deepens
the poem's tragic vision, where human efforts to subdue nature or exert control inevitably
lead to collapse.
5. Language Play and Ambiguity
Atwood is known for her wordplay, and The City Planners is rich with ambiguous
language that allows for multiple interpretations. For instance, the term “sanitary” can be
read both as a description of cleanliness and as a symbol of sterility and control. The
planners’ sanitary trees are artificial, imposed on nature to make it more predictable, yet
this artificial purity is precisely what the speaker finds unsettling. The “hysteria” that the
driveways neatly sidestep might suggest the human impulse to repress emotional or
psychological disorder, yet hysteria itself, as a concept, carries layers of
meaning—particularly in the context of Atwood’s feminist lens, where women have
historically been labeled “hysterical” for expressing discontent or rejecting societal norms.
The "vicious coil" of the hose is another instance of Atwood’s personification of
inanimate objects, turning them into metaphors for deeper human tensions. The coil
suggests something that is waiting to strike, symbolizing nature’s latent power that is
always present in the background of the supposedly perfect suburban world. It’s an image
of control, but also of danger—a reminder that humanity cannot contain or suppress
nature for long. The “wide windows” with their “too-fixed stare” further suggest the
dehumanizing aspects of the suburban environment, where life is watched, regulated,
and controlled.
6. Ecological Concerns and the Broader Movement
Atwood’s concerns in The City Planners align with the growing ecological movement of
the 1960s and 1970s, which raised awareness about the destructive impact of unchecked
industrialization. In the poem, the city planners’ desire to control the environment mirrors
the growing industrial exploitation of the earth during this period. The planners' efforts
to carve up the natural world into predictable, sterile plots reflect broader societal efforts
to dominate and reshape nature for human use. This critique resonates with the rise of
environmentalism in the 1960s, symbolized by works like Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring,
which exposed the dangers of pesticides and argued for a more sustainable, respectful
relationship with the environment.
Atwood’s environmental critique in The City Planners also anticipates the ecocritical
literary movement that would gain momentum later in the 20th century. Ecocriticism,
which explores the relationship between literature and the environment, aligns with
Atwood’s call for a deeper connection to nature. In this sense, Atwood’s poem is not just a
critique of suburbia but also a warning about the broader environmental consequences
of human disregard for the natural world.
7. Atwood’s Political Activism
Atwood’s political activism also informs her critique of suburban capitalism. The planners’
greed-driven control over the land and their disregard for nature can be seen as a direct
critique of the capitalist drive for profit that fuels suburbanization. The uniformity of the
suburbs, the mass-production of homes and developments, symbolizes a
commodification of space, land, and life—a process driven by capitalist interests that
ultimately alienates humans from the natural world. Atwood critiques this capitalist
system, positioning suburban development as part of a larger cultural mechanism that
exploits both the land and the individuals who live in it.
Conclusion
By integrating psychological insights, historical allusions, structural choices, and
intertextual connections, we've expanded the analysis into a multi-layered exploration
that aligns The City Planners with Atwood’s broader thematic concerns, including her
views on environmental degradation, human control, and societal repression. These
elements converge to present a complex critique of suburbanization, offering a profound
commentary on the destructive pursuit of perfection and order at the expense of nature
and authentic human existence.
This deeper exploration places The City Planners in the broader context of Atwood’s
literary career, illuminating how it aligns with her ecological activism, feminist critique,
and apocalyptic visions.
2. Structure and Form
Margaret Atwood’s The City Planners is carefully crafted in terms of its structure and form,
which reflect the poem’s themes of order, control, and underlying chaos. Atwood uses a
variety of techniques—ranging from stanza structure to punctuation choices, line breaks,
and caesura—to reinforce her critique of suburban life and humanity’s futile attempts to
impose order on nature. Each formal element serves to underscore the tension between
artificial order and the inevitable disorder that lies beneath.
Overall Structure: Stanzas and Line Count
The City Planners is composed of seven stanzas with irregular line lengths, a structural
choice that visually contrasts with the rigid order imposed by the city planners within the
poem’s content. The stanzas range in line count, with the first stanza being the longest at
twelve lines and the final stanza consisting of just two lines. This uneven structure
mirrors Atwood’s thematic critique of suburbia: although the city planners attempt to
impose uniformity and order on the landscape, the poem itself resists this by refusing a
predictable, regular form.
1.
2.
3.
Irregularity as a Reflection of Nature’s Chaos: The varying stanza lengths
underscore the poem’s exploration of human limitations in the face of nature.
Suburbia, with its meticulously organized layout, symbolizes humanity’s desire to
control and sanitize the natural world, yet the poem’s asymmetrical structure
serves as a reminder that nature defies this rigid ordering. The decreasing line
lengths from stanza to stanza evoke a sense of gradual decay or erosion,
paralleling Atwood’s vision of suburbia’s eventual decline as nature inevitably
reclaims the constructed landscape. This progression from a long stanza to a short
two-line closing also mimics the way suburban developments slowly give way to
cracks and fissures, leading to an ultimate breakdown.
Absence of a Traditional Form: Atwood’s poem does not follow any traditional
poetic form such as a sonnet, haiku, or ballad, choosing instead the flexibility of
free verse. The decision to use free verse aligns with the poem’s rejection of
artificial constraints; just as Atwood criticizes the imposed order of the planners,
she herself avoids a rigid poetic form. Free verse allows her to break from
convention, reinforcing the message that nature and human experience cannot
be confined to predefined structures. The lack of a recognizable form emphasizes
the organic unpredictability that the planners attempt, unsuccessfully, to
suppress.
Fragmented Stanza Structure: The fragmentation of the poem into seven stanzas,
each with a different line count, creates a visual dissonance that echoes the
tension between the suburban ideal of perfection and the reality of nature’s
inherent disorder. The poem’s structure is disjointed and varied, resisting the
uniformity of the suburban landscape it describes. This lack of structural regularity
acts as a subtle reminder that despite the planners’ efforts to impose symmetry,
life and nature are fundamentally fragmented and unpredictable.
Punctuation and Line Breaks
Punctuation and line breaks play a critical role in Atwood’s The City Planners, helping to
convey the themes of control, containment, and underlying chaos. Atwood’s manipulation
of end-stopped lines, enjambment, and caesura serves to create a rhythmic tension that
reflects the themes of the poem.
1.
2.
3.
End-Stopped Lines: Artificial Closure and Control: Several lines in the poem are
end-stopped with punctuation, creating moments of artificial closure that mimic
the rigidity and order of the suburban landscape. End-stopping a line with
punctuation, such as a period or comma, gives the impression of finality and
control, reinforcing the planners’ attempts to create a “neat” and “sanitary” world.
For example, the line “the houses in pedantic rows, the planted / sanitary trees”
ends with a comma, suggesting a brief, controlled pause that mirrors the planners’
desire for an orderly environment. However, this sense of control is often undercut
by enjambed lines that immediately disrupt the sense of containment.
Enjambment: Flow and Resistance to Containment: Atwood frequently employs
enjambment in The City Planners, where lines flow into one another without a
pause. Enjambment creates a sense of movement and continuity, resisting the
rigid boundaries implied by end-stopping. For instance, the line “the levelness of
surface like a rebuke / to the dent in our car door” flows directly into the next line,
symbolizing the underlying resistance of nature to the imposed order.
Enjambment disrupts the illusion of neatness created by end-stopping,
introducing an unpredictable, fluid quality that echoes the chaos lying just
beneath the controlled suburban surface.
The frequent enjambment in the poem also reinforces the theme of suppressed
chaos—the planners can try to enforce order, but they cannot fully contain the
natural flow of life. Each enjambed line breaks free of the constraints that might be
imposed by punctuation, symbolizing how nature itself will eventually break free
of human attempts at regulation.
Caesura: Pausing to Reveal Inner Tensions: Atwood uses caesura—a pause
within a line—to draw attention to specific contrasts or shifts in tone, revealing the
underlying tensions and contradictions of the suburban landscape. The caesura
in lines such as “give momentary access to / the landscape behind or under / the
future cracks in the plaster” disrupts the flow of the line, creating a moment of
reflection that emphasizes the impermanence of human constructions. The
cracks in the plaster are a symbolic glimpse into the eventual decay of the
suburban ideal, and the pause created by the caesura mirrors the slow but
inevitable breakdown of these artificial structures.
The caesuras in the poem often occur at points where the speaker shifts from a
description of surface perfection to hints of underlying imperfection or decay. This
technique reinforces the idea that beneath the polished, controlled exterior of
suburbia lies a world that will ultimately slip out of human control.
The Interplay of Structure and Theme
The structure and form of The City Planners are deeply intertwined with its themes,
creating an interplay between order and disorder that enhances the poem’s critique.
Each element—stanza structure, line breaks, punctuation—works together to underscore
the futility of human attempts to control the natural world.
1.
Order versus Disorder: Atwood’s structural choices reflect the poem’s central
theme of order versus disorder. The planners’ attempt to create a world of perfect
symmetry and control is undermined by the irregular form of the poem itself. This
opposition is visible in every structural decision, from the irregular stanza lengths
to the alternating use of end-stopped lines and enjambment. The poem’s form,
much like nature itself, is resistant to total control. Even though the planners can
impose superficial order on the landscape, they cannot change the underlying
chaotic essence of nature.
2. Decay and Fragmentation: The gradual reduction in line count from stanza to
stanza mirrors the decay and fragmentation of the suburban landscape. Just as
the artificial order of suburbia begins to show cracks over time, the structure of the
poem gradually disintegrates, moving from the more substantial first stanza to the
brief, two-line final stanza. This decline in structure reflects the inevitable
breakdown of suburban order and the impermanence of human creations.
Atwood uses this structural decay to suggest that, over time, nature will reclaim its
place, and the artificial structures of suburbia will dissolve into the natural world.
3. Fluidity as a Symbol of Nature’s Resistance: The free verse form and frequent
enjambment give the poem a sense of fluidity that contrasts sharply with the rigid
suburban world it describes. This fluidity acts as a symbol of nature’s resistance to
containment. Where the planners seek to create a static, controlled environment,
the poem flows and shifts, resisting the confinement of traditional structure.
Atwood’s use of enjambment, which allows lines to flow uninterrupted into one
another, embodies the unpredictable, unstoppable force of nature that
ultimately transcends human control. The uncontained structure of the poem is a
constant reminder that nature cannot be fully restrained.
4. Finality and Ambiguity in the Closing Stanza: The last stanza, composed of just
two lines, provides a stark and ambiguous conclusion to the poem. The brevity of
the stanza suggests a sense of finality, as if to imply that, despite all human efforts,
nature will have the last word. The closing lines, “tracing the panic of suburb / order
in a bland madness of snows,” emphasize the inevitable collapse of suburban
order into natural chaos. The phrase “bland madness of snows” suggests an
impersonal, unstoppable force that will erase the planners’ designs, returning the
landscape to a state of natural ambiguity. By ending on such a brief, open note,
Atwood underscores the ephemeral nature of human control and the eternal
presence of natural forces that will outlast any artificial order.
Conclusion
In The City Planners, Atwood’s use of structure and form serves as a powerful extension
of her thematic critique. Through irregular stanza lengths, a lack of traditional form, and
strategic punctuation, Atwood crafts a poem that resists the rigid order it critiques. The
free verse and frequent use of enjambment create a sense of fluidity and natural
resistance, while the caesuras introduce moments of tension that reflect the fragility of
human constructions.
Ultimately, the form of The City Planners serves as an embodiment of Atwood’s message:
that nature cannot be fully contained by human efforts, and that the artificial
landscapes of suburbia are destined to erode and give way to the chaos of the natural
world. Through each structural element, Atwood reinforces the themes of human hubris,
ecological critique, and the inevitable power of nature, creating a poem that is both a
scathing critique of suburban ideals and a meditation on humanity’s limitations in the
face of the natural order.
Expanded Analysis of Structure and Form in The City Planners
Stanza 1: The Length and Tone of the Opening Scene
The opening stanza is twelve lines long, making it the longest in the poem. This length
immediately gives the impression of an extended description—a sense of the speaker
surveying the entire suburban landscape, taking in its artificial neatness and oppressive
order. The poem opens with:
"Cruising these residential Sunday / streets in dry August sunlight:"
1.
2.
3.
Enjambment and Opening Flow:
○ The line break between “Sunday” and “streets” introduces an initial sense of
movement, as if the poem is taking the reader on a journey through these
suburban streets. By delaying the full scene until the second line, Atwood
creates a moment of suspense, almost as if she is inviting the reader to
take a closer look at this setting before making her critique explicit.
Use of Colon and Detached Observation:
○ The colon at the end of “sunlight” introduces a list of grievances and hints
at the speaker’s judgmental tone. This colon serves as a kind of boundary,
separating the idyllic first impression of the suburban setting from the
speaker’s deeper disdain for it. It almost mirrors the artificial separation
between the pristine suburban facade and the reality beneath it.
End-Stopped Lines Creating Forced Control:
○ The line “what offends us is / the sanities:” introduces the poem’s central
critique. The use of an end-stop here after “sanities” serves to emphasize
the rigidity of suburban control. The line stops suddenly, as if even the
words themselves are being forced into order. This brief pause before the
speaker’s complaints reinforces the idea of repressed tension in a
superficially controlled environment.
Specific Examples of Diction and Line Breaks in Stanza 1
"the houses in pedantic rows, the planted / sanitary trees, assert / levelness of
surface like a rebuke / to the dent in our car door."
1.
Line Break on “planted”:
○ The break after “planted” is significant, as it places emphasis on the word,
suggesting a deliberate act of control over nature. This draws attention to
human manipulation—the trees are not natural, wild, or spontaneous; they
are “planted” with purpose, a visual representation of suburbia’s meticulous
control over the landscape. The enjambment here also allows the line to
flow into the phrase “sanitary trees,” which creates an oxymoronic
juxtaposition, as trees are rarely associated with sterility or sanitation.
2.
3.
This tension between nature and human intervention is underscored by the
enjambed structure.
Caesura and Rebellion in “like a rebuke”:
○ The phrase “like a rebuke” is set apart by a line break, which isolates the
comparison and heightens its impact. The caesura within the line (with
“levelness of surface” on one side and “like a rebuke” on the other)
emphasizes the conflict between natural imperfections (represented by
the dent in the car door) and the forced uniformity of suburbia. This division
in the line mirrors the thematic division between authenticity and
artificiality.
Comma Usage and Controlled Rhythm:
○ The repeated use of commas in lines like “the houses in pedantic rows, the
planted / sanitary trees,” imposes a deliberate, controlled rhythm that
mirrors the sterile order of the suburbs. Each phrase is contained, as if the
language itself is restricted by the suburban values of control and
containment.
Stanza 2: Subversion Through Enjambment and the Creation of Tension
In the second stanza, Atwood uses enjambment extensively, which contrasts with the
punctuated control of the first stanza:
"But though the driveways neatly / sidestep hysteria / by being even, the roofs
all display / the same slant of avoidance to the hot sky, / certain things:"
1.
2.
3.
Irony in Enjambment:
○ The line break after “driveways neatly” suggests a moment of
contradiction—the word “neatly” is immediately followed by the enjambed
phrase “sidestep hysteria.” This enjambment captures a sense of irony, as
the neatly organized driveways are, in fact, a frantic attempt to avoid chaos.
By subverting the reader’s expectation of a neat end to the phrase, Atwood
highlights the tension between appearance and reality.
Ambiguity Created by Enjambed Lists:
○ The stanza ends with a colon after “certain things,” which introduces a list
of unsettling images in the next lines. This colon implies that these items
are merely a small sample of the suppressed “hysteria” beneath the surface.
The way the list is presented in enjambed lines rather than in a punctuated
list format (such as with semicolons or commas) creates a fluid, chaotic
flow, subverting the “neatness” implied by the driveways. This visual list,
broken by line endings rather than commas, hints at a barely-contained
disorder, reflecting the speaker’s view that suburbia’s order is superficial
and ultimately unsustainable.
Personification and End-Stopped Punctuation:
○ In the list—“the smell of spilled oil a faint / sickness lingering in the garages,
/ a splash of paint on brick surprising as a bruise, / a plastic hose poised in a
vicious / coil”—each object is personified, with the phrase “surprising as a
bruise” ending in a comma, creating a feeling of pause and ambiguity. The
bruised paint and viciously coiled hose suggest latent violence beneath
suburbia’s placid surface, while the comma after “bruise” creates a
hesitation, making the reader consider the imperfections in this sanitized
world.
Stanza 3: Disintegration of Structure and Cracks in the Façade
The third stanza begins with enjambed lines that reveal the unseen reality beneath
suburbia’s facade:
"give momentary access to / the landscape behind or under / the future cracks
in the plaster"
1.
2.
Line Breaks that Reveal Hidden Layers:
○ The enjambment from “momentary access to” into “the landscape behind
or under” mimics a slow unveiling. Each line flows into the next, as if
peeling back layers of the suburban facade to reveal hidden realities. This
structural choice mirrors the process of decay that the speaker predicts
for the suburban landscape.
Caesura and Unstable Phrasing:
○ The phrase “future cracks in the plaster” is fragmented by punctuation that
causes slight pauses, creating a staccato rhythm that emphasizes the
fragility of the suburban ideal. The cracks are not immediate—they are
“future cracks,” suggesting an impending breakdown, and the placement
of the words through enjambment and caesura hints at the inevitable
erosion of suburban stability.
Stanza 4: Sliding into Oblivion – Symbolic Line Length Reduction
This stanza begins with a continuation of enjambment from the previous lines:
"when the houses, capsized, will slide / obliquely into the clay seas, gradual as
glaciers / that right now nobody notices."
1.
2.
Imagery of Slow Decay and Extended Flow:
○ The enjambment here allows the image of “houses… sliding obliquely” to
stretch across lines, visually enacting the slow, inevitable decay of
suburban structures. This line, with its gradual descent, mirrors the glacial
movement of nature overtaking human constructions. The image of
glaciers serves as a symbol of unstoppable natural forces that gradually
erode all human efforts at permanence.
Caesura with “capsized,”:
○ The use of commas around “capsized” isolates the word, emphasizing the
fragility of the suburban homes. This word placement evokes a sudden
moment of imbalance within the line, symbolizing how easily the ordered
structures of suburbia can be upturned by nature.
Final Stanzas: Dissolution and the Vanishing of Structure
In the last three stanzas, the line lengths continue to shrink, reflecting the disintegration
of human control:
"That is where the City Planners / with the insane faces of political conspirators
/ are scattered over unsurveyed / territories, concealed from each other, / each
in his own private blizzard;"
1.
2.
Isolation and Fragmentation in Line Structure:
○ The short, fragmented lines reflect the planners’ disconnected and
isolated states. Each line ends abruptly, creating a stilted, almost disjointed
rhythm, mirroring the lack of unity and direction among the planners.
Final Two-Line Stanza and Concluding Image:
○ The poem’s final stanza is just two lines, reflecting a collapse in form that
mimics the collapse of suburban order. The phrase “bland madness of
snows” is paradoxical—“bland” and “madness” together create an
oxymoron, suggesting a state of unremarkable chaos. This last image, with
its abrupt brevity, suggests a return to a natural, chaotic state where the
planners’ lines and boundaries are erased by the indifferent snow.
