CE LAWS, ETHICS AND CONTRACTS ENGR. DAN GERICO L. BACANI ETHICS moral principles that govern a person's behavior or the conducting of an activity. examines the rational justification for our moral judgments; it studies what is morally right or wrong, just or unjust Ethics or moral philosophy is a branch of philosophy that "involves systematizing, defending, and recommending concepts of right and wrong behavior GENERAL ETHICS General ethics develops general principles concerning the morality of human actions. Why is general ethics important? Ethics is what guides us to tell the truth, keep our promises, or help someone in need. There is a framework of ethics underlying our lives on a daily basis, helping us make decisions that create positive impacts and steering us away from unjust outcomes. ETHICAL VALUES Ethical values are a set of moral guiding principles that determine how a company conducts business. These principles seek to serve and protect others above the organization's self-interest. Beyond fulfilling legal obligations, ethical values in business show strong moral character from leaders and employees. What are some ethical values? Ethical decision-making is based on core character values like trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness, caring, and good citizenship. Ethical decisions generate ethical behaviors and provide a foundation for good business practices. See a model for making ethical decisions CIVIL ENGINEERING: CODE OF ETHICS FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES Civil engineers uphold and advance the integrity, honor and dignity of the civil engineering profession by: • using their knowledge and skill for the enhancement of human welfare and the environment; • being honest and impartial and serving with fidelity the public, their employers/employees and clients; • striving to increase the competence and prestige of the civil engineering profession; and • supporting the professional and technical societies of their disciplines. FUNDAMENTAL CANONS 1. Civil Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public and shall strive to comply with the principles of sustainable development in the performance of their duties. 2. Civil Engineers shall perform services only in areas of their competence. 3. Civil Engineers shall issue public statements only in an objective and truthful manner. 4. Civil Engineers shall act in professional matters for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees, and shall avoid conflicts of interest. 5. Civil Engineers shall build their professional reputation on the merit of their services and shall not compete unfairly with others. 6. Civil Engineers shall act in such a manner as to uphold and enhance the honor, integrity, and dignity of the civil engineering profession. 7. Civil Engineers shall continue their professional development throughout their careers, and shall provide opportunities for the professional development of those civil engineers under their supervision. THE PRACTICE OF CIVIL ENGINEERING Quality is defined in the manual as a condition of satisfactorily meet both the project requirement and the expectations of the client or employer. It requires much effort which is considered: Conscious- Aware, sensible Continuous- Direct, Straight Consistent- Constant, Unchanging PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY As a faithful trustee to the public interest and private interest of clients, civil engineers have the following responsibilities: 1. Civil engineers shall conduct themselves in a highly professional manner and faithfully serve their clients and employers. 2. Civil engineers are bound by the Canon Laws/Guided by priciples. 3. Sustainable development is the top priority in professional engagement. 4. The highest standard of Ethical Professional Practice should be maintained when civil engineers are dealing with employers or clients. CLIENT-CIVIL ENGINEERING RELATIONSHIPS Many engineering works are formed between civil engineers and the following: Government agencies, Industry Private clients Civil engineering firms engaged for a specific project Public agencies Independent civil engineering firms OBLIGATIONS OF THE CIVIL ENGINEER As a faithful trustee, civil engineers are obliged to do the following: 1. Perform their obligations with diligence, care, and reasonable skill. 2. Shall act independently and accordingly to the contract, when required to certify or decide between a client and a third party. 3. Act as the client's faithful agent implied in the contract. 4. Give written notice on particulars of any change in the scope of services. 5. For staged services, civil engineers shall not initiate ay service without the approval of the client. 6. When required, civil engineers shall direct or work with other professions and integrate concerned work, but shall not be professionally liable for their work. 7. The civil engineer may recommend contractors or specialists to design and execute certain parts of the works. 8. Any interest which may have conflict of interest of the client should be notified by the civil engineer. LIABILITY OF THE CIVIL ENGINEER AND THE CLIENT 1. The civil engineer shall pay for damages arising out of breach of duty of care against the civil engineer to the client. 2. The client shall be liable to pay to the civil engineer if a break of client's duty is established against the client. 3. Conflicts arising from the agreement between the client and the civil engineer follows the following process: Amicable settlement. Mutual understanding Mediation. Negotiation overseen by a third-party called the mediator. Arbitration. negotiation where the thirdparty(considered as impartial) is in control in making the final decision. Litigation (court proceeding). Negotiation where courts and civil justice system are involved. 4. A third-party arbitrator should be mutually acceptable to both parties. LIMITATION OR CIVIL ENGINEER'S RESPONSIBILITY 1. The civil engineer shall not be liable for damages, loss, and costs: for any errors or omissions for documents not prepared by him or under his control, for fraudulent services or negligence by the client or any other consultant , contractor, supplier. 2. The civil engineer shall not be liable for the performance of other consultants, contractors, suppliers (regardless of recommendation). 3. The civil engineer shall not be responsible for the procedures of techniques adopted by any third party. CIVIL ENGINEERING SERVICES Typical services offered by civil engineers: Designs, consultations, and advice Feasibility studies Field investigations and engineering data collection Environmental assessments, impact statements, or engineering reports Opinions of estimates Preliminary and final designs, drawings, specifications, and construction bidding documents. Assistance in securing construction bids and in awarding contracts Construction administration and observation . Arrangements for or performance of testing of materials and equipment Assistance in start-up, assessment of capacity, and operation of facilities Preparation of operation and maintenance manuals Appraisals and rate studies Value engineering Expert testimony Assessment of risks Structural remediation or rehabilitation Project management and controls Provision of supplemental temporary staff Teaching SELECTION OF A CIVIL ENGINEER The selection of a civil engineer is one important decision for the client. A. For engineering services in construction projects. The compensation for services (full range) of an engineer in construction projects should not be less than 1 to 2% of the life-cycle cost. Thereby, selection should include an engineer who can monitor the project from design, construction, and start-up. B. As a consultant Compensation depends on the cost of services so selection is based on: Qualification Experience Reputation Quality of client service Although selection based on quality and expertise made by the client might be subjective, it is better to assign a qualified individual in the company to do the choosing. Once the selection is completed, discussions between the client and the civil engineer should define the two important things before the compensation of the engineer PRIME PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE The civil engineer can work: 1. Directly. Serve the client (considered as the project owner) 2.Indirectly. When working as a subconsultant through another engineer or architect. DESIGN COMPETITION Design competition is the process through which a civil engineer is to be selected above other competitors based on proposal or an innovative approach to solving a client's needs. Invitation is through: Directly through solicitation Indirectly through a letter of request through publication or newspaper PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE OF FOREIGN CIVIL ENGINEERS RA 8981 allows foreign engineers to practice in the Philippines by the following conditions: 1. Laws of the foreign country also allow Filipino civil engineers to practice their profession on the foreign soil. 2. Allowed under international agreement. 3. Consultant to be engaged in foreign-funded, joint venture or foreignassisted projects of the government 4. Employees of Philippine or foreign private institutions pursuant to the law. 5. Naturalized Filipino civil engineers who had been registered prior to naturalization. There are requirements for foreign civil engineers to comply before practicing in the country: Certificate of registration/license Special permit from PRC Special permit from Department of Labor and Employment CLASSIFICATION OF ENGINEERING SERVICES Services provided by Civil Engineers can be grouped into seven broad categories: A. Consultations, research, investigations, and reports B. Design services for construction projects C. Construction services D. Special services for construction projects E. Engineering support services F. Academic services G. Services as Employee A. CONSULTATIONS, RESEARCH, INVESTIGATIONS AND REPORTS This services deal primarily with collecting, interpreting, and reporting information, together with formulating conclusions and making recommendations. Typical services in this category are: A1. Preliminary and Feasibility Investigations and Reports These services usually precede the authorization of a capital project and may involve extensive investigations, analyses of conditions, and comparison of several possible plans. These studies may include the impact of a project upon the environment, sustainable development, operating costs, life-cycle costs, financing considerations, and expected revenues as bases for conclusions and recommendations regarding the advisability of undertaking a project. A2. Planning Studies These services may include the broad areas of developing the engineering requirements of master plans for long-range capital improvement programs; preparation of preliminary engineering of land development plans, urban plans, and regional plans; and the investigation of environmental conditions and preparation of environmental impact studies with subsequent engineering planning to improve or maintain existing conditions. A3. Appraisals, Valuations and Rate These services may include investigations and analyses of existing conditions; capital and operating costs; overhead costs and costs of financing: and revenues as needed to evaluate a property or to recommend establishment of prospective rates Studies A4. Assistance in Financial Matters The Civil Engineer may be engaged by a client who is planning to issue bonds, particularly revenue bonds, to finance a capital project. The scope of services may include an evaluation of capabilities of existing or proposed facilities to meet present and future needs, statements of probable construction cost, and an estimate of annual revenue requirements, with a determination of appropriate rates to provide this income. A5. Materials Engineering and Equipment Tests These services include tests of materials and equipment under established codes and standards, specialized examination of equipment and materials used in construction and industry, and other inspections and monitoring required by a client. A6. Direct Personal Services This includes services such as assistance in preparation for legal proceedings. Appearances before courts or commissions to render expert opinions and conclusions, and investigations of technical matters where specialized civil engineering knowledge, experience, and judgment is required. A7. Research and Development Research is a specialized investigation and gathering of data from existing resources or through laboratory works and processes related to the purpose and object of the research. Research and development may cover the following: (a)Development of new construction materials and methods from concept to commercialization (b)Improvement of construction materials and methods through exhaustive studies to reduce total construction cost and at the same time improve quality A8. Special Services These services can vary to suit special needs of the client and can include such diverse activities as: Value Engineering Appraisal and valuation Load testing Environmental evaluations Traffic engineering Forensic engineering for structural and other failures Operational assistance Materials design process Pilot studies Computer modelling Safety engineering Topographic, sounding and boundary survey engineering Toxic and hazardous waste evaluation Permit and application services Sales and marketing service Expert witness Representation of municipal or private entities in projects proposed for privatization B. DESIGN SERVICES FOR CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS The six standard phases of a construction project and the engineering services needed for each are; B1. Study and Report Phase This phase involves determination of project scope and economic and technical evaluation of feasible alternatives. B2. Preliminary Design Phase This phase involves the establishment of the general size and scope of the project and its location on the selected site B3. Final Design Phase This phase of project development is usually undertaken only after the client has approved the preliminary design phase material. B4. Bidding and Negotiating Phase Services under this phase may include: 1. Assisting the client in advertising for and obtaining bids or negotiating proposals for each separate prime construction contract, maintaining a record of prospective bidders to whom bidding documents have been issued, attending pre-bid conferences, and receiving and processing deposits for bidding documents. 2. Issuing addenda as appropriate to interpret, clarity, expand or amend the bidding documents. 3. Assisting the client in determining the qualifications and acceptability of prospective contractors, subcontractors and materials suppliers. 4. Consulting with and advising the client as to the acceptability of alternative materials and equipment proposed by the prospective constructors when substitution prior to the award of contracts is allowed by the bidding documents. 5. Attending the bid opening, preparing bid tabulation sheets and providing assistance to the client in evaluating bids or proposals and in assembling and awarding contracts for construction, materials, equipment and services. B5. Construction Phase Services under this phase involve consulting with and advising the client during construction and are usually those associated with service as the client's representative. Most Civil Engineers are not willing to assume the responsibilities associated with construction phase services without providing resident project representative services at the site. B6. Operation Phase At the completion of construction, the Civil Engineer may as a basic service, assist in the start- up of project operations. The Civil Engineer may be commissioned to prepare a manual for both operation and maintenance requirements, and may also provide assistance in adjusting and balancing equipment, identifying deficiencies and assisting in obtaining corrections, and performing inspections prior to the end of the project warranty period. The Civil Engineer may assist in operator training, setting up job classifications and salaries, organizing the purchase of supplies, developing charts for recording operational data, and observing and reporting on project operations C. CONSTRUCTION SERVICES • A registered Civil Engineer may engage in construction contracting after being licensed as a contractor by the Contractors Accreditation Board. It is considered unethical for a civil engineer to allow his license to be used by any other construction company except his own. • A registered Civil Engineer may provide the services of a supporting technical employee as required of a construction company. He shall however, be paid the professional fees, in addition to his regular salary, for any design work he performs for which he signs as professional Civil Engineer and/or engineer on record. • A Civil Engineer may be employed as a construction engineer, resident Civil Engineer, project engineer, quality control engineer, cost engineer or engineer inspector in a project. In accordance with section 23 of RA544, only registered Civil Engineer can take charge or supervise construction or alteration of any building or structure and any other civil engineering works mentioned in Section 2 of the mentioned Republic Act. The Civil Engineer when employed is similarly required to comply with the code of ethics of the profession as the consulting Civil Engineer. D. SPECIAL SERVICES FOR CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS Special Services required during the study, design, construction, and operation phases of a construction project may include investigations, reports, and activities beyond the scope of the basic services. These services, many of which are also listed earlier in this section under the category *Consultations, Investigations, and Reports", may relate to the clients decisions as to the feasibility scope, and location of the project. The research, compilation of engineering data, and acquisition of property may involve professional specialists in engineering and other fields. Special Services that may be provided by the Civil Engineer or negotiated with other firms or sub-consultants by the Civil Engineer acting on behalf of the client could include: Geotechnical engineering - including test borings, sampling and analysis, and recommendations. 2. Special studies, tests, and process determinations to establish design criteria or demonstrate compliance. 3. Land surveys, establishment of boundaries and monuments, preparation of easement descriptions, and related computations and drawings. 4. Engineering and topographic surveys for design and construction. 5. Mill, shop, or laboratory inspections of the materials and equipment. 6. Additional copies of reports, construction drawings, specifications, and other documents as required for bidding and construction beyond the number specified in the Basic Services agreement. 7. Extra travel and subsistence as defined by the agreement for engineering services. 8. Value engineering including review of the work of other engineers, either within the same organization or in other firms to determine whether a proposed solution is optimum and, if not, to suggest a better approach for meeting the project's functional and financial criteria. 9. Redesign to reflect changes requested by the client or necessitated by the client's acceptance of substitutions proposed by the contractor. 10. Assistance to the client as an expert witness in litigation in connection with the project or in hearings before approving and regulatory agencies. 11. Final investigations involving detailed consideration of operation, maintenance, and overhead expenses; preparation of final rate schedules, and earning and expense statements; appraisals, valuations, and material audits or inventories required for certification of force account construction performed by the client or for extra work done by the contactor. 12. Preparation of detailed applications and supporting documents, grants or advances for public works projects. 13. Plotting, computing, and filling of subdivision plans, staking of lots, and other land planning and partitioning activities. 14. Preparation of environmental assessment and impact statements and other assistance to the client in connection with public hearings. 15. Additional studied and design efforts to meet special conditions encountered during construction. 16. Assistance to the client in the selection and engagement of architects, other engineers, contractors and subcontractors, and observation and approval of their services or work; contacts with governmental agencies to obtain permits and documents; and other services related to the project development. 17. Assessment of a completed project's ability to meet its design intent relative to capacity, maintainability, operability, or reliability. 