UNDERLYING VALUES UNCONDITIONAL LOYALTY AND COMMITMENT One of the underlying values presented is nationalism. Based on the first editorial cartoon 11.1 “Wherever you go, we will follow” if we interpret this title it may be a statement of loyalty and support, indicating that no matter where someone goes or what they do, there will always be people who support and accompany them. It’s often used to convey a sense of unity, commitment, and solidarity. We can see unconditional loyalty and commitment since, in the Philippines throughout the American era, there was a complicated interplay between the quest of political autonomy, cultural revival, and resistance against colonial control. And, even though we are sunken due to different circumstances we are enabled to support and stay loyal. DEMOCRACY AND FREEDOM The concepts of democracy and freedom were promoted in both life and politics during American period as Filipino sought greater participation in governance and protection of individuals right, the ideals of democracy and active citizen participation emerged as foundational values, emphasizing of collective decision making and political engagement. And, it emphasizes the ideals of liberty in both personal lives and political system. We can see this value in editorial cartoon 11.4 “FIFTEEN YEARS OF PARTY POLITICS” which depicts the elected government officials and citizens voting based on their respective platforms. EDUCATION AND ENLIGHTENMENT In the editorial cartoon 11.20 “AKALA MO KUNG SINO”, this emphasize the education and enlightenment were prevalent as the Filipino recognized the importance of knowledge and critical thinking in shaping the future of the nation. This was also meant that we are uplifting the society and fostering social mobility. RACIAL DISCRIMINATION During the American period in the Philippines, racial discrimination was a pervasive issue, both in daily life and in politics. Filipinos were often treated as second-class citizens by the American colonial government and by American civilians living in the Philippines. In politics, Filipinos were marginalized and excluded from positions of power, with governance primarily in the hands of American officials. In Philippine cartoons era, racial discrimination might be depicted through caricatures of Filipinos as inferior or subservient to their American counterparts. These cartoons could reflect the power dynamics and inequalities present in society at the time, serving as a form of social commentary or critique. We can see this in the editorial cartoons 11.11 “FILIPINO VS. AMERICAN TEACHER IN 1915” this depicts the injustice and inequality as well as in editorial cartoon 11.17 “FILIPINO VS. AMERICAN WORKER IN 1928”. RESILIENCE AND ADAPTABILITY In this reading, Filipinos demonstrated as resilience and adaptability in navigating the complexities, in finding ways to preserve their heritage and traditions while also embracing modernity and progress. And we can see this in editorial cartoon 11.21 “MANILA UNDERWATER” as we can see in this caricature the American started to address the public sanitation in a destitute state with overflowing esteros and without adequate sewers and drainages system. So, they started building canals for sanitation and public health. But the only problem is they didn’t plan it well so there was more trouble than resolving it.