Conclusion
By expanding this analysis to capture each punctuation choice, line break, and structural
decision in detail, we see how Atwood uses every element of structure and form to
enhance her critique of suburbia. The interplay of rigid punctuation and flowing
enjambment reflects the tension between imposed control and natural chaos. The
gradual reduction in line length reflects the inevitable disintegration of human efforts,
while specific word placements and caesurae emphasize the fragility of the suburban
ideal.
This refined analysis ensures that no detail is overlooked, fully capturing how Atwood’s
structural decisions work in tandem with her themes, making The City Planners a
profound critique of human hubris and the futility of imposed order on an untamable
world. Let me know if this covers everything you envisioned or if there’s anything more
you’d like to delve into!
Section 3: Rhyme Scheme and Meter – Comprehensive Analysis
The City Planners by Margaret Atwood is a free verse poem that intentionally avoids a
traditional rhyme scheme or regular meter. This choice aligns with the poem’s theme of
underlying chaos, as Atwood resists any sense of imposed order or predictability in
structure, just as she critiques the planners’ attempts to impose order on nature.
Let’s proceed line by line, exploring all rhyme, sound, and meter elements.
Lines 1-2: Setting Up the Scene with Internal Rhythm
“Cruising these residential Sunday / streets in dry August sunlight:”
1.
2.
Internal Assonance and Rhythm:
○ The repetition of long vowels in “dry” and “August” creates a slow, heavy
rhythm that reflects the oppressive atmosphere of the suburb. The
combination of “Sunday,” “dry,” and “sunlight” in this line introduces a sense
of uneasy stillness.
Consonance with ‘s’ Sounds:
○ The repeated ‘s’ sounds in “Cruising,” “residential,” and “streets” creates a
soft, almost hissing quality, suggesting a quiet, constrained environment.
This consonance hints at the suppressive nature of suburbia, where any
vibrant sound or disorder is muted.
Lines 3-4: Breaking the Illusion of Peace
“what offends us is / the sanities:”
1.
2.
Enjambment and Disruption:
○ The enjambment between lines adds a sense of abruptness as the speaker
shifts from a calm description to expressing discomfort. The flow between
“offends us is” creates a natural pause, a forced division that mirrors the
speaker’s dissatisfaction with the stifling order.
Rhetorical Impact of “Sanities”:
○ Ending the line with “sanities” and following with a colon highlights the
artificiality of the suburban ideals. The line is end-stopped, which mirrors
the rigid order that “sanities” implies.
Lines 5-9: Repetition of Sound and Subtle Rhyme within Control
“the houses in pedantic rows, the planted / sanitary trees, assert / levelness of
surface like a rebuke / to the dent in our car door.”
1.
2.
Consonance with ‘t’ and ‘s’ Sounds:
○ Atwood uses consonance in “planted,” “sanitary,” and “assert,” which
enhances the mechanical feel of the setting. These sounds echo the
orderliness of the suburb, as if the landscape itself is enforcing rules
through its structure.
Internal Rhyme and Subtle Rhythmic Balance:
○
The phrase “levelness of surface” and “rebuke” carry a slant rhyme, creating
a subtle sense of harmony that feels forced—mirroring the artificial
uniformity of the neighborhood.
Lines 10-12: Artificial Sounds and Rhythmic Control
“No shouting here, or / shatter of glass; nothing more abrupt / than the
rational whine of a power mower / Cutting a straight swath in the discouraged
grass.”
1.
2.
Internal Assonance in “Rational Whine”:
○ The long ‘i’ sounds in “rational whine” resonate with a sense of controlled
distress, enhancing the poem’s tone of quiet, repressed tension. The phrase
itself evokes a sense of mechanized monotony—a robotic hum that mirrors
suburbia’s suffocating predictability.
Internal Rhyme of “Shatter” and “Abrupt”:
○ The near rhyme between “shatter” and “abrupt” creates a momentary
break from the peaceful flow, drawing attention to these words that imply
disruption. This subtle rhythmic shift underscores the suppressed energy
that suburbia tries to contain.
Lines 13-16: The Artificial Calm
“But though the driveways neatly / sidestep hysteria / By being even, the roofs
all display / the same slant of avoidance to the hot sky,”
1.
2.
Alliteration in “Driveways” and “Display”:
○ The alliterative ‘d’ sounds echo the sense of controlled alignment,
emphasizing the monotonous uniformity of suburbia.
Internal Rhyme and Repetition of ‘S’ Sounds:
○ “Sidestep hysteria” and “same slant” use internal rhyme and sibilant ‘s’
sounds, creating a sense of smoothness that’s almost unsettling. This
repetition enforces the impression of conformity, as if each driveway and
roof is part of a silent agreement to avoid disorder.
Lines 17-22: Hidden Disorder and Internal Chaos
“certain things: / the smell of spilled oil a faint / sickness lingering in the
garages, / a splash of paint on brick surprising as a bruise, / a plastic hose
poised in a vicious / coil; even the too-fixed stare of the wide windows”
1.
2.
Internal Rhyme and Consonance:
○ The ‘s’ sounds in “smell of spilled oil a faint sickness” and “plastic hose
poised in a vicious coil” create an underlying hiss that feels both subtle and
menacing, reinforcing the latent disorder that the planners attempt to hide.
Rhythmic Dissonance:
○ The words “lingering” and “garages,” when spoken aloud, have a slow,
drawn-out rhythm that contrasts sharply with “splash” and “bruise.” This
creates a rhythmic tension between slow decay and sudden surprise,
which reflects the poem’s theme of underlying chaos within controlled
environments.
3.
Caesura with a Vicious Pause:
○ The word “vicious” stands out due to the line break before “coil”,
emphasizing the sense of tension. The line break serves as a caesura,
causing the reader to pause and anticipate the coiled potential for violence
hidden in suburbia.
Lines 23-25: Foreshadowing Decay
“give momentary access to / the landscape behind or under / the future cracks
in the plaster”
1.
2.
Assonance with ‘A’ Sounds:
○ Repeated ‘a’ sounds in “landscape,” “behind,” and “cracks” draw attention to
the natural elements behind the artificial facade. The assonance gives a
sonic depth, suggesting that the real landscape lies beyond what is visible.
Flow of Enjambment Reflecting Hidden Decay:
○ The enjambed lines here flow without interruption, mimicking how nature
seeps into the cracks of the constructed world. This flow mirrors the
inevitable encroachment of nature on human-made structures.
Lines 26-28: Imminent Collapse and Inevitable Movement
“when the houses, capsized, will slide / obliquely into the clay seas, gradual as
glaciers / that right now nobody notices.”
1.
2.
Repetition of Long Vowel Sounds in “Capsized” and “Slide”:
○ The long ‘i’ sound in “capsized” and “slide” creates a drawn-out, slow
rhythm that mimics the gradual erosion of suburban structures. This
slow-moving rhythm reflects the unstoppable nature of time and decay.
Internal Rhyme with “Seas” and “Glaciers”:
○ The soft slant rhyme between “seas” and “glaciers” reinforces the poem’s
theme of subtle, creeping decay. These words, while not perfectly
rhyming, create a harmonious dissonance, evoking the gradual, quiet
forces of nature.
Lines 29-33: The City Planners and their Self-Deception
“That is where the City Planners / with the insane faces of political conspirators
/ are scattered over unsurveyed / territories, concealed from each other, / each
in his own private blizzard;”
1.
2.
Repetitive ‘S’ Sounds in “City Planners” and “Insane Faces”:
○ The sibilant ‘s’ sounds contribute to an almost serpentine tone, evoking
the planners’ secretive, conspiratorial behavior. This sound creates a
whispering effect, as if their actions are hidden even from each other.
Internal Rhyme in “Each” and “Blizzard”:
○ The slant rhyme here between “each” and “blizzard” offers a subtle sonic
connection, emphasizing the planners’ isolation and the futility of their
efforts in the vast, indifferent forces of nature.
Final Lines 34-35: The Inevitable Triumph of Nature
“tracing the panic of suburb / order in a bland madness of snows.”
1.
2.
Paradoxical Contrast in “Bland Madness”:
○ The juxtaposition of “bland” and “madness” creates an oxymoron that
emphasizes the quiet chaos of suburbia. The phrase captures the repetitive
monotony that is simultaneously disorienting and meaningless.
Sibilance and Finality:
○ The repeated ‘s’ sounds in “snows” and “suburb” offer a hissing closure,
suggesting that nature’s power will ultimately erase all traces of the
planners’ efforts. The soft ending mimics the inevitability of snowfall,
blanketing everything in white.
Conclusion: Rhyme Scheme, Meter, and Sound Devices as Reflection of Theme
Every instance of rhyme, internal rhythm, sound device, and meter enhances the thematic
tension in The City Planners. By avoiding a strict rhyme scheme, Atwood emphasizes the
poem’s natural resistance to artificial order. Each internal rhyme, subtle alliteration, and
instance of consonance or assonance works to underscore the underlying chaos that
suburban order tries to suppress. This line-by-line analysis captures every structural detail,
offering a nuanced, thorough understanding of how Atwood uses rhyme and meter to
enrich her critique of human attempts to control nature.
Certainly! I’ll expand on each of these enhancements in detail, focusing exclusively on the
effects of sound, rhythm, and reader impact without overlapping with other literary
elements. This will bring out every nuance in how Atwood’s choices in sound and rhythm
contribute to the poem’s subtle tensions and themes.
Expanded Analysis of Rhyme Scheme and Meter in The City
Planners
In The City Planners, Margaret Atwood employs a deliberate lack of traditional rhyme and
meter, combined with intricate internal rhymes, rhythmic interruptions, and specific
phonetic choices. These techniques work together to create a subtle, unsettling tone that
enhances the poem’s critique of suburbia and human attempts to impose order on
nature. Here’s an in-depth look at how each sound and rhythmic element serves this
purpose.
1. Phonetic Effects on Reader Experience: Subtle Sound Patterns and Tone
Atwood’s use of sibilant sounds (soft ‘s’ sounds) is pervasive throughout the poem, and
this sound pattern creates a whispering, almost sinister tone that evokes a sense of
suppressed tension within the seemingly perfect suburban environment. This use of
sibilance, especially in lines such as “sidestep hysteria” and “sanitary trees,” mirrors the
quiet, controlled atmosphere of suburbia, yet hints at an underlying disquiet. Let’s break
down these instances to see how they shape the reader’s experience:
1.
2.
“Sidestep hysteria” and “sanitary trees”:
○ The soft ‘s’ sounds in these phrases produce a calm but eerie quality, as if
suburbia itself is shushing any expressions of disorder or emotion. The
repetition of these sounds reinforces the quiet repression that the poem
critiques; the phonetic softness makes the reader feel as though something
is being stifled or muted, reflecting the rigid uniformity imposed by the
planners.
○ This sibilance also subtly personifies suburbia, giving it a character that
seems both lifeless and oppressive. The reader is made to feel the almost
stifling silence that hangs over the environment, lending the setting an
unnatural calmness that feels distinctly unsettling.
“Straight swath” and “discouraged grass”:
○ In this line, the sharp consonant sounds in “straight swath” contrast with
the softer ‘s’ sound in “discouraged,” capturing the rigid imposition of order
onto something that should be alive and growing. The reader can sense the
tension between the harsh control and natural resistance. Phonetically,
the switch from sharper consonants to softer sibilance evokes a feeling of
something being cut down, mirroring the “discouraged” state of the grass.
Through these sibilant sounds, Atwood establishes an auditory landscape that mirrors the
poem’s themes of artificiality and underlying chaos. The reader feels the sinister restraint
of suburbia, where even natural elements seem subdued and lifeless, creating a subtly
disturbing effect.
2. Psychological Effects of Caesuras and Rhythmic Pauses
Atwood’s use of caesuras and line breaks is intentional, causing rhythmic interruptions
that mirror the psychological discomfort the speaker feels in suburbia. These pauses
create a stop-start rhythm that reflects the fragile, forced control of the suburban
landscape and heightens the reader’s sense of unease.
1.
2.
Pauses in “levelness of surface like a rebuke / to the dent in our car door”:
○ Here, the line break creates a momentary pause, interrupting the rhythm
and calling attention to the phrase “like a rebuke.” This caesura serves as a
visual and rhythmic halt that mirrors the unsettling presence of suburbia.
The reader’s experience is disrupted, mirroring the speaker’s own
discomfort with the imposed uniformity.
○ Psychologically, this pause forces the reader to reflect on the image of
suburbia as a “rebuke.” The break in rhythm mirrors the internal tension in
the speaker’s mind and forces the reader to absorb the critique of
suburbia as a stifling, oppressive space.
“Capsized, will slide / obliquely into the clay seas”:
○ The comma after “capsized” creates a caesura that emphasizes the sense of
instability and impending collapse. By introducing this pause, Atwood gives
○
the word “capsized” a moment to resonate on its own, highlighting the
fragility of human-made structures. The pause also reflects the slow
inevitability of nature reclaiming its space.
This rhythmic disruption gives the reader a moment of apprehension, as if
they’re watching the houses begin their gradual slide into disrepair. The
caesura disrupts the flow, mirroring the loss of balance and the idea that
suburbia’s perfection is on the verge of collapse.
These rhythmic interruptions contribute to a psychological sense of unease, as the
reader is never allowed to settle into a predictable rhythm. The pauses mirror the
speaker’s inner discomfort and reflect the cracks in suburbia’s façade, making the
reading experience itself unsettling.
3. Internal Rhyme and Slant Rhyme as Symbols of Subconscious Tension
Atwood’s use of internal rhyme and slant rhyme creates subtle dissonances that
enhance the poem’s tone of unease. Unlike traditional rhyme schemes, which create a
sense of harmony, these slight rhymes produce a feeling of incomplete alignment,
mirroring the subtle flaws in suburbia’s attempt at perfection. Let’s look at some specific
examples:
1.
2.
Internal rhyme with “smell of spilled oil” and “lingering”:
○ The repetition of the ‘l’ sound in “smell,” “spilled,” and “lingering” produces
a faint internal rhyme that captures the sense of something unpleasant but
hidden. This subtle rhyme acts like an echo of decay that suburbia tries to
conceal, making the reader feel an underlying rot or sickness within the
polished exterior.
○ The faint internal rhyme here mirrors the subconscious awareness of
suppressed chaos. As the reader picks up on these subtle echoes, they are
subtly made aware of the discord beneath the surface, enhancing the
poem’s theme of hidden disorder.
Slant rhyme between “rebuke” and “surface”:
○ Although not a perfect rhyme, the near rhyme between “rebuke” and
“surface” feels slightly off, as if it is reaching for alignment but falls short.
This off-kilter rhyme reflects the uneasy alignment in suburbia, where
things appear ordered but are fundamentally misaligned with nature.
○ This slant rhyme creates a dissonant harmony, adding to the reader’s sense
of something being out of place. It mirrors the imperfections in suburbia’s
“perfect” surface, suggesting that human attempts at order are flawed and
incomplete.
Through these internal and slant rhymes, Atwood subtly emphasizes the fragility of
imposed order. These slight, imperfect rhymes create a dissonance that reflects the
hidden tension beneath the calm suburban surface, engaging the reader on a
subconscious level with the poem’s critique.
4. Linking Sound Patterns to Rhythmic Flow and Natural Forces
The interplay between enjambment and line breaks in The City Planners mirrors the
flowing, unstoppable quality of natural forces. Atwood’s use of line breaks that move
smoothly from one line to the next contrasts with the rigid structure of suburbia and
reflects the inevitability of nature reclaiming its place.
1.
2.
Enjambment in “houses, capsized, will slide / obliquely into the clay seas”:
○ The line flows naturally into the next without a pause, mirroring the gradual
movement of nature as it reclaims the landscape. This uninterrupted flow
creates a sense of inevitability, as if the reader is witnessing the slow but
unstoppable decay of suburbia. The enjambment mimics the fluidity of
natural forces, in contrast to the artificial, grid-like order of suburbia.
○ The rhythmic flow here reinforces the idea that nature cannot be truly
contained. By allowing the line to slide into the next, Atwood evokes the
relentless movement of glaciers, echoing nature’s slow, inevitable
reclamation.
Fluid Enjambment throughout the Poem:
○ In multiple instances, Atwood uses enjambment to create a natural rhythm
that resists the poem’s subject of controlled suburban landscapes. For
example, lines like “give momentary access to / the landscape behind or
under” flow continuously, symbolizing how nature’s presence is
constantly pushing through the imposed structures.
○ This fluidity reflects the tension between the natural world’s unpredictable
flow and the planners’ efforts to enforce order. By using enjambment to
create a rhythm that defies containment, Atwood subtly reinforces her
message that nature will ultimately prevail over human attempts at
control.
The seamless movement from line to line enhances the immersive quality of the poem,
as the reader is carried along in a rhythm that feels closer to the natural world than to
suburbia’s artificial order. This rhythmic flow reinforces the poem’s critique of human
control and suggests that nature, in its persistence, cannot be permanently subdued.
Conclusion
Through her choices in sound and rhythm, Atwood creates an auditory landscape that is
both constrained and subtly chaotic, mirroring the tension in suburbia’s attempt to
control nature. The sibilant sounds evoke a sense of suppressed energy, the caesuras and
pauses disrupt the rhythm to reflect hidden discomfort, and the internal and slant rhymes
create subconscious tension. Finally, the fluid enjambment reflects the unstoppable flow
of natural forces.
These sound patterns, rhythmic pauses, and rhyme choices make The City Planners not
only a visual critique of suburbia but also a sonic representation of tension and
impending decay. By engaging the reader’s auditory and psychological senses, Atwood
deepens her critique, allowing the reader to feel the constraints of suburbia and the
inevitable resurgence of nature. This expanded analysis reveals the full depth of how
rhyme, meter, and sound work together to create a multilayered, immersive experience
that reinforces the poem’s themes.
Let me know if this aligns with your vision or if there’s anything else I can expand upon!
Understood! I'll expand this analysis to make it as detailed and comprehensive as possible,
diving into each word choice, figurative device, and instance of imagery in The City
Planners, ensuring that every perspective, implication, and possible interpretation is fully
explored. Here’s a deep-dive into Section 4: Diction and Word Choice with every layer of
meaning, literary device, and connotation.
Section 4: Diction and Word Choice in The City Planners
Margaret Atwood’s diction in The City Planners reflects the underlying tension between
the sanitized, orderly suburban environment and the chaotic, uncontrollable forces of
nature. Every choice, from the formality of the language to the subtle connotations of
individual words, contributes to the poem’s critique of human attempts to dominate the
natural world.
Levels of Diction
1.
Formal vs. Informal Language:
Overall Formality: The poem’s language is deliberately formal and
detached. Words like “pedantic,” “sanitary,” and “rational” convey a clinical
tone, reflecting the mechanical, impersonal nature of suburbia. This formal
language, devoid of warmth or humanity, mirrors the sterile atmosphere of
the suburban landscape, emphasizing its inhuman, artificial quality.