18. Computer simulation and modelling. E. ENGINEERING SUPPORT SERVICES The engineering support services in general civil engineering practice may involve drafting, land and construction surveying, and other data gathering activities for specialized purposes. Although persons who are not Civil Engineers sometimes accomplish some of these tasks, the procurement of adequate and correct data usually requires professional. Civil Engineering judgment and guidance. Since soundness of any engineering decision is dependent upon the accuracy and suitability of data obtained in field and laboratory investigations these supporting services must be under the guidance of the Civil Engineer whose decisions will be based upon those data. F. ACADEMIC SERVICES These services involve full or part time teaching or training of prospective professionals and also the upgrading of knowledge and skills of fellow professionals. Academic services may include: a) Teaching of civil engineering courses in engineering colleges/universities on part/full time basis. As per RA8981, all subjects for licensure examinations shall be taught by persons who are holders of valid certificates of registration/professional licenses and professional identification cards, or special temporary permits, or a valid certificate of competency for the profession issued by the Commission, and who comply with the other requirements of the CHED. b) Lecturing in civil engineering courses designed by the Philippine Institute of Civil Engineers for practicing engineers who want to obtain CPD credits. c. Conducting tutorials/refresher courses on civil engineering concepts and related subjects c) Serving as a Resource Speaker in Technical Session. d) Writing technical articles and pamphlets G. SERVICES AS EMPLOYEE This is a condition when a Civil Engineer engages to perform work or fulfil duties regularly for wages or salary being paid by an employer. • A Civil Engineer may be employed for any position or function in any commercial or institutional organization. Where he is performing civil engineering functions, he is required to follow the code of ethics for Civil Engineers and comply with the standards and guidelines of PICE manual. A licensed Civil Engineer may not allow his license to be used by the company that employs him without proper agreement for his professional services. Where the firm he is working for uses his license to sign and seal the plans, specifications and contract document, the Civil Engineer must charge the professional fee for said services. • A Civil Engineer in part time employment with a firm is considered to be an employee and the same time a consultant of the firm. The standards for an employee and an individual consultant as defined in the PICE manual apply to this Civil Engineer. • Any Civil Engineer employed as an individual consultant of any firm, whether the firm is performing engineering, commercial, administrative, management or financial services is required to comply with the requirements and the standards herein established for a consulting Civil Engineering firm or consulting Civil Engineer. • All Government Civil Engineers employed by the instrumentalities of the Government e.g. national and local, shall be governed by the pertinent existing laws and regularities and particularly to those prescribed by the Civil Service Commission. In case of any conflict with any of the provisions of the Manual of Practice, such pertinent laws and regulations shall take precedence and shall govern. LET US EVALUATE: In about three to five sentences, express your answers in clear and grammatically correct sentences, and logical statements. 1. Why do we need to know the obligations and liabilities of both the Civil Engineer and the Client? 2. What are the typical services offered by Civil Engineers or civil engineering firms? 3. What are the requirements for foreign civil engineers to practice their profession in the Philippines? 4. Give one classification of Engineering Services, elaborate. 5. Give the Two Prime Professional Practice of our profession. Explain. LET US EVALUATE: In about three to five sentences, express your answers in clear and grammatically correct sentences, and logical statements. 1. Give one classification of Engineering Services, elaborate. 2. What are the different professional responsibilities of a Civil Engineer? 3. How should a dispute between the Civil Engineer and the Client be settled? 4. What are the typical services offered by a Professional Civil Engineer? 5. Explain the following statement: “Quality Project by definition is one satisfactorily meeting both the expectation of the client or employer and the requirements of the project.” THE SELECTION OF THE CIVIL ENGINEER The selection and engagement of a Civil Engineer is one of the most important decisions to be made during the development of an engineering project. No two Civil Engineers have the same training, experience, capabilities, personnel, workloads, and particular abilities. Selection of the most qualified Civil Engineer for a specific project will result in a well-planned and designed, economical, and successful project BASIS FOR SELECTION The client should establish administrative policy and criteria for the selection of qualified Civil Engineer for particular projects. The client’s first step is to define the proposed scope of the project. In some cases, this may be a general statement of the performance requirements of the project. At other times, the tasks to be performed maybe individually identified and defined. By clearly defining the services which the Civil Engineer is to furnish, the client can accurately judge whether or not the; Civil Engineer is best equipped to provide them. Some of the factors that should be considered in the selection process are: 1. The professional and ethical reputation of the Civil Engineer and his staff as determined by inquiries to previous clients and other references. 2. Responsible Civil Engineers and its employee and must be registered professional Civil Engineers. 3. Civil Engineers should have demonstrated qualifications and expertise in performing the services required for the project. 4. Civil Engineer should be able to assign qualified engineering staff who will be responsible charge of the project and will be able to provide and complete the required services within the time allotted. 5. The Civil Engineer should have the necessary financial and business resources to accomplish the assignment and provide continuing service. The selection procedures that will be described in the foregoing discussions apply to projects of the private sector. For government projects, E.O.164 and PD 1594 as amended apply to procurement of consulting services and selection of contractor for construction, respectively. CLIENT’S SELECTION COMMITTEE Within the client’s organization there should be an established administrative policy for designating the persons authorized to select or recommend selection of Civil Engineers for specific assignments. The persons appointed should be familiar with the project requirements and should be kept free of internal or external pressure during the selection process. One satisfactory procedure is to utilize a selection committee of three or more individuals, at least one of whom is a professional engineer of the appropriate discipline. For public projects, the client must choose individuals who demonstrate objectivity in order to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest in the selection of the Civil Engineer. At least one of the individuals should be thoroughly familiar with the civil engineering practices. The committee is responsible for making recommendations after conducting appropriate investigations, interviews, and inquiries. The final selection is then based upon the selection committee’s recommendations QUALIFICATIONS-BASED SELECTION (QBS) PROCEDURE The selection procedure is considerably enhanced when the client is fully familiar with the purpose and nature of the proposed project, can describe the project in detail, and can prepare a project scope and outline of services expected of the Civil Engineer. In some cases the client may not have professional staff available to define the project scope and describe the required services. The client should still be familiar enough with the project requirements to understand what is expected of the Civil Engineer. The selection procedure, however, can be modified to suit the circumstances. The client’s usual steps in the selection procedure are presented below. If the client has had satisfactory experience with one or more Civil Engineers, it may not be necessary to follow all of the steps outlined 1. By invitation or by public notice, state the general nature of the project, the services required, And request statements of qualifications and experience from Civil Engineers who appear to be capable of meeting the project requirements. The client may issue a “Request for qualifications” (RFQ) or "Request for proposals” (RFP). RFQs are normally used to ascertain the general qualifications in selected area of expertise while RFPs are used to seek Civil Engineers for creating “short lists” for selecting a Civil Engineer for a specific project. 2. Prepare a budget for the staff time and costs that can be expected from potential Civil Engineer prior to receipt of RFQs and RFPs. 3. Evaluate the statements of qualifications received. Select at least three Civil Engineers or firms that may appear to be best qualified for the specific project. It should be noted that often more than three Civil Engineers or firms may appear to be equally qualified – in which case more Civil Engineers or firms may be considered. However, in fairness to those not selected it is usually best to make a conscientious effort to keep the number selected for further consideration for realistic minimum in view of the cost and time required to prepare competent proposals. 4. Write a letter to each Civil Engineer or selected for further consideration describing the proposed project in detail, including a project scope and outline of services required, and asking for a proposal describing in detail the Civil Engineer’s plan for managing and performing the required services, the personnel to be assigned, the proposed schedule, experience with similar projects, office location in which services are to be performed, financial standing, present workload, and references. Each Civil Engineer or firm should have an opportunity to visit the site, review all pertinent data and obtain clarification of any items as required. For major or complex projects, a pre-proposal conference may be desirable to explain the details of the proposed scope of services and to answer questions. 5. On receipt of proposals, invite the Civil Engineers or firms to meet individually with the selection committee for interviews and discussions of the desired end results of the project and the engineering services required. These interviews may be held at the Civil Engineer’s office. The client may consider supplementing the selection committee with personnel who have specialized expertise to advise the committee, when appropriate. During each interview the selection committee should review the qualifications and experience of each Civil Engineer or firm, the capability to provide the services within the time allotted, and the key personnel to be assigned to the project 6. Check with recent clients of each Civil Engineer or firm to determine the quality of their performance. This check need not limited to references listed by the Civil Engineer. 7. List the Civil Engineer or firms in the order of preference, taking into account their approach and understanding of the project, reputation, experience, financial standing, size, personnel available, quality of references, workload, location, and other factors pertinent to the project being considered. 8. Invite the Civil Engineer considered to be best qualified to develop a detailed scope, list of deliverables and schedule, and to negotiate fair compensation for the services. 9. The compensation proposed by the Civil Engineer should be evaluated on the basis of the clients experience and budget estimate, taking account of the range of charges, giving consideration to the project’s special characteristics and the scope of services agreed upon. Fair and reasonable compensation to the Civil Engineer is vital to the success of the project since it will enable the consultant’s expertise to be fully utilized. 10. If satisfactory agreement is not reached with the first Civil Engineer, the negotiations should be terminated and the Civil Engineer or firm be notified in writing to that effect. Similar negotiations should then be held with the second Civil Engineers or firm and, if necessary, with the third Civil Engineers or firm. If no accord is reached, the client should seek outside assistance before continuing. CHARGING FOR CIVIL ENGINEERING SERVICES Charges for engineering services are usually computed using one six methods: 1. Salary cost times multiplier plus direct nonsalary expense (“Reimbursable”). 2. Hourly billing rates plus reimbursables. 3. Per Diem 4. Cost plus fixed fee (“CPFF”). 5. Fixed price 6. Percentage of construction cost (“Percentage”). SALARY COST TIMES MULTIPLIER PLUS DIRECT NONSALARY EXPENSE Compensation on the basis of the salary cost times an agreed multiplier is a frequently used method of determining charges for engineering services. With this method, charges for engineering services based mainly on direct salaries. It is therefore advisable that the Civil Engineer reach an agreement with the client on salary ranges for each classification of service applicable, as well as on the time period over which they can be guaranteed. This may helpavoid future surprises, misunderstandings, and disputes. Regardless of the method utilized as a basis of compensation, a provision in the agreement should state that payments will be made to the Civil Engineer during progress of the services, based on monthly invoices and within a reasonable time after billing. Direct non salary expenses are a separate item for reimbursement usually with a service charge. The following factors are pertinent to the salary cost time multiplier version of this method (they may also apply for other methods of charging for civil engineering services) 1. Salary cost is defined as “direct salaries plus employee benefits” and includes salaries for partners or principals and for technical, professional, administrative and clerical staff directly”. Chargeable to the project: sick leave, vacation, holiday and incentive pay; unemployment and other payroll taxes; and he contributions for social security, worker’ compensation insurances retirement, medical, and other group benefits. 2. Multiplier which is applied to salary cost is a factor that compensates the Civil Engineer for overhead (as defined hereinafter) plus a reasonable margin for contingencies, interest or invested capital readiness to serve, and profit. The size of the multiplier will vary with the type of service, the nature and experience of the civil engineering firm, and the geographic area in which its office is located. Direct non-salary expenses usually incurred in engineering engagements may include the following: a. Living and traveling expenses of principals and employees when away from the home office on business connected with the project. b. Identifiable communications expenses, such as long-distance telephone, facsimile, telegraph shipping charges, and special postage charges (for other than general correspondence). c. Expenses for services and equipment directly applicable to the project, such as for specialized technical equipment, special legal and accounting services, special computer rental and programming services, computer run time and file storage, CADD charges, sub consultants and subcontractors commercial printing and binding, and similar services that are not applicable for inclusion in general overhead. d. Identifiable drafting supplies, stenographic supplies, and reproduction work (blueprint, photocopying, and printing) charged to the client’s project) as distinguished from such supplies and expenses applicable to several projects. e. Expenses for unusual insurance and specialized health and safety programs and for special clothing for projects with extraordinary risks such as toxic and hazardous waste conditions. Such projects may require special insurance, which is also normally billed as a direct cost to the project. Such expenses are normally reimbursed by the client at actual invoice cost plus an administration charge to compensate for associated accounting, purchasing, contract administration, risk of liability, etc. 4. The Civil Engineers overhead which comprises a major portion of the compensation generated by the multiplier on salary cost, includes the following indirect costs: a. Provisions for office expenses-light, heat, telephone depreciation, rental furniture, rent, drafting equipment and engineering instruments, transportation expenses, and office and drafting supplies not identifiable to a specific project. b. Taxes and insurance other than those included as salary cost. c. Library and periodical expenses and other costs of keeping abreast of advances in engineering, such as attendance at technical and professional meetings and continuing education courses. d. Executive, administrative, accounting, legal, stenographic, and clerical salaries and expenses (other than identifiable salaries included in salary costs and expenses) plus salaries or imputed salaries of partners and principals to the extent that they perform general executive and administrative services as distinguished from technical or advisory services directly applicable to particular projects. These services and expenses, essential to conduct of the business, include preliminary arrangements for new projects or assignments and interest on borrowed capital. e. Business development expenses, including salaries of principals and employees so engaged. f. Provision for loss of productive time of technical employees between assignments, and for time of principals and employees on public service assignments. g. Costs of acquiring and maintaining computers, development of software, and training staff when not billed as a direct cost 5. Accounting records. The Civil Engineer who performs services under a salary cost times multiplier agreement or other costbased agreement must provide the accounting necessary to segregate and record the appropriate expenditures. Adequately detailed hourly time records must be maintained for principals, engineers and other employees who devote; time to the project. Applicable payroll records, together with receipts or other documents to substantiate chargeable expenditures, must be available for inspection audit by the client if required by contract. HOURLY BILLING RATE The hourly billing rate method of the compensation is very similar to the salary cost times multiplier method in that the hourly billing rate includes all direct personnel expenses, overhead and profit. Direct non-salary expenses (as defined under the salary cost times multiplier section) are a separate item for reimbursement, usually with a service charge. PER DIEM The term per diem normally refers to an eight-hour day. Direct personal services of the type described in Section 2 which are frequently charged on a per diem basis. This basis is particularly suited to expert witness or other legaltype services and to other short-term engagements involving intermittent personal services. Where per diem services are furnished, the Civil Engineer should be compensated for all of the time devoted to providing them including travel and standby time. The per diem charge should be based on complexity, risk, and important of the services and on the Civil Engineer’s professional standing, expertise, and breadth of experience. The Civil Engineer is also reimbursed for travel and subsistence costs and for other out-of-pocket expenses incurred when away from the home office. COST PLUS FIXED FEE Under a cost-plus fixed fee agreement, the Civil Engineer is reimbursed for the actual costs of all services and supplies related project. including: • Salary costs, as previously defined • Overhead, as previously defined (The Civil Engineer should be prepared to support the basis for overhead charges.) • Direct non-salary expenses, as previously defined • Fixed fee, an amount to compensate the Civil Engineer for contingencies, interest on invested capital, readiness to serve, and profit. The fixed fee amount varies with the complexity and scope of the engineering services required. It is frequently calculated as a percentage of the salary costs, overhead, and direct non-salary expenses. FIXED PRICE The fixed price method of compensation is frequently used for investigations and studies and for basic services on design type projects where the scope and complexity of the assignment are clearly and fully defined. The fixed price amount can be calculated as the sum total of the estimated engineering costs for salaries, overhead and non-salary expenses, an allowance for contingencies, interest on invested capital, readiness to serve, and a reasonable amount for profit. A fixed price agreement should contain a clearly stated time period during which the services will be performed and a provision for adjustment of compensation if the project is delayed for reasons beyond the Civil Engineer’s control. For design services, there should be provision for changes required after approval of the preliminary design, with a clear understanding as to where the final approval authority lies. Partial payments should be made to the Civil Engineer at stated intervals usually once a month during the performance of the services. These payments are usually based on the Civil Engineer’s statement of percent completion to date. PERCENTAGE OF CONSTRUCTION COST The percentage of construction cost method is seldom used raw. Because of increasing complexity and large variation in tasks for projects, the percentage of construction cost fee curves no longer have a direct correlation to the required engineering fees for specific projects. Owners should either use experienced "in-house" staff or retain consultants to develop detailed program budgets for construction costs, right of way, legal, administrative, engineering services and permits. This Method may be used to determine the compensation of the engineer for services where the principal responsibility is the detailed design or construction supervision of facilities to be constructed. The percentage fee shall consider the type, complexity, location, and magnitude of construction cost of the project and shall not exceed the following percentages of estimated construction cost: a. Feasibility studies-three percent (3%); b. Detailed engineering design-six percent (6%); c. Detailed architectural and engineering design-eight percent (8%); and d. Construction supervision-ten percent (10%) SCHEDULE OF MINIMUM BASIC FEES Certain principles to be observed in the rates of compensation for Civil Engineers: 1. When doing work on foreign assisted projects or in projects where international consultants participate, the Civil Engineer performing similar or equivalent work, should accept compensation that approximates the international standard rates. 