EPOXY COATINGS 101 WHAT KIND TO USE AND WHEN Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When_____________________ 3 Epoxy Curing_____________________________________ 3 Types of Epoxy Resins____________________________ 4 Bisphenol A Epoxies______________________________ 4 Bisphenol F Epoxies______________________________ 5 Novolac Epoxies__________________________________ 6 Curing Agents____________________________________ 8 Evaluating the Various Types of Epoxy Coating Systems_________________ 10 Alternative Polyaspartic Coating Systems________ 14 Use Applications for Epoxy Systems_______________15 Surface Preparation_____________________________ 18 Conclusion______________________________________ 20 Useful References_______________________________ 20 Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 2 EPOXY COATINGS 101: WHAT KIND TO USE AND WHEN Epoxies are thermoset plastics typically made by the reaction of two or more chemical compounds that develop a hard and chemically resistant surface. The cured epoxy is used in a wide array of consumer and industrial applications due to its material hardness, strong adhesion, chemical resistance and other specialized properties. Such cured epoxies make durable coatings and can be used for a variety of purposes including strong adhesives, paints, primers and coatings for metals and floors. For example, one of the most economical approaches for the prevention of material degradation or corrosion is to use an epoxy coating. Another application is for high performance, heavy-duty protective flooring. For ambient temperature applications, epoxy and polyaspartic coating systems are preferred because of their protective properties and ease of application on metallic and concrete surfaces. This whitepaper will discuss the chemistry, properties, applications and examples of use for these types of coatings. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 3 EPOXY CURING Generally, epoxies are cured as one component (1k) or two component (2k) systems. The 2k system consists of an epoxy resin, which is often referred to as Part A, and the epoxy curing agent or hardener, which is usually referred to as Part B. These are mixed together prior to application and on curing develop a highly crosslinked macromolecular structure. The applicator has a specific amount of time to apply the coating before the system gels or becomes hard. The 1k system will contain both the epoxy and the hardener together in the same pot, but will be more dependent on the evaporative properties in comparison to the 2k system; therefore, the 1k system is not commonly used for coating applications. Figure 1. Epoxide chemical structure. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 4 TYPES OF EPOXY RESINS The most common Part A components are bisphenol A, bisphenol F or novolac resins. BISPHENOL A EPOXIES Bisphenol A epoxies are general purpose and are very cost effective. This type of epoxy has excellent alkali resistance, good acid resistance and reasonable solvent resistance. Bisphenol A is a reaction product of phenol and acetone, which is then reacted with epichlorohydrin via a condensation reaction to form diglycidyl ether bisphenol A resin or DGEBA. The DGEBA has a honey-like viscosity that is often used in solvent-free coatings and flooring systems. By increasing the concentration of bisphenol A in liquid DGEBA, a higher molecular weight formulation can be produced that form semi-solid or solid resins. Such resins require a solvent to reduce their viscosity to allow their use as maintenance primers for steel or as corrosion resistant films. The higher molecular weight formulation allows for longer branching when cured with the hardener. With more reactive sites per DGEBA molecule, the greater the three-dimensional crosslink density of the resultant cured epoxy. The higher the crosslink density, the greater the hardness and chemical resistance of the cured epoxy. Bisphenol A epoxy resins are widely used for epoxy coatings for concrete and steel. One of the highest volume cycloaliphatic epoxies is hydrogenated bisphenol A epoxy. It exhibits a lower resin viscosity and lower glass Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 5 transition temperature than DGEBA with the same number of repeat units but also has superior moisture resistance, better UV-stability, better color and gloss stability, higher impact resistance, improved dimensional stability and higher thermal stability. BISPHENOL F EPOXIES Bisphenol F epoxies have a lower viscosity, excellent alkali resistance and better acid and solvent resistance compared to Bisphenol A. The difference between the two is that the bisphenol F is produced from the reaction of phenol with formaldehyde, which results in a phenolic chemical lacking the two methyl groups that are present between the ring structure of bisphenol A resins. Bisphenol F is then reacted with epichlorohydrin to form the diglycidyl ether bisphenol F resin or DGEBF. Because of the missing two methyl groups, the viscosity of DGEBF resins is about one-third of that of the equivalent DGEBA resins. The lower viscosity results in the requirement for fewer additives and diluents for ease of application. With this chemistry there is a higher proportion of trifunctional epoxy molecules, which can somewhat enhance the strength and chemical resistance of the cured epoxy. An advantage of the bisphenol F epoxy resins is they are less likely to crystallize at low temperatures during curing. Heating the resin to re-liquefy the crystals is feasible, but heating the resin pot at the job site is non-trivial. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 6 NOVOLAC EPOXIES Novolac epoxy resins are modifications of bisphenol F formed by using excess phenol. This results in epoxy resins with a higher molecular weight and thus higher viscosity. The higher molecular weight produces a resin that has better chemical resistance and the aromatic ring structure increases the heat resistance of the cured epoxy. Novolac resins tend to be more brittle but the brittleness can be reduced through formulation and curing agent selection. Note that resin content is often modified by the formulator in order to impart certain desirable properties such as chemical resistance. In addition, the formulator can also alter the chemistry to produce a required surface appearance or specific application properties. Typical properties for these resins are shown in Table 1. Table 1 Relative Performance Properties of Epoxy Resins Typical Performance Property Bis A Epoxy Bis F Epoxy Novolac Epoxy Adhesion H H H UV protection L L L Abrasion resistance H H H VOCs M H H Crystallization L H H Moisture tolerance H H H Heat resistance L M H Chemical resistance L M H Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 7 Sulfuric acid L M H Acetone L M H Methanol L M H Sodium hydroxide H H H Organic acids L L H Performance: H – Highest, M – Medium, L – Lowest (Source: J.D. Durig, “Comparisons of Epoxy Technology for Protective Coatings and Linings in Wastewater Facilities”, Proceedings of the Seminars, SSPC 99-14, p 31-37, 1999) CURING AGENTS There are many epoxy curing agents available, some of which are polyamine based. These promote the crosslinking reaction and fall into one of four categories: 1. Aliphatic and cycloaliphatic amines and polyamines 2. Amides and polyamides 3. Cycloaliphatic 4. Amine adducts The type of curing agent determines the properties of the final cured epoxy, including pot life, dry time, penetration, wetting ability and hardness. Aliphatic ethylene amines include aminoethyl piperazine, diethylene triamine, ethylene diamine and triethylene tetramine. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 8 These curing agents have high reactivity and thus the curing is fairly fast at ambient temperatures. The amine-based curing agents usually produce more durable and chemically resistant coatings than amide-based curing agents but most have a tendency to blush in moist conditions. Blushing is a reaction between the curing agent and the moisture in the air; this produces a waxy surface layer on actively curing epoxy. Formulators may modify these agents with other hardeners to obtain the desired properties. For example, hexamethylene diamine and trimethyl hexamethylene diamine are a class of aliphatic ethylene polyamines that minimize blushing. Because of their structure they have greater compatibility with the resin but produce less flexible and higher hardness cured systems. Formulation modifications can overcome some of these issues. Polyetheramines result in good color retention, good flexibility and reduced carbonation tendencies but react more slowly. Metaxylylene diamine has good compatibility with epoxy resins, and because of the aromatic backbone it has good heat resistance. Because it also has unhindered primary amines in the structure, the resin can cure at lower temperatures. However, because potentially toxic chemicals from the curing agent can also be released, aliphatic amines tend to be viewed less favorably. Polyamides and amidoamines are more surface-tolerant and less troubled by moisture than the aliphatic amines. In addition, this class of curing agent has lower viscosity, improved adhesion, longer pot life, less risk for carbonation and fewer health hazards. The advantage is from the inclusion of a fatty acid into the backbone of the molecule from the reaction of tall oil fatty acid and ethylene amine. Typical applications include their use as primers or tie-coats for steel and concrete. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 9 Cycloaliphatic curing agents generally provide better water/ moisture resistance, weatherability, low blush and water spotting, heat resistance and better chemical resistance. The stretch of the ring structure imparts better impact resistance, rigidity and mechanical strength. Most widely used are isophorone diamine and diaminocyclohexane. High performance epoxy coatings employ a Part B curing agent that is a blend consisting partially of cycloaliphatics. Bis-(p-aminocyclohexyl) methane curing agent produces good low temperature cure properties with good heat resistance and mechanical strength, which yields a tougher coating and solvent resistance. Acid resistance is somewhat reduced depending on the formulation. Part B curing agents of amine adducts are produced when an amine such as diethylene triamine is reacted with a small amount of the epoxy resin where an active hydrogen of the residual amino