○ Clinical and Detached Tone: This formality is intentional; it mirrors the
suburban residents’ attempt to distance themselves from natural forces
and imperfections. The speaker’s tone remains reserved and dispassionate,
highlighting the emotional and physical sterility of suburban life. For
example, using “sanitary” to describe trees suggests a need to remove any
sign of natural spontaneity or vitality, reinforcing the image of an overly
controlled, dehumanized environment.
Abstract vs. Concrete Language:
○ Abstract Concepts in Tangible Settings: Atwood balances abstract terms
with concrete descriptions, creating a contrast between ideals and reality.
Words like “sanities” and “hysteria” bring abstract concepts into the very
tangible setting of suburbia, inviting readers to see the tension between
human ideals of order and the unpredictable nature of reality. “Sanities”
implies a forced, superficial sense of control, while “hysteria” hints at a
deeper, unrestrained chaos that suburbia cannot fully contain.
○ Concrete Imagery with Specific Details: Concrete terms, such as “plaster,”
“oil,” “brick,” and “clay seas,” add sensory texture to the poem. These words
bring a vivid, tactile dimension to the poem, drawing attention to the
physical degradation beneath suburbia’s façade. For example, the
mention of “clay seas” evokes a powerful image of the land’s inevitable
erosion, suggesting that the planners’ structures are no match for nature’s
force.
○
2.
This mix of abstract and concrete language reflects the theme of suburban
impermanence. The abstract ideals of control (sanity, rationality) are overlaid onto
concrete physical elements that are subject to wear and decay, symbolizing the futility of
human efforts to dominate nature.
Connotation and Denotation
Atwood’s diction is laden with connotations that reveal deeper meanings beneath the
surface. Each word is chosen for both its literal and implied significance, creating a layered
reading experience.
1.
2.
3.
Literal vs. Implied Meaning:
○ “Sanities”: Literally, “sanities” refers to mental stability, but in this context, it
suggests an ironic critique of suburbia’s rigid order. The speaker finds this
“sanity” offensive because it implies an unquestioned conformity, as if the
planners believe that eradicating chaos equates to mental wellness. The
word implies that suburbia’s orderliness, though intended to be “sane,”
actually creates an environment that feels unnatural, oppressive, and
disturbingly stagnant.
○ “Hysteria”: Traditionally, “hysteria” denotes a loss of control or emotional
excess. Here, it represents the natural unpredictability and vitality that
suburbia suppresses. The use of “hysteria” suggests that the planners view
any deviation from uniformity as dangerous or irrational, highlighting
suburbia’s aversion to emotional depth, spontaneity, and chaos.
Positive and Negative Connotations:
○ “Pedantic rows”: “Pedantic” has a negative connotation, implying an
overemphasis on rules and trivial details. This word choice reflects the
suburban obsession with uniformity, as if houses and lawns must adhere to
strict guidelines to maintain a “perfect” appearance. The connotation here
suggests that suburbia’s meticulousness is both trivial and restrictive,
devoid of creativity or flexibility. The term “pedantic” evokes the planners’
tendency to value order over substance, reflecting Atwood’s critique of an
environment that prioritizes appearance over authenticity.
○ “Discouraged grass”: The word “discouraged” implies an emotional
suppression, anthropomorphizing the grass to reflect the stifling
atmosphere of suburbia. Rather than thriving, the grass is subdued, its
growth constrained by human intervention. This word choice hints at the
emotional and psychological impact of suburbia on its residents, as if life
itself is discouraged within this setting. The negative connotation of
“discouraged” reinforces the sense that suburbia represses natural
impulses, stifling any sign of vitality or individuality.
Double Meanings and Ambiguity:
○ “Rational whine of a power mower”: The word “whine” has a dual
meaning, both as an actual sound and as an expression of complaint or
dissatisfaction. The mower’s “whine” reflects suburbia’s monotonous
routine, suggesting that even the machines in this environment express a
kind of resigned complaint. The mower’s sound is described as “rational,”
implying that this routine is deemed logical or necessary, yet the word
○
“whine” hints at an underlying discomfort with this order. This subtle
dissonance between “rational” and “whine” suggests that suburbia’s order
may be logical, but it is also inherently unsatisfying.
“Clay seas”: The phrase “clay seas” has a layered interpretation. On one
level, it refers to the earth’s natural erosion, with clay symbolizing the
foundation of the land. However, the word “seas” introduces an image of
something vast and uncontrollable, contrasting with suburbia’s artificial
order. This phrase suggests that, despite the planners’ efforts, the land is
ultimately a force of nature that cannot be restrained. The connotation of
“seas” as boundless and powerful underscores the inevitability of nature’s
reclaiming force, adding a sense of looming threat beneath suburbia’s
stable surface.
Figurative Language and Imagery
Atwood’s figurative language in The City Planners enriches the poem’s critique of
suburbia, using personification, simile, metaphor, and vivid imagery to bring out the
hidden tensions and underlying decay within the suburban landscape.
1.
2.
Visual Imagery:
○ “Pedantic rows” and “sanitary trees”: These phrases create an image of
unnaturally neat and lifeless suburban streets. The “pedantic rows” of
houses evoke a vision of conformity, suggesting that individuality has been
sacrificed for uniformity. “Sanitary trees” implies that even nature has been
stripped of its wildness, molded to fit suburban ideals of cleanliness. This
image reflects the forced conformity and artificiality of suburbia, as if the
planners view even trees as objects to be sterilized and regulated.
○ “Splash of paint on brick surprising as a bruise”: Atwood uses a simile to
compare an imperfection on a wall to a “bruise.” This unexpected flaw in
the otherwise pristine setting hints at the hidden damage within suburbia.
The image of a bruise, a mark caused by an injury, suggests that suburbia’s
apparent perfection conceals internal wounds or weaknesses. This visual
detail symbolizes the suppressed imperfections and inevitable breakdown
beneath the suburb’s polished surface.
Auditory Imagery:
○ “Rational whine of a power mower”: This auditory imagery captures the
mechanical, repetitive sounds of suburban life. The “whine” of the mower
suggests a lifeless routine, as if the machinery itself is weary of its task.
Describing the sound as “rational” implies that this order is maintained out
of a sense of duty rather than desire, adding to the sense of enforced
monotony. The grating, repetitive sound of the mower symbolizes the
soulless regularity of suburbia, where even sounds are stripped of
emotional depth.
○ “Lingering sickness”: The phrase “lingering sickness” conveys both an
unpleasant smell and a sense of decay. The smell of “spilled oil” lingers like
an illness, symbolizing the underlying rot within suburbia. This auditory and
olfactory imagery suggests that, despite its sanitized appearance, suburbia
is marked by traces of decay and contamination, further emphasizing the
poem’s critique of human efforts to create an idealized environment.
3. Tactile Imagery:
○ “Plastic hose poised in a vicious coil”: This tactile image of a coiled hose
evokes a sense of latent threat. The “vicious coil” suggests that even
ordinary objects within suburbia possess a concealed danger, as if
suppressed aggression lies beneath the calm surface. Describing the hose
as “poised” adds tension, as though it is ready to strike, reflecting the
hostility and instability that lurks within the suburban landscape.
4. Symbolism:
○ “Sanities” and “hysteria”: These terms symbolize the duality between
order and chaos. “Sanities” represents the planners’ attempts to impose
rationality and control, while “hysteria” symbolizes the unpredictable,
emotional side of nature. This symbolic opposition reflects the central
theme of the poem: that human constructs of order are fragile and
ultimately incompatible with the natural world.
○ “Cracks in the plaster”: The cracks symbolize the inevitable flaws within
the suburban environment. Despite suburbia’s polished surface, these
“future cracks” foreshadow its eventual breakdown, suggesting that no
amount of control can fully contain or eliminate the forces of decay and
entropy. This symbol underscores Atwood’s critique that suburban
perfection is superficial and temporary.
5. Personification:
○ “The houses in pedantic rows”: The houses are personified as being
“pedantic,” as if they enforce a strict adherence to rules. This personification
reflects the rigid, lifeless order of suburbia, where even inanimate structures
seem to embody the planners’ obsession with uniformity.
○ “The driveways neatly sidestep hysteria”: This line personifies the
driveways as actively avoiding hysteria, symbolizing suburbia’s attempt to
suppress any hint of chaos. The use of “sidestep” suggests a calculated
avoidance, as if the suburban environment is designed to dodge or evade
any signs of disorder.
6. Simile:
○ “Surprising as a bruise”: The comparison of a paint splash to a bruise
underscores the sense of suppressed injury within suburbia. This simile
suggests that even minor flaws within the landscape carry a deeper
significance, hinting at a hidden vulnerability that suburbia seeks to
conceal.
7. Metaphor:
○ “Rational whine of a power mower”: This metaphor captures the
soul-draining monotony of suburbia, with the mower’s whine symbolizing
the lifeless routine of maintaining an artificial landscape. It serves as a
metaphor for the tedium of suburban life, where even the tools of
maintenance seem to lament their role in enforcing this sterile order.
Conclusion
Atwood’s careful diction in The City Planners reveals layers of meaning within the
suburban landscape. Through formal language, layered connotations, and a rich tapestry
of imagery and figurative language, Atwood creates a critique of suburbia’s rigid control,
showing how this order masks underlying chaos and decay. This exhaustive analysis
uncovers every layer of Atwood’s language, demonstrating how her word choices enhance
the poem’s thematic complexity and depth. Let me know if there’s anything else you’d like
to explore!
1. Additional Symbolic Interpretations of Key Words
Margaret Atwood’s diction choices in words like “sanities” and “vicious coil” carry layered
symbolic meanings that reveal the psychological and cultural undercurrents of
suburban life.
●
●
“Sanities”:
○ This word, on the surface, denotes mental stability. However, within the
poem, it also symbolizes suburbia’s attempt to impose a cultural standard
of normality and conformity. By choosing this word, Atwood suggests that
suburbia’s environment enforces a specific, restrictive definition of sanity. In
the social context of suburbia, where uniformity is valued, individual
eccentricities or deviations are often stifled or viewed as dangerous,
potentially “insane.” This word choice critiques how the planners—through
physical order and control—seek to define what is “sane” in a way that is
ultimately repressive and unnatural.
○ Furthermore, “sanities” carries an ironic tone; the forced, rigid order of
suburbia is itself counter to natural balance. In this way, Atwood subtly
questions the true nature of sanity within a context where every detail is
controlled to the point of lifelessness. The word “sanities” becomes symbolic
of society’s collective aversion to natural variation, suggesting that
suburbia’s sanity may actually verge on madness.
“Plastic hose poised in a vicious coil”:
○ The phrase “vicious coil” contains layers of symbolism. First, it evokes an
image of a snake, which is often associated with latent danger or betrayal.
In this context, the “plastic hose” symbolizes the suburban infrastructure
that, though seemingly benign, contains an underlying hostility or violence.
This phrase subtly conveys that suburbia’s control over nature is not only
unnatural but also inherently oppressive, holding an insidious threat
beneath its surface.
○ The hose, an artificial object designed to control water (and by extension,
nature), represents suburbia’s attempt to harness and regulate the
natural world. Its “vicious” form indicates that this control comes at a cost,
introducing an element of aggression into an otherwise peaceful setting.
The connotation of “vicious” in this context suggests that suburbia’s quiet
appearance masks a more hostile stance against the natural world, as if
ready to lash out at any sign of wildness.
2. Layered Analysis of Ambiguity in Word Choice
Atwood’s diction is carefully chosen to incorporate ambiguity in specific terms, inviting
readers to explore multiple meanings that enrich the poem’s thematic depth.
●
●
“Clay seas”:
○ This phrase combines two seemingly incongruous elements: “clay,” a
malleable material, and “seas,” a vast, uncontrollable force. On one level,
“clay” represents the foundation of suburbia—the soil and land on which it
is built—while “seas” alludes to the immense power of natural elements
that cannot be contained. The words together imply that, despite human
attempts to mold and shape the earth, it remains connected to a greater,
unpredictable natural force.
○ The image of “clay seas” also has connotations of earth being reshaped by
human intervention, as clay is pliable and can be molded. However, in this
context, it carries a sense of irony, as the phrase suggests that suburbia’s
foundation is not truly stable. By using “clay” instead of a more solid
material like stone, Atwood implies that the foundations of suburbia are
weak and malleable, susceptible to erosion. This layer of meaning positions
suburbia as inherently fragile, built on an unsound foundation that nature
will inevitably reclaim.
○ Additionally, “seas” introduces an emotional resonance, evoking feelings of
vastness, depth, and mystery. This expands the meaning of suburbia
beyond a physical space to a psychological one, where human control is an
illusion against the greater power of nature. The ambiguous nature of “clay
seas” prompts the reader to consider suburbia as both a tangible place and
a metaphor for human attempts to dominate the unknowable.
“Rational whine of a power mower”:
○ The phrase “rational whine” is particularly rich in its ambiguity. “Rational”
suggests a logical, routine action, while “whine” conveys a sense of
complaint or dissatisfaction. This subtle contradiction within a single phrase
invites readers to consider how suburbia’s rational order is itself unnatural
and inherently unsatisfying.
○ The “whine” could be interpreted as the sound of suburbia itself, emitting a
low, insistent complaint against its enforced conformity. Alternatively, it
could symbolize the emotional cost of suburban life—the monotony, the
weariness, and the underlying sense of discontent that accompanies this
lifestyle. The ambiguity of this word choice makes suburbia’s order seem
hollow, as if even the machinery resents its repetitive, mindless task.
○ This line also suggests that suburbia’s attempts at rationality are, in a way,
mechanically enforced. The rational “whine” might imply a forced order
that is sustained by routine maintenance, with the mower symbolizing the
constant upkeep required to preserve suburbia’s image. This reading
presents suburban order as both labor-intensive and ultimately
unsustainable, reinforcing the poem’s critique of artificial control.
3. Deepened Examination of Diction and Tone Shifts
Examining subtle shifts in tone, especially through Atwood’s choice of descriptive words,
can further highlight how diction reflects the poem’s tension between surface order and
underlying chaos.
●
●
Tone Shift from “sanitary trees” to “vicious coil”:
○ At the beginning of the poem, words like “sanitary” and “pedantic”
emphasize suburbia’s artificial cleanliness, reflecting a tone of sterility and
order. This shifts dramatically as we encounter phrases like “vicious coil” and
“bruise,” which introduce a darker, more ominous tone. These words reveal
hints of hostility beneath suburbia’s calm surface, suggesting that the very
order imposed on the environment conceals latent aggression.
○ The transition from clinical, detached diction to more intense, suggestive
words mirrors the unveiling of suburbia’s true nature. Initially, the tone
suggests a facade of calm control; however, as the speaker delves deeper,
this control is revealed to be unstable, with cracks emerging that
foreshadow a collapse. This shift from sterile to hostile diction aligns with
Atwood’s theme that human attempts to enforce order are inherently
flawed and unsustainable.
○ By tracking this shift, we see how Atwood’s word choice guides the reader
through a transformation from calm observance to unease, revealing the
creeping instability that lurks beneath suburbia’s surface. Each shift in tone
subtly foreshadows the eventual “capsizing” of suburbia, aligning the
diction with the poem’s narrative arc of decay.
Evolving Tone in Words Associated with Suburbia’s Decay:
○ Atwood’s choice of words such as “lingering sickness,” “bruise,” and “cracks”
contributes to a deteriorating tone, reflecting how suburbia’s facade of
perfection is progressively destabilized. Each of these terms hints at a
subtle, almost imperceptible degradation, suggesting that suburbia is in a
constant state of slow erosion.
○ Words like “lingering” imply something that is not easily dispelled, hinting
at a persistent decay that suburbia cannot fully suppress. This tone shift
deepens the reader’s awareness of suburbia’s temporariness, contrasting
with the initial sterility and rationality presented in the first lines.
○ As Atwood introduces these words, the diction becomes increasingly
imbued with a sense of foreboding, reflecting the gradual erosion of the
suburban landscape and reinforcing the theme that suburbia’s order is a
temporary illusion.
4. Additional Layers in Imagery Interpretation
Delving further into Atwood’s imagery reveals a multi-sensory experience that evokes
emotional responses tied to suburbia’s repressed chaos and artificial order.
●
Enhanced Olfactory and Auditory Interpretation of “Lingering Sickness”:
○ The phrase “lingering sickness” does more than evoke a general sense of
decay; it also appeals to the olfactory senses, inviting readers to imagine
the unpleasant smell of “spilled oil” and other residual pollutants. This
subtle sensory detail enhances the physical discomfort of suburbia,
●
suggesting that despite its sanitized appearance, suburbia is pervaded by a
faint, inescapable odor of deterioration.
○ The word “lingering” also implies that this sickness is not merely a passing
sensation but a persistent stain on the suburban landscape. It conveys the
idea that suburbia is plagued by an underlying malaise that cannot be
removed, mirroring the hidden imperfections that the planners attempt to
suppress. This olfactory imagery heightens the reader’s visceral response,
intensifying the poem’s critique of suburbia’s facade.
Expanded Interpretation of “Rational Whine of a Power Mower”:
○ Beyond auditory imagery, the “whine of a power mower” symbolizes
enforced productivity and order, as if the constant sound reflects an
unyielding need to maintain appearance. The repetitive whine suggests the
monotony of suburban upkeep, a chore that both physically and
psychologically grates on the senses.
○ This sound could also represent suburbia’s underlying irritability, a subtle
complaint against the tedium of uniformity. The “whine” is not just a sound
but an expression of suburbia’s dissatisfaction with its own forced
cleanliness, an auditory metaphor for the discontent simmering within its
carefully managed order.
5. Historical and Cultural Context to Enhance Symbolism
Adding context about mid-20th century suburban expansion allows readers to see
Atwood’s critique as a broader commentary on post-war conformity and consumerism.
●
Suburbia as a Product of Post-War Consumerism:
○ Atwood’s imagery of “pedantic rows” and “sanitary trees” echoes the
post-World War II boom in suburban development, which valued uniformity
and conformity as symbols of stability and success. These words evoke a
historical moment when suburban life was idealized as a sanitized refuge
from urban chaos, representing a societal shift towards consumerism and
materialism.
○ By using diction that highlights the artificiality and homogeneity of
suburbia, Atwood critiques the cultural pressures of this period, suggesting
that suburbia’s order is ultimately an illusion masking deeper discontent.
This historical perspective enriches the poem’s themes, framing suburbia’s
sterility as a byproduct of cultural expectations that promote order at the
expense of individuality and connection to nature.
Incorporating these nuanced perspectives, Atwood’s diction emerges as a complex and
layered critique of suburbia, imbued with cultural commentary and psychological depth
that invites readers to question the stability of human-made order. Let me know if you’d
like further detail on any point!
Section 5: Tone and Mood in The City Planners
In The City Planners, Margaret Atwood crafts an intricate tone and mood that guide the
reader from a detached critique of suburbia’s order to a sense of existential despair. This
tonal journey mirrors the poem’s broader commentary on the human desire to impose
control over nature. Atwood’s tone shifts gradually, from a critical detachment tinged with
irony to a foreboding sense of inevitability, while the mood moves from superficial calm to
unsettling tension, eventually reaching an atmosphere of bleak inevitability. Let’s examine
these elements in finer detail.
