Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Chapter Two Determinants of Interest Rates 1 Interest Rate Fundamentals Nominal interest rates: the interest rates actually observed in financial markets Directly affect the value (price) of most securities traded in the money and capital markets. Changes in interest rates influence the performance and decision making for individual investors, businesses, and governmental units. 2-2 2 1 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Key U.S. Interest Rates, 1972 to 2019 2-3 3 Loanable Funds Theory Loanable funds theory explains interest rates and interest rate movements The interaction of supply and demand of funds sets the basic opportunity cost rate (real interest rate) in the economy. The central bank estimates supply and demand of funds from households, business, government and foreign sources through its flow of funds accounts. 2-4 4 2 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Supply and Demand of Loanable Funds Interest Rate Demand Supply r* Quantity of Loanable Funds 2-5 5 Supply and Demand of Loanable Funds Other factors held constant; more funds are supplied as interest rates increase. (The reward of supplying funds is higher.) More funds are demanded as interest rates decrease. (The cost of borrowing funds is lower.) The interaction of supply and demand of funds sets the basic opportunity cost rate (real interest rate) in the economy. 2-6 6 3 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Supply and Demand of Loanable Funds The central bank estimates supply and demand of funds from households, business, government and foreign sources through its flow of funds accounts. The largest suppliers of loanable funds are households. Household savings rates have increased since the financial crisis. The second largest net supplier of funds is the foreign sector. The U.S. remains highly reliant on foreign sources of funds to meet its funds’ demands. 2-7 7 Net Supply of Funds in U.S. in 2019 2-8 8 4 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Determinants of Household Savings 1. 2. 3. 4. Interest rates Income and wealth: the greater the wealth or income, the greater the amount saved, Risk of securities investments: the greater the perceived risk of securities investments, the less households are willing to invest at each interest rate. Near-term spending needs: they will reduce the supply of funds from a given household. 2-9 9 Determinants of Business Invested domestically. Business sector often has excess cash or working capital, that it can invest for short period of time in financial assets. 1. Interest rates on financial assets 2. Expected risk on financial securities 3. Businesses’ future investment needs 2-10 10 5 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Determinants of Governments Invested in the U.S. When some governments temporarily generate more cash inflows than they have budgeted to spend. These fund can be loaned out to financial market fund users until needed. During the financial crisis, the federal government significantly increased the funds it supplied to business and consumers as it attempted to rescue the U.S. economy. 2-11 11 Determinants of Foreign Funds Invested in the U.S. 1. Relative interest rates and returns on global investments 2. Expected exchange rate changes 3. Financial conditions in foreign investors’ home countries change relative to the U.S. economy 4. Foreign central bank investments in the U.S. 2-12 12 6 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Demand for Loanable Funds Other factors held constant, more funds are demanded as interest rates decrease (the cost of borrowing funds is lower). Demand by Households Financing purchase of homes (mortgage loans) Durable good (car loans, appliance loans) Nondurable goods (education loans, medical loans) 2-13 13 Demand for Loanable Funds Demand by Businesses Financing investment in long-term (fixed) assets (plant and equipment) Financing short-term working capital needs (inventory and accounts receivable) By issuing debt and other financial instruments The greater the number of profitable projects available to businesses, or the better the overall economic conditions, the greater the demand for loanable funds. 