groups is formed. This produces a curing agent where there has already been some initial curing. The pre-reacted amine adduct prior to application is mixed with the polyamine curing agent to produce the cured epoxy. The resulting epoxy is much like other epoxies, but because of the higher molecular weight it has improved overall physical properties including less volatility with little amine odor, less toxicity, less exotherm output, better color stability and curing at slightly cooler temperatures. Curing time may also be faster than with epoxies using other types of curing agents. EVALUATING THE VARIOUS TYPES OF EPOXY COATING SYSTEMS To obtain the desired optimum cured epoxy properties, the thermoset resins and hardeners must be mixed. However, it is Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 10 critical that a specific amount of hardener is used for a certain weight of resin as specified by the formulator. For specialty epoxy systems the formulator can vary the epoxy equivalent weight, which is the weight of material that is considered to have one reactive site in order to produce cured material with specific properties. Solvent-borne epoxy resins have an issue with the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during application and are no longer as widely used. Waterborne epoxy systems were developed to overcome this issue. There are two basic coating systems, often referred to as Type I and Type II. The Type I system primarily consists of liquid bisphenol A and epoxy resins with an epoxy equivalent weight that is less than 250, while Type II is mostly composed of solid epoxy resin with a higher molecular weight. For Type I systems, the curing agent both crosslinks the epoxy resins in the final form and also serves as the emulsifier for the epoxy resin. Thus, immediately after mixing the emulsion particles contain both the curing agent and the epoxy resin. There may also be some amine in the aqueous phase. Waterborne Type I systems are typically formulated to a zero volatile organic compound and because of their good handling, flow and film formation properties do not require a co-solvent. In addition, the low epoxide equivalent weight of the epoxy resin has a high concentration and close proximity of epoxide groups within the same dispersed particle that leads to a rapid reaction within the particle. This can result in a short working or pot life. After the water evaporates from the system, the particles will coalesce and produce a relatively uniform morphology form because of the high rates of diffusion. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 11 This results in a coating with good adhesion. Originally Type II solid epoxy at about 50 to 55% solids content is pre-dispersed in water and co-solvent with an emulsifier. Because of the potential for poor flow and coalescence of solid epoxy particles, about 5-10% glycol ether is added to the dispersions. To react with the epoxy resin, curing agents are needed to migrate from the water phase to the dispersed epoxy particles. As the water evaporates a heterogeneous film forms as the coating coalesces. Although the properties of the resulting coating are good, they still produced some VOCs and have thus been primarily replaced by the development of the 100% solids-based epoxy systems. A 100% solids-based epoxy system was developed to eliminate any VOC and water. Basically, it is simply resin that is mixed with some hardener or reactive diluent. No water or co-solvents are used. Thus, rather than drying by evaporation, it is cured. This type of epoxy system creates the thickest coating, about 10 mils or more, and results in the strongest coating in a single application. They tend to be more abrasion, stain and chemical resistant and have a high gloss finish. These epoxy systems provide excellent durability, and depending on formulation and installation technique, can protect concrete from chemical exposure, impact and other abuse. The biggest issue is the short pot life for these epoxy systems. There are many benefits for the 100% solids-based epoxy polymeric system. Because there is no solvent the coating thickness remains almost identical before and after curing. The lack of solvent also renders these systems almost odorless. Since there is little shrinkage, a single coating can achieve thicknesses of about 10 mils. Curing time and return to service Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 12 is shorter because the curing is via an exothermic reaction. Because crosslinking density is higher compared to waterborne formulations, their mechanical properties are better. Table 2 compares generic waterborne to 100% solid epoxy systems. Table 2 Comparison of Epoxy Systems Attribute Waterborne 100% Solids Volatile organic compounds Low to zero Low to zero Coating thickness per application Less More Requirement for multiple applications Yes None Typical single coating thickness 3 mils 10 mils Cost for 10 mil thickness coating Greater Less Cure time Longer Less Pot life Longer Shorter Industrial applications Light Heavy Durability Good Longer Chemical resistance Good Better Abrasion resistance Good Better UV stability Poor Poor Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 13 ALTERNATIVE POLYASPARTIC COATING