2. Civil Engineers regularly employed in the private sector shall have a minimum compensation corresponding to 10% more than the minimum wage prevailing in the region as basic monthly salary. Civil Engineers employed in the government sector shall have a minimum basic monthly salary corresponding to appropriate entry positions provided by the Civil Service Commission. 3. A Civil Engineer employed in the private sector who signs and seals the Civil Engineering plans, specifications, and other related documents of a certain project for and in behalf of his employers shall be compensated with a minimum of 10% of the professional fee for the project, over and above the basic monthly salary. TOTAL PROJECT COST Probable total cost is the approximation of the cost of a program, project, or operation. It is the main concern of the client throughout the planning design and construction phases of a project. Probable total cost often used to establish budgets for a typical project, is made up of: Professional Engineering Cost. Construction Cost Legal and Land costs Owner’s cost (project administration, staffing, financing, and other overhead) Contingency Allowance for unknowns PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING COST Civil engr. Engaged to study & render planning report on the contemplated project Study & report phase includes cost for field surveys, planning analysis, geotechnical exploration analysis in addition to direct engineering cost. Cost of coordination, evaluation implementation and compliance increased correspondingly study and report phase is important because its implementation determines the scope and development of the entire project. In final design and construction phase services like surveying and geotechnical engineering is needed. CONSTRUCTION COST The cost of all the construction portions of a project generally based upon the sum of the construction contract(s) and other direct construction costs; does not include the compensation paid to the architect and consultants, the cost of the land, right-of-way, or other costs which are defined in the contract documents as being the responsibility of the owner. Is the estimated total cost of constructing the facility to be covered by the proposed detailed design or construction supervision services, excluding the fess and other costs of such services, the cost of land and right of way, and legal administrative expenses of the agency. The estimated construction cost must be approved by the client before the invitation to submit technical proposal is issued LEGAL COST These cost includes the issuing of pledges, audits, cost of the land and the interests of the lent money throughout the construction. And can be best estimated in collaboration with the customers because they are frequently outside the understanding and control of the Civil Engineer. LAND COST Land Cost varies considerably from the land cost. Hence land cost should be add at actual, considering the expenses under the following heads 1. Legal Charges 2. Brokerage 3. Tenant Shifting (If applicable) OWNER’S COST (INCLUDES ADMINISTRATION, STAFFING, FINANCIAL COST) These costs, which includes Staffing Project administration Financing and; Other overhead CONTINGENCY ALLOWANCE A contingency may be included in an estimate to provide for unknown costs which are indicated as likely to occur by experience, but are not identifiable. When using an estimate which has no contingency to set a budget or to set aside funding, a contingency is often added to improve the probability that the budget or funding will be adequate to complete the project. Being unable to complete a project risks public ridicule. I. General Overview of RA 9184 and its IRR Historical Background GPPB and its Functions Key Features of RA 9184 and its IRR Scope and Coverage II. Definition of Terms III. Principles of Public Procurement IV. Procurement Methods and Procedures V. Procurement Organizations Government Procurement Policy Board – Technical Support Office 3 AMERICAN LAWS ON PROCUREMENT CONTRACTS American Practice of Public Bidding was introduced in the Philippines on 1900 INVITATION TO BID NO CONTRACT SHALL BE ENTERED INTO WITHOUT PUBLIC BIDDING LOWEST RESPONSIVE BIDDER PHILIPPINE PUBLIC PROCUREMENT 4 PE BEFORE THE ENACTMENT OF GPRA 5 Executive Orders Implementing Rules and Regulations Government Procurement Reform Act Administrative Issuances 10 January 2003 Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) Part A 8 October 2003 Revised IRR of 2009 Memorandum Circulars 2 September 2009 Revised IRR of 2016 28 October 2016 6 PROBLEMS REFORMS Confusion caused by fragmented legal system Enactment of the Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA) Inconsistent policies, rules, and regulations due to lack of standards Creation of the Government Procurement Policy Board (GPPB) Lack of transparency Use of PhilGEPS (Philippine Government Electronic Procurement System) Lack of check and balance Participation of civil society 7 Covers procurement of all government agencies General Rule is Public/Competitive Bidding Alternative Methods of Procurement allowed in highly exceptional cases Use of the Approved Budget for the Contract (ABC) as ceiling for the bid price Use of transparent, objective, and non-discretionary criteria Increased transparency in the procurement process Professionalization of procurement officials Inclusion of Penal and Civil Liabilities Composed of the following: Chairman: Secretary of Department of Budget and Management Alternate Chairman: Director-General of the National Economic and Development Authority 12 Regular Members Invited Resource Persons (audit, anticorruption agencies) DPWH DOH NEDA DOF DND DTI DBM DEPED DOST DILG PRIVATE SECTOR REP DOE DOTr DICT 9 11 Regular Members – Secretaries of the following: DPWH - Department of Public Works and Highways DTI - Department of Trade and Industry DOH - Department of Health DND - Department of Defense DEPED - Department of Education DOF - Department of Finance DILG - Department of Interior and Local Government DOST - Department of Science and Technology DOTr - Department of Transportation DOE - Department of Energy DICT - Department of Information and Communication Technology DPWH DOH DEPED Private Sector Representative DBM NEDA DOF DND DTI 12th Regular Member DOST DILG PRIVATE SECTOR REP DOE DOTr DICT 10 Policy-Making > Amend implementing rules & regulations of procurement law (quasi-legislative function) > Prepare generic procurement manual and standard bidding forms Capacity Development > Establish a sustainable training program Monitoring > Ensure the proper implementation by PEs of the Act, this IRR and all other relevant rules and regulations on public procurement > Review effectiveness of procurement law > Protect national interest in all matters affecting public procurement, having due regard to the country’s regional and international obligations. 11 13 Sec. 8.5.2 All bidders shall upload and maintain in PhilGEPS a current and updated file of the following Class “A” eligibility documents under Sections 23.1(a) and 24.1(a): a) Registration Certificate; b) Mayor’s/Business Permit or its Equivalent Document; c) Tax Clearance; d) Philippine Contractors Accreditation Board (PCAB) license and registration; and e) Audited Financial Statements. For foreign bidders participating in the procurement by a Philippine Foreign Service Office or Post, they shall submit their eligibility documents under Sec. 23.1 of the 2016 IRR of RA 9184. R.A. 9184 applies to all branches and/or instrumentalities of the government: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. National Government Agencies (NGAs) State Universities and Colleges (SUCs) Government Owned or Controlled Corporations (GOCCs) Government Financial Institutions (GFIs) Local Government Units (LGUs) It shall apply to all procurement activities involving: 1. Goods and Services 2. Infrastructure Projects 3. Consulting Services Section 4, Revised IRR All fully domestically-funded procurement activities All foreign-funded procurement activities, unless otherwise provided in a treaty or int’l/executive agreement Mandates adherence to RA 9184 or selection through competitive bidding. Otherwise, negotiating panel shall ensure that the reasons for the adoption of a different rule or method of procurement are clearly reflected in the records of discussion. (Sec. 4.3, 2016 IRR of RA 9184) Section 4, Revised IRR As may be agreed upon by the GOP and IFI in their treaty or int’l/executive agreement • Projects funded from foreign grants • Projects for International Competitive Bidding • Consulting Services for National Competitive Bidding EXCEPT: 1. Procurement for goods, infrastructure projects, and consulting services funded from Foreign Grants covered by R.A. 8182, as amended by R.A. 8555, entitled “An Act Excluding Official Development Assistance (ODA) from the Foreign Debt Limit in order to Facilitate the Absorption and Optimize the Utilization of ODA Resources, Amending for the Purpose Paragraph 1, Section 2 of Republic Act No. 4860, as amended”, unless the GOP and the foreign grantor/foreign or international financing institution agree otherwise; 2. Acquisition of real property which shall be governed by R.A. 8974, as amended by RA 10752 entitled “An Act to Facilitate the Acquisition of Right-of-Way Site or Location for National Government Infrastructure Projects and for Other Purposes,” and other applicable laws; 3. Public-Private sector infrastructure or development projects and other procurement covered by R.A. 6957, as amended by R.A. 7718 (BOT Law), entitled “An Act Authorizing the Financing, Construction, Operation and Maintenance of Infrastructure Projects by the Private Sector, and for Other Purposes,” as amended; 4. Disposal of government properties; Commission on Audit Circular No. 86-264 DBM National Budget Circular No. 425 Enumerated activities that are not considered as procurement undertakings under RA 9184 and its IRR: 1. Direct financial or material assistance to beneficiaries Section 4.5(a) of the 2016 Revised IRR of RA 9184 contemplates financial or material assistance given directly to individual recipients or beneficiaries to address their immediate medical, funeral, transportation and other allied needs and concerns, which do not involve actual procurement of goods and services by government agencies. Enumerated activities that are not considered as procurement undertakings under RA 9184 and its IRR: 1. Direct financial or material assistance to beneficiaries If the direct financial or material assistance takes the form of goods, supplies or items that are to be procured (e.g., relief goods), the same do not fall within the coverage of the cited provision, but is subject to procurement rules and regulations embodied in RA 9184 and its IRR. (GPPB Circular 01-2017) Enumerated activities that are not considered as procurement undertakings under RA 9184 and its IRR: 2. Participation to scholarships, trainings, continuing education, etc 3. Lease of government property for private use 4. Job order workers 5. Joint Venture Agreements between Private Entities and GOCCs or LGUs 6. Disposal of property and assets Government Procurement Policy Board – Technical Support26Office Procurement Procurement refers to the acquisition of goods, consulting services, and the contracting for infrastructure projects by procuring entity. (Sec. 5(aa), IRR, R.A. 9184) Refer to: All items, supplies and materials Including general support services Needed in the transaction of public businesses or in the pursuit of any government undertaking, project or activity Whether in the nature of equipment, furniture, stationery, materials or construction, personal property, including non-personal or contractual services, such as: repair and maintenance of equipment and furniture trucking, hauling, janitorial and security and other related and analogous servicesJustified by conditions specified in R.A. 9184 and its IRR Except: Infrastructure projects and consulting services Refer to: construction, improvement, demolition, rehabilitation, restoration or maintenance of civil works components of : IT projects Irrigation flood control and drainage water supply sanitation, sewerage and solid waste management national buildings, hospital buildings, constructions projects of the Government and other repair, related Refer to services for Infrastructure Projects and other types of projects or activities of the Government requiring adequate external technical and professional expertise that are beyond the capability and/or capacity of the Government to undertake such as, but not limited to: advisory and review services; pre-investment or feasibility studies; design; construction supervision; management and related services; and other technical services or special studies. In case of projects involving mixed procurements, the nature of the procurement, shall be determined based on the primary purpose of the contract. Determination shall be made by the procuring entity. In mixed procurements, the PE shall specify in the Bidding Documents all requirement applicable to each component of the project. In the preparation of Bidding Documents, the PE shall ensure compliance with existing laws, rules and regulations, especially those concerning licenses and permits required for the project (Sec. 17.2, 2016 IRR of RA 9184) PE is in the best position to determine the correct classification of its procurement based on its identified needs and the best way by which these needs may be addressed, managed, and satisfied. It is the motivation or intention of the PE in pursuing the project that will determine the primary purpose of a project. NPM 11-2013 ublic Monitoring Awareness and vigilance ccountability Responsibility over actions/decisions (“Answerable”) ompetitiveness Equal opportunity to all eligible bidders ransparency Wider dissemination of bid opportunities treamlined Process Uniformly applicable to all government agencies Effective and efficient method All Procurement shall be done through competitive bidding except as provided in R.A. 9184. Resort to alternative methods shall be made: Only in highly exceptional cases To promote economy and efficiency Justified by conditions specified in R.A. 9184 and its IRR PreProcurement Conference Bid Submission Bid Evaluation Advertisement and/or Posting Pre-Bid Conference Opening of Technical Proposal (incl. eligibility docs) Opening of Financial Proposal Post-qualification Contract Award 44 PreProcurement Conference Pre-Bid Conference Bid Evaluation (QBE or QCBE) Advertisement and/or Posting Bid Submission Post-qualification Eligibility and Shortlisting Opening of Bids (QBE or QCBE) Contract Award Negotiation 45 Head of the Procuring Entity (HOPE) Bids and Awards Committee (BAC) BAC Secretariat Te c h n i c a l Wo r k i n g G r o u p ( T W G ) Observers Refers to: Head of the agency or body, or his duly authorized official, for NGAs and the constitutional commissions or offices, and other branches of government; Governing Board or its duly authorized official, for GOCCs, GFIs and SUCs; or Local Chief Executive, for LGUs Note: In an agency, department, or office where the procurement is decentralized, the head of each decentralized unit shall be considered as the HoPE, subject to the limitations and authority delegated by the head of the agency, department, or office FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES: 1. Establishes BAC and appoints its members Ensures that BAC members give their utmost priority to duties Ensures professionalization of members of the procurement organization Within six (6) months upon designation, the BAC, its Secretariat and TWG members should have satisfactorily completed such training or program conducted, authorized or accredited by the GPPB through its TSO. (Sec. 16, 2016 IRR of RA 9184) 2. Approves the Annual Procurement Plan (APP) 3. Approves/Disapproves the Contract Award 4. Resolves Protests As a general rule, HOPE must create a single BAC. However, separate BACs may be created under any of the following conditions: 1. The items to be procured are complex or specialized; 2. If the single BAC cannot reasonably manage the procurement transactions as shown by delays beyond the allowable limits; or 3. If the creation is required according to the nature of the procurement. PE’s creation of sub-BACs to be placed under a main BAC is not in compliance with the requirements under Sec 11 of the IRR of RA 9184. PE may, however, establish separate BACs with the composition of the BAC members subject to the qualifications under Section 11.2.2 of the IRR of RA 9184. Each BAC shall not be considered as decentralized committees pursuant to Section 11.1.2 of the IRR since it will be headed by a single HOPE. NPM 74-2013 FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES: Recommends Procurement Method Creates a Technical Working Group (TWG) Conducts the bidding activities Resolves Requests for Reconsideration Recommends Imposition of Sanctions Invites Observers during all stages of the procurement process Conducts due diligence review or verifications of the qualifications of observers Prepares Procurement Monitoring Report FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES: Advertise and/or post the IB/REI Conduct pre-procurement and pre-bid conferences; Determine the eligibility of prospective bidders; Receive and open bids; Conduct the evaluation of bids; Undertake post-qualification proceedings; Recommend award of contracts to the HoPE or his duly authorized representative; Recommend to the HoPE the use of Alternative Methods of Procurement FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES: Conduct any of the Alternative Methods of Procurement; Conduct periodic assessment of the procurement processes and procedures Perform such other related functions as may be necessary (Sec. 12.1, 2016 IRR of RA 9184) M E M B E R S H I P A N D Q U A L I F I C AT I O N S : BAC members should occupy plantilla positions with the procuring entity concerned. All members are regular members except the end-user member who is considered as a provisional member. The members, whether regular or provisional, are equally entitled to participate and to vote during deliberations. COMPOSITION: 5 but not more than 7 MEMBERS designated by the HOPE 1. Regular Members: Chairperson (3rd Ranking Permanent Official); Member representing the Legal or Administrative areas (5th Ranking Permanent Personnel); or if not available, an officer of the next lower rank; Member representing the Finance Area (5th Ranking Permanent Personnel); or if not available, an officer of the next lower rank; COMPOSITION: 5 but not more than 7 MEMBERS designated by the HOPE 2. Provisional Members Officer possessing procurement. Technical expertise relevant to the End user unit Representative. In case of procurement outsourcing, a representative from the Procuring Entity may be designated as a provisional member HOPE 2nd 3rd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 3rd Same qualifications as their principals. Same term as the principal. Presence of alternate BAC members in BAC meetings are considered for purposes of quorum. The relationship of the principal and the alternate is of co-equal nature, rather than hierarchical. Accountability shall be limited to their respective acts and decisions. Shall be entitled to the proportionate honoraria for attendance in meetings. TERMS OF MEMBERSHIP: The BAC members shall be designated for a term of one (1) year only, reckoned from the date of designation. However, the HOPE may renew or terminate such designation at his discretion. Upon expiration of the terms of the current members, they shall continue to exercise their functions until new BAC members are designated. TERMS OF MEMBERSHIP: In case of resignation, retirement, separation, transfer, re-assignment, or removal of a BAC member, the HOPE shall designate a replacement that has similar qualifications as the official replaced. The replacement shall serve for the unexpired term. In case of leave or suspension, the replacement shall serve only for the duration of the leave or suspension. 