2-14 14 7 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Demand for Loanable Funds Demand by Governments State and local government issue debt instrument to finance temporary imbalances between operating revenues (e.g. taxes) and budged expenditures. The central government finance current budget deficit (expenditures greater than taxes) and partly to finance past deficit. 2-15 15 Demand for Loanable Funds Demand by Foreign participants (households, businesses, and governments) Foreign borrowers look for the cheapest source of dollar funds globally. In addition to interest costs, foreign borrowers consider non-price terms on loanable funds as well as economic conditions in their home country and the general attractiveness of the U.S. dollar relative to their domestic currency. 2-16 16 8 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Equilibrium Interest Rates Excess supply Excess demand 2-17 17 Equilibrium Interest Rates As long as competitive forces are allowed to operate freely in a financial system, the interest rate that equates the aggregate supply of loanable funds with the aggregate demand, Q*, is the equilibrium interest rate, i*. When the interest rate is iH, a surplus of loanable funds in the financial system will result in a lower interest rate. In contrast, when the interest rate is iL, a shortage of loanable funds in the financial system will result in a higher interest rate. 2-18 18 9 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Shifts in Supply and Demand Curves change Equilibrium Interest Rates Increased supply of loanable funds Increased demand for loanable funds Interest Rate Interest Rate SS DD SS* DD DD* i** i* E i* E* i** Q* Q** Quantity of Funds SS E* E Q* Q** Quantity of Funds 2-19 19 Factors that Cause Supply and Demand Curves to Shift Increase in Affect on Supply Affect on Demand Wealth & income Increase N/A As wealth and income increase, funds suppliers are more willing to supply funds to markets. Result: lower interest rates Risk Decrease Decrease As the risk of an investment decreases, funds suppliers are less willing to increases purchase the claim. All else equal, demanders of funds would be less willing to borrow as well. Result: higher interest rates Near term spending needs Decrease N/A As current spending needs increase, funds suppliers are less willing to invest. Result: higher interest rates Monetary expansion Increase N/A As the central bank increases the supply of money in the economy, this directly increases the supply of funds available for lending. Result: lower interest rates 2-20 20 10 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Factors that Cause Supply and Demand Curves to Shift Increase in Affect on Supply Affect on Demand Economic growth Increase Increase With stronger economic growth, wealth and incomes rise, increasing the supply of funds available. As U.S. economic strength improves relative to the rest of the world, foreign supply of funds is also increased. Business demand for funds increases as more projects are profitable. Result: indeterminate effect on interest rates, but at more rapid growth rates interest rates tend to rise. Utility derived from assets Decrease Increase As utility from owning assets increases, funds suppliers are less willing to invest and postpone consumption whereas funds demanders are more willing to borrow. Result: higher interest rates Restrictive covenants Increase Decrease As loan or bond covenants become more restrictive, borrowers reduce their demand for funds. Result: lower interest rates 2-21 21 Factors that Cause Supply and Demand Curves to Shift Factor Impact on Supply of Funds Impact on Equilibrium Interest Rate* Interest rate Movement along the supply curve Direct Total wealth Shift supply curve Inverse Risk of financial security Shift supply curve Direct Near-term spending needs Shift supply curve Direct Monetary expansion Shift supply curve Inverse Economic conditions Shift supply curve Inverse Factor Impact on Demand of Funds Impact on Equilibrium Interest Rate Interest rate Movement along the demand curve Direct Utility derived from asset purchased with borrowed funds Shift demand curve Direct Restrictiveness of nonprice conditions Shift demand curve Inverse Economic conditions Shift demand curve Direct 2-22 22 11 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Interest Rate Fundamentals The components of the nominal interest