Defining Tone
1.
Speaker’s Attitude Toward the Subject:
○
○
○
Initial Critical Detachment:
■ At the start, Atwood’s tone is one of cold, almost clinical
detachment. She chooses words like “pedantic rows,” “sanitary
trees,” and “discouraged grass” to convey a sense of suburban life
that is overly controlled and devoid of vitality. The use of “pedantic”
conveys a condescending attitude, as if the planners’ obsession with
uniformity is trivial and meaningless. The tone is passive yet tinged
with irony, suggesting that the speaker finds the efforts of the
planners to be both futile and absurd.
■ This tone of critical detachment establishes the speaker’s attitude
toward suburbia as something to be observed from a distance. The
word choices reveal a disdain for suburbia’s lifeless, “sane”
landscape. The speaker’s tone implies that this environment,
though orderly, is ultimately alienating, devoid of any genuine
connection to the natural world.
Ironic Tone of Subtle Condemnation:
■ Through Atwood’s diction, an ironic tone of condemnation is subtly
woven into the poem. Words like “sanitary” and “rational whine” are
seemingly neutral, yet in context, they suggest a mockery of the
planners’ attempts to create a “perfect” landscape. The irony lies in
the fact that these words, typically associated with order and
cleanliness, reveal a landscape that feels sterile and artificial.
■ The tone here suggests that the speaker perceives suburbia’s efforts
to control nature as inherently flawed. By using words that imply
cleanliness and order, Atwood critiques the planners’ belief that
their efforts to sterilize and rationalize the natural world are
desirable or meaningful. This ironic tone sets up a subtext of
condemnation, as if the speaker is calling out the planners for their
misguided approach.
Underlying Tone of Resigned Disapproval:
■ Alongside this ironic detachment, there’s an undertone of resigned
disapproval. Phrases like “sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass”
imply that the speaker views suburbia’s sterility as both
disappointing and inevitable. The speaker’s tone, while critical, also
■
2.
3.
carries a sense of quiet resignation, as if they’ve accepted that
suburbia is beyond salvation.
This resignation deepens the critique, as it suggests that the speaker
has lost hope for suburbia’s redemption. The tone hints that,
despite recognizing suburbia’s flaws, the speaker believes these
flaws to be irreversible. This resignation aligns with Atwood’s larger
critique of humanity’s hubris in thinking it can control nature,
adding a layer of futility to the tone.
Shift in Tone:
○ Transition to Discomfort and Disdain:
■ As the poem progresses, the tone shifts from detached observation
to discomfort and disdain. This shift is marked by phrases like
“lingering sickness” and “vicious coil,” which introduce a sense of
underlying threat within suburbia. These words suggest that,
beneath the surface, suburbia harbors hidden dangers. The tone
becomes increasingly disdainful, reflecting the speaker’s growing
awareness of suburbia’s concealed flaws.
■ This tonal shift is crucial, as it signals a move from passive critique to
a more active disdain. The speaker is no longer just observing but is
now fully aware of the disturbing aspects of suburbia’s façade. This
change in tone adds depth to the critique, as it reveals that
suburbia’s apparent perfection is not only hollow but actively
harmful.
○ Final Shift to Doom and Inevitability:
■ The tone takes on an even darker edge in the final stanzas, where
phrases like “future cracks in the plaster” and “houses, capsized, will
slide” suggest an atmosphere of imminent doom. Here, the tone
shifts to one of inevitability, as if the speaker is resigned to the
collapse of suburbia. This resignation is underscored by Atwood’s
use of words that imply gradual decay and disintegration, evoking a
sense of existential inevitability.
■ In this final tonal shift, Atwood aligns the speaker’s attitude with a
broader philosophical perspective: the belief that human attempts
to control nature are not only futile but also doomed to failure. This
tone of inevitability underscores the poem’s central theme,
suggesting that suburbia’s artificial order will ultimately succumb to
the forces of nature.
Techniques That Establish Tone:
○ Word Choice and Irony:
■ Atwood’s choice of words like “sanitary” and “rational” adds an ironic
undertone to the tone, as these words typically imply positive
qualities, yet here they are used to highlight suburbia’s lifelessness.
The irony in these word choices suggests that suburbia’s order,
though rational, is emotionally hollow. This technique allows Atwood
to subtly critique suburbia’s artificial values without overtly stating
her disapproval.
○ Contrasting Imagery and Personification:
■ The imagery of “sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass” contrasts
sharply with the phrase “vicious coil,” which suggests hidden
○
aggression. This contrast in imagery reflects the poem’s shifting
tone, as the speaker’s attitude evolves from detached observation to
disdainful awareness. Personifying the grass as “discouraged”
further emphasizes the tone of suppressed vitality, hinting that
suburbia’s order is achieved at the cost of natural energy and
growth.
Gradual Build of Dark Metaphors:
■ Atwood uses metaphors like “lingering sickness” and “future cracks
in the plaster” to suggest that suburbia’s order is deteriorating
beneath the surface. These metaphors create a tone of subtle
foreboding, as if the speaker is uncovering the hidden rot within
suburbia. This technique allows the tone to shift organically, from
passive critique to a sense of doom, aligning the speaker’s attitude
with Atwood’s overarching themes of decay and entropy.
Mood
1.
Impact on Reader:
○
○
○
Mood of Superficial Calm and Stifling Uniformity:
■ At the beginning of the poem, the mood is one of superficial
tranquility. Words like “sanitary trees” and “pedantic rows” convey a
sense of stifling uniformity, creating a mood that is calm but
unnaturally so. This mood reflects the sanitized, controlled
environment of suburbia, where every element is meticulously
arranged to avoid chaos.
■ However, this calmness feels forced, as if imposed by the planners.
The reader senses that the landscape is too perfect, too organized,
and this perfection evokes a subtle feeling of discomfort. Atwood’s
diction creates a tense, stifling atmosphere that mirrors suburbia’s
oppressive order. This mood of stifling calm invites readers to feel
the weight of suburbia’s conformity, drawing them into the
speaker’s perspective.
Building Unease and Subdued Tension:
■ As Atwood introduces phrases like “lingering sickness” and “vicious
coil,” the mood shifts to one of underlying tension and unease.
These words hint that suburbia’s order is not as stable as it appears,
creating a sense of discomfort that unsettles the reader. The calm,
controlled surface is now marred by signs of hidden decay, evoking a
mood that is tense and foreboding.
■ This mood of unease is crucial to Atwood’s critique, as it mirrors the
poem’s theme that suburbia’s perfection is only skin-deep. The
reader is invited to sense the fragility of suburbia’s structure, as if
the landscape could crumble at any moment. This shift from calm to
tension reflects the speaker’s deepening awareness of suburbia’s
flaws, immersing the reader in an atmosphere of growing
discomfort.
Final Mood of Existential Despair:
In the closing lines, the mood shifts once more to one of existential
despair and bleak inevitability. Words like “future cracks,” “houses,
capsized,” and “clay seas” evoke images of gradual collapse and
erosion, as if suburbia is doomed to decay. This mood of despair
reflects the speaker’s resignation to the forces of nature, suggesting
that suburbia’s order will ultimately be undone.
■ This final mood shift reinforces Atwood’s central message: that
human attempts to impose order on nature are futile. By creating a
mood of existential despair, Atwood leaves the reader with a sense
of vulnerability, as if they too are subject to the unstoppable forces of
decay. This mood amplifies the poem’s impact, leaving the reader
with a profound sense of suburbia’s transience and insignificance.
How Mood Changes:
○ From Tranquility to Latent Tension:
■ The poem begins with a mood of calm and order, reflecting
suburbia’s sanitized environment. However, this tranquility quickly
shifts to latent tension as words like “lingering sickness” introduce a
sense of hidden decay. This shift in mood mirrors the thematic
development of the poem, as the speaker moves from detached
observation to an awareness of suburbia’s concealed flaws.
■ This tension builds gradually, with each line adding a layer of
discomfort. The reader senses that suburbia’s order is tenuous, held
together by a fragile structure. This transition from calm to tension
aligns with Atwood’s critique of suburbia’s unsustainable order,
drawing the reader deeper into the poem’s atmosphere of
controlled unease.
○ Final Shift to Bleak Despair:
■ In the final stanzas, the mood shifts from tension to a sense of bleak
inevitability. As the speaker envisions suburbia’s eventual collapse,
the mood becomes one of existential despair, reflecting the futility
of suburbia’s control. This shift reinforces Atwood’s theme that
human structures are ultimately powerless against nature’s forces.
■ The shift to despair leaves the reader with a sense of existential
vulnerability, as if they too are subject to the inevitable decay of all
human creations. This mood mirrors the poem’s closing lines, where
the speaker resigns to the eventual collapse of suburbia. By ending
on this note, Atwood leaves a lasting impression of suburbia’s
transience and the unstoppable power of nature.
■
2.
Conclusion
This expanded analysis of tone and mood in The City Planners offers a multi-dimensional
view of how Atwood’s language, imagery, and shifts in tone shape the poem’s emotional
landscape. Each tonal shift—from detached critique to foreboding and finally to
despair—invites the reader to share in the speaker’s disillusionment with suburbia’s
artificiality. The mood transitions from calm to tense and finally to despair, reflecting
Atwood’s critique that human attempts to control nature are ultimately futile. Let me
know if there are any other areas you’d like to expand further or specific perspectives to
add!
1. Layered Interpretations for Tone and Mood Transitions
Expanding on the psychological journey of the speaker helps reveal the poem as an
unfolding realization. Atwood’s tone shifts progressively from a calm, detached
observation to a deeper understanding of the bleak consequences of suburbia’s rigid
control.
●
●
From Curiosity to Disillusionment:
○ Initially, the speaker’s tone could be seen as detached curiosity. Atwood’s
word choices, like “sanitary trees” and “pedantic rows,” suggest a clinical
observation, as though the speaker is trying to understand suburbia as an
organized, controlled experiment. However, this observation lacks warmth
or appreciation for what the speaker sees, already suggesting an underlying
critique.
○ As the speaker examines suburbia more closely, the tone shifts to reveal an
emotional response—one of subdued dissatisfaction and discomfort. This
progression reflects the speaker’s growing awareness of suburbia’s flaws, as
well as a creeping disillusionment with its sterility. This change mirrors the
psychological process of awakening to the unsettling reality beneath the
surface.
Growing Discomfort to Existential Despair:
○ The final shift in tone toward foreboding and despair suggests that the
speaker has moved from detached critique to a profound recognition of
suburbia’s limitations. Phrases like “houses, capsized” and “future cracks”
reflect not just physical decay but also a sense of philosophical
disillusionment. At this stage, the speaker’s tone seems to mourn the loss
of what suburbia could have represented—community, nature, and
vitality—underscoring the existential weight of this realization.
○ This layered tonal journey reflects a broader thematic arc, where the
speaker’s personal disillusionment with suburbia serves as a symbolic
critique of human attempts to dominate nature. The tonal shift from
detachment to despair captures the speaker’s growing understanding that
suburbia’s promise of perfection is both unsustainable and fundamentally
empty.
2. Exploring the Contrast Between Tone and Mood for Added
Complexity
The contrast between the speaker’s tone and the mood of the suburban landscape is a
powerful technique that emphasizes the psychological disconnect between outward
appearances and underlying realities.
●
Tone as Critical, Mood as Ominous:
○ At the start, the tone is marked by ironic detachment, observing suburbia’s
layout with mild disdain. However, the mood created by Atwood’s
diction—words like “sanitary” and “rational whine”—is unsettling and
●
subtly ominous. This contrast suggests that even though the speaker
seems calm, the environment carries a hidden menace. The irony of the
tone against the eerie mood highlights the speaker’s recognition that
suburbia’s control over nature is inherently unstable.
○ This discord reflects the internal contradictions of suburbia, where a
controlled, sanitized environment conceals deeper, more chaotic forces. The
contrast between tone and mood serves to critique the superficial calm of
suburbia, suggesting that beneath this placid exterior lies a simmering
instability that the planners cannot contain.
Emphasizing Psychological Repression:
○ This tone-mood contrast can be interpreted as a commentary on
psychological repression within suburban life. The detached tone
represents the speaker’s critical distance from the emotional impact of
suburbia’s sterility, while the unsettling mood reflects the psychological
cost of this control. This juxtaposition highlights the ways in which suburbia
represses individuality, spontaneity, and natural vitality, mirroring a society
that values conformity over authentic connection.
○ The tone and mood, working in opposition, underscore Atwood’s critique of
suburban values. The cheerful facade of order and control becomes a mask,
hiding a darker emotional landscape that threatens to break through,
much like the natural world underlying the paved streets and manicured
lawns.
3. Symbolic Interpretation of Mood as a Reflection of Suburban
Life’s Lifecycle
Examining the poem’s mood shifts as symbolic representations of the lifecycle of
suburban idealism allows for a richer socio-historical analysis. Atwood’s mood
transitions—from superficial calm to tension and finally to despair—can be seen as a
metaphor for the rise, peak, and eventual disillusionment with post-war suburban
expansion.
●
●
Superficial Calm as Idealized Suburbia:
○ The initial mood of forced tranquility, established by phrases like “pedantic
rows” and “sanitary trees,” reflects the idealized version of suburbia that
emerged in post-war culture. This mood evokes the initial allure of
suburban life, with its promise of safety, order, and uniformity, offering a
controlled, almost utopian environment for families.
○ However, Atwood’s language reveals that this mood of calm is superficial,
creating an atmosphere that feels slightly strained, as if forced conformity
is hiding something darker. This shift critiques the cultural idealism of
suburbia, hinting at the repressed tensions beneath its surface.
Tension as Disillusionment:
○ The introduction of words like “vicious coil” and “lingering sickness” signifies
a shift to a mood of tension and unease, symbolizing the dawning
realization of suburbia’s flaws. This shift represents the disillusionment
with the suburban dream, as people began to realize that uniformity and
control could not bring true contentment or harmony.
This mood of tension mirrors the historical period when suburban
expansion faced criticism for its environmental impact, social isolation, and
lack of community. By aligning the mood with this cultural critique, Atwood
uses suburbia’s mood shifts as a symbol of society’s disillusionment with
the superficial values it once embraced.
Despair as Suburbia’s Decline:
○ The final mood of despair and inevitability, encapsulated by phrases like
“capsized” and “clay seas,” suggests that suburbia is fated to decay and
dissolve. This mood represents the decline of suburban idealism, a final
realization that control over nature is futile and unsustainable.
○ Atwood’s bleak portrayal of suburbia’s end mirrors a broader cultural
narrative: that the human pursuit of order, structure, and perfection often
leads to disenchantment and collapse. This mood shift reflects Atwood’s
larger theme that attempts to control or constrain nature are bound to fail,
leaving a sense of emptiness in their wake.
○
●
4. Enhanced Analysis of Tone through Sound and Rhythm
By examining the sound and rhythm of Atwood’s language, we can gain further insight
into how the tone of the poem conveys a sense of lifeless monotony and latent hostility
within suburbia.
●
●
Sound as Reinforcing Monotony and Discomfort:
○ Atwood’s phrase “rational whine of a power mower” uses repetitive sounds
that evoke the grating monotony of suburbia’s maintenance routines.
The “whine” suggests a high-pitched, irritating noise, one that becomes
increasingly grating the longer it persists. This auditory image emphasizes
the tone of detached irritation, as if the speaker can barely tolerate the
oppressive monotony.
○ The rhythmic sound of the power mower also mirrors the mechanized and
repetitive nature of suburban life. The constancy of this sound reflects the
tone of suffocating control, suggesting that suburbia’s tranquility is
maintained at the cost of relentless, repetitive labor. This interpretation
aligns with Atwood’s critique of the emptiness of suburban values, where
life is drained of spontaneity in favor of imposed routines.
Caesura and Enjambment as Markers of Tone Shifts:
○ Atwood’s use of caesura and enjambment can be analyzed as markers of
tonal shifts. In lines where phrases like “lingering sickness” and “vicious coil”
introduce unsettling ideas, the rhythm shifts subtly to disrupt the flow,
reflecting a shift from calm to discomfort. These pauses and disruptions in
rhythm mirror the speaker’s tone of growing unease, as if the carefully
constructed language itself begins to “crack.”
○ This rhythmic dissonance reinforces the critique of suburbia’s artificial
stability. Just as the poem’s rhythm breaks down to reflect tonal shifts, the
controlled environment of suburbia conceals fractures that will eventually
emerge. The rhythm, then, serves as an auditory reflection of suburbia’s
vulnerability, emphasizing the speaker’s awareness of its inevitable collapse.
5. Connotations of Nature and Tone’s Relationship to
Environmental Critique
Atwood’s final tone of despair can be seen as a call for environmental awareness,
positioning suburbia’s eventual decay as a critique of humanity’s ecological footprint.
●
●
Tone as a Plea for Environmental Realism:
○ In viewing Atwood’s tone as a warning about human impact on nature,
we see the tone of inevitability and despair as an acknowledgment of
nature’s ability to reclaim the land. Phrases like “clay seas” and “gradual as
glaciers” suggest a natural world that will eventually overpower human
creations. This tone of inevitability can be read as a subtle plea for
environmental humility, urging readers to recognize the limits of human
control.
○ This reading aligns Atwood’s critique of suburbia with her broader
environmental activism. By portraying suburbia’s order as doomed,
Atwood’s tone highlights the unsustainable nature of human
encroachment on the environment. Her tone of despair thus serves as a
cautionary reminder of the consequences of ecological arrogance.
Personifying Nature as an Unstoppable Force:
○ The final tone positions nature as an entity with agency, capable of eroding
suburbia’s structures over time. Phrases like “capsized” and “slide obliquely”
personify nature as an unstoppable force that reclaims what humans
attempt to control. The speaker’s tone shifts to respect, almost resignation,
as they confront nature’s ultimate power.
○ This environmental tone suggests that suburbia’s control is a temporary
illusion, one that nature will inevitably dismantle. By ending the poem with
this tone, Atwood leaves the reader with a lasting impression of nature’s
enduring dominance, suggesting that human creations are fleeting in
comparison.
Conclusion
This expanded analysis enriches our understanding of Atwood’s use of tone and mood in
The City Planners. Each suggestion provides additional layers, from the symbolic arc of
suburbia’s lifecycle to environmental critique, enhancing the analysis of how tone and
mood convey the speaker’s complex relationship with suburbia. Let me know if you'd like
to delve further into any specific aspect or add even more depth to particular areas!
Section 6: Theme and Message Analysis of The City Planners
In The City Planners, Margaret Atwood delves deeply into the themes of humanity’s
control over nature, environmental inevitability, conformity, and spiritual emptiness,
weaving together a critique that is both societal and existential. Atwood’s language,
imagery, and structure create a complex tapestry, drawing the reader into her perspective
on the absurdity and arrogance of modern suburbia. Each theme acts as a facet of this
critique, peeling back layers of Atwood’s observations on human ambition and its futility
against the vast, uncontrollable power of the natural world.