SYSTEMS Polyaspartic systems are a hybrid material that is similar to polyurethane and is based on an aliphatic polyisocyanate that is reacted with an aliphatic diamine. This makes up a special class of hindered secondary amines that have been specially designed for certain properties for specific coating applications. The reactivity of these amines is influenced by steric hinderance and the intramolecular hydrogen bonding. Modifications of the polyaspartic ester resin and polyisocyanate allow the formulator to optimize the pot life and dry time of the coating, and forgo the use of tin catalysis. The elimination of the tin catalyst permits thicker film application than is possible with traditional polyurethane coatings as well as the microblistering from the release of carbon dioxide because of the tin catalyzed reaction of isocyanate with water. For these systems, atmospheric moisture vapor catalyzes the polyaspartic curing reaction. Thus, the coating cures quickly but maintains a workable pot life. Curing time is faster than the epoxy resin systems and depending on the formulation can be applied and cured at below freezing temperatures. The result is a hard, durable surface with excellent abrasion, chemical resistance and UV-stability, with the UV-stability being better than available from epoxy systems. These types of coatings have low or zero VOC. However, solvent based polyaspartic systems release VOCs and require good ventilation during installation. Surface preparation is critical for proper coating adhesion. Polyaspartic coatings, such as the Performance Industries Poly 200, can be used as a top coat over an epoxy coating, resulting Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 14 in a complete flooring system with better UV-stability and more comfortable walking because of its flexibility. USE APPLICATIONS FOR EPOXY SYSTEMS Epoxy systems applications include coatings, molded parts and electronic packaging. For this whitepaper we will focus on the flooring application and in particular coating concrete floors. An epoxy coating on a concrete floor will provide a durable, long lasting solution for a variety of commercial and industrial applications, such as in manufacturing and industrial plants, commercial and retail stores, hospitals, garages, warehouses, and aircraft hangars to mention just a few. Such coatings can produce a decorative, high gloss finish that is easy to clean, chemically resistant and can eliminate potential safety hazards by improving traction. Figure 2. Epoxy systems provide an attractive and functional coating for aircraft hangars and garages. Both waterborne and 100% solid-based epoxy systems are widely used for coating concrete flooring because of the broad range of benefits they provide. These include long-term durability and Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 15 life span, customizable color and appearance, moisture vapor transmission mitigation, chemical resistance, slip resistance, ease of cleaning, static control, thermal shock resistance and flexible installation. The solid-based epoxy system produces a thicker single application heavy-duty coating that is hard, resilient and highly durable, while the waterborne epoxy system may require additional coating applications. The pot life is less for a 100% solid-based epoxy system, but dries more rapidly and the floor will be back in operation more quickly. Both systems require similar surface preparations. Some formulators modify the resin and curing agent to enhance properties such as abrasion or chemical resistance. A premium 100% solid-based epoxy system that has been specially modified to optimize properties for flooring is Epoxy-Coat, a cycloaliphatic product from Certified Performance Coatings. Certified Performance Coatings is a world-class, high performance coating systems formulator that specializes in industrial and commercial floor coatings designed for high impact and abrasion and corrosion resistance. Certified Performance Coatings formulations are unique and have been developed based on customer input, testing and applicator feedback and are available in an easy-to-use kit. All of their resins must meet strict quality control standards. Nearly one billion square feet of coated installations have used products from Certified Performance Coatings. Epoxy-Coat is their flagship product line for commercial and residential uses and can be applied over concrete or asphalt, wood, and metal surfaces. Pave-Patch is an epoxy product used to repair cement and asphalt surfaces. Deck-Coat is perfect for outdoor use on cement, asphalt and wood surfaces, and Counter-Coat is perfect for interior counter Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 16 tops for bars, kitchens bathrooms. It is available in out rejection flake colors from epoxy-coat and all of the metallic colors in Metallic Coat. Metallic Coat is another epoxy-based product with primary uses being interior floors from bars, restaurants and offices to kitchen floors, garage floors and basements. Because Epoxy-Coat can be applied in a single coat with a thickness of 10 mils (five times the thickness of single application waterborne epoxy coatings), the coating is long lasting. When compared to a waterborne epoxy