rate: The real riskless rate of interest that is compensation for the pure time value of money, An expected inflation premium that is time dependent A risk premium for liquidity, default and interest rate risk. 2-23 23 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities 𝒊∗𝒋 = 𝒇 𝑹𝑰𝑹, 𝑰𝑷, 𝑫𝑹𝑷𝒋 , 𝑳𝑹𝑷𝒋 , 𝑺𝑪𝑷𝒋 , 𝑴𝑷𝒋 where 𝑹𝑰𝑹 = 𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒍 𝒊𝒏𝒕𝒆𝒓𝒆𝒔𝒕 𝒓𝒂𝒕𝒆 𝑰𝑷 = 𝒊𝒏𝒇𝒍𝒂𝒕𝒊𝒐𝒏 𝒓𝒂𝒕𝒆 𝑫𝑹𝑷𝒋 = 𝒅𝒆𝒇𝒂𝒖𝒍𝒕 𝒓𝒊𝒔𝒌 𝒑𝒓𝒆𝒎𝒊𝒖𝒎 𝑳𝑹𝑷𝒋 = 𝒍𝒊𝒒𝒖𝒊𝒅𝒊𝒕𝒚 𝒓𝒊𝒔𝒌 𝒑𝒓𝒆𝒎𝒊𝒖𝒎 𝑺𝑪𝑷𝒋 = special provisions 𝑴𝑷𝒋 = 𝒎𝒂𝒕𝒖𝒓𝒊𝒕𝒚 𝒑𝒓𝒆𝒎𝒊𝒖𝒎 2-24 24 12 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities: Inflation Inflation is the continual increase in the price level of a basket of goods and services In a lot of countries, inflation is measured using indexes. • Consumer price index (CPI). • Producer price index (PPI). Annual inflation rate using the CPI index between years t and t + 1 would be equal to: Inflation (IP ) CPI t 1 CPI t 100 CPI t © McGraw Hill 2-25 25 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities: Real Risk-Free Rate A real risk-free rate is the interest rate that would exist on a risk-free security if no inflation were expected over the holding period of a security. The higher society’s preference to consume today, the higher the real risk-free rate (𝑹𝑭𝑹). Relationship among the real risk-free rate (𝑹𝑭𝑹), the expected rate of inflation (𝑬 𝑰𝑷 ), and the nominal interest rate (i) is referred to as the Fisher effect. • The Fisher effect is often written as the following: 𝒊 = 𝑹𝑭𝑹 + 𝑬(𝑰𝑷) © McGraw Hill 2-26 26 13 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Example 2-1 Calculations of Real Interest Rates (r) The one-year T-bill rate in 2018 averaged 2.25% and inflation for the year was 1.90%. If investors had expected the same inflation rate as that actually realized (i.e., 1.90%), then according to the Fisher effect the real interest rate for 2018 was: r (RIR) = 2-27 27 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities (cont’d) Default Risk Premium (DRP)(Credit Risk) DRPj = ijt – iTt ijt = interest rate on security j at time t iTt = interest rate on similar maturity U.S. Treasury security at time t (risk-free rate) the risk that a security issuer will fail to make its promised interest and principal payments to the buyer of a security. The default risk on many corporate bonds is evaluated and categorized by various bond rating agencies such as Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s.. The default risk premium tend to increase when the economy is contracting. 2-28 28 14 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Moody’s Rating 2-29 29 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities (cont’d) Financial Crisis 2-30 30 15 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities (cont’d) Liquidity risk the risk that a security can be sold at a predictable price with low transaction costs on short notice. A highly liquid asset is one that can be sold at a predictable price with low transaction costs, and thus can be converted into its full market value at short notice. If a security is illiquid, investors add a liquidity risk premium (𝑳𝑹𝑷) to the interest rate on the security that reflects its relative liquidity. • L R P might also be thought of as an “illiquidity” premium. L R P may also exist if investors dislike long-term securities because their prices (present values) are more sensitive to interest rate changes than short-term securities. 2-31 31 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities (cont’d) Special Provisions (SCP) Written into the contracts underlying the issuance of a security. Taxability: Convertibility Ex. Interest payments on municipal bonds are free of federal, state, and local taxes. Security holders have the opportunity to exchange one security for another type of the issuer’s securities at a preset price. Callability An issuer has the option to call a security prior to maturity at a preset price. 2-32 32 16 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Determinants of Interest Rates for Individual Securities (cont’d) Term to Maturity Term structure of interest rates (yield curve) a comparison of market yields on securities, assuming all characteristics except maturity are the same. Maturity premium (MP) The difference between the required yield on longand short-term securities of the same characteristics except maturity. 