1. Humanity’s Attempt to Control Nature
In The City Planners, one of the most prominent themes is humanity’s obsessive drive to
impose order on nature. Atwood uses the suburban landscape as a symbol of human
control, where the city planners’ attempts to sanitize and organize nature into neat,
repetitive patterns reveal a fundamental arrogance. This desire to control is captured in
the poem’s imagery, diction, and ironic tone.
●
●
Human Control Through Sterility and Order:
○ Atwood begins by establishing a calm, controlled environment with
phrases like “sanitary trees” and “pedantic rows.” These descriptors
immediately hint at suburbia’s artificial quality, as if nature has been
disciplined into strict, unnatural forms. The use of “sanitary” suggests a
sterile cleanliness, but when applied to trees, it evokes an image of life
stripped of its organic qualities. Trees, symbols of growth and vitality, are
made to appear clean and orderly, devoid of the very wildness that defines
them.
○ This attempt to organize and sterilize nature implies a deep-seated human
arrogance, as if people believe they can control the unpredictable through
superficial efforts. By presenting suburbia in this way, Atwood highlights
the absurdity of believing that something as complex and uncontrollable as
nature can be reduced to repetitive patterns.
Irony and Hubris in Human Ambition:
○ Atwood’s tone in describing these suburban features is laced with irony,
particularly when she refers to the “sanities” of suburbia. This word choice is
revealing: while “sanity” usually conveys rationality and order, in Atwood’s
portrayal, it becomes a kind of madness. The planners’ quest to sanitize and
control becomes an ironic “insanity,” wherein their very rationality exposes
them to ridicule. The poem implies that in attempting to sidestep chaos,
humanity has become fixated on an ideal that is ultimately unachievable.
○ This ironic depiction of human control reflects Atwood’s broader critique of
human hubris. By showing the artificiality of suburbia’s order, Atwood
suggests that such efforts are ultimately meaningless and absurd.
Humanity’s attempt to control nature is not only foolish but also harmful, as
it suppresses the natural world’s inherent vitality.
2. Environmental Inevitability and Nature’s Power
A closely related theme in The City Planners is the inevitability of nature’s dominance.
Atwood presents nature as a powerful, enduring force that will ultimately reclaim the
artificial order imposed upon it. This theme speaks to Atwood’s environmental
perspective, wherein human structures, no matter how rigid, are temporary against the
timelessness of nature.
●
●
Nature as an Inevitable Force:
○ Atwood’s language becomes almost prophetic when she speaks of “future
cracks in the plaster” and the image of “houses, capsized.” These phrases
conjure a sense of gradual decay, as though nature is lying in wait, biding its
time until it can reassert its dominance. The description of “houses,
capsized” emphasizes the fragility of human creations; a house, normally a
symbol of stability, is portrayed as a vessel overturned, helpless in the face of
natural forces.
○ By using words like “cracks” and “capsized,” Atwood implies that no matter
how perfect or sturdy humanity’s constructions appear, they are bound to
disintegrate over time. The planners’ work is impermanent, vulnerable to
the inevitable return of the natural world.
Glaciers and Geological Time:
○ Atwood’s comparison of suburbia’s decay to the slow movement of
glaciers—“gradual as glaciers that right now nobody notices”—reinforces
nature’s patience and inexorability. This simile is significant; it suggests that
while human efforts are fast-paced and frantic, nature operates on a
geological scale, moving slowly but with unstoppable force. By comparing
the fate of suburbia to a glacial movement, Atwood emphasizes that
humanity’s efforts to control the environment are insignificant in the face of
time.
○ This theme of inevitability underscores Atwood’s environmental critique.
Humanity may impose order temporarily, but in the long run, nature will
always reclaim its place. This idea reflects Atwood’s message that human
civilization, with all its advancements, remains vulnerable to the larger
forces of the natural world.
3. Conformity and Uniformity in Suburban Life
Atwood’s critique extends beyond the environmental to encompass a social commentary
on conformity within suburban life. The uniformity and monotony of suburbia are
presented as stifling forces, suppressing individuality and enforcing a superficial sense of
order. This theme reflects Atwood’s criticism of modern society’s tendency to prioritize
appearance and structure over authenticity.
●
Monotony as a Form of Control:
○ Atwood captures the essence of suburban conformity through phrases like
“houses in pedantic rows” and “no shouting here, or shatter of glass.” The
repetitive nature of suburbia’s design reflects a desire for predictability and
control, but it also suggests a lack of life and spontaneity. By referring to the
houses as “pedantic,” Atwood implies that this order is trivial and obsessive,
lacking any true purpose or beauty.
○ The silence that Atwood describes—“no shouting here, or shatter of
glass”—underscores the repressive nature of suburban conformity. The
●
absence of sound, typically associated with life and activity, becomes a
metaphor for the suppression of individuality. In this quiet, controlled
environment, there is no room for expressions of joy, anger, or other
emotions that disrupt the imposed order.
Critique of Societal Expectations:
○ Atwood’s portrayal of suburbia reflects a broader critique of societal
expectations. Suburbia’s sanitized environment embodies the cultural ideal
of neatness and propriety, where everything is carefully curated to create a
facade of perfection. Atwood suggests that this ideal comes at a cost, as
people are forced to conform to a lifestyle that prioritizes order over
authenticity.
○ Through this theme, Atwood questions whether suburbia’s uniformity truly
benefits its inhabitants. By depicting suburbia as lifeless and sterile, she
implies that such conformity alienates people from their natural selves,
stripping away the richness and diversity of human experience.
4. Spiritual Emptiness and Alienation
Atwood’s depiction of suburbia is not only physically sterile but also emotionally and
spiritually barren. The lack of vibrancy within the suburban landscape suggests a deeper
alienation, where humanity’s disconnection from nature leads to a loss of meaning and
fulfillment. This theme explores the spiritual cost of prioritizing order and control over
connection and vitality.
●
●
Symbolic Emptiness in the Built Environment:
○ Atwood uses the “too-fixed stare of the wide windows” to symbolize the
spiritual emptiness of suburbia. The windows, meant to offer a view of the
outside world, instead become watchful eyes, monitoring and containing
the lives within. The phrase “too-fixed stare” implies a lack of warmth or
humanity, as if the houses themselves are devoid of life.
○ This image reflects the spiritual hollowness that permeates the suburban
environment. The windows suggest surveillance rather than connection, a
barrier rather than an opening to the outside world. Atwood’s portrayal
implies that suburbia, in its quest for control, has created an emotionally
sterile landscape that alienates its inhabitants from any sense of genuine
fulfillment.
Spiritual Disconnect from Nature:
○ Atwood’s depiction of suburbia’s artificial order can also be seen as a
metaphor for humanity’s spiritual disconnect from nature. The rigid
structures of suburbia suppress the organic flow of life, creating an
environment that is unnatural and spiritually void. By removing natural
elements and enforcing conformity, suburbia distances people from the
inherent rhythms of nature, leading to a profound sense of alienation.
○ This theme suggests that spiritual fulfillment is found not in controlled,
artificial environments but in authentic, organic experiences. Atwood’s
critique implies that by divorcing themselves from nature, people lose a
fundamental part of their humanity, becoming spiritually isolated within
the sterile confines of suburbia.
5. Paradox and Irony: The Folly of Human Control
Atwood’s use of paradox and irony throughout The City Planners serves as a critique of
humanity’s misplaced confidence in its ability to control nature. The irony embedded in
the poem highlights the absurdity of human efforts to impose order on the
uncontrollable, suggesting that these attempts are not only futile but also self-destructive.
●
●
Irony of “Sanities” and Sterility:
○ One of the most striking ironies in the poem is Atwood’s description of
suburbia as embodying “sanities.” Normally, sanity would imply rationality
and soundness of mind, but in the context of suburbia, this sanity becomes
an irrational fixation on control. Atwood’s irony suggests that the very
attempts to create a “sane” environment lead to a form of spiritual insanity,
where humanity’s obsession with control blinds it to the natural world’s
beauty and complexity.
○ This irony reinforces Atwood’s message that suburbia’s order is superficial
and counterproductive. By imposing such rigid structures, humanity
creates an environment that is ultimately unsustainable and at odds with
the natural world.
Paradox of Control and Decay:
○ The paradox of suburbia’s control leading to decay is central to Atwood’s
critique. The “future cracks in the plaster” and the image of houses
“capsized” reveal the folly of believing that human creations are permanent.
While the planners attempt to enforce stability, Atwood suggests that this
very rigidity ensures that their creations will not last.
○ This paradox highlights the self-defeating nature of humanity’s attempts to
dominate nature. Rather than achieving true control, these efforts only
bring about the eventual collapse of human structures. Atwood’s use of
paradox serves as a warning, illustrating the consequences of overreaching
ambition and the inherent limits of human power.
Through each of these themes, Atwood constructs a comprehensive critique of suburbia,
modernity, and humanity’s relationship with the natural world. The poem’s themes
coalesce to form a message that warns against the dangers of control, conformity, and
disconnection from nature, urging readers to reconsider humanity’s place within a larger,
uncontrollable environment. Let me know if you'd like to expand further on any part or
add more perspectives!
Expanded Analysis of Themes in The City Planners
1. Additional Examples: Line-by-Line Interpretation for Each Theme
To enrich the analysis, let’s draw from specific lines that reinforce each theme,
highlighting how Atwood’s choice of words contributes to her social and environmental
critique.
●
Humanity’s Attempt to Control Nature:
○ The line “pedantic rows” introduces the rigidity of suburbia, with “pedantic”
connoting trivial obsessiveness. This word suggests that suburbia’s
●
●
meticulous organization is ultimately meaningless, emphasizing that the
city planners’ approach to “order” is devoid of creativity or true purpose.
○ In “discouraged grass,” the word “discouraged” personifies the grass, as if it
has been emotionally stifled. Here, Atwood implies that even the most
natural and spontaneous elements of the environment are subjected to
suppression, fitting into a lifeless uniformity.
Environmental Inevitability and Nature’s Power:
○ The phrase “future cracks in the plaster” serves as a powerful symbol of
impending decay. The “cracks” signify not only physical deterioration but
also metaphorical fractures in the illusion of suburban control. This line
supports the theme that nature will inevitably reclaim its space, breaking
through the artificial structures imposed upon it.
○ Atwood’s comparison of suburbia’s eventual collapse to glacial
movement—“gradual as glaciers that right now nobody
notices”—underscores the slowness of nature’s power. By alluding to
glaciers, she suggests that nature’s processes may be gradual but are
nevertheless unstoppable, emphasizing the transience of human creations.
Spiritual Emptiness and Alienation:
○ The “too-fixed stare of the wide windows” encapsulates a sense of
surveillance and spiritual barrenness. Windows, typically associated with
light and connection, here serve as hollow symbols of detachment. The
“too-fixed” quality suggests an uncomfortable, almost oppressive vigilance,
implying that suburbia’s controlled environment fosters alienation rather
than community.
○ Atwood’s depiction of the “rational whine of a power mower” further
reflects suburbia’s spiritual emptiness. The “whine” evokes a sense of
monotony, as if the very tools meant to maintain suburban order are filled
with discontent. This sound is symbolic of a restless, mechanized existence,
suggesting that suburbia’s order comes at the cost of spiritual and
emotional fulfillment.
2. Enhanced Layers of Irony in Suburbia’s Expectations vs. Reality
Adding layers to the irony in Atwood’s portrayal of suburbia enhances her critique of
human ambition and control. Atwood’s ironic tone throughout the poem exposes the gap
between suburbia’s outward promises and its actual reality, emphasizing the folly of
human arrogance in attempting to perfect nature.
●
The Irony of “Sanities”:
○ By referring to suburbia’s sterile order as “sanities,” Atwood ironically
questions what is truly “sane.” In this context, suburbia’s “sanity” is an
obsession with tidiness and control, which Atwood implies is itself a form of
irrationality. The planners’ meticulous attention to detail becomes absurd
when contrasted with nature’s boundless complexity, suggesting that their
attempts to create “sanity” are, paradoxically, the product of a
narrow-minded approach to life.
○ This irony critiques the false promise of suburbia: that order and
cleanliness are inherently beneficial. Atwood suggests that this desire for
●
●
order borders on insanity, revealing the underlying absurdity in suburbia’s
quest for superficial perfection.
The Paradox of Control and Futility:
○ Atwood presents the city planners’ efforts as ultimately futile, describing
their work as if it is already beginning to decay with “future cracks in the
plaster.” This paradoxical image—control paired with inevitable
decay—reflects the self-defeating nature of their ambition. The planners’
attempts to impose order on nature ironically hasten their creations’
demise, as if the structures they’ve built are fragile facades waiting to
crumble.
○ This paradox aligns with Atwood’s environmental message, exposing the
planners’ ignorance in believing they can defy the laws of nature. The irony
here is that by trying to “tame” nature, humanity actually accelerates its
own vulnerability to nature’s forces, suggesting that human control is both
illusory and self-destructive.
Irony in Suburbia’s Controlled Environment:
○ The “discouraged grass” and “sanitary trees” represent suburbia’s repression
of natural growth, reinforcing the irony of a “controlled” nature. While the
planners may believe that they’ve subdued nature by landscaping trees
and mowing grass, Atwood’s language suggests that this control is forced
and unnatural. The very elements of nature that make a landscape
beautiful and diverse are stripped away, revealing that suburbia’s ideal of
perfection is hollow and artificial.
○ By presenting nature as something that must be controlled, Atwood’s irony
implies that suburbia’s environment is ironically unnatural. This
environment, designed for human pleasure, becomes cold and sterile, far
removed from the richness and unpredictability of the natural world.
Atwood critiques suburbia’s attempt to impose human values onto nature,
suggesting that it results in an environment stripped of life and meaning.
3. Exploring Ambiguity in Atwood’s Portrayal of Suburbia
Atwood’s poem invites multiple interpretations by embedding ambiguity in her language,
allowing suburbia to represent both a stifling control over nature and a deeper,
unresolved tension between humanity and the environment.
●
Suburbia as Both Controlled and Controlled By:
○ One interpretation is that suburbia represents humanity’s attempt to
control nature, with the city planners symbolizing a desire for order.
Atwood’s detailed descriptions of the environment—“the houses in
pedantic rows, the planted / sanitary trees”—imply an external force
imposing its will upon the landscape. In this sense, suburbia is an artificial
construct, engineered to uphold human values.
○ However, Atwood’s imagery also suggests that suburbia itself exerts
control over its inhabitants, shaping their lives and stifling their
individuality. The “no shouting here” line implies that those who live in
suburbia have adapted to its demands, suppressing their emotions to fit
the quiet, orderly environment. This ambiguity reflects a complex
●
●
relationship between humanity and suburbia, where both are locked into a
dynamic of control and constraint.
Ambiguity in Environmental Destruction and Self-Destruction:
○ Atwood’s use of images like “future cracks in the plaster” and “houses,
capsized” creates an ambiguity as to whether the destruction of suburbia is
driven by nature or by humanity’s own shortsightedness. On one level,
these images represent nature’s inevitable reclaiming of the land, a
reminder that suburbia’s artificiality cannot withstand the forces of nature.
Yet they also suggest that suburbia’s collapse is self-inflicted, the result of
human hubris in attempting to create a world that ignores natural
principles.
○ This ambiguity allows Atwood’s critique to operate on multiple levels,
inviting readers to interpret suburbia’s decay as both a natural
consequence of environmental ignorance and a metaphor for human
self-destruction. By not fully resolving this tension, Atwood emphasizes the
complexity of humanity’s relationship with nature, suggesting that our
attempts at control carry inherent risks and contradictions.
Dual Nature of Suburban Silence:
○ Atwood’s depiction of suburban silence—“no shouting here, or shatter of
glass”—introduces another layer of ambiguity. Silence could be read as a
symbol of peace, suggesting that suburbia offers a retreat from the chaos of
urban life. This interpretation aligns with the idealized view of suburbia as a
safe, controlled environment, free from the noise and disruptions of the
outside world.
○ However, this silence is also unsettling, implying suppression rather than
tranquility. The lack of sound suggests a repressive quality, as if suburbia
demands conformity to an ideal of order that leaves no room for
spontaneity or self-expression. This ambiguous silence reflects Atwood’s
critique of suburbia as a place that may offer material comfort but exacts a
psychological cost, isolating individuals from both nature and authentic
human experiences.
Conclusion
In this expanded exploration, we see that Atwood’s The City Planners functions as both a
specific critique of suburban life and a broader meditation on humanity’s place within the
natural world. By employing detailed line-by-line analysis, irony, and ambiguity, Atwood
critiques the assumptions and ideals underlying suburbia, exposing the emptiness within
its promises of order and control.
●
Integrating All Perspectives:
○ Through the irony of suburbia’s attempts to control nature, Atwood exposes
the delusion and danger of human arrogance. The ambiguity in her
portrayal allows suburbia to represent not only an artificial environment but
also the broader social constructs that limit individuality and spiritual
fulfillment.
○ These expansions build on the poem’s layered critique, emphasizing that
Atwood’s work invites readers to question humanity’s values and ambitions.
Her nuanced, multi-faceted approach to themes reveals the depth of her
perspective on environmental and social issues, making The City Planners a
complex, resonant piece that challenges readers to reconsider their own
views on the relationship between society and nature.
This expanded analysis adds both line-specific insights and interpretative layers,
strengthening the argument by linking each theme to Atwood’s broader critique of
human ambition, conformity, and environmental consequences. Let me know if there’s
any other angle or detail you’d like to delve into!
Section 7: Speaker and Perspective in The City Planners
Margaret Atwood’s The City Planners is told from a distinct speaker’s point of view, one
that is observational, critical, and emotionally detached from the subject matter. The
speaker functions as an observer, analyzing suburban landscapes and the actions of the
city planners with a critical eye. Atwood crafts this voice to highlight the speaker’s unease
with suburbia’s sterility, creating a layered perspective that reflects both a personal
disdain for the artificial order and a broader critique of humanity’s misguided ambition.
Point of View and Voice
1.
Observational Perspective: Detached Yet Insightful
○ First-Person Plural Point of View:
The City Planners is told primarily from a first-person plural
perspective, with the speaker using “us” and “we” to describe their
viewpoint. This collective perspective serves to create an
observational, somewhat detached tone, as if the speaker is not just
speaking for themselves but for anyone who might share their
critique of suburbia’s sterile order. The use of “we” suggests that the
speaker’s observations are not just personal complaints but shared
criticisms that many might feel when faced with suburbia’s artificial
landscapes.
■ By adopting this perspective, Atwood’s speaker situates themselves
as a part of a broader group that feels alienated by the suburban
environment. The speaker’s point of view allows readers to interpret
their observations as a reflection of wider societal discomfort with
suburban uniformity and environmental control.
○ The Voice as a Detached Observer:
■ The speaker’s voice is marked by an objective, almost clinical tone as
they describe the suburb’s “sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass.”
This detached tone allows the speaker to maintain a critical distance,
presenting the suburban landscape as a kind of experiment in
human control. While the speaker is emotionally distanced, their
descriptions carry an implicit disdain, as they describe the suburb in
sterile, lifeless terms.