system, the coating can be ten times more durable but at only 1.5 times the cost. It is self-leveling with no odors. Aluminum oxide can be added to make a non-skid surface. The product is available for both large-scale industrial and commercial applications as well as for the do-it-yourselfer. It is the same formulation as used by NASA. Performance Industries provides a lifetime warranty for its EpoxyCoat product when used with a Poly 200 top coat. The Poly 200 is a UV stable, abrasion resistant, single component top coat that outperforms polyurethane because it is polyaspartic based. The Epoxy-Coat product data sheet provides the properties and installation requirements. Performance Industries can provide experienced, professional applicators for large commercial or industrial projects, and tutorials for the do-it-yourselfer that wants to obtain a professional coating for a home project. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 17 Figure 3. Layers of a coating system. SURFACE PREPARATION Surface preparation is critical for an acceptable application. The concrete floor must be swept clean of debris, and any oils, grease or sealant on the floor must be removed. With new concrete, contaminants are released during curing and thus waiting about 28 days is usually recommended. To minimize pinholes from air release from the concrete into the coating, any temperature difference between the concrete and air Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 18 should be minimal or the application should be performed in the evening to allow for natural cooling. Many formulators recommend application should be between 40-80°F (4-27°C). For new and old concrete too much moisture being released can affect the bond between the floor and the coating. Professional instruments such as a non-invasive depth electronic moisture meter can be used to check the conditions. For the do-it-yourselfer, a reasonable trick is to completely tape down a plastic bag and check on it after a day has passed. If there is any moisture present when the plastic is peeled away then a moisture barrier coating will be required before the epoxy coating can be applied. Surface roughness can impact adhesion and should be examined prior to installation. This is particularly critical for coating metal surfaces. The do-it-yourselfer should follow the formulator’s instructions such as provided by the Performance Industries EpoxyCoat video tutorial in order to obtain optimum results. Note that most failures are not because of the coating but because of issues associated with an inadequate or improper installation. Preparation Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When Mixing 19 Application After curing Figure 4. Steps to installing an epoxy coating system. To ensure proper surface preparation, one can also consider using an installation company. Performance Floors and Performance Roads both utilize Certified Performance Coatings for installation services. Performance Roads handles larger projects, such as repairing roads, bridge decks, curbs, highways and more. Performance Floors specializes in epoxy coating installations on commercial and residential floors. CONCLUSION Epoxy and polyaspartic systems have a wide range of commercial applications. In this whitepaper we have focused on floor coating applications, described the chemistry of the various commercially available formulations and their strengths and weaknesses. Formulators, such as Epoxy-Coat, modify the resins and curing agents in order to optimize the properties of the resulting coating. For this reason, there is no standard epoxy and not all epoxy systems behave the same or have the same cured properties. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 20 USEFUL REFERENCES 1. K.B. Tator ed, ASM Handbook volume 5B: Protective Organic Coatings (2015). 2. J.D. Durig, “Comparisons of Epoxy Technology for Protective Coatings and Linings in Wastewater Facilities”, Proceedings of the Seminars, SSPC 99-14, pp 31-37 (1999). 3. Three Bond Technical News, Curing Agents for Epoxy Resin (1990). 4. Q.Xiang and F. Xiao, “Applications of epoxy materials in pavement engineering”, Construction and Building Materials, 235 (2020). 5. M.J. Watkins, D.J. Weinmann and J.D. Elmore, Formulating HighPerformance Waterborne Epoxy Coatings (2006). 6. NACE No.6/SSPC-SP 13-2018, Surface Preparation of Concrete-2018 (2018). 7. J.R. Cavallo, “A Systematic Approach to Coating Failure Analysis”, CoatingsPro, January 2021, pp 64-66. 8. Performance Epoxy Curing Agent Part B. Material Safety Data Sheet. 9. Epoxy-Coat Floor Coating Kit. Product Data Sheet. 10. Epoxy-Coat Epoxy Flooring Installation Instructions. Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 21 169 N. Gratiot • Mt. Clemens, MI 48043 Office: 800-841-5580 Fax: 586-468-8440 Tech Support: support@epoxy-coat.com CertifiedPerformanceCoatings.com A family of professional high performance coating kits and installation Epoxy-Coat Metallic-Coat Deck-Coat Counter-Coat Pave Patch Do-It-Yourself Kits: epoxy-coat.com metallic-coat.com counter-coat.com deck-coat.com PerformancePavePatch.com Installation Services: PerformanceFloor.com PerformanceRoads.com Expert Services Provided to: Epoxy Coatings 101: What Kind to Use and When 22