1. Head of the Procuring Entity 2. Official who approves procurement contracts; 3. Chief Accountant or Head of the Provincial/City/Municipal Accounting Office and his/her staff, unless the Accounting Department is the end-user unit, in which case the Chief Accountant, Head of the Accounting Department or his/her staff may be designated as an end-user member. (COA Circular Letter No. 2004 – 3) HOPE may create a new office or designate an existing organic office to act as BAC Secretariat In case of ad hoc BAC Secretariat, the HOPE shall assign fulltime support staff in its BAC Secretariat (Sec. 14.2) There is no minimum or maximum number of members of the BAC Secretariat. Head of the BAC Secretariat must be at least a 5th or 3rd ranking permanent employee or, if not available, a permanent official of the next lower rank FUNCTIONS: Provide administrative support to the BAC and TWG Organize BAC and TWG meetings and conferences Take custody of procurement documents and other records Manage the sale and distribution of bidding documents Advertise/post bidding opportunities, Documents, and notices of awards Assist in managing the procurement process Monitor procurement activities and milestones Consolidate PPMPs Act as central channel of communications Prepare minutes of meetings and resolutions of the BAC including Bidding Created by the BAC from a pool of legal, technical and financial experts - those experts outside the procuring entity concerned may be included, i.e. government personnel and officials and consultants from the private sector and academe with proven expertise on the sourcing of goods, works or consulting services. (GPPB Resolution No. 07-2012, GPPB Circular No. 02-2012) BAC may create separate TWGs to handle different procurements FUNCTIONS: Assist BAC in the following activities: Eligibility screening Bid evaluation Post-qualification Review of the Technical Specifications, Scope of Work, and Terms of Reference Review of Bidding Documents Shortlisting of consultants Resolution of Request for Reconsideration (Sec. 12.1, 2016 IRR of RA 9184) Observers represent the public, the taxpayers who are interested in seeing to it that procurement laws are observed and irregularities are averted. At least three (3) Observers shall be invited coming from: COA Duly recognized private group in the sector or discipline of the particular type of procurement involved Non-Government Organization (NGO) In all stages of procurement process, During the 1) eligibility checking, 2) shortlisting, 3) pre-bid conference, 4) preliminary examination of bids, 5) bid evaluation, and 6) post-qualification, the BAC must invite, in writing, at least three (3) Observers, at least 3 cd 5cd before the date of the procurement stage/activity Observers shall be allowed access or be provided with the following documents free of charge upon their request, subject to signing of a confidentiality agreement: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Minutes of BAC meetings; Abstract of Bids; Post-qualification summary report; APP and related PPMP; and Opened proposals In all instances, observers shall be required to enter into a confidentiality agreement with the concerned Procuring Entity in accordance with the form prescribed by the GPPB. RESPONSIBILITIES: 1. Prepare report (jointly or separately) indicating their observations on the procurement activities 2. Submit report to the PE and furnish a copy to the GPPB and the Office of the Ombudsman/Resident Ombudsman. 3. Immediately inhibit and notify in writing the PE of any actual or potential conflict of interest If no report is submitted by the observer within seven (7) calendar days after each procurement activity, then it is presumed that the bidding activity conducted by the BAC followed the correct procedure PE is authorized to grant honoraria to the members of the BAC, the TWG, and the BAC Secretariat provided the amount so granted does not exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of their respective basic monthly salary, subject to the following conditions: funds are available for the purpose; and the grant of honoraria conforms to the guidelines promulgated by the DBM. (Section 15, IRR of R.A. 9184) DBM Budget Circular No. 2004-5A, dated 7 October 2005, as amended by DBM Budget Circular No. 2007-3, dated 29 November 2007. Only for successfully completed procurement projects Limited to procurement that involves competitive bidding – Competitive Bidding, LSB and Nego Proc-Two Failed Bidding. Granted to Chair or Members of the BAC or the TWG by the PE concerned. BAC Secretariat performing attendant functions in addition to their regular duties and functions may be paid honoraria at the same rate as the TWG Chair and Members Those who are receiving honoraria shall no longer be entitled to overtime pay for procurement-related services rendered. Payment of overtime services may be allowed for the administrative staff, (clerks, messengers and drivers supporting the BAC, the TWG and the Secretariat), for procurement activities rendered in excess of official working hours. Collections from successfully completed procurement projects, limited to activities prior to the awarding of contracts to winning bidders: proceeds from sale of bid documents; fees from contractor/supplier registry; fees charged for copies of minutes of bid openings, BAC resolutions and other BAC documents; protest fees; and proceeds from bid security forfeiture Maximum Honorarium rate per procurement project BAC Chair Php 3,000.00 BAC Members Php 2,500.00 BAC Secretariat (Ad hoc) TWG Chair and Members Php 2,000.00 Members of the BAC Secretariat whose positions are in the Procurement Unit of the agency shall not be entitled to honoraria although the payment of overtime services may be allowed, subject to existing policy on the matter. House Bill No. 182 entitled Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act of 2016 provide for mechanisms to enable government agencies to procure energy savings performance contracts. Through Resolution No. 20-2016, dated 23 September 2016, GPPB espoused that in the procurement of goods, government agencies shall be able to incorporate the minimum energy performance standards for equipment, products and devices in crafting technical specifications. Why Go Green? The PDP 2017-2022 aims to strengthen the nation’s aspirations of inclusive and sustainable development through national efforts; GPP is one of the mechanisms. Support of local businesses GPP’s contribution to the Philippine Development Plans & other policies Increase competitiveness Help to achieve environmental objectives at national and international levels GPPB Resolution 25-2017, dated 30 May 2017 approves the Philippine Green Public Procurement Roadmap, providing for strategies and mechanisms for the gradual advancements of GPP in the country. The intervention logic of the Philippine Green Public Procurement Roadmap GOAL POSITIVE IMPACT STRATEGIES FOR THE WAY FORWARD STATE OF PLAY RATIONALE GPP is established throughout the government (national to local) …on Environment + Society + Economy Policy commitment - GPP for CSEs and non-CSEs communication and awareness - monitoring Building on existing policies and laws, inspired by international best practices and addressing stakeholders issues and concerns The government shall lead by example in creating a green market SESSION 2 – OVERVIEW 1 THEFORWARD PHILIPPINE OF THE GREEN GPP EDUCATION PUBLIC PROCUREMENT MODULE ROADMAP 2017 - 2022 THE WAY 5 Strategies 1 Policy commitment 2 GPP for CSEs 3 GPP for Non-CSEs 4 Communication & Awareness 5 Monitoring Commitment GPP shall be the desirable norm of public procurement A resolution shall adopt: • The first set of CSEs and the mechanisms of the roadmap • The first set of non-CSEs and the mechanisms of the roadmap in this respect • To establish and implement complementary measures (capacity development, communication, monitoring) GPP: Common-use Supplies and Equipment (CSEs) ASSESSMENT MATRIX Market readiness Environmental impact Cost implications Practicability Support to government Environmental objectives Support to the local economy FIRST SET OF PRIORITIZED CSEs GPP: Non-Common-use Supplies and Equipment (Non-CSEs) FIRST SET OF PRIORITIZED PRODUCTS (non-CSEs) ASSESSMENT MATRIX Market readiness Environmental impact Cost implications Practicability Support to government Environmental objectives Support to the local economy Sample Green Core Criteria and Technical Specifications CSE PRODUCT: TOILET PAPER SCOPE: Toilet paper in rolled form, interfolded or coreless for toilet facilities of government offices and public amenities KEY ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT • Forest destruction and potential loss of biodiversity related to the pulp production; • Energy and water consumption during production of toilet paper; • Harmful emissions to air and water during pulp and paper production. • Chemical consumption during production; • Waste generation and packaging. GPP APPROACH • .Purchase products with a low energy and resource use during processing; • Purchase products which avoid harmful substances in paper production and bleaching; • Purchase products with high recycled content; • Purchase products from legally and sustainably harvested wood. Sample Green Core Criteria and Technical Specifications CSE PRODUCT: TOILET PAPER PRODUCT SPECIFICATIONS: • Product must be made out of raw materials from 100% recycled fiber. • At least Elementary Chlorine Free (ECF). • The core as well as any paper wrapping and carton box packing must be made from 100% recycled fiber and the cartons must be strong enough for storage transit. FUTURE CRITERIA: • Recycled fiber must contain not less than 60% post-consumer fiber. • Totally Chlorine Free (TCF) Sample Green Core Criteria and Technical Specifications CSE PRODUCT: TOILET PAPER JUSTIFICATION: • Paper production from recycled paper is far less environmentally damaging. It avoids destruction of natural forests, reduces water consumption, energy consumption (40%-64%) as well as emissions of chemical substances to the air (74%) and to the water (35%). EVIDENCE: • Supplier must provide evidence that specifications are met. Especially concerning the origin of raw materials certification schemes or evidence or recycled materials must be provided • Any appropriate means of proof demonstrating that the criteria are met will be accepted (technical dossier from manufacturer, test report from recognized body) Sample Green Core Criteria and Technical Specifications CSE PRODUCT: TOILET PAPER VERIFICATION: • High quality recycled paper may look identical to conventional paper, which neither has an official label nor a product mark indicating the recycled content. • Independent testing can be carried out by the Forest Product Research and Development Institute (DOST) CONTACT US AT: Unit 2506 Raffles Corporate Center F. Ortigas Road, Ortigas Center Pasig City, Philippines 1605 TeleFax: (632)900-6741 to 44 Email address: gppb@gppb.gov.ph CIAP DOCUMENT 102 Uniform General Conditions of Contract for Private Construction Download your copy of the CIAP Document 102 from our website! Interested to know more about CIAP Document 102? Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Scan the QR Code to be directed to the link of the document: You may reach us through the following: Primer on CIAP Document 102 PHILIPPINE DOMESTIC CONSTRUCTION BOARD CIAP Document 102 (Uniform General Conditions of Contract for Private Construction) 2004 Ed. ciap.dti.gov.ph pdcb@dti.gov.ph www.facebook.com/DTI.CIAP.PDCB/ 8896-1801 /8897-0791 Photo Source: Philippine Construction Industry Roadmap 2020 - 2030 WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT CIAP DOCUMENT 102? Here are some of the Frequently Asked Questions to guide you: What is CIAP Document 102? It contains the general conditions ordinarily established in construction contracts, reflecting the usages, customs, and best practices in the construction industry. It forms part of the Contract Documents which include the: Agreement Bid Documents Specifications Drawings Special Conditions of Contract Other Contract Documents. Does CIAP Document 102 apply to all construction contracts? No. As its title suggests, it is applicable only to private contracts involving the construction of any type of structure or works as reflected in R.A. No. 4566 (Contractor's License Law). It is strictly for domestic use. Photo Source: Philippine Construction Industry Roadmap 2020 - 2030 What are the objectives of CIAP Document 102? Do the Courts recognize CIAP Document 102? It is intended to have suppletory effect on private construction contracts. Yes. Its usage follows from the premise that customs or accepted usages of trade as a source of law. Its provisions serve as the procedures, guidelines, and criteria to be used in the implementation of the Contract, most especially in the interpretation of the ambiguities and omissions of stipulations in the Contract. It provides equitable and realistic contract conditions which aims to promote fair contractual relationships in the construction industry. The Courts apply the provisions of CIAP Document 102 on the basis of Article 1376 of the Civil Code, which says: “The usage of customs of the place shall be borne in mind in the interpretation of the ambiguities of a contract, and shall fill the omission of stipulations which are ordinarily established.” PRIMER on CIAP DOCUMENT 102 UNIFORM GENERAL CONDITIONS OF CONTRACT FOR PRIVATE CONSTRUCTION Philippine Domestic Construction Board Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines Department of Trade and Industry FOREWORD The Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines (CIAP) is an attached agency of the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) which was created under Presidential Decree No. 1746, as amended by Executive Order Nos. 679 and 768, to promote, accelerate, and regulate the growth and development of the construction industry. Under the said law, the CIAP is mandated, among others, to recommend and encourage the adoption of equitable and realistic contract conditions for construction. In line with such mandate, the CIAP established the Uniform General Conditions of Contract for Private Construction or the “CIAP Document 102”. It was formulated by a Committee composed of representatives from various professional organizations namely: Council of Engineering Consultants of the Philippines (CECOPHIL); Construction Project Management Association of the Philippines (CPMAP); Chamber of Real Estate and Builders Association (CREBA) International Federation of Building and Wood Workers (IFBWW); Philippine Constructors Association, Inc. (PCA); Philippine Chamber of Commerce, Inc. (PCCI); Philippine Institute of Construction Arbitrators (now Philippine Institute of Construction Arbitrators and Mediators or PICAM); Philippine Institute of Civil Engineers (PICE); Subdivision and Housing Developers Association of the Philippines (SHDA); United Architects of the Philippines (UAP); Society of Philippine Accredited Consultants (SPAC); and the Confederation of Filipino Consulting Organizations, Inc. (COFILCO). The Philippine Domestic Construction Board (PDCB) and the Philippine Overseas Construction Board (POCB), two of the implementing arms of the CIAP, have, likewise, submitted their inputs in the formulation of CIAP Document 102 to support their recommendation for CIAP to bolster the acceptance and use of the said document in private construction. The first edition of CIAP Document 102 was published on 15 October 1997. The revised version was issued on 29 June 2004 to incorporate prevailing best practices and the changes that evolved in the construction industry over the years. In 2017, DTI Undersecretary Atty. Ruth B. Castelo, in accord with PDCB’s recommendation for CIAP to boost its efforts in promoting the use of CIAP Document 102 and enhance its marketability especially to small contractors, approved the formulation and publication of a Primer to increase the public’s awareness about the existence and importance of CIAP Document 102 in promoting fair contractual relationships in the construction industry. Through this Primer, the PDCB hopes to inform the public and all sectors concerned of the existence of CIAP Document 102 whose provisions reflect usages and customs in the Philippine construction industry, as reference and guide in the interpretation of contract provisions and fill the omission of stipulations which are ordinarily established. i What is CIAP Document 102? CIAP Document 102 or the “Uniform General Conditions of Contract for Private Construction” contains terms and conditions ordinarily established in construction contracts. It is intended for use in contracts for private construction in the Philippines. What is the intent of CIAP Document 102? CIAP Document 102 was formulated to provide the procedures, guidelines, and criteria to be used by parties in a construction Contract, or reference to the Contract to address deficiencies and/or any ambiguity. The CIAP Document 102 will contribute to the enhancement of fair contractual relationships in the construction industry. What is a Construction Contract? A typical Construction Contract consists of an Agreement, General Conditions, Drawings, Specifications, and other documents. Contract is used to describe the combination of two (2) sets of documents: the Agreement and the Contract Documents. Agreement is used to describe the agreement signed by the Owner and the Contractor, excluding the Contract Documents. Contract Documents are attached to the Agreement identified therein as Contract Documents, including all additions, deletions and modifications which generally include the following: Special Provisions or Conditions; General Conditions; Specifications; Drawings; and other Bid Documents. Special Provisions or Conditions are instructions which are issued prior to bidding to supplement and/or modify the Drawings, Specifications and/or General Conditions of the Contract. Specifications are the written or printed description of the work to be done describing qualities of the material to be used, the equipment to be installed and the mode of construction. Drawings are graphical presentations of the Work, including supplementary details and shop drawings. General Conditions of Contract pertain to the roles, rights and obligations of the contracting parties, and the rules and procedures by which the parties and everyone concerned will be able to meet their obligations and perform the Works covered under the Contract. 1 CIAP Document 102 contains these conditions which are generally applicable for all types of construction contracts, to wit: Section I. Definitions and Documents (Art. 1 Definitions; Art. 2 Execution, Correlation, Meaning of Terms and Intent of Documents; Art. 3 Drawings and Specifications; Art. 4 Detail Drawings and Instructions; Art. 5 Shop Drawings) Section II. Laws, Regulations, Site Conditions, Permits & Taxes (Art. 6 Laws and Site Conditions; Art. 7 Permits, Taxes and Surveys) Section III. Equipment and Materials (Art. 8 General; Art. 9 Equipment; Art. 10 Materials, Fixtures, Appliances, and Fittings Furnished by the Contractor; Art. 11 Materials, Equipment, Fixtures, Appliances and Fittings Furnished by the Owner; Art. 12 Royalties and Patents; Art. 13 Manufacturer’s Directions) Section IV. Premises and Temporary Structures (Art. 14 Use of Premises; Art. 15 Temporary Structures and Facilities) Section V. Protection of Work and Property (Art. 16 Protection of Work and Owner’s Property; Art. 17 Protection of Adjacent Property and Existing Utilities; Art. 18 Protection of Life, Work and Property During an Emergency) Section VI. Labor, Work and Payments (Art. 19 Labor; Art. 20 Work; Art. 21 Time of Completion of Work; Art. 22 Payments) Section VII. Contractor-Separate Contractor-Subcontractors Relationship (Art. 23 Separate Contracts with Other Contractors; Art. 24 Contractor-Separate Contractors Relations; Art. 25 Sub-Contracts) Section VIII. Suspension of Work and Termination of Contract (Art. 26 Contractor’s Rights to Suspend Work or Terminate Contract; Art. 27 Owner’s Right to Suspend the Work; Art. 28 Owner’s Right to Terminate Contract; Art. 29 Owner’s Right to proceed with the Work After Reduction in Contractor’s Scope of Work, Partial Takeover from Contractor) Section IX. Responsibilities and Liabilities of Contractor and of Owner (Art. 30 Contractor’s Responsibility for Accidents and Damages; Art. 31 Contractor’s Insurance and Bonds; Art. 32 Owner’s Responsibilities and Liabilities; Art. 33 Liens, Disputes and Arbitration) Section X. Owner’s Representative Section XI. Schedule of Time Limits 2 What is the importance of clear contract terms and harmonized contract documents? Many disputes in construction arise from inconsistent and ambiguous contract terms and conditions which lead to varied interpretations and conflict between the contracting parties. To avoid disputes that may affect the completion of the Work and strain the relationship of the parties, it is important that contract documents objectively reflect the agreement and true intent of the parties. Section I (Definitions and Documents) provides the definitions of the terms used and the execution, correlation, and intent of contract documents, as well as the rules to be followed in case of conflict or discrepancy. What are the obligations of the contracting parties when it comes to permits and licenses, and payment of taxes? Section II (Laws, Regulations, Site Conditions, Permits and Taxes) stipulates compliance with all Laws in so far as they are binding upon or affect the parties to the Contract. The Owner, with the Contractor’s assistance, shall secure and pay all construction permits and licenses necessary for the execution of the Work. The Contractor shall secure the Final Occupancy Permit but he shall not be responsible to the Owner if, without his fault, the license is not issued or there was delay in its issuance. The Contractor shall pay all taxes as required by Laws pertinent to the construction of the project. Who is in charge of the safety and sanitation in the work premises? Pursuant to Section IV & VI, the Contractor is in charge of the safety and sanitation at the work site during and upon completion of work. Who has the obligation to protect the Work and the Owner’s property from damage? Section V (Protection of Work and Property) provides that it is the obligation of the Contractor to protect the work and the Owner’s property from damage. Who is responsible for accidents in the work premises? Section IX, Article 30 (Contractor’s Responsibility for Accidents and Damages) states that the Contractor shall be primarily responsible for all safety measures in executing the Work. 3 What are the bonds and guarantees required of the Contractor? Section IX, Article 31 (Contractor’s Insurance and Bonds), enumerates the insurance, bonds, and guarantees required of the contractor, to wit: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Contractor’s Liability Insurance (Contractor, Subcontractors and Owner) Accident Insurance for Workers Contractor’s Fire Insurance Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds Contractor’s Guarantee Bond Contractor’s Guarantee-Warranty Is the Owner required to obtain insurance? Article 32.02 states that the Owner may opt to obtain an insurance that will protect him from his contingent liability. Is the Subcontractor also required to obtain bonds and insurance? Article 33.03 provides that the Subcontract must require the Subcontractor to obtain the same bonds and insurance coverage as are required of the Contractor. What is the difference in the contractual relationship between the Owner and “Separate Contractor” and between the Contractor and the “Subcontractor”? The Owner shall provide for the coordination of the work performed by the Separate Contractor with the Work of the Contractor. The Contractor is fully responsible to the Owner for the acts and omissions of his Subcontractors. Is there a contractual relationship between the Owner and the Subcontractor? The consent of the Owner to the Contractor’s engagement of a Subcontractor shall not create any contractual relation between the Subcontractor and the Owner. Is it required to appoint an Owner’s representative? Section X, Article 34 (Owner’s Representative) provides for the appointment of the representative of the Owner, and the extent and limitation of the authority granted to the representative. 