■ This observational quality of the voice reinforces the idea that the
speaker is not part of this suburban world but rather a spectator
who sees its flaws. The speaker’s tone allows them to adopt an
analytical perspective, critiquing suburbia’s artificiality without being
personally affected by it.
Reliability of Speaker: A Trustworthy, Insightful Critique
○ Reliable Yet Opinionated:
■ The speaker in The City Planners appears largely reliable, presenting
a clear-eyed critique of suburbia without excessive exaggeration or
bias. Their descriptions of the suburban landscape—“houses in
pedantic rows,” “rational whine of a power mower”—are grounded in
observable reality, suggesting that the speaker is providing an
■
2.
3.
honest, if opinionated, account of suburbia’s artificiality. The
reliability of the speaker is strengthened by their calm, measured
tone, which allows them to offer a critical perspective without
veering into emotional extremes.
■ However, while the speaker is reliable, they are also unmistakably
opinionated. Their word choices, such as “pedantic,” “sanitary,” and
“discouraged,” reflect a personal bias against suburbia’s order. This
bias does not undermine the speaker’s reliability but rather adds
depth to their critique, revealing a sense of discontent with the
suburban values that prioritize control over authenticity.
○ Unreliable Elements Through Ambiguity and Tone:
■ Although the speaker is largely reliable, there are subtle elements
that suggest potential bias or emotional investment. For example,
the speaker’s use of irony and sarcasm—seen in phrases like
“sanities” and “the rational whine of a power mower”—implies a
hidden frustration or disdain. This tone creates an ambiguous
relationship with the subject, as the speaker’s detachment may
mask a deeper, more personal discontent with suburban conformity.
■ The speaker’s ambiguous stance also raises questions about
whether their critique reflects a purely observational perspective or
a reaction to personal feelings of alienation. This subtle tension
between reliability and personal bias allows Atwood to explore the
complexities of suburbia’s impact on those who feel out of place
within it.
Persona: Distinguishing the Speaker from Atwood Herself
○ The Speaker as a Constructed Persona:
■ Although the speaker in The City Planners shares some of Atwood’s
environmental and social concerns, the poem presents a distinct
persona that is not necessarily identical to the poet herself. Atwood
constructs a speaker who embodies the perspective of a critical
observer, one who feels distanced from suburbia’s order but is not
explicitly a mouthpiece for Atwood’s personal beliefs.
■ By crafting this persona, Atwood allows readers to view the speaker’s
critique as part of a larger societal commentary rather than a
personal grievance. The speaker functions as an archetype of the
outsider who questions suburban values, allowing Atwood to
explore themes of conformity, control, and environmental impact
without directly inserting her own voice.
○ Divergence from Atwood’s Known Beliefs:
■ While Atwood’s environmental advocacy aligns with the speaker’s
concerns about human attempts to control nature, the speaker’s
emotional detachment distinguishes them from Atwood’s typical
passion on the topic. Atwood uses this detached persona to add
layers of irony and critique, making the speaker’s observations feel
more universal and less personal. This separation between Atwood
and the speaker emphasizes the broader social critique embedded
in the poem, inviting readers to interpret suburbia’s flaws as
reflective of society’s values rather than one individual’s opinions.
Speaker’s Relationship to the Subject
1.
Emotional Detachment Coupled with Disdain
○ The Speaker’s Detached Yet Critical Stance:
The speaker’s relationship with suburbia is characterized by
emotional detachment, bordering on disdain. This distance allows
the speaker to examine the suburban landscape without being
swayed by personal feelings of warmth or nostalgia. Words like
“sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass” highlight the speaker’s
dissatisfaction with suburbia’s enforced cleanliness, suggesting that
the speaker views this landscape as sterile rather than comforting.
■ This detachment serves a crucial purpose in Atwood’s critique. By
presenting suburbia from an emotionally distant perspective, the
speaker invites readers to see the landscape as it truly is: a place
devoid of vitality, stifled by human control. The speaker’s tone,
therefore, reinforces the theme of spiritual emptiness, as if they feel
nothing for suburbia except mild disdain.
○ Hints of Emotional Alienation:
■ While the speaker’s detachment suggests objectivity, their word
choices reveal hints of emotional alienation. Phrases like “the
too-fixed stare of the wide windows” and “no shouting here” imply a
world that is not only controlled but also isolating. This sense of
alienation reflects the speaker’s unease with the suburban
environment, suggesting that they feel out of place or disconnected
within this artificial world.
■ The speaker’s relationship with suburbia is thus one of alienation
and rejection; they do not belong to this world but instead observe
it critically, revealing its flaws. This sense of alienation adds a layer of
emotional depth to the speaker’s perspective, suggesting that their
detachment is not purely objective but rooted in a discomfort with
suburbia’s values.
Use of Indirect Address and Observational Distance
○ Lack of Direct Address: Maintaining Objectivity:
■ Throughout The City Planners, the speaker does not directly address
any individuals or entities within the poem. Instead, they maintain
an observational stance, describing the landscape and its
characteristics from a distance. This lack of direct address enhances
the speaker’s objectivity, as they do not attempt to confront or
persuade anyone. Instead, they simply present their observations,
allowing readers to draw their own conclusions.
■ By avoiding direct address, the speaker maintains a critical distance
from the subject. This approach reinforces the theme of
detachment, as if the speaker sees suburbia as an environment
unworthy of personal engagement. The absence of direct address
suggests that the speaker views suburbia as a symbol rather than a
personal reality, reinforcing the idea that suburbia’s flaws are
emblematic of broader societal issues.
○ Observational Tone as a Method of Critique:
■
2.
■
■
The speaker’s observational tone serves as a method of critique,
allowing them to analyze suburbia without becoming emotionally
entangled. By maintaining a distance, the speaker highlights the
emptiness and sterility of suburbia, subtly suggesting that they have
no desire to engage with such an environment. This tone creates a
sense of judgment, as if the speaker is both witnessing and
condemning suburbia’s lifelessness.
The speaker’s distance also reflects the psychological impact of
suburban conformity. By observing rather than participating, the
speaker implies that suburbia creates a culture of passivity and
detachment, one that alienates individuals from nature and
authentic experience. This observational tone underscores the
poem’s theme of alienation, suggesting that suburbia’s values are
incompatible with the speaker’s own sense of vitality.
Conclusion: A Critique Embodied in the Speaker’s Perspective
Through a carefully constructed observational perspective, Margaret Atwood’s speaker in
The City Planners critiques the sterility, conformity, and environmental ignorance of
suburbia. The speaker’s voice—detached yet insightful, reliable yet subtly
opinionated—serves as a conduit for Atwood’s broader societal critique, revealing the
emptiness and futility of humanity’s attempts to control nature.
●
●
A Voice of Alienation and Judgment:
○ The speaker’s detachment allows them to analyze suburbia without
personal attachment, creating a tone of alienation and judgment. Their
distance reflects their disconnection from suburbia’s artificial world,
suggesting that they are both repelled by and critical of its values. This
stance reinforces Atwood’s environmental and social critique, highlighting
the emptiness of a culture that prioritizes order over authenticity.
Complex Layers of Perspective:
○ Atwood’s use of a detached, observational voice adds complexity to the
poem’s themes, as the speaker’s perspective invites readers to question the
values underpinning suburban life. By maintaining a distance, the speaker
embodies the critique, revealing that suburbia’s sterile environment fosters
a culture of isolation and control, ultimately estranging people from nature
and themselves.
This detailed analysis underscores the nuances in Atwood’s choice of speaker and
perspective, illustrating how the poem’s voice reinforces its critique of suburbia’s
artificiality and environmental ignorance. Let me know if you’d like further exploration into
any specific aspect of the speaker’s perspective!
Expanded Analysis of Speaker and Perspective in The City
Planners
In The City Planners, Atwood’s speaker operates as an observer of suburbia, presenting a
layered critique through a voice that is detached yet implicitly opinionated. This
detachment allows Atwood to draw readers into the poem as participants in the speaker’s
judgment, encouraging them to reflect on the sterility of suburban life and humanity’s
illusory attempts to control nature. Expanding upon previous observations, we’ll explore
the nuances in the speaker’s tone, the ambiguity of their emotional distance, and how
Atwood uses the speaker’s perspective to suggest broader societal critiques.
1. Subtleties in Tone Shifts
While the speaker maintains an observational, almost clinical tone throughout The City
Planners, a closer look reveals subtle shifts that enrich the poem’s critical stance. These
tone shifts move the speaker from detached observation toward veiled frustration,
revealing an underlying sense of futility regarding humanity’s attempts to dominate
nature.
●
●
Shifts from Calm Observation to Contemptuous Critique:
○ At the beginning, the speaker’s tone appears calm and descriptive, as they
simply recount their observations: “Cruising these residential Sunday /
streets in dry August sunlight.” This initial description feels casual, evoking a
leisurely drive through suburbia. However, as the poem progresses, the
language shifts to reveal disdain, describing the houses as “in pedantic
rows” and the trees as “sanitary.” These word choices suggest that the
speaker finds suburbia not only repetitive but also oppressively lifeless.
○ By using terms like “pedantic” and “sanitary,” the speaker’s tone edges into
contempt, as if critiquing suburbia’s obsession with order and control. This
shift suggests that the speaker’s detachment may mask deeper feelings of
unease or frustration, hinting at an implicit critique of society’s disregard for
nature’s inherent vitality.
The Cumulative Effect of Irony and Sarcasm:
○ The speaker’s irony becomes more pronounced as the poem moves into
detailed descriptions of suburban conformity, with phrases like “the rational
whine of a power mower” and “discouraged grass.” Initially, the tone of irony
is mild, but it grows sharper as the poem continues. By the time the
speaker describes the landscape as containing “future cracks in the plaster,”
the tone has evolved into one that borders on sardonic, exposing the
absurdity of suburbia’s manufactured stability.
○ This shift from mild irony to sarcasm creates a layering effect within the
speaker’s tone, amplifying the sense that suburbia’s order is unsustainable
and inherently absurd. By introducing sarcasm, Atwood subtly nudges
readers to question the values underpinning suburban life, reinforcing the
theme of humanity’s delusion in believing it can control or subdue the
natural world.
2. Ambiguity in the Speaker’s Emotional Distance
Though the speaker in The City Planners maintains an ostensibly detached, observational
tone, there are hints that their detachment may not be purely objective. This ambiguity
suggests that the speaker’s voice might mask a more complex emotional response to
suburbia, revealing an internal conflict between objective observation and a repressed
discontent with suburban values.
●
●
Subtle Emotional Investment Beneath the Detachment:
○ While the speaker appears emotionally distanced, certain word
choices—such as “pedantic” and “rational whine”—hint at a possible
internal conflict. These words convey a judgmental quality that implies
more than simple observation. For instance, “pedantic” suggests that the
speaker finds suburbia overly concerned with trivial order, hinting that the
speaker may feel confined or alienated by this setting. The term “rational
whine,” on the other hand, combines rationality with complaint, suggesting
an underlying irritation that adds depth to the speaker’s critique.
○ This emotional ambiguity creates a dual effect: on the surface, the speaker
is simply describing suburbia, yet beneath this detachment lies a sense of
discontent. Atwood may be using this technique to critique societal values
without overtly stating the speaker’s emotional stance, allowing readers to
interpret the speaker’s observations as reflections of their own potential
frustrations with suburban conformity.
The Ambiguity of Alienation and Judgement:
○ By maintaining a distance yet using charged language, Atwood’s speaker
simultaneously conveys both alienation from suburbia and a sense of
judgment toward its values. The line “no shouting here, or shatter of glass”
suggests a controlled environment, yet the lack of noise implies an
unsettling silence that borders on eerie. This quiet, coupled with phrases
like “sanitary trees,” suggests that the speaker finds suburbia lifeless, almost
stifling.
○ This ambiguity creates a tension between detachment and judgment,
suggesting that the speaker’s emotional response is not entirely neutral.
Atwood uses this nuanced perspective to imply that while suburbia may
appear safe and ordered, its lack of spontaneity alienates individuals from
genuine experiences. This duality—of detachment masking
alienation—reflects the broader critique of a society that values control over
vitality.
3. Contrast Between Atwood’s Personal Views and the Speaker’s Detachment
The speaker’s distanced tone contrasts with Atwood’s own environmental advocacy,
adding layers to the critique by portraying the speaker as a detached observer rather than
an impassioned advocate. This choice allows Atwood to explore suburbia’s flaws through a
lens of irony and skepticism, making the critique feel more universal.
●
Detachment as a Universalized Perspective:
○ Atwood’s speaker refrains from passionate declarations, opting instead for
an observational stance. This choice allows readers to interpret the critique
as a broader societal perspective rather than a personal grievance. The
●
speaker’s voice, therefore, serves as a mouthpiece for a collective unease
with suburbia, suggesting that the discomfort extends beyond Atwood’s
personal views.
○ By choosing detachment, Atwood creates a persona that feels universally
relatable, allowing the poem’s critique of suburbia to resonate with a wide
range of readers. The speaker’s distance from the subject implies that their
observations are shared criticisms, encouraging readers to adopt a similar
viewpoint and question the values embedded within suburban life.
The Speaker as a Reflection of Societal Observers:
○ This detached perspective may represent a broader societal phenomenon,
where people recognize suburban sterility but do not actively resist or
challenge it. Atwood’s speaker embodies this passive observation, reflecting
the way modern individuals often witness environmental degradation or
societal issues without directly addressing them. This passivity adds
another layer to the critique, implying that society’s lack of engagement
with nature contributes to its ongoing alienation.
○ By crafting a speaker who observes but does not intervene, Atwood
critiques society’s tendency to witness problems without taking action. This
passive stance allows readers to question their own roles as “observers” in a
society that prioritizes control over harmony with nature.
4. Broader Implications of the Speaker’s Observational Distance
The speaker’s observational distance functions not only as a critique of suburbia but also
as a commentary on modern societal detachment from environmental and societal issues.
This detached stance invites readers to examine the impact of passivity, as the speaker’s
distance reflects a broader cultural tendency to accept or ignore societal flaws without
challenging them.
●
●
Passivity as a Societal Critique:
○ The speaker’s detachment can be interpreted as a reflection of society’s
passive acceptance of suburban conformity and environmental control. By
observing suburbia without attempting to change or engage with it, the
speaker represents a culture that acknowledges problems but remains
inactive. This passivity mirrors society’s often complacent stance toward
environmental degradation, suggesting that suburbia’s sterility is a product
of collective indifference.
○ Atwood’s use of a passive speaker implies that society’s acceptance of
suburban values perpetuates its own alienation from nature. The speaker’s
distance therefore critiques not only suburbia itself but also the societal
mindset that allows such sterile environments to thrive. Through this
perspective, Atwood warns that complacency leads to spiritual and
environmental decay, as society becomes increasingly disconnected from
nature.
The Speaker as a Mirror for Reader Reflection:
○ The speaker’s observational stance also serves as a mirror, encouraging
readers to examine their own relationship with suburban life and
environmental issues. By presenting a voice that observes yet remains
○
detached, Atwood invites readers to consider how their own lives may be
shaped by suburban ideals of control, conformity, and order.
This reflective quality encourages readers to question whether they, too,
have accepted suburban sterility as a norm. The speaker’s distance
becomes a tool for self-examination, prompting readers to assess whether
they are content with observing societal issues from afar or whether they
might feel compelled to take action. Atwood’s use of the speaker as a
reflective device suggests that suburban alienation is not only a cultural
phenomenon but also a personal choice, encouraging readers to reconsider
their own values.
5. The Role of the Collective “We”
Atwood’s choice to use the collective “we” adds a dimension of complicity to the speaker’s
critique, subtly inviting readers to share the speaker’s observations and, in turn, question
their own alignment with suburban values. The use of “we” bridges the gap between the
speaker’s perspective and the reader’s, making the critique feel both personal and
universal.
●
●
Creating a Shared Experience of Critique:
○ The collective “we” makes the speaker’s observations feel communal, as if
the critique of suburbia is a shared experience. This choice fosters a sense of
collective dissatisfaction, suggesting that the speaker’s perspective is not
unique but rather reflective of a broader societal discontent. The use of “we”
invites readers to adopt the speaker’s viewpoint, creating a sense of unity in
the critique.
○ By using “we,” Atwood subtly implicates the reader in the critique,
encouraging them to view suburbia through the same lens of skepticism.
This shared perspective reinforces the poem’s themes, suggesting that
suburban sterility is a phenomenon that affects everyone, not just the
speaker. Through this communal language, Atwood creates a feeling of
complicity, as if readers, too, are complicit in suburban conformity.
Bridging the Gap Between Speaker and Reader:
○ The collective “we” serves to bridge the gap between the speaker and
reader, drawing the reader into the poem as a participant in the critique.
This choice encourages readers to adopt a critical stance toward suburbia,
as if they, too, are observing the artificial landscape with the same sense of
detachment. By addressing the reader through this shared perspective,
Atwood creates an intimate bond, making the critique feel more
immediate and pressing.
○ This use of “we” also reinforces the poem’s reflective quality, prompting
readers to question their own views on suburban conformity. The speaker’s
collective perspective suggests that the critique is not merely a personal
opinion but a shared realization, one that invites readers to confront the
sterility of suburban life and reconsider their relationship with nature.
Conclusion
Through these expanded layers of tone shifts, emotional ambiguity, and shared
perspective, Atwood’s speaker in The City Planners presents a complex critique of
suburbia, modernity, and humanity’s detachment from nature. The speaker’s detached
voice, tinged with subtle frustration and judgment, allows readers to view suburbia from
multiple angles, deepening the poem’s themes and societal implications.
●
●
A Complex Voice of Alienation and Passive Critique:
○ The speaker’s observational stance, layered with irony, sarcasm, and
emotional ambiguity, serves as a powerful reflection of societal passivity.
Through this complex voice, Atwood critiques the way individuals witness
societal issues without challenging them, suggesting that this detachment
perpetuates environmental degradation and spiritual emptiness.
Bridging Speaker and Reader in Shared Reflection:
○ By using the collective “we,” Atwood invites readers to join the speaker’s
critique, encouraging self-reflection and shared discontent. This choice
makes the critique feel immediate and personal, as if the reader is not
merely observing suburbia but also participating in the judgment. The
speaker’s voice thus becomes a tool for societal introspection, urging
readers to question their acceptance of suburban values and consider their
own relationship with nature.
Section 8
Line-by-Line, Comprehensive Literary Device Analysis of The City
Planners
Lines 1–2: “Cruising these residential Sunday / streets in dry August sunlight:”
●
●
Alliteration: The “s” sounds in “Sunday,” “streets,” and “sunlight” create a soft,
soothing beginning that mimics the calm, almost sedate feel of a suburban drive.
This initial alliteration contrasts with the later critique, setting up the expectation of
tranquility in suburbia.
○ Effect: This sound lulls readers into the artificial calm of suburbia, setting
the stage for the disillusionment that follows.
Imagery: “Dry August sunlight” provides a sensory image of late summer warmth,
suggesting a parched landscape that is bright but somewhat barren.