2-33 33 Term Structure of Interest Rates Relationship between a security’s interest rate and its remaining term to maturity (that is, the term structure of interest rates) can take a number of different shapes. Explanations for the shape of the yield curve fall predominately into three theories: 1. Unbiased expectations theory. 2. Liquidity premium theory. 3. Market segmentation theory. © McGraw Hill 2-34 34 17 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Explanations for the Shape of the Term Structure of Interest Rates Unbiased expectations theory—at any given point in time, the yield curve reflects the market’s current expectations of future short-term rates. According to the unbiased expectations theory, the return for holding a four-year bond to maturity should equal the expected return for investing in four successive one-year bonds (as long as the market is in equilibrium). Liquidity premium theory—long-term rates are equal to geometric averages of current and expected short-term rates, plus liquidity risk premiums that increase with the security’s maturity. Longer maturities on securities mean greater market and liquidity risk. So, investors will hold long-term maturities only when they are offered at a premium to compensate for future uncertainty in the security’s value. The liquidity premium increases as maturity increases. Market segmentation theory—assumes that investors do not consider securities with different maturities as perfect substitutes. Rather, individual investors and FIs have preferred investment horizons (habitats) dictated by the nature of the liabilities they hold. Thus, interest rates are determined by distinct supply and demand conditions within a particular maturity segment (for example, the short end and long end of the bond market). 2-35 35 Term Structure of Interest Rates: the Yield Curve Yield to Maturity 3 most common sharps: (a) Upward sloping (b) Inverted (or downward) sloping (a) (c) Flat (c) (b) Time to Maturity 2-36 36 18 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Unbiased Expectations Theory Long-term interest rates are geometric averages of current and expected future short-term interest rates 0 RN [(1 0 R1 )(1 E (1 r1 ))...(1 E ( N 1 r1 ))]1/ N 1 0RN = actual N-period rate today N = term to maturity, N = 1, 2, … 0R1 = actual current one-year rate today E(ir1) = expected one-year rates for starting years, i =0, 1 to N-1 2-37 37 Unbiased Expectations Theory Example: construction of a yield curve using the unbiased expectation theory 0R1=1.3%, E(1r1)=1.5%, E(2r1)=1.7%, E(3r1)=1.9% 0R2=? 0R3=? 0R4=? Yield curve 2-38 38 19 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Liquidity Premium Theory Long-term interest rates are geometric averages of current and expected future short-term interest rates plus liquidity risk premiums that increase with maturity 0 RN [(1 0 R1 )(1 E (1 R 1 ) L2 )...(1 E ( N 1 R 1 ) LN )]1/ N 1 Lt = liquidity premium for period t L2 < L3 < …<LN 2-39 39 Liquidity Premium Theory Example: construction of a yield curve using the liquidity premium theory 0R1=1.3%, E(1r1)=1.5%, E(2r1)=1.7%, E(3r1)=1.9% L2= 0.1%, L3= 0.2%, L4= 0.3% 0R2=? 0R3=? 0R4=? Yield curve 2-40 40 20 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 2-41 41 Market Segmentation Theory Individual investors and FIs have specific maturity preferences Interest rates are determined by distinct supply and demand conditions within many maturity segments Investors and borrowers deviate from their preferred maturity segment only when adequately compensated to do so Figure 2-10: As the supply of securities decreases in the short-term market and increases in the long-term market, the slope of the yield curve becomes steeper. 2-42 42 21 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Market Segmentation Theory 2-43 43 Implied Forward Rates A forward rate (f) is an expected rate on a shortterm security that is to be originated at some point in the future The one-year forward rate for any year N in the future is: f [(1 0 RN ) N /(1 0 RN 1 ) N 1 ] 1 N 1 1 2-44 44 22 Edited by Tracy Wang 2024/2/27 Forecasting interest Rates Example: construction of implied forward rates using the unbiased expectation theory 0R1=1.3%, 0R2=1.4%, 0R3=1.5%, 0R4=1.6%, 1f1=? 2f1 =? 3f1 =? 2-45 45 23