4 Is the Owner required to make advance payment to the Contractor? Article 32 (Owner’s Responsibilities and Liabilities) provides that the Owner shall pay the Contractor an advance payment, which shall be used for mobilization, purchase of materials, and shall be recouped pro rata in the progress billings. Can the Contractor commence with the Work even without the consent of the Owner? Article 21.01 (Notice to Proceed, when required) states that premature commencement of construction shall be at the Contractor’s risk, and the Owner gives the Contractor express or implied authority to do so. How can the Owner ensure the quality and efficient execution of the Work? Section VI (Labor, Work and Payments) provides that the Owner shall at all times have access to the Work and shall provide sufficient number of inspectors while Work is in progress to ensure quality. Is substitution of materials and equipment allowed? Section III (Equipment and Materials) provides that all materials and equipment must conform to all Laws that are in force and applicable during the period of construction, and that the Contractor shall bear all damages by reason of any delay in the Work arising from failure to comply with such Laws. What constitutes Change Order and adjustment of contract price? Section VI, Article 20 (Work) describes the circumstances that are covered by a Change Order and that warrant adjustment in contract price and, if necessary, corresponding adjustment in completion time. What are the conditions for the release of payment to the Contractor? Art. 22.01 provides that the Contractor shall submit to the Owner the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value of the Contract Amount showing the value assigned to each part of the Work. What is Progress Payment? The Contractor may submit periodically but not more than once each month a Request for Payment for work done. 5 Each request for progress payment shall be computed from the work completed on all items listed in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value, less a retention of 10% of the progress payment to the Contractor. What is Retention Money? Progress payments are subject to retention of ten percent (10%). The purpose of retention is to cover uncorrected discovered defects and third party liabilities. (Not in CIAP Doc. 102) What are the documents to be submitted by the Contractor to the Owner before final payment? 1. Certificate of Final Building Occupancy; 2. Certificate of Final Inspection of electrical, telephone, sanitary, mechanical, water, gas, safety and other utilities; 3. Original and three (3) sets of prints of “As-Built Drawings” of electrical, sanitary, gas, telephone, and mechanical works; 4. Three (3) copies of Directory of Panel Boards and list of circuits; 5. Three (3) copies of Instructions and Manual for operating and maintaining of fixtures and equipment; 6. Three (3) copies of Keying Schedule; and 7. Release of liens arising under the Contract (Sworn Statement or Indemnity Bond). Does the release of final payment relieve the Contractor of liability for any defect in the Work? After release of final payment and acceptance by the Owner of the Work, the Contractor is still liable for any defect in the Work, if: 1. the defect is hidden; 2. the Owner’s acceptance of the Work was made with reservations to specific portion of the Work; 3. inferior work or work which does not comply with the Drawings and Specifications and is apparent upon inspection by the Owner within one year from final payment; and 4. hidden defect discovered within the warranty period or within one year from posting of the Guarantee Bond. 6 The Contractor is likewise liable for damages if the edifice falls, within fifteen years from completion of the structure, on account of defects in the construction or the use of materials of inferior quality or due to any violation of the terms of the Contract as provided in Article 1723 of the Civil Code of the Philippines. When shall the Owner release the retention money? The amount retained by the Owner under the provision of the Contract shall be released not later than the expiration of the “Period of Making Good of Known Defects”. What does “Period of Making Good of Known Defects” mean? The expression “Period of Making Good of Known Defects” shall mean a period of not more than thirty (30) calendar days, calculated from the date of receipt by the Contractor of the last item in the punch list. If after release to the Contractor of final payment or retention there are still unpaid claims of Subcontractors and/or suppliers, is the Owner obliged to pay such claims? Section IX, Article 33.01 provides that, as a condition to final payment and/or release of the retention, the Contractor shall release the Work from any legal liens. Can the Owner take possession of and use any completed portion of the Work prior to overall completion? Section VI, Article 20.10 (Use of Completed Portions of Work) provides that the Owner may take possession of and use any completed or partially completed portion of the Work prior to overall completion, and shall issue a Certificate of Completion for such portion taken over and release retention as required by the Contract. What is substantial completion? Section VI, Article 20.11 (Substantial Completion and its Effect) provides that there is substantial completion when the Contractor completes ninety five percent (95%) of the Work. What is a punch list? Punch list, as defined under Article 20.11 C (a), is the list of defects found or discovered on the completed work and which should be received by the Contractor not later than 30 days from date of substantial completion. 7 What are the grounds for the suspension of the Work or termination of the Contract? Section 8 (Suspension of Work and Termination of Contract) illustrates the conditions by which the Contractor or the Owner may suspend the Work or terminate the Contract. Are there prescribed periods within which the contracting parties shall perform their respective obligations under the Contract? CIAP Document 102 provides the prescribed time limits for the execution of the contract conditions in order to facilitate the performance of the Works covered under the Contract [Section XI (Schedule of Time Limits)]. What circumstances necessitate an extension of time? Article 21.04 (Extension of Time) provides that the Contractor shall be entitled to an equitable adjustment of completion time subject to certain conditions. Article 21.04 (D) states that delay in the payment of any progress billing shall automatically extend the Completion Time by a period equal to the delay. What is the penalty for delay? Article 21.05 provides that upon failure of the Contractor to complete the Work within the Completion Time, the Contractor shall pay the Owner liquidated damages in the amount stipulated in the Contract as indemnity, but shall not exceed ten percent (10%) of the total contract price [Art. 29.06 (3)]. In case of disagreements in the interpretation and implementation of the contract conditions, how can CIAP help resolve such disputes? Section IX, Article 33.04 provides that in case of disagreements, the parties may engage the services of an adjudicator to resolve their disputes, and that if either of the party disagrees with the resolution of the adjudicator, the parties may submit such disputes to arbitration. One of the implementing arms of the CIAP, the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC), is tasked to provide alternative dispute resolution facilities for the speedy and equitable settlement of claims and disputes arising from, or connected with, construction contracts in the Philippines. CIAC offers mediation and arbitration as ways of reconciling differences between disputants with the help of people who are familiar/knowledgeable with the construction industry. 8 What is Mediation? Mediation, as defined under Section 6 of the CIAC Mediation Rules, shall mean a voluntary process in which a mediator, selected by the disputing parties, facilitates communication and negotiation, and assists the parties in reaching a voluntary agreement regarding a dispute. What is Arbitration? Arbitration is defined as the investigation and determination of matters of differences between contending parties by one or more unofficial persons, called arbitrators or referees, chosen by the parties. It is intended to avoid the formalities, the delay, the expense and vexation of ordinary litigation. How can interested parties avail of CIAC facilities? If a dispute arises, a party may initiate the mediation by delivering a written Request for Mediation to the other party in accordance with the CIAC Mediation Rules, or if mediation fails, a Request for Arbitration in accordance with the CIAC Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration. Are there recommended dispute resolution clauses? For parties entering into a Contract who wish to have future disputes referred to mediation and/or arbitration, the following dispute resolution clauses may be included: Mediation and Arbitration (by CIAC): Any dispute or differences arising out or in connection with this contract shall be referred to the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC) for settlement, first through mediation under its Mediation Rules; or failing which, by arbitration under its Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration by [indicate number; one or three] arbitrator(s). The appointment of mediator or arbitrator/s shall be made in accordance with such Rules. The place of mediation or arbitration shall be [indicate place]. Purely Arbitration (by CIAC): Any dispute arising out of or in connection with this contract, including any question regarding its existence, validity or termination shall be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration under the Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration promulgated by the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission, by [indicate number: one or three] arbitrator(s) to be appointed in accordance with such Rules. The place of arbitration shall be [indicate place]. 9 By negotiation among the parties (w/ time frame), Mediation and Arbitration (by CIAC): Any dispute or differences arising out or in connection with this contract shall be settled by negotiation within a non-extendible period of 30 days from written demand by either party. If such negotiation should fail, the same shall be referred to the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC) for settlement; first, through mediation under its Mediation Rules within a non-extendible period of 48 days; or failing which, by arbitration under its Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration by [indicate number: one or three] arbitrator(s). The appointment of mediator or arbitrator/s shall be made in accordance with such Rules promulgated by the CIAC. The place of mediation or arbitration shall be [indicate place]. What are the issues that can be submitted for mediation or arbitration? The jurisdiction of the CIAC may include, but is not limited to, the following: - violation of specifications for materials and workmanship; violation of the terms of agreement; interpretation and/or application of contractual provisions; commencement time and delays; maintenance and defects; changes in contract cost payment default of employer or contractor; and amount of damages and penalties. 10 SECTION XI SCHEDULE OF TIME LIMITS The Contractor shall perform his work subject to certain Time Limits. This indexed section, as based on the entire General Conditions, is provided for in order to facilitate the execution of his work. Reference No. & Title Time Limit Article No. 1. CONTRACT TIME 1.1 Contract Time Reckoning 1.2 Request for Time 2. CONTRACT SUM 2.1 Breakdown of Work & Corresponding Value 2.2 Claim for Extra Cost 3. PROGRESS/FINAL PAYMENT 3.1 Owner’s Action on Payment Request 3.2 Owner’s Action on Final Payment Request 3.3 Delayed Payment 3.4 Release of Retention 4. SUBSTANTIAL COMPLETION and its EFFECTS The Contractor shall commence the Work within seven (7) days from receipt of Notice to Proceed (NTP) unless NTP provides for a later date To be filed within fifteen (15) days from occurrence of event which caused delay (par. B) 21.02 To be submitted within fifteen days from receipt of the Notice to Proceed 22.01 Notice to be given to Owner within fifteen (15) days (1) after receipt of instruction involving extra cost, or (2) after recognition of delay due to Owner’s fault 20.08 To be made within thirty (30) days after receipt of request for payment To act within thirty (30) days from receipt of the request for payment 22.05 Delay in payment of the amount due shall entitle the Contractor to interest from due date based on the thirty (30) day loan rate of the Land Bank of the Philippines To be released not later than sixty (60) days from substantial completion upon posting of Contractor’s Guarantee Bond. 22.05 Substantial Completion is attained if the Contractor completes ninety-five percent (95%) of the works; or the 20.11 21.04 22.11 11 No. & Title Time Limit Reference Article No. Owner approves the Contractor’s billing for completing at least 95% of the works unless the Owner can establish that the unfinished portion prevents the normal use of the completed portion [par. A (a) & (b)]. The Owner may issue a Certificate of Substantial Completion or equivalent document but the date of document is not controlling if substantial completion is shown to have been attained earlier, unless the Contractor accepts the certificate without taking any exceptions thereto in writing within fifteen (15) days from receipt of the certificate [par. A (c)]. 5. CORRECTION OF WORK 5.1 Issuance of Punch List 5.2 Correction Before or After Final Payment 5.3 Making Good of Known Defects 6. CONTRACTOR’S RIGHT TO SUSPEND WORK OR TERMINATE CONTRACT The Owner shall issue the punch list/s which the Contractor must receive not later than thirty (30) days from date of substantial completion [par C (a)]. The Owner may add to the punch list items but only as to corrective work in the original punch list/s not later than sixty (60) days from substantial completion [par. C (b)]. 20.11 Poor or inferior work, apparent upon inspection to be condemned & Contractor notified to enable him to correct, remove & replace the same. Owner has one year from date of final payment to condemn poor or inferior work, otherwise, instructions to remove or replace such shall be treated as change order. 22.10 Thirty (30) days from receipt by the Contractor of the last item in the punchlist 20.12 & 20.13 26.00 Contractor may suspend work or terminate Contract upon 15 days written notice to Owner, for any of the following reasons: 12 No. & Title 7. OWNER’S RIGHT TO TERMINATE CONTRACT Time Limit (1) If any court or other public authority orders work to be stopped or suspended for ninety (90) days through no fault of the Contractor or his employees; (2) If Owner fails to pay Contractor the approved request for payment within thirty (30) days from receipt. (3) If Owner fails to pay Contractor the agreed sum within thirty (30) days after its award by arbitrators. (4) If the Owner suspends the work without cause for more than fifteen (15) days without Contractor’s consent. (5) If the Owner fails to deliver at the construction site Owner-supplied/furnished materials and/or equipment, for work along the critical path beyond fifteen (15) days after its scheduled delivery date. (6) If approval of Variation Orders for additional works along the critical path is delayed beyond fifteen (15) days after submission for approval by the Owner. May be done immediately and without notice if Contractor should: (1) Declare bankruptcy, become insolvent or assigns his assets for the benefit of his creditors or appointment of trustee/receiver for Contractor or any of its property. May be done after giving fifteen (15) days written notice to Contractor or to his Surety if Contractor should: (1) Disregard or violate provisions of the Contract Documents or Owner’s instructions; (2) Fail to provide skilled superintendent, workmen or suitable materials or equipment; (3) Fail to make prompt payment to subcontractors, for labor or materials or equipment; (4) Disregard the authority of the Owner’s Representative; Reference Article No. 28.01 28.02 13 No. & Title Time Limit Reference Article No. (5) Violates in any substantial way any provisions of the Contract Documents; (6) Repeatedly delays prosecution of work per agreed Construction Schedule and/or PERT/CPM plus any time extension duly granted the Contractor. 8. DISPUTES 9. GUARANTEE BOND 9.1 Contractor’s Guarantee Bond The Owner or his representative shall act within a period of fifteen (15) days on all matters under the Contract requiring the Owner’s approval, acceptance or decision. If the Contractor disagrees with the determination by the Owner or his representative, the same shall be submitted to an adjudicator to be jointly engaged by the parties within 15 days before the commencement of the work. If either party disagrees with the resolution of the adjudicator, such shall be deemed a dispute that may be submitted to arbitration. 33.04 & 33.05 To be furnished the Owner upon release of retention and shall be effective for a period of one year commencing from the date of acceptance as a guarantee that all materials and workmanship installed are of good quality. 