○ Effect: This image contributes to a feeling of superficial warmth, a quiet
atmosphere that implies comfort but hints at an underlying lifelessness in
suburbia.
Line 3: “what offends us is”
●
Tone Shift and Irony: This line marks a shift from calm observation to
judgmental critique, introduced abruptly with “offends.” The irony lies in finding
“offense” in what is typically seen as mundane or benign.
○ Effect: By framing suburbia as offensive, Atwood disrupts the reader’s
expectations, foreshadowing the deep-seated issues beneath the surface of
this “normal” environment.
Lines 4–5: “the sanities: / the houses in pedantic rows”
●
●
●
Irony: Using “sanities” ironically suggests that the strict orderliness of suburbia is,
paradoxically, a sign of irrationality.
○ Effect: This phrase captures the unnatural level of control in suburbia,
portraying the “sanities” as stifling rather than reassuring.
Alliteration: The phrase “pedantic rows” repeats the “p” sound, emphasizing the
strict, almost obsessively neat arrangement of the houses.
○ Effect: This alliteration reinforces the robotic, unnatural feel of suburbia’s
conformity, evoking a sense of monotony.
Personification: Describing houses as “pedantic” gives them a human quality, as if
they obsess over minor details, embodying suburbia’s obsession with control.
○ Effect: This personification conveys the sense that even inanimate objects
reflect suburban rigidity, enhancing the claustrophobic tone.
Lines 6–7: “the planted / sanitary trees, assert / levelness of surface like a
rebuke”
●
●
●
Alliteration: The “s” sounds in “sanitary” and “surface” emphasize sterility,
suggesting that the trees are stripped of any wildness.
○ Effect: The alliteration makes the trees feel artificially “clean,” reinforcing
the theme of suburbia’s attempt to control nature.
Personification: Trees are “sanitary,” which implies they’ve been artificially shaped
or cleansed of natural unpredictability. The trees are also said to “assert” levelness,
giving them an active role in maintaining order.
○ Effect: By attributing human-like qualities to the trees, Atwood highlights
the absurdity of trying to make nature conform to human standards of
cleanliness.
Simile: “Levelness of surface like a rebuke” compares the unnatural evenness of the
land to a scolding, suggesting that the landscape itself criticizes any imperfection.
○ Effect: This simile suggests that suburbia’s perfectionism is antagonistic, as
if it rejects any form of disorder or individual expression.
Line 8: “to the dent in our car door.”
●
Juxtaposition and Symbolism: The dent symbolizes a flaw or an irregularity,
contrasting with the flawless suburban landscape. Here, human imperfection (the
dent) clashes with the sterile, “sanitary” environment.
○ Effect: The dent symbolizes the intrusion of individuality or unpredictability
into the hyper-controlled suburban world, emphasizing suburbia’s
intolerance for imperfection.
Lines 9–10: “No shouting here, or / shatter of glass; nothing more abrupt”
●
Imagery: The imagery of “no shouting” and “no shatter of glass” conveys silence
●
and control, suggesting an almost eerie quietness.
○ Effect: This visual and auditory imagery underscores suburbia’s oppressive
order, giving the reader a sense of discomfort in the silence.
Consonance: The “t” sounds in “shatter” and “abrupt” add a slight harshness,
contrasting with the softness of earlier lines.
○ Effect: The consonance subtly introduces tension, reflecting the stifled
nature of suburban life.
Line 11: “than the rational whine of a power mower”
●
Onomatopoeia: “Whine” imitates the sound of the mower, creating an auditory
experience that feels intrusive.
Effect: This sound embodies the repetitive, grating nature of suburban
maintenance, conveying an atmosphere of monotony and lifelessness.
Irony: Describing the mechanical “whine” as “rational” is ironic, suggesting that the
regularity of suburban life feels almost absurdly logical and lacking in emotion.
○ Effect: This irony underlines the emptiness of suburbia’s strict order,
implying that rationality here equates to lifelessness.
○
●
Lines 12–13: “Cutting a straight swath in the discouraged grass.”
●
Personification: The grass is described as “discouraged,” implying that it is worn
down or disheartened by the constant trimming.
○ Effect: This personification reinforces the idea that even nature feels
oppressed under suburbia’s control, enhancing the critique of human
interference in natural processes.
Lines 14–16: “But though the driveways neatly / sidestep hysteria / by being
even”
●
●
Irony: The term “sidestep hysteria” is ironic, suggesting that the driveways avoid
any form of chaos by remaining orderly. The implication is that this control creates
an illusion of calm, masking underlying instability.
○ Effect: This irony suggests that the calm of suburbia is superficial, achieved
through suppression rather than genuine peace.
Alliteration: The repetition of “s” sounds in “sidestep hysteria” provides a smooth
flow, mirroring the facade of calm that suburbia presents.
○ Effect: This sound pattern reinforces the idea of smoothness and order, but
in a way that feels artificial and overly controlled.
Lines 17–19: “the roofs all display / the same slant of avoidance to the hot sky,”
●
Personification: The roofs “display” a slant, as if they consciously choose their
●
angle to avoid the sun. This implies a deliberate attempt to shut out natural
elements.
○ Effect: By giving the roofs human-like intent, Atwood criticizes suburbia’s
tendency to shelter itself from natural influences, emphasizing its isolation
from the natural world.
Symbolism: The “hot sky” represents uncontrollable natural forces, such as climate
and time. Suburbia’s attempt to avoid it symbolizes the broader human desire to
control or ignore nature.
○ Effect: This symbolism deepens the poem’s critique, suggesting that
suburbia’s desire for order is both artificial and ultimately futile in the face
of natural forces.
Lines 20–22: “certain things: / the smell of spilt oil a faint / sickness lingering
in the garages,”
●
Imagery: “Smell of spilt oil” and “faint sickness” create an olfactory image, adding
●
a sense of decay and contamination beneath suburbia’s clean surface.
○ Effect: This sensory detail suggests that, despite appearances, suburbia is
tainted by pollution and stagnation, symbolizing the unseen consequences
of human interference with nature.
Metaphor: “Sickness” serves as a metaphor for the subtle corruption and decay
underlying suburban life.
○ Effect: This metaphor hints at the idea that suburbia, despite its orderly
appearance, is inherently flawed or “ill,” underscoring the unsustainable
nature of its control.
Lines 23–24: “a splash of paint on brick surprising as a bruise,”
●
●
Simile: Comparing the “splash of paint” to a “bruise” suggests an unexpected,
unnatural mark on the otherwise sterile landscape.
○ Effect: This simile emphasizes the idea that imperfections are jarring in
suburbia, highlighting how the environment is unable to tolerate
irregularities or deviations from its controlled order.
Imagery: The “splash of paint” serves as a visual intrusion, hinting at hidden flaws
within suburbia’s facade.
○ Effect: This visual detail introduces a sense of vulnerability, as if the surface
perfection of suburbia is fragile and easily marred.
Line 25: “a plastic hose poised in a vicious / coil”
●
Personification: The hose is “poised in a vicious coil,” giving it an aggressive,
almost sentient quality.
○ Effect: This personification suggests that even mundane objects in
suburbia carry a latent hostility, mirroring the suppressed aggression
beneath suburbia’s order.
Lines 26–27: “when the houses, capsized, will slide / obliquely into the clay
seas”
●
Imagery and Metaphor: The “clay seas” symbolize the earth reclaiming human
structures, and the houses “capsized” evoke images of sinking ships.
○ Effect: These images reinforce the theme of nature’s eventual dominance,
implying that human constructions are fleeting in comparison to natural
forces.
●
Assonance: The long “a” sound in “capsized” and “clay” adds a fluid, almost gentle
quality, emphasizing the slow but inevitable process of nature reclaiming
suburban landscapes.
○ Effect: This sound pattern reinforces the idea that nature’s influence is
persistent and quietly powerful, outlasting human structures.
Lines 28–30: “The City Planners / with the insane faces of political
conspirators”
●
Irony: Describing the city planners as “insane” is ironic, as their attempts at strict
control are portrayed as irrational despite their supposed rationality.
○ Effect: This irony highlights the absurdity of trying to impose rigid order on
nature, casting the planners’ efforts as fundamentally flawed.
Lines 31–33: “are scattered over unsurveyed / territories, concealed from each
other, / each in his own private blizzard”
●
Metaphor: “Private blizzard” symbolizes the planners’ isolation and detachment
from reality, suggesting that each planner is lost in their own futile vision.
○ Effect: This metaphor underscores the fragmented and disconnected
nature of suburban planning, implying that the planners are oblivious to
the true impact of their actions.
Conclusion
This line-by-line breakdown covers each instance of literary devices in The City Planners,
fully analyzing how Atwood’s precise choices enhance the poem’s critique. Every sound,
image, and figurative device works to reinforce the themes of artificiality, control, and the
futility of human attempts to subdue nature. Let me know if you'd like further elaboration
on any specific line or device!
Expanded Analysis of The City Planners by Margaret Atwood
Alternative Interpretations and Symbolic Connections
In The City Planners, Margaret Atwood’s choice of language, structure, and literary devices
creates multiple layers of meaning that invite a range of interpretations. This expanded
analysis will cover not only the primary interpretations of each line but also examine
alternative perspectives and symbolic layers that offer insight into the poem’s critique of
suburban conformity, the tension between order and chaos, and humanity’s psychological
need for control.
Lines 1–2: “Cruising these residential Sunday / streets in dry August sunlight”
●
Surface Calm vs. Underlying Discomfort:
●
The word “cruising” implies ease and relaxation, an unhurried pace typical
of a quiet Sunday. This introduces a false sense of calm, inviting the reader
to experience suburbia as a place of peace. However, there is an underlying
discomfort conveyed by the “dry August sunlight,” a seemingly pleasant
image that nonetheless implies barrenness and dryness—a subtle hint that
this calm is superficial.
○ Effect: This juxtaposition sets up the reader to expect peace but primes
them to feel a vague unease, as if the environment’s tranquility is only
surface-deep. The dryness implies an absence of life, subtly suggesting that
something is lacking or sterile.
Alternative Interpretation of “Sunday Streets”:
○ “Sunday” is traditionally associated with rest, spirituality, and reflection.
However, in this context, it might also imply a sense of emptiness—of
repetition and routine in a suburban setting where every Sunday looks the
same. Here, Atwood may be critiquing not only the physical but also the
cultural sterility of suburban life, where even rest and spirituality feel
scheduled and devoid of meaning.
○ Effect: This idea of “scheduled peace” adds a layer of irony, reinforcing the
poem’s critique of artificiality. By choosing “Sunday,” Atwood subtly
questions whether the peace of suburbia is authentic or merely
performative.
○
Line 3: “what offends us is”
●
Shift to Critique and Irony:
The word “offends” immediately disrupts the serene tone, signaling a shift
from observation to judgment. Ironically, it’s not the chaos or disorder that
offends the speaker, but the orderliness itself. This irony suggests a reversal
of expectations, as the speaker sees suburbia’s calm as unsettling rather
than comforting.
○ Effect: This line prepares the reader for a deeper critique, where what
seems normal (orderliness) becomes offensive in its artificiality. The word
“offends” implies an active discomfort, hinting that the speaker finds
suburbia’s perfectionism not only unsettling but fundamentally wrong.
Psychological Interpretation of “Offense”:
○ The speaker’s reaction can be seen as a projection of their own discomfort
with order, suggesting a psychological conflict. Perhaps the speaker feels
constrained by society’s demands for order and control, making suburbia’s
rigid conformity feel suffocating. This interpretation sees suburbia as a
metaphor for societal expectations that force individuals into uniformity.
○ Effect: This interpretation suggests that suburbia, as a physical
manifestation of order, represents a psychological prison. The “offense”
○
●
reflects the tension between the human desire for individuality and
society’s pressure to conform, making suburbia’s calmness oppressive.
Lines 4–5: “the sanities: / the houses in pedantic rows”
●
Irony and the Concept of “Sanity”:
The use of “sanities” ironically labels the conformity of suburbia as “sane,”
implying that suburbia’s version of sanity is restrictive and superficial. This
line suggests that in this world, sanity means adhering to strict order at the
expense of individuality.
○ Effect: This irony highlights the absurdity of equating order with sanity,
emphasizing the emptiness of suburban conformity. By labeling these
structures as “sanities,” Atwood critiques society’s narrow definition of
mental health, implying that true sanity may require freedom and
spontaneity.
Alternative Interpretation of “Pedantic Rows”:
○ “Pedantic” implies an excessive concern with trivial details, suggesting that
suburbia is obsessed with meaningless perfection. This might symbolize
society’s fixation on appearances, where maintaining a perfect facade takes
precedence over genuine well-being.
○ Effect: The idea of “pedantic rows” evokes a sense of lifelessness, as if
suburbia’s need for order smothers creativity and spontaneity. This
interpretation suggests that the “sanity” of suburbia is rigid and lifeless,
revealing a society that prioritizes appearance over substance.
○
●
Lines 6–7: “the planted / sanitary trees, assert / levelness of surface like a
rebuke”
●
Personification and Control of Nature:
●
By describing trees as “sanitary” and “asserting levelness,” Atwood gives
them a passive-aggressive role in maintaining order. This personification
suggests that even nature is forced to conform to suburbia’s standards,
reflecting humanity’s need to control and sanitize the environment.
○ Effect: The image of “sanitary trees” creates an eerie feeling of artificiality,
suggesting that suburbia’s order extends to every aspect of life. The trees,
traditionally symbols of vitality, are stripped of their wildness, reinforcing
suburbia’s suppression of natural expression.
Simile as Subtle Critique:
○ The phrase “like a rebuke” implies that the perfect surface of suburbia
scolds anything that deviates from its uniformity. This comparison critiques
the restrictive nature of suburban expectations, where any flaw or
irregularity is seen as an offense.
○ Effect: This simile underscores suburbia’s intolerance for imperfection,
portraying it as judgmental and unforgiving. The “rebuke” suggests that
conformity in suburbia comes with social pressure to suppress individuality,
amplifying the poem’s critique of enforced order.
○
Line 8: “to the dent in our car door.”
●
Symbol of Imperfection and Humanity:
●
The dent serves as a symbol of individuality and imperfection, standing in
contrast to the flawless environment around it. It suggests that true human
experiences—symbolized by wear and tear—are at odds with suburbia’s
pursuit of perfection.
○ Effect: This line emphasizes the tension between natural human flaws and
the artificial standards of suburbia. The dent symbolizes authenticity,
highlighting suburbia’s intolerance for the imperfections that make people
unique.
Psychological Interpretation of Repression:
○ The dent can be seen as a metaphor for repressed individuality, implying
that suburbia’s obsession with perfection leaves no room for genuine
human experience. The speaker’s awareness of the dent suggests a longing
for freedom from societal pressures to conform.
○ Effect: This interpretation adds a psychological dimension, where
suburbia’s order symbolizes internal repression. The dent represents the
suppressed parts of the self that do not fit into societal molds, suggesting
that true identity is incompatible with suburban ideals.
○
Lines 9–10: “No shouting here, or / shatter of glass; nothing more abrupt”
●
Imagery of Silence and Repression:
The lack of noise (“no shouting” and “no shatter of glass”) creates a sterile,
almost eerie silence, emphasizing suburbia’s need for control. The absence
of abruptness suggests that even natural expressions of emotion are stifled.
○ Effect: This silence is unsettling, implying that suburbia’s order comes at
the cost of vitality. The lack of sound symbolizes repression, suggesting that
suburbia suppresses any expression that might disrupt its uniformity.
Alternative Interpretation of Emotional Suppression:
○ “No shouting” could be interpreted as a metaphor for emotional
suppression, where suburbia’s calm exterior hides a lack of true human
expression. By excluding emotional outbursts, suburbia becomes a space
where individuality is silenced.
○ Effect: This reading highlights suburbia’s repressive nature, where
emotions are stifled to maintain appearances. The silence implies a lack of
authenticity, reinforcing the idea that suburbia is lifeless beneath its orderly
facade.
○
●
Line 11: “than the rational whine of a power mower”
●
Onomatopoeia and Irony of “Rational”:
The “whine” of the mower mimics the grating sound of machinery,
emphasizing the mechanical nature of suburbia. Describing it as “rational”
is ironic, as it suggests that the repetitive noise of maintenance is somehow
logical or normal.
○ Effect: This irony critiques the way suburbia equates rationality with
lifelessness. The “whine” is intrusive and unpleasant, symbolizing the
constant maintenance required to uphold suburbia’s facade of perfection.
Symbol of Monotony:
○ The mower’s “whine” represents the endless cycle of upkeep in suburbia,
where every aspect of the environment must be controlled. This cycle
symbolizes the monotony of suburban life, suggesting that order requires
constant intervention.
○ Effect: This interpretation adds a sense of futility, as if suburbia’s perfection
is always on the verge of decay. The mower represents the exhausting
maintenance needed to sustain an artificial lifestyle, underscoring the
poem’s critique of unnatural order.
○
●
Lines 12–13: “Cutting a straight swath in the discouraged grass.”
●
Personification of “Discouraged Grass”:
●
The grass is described as “discouraged,” as if it feels defeated by the
mower’s relentless cutting. This personification emphasizes the unnatural
suppression of nature in suburbia, where even grass must be kept in line.
○ Effect: This line portrays suburbia as hostile to natural growth, suggesting
that it requires the constant suppression of nature’s inherent vitality. The
grass, which would naturally grow freely, becomes a victim of suburbia’s
obsessive control.
Alternative Interpretation as a Symbol of Stifled Creativity:
○ The “discouraged grass” can symbolize creativity and individuality stifled by
societal expectations. Just as grass is cut down to fit a standard, people in
suburbia may feel pressured to conform, suppressing their unique qualities.
○ Effect: This interpretation reinforces the poem’s theme of repression, where
suburbia’s order requires the erasure of anything unpredictable. The grass
serves as a metaphor for the human spirit, which is “cut down” by societal
pressures to maintain uniformity.
○
Overall Psychological Interpretation
Throughout The City Planners, Atwood’s language reflects not only a critique of suburbia’s
physical structure but also a deeper commentary on the human psyche. Suburbia is
depicted as a manifestation of society’s fear of chaos, where order becomes a
psychological cage that stifles individuality, emotion, and authenticity. The speaker’s sense
of “offense” suggests an inner conflict, as if they feel trapped by societal expectations to
conform, yet are inherently uncomfortable with the lifelessness this conformity entails.
●
Order vs. Chaos as a Psychological Conflict:
Atwood presents suburbia’s order as a response to humanity’s fear of chaos. This
order represents a collective attempt to suppress the unpredictable aspects of
human nature, leading to an environment where creativity, emotion, and
individuality are sacrificed for a sense of control. The speaker’s reaction reveals the
psychological cost of this suppression, suggesting that suburbia’s order is
inherently hostile to authentic human experience.
Section 9: Advanced Analysis of The City Planners by Margaret
Atwood
Using both the TP-CASTT and MITSL methods, we’ll dissect The City Planners in a layered
approach, illuminating every facet of its structure, language, and meaning. These
analytical frameworks will reveal how Atwood’s precise choices in language, tone, and
imagery construct a complex critique of suburban conformity and humanity’s futile
attempts to control nature.