31.05 Copies of this Primer, CIAP Document 102, the CIAC Mediation Rules and Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration, are available at the CIAP website at www.ciap.dti.gov.ph 14 The PDCB Board: Atty. Ramon P. Ereñeta, Jr. Chairman Members: Engr. Rogelio C. Lombos Engr. Liberito V. Espiritu Engr. Anthony L. Fernandez Atty. Romeo S. Lagman (resigned) 15 Philippine Domestic Construction Board 5th Floor, Executive Building Center, 369 Sen. Gil J. Puyat Ave. cor. Makati Ave., Makati City Telephone No.: (632) 897-0791; Telefax No.: (632) 896-1801 Email: pdcb@dti.gov.ph Website: ciap.dti.gov.ph Republic Act No. 544* (As Amended by R.A. 1582) An Act to Regulate the Practice of Civil Engineering in the Philippines Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the Philippines in Congress assembled: Article I TITLE OF THE ACT AND DEFINITION OF TERMS Section 1. Title of Act.” This Act shall be known as the “Civil Engineering Law.” Section 2. Definition of Terms.” (a) The practice of civil engineering within the meaning and intent of this Act shall embrace services in the form of consultation, design, preparation of plans, specifications, estimates, erection, installation and supervision of the construction of streets, bridges, highways, railroads, airports and hangars, port works, canals, river and shore improvements, lighthouses, and dry docks; buildings, fixed structures for irrigation, flood protection, drainage, water supply and sewerage works; demolition of permanent structures; and tunnels. The enumeration of any work in this section shall not be construed as excluding any other work requiring civil engineering knowledge and application. (b) The term “civil engineer” as used in this act shall mean a person duly registered with the Board for Civil Engineers in the manner as hereinafter provided. Article II BOARD OF EXAMINERS FOR CIVIL ENGINEERS Section 3. Composition of Board.” Within thirty days after the approval of this Act there shall be created a Board of Examiners for Civil Engineers, hereinafter referred to as the Board, to be composed of a chairman and two members who shall be appointed by the President of the Philippines, upon recommendation of the Commissioner of PRC. The members of the Board shall hold office for a term of three years after appointment or until their successors shall have been appointed and shall have qualified. The first members of the Board appointed under this Act shall hold office for the following terms: One member for one year; one member for two years; and one member for three years. Each member of the Board shall qualify by taking the proper oath of office before entering upon the performance of his duties. Any member of the Board may be removed by the President of the Philippines, upon recommendation by the Professional Regulation Commission for neglect of duty, incompetency, malpractice, unprofessional, unethical, immoral, or dishonorable conduct, after having been given opportunity to defend himself in a proper administrative investigation: Provided, That during the process of investigation, the President of the Philippines, upon the recommendation of the PRC, shall have the power to suspend such member under investigation and shall appoint a temporary member in his place. Vacancies in the Board shall be filled for the un expired term only. Section 4. Powers and Duties of the Board.” The Board for Civil Engineers is vested with authority, conformable with the provisions of this Act, to administer oaths, issue, suspend and revoke certificates of registration for the practice of civil engineering, issue certificates of recognition to civil engineers already registered under this Act for advanced studies, research, and/or highly specialized training in any branch of civil engineering subject to the approval of the PRC, to investigate such violations of this Act and the regulations, there under as may come to the knowledge of the Board and, for this purpose, issue subpoena and subpoena duces tecum to secure appearance of witnesses in connection with the charges presented to the Board, to inspect at least once a year educational institutions offering courses in civil engineering, civil engineering works, projects or corporations, established in the Philippines and, for safeguarding of life, health and property, to discharge such other powers and duties as may affect ethical and technological standards of the civil engineering profession in the Philippines. For the purpose of this Act, the Director of Public Works and/or his authorized representative in the provinces and chartered cities shall be ex-officio agents of the Board and as such it shall be their duty to help in the enforcement of the provisions of this Act. The Board may, with the approval of the Professional Regulation Commission issue such rules and regulations as may be deemed necessary to carry out the provisions of this Act. The board shall also adopt a code of ethics in the practice of civil engineering and have an official seal to authenticate its official documents. Section 5. Qualifications of Board Members.” Each member of the Board shall, at the time of his appointment: a. b. c. d. e. f. g. Be a citizen and resident of the Philippines; Be at least thirty years of age and of good moral character; Be a graduate of civil engineering from a recognized and legally constituted school, institute, college or university. Be a registered civil engineer duly qualified to practice civil engineering in the Philippines; Have practiced civil engineering, with a certificate as such, for a period of not less than ten years prior to his appointment. Not be a member of the faculty of any school, institute, college, or university where civil engineering course is taught, nor have a pecuniary interest in such institutions; No former members of the faculty of any school, institute or university where civil engineering is taught can become a member of the Board unless he had stopped teaching for at least three consecutive years. Section 6. Fees and Compensation of Board.” The Board for Civil Engineers shall charge for each application for examination the sum of P100 (one hundred) payable to the collecting and disbursing officer of the PRC upon filing of said application, and for each certificate of registration, fifty pesos. Each member of the Board shall receive a compensation of fifteen pesos for each applicant examined. A civil engineer in the service of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines appointed as member of the Board shall receive the compensation as herein provided, in addition to his salary in the Government. All authorized expenses of the Board, including the compensation provided for herein, shall be paid by the collecting and disbursing officer of the PRC out of such appropriation as may be made for the purpose. (See RA 6511 & PD 223) Section 7. Annual Report.” The Board shall, at the end of each fiscal year, submit to the PRC a detailed report of its activities and proceedings during the period covered by the fiscal year ended. Article III EXAMINATION AND REGISTRATION Section 8. Examination Requirement.” All applicants for registration for the practice of civil engineering shall berequired to pass a technical examination as hereinafter provided. Section 9. Holding of Examination.” Examination of candidates desiring to practice civil engineering in the Philippines shall be given in the City of Manila of each year, provided that such days do not fall on official holidays, otherwise the examinations shall be held on the days next following. Section 10. Subjects of Examination.” Applicants for certificate of registration as civil engineer shall be examined, in the discretion of the Board, on the following subjects: mathematics, including algebra, plane and spherical trigonometry, analytics, descriptive and solid geometry, differential and integral calculus, and rational and applied mechanics; hydraulics; surveying, including highway and railroad surveying; plane, topographic and hydrographic surveying, and advance surveying; design and construction of highways and railroads, masonry structures, wooden and reinforced concrete buildings, bridges, towers, walls, foundations, piers, ports, wharves, aqueducts, sanitary engineering works, water supply systems, dikes, dams and irrigation and drainage canals. Section 11. Executive Officer of the Board.” The Commissioner of Professional Regulation Commission shall be the executive officer of the Board and shall conduct the examinations given by the said Board. He shall designate any subordinate officer of the Professional Regulation Commission to act as the Secretary and custodian of all records including examination papers and minutes of the deliberation of the Board. Section 12. Qualifications for Examination.” Any person applying for admission to the civil engineering examination as herein provided shall, prior to the date of the examination, establish to the satisfaction of the Board that he has the following qualifications: a. b. c. d. Be at least twenty-one years of age; Be a citizen of the Philippines; Be of good reputation and moral character; and Be a graduate of a four-year course in civil engineering from a school, institute, college or university recognized by the Government or the State wherein it is established. Section 13. Oath of Civil Engineers.” All successful candidates in the examination shall be required to take a professional oath before the Board of Civil Engineers or other Government Officials authorized to administer oaths, prior to entering upon the practice of the civil engineering profession. Section 14. Seal and Use of Seal.” All registered civil engineers shall obtain a seal of such design as the Board shall authorize and direct: Provided, however, That the serial number of the certificate issued by the Board shall be included in the design of the seal. Plans and specifications prepared by, or under the direct supervision of a registered civil engineer shall be stamped with said seal during the life of the registrant’s certificate, and it shall be unlawful for any one to stamp or seal any documents with said seal after the certificate of registrant named thereon has expired or has been revoked, unless said certificate shall have been renewed or re-issued. Section 15. Exemption from Registration.” 1. Registration shall not be required of the following persons: a. Officers or enlisted men of the United States and Philippine Armed Forces, and civilian employeesof the Government of the United States stationed in the Philippines while rendering civil engineering services for the United States and/or Philippines. b. Civil engineers or experts called in by the Philippine Government for consultation, or specific designand construction of fixed structures as defined under this Act, provided that their practice shall be limited to such work. 2. Any person residing in the Philippines may make plans on specifications for any of the following: a. Any building in chartered cities or in towns with building ordinances, not exceeding the space requirement specified therein, requiring the services of a civil engineer. b. Any wooden building enlargement or alteration which is to be used for farm purposes only and costingnot more than ten thousand pesos. c. Provided, however. That there shall be nothing in this Act that will prevent any person from constructing his own (wooden or light material) residential house, utilizing the services of a person or persons required for the purpose, without the use of a civil engineer, as long as he does no violate local ordinances of the place where the building is to be constructed. 3. Nor shall anything in this Act prevent draftsmen, student clerk-or-work, superintendents, and other employees of those lawfully engaged in the practice of civil engineering under the provisions of this Act, from acting under the instruction, control or supervision of their employer. 4. Nor shall anything in this Act prevent any person who prior to the approval of this Act have been lawfully engaged in the practice of “maestro de obras” to continue as such, provided they shall not undertake the making of plans supervision for the following classes of work: a. b. c. d. Building of concrete whether reinforced or not. Building of more than two stories. Building with frames of structural steel. Building of structures intended for public gathering or assemblies such as theaters, cinematographs, stadia, churches, or structures of like nature. 5. Nor shall anything in this Act prevent professional architects and engineers to practice their professions. Section 16. Refusal to Issue Certificate.” The Board for Civil Engineers shall not issue a certificate to any person convicted by a court of competent jurisdiction of any criminal offense involving moral turpitude, or to any person guilty of immoral or dishonorable conduct, or to any person guilty of immoral or dishonorable conduct, or to any person of unsound mind. In the event of a refusal to issue a certificate to any person, the Board shall give to the applicant a written statement setting forth its reason for such action, which statement shall be incorporated in the records of the Board. Section 17. Suspension and Revocation of Certificates. “ The Board shall have the power, after due notice and hearings to suspend or revoke the certificate of registration for any cause mentioned in the preceding section. Section 18. Re-issue and Replacement of Certificates. “ The Board may, after the expiration of one year from the date of certificate of registration is revoked and for reasons it may deem sufficient, entertain an application for a new certificate of registration from the registrant concerned. Such application shall be accomplished in the same form prescribed for examination, but the Board may, in its discretion, exempt the applicant from taking the requisite examination. Section 19. Transitory Provisions.” As soon as this Act takes effect, any person desiring to practice the profession of civil engineering shall be required to obtain a certificate of registration in the manner and under the conditions hereinafter provided. All civil engineers duly licensed under the provisions of Act Numbered Twenty-nine hundred and eighty-five, as amended, at the time this Act takes effect, shall be automatically registered under the provisions hereof. Certificates of registration held by such persons in good standing shall have the same force and effect as though the same have been issued under the provisions of this Act. All graduates in civil engineering from a school, institute, college, or university recognized by the Government who have passed the civil service examination for senior civil engineer and have been practicing or employed in the Government as such during five years are exempted from taking examination. Article IV ENFORCEMENT OF ACT AND PENAL PROVISIONS Section 20. Enforcement of the Act by officers of the law.” It shall be the duty of all duly constituted law officers of the national, provincial, city and municipal governments, or any political subdivisions thereof, to enforce the provisions of this Act and to prosecute any person violating the same. Section 21. Registration required.” Unless exempt from registration, no person shall practice or offer to practice civil engineering in the Philippines without having obtained the proper certificate of registration from the Board for Civil Engineers.* Section 22. Penal provisions.” Any person who shall practice or offer to practice civil engineering in the Philippines without being registered in accordance with the provisions of this Act or any person presenting or attempting to use as his own the certificate of registration of a registered civil engineer, or any person who shall give any false or forged evidence of any kind to the Board, or any person who shall impersonate any registrant civil engineer of different name or any person who shall attempt to use a revoked or suspended certificate of registration, or any person who shall use in connection with his name or otherwise assume, use or advertise any title or description tending to convey the impression that he is a civil engineer, without holding a valid certificate of registration, or any person who shall violate any of the provision of this Act, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and shall, upon conviction, be sentenced to a fine of not less than five hundred pesos nor more than two thousand pesos, or to suffer imprisonment for a period of not less than six months not more than one year, or both, in the discretion of the court. Article V MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS Section 23. Preparation of plans and supervisions of construction by registered civil engineer.” It shall be unlawful for any person to order or otherwise cause the construction, reconstruction, or alteration of any building or structure intended for public gathering or assembly such as theaters, cinematographs, stadia, churches or structures of like nature, and any other engineering structures mentioned in section two of this Act unless the designs, plans, and specifications of same have been prepared under the responsible charge of, and signed and sealed by a registered civil engineer, and unless the construction, reconstruction and/or alteration thereof are executed under the responsible charge and direct supervision of a civil engineer. Plans and designs of structures must be approved as provided by law or ordinance of a city or province or municipality where the said structure is to be constructed. Section 24. The practice of civil engineering is a professional service, admission to which must be determined upon individual, personal qualifications. Hence, no firm, partnership, corporation or association may be registered or licensed as such for the practice of civil engineering: Provided, however, That persons properly registered and licensed as civil engineers may, among themselves or with a person or persons properly registered and licensed as architects, form, and obtain registration of, a firm, partnership or association using the term “Engineers” or “Engineers and Architects,” but, nobody shall be a member or partner of such firm, partnership or association unless he is duly licensed civil engineer or architect, and the members who are civil engineers shall only render work and services proper for a civil engineer, as defined in this Act, and the members who are architects shall also only render work and services proper for an architect, as defined in the law regulating the practice of architecture; individual members of such firms, partnership or association shall be responsible for their own respective acts. Section 25. Reciprocity requirements.” No person who is not a citizen of the Philippines at the time he applies to take the examination shall be allowed to take it unless he can prove in the manner provided by the Rules of Court that, by specific provision of law, the country of which he is a citizen, subject, or national either admits citizens of the Philippines to the practice of the same profession without restriction or allows them to practice it after an examination on terms of strict and absolute equality with citizens, subjects, or nationals of the country concerned, including the unconditional recognition of degrees issued by institutions of learning duly recognized for the purpose by the Government of the Philippines: Provided, That if he is not a citizen of the Philippines, and was admitted to the practice of a profession in the Philippines after December 8, 1941, his active practice in that profession, either in the Philippines or in the state or country where he was practicing his profession, shall not have been interrupted for a period of two years or more prior to July 4, 1946, and that the country or state from which he comes allows the citizens of the Philippines by specific provision of law, to practice the same profession without restriction or on terms of strict and absolute equality with citizens, subjects or nationals of the country or state concerned. Section 26. Roster of civil engineers.” A roster showing the names and places of business of all registered civil engineers shall be prepared by the Commissioner of PRC periodically but at least once a year. Copies of this roster shall be placed on file with the PRC and furnished to all department heads, mayors of all chartered cities, to the Director of Public Works, to such other Bureaus, government entities or agencies and municipal and provincial authorities as may be deemed necessary and to the public upon request. Section 27. Repeal.” All laws, parts of laws, orders, ordinances, or regulations in conflict with the provisions hereof; including parts of Act Numbered Twenty-nine hundred and eighty-five, as amended, as pertains to the practice of civil engineering, are hereby repealed, except the provisions of Act Numbered Thirtyone hundred and fifty nine amending Act Numbered Twenty-nine hundred and eighty-five, pertaining to the practice of “maestro de obras.” Section 28. Construction of Act.” If any part or section of this Act shall be declared unconstitutional, such declarations shall not invalidate the other provisions hereof. Section 29. Effectivity.” This Act shall take effect upon its approval. Approved, June 17, 1950 (As amended by R.A. No. 1582, approved on June 16, 1956). 2 FOREWORD One of the cornerstones of sound and harmonious business dealings is a fair contract which balances risks-sharing and clearly defines the rights and obligations of the contracting parties. Fair contract terms and conditions are of vital importance to an industry such as construction because of the huge investments involved and the high risks faced by contractors and project owners alike. Inequitable contractual relationships in the industry have, more often than not, resulted in abandonment of projects, huge losses, and even bankruptcy, hence, posing a threat to the long-term viability of the construction sector. To address the problem, and in line with its mandate to recommend and encourage the adoption of equitable and realistic contract conditions for construction and to reflect usages of the trade and generally accepted construction industry standards, the Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines (CIAP) joined hands with the private sector to draft CIAP Document 102 and promote its adoption as the general conditions of contract for private construction in the Philippines. Work on this document started in May 1990 by a committee composed of representatives from the Philippine Constructors Association (PCA); the United Architects of the Philippines (UAP); the Philippine Institute of Civil Engineers (PICE); the Philippine Chamber of Commerce & Industry (PCCI); and the Confederation of Filipino Consulting Organizations (COFILCO). With UAP Document 301 as the frame of reference, an interim draft was completed in December 1990 and adopted for use by UAP; PCA; PCCI; PICE; and CIAP. Refinements to the interim CIAP Document 102 were completed in February 1997 by the same committee which has since expanded its membership to include the Chamber of Real Estate & Builders Association (CREBA); the Construction Project Managers Association of the Philippines (CPMAP); and the Philippine Institute of Construction Arbitrators (PICA now the Philippine Institute of Construction Arbitrators and Mediators or PICAM). A Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) on the adoption of the final draft was signed on August 14, 1997 by the PCA; PCCI; CREBA; PICE; CPMAP; PICA; and CIAP. In line with the Construction Industry Strategic Plan for the 21 st Century (CI21), the Committee reconvened in May 2002 to discuss and draft amendments to the document to incorporate prevailing best practices in the industry and attune the same to the needs of the changing times. The amendments were subjected to consultations with and among the professional organizations in the industry. In its 43rd Regular Meeting held on June 29, 2004, the CIAP Board approved the amendments to CIAP Document 102 under CIAP Board Resolution No. 15, series of 2004. Subsequently, a MOA was signed on October 4, 2004 by the PCA; UAP; PICE; PCCI; COFILCO; CREBA; CPMAP; PICA (now PICAM); and Society of Philippine Accredited Consultants (SPAC), signifying their commitment to adopt CIAP Document 102 for use as a standard and integral part of their construction Contracts. On March 30, 2005, the CIAP Board issued a resolution, CIAP Board Resolution No. 1, series of 2005, prescribing the use and application of the provisions of CIAP Document 102 to serve as the procedures, guidelines and criteria to be used by the contracting parties, more specifically in the adjudication and settlement of claims and disputes in contract implementation, and in the following instances: a) where the parties had failed to incorporate into their construction contract the general conditions of contract; or b) where the conditions of contract agreed upon are incomplete, in which case, CIAP Document 102 shall fill the omission of stipulations; or c) where certain provisions of the conditions of contract agreed upon are ambiguous, in which case, reference may be made to CIAP Document 102 to explain the ambiguity. 3 In 2017, the Committee, composed of PCA; PICAM; CPMAP; PICE; PCCI; UAP COFILCO; CECOPHIL; SHDA together with CIAP; PDCB; CIAC; and the DTI-Bureau of Philippine Standards (BPS), was again reconvened to assess the document if it’s still relevant to the needs of the industry or if there is a need to update/improve it. In consultation with stakeholders, the Committee affirmed that CIAP Document 102 is still relevant but needs to be updated/improved. The CIAP Board, in its 79th Regular Meeting held on 18 February 2019, issued CIAP Board Resolution No. 2, Series of 2019, creating the Technical Working Group (TWG) tasked to review CIAP Document 102 and to make the necessary updates/amendments to make it relevant to the needs of the industry. The TWG, after due deliberations, submitted to the PDCB its proposed amendments to CIAP Document 102 which consist of minor changes in the format, use of gender-fair language in compliance with the directive of the Civil Service Commission (CSC) (CSC Memo Circular No. 12-2005), and few minor updates and improvement on certain provisions (see Appendix A). The PDCB, through PDCB Board Resolution No. 01, Series of 2022, endorsed to the CIAP Board the aforesaid TWG recommended revisions to CIAP Document 102, with its new feature--the Annotations with Case Synopses and Jurisprudence, which the CIAP Board approved in its 90th Regular Meeting held on 30 September 2022, through CIAP Board Resolution No. 07, Series of 2022. 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The CIAP would like to express its sincere gratitude to the various professional organizations which gave full and invaluable support to this endeavor of providing the construction industry with an equitable and realistic contract conditions reflecting the usages of the trade and generally accepted construction industry standards. CIAP Document 102 would not have been possible without the support of the presidents and representatives of the various professional organizations, and the patience, diligence, and selfless dedication of the members of the Committee who religiously participated in the deliberations and drafting work: 1st Edition that was published in 1997: Messrs. Rogelio M. Nurga and Jaime H. Pajara (PCA); Mr. Joven B. Joaquin (PICA, now PICAM); Messrs. Gregorio G. Sta. Maria, Sr. and Claudio B. Altura (CPMAP); Messrs. Vicente B. Lopez and Felipe F. Cruz (PICE); Messrs. Charlie Gorayeb and Jerry M. Navarrete (CREBA); Mr. Federico C. Pascual (PCCI); and Messrs. Nestor S. Mangio and Emmanuel P. Cuntapay (UAP). The members of the Committee: Archt. Ramon L. Abiera (UAP); Engr. Fedrico Carandang (CREBA); Engr. Enrique P. Inciong and Mr. Joven B. Joaquin (PICA, now PICAM); Engr. Potenciano A. Leoncio, Jr. (PICE); Engr. Manuel Limgenco and Engr. Alfredo P. Montecillo (PCA); Mr. Manolito Madrasto (PCCI); Archt. Felicitas A. Pio Roda (CPMAP); Atty. Custodio O. Parlade (CIAP Consultant); and Ms. Alicia A. Tiongson (CIAP). The Committee was ably assisted by the following staff of the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC): Kathryn Josephine T. Dela Cruz, Emily P. Morallos, and Roger G. Antonio. 2004 Revised version: Mr. Emilio Lolito J. Tumbocon (PCA); Engr. Eliseo I. Evangelista (PICA, now PICAM); Archt. Felicitas A. Pio Roda (CPMAP); Mr. Peter N. Aventajado (PICE); Ms. Purita L. Soliven (CREBA); Ms. Noemi L. Saludo (PCCI); Mr. Enrique O. Olonan (UAP); Dr. Leandro A. Viloria (SPAC); and Ms. Elvira Ablaza (COFILCO). The members of the Committee: Mr. Florentino S. Dulalia, Jr. (CREBA); Archt. Prosperidad Luis (UAP); Mr. Joven B. Joaquin and Engr. Joel J. Marciano (PICA, now PICAM); Dr. Ernesto S. De Castro (PICE); Messrs. Justo E. Manalo, Alfredo Montecillo, and Manolito Madrasto (PCA); Messrs. Sergio Ortiz-Luis, Jr. and Manuel J. Colayco, Jr. (PCCI); Archt. Felicitas A. Pio Roda (CPMAP); Engr. Guadalupe O. Mansueto (SPAC); Engr. Ricardo Basa (COFILCO); Archt. Geronimo V. Manahan (PDCB); Atty. Custodio O. Parlade; and Ms. Kathryn Josephine T. Dela Cruz (CIAP) The Committee was ably assisted by the following staff of the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC): Roger G. Antonio, Emily P. Morallos, Delia B. Perlada, Jocelyn C. Carrasco, and Jose L. Pring, Jr. 2022 Revised version: Presidents of the following organizations: PCA; PICAM; PICE; UAP; PCCI; CPMAP; COFILCO; CECOPHIL; NACAP; SHDA; IIEE; PSPE; PSVARE; SPECS; ASEP; and SOPI. The Technical Working Group (TWG): Atty. Ma. Elena G. Francisco (PCA); Atty. Jesusito G. Morallos and Archt. Felicitas A. Pio Roda (PICAM & CPMAP); Dr. 5 Ernesto S. De Castro (CECOPHIL/COFILCO); Engr. Isaac S. David and Engr. Gil Talingdan II (PICE); Mr. Renato S. Tan and Mr. Santiago Ducay (SHDA); Engr. Huillio B. Belleza (NACAP); Archt. Ramon L. Abiera (CIAP); Engr. Liberito V. Espiritu (PDCB); Atty. Custodio O. Parlade (Legal Adviser); and Ms. Kathryn Josephine T. Dela Cruz (CIAC). Other contributors: Archt. Philip H. Recto; Engr. Salvador P. Castro Jr.; Engr. Rodolfo R. Peñalosa; Engr. Rogelio M. Avenido; Mr. Joven B. Joaquin; Engr. Jerico T. Borja; Mr. Paolo Wenceslao; Archt. Carlo Marudo; Atty. Michael Macapagal; Atty. Donemark Calimon; Engr. Anna Encarnacion; Ms. Elvira Roseph Castelo; Ms. May Rodriguez; Ms. Rosie Tsai; Ms. Karen Cristi; Mr. Alberto Molina; Mr. Norman Bautista; and the Standards Development Division (SDD) of the DTI—Bureau of Philippine Standards (BPS). The TWG was ably assisted by the PDCB Secretariat: Executive Director Doris U. Gacho, Engr. Jocelyn C. Carrasco, and Ms. Dana Lorraine C. Faurillo. Sincere appreciation for the support extended to CIAP by DTI Undersecretary Ruth B. Castelo for the Bureau of Philippine Standards (BPS) during the review of CIAP Document 102. 6 CIAP BOARD RESOLUTION NO. 7 Series of 2022 APPROVAL OF THE REVISIONS FOR CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY AUTHORITY OF THE PHILIPPINES (CIAP) DOCUMENT 102 AND RECOMMENDING THE USE OF CIAP DOCUMENT 102 AS GENERAL CONDITIONS IN THE PRIVATE CONTRACTS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS WHEREAS, under Section 2 (a) of PD 1746, the Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines (CIAP), is tasked to promote, accelerate and regulate the growth and development of the construction industry in conformity with national goals; WHEREAS, the same law also provides that CIAP is tasked to recommend and encourage the adoption of equitable and realistic contract conditions for construction; WHEREAS, in 1997, CIAP in line with its mandate, created a Committee composed of various professional groups in the industry to formulate the Uniform General Conditions of Contract for Private Construction otherwise known as CIAP Document 102. The first and latest revised editions were then published by the CIAP thru Philippine Domestic Construction Board (PDCB) in 1997 and 2004, respectively. WHEREAS, during the 101st Philippine Domestic Construction Board (PDCB) Meeting held on 20 July 2016, the Board recommends the formulation of annotations in CIAP Doc. 102 so that the public will be able to understand its provisions and appreciate its importance in the proper implementation of construction projects. WHEREAS, after series of PDCB Board Meetings on this, on 17 September 2018, a Committee on CIAP Document 102 was reactivated to assess the relevance of the use of CIAP Document 102 as general conditions in the private contracts in the implementation of construction projects. For this purpose, the Committee on CIAP Document 102 thru the PDCB likewise conducted Consultative and Briefing sessions with the industry stakeholders on 28 September and 20 November 2018, respectively; WHEREAS, As a result thereof, the Committee finds the existing CIAP Document 102 is still relevant but needs to be revised to incorporate best practices in the industry and update the documents considering the last revision was made in 2004; WHEREAS, the Committee on CIAP Document 102, after due deliberations, recommended revisions, among others: • • • New provisions to define the scope and coverage of CIAP Document 102; Inserted new definitions such as advance payment and as-built drawings as other Requirements before Final Payment; and Deleted, modified, rephrased, and added words, provisions, and phrases. WHEREAS, the Board agreed that a copy of the CIAP Document 102 shall be submitted to the Office of the National Administrative Register (ONAR) of the University of the Philippines. 7 NOW, THEREFORE, the Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines, in 90th CIAP Regular Board Meeting held on 30 September 2022, RESOLVES, as it is HEREBY RESOLVED, to approve the revisions to CIAP Document 102 and recommend the use of CIAP Document 102 as general conditions in the private contracts in the implementation of construction projects as well as the submission of a copy at the Office of the National Administrative Register (ONAR) of the University of the Philippines. Hereto attached, are the proposed revisions and the CIAP Doc. 102 copy, as Annexes A and B respectively, made as integral parts of this Resolution. MAJORITY APPROVED. 30 September 2022 8 9 10 TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD ………………………………………………………………………………………………….2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .......................................................................................... 5 SCOPE……………………………………………………………………………………………………………19 Section I Article 1 Definitions and Documents ........................................................... 19 Definitions .................................................................................... 19 1.01 act of God or force majeure ......................................................................................................... 19 1.02 advance payment/ down payment ............................................................................................. 19 1.03 Agreement................................................................................................................................... 20 1.04 As-Built Drawings ...................................................................................................................... 20 1.05 bid................................................................................................................................................ 20 1.06 bid bond ...................................................................................................................................... 20 1.07 Bid Bulletin ................................................................................................................................. 20 1.08 Bid Documents ........................................................................................................................... 20 1.09 Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value ........................................................................ 20 1.10 change order................................................................................................................................ 20 1.11 Completion time limit .................................................................................................................. 21 1.12 Contract ........................................................................................................................................ 21 1.13 Contract Documents .................................................................................................................... 21 1.14 Contractor .................................................................................................................................... 21 1.15 Contract Price ............................................................................................................................... 21 1.16 cost ................................................................................................................................................ 21 1.17 Drawings ...................................................................................................................................... 22 1.18 Final payment ............................................................................................................................. 22 1.19 Guarantee Bond .......................................................................................................................... 22 1.20 Instruction to Bidders ................................................................................................................ 22 1.21 Invitation to Bid .......................................................................................................................... 22 1.22 last known address of a party .................................................................................................... 22 1.23 Laws............................................................................................................................................. 22 11 1.24 Owner .......................................................................................................................................... 22 1.25 Owner's Representative.............................................................................................................. 23 1.26 Payment Bond ............................................................................................................................ 23 1.27 Performance Bond ...................................................................................................................... 23 1.28 retention...................................................................................................................................... 23 1.29 Schedule of Materials and Finishes ........................................................................................... 23 1.30 Special Provisions or Conditions ............................................................................................... 23 1.31 Specifications .............................................................................................................................. 23 1.32 Sub-Contractor ........................................................................................................................... 23 1.33 Supplementary Specifications ................................................................................................... 24 1.34 Surety .......................................................................................................................................... 24 1.35 Work ............................................................................................................................................ 24 1.36 written notice .............................................................................................................................. 24 Article 2 Execution, Correlation, Meaning of Terms, and Intent of Documents 24 2.01 Intent of Contract .................................................................................................................. 24 2.02 Standard of Conduct .......................................................................................................... 24 2. 03 Interpretation of Contract ................................................................................................ 24 2.04 Conformity to the Contract ............................................................................................... 26 2.05 Meaning of Terms ...................................................................................................................27 2.06 Timely Exercise of Administrative Responsibilities .........................................................27 2.07 Defective Equipment, Materials, or Work............................................................................ 28 2.08 Review of Contract............................................................................................................. 28 2.09 Documents and Samples at the Site ................................................................................. 29 2.10 Ownership of Contract and Models ...................................................................................... 29 Article 3 Drawings and Specifications .......................................................... 29 3.01 Copies of Drawings and Specifications ................................................................................. 29 3.02 Coordination of Drawings and Specifications ...................................................................... 29 3.03 Clarification of Meaning of Drawings and Specifications ................................................... 30 3.04 Discrepancy in Drawings................................................................................................... 30 Article 4 Detail Drawings and Instructions .................................................. 30 12 4.01 Supplementary Drawings and Instructions ......................................................................... 30 Article 5 Shop Drawings .............................................................................. 30 5.01 Conditions in the Preparation of Shop Drawings ................................................................ 30 5.02 Identification........................................................................................................................... 31 5.03 Letter of Transmittal............................................................................................................... 31 5.04 Corrections, Changes and Variations .................................................................................... 31 5.05 Responsibility for Accuracy ................................................................................................... 32 5.06 Owner’s Approval .................................................................................................................. 32 Section II Laws, Regulations, Site Conditions, Permits and Taxes .................. 32 Article 6 Laws and Site Conditions............................................................... 32 6.01 Laws and Regulations ............................................................................................................ 32 6.02 Site Conditions................................................................................................................... 32 Article 7 Permits, Taxes and Surveys ........................................................... 33 7.01 Permits and Licenses ............................................................................................................. 33 7.02 Taxes ....................................................................................................................................... 33 7.03 Construction Stakes and Reference Mark ............................................................................ 33 7.04 Services of Geodetic Engineer ............................................................................................... 33 Section III Equipment and Materials .............................................................. 34 Article 8 General ......................................................................................... 34 Article 9 Equipment .................................................................................... 34 9.01 Quality of Equipment ............................................................................................................ 34 9.02 Equipment Substitution .................................................................................................... 34 Article 10 Materials, Fixtures, Appliances, and Fittings Furnished by the Contractor 35 10.01 Samples of Materials ..........................................................................................................35 10.02 Brand Name Materials and Substitutes ............................................................................35 10.03 Testing Samples of Materials .............................................................................................35 10.04 Quality of Materials ........................................................................................................... 36 10.05 Storage and Stockpiling of Materials................................................................................ 36 10.06 Defective Materials ............................................................................................................ 36 13 10.07 Imported Materials, Fixtures and Equipment ................................................................. 36 10.08 Owner’s Approval ...............................................................................................................37 Article 11 Owner Materials, Equipment, Fixtures, Appliances and Fittings Furnished by the 37 Article 12 Royalties and Patents .................................................................... 37 Article 13 Manufacturer’s Directions............................................................. 37 Section IV Article 14 Premises and Temporary Structures .............................................. 38 Use of Premises ............................................................................. 38 14.01 Limitation of Use ............................................................................................................... 38 14.02 Safeguard for Structure ..................................................................................................... 38 Article 15 Temporary Structures and Facilities .............................................. 38 15.01 Temporary Office and Contractor’s Building ................................................................... 38 15.02 Temporary Housing for Workers...................................................................................... 38 15.03 Safety and Sanitation......................................................................................................... 38 15.04 Temporary Signs................................................................................................................ 39 15.05 Temporary or Trial Usage ................................................................................................. 39 Section V Article 16 Protection of Work and Property ................................................... 40 Protection of Work and Owner’s Property ..................................... 40 16.01 Safeguard Measures .......................................................................................................... 40 16.02 Old Materials ..................................................................................................................... 40 16.03 Trees and Other Plants ...................................................................................................... 40 16.04 Drainage .............................................................................................................................. 41 Article 17 Protection of Adjacent Property and Existing Utilities .................... 41 17.01 Contractor's Responsibility ................................................................................................ 41 17.02 Damages to Adjacent Utilities............................................................................................ 41 17.03 Condition Survey ................................................................................................................ 41 Article 18 Authorization to Contractor for the Protection of Life, Work and Property During an Emergency ....................................................................................... 42 Section VI Labor, Work and Payments ........................................................... 42 Article 19 Labor ............................................................................................ 42 Article 20 Work............................................................................................. 42 14 20.01 Methods and Appliances ................................................................................................... 42 20.02 Laying Out the Work ......................................................................................................... 42 20.03 Defective Work .................................................................................................................. 43 20.04 Inspection of Work ............................................................................................................ 43 20.05 Work During an Emergency ............................................................................................. 44 20.06 Increased or Decreased Quantities of Work .................................................................... 44 20.07 Changes in the Work ......................................................................................................... 44 A. Changes Ordered by Owner ..................................................................................................... 44 B. Change of Sub-Surface Conditions........................................................................................... 45 C. Adjustment of Contract ............................................................................................................. 45 D. Value of Extra Work.............................................................................................................. 45 E. Award of Extra Work to Other Contractors ....................................................................... 46 20.08 Claims for Extra Cost......................................................................................................... 46 20.09 Cleaning up at Completion of Work ..................................................................................47 20.10 Use of Completed Portions of Work ..................................................................................47 20.11 Substantial Completion and its Effect .............................................................................. 48 20.12 Period of Making Good of Known Defects or Faults ....................................................... 49 20.13 Making Good of Known Defects or Faults ....................................................................... 49 20.14 Special Test and Inspection .............................................................................................. 49 20.15 Acceptance of Non-Conforming Work ............................................................................. 49 20.16 Adjustment of Prices ......................................................................................................... 50 20.17 Payment in Legal Tender ................................................................................................... 51 Article 21 Time of Completion of Work ........................................................... 51 21.01 Notice to Proceed, When Required ................................................................................... 51 21.02 Completion Time ................................................................................................................ 51 21.03 Schedule of Construction Work ......................................................................................... 51 21.04 Extension of Time ...............................................................................................................52 21.05 Delay in Completion of the Work ......................................................................................53 Article 22 22.01 Payments ...................................................................................... 54 Breakdown of Contract Amount ....................................................................................... 54 15 22.02 Requests for Payment........................................................................................................ 54 22.03 Authorized Deductions from Value of Completed Work ................................................ 54 22.04 Conditions Relative to Payments .......................................................................................55 22.05 Owner's Action on Requests for Payment .........................................................................55 22.06 Payment of Unpaid Labor, Sub-Contractors and Suppliers.............................................55 22.07 Payments Over Ninety Percent (90%)...............................................................................55 22.08 Other Requirements Before Final Payment ..................................................................... 56 22.09 Acceptance and Final Payment ......................................................................................... 56 22.10 Corrections of Work Before or After Final Payment ........................................................ 57 22.11 Release of Retention .......................................................................................................... 58 Section VII Contractor—Separate Contractors—Sub-Contractors Relations...... 58 Article 23 Separate Contracts with Other Contractors .................................... 58 Article 24 Contractor and Separate Contractors Relations ............................. 58 24.01 Storage of Materials and Work Coordination .................................................................. 58 24.02 Cutting, Patching and Digging .......................................................................................... 58 24.03 Defective Work by Separate Contractors ......................................................................... 59 24.04 Damage Caused by Contractor to Separate Contractors ................................................. 59 24.05 Damage Caused by Separate Contractors to Contractor ...................................... 59 Article 25 Sub-Contracts ............................................................................... 59 25.01 General ............................................................................................................................... 59 25.02 Contractor's Responsibility ............................................................................................... 60 Section VIII Suspension of Work and Termination of Contract .......................... 60 Article 26 Contractor's Right to Suspend Work or Terminate Contract ........... 60 Article 27 Owner's Right to Suspend the Work............................................... 61 27.01 Suspension Without Cause ................................................................................................ 61 27.02 Just Causes for Suspension of Work ................................................................................. 61 Article 28 Owner's Right to Terminate Contract ............................................. 62 28.01 Termination with Cause .................................................................................................... 62 28.02 Other Grounds for Termination with Cause .................................................................... 62 28.03 Termination Without Cause.............................................................................................. 63 16 Article 29 Owner's Right to Proceed with the Work after Reduction in the Contractor's Scope of Work; Partial Takeover from Contractor ......................... 63 29.01 Owner's Right to Carry Out the Work .............................................................................. 63 29.02 Use of Materials and Equipment at Site ........................................................................... 64 29.03 Owner to Complete Work.................................................................................................. 64 29.04 Evaluation of Cost of Work ............................................................................................... 64 29.05 Owner's Right to Recover Damages ................................................................................. 65 29.06 Liquidated Damages .......................................................................................................... 65 Section IX Article 30 Responsibilities and Liabilities of Contractor and of Owner ........... 66 Contractor's Responsibility for Accidents and Damages ................. 66 30.01 Safeguards to be Undertaken by Contractor .................................................................... 66 30.02 Owner Not to be Responsible ........................................................................................... 66 30.03 Contractor's Default ...........................................................................................................67 Article 31 Contractor's Insurance and Bonds ................................................. 67 31.01 Contractor's Liability Insurance ........................................................................................67 31.02 Accident Insurance for Workers ........................................................................................67 31.03 Contractor's Fire Insurance ...............................................................................................67 31.04 Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds ............................................................... 68 31.05 Contractor’s Guarantee Bond ........................................................................................... 68 31.06 Contractor’s Guarantee-Warranty .................................................................................... 68 31.07 Mandatory Conditions of Bonds ....................................................................................... 69 Article 32 Owner’s Responsibilities and Liabilities......................................... 70 32.01 Advance Payment .............................................................................................................. 70 32.02 Protection of Employees and Professionals Performing Services for the Owner ...... 70 32.03 Owner's Optional Insurance ............................................................................................. 70 32.04 Additional Information and Services Required of the Owner ........................................ 70 Article 33 Liens, Disputes and Arbitration ..................................................... 70 33.01 Liens ................................................................................................................................... 70 33.02 Assignment ......................................................................................................................... 71 33.03 Subcontracting .................................................................................................................... 71 17 33.04 Disputes...............................................................................................................................72 33.05 Settlement of Disputes .......................................................................................................72 Section X Owner's Representative ................................................................. 73 Section XI Schedule of Time Limits ................................................................ 75 APPENDIX……………………………………………………………………………………………………..79 18 SCOPE This document specifies general conditions of contract between a private Owner and Contractor applicable for the construction of any type of structure or works as contemplated in the Republic Act No. 4566 otherwise known as Contractors’ License Law. Section I Definitions and Documents Article 1 Definitions For the purposes of this document, the following definitions apply: 1.01 act of God or force majeure shall mean any event beyond the reasonable control of the Owner or the Contractor, as the case may be, and which is unavoidable notwithstanding the reasonable care of the party affected and shall include, without limitation, the following: (a) war, hostilities or warlike operations (whether a state of war be declared or not), invasion, act of foreign enemy, civil war; (b) rebellion, revolution, insurrection, mutiny, usurpation of civil or military government, conspiracy, riot, civil commotion, terrorist acts; (c) confiscation, nationalization, mobilization, commandeering or requisition by or under the order of any government or de jure or de facto authority or ruler or any other act or failure to act of any local or state or national government authority; (d) strike, sabotage, lock-out, embargo, import restriction, port congestion, lack of usual means of public transportation and communication, industrial dispute, shipwreck, shortage or restriction of power supply, epidemics, quarantine, plague; (e) earthquake, landslide, volcanic activity, fire, flood, inundation, tidal wave, typhoon or cyclone, hurricane, storm, lightning, or other inclement weather condition, nuclear and pressure waves, or other natural or physical disaster; (f) shortage of labor, materials or utilities where caused by circumstances that are themselves force majeure. 1.02 advance payment/ down payment the money given by the Owner to the Contractor to help the latter underwrite significant start up or procurement costs that may have to be incurred before construction begins 19 1.03 Agreement the term used to describe the agreement signed by the Owner and the Contractor excluding the Contract Documents which are attached thereto 1.04 As-Built Drawings drawings showing the structure as actually constructed including system and actual locations of outlets, fixtures, services and equipment that were installed 1.05 bid the tender, proposal, quotation, or offer of a bidder to perform the Work described in the Contract which in form and substance complies with the Instruction to Bidders 1.06 bid bond any acceptable form of bond accompanying the Bid submitted by the bidder as a guarantee that the bidder will enter into the Contract with the Owner for the construction of the Work, if the Contract is awarded to him 1.07 Bid Bulletin a document containing additional information on Bid Documents issued to bidders before date of bidding 1.08 Bid Documents collectively refer to all documents provided or made available to prospective bidders which include the Invitation to Bid, drawings and technical specifications and a copy of the Contract which the winning bidders would be required to sign with the Owner 1.09 Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value a listing of the different parts of the Work indicating each part and its corresponding value 1.10 change order a written order to the Contractor issued by the Owner after the execution of the Contract, authorizing a change or variation in the Work or an adjustment in the Contract Price or Contract Time 20 1.11 Completion time limit period of time allowed by the Contract for the completion of the project or any stipulated portions thereof 1.12 Contract the term used to describe the Agreement and the Contract Documents 1.13 Contract Documents documents attached to the Agreement identified therein as Contract Documents, including all additions, deletions and modifications incorporated therein. These generally include the following documents which shall form part of this Contract and constitute integral parts hereof: (a) Special Provisions or Conditions; (b) General Conditions; (c) Specifications; (d) Drawings; (e) Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof; (f) Contractor’s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof; and (g) other Bid Documents 1.14 Contractor the person or firm duly registered and licensed by the Philippine Contractors Accreditation Board whose proposal has been accepted and to whom the Contract to execute the Work was awarded 1.15 Contract Price the amount in money, or other consideration, to be paid by the Owner to the Contractor for the execution of the Work in accordance with the Contract 1.16 cost all expenditures properly incurred or to be incurred, whether on or off the site, including overhead and other charges properly allocable thereto but does not include any allowance for profit 21 1.17 Drawings graphical presentations of the Work that include all supplementary details and shop drawings 1.18 Final payment the payment of the final progress billing and all approved claims including but not limited to variations in the work, Contract Price adjustments and/or escalation, acceleration of work, and others. NOTE: final payment does not include the retention money 1.19 Guarantee Bond approved form of security furnished by the Contractor and its Surety as a guarantee of the quality of the materials provided, the equipment installed, and the workmanship performed by the Contractor 1.20 Instruction to Bidders the list of instructions regarding the manner bids are to be prepared and the conditions for the award of the Contract 1.21 Invitation to Bid the notice or advertisement published by the Owner or the invitation issued to prospective bidders, giving information as to the nature of the proposed project, conditions for the issuance of Contract documents, date of bidding, and information that would give the Contractor a general idea of the magnitude and extent of the project 1.22 last known address of a party refers to the address in the Philippines given by a party in the Contract 1.23 Laws all laws, ordinances and other governmental rules and regulations applicable to the project and to its execution 1.24 Owner person or entity, or authorized representative thereof, who signed the Contract as Owner 22 1.25 Owner's Representative the person or entity commissioned by the Owner, or authorized in writing by the Owner, to act on its behalf 1.26 Payment Bond approved form of security furnished by the Contractor and its Surety as a guarantee of good faith on the part of the Contractor to faithfully comply with the Contract in respect of its obligations arising therefrom to its workers, Sub-Contractors, and suppliers 1.27 Performance Bond approved form of security furnished by