TP-CASTT Analysis
Title
●
Prediction Based on Title:
●
At first glance, The City Planners suggests a straightforward focus on
individuals responsible for urban design. One might assume the poem will
discuss their role in shaping landscapes and how they influence city life.
However, given Margaret Atwood’s reputation for social critique, there is a
sense that the title might be ironic, indicating that the poem will not
merely celebrate these figures but rather interrogate or critique their
impact.
Revisited Meaning:
○ Upon reading, it becomes clear that the title The City Planners is loaded
with irony. Atwood’s focus is less on the planners themselves and more on
the consequences of their actions—the artificiality and sterility imposed
upon nature and the environment. The title, therefore, serves as an entry
point into Atwood’s larger critique of humanity’s desire to dominate nature,
with the city planners symbolizing a mindset that values order and control
at the expense of authenticity, vitality, and freedom.
○
Paraphrase
●
The speaker drives through an orderly suburb on a quiet, sunny Sunday, observing
the calm streets and houses arranged in precise rows. This perfection, however,
feels strange and unsettling, as if suburbia’s attempt at control conceals an
underlying tension. The neatly arranged trees and meticulously maintained lawns
lack any signs of natural growth, mirroring suburbia’s sanitized, artificial order. The
driveways and lawns avoid chaos, but there are signs of hidden decay—the faint
smell of oil, splashes of paint, and cracks in the plaster hint at nature’s quiet
persistence beneath suburbia’s surface. The poem then shifts to the planners
themselves, depicted as detached and oblivious figures lost in their own insular
worlds, drawing lines that only temporarily impose order on nature.
Connotation
●
Figurative Language:
Atwood employs rich figurative language to convey suburbia’s artificiality
and the futility of attempting to suppress natural forces. For instance, the
“sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass” reflect how nature is subdued and
stripped of vitality. Words like “sanitary” and “discouraged” imply sterility
and suggest that suburbia enforces a rigid order that diminishes life’s
organic qualities.
Symbolism:
○ The cracks in the plaster and the smell of oil serve as symbols of decay and
the inevitability of nature’s return. These symbols suggest that beneath
suburbia’s orderly facade, the natural world remains persistent and will
eventually disrupt the artificial structures imposed on it.
Irony:
○ Irony is woven throughout the poem, with the term “sanity” used to
describe the unnatural order of suburbia, as if rigidity and lifelessness are
the epitome of rationality. By presenting the city planners as “insane,”
Atwood ironically criticizes the mindset that prioritizes control over
authenticity.
○
●
●
Attitude (Tone and Mood)
●
Tone:
○
●
Atwood’s tone is one of disapproval and skepticism. The choice of words like
“pedantic,” “sanitary,” and “discouraged” conveys a disdain for suburbia’s
artificial order and for the planners who impose it. Her language suggests
that suburbia’s order is shallow and forced, lacking genuine vitality.
Mood:
○ The mood is eerie and unsettling, as the reader is guided to feel
uncomfortable in the sterile environment of suburbia. There’s a sense of
underlying tension, as if the calm atmosphere hides an inevitable upheaval.
The detailed imagery of mechanical noises, suppressed growth, and lurking
decay intensifies this unsettling atmosphere, suggesting a world in denial
of its own fragility.
Shifts
●
Shift in Focus:
The poem shifts from an observational tone in the opening lines to a more
critical, ironic tone when describing the planners themselves. This shift
occurs after describing the houses and trees, with the poem moving from
imagery that critiques suburbia’s controlled landscape to a direct depiction
of the planners as figures disconnected from reality.
Shift in Tone:
○ There is also a tonal shift from calm to critical, where the initial detached
observation transforms into open criticism of suburbia’s lifelessness and the
planners’ “insane” pursuit of control. This shift underscores Atwood’s
message that suburbia’s order is both shallow and inherently flawed.
○
●
Theme
●
Central Ideas:
The central theme of The City Planners is the critique of human attempts to
control and sanitize nature. Atwood argues that humanity’s obsession with
order is not only superficial but also futile, as nature’s persistence will
eventually undermine these efforts. The poem also explores themes of
artificiality, conformity, and the dehumanizing effect of suburbia’s rigid
structures.
Supporting Evidence:
○ Atwood’s choice of language—“pedantic rows,” “sanitary trees,”
“discouraged grass”—supports the theme of artificiality, while the “cracks in
the plaster” and “private blizzard” suggest that suburbia’s order is
unsustainable and destined to be reclaimed by nature.
○
●
Title Revisited
●
Upon revisiting, the title The City Planners encapsulates Atwood’s ironic stance
toward the planners’ attempts to control nature. Rather than highlighting the
planners’ achievements, the title critiques their hubris and their “insane” disregard
for the natural world. It reflects the poem’s central theme that efforts to impose
order on nature are ultimately absurd and doomed to fail.
MITSL Analysis
Meaning
●
Literal Meaning:
The poem describes a suburban landscape where order and control
dominate every aspect, from the “sanitary trees” to the “discouraged grass.”
The speaker critiques the planners responsible for this artificial
environment, depicting them as out of touch with nature’s unpredictability.
Deeper Meaning:
○ At a deeper level, The City Planners questions humanity’s obsession with
order and its denial of natural processes. Atwood suggests that by
attempting to sanitize and control nature, society isolates itself from the
organic rhythms of life, leading to a lifeless, unsustainable environment. The
planners’ attempts at control are shown to be both ridiculous and
unsustainable, as the natural world will inevitably resurface and disrupt
suburbia’s order.
○
●
Imagery
●
Visual Imagery:
The “sanitary trees” and “discouraged grass” create a visual of an overly
controlled, lifeless landscape. These images emphasize suburbia’s
artificiality, with nature stripped of its wildness and forced into sterile
shapes.
Auditory Imagery:
○ The “whine of a power mower” provides an auditory image that contrasts
with the silence of suburbia. This noise is mechanical and intrusive,
○
●
●
symbolizing suburbia’s constant maintenance and its need to enforce order
at all costs.
Symbolic Imagery:
○ Symbols such as the “cracks in the plaster” and “capsized” houses hint at
nature’s resilience and the futility of human attempts to control it. These
symbols suggest that, despite suburbia’s appearance of stability, nature will
eventually reclaim these spaces.
Tone
●
Attitude of the Speaker:
The speaker’s attitude is one of disdain and irony. The choice of words like
“pedantic,” “sanitary,” and “insane” reflects a critical view of suburbia’s rigid
order and the planners’ misguided attempts to control nature.
Effect of Tone:
○ The tone enhances the poem’s critique by presenting suburbia as lifeless
and the planners as deluded figures who cannot see the absurdity of their
efforts. This critical tone makes the poem feel like a warning about the
dangers of prioritizing control over authenticity.
○
●
Structure
●
Stanza Arrangement:
The poem is structured in uneven stanzas, reflecting the unnatural and
forced order of suburbia. The lack of uniform stanza length mirrors
Atwood’s message about the futility of imposing rigid structures on nature.
Meter and Rhyme:
○ Atwood employs free verse, which lacks a fixed meter or rhyme scheme,
emphasizing the contrast between natural rhythms and the artificial
structure of suburbia. This structure reinforces the idea that nature resists
confinement and will ultimately defy human attempts to control it.
○
●
Language
●
Word Choice:
Atwood’s language is carefully selected to convey sterility and lifelessness,
with words like “sanitary,” “pedantic,” and “discouraged.” This choice of
language reflects the poem’s themes of artificiality and control.
Symbolism and Allusions:
○ Words like “blizzard” and “capsized” serve as symbols of natural forces that
challenge suburbia’s stability, hinting at nature’s inevitable reclamation of
human structures. These symbols reinforce the theme that suburbia’s order
is both fragile and unnatural.
○
●
Layered Themes and Juxtapositions
Contrasting Images
●
Order vs. Decay:
Atwood juxtaposes the orderly “pedantic rows” and “sanitary trees” with
images of decay, such as the “cracks in the plaster” and “sickness lingering.”
This contrast highlights the tension between suburbia’s superficial order
and the inevitable presence of natural decay.
○ Effect: This juxtaposition suggests that suburbia’s order is unsustainable, as
nature’s resilience will eventually disrupt human structures.
Mechanical vs. Organic:
○ The “rational whine of a power mower” contrasts with the “discouraged
grass” and “sanitary trees,” pitting mechanical control against organic
growth. This contrast emphasizes suburbia’s hostility toward natural
processes.
○ Effect: By contrasting mechanical and organic elements, Atwood critiques
society’s reliance on artificial means to impose order, implying that these
efforts are ultimately futile.
○
●
Structural and Thematic Symmetry
●
Symmetry in Control vs. Chaos:
●
The poem’s structure mirrors its themes by using free verse and uneven
stanzas to reflect the futility of enforcing rigid order on nature. The lack of
uniform stanza length serves as a visual reminder that nature defies
human-imposed structures.
○ Effect: This structural choice reinforces Atwood’s message that attempts to
control nature are inherently flawed, as nature’s rhythms are free and
cannot be confined within rigid boundaries.
Psychological Symmetry in Tone and Imagery:
○ The poem’s tone, from the ironic use of “sanitary” to the sinister “private
blizzard,” mirrors the speaker’s psychological discomfort with suburbia’s
sterility. This symmetry between tone and imagery creates a unified critique
of suburbia, portraying it as lifeless and oppressive.
○ Effect: By aligning tone and imagery, Atwood deepens her critique,
suggesting that suburbia’s order is not only physically oppressive but also
psychologically stifling.
○
Conclusion
Through the TP-CASTT and MITSL methods, we see that The City Planners is an intricate
critique of suburbia’s artificial order and humanity’s attempts to control nature. Atwood’s
choices in language, structure, and imagery create a layered poem that questions the
sustainability and authenticity of suburban life, presenting suburbia as a fragile construct
that nature will inevitably reclaim. The poem warns of the dangers of prioritizing control
over vitality, implying that true sanity might lie in embracing nature’s organic
unpredictability.
Expanded Symbolism and Cultural Critique
In The City Planners, Atwood uses the suburban landscape as a backdrop for a broader
critique of societal tendencies toward control, materialism, and environmental
degradation. By interpreting the poem as a reflection of society’s obsession with perfect
order and sanitized aesthetics, we can see how Atwood's critique is not only of the
planners but of the values that these planners represent.
●
●
Suburban Symbolism as a Microcosm of Consumerism: The "sanitary trees" and
"pedantic rows" of houses evoke the idea of a meticulously controlled
environment, where every element is in its place. These images resonate with the
idea of consumer culture—products designed for mass consumption, each
identical and standardized. The trees, which are supposed to represent life and
growth, are instead reduced to a controlled, lifeless uniformity, much like the
products on an assembly line.
○ Effect: Atwood seems to be commenting on how consumerism and
industrialization lead to the death of natural diversity, substituting mass
production and standardized products for the richness of organic variation.
The planners' obsession with order parallels society's tendency to
homogenize and commodify everything, even nature, for convenience and
efficiency. The critique, thus, goes beyond the immediate suburban setting,
offering a biting commentary on how society itself is constructed upon
these values.
Environmental Degradation as a Result of Consumerism: The mention of spilled
oil and the “splash of paint on brick” can be interpreted as subtle nods to pollution
and waste, which are inevitable byproducts of unchecked urbanization. These
elements suggest the cost of progress—the way suburban expansion, while
seemingly orderly, carries with it hidden environmental consequences. By focusing
on the mechanical, impersonal noise of the power mower and the image of oil
staining the garage, Atwood emphasizes how the pursuit of suburban perfection
comes at a significant environmental cost.
○ Effect: This deepens the poem’s critique, positioning it not just as a
condemnation of the planners’ vision but also as a broader commentary on
the human tendency to disregard the natural world for the sake of
short-term gain. The pollution and decay, represented by the “faint
sickness” of oil, highlight the hypocrisy in trying to impose control over
nature when nature’s forces are being slowly but surely destroyed.
Tone Through Diction: Deepening the Analysis of Word Choices
The speaker’s tone evolves throughout the poem, and a detailed examination of Atwood’s
diction will reveal how each choice builds on the mood and reinforces the poem’s themes.
The choice of words such as “pedantic,” “sanitary,” and “rebuke” carry heavy connotations,
intensifying the poem's critique of suburbia’s artificial nature.
●
From Order to Destruction: The word “pedantic” introduces the suburban world
as one obsessed with small, irrelevant details, where nothing is allowed to deviate
from the expected. “Sanitary,” with its connotation of cleanliness and sterility,
amplifies the critique, making the trees appear less like part of nature and more
like instruments of control—artificially engineered to fit an idealized aesthetic.
Effect: The tone is set with disdain and disillusionment, especially as
“pedantic” is used to suggest that suburbia is a place of rigid, unnecessary
rules. By highlighting these terms, Atwood conveys a sense of discomfort
with an environment that forces conformity and order, ignoring the natural
world’s complexity and messiness.
Irony and the Absurdity of Order: The term “sanities” is particularly ironic when
used to describe the obsessive order of suburbia. What is considered “sane”
here—the strict regulation of nature—is portrayed as a form of madness. Atwood’s
use of this word challenges the idea that order and control are inherently good,
making the speaker’s perspective one of skepticism and disbelief at how suburbia,
though perfectly arranged, is unnatural and unsustainable.
○ Effect: This ironic use of “sanities” subtly criticizes the societal norm of
equating order with health and rationality. By suggesting that suburbia’s
artificial neatness is not “sane,” Atwood calls into question the wisdom of
controlling nature to such an extent.
Gradual Build-Up of Disdain: As the poem progresses, Atwood’s word choices
become more forceful. The transition from observing suburbia to critiquing it
intensifies the speaker’s attitude toward the planners. Words like “rebuke” and
“discouraged” inject an emotional charge, moving from a clinical observation to an
impassioned response to the imposition of order on the natural world.
○ Effect: The shift in tone, from detached observation to direct criticism,
illustrates how the speaker’s discomfort with suburban order grows as the
poem progresses. The tone becomes more aggressive, reflecting the idea
that the poem itself is an act of defiance against suburban sterility.
○
●
●
Structural Connections and Symbolism
The free verse structure and uneven stanza lengths in The City Planners are not merely
formal choices—they actively contribute to the poem’s critique of suburbia’s rigid order.
The lack of a fixed rhyme scheme or meter mirrors the idea that natural forces cannot be
contained by human structures.
●
●
Structural Significance of Uneven Stanzas: Atwood’s decision to use irregular
stanza lengths, starting with longer stanzas and moving toward shorter ones,
symbolizes the instability of the suburbia she critiques. Each stanza feels like an
imposition on the poem, an attempt to force order, yet the poem refuses to
conform to a strict structure.
○ Effect: The shifting stanza lengths disrupt the flow, just as Atwood’s critique
of suburban order disrupts the notion of permanence. The poem reflects its
content: nature resists human efforts to structure and control it, and so
does the poem resist the imposition of a rigid form. The structural
irregularity enhances the critique of suburban order by underscoring the
futility of such efforts.
Meter and Free Verse: The free verse form, with its lack of meter, represents
nature’s spontaneity and unpredictability. The disordered line breaks and lack of
rhythm suggest that nature’s chaotic beauty cannot be contained by human
attempts at order. The lack of meter contrasts with the manicured, predictable
world of suburbia, emphasizing the disconnect between human control and the
organic forces of nature.
○ Effect: The use of free verse amplifies the poem’s theme of nature’s
resistance to control. The form becomes a subtle act of rebellion against the
artificiality of the suburban landscape, suggesting that true vitality lies in
unpredictability and spontaneity, not in the regulated, sterilized
environment of suburbia.
Psychological Depth and Persona of the Speaker
The poem’s speaker represents more than just an observer of suburban life; their
commentary serves as a critique of society’s pressures to conform. By analyzing the
psychological conflict embedded in the speaker’s perspective, we can better understand
the poem’s emotional intensity.
●
●
Internal Conflict and Unreliable Narration: The speaker’s attitude toward
suburbia is layered with internal conflict. At times, the speaker seems to revel in
the critique of suburbia, using sarcastic language like “sanitary trees” and “insane
faces,” but at other times, the speaker’s detachment suggests an underlying fear or
anxiety about the disordered world outside of suburbia. The discomfort with
suburbia’s order may reveal a deep psychological unease about the world’s
complexity and unpredictability.
○ Effect: This psychological tension mirrors the broader human struggle
between conformity and freedom. The speaker’s discomfort with the world
they inhabit reflects the tension many individuals feel between the desire
for safety and control (represented by suburbia) and the instinct to break
free from rigid structures (represented by nature).
Duality of the Speaker’s Persona: The speaker's persona appears both as an
insider and an outsider. While they are physically part of the suburban world, their
critical perspective positions them as an outsider looking in. This duality reflects
the tension between personal involvement and societal detachment, showing how
individuals may be complicit in a system yet remain critical of it.
○ Effect: The tension between the speaker’s role as a participant and critic
underscores the emotional conflict many people face in societies that
impose conformity. The speaker’s critique becomes an act of
self-examination, suggesting that all of us are part of this system, yet
capable of recognizing its flaws.
Layered Themes and Juxtapositions
Atwood uses contrasting images throughout the poem to reveal the complexity of
suburban life and its impact on both individuals and the environment. These
juxtapositions heighten the poem’s thematic complexity and deepen its critique of
artificiality and control.
●
●
Nature vs. Order: The contrast between the natural world and suburban order is
central to the poem’s theme. The “pedantic rows” of houses and the “sanitary
trees” are depicted as unnatural impositions on the land, while the references to
decay—“cracks in the plaster,” “faint sickness,” and the inevitable “capsizing” of
houses—suggest that nature’s resistance to order is inevitable and natural.
○ Effect: This juxtaposition emphasizes the tension between human
attempts to create a perfect, ordered world and the natural world’s inherent
chaos. Atwood argues that nature will always reclaim what is rightfully hers,
as evidenced by the inevitable decay and erosion of suburban life.
Control vs. Chaos: The poem juxtaposes control, represented by the planners and
their neatly ordered designs, with chaos, symbolized by nature and the eventual
crumbling of the suburbia they created. The “private blizzards” and “transitory
lines” drawn by the planners represent the futility of their attempts to impose
lasting order on an environment that defies it.
○ Effect: This contrast underscores the futility of human efforts to control the
uncontrollable, highlighting the fragility of the structures we build in the
face of nature’s enduring forces. It suggests that no matter how much
humans strive for perfection, disorder and decay will always find a way
through.
Conclusion
This comprehensive analysis, utilizing both the TP-CASTT and MITSL methods, has
allowed for a thorough exploration of Atwood’s The City Planners. By expanding on
symbolism, diction, tone, structure, and psychological depth, we’ve uncovered multiple
layers of meaning, revealing how Atwood critiques suburban life, human attempts at
control, and the inevitable reclamation of the natural world. The title’s ironic resonance,
the evolving tone, and the layered thematic juxtapositions all contribute to a poem that
not only critiques suburban artificiality but also delves deeply into the human psyche,
offering a poignant reflection on societal pressures, environmental concerns, and the
fragility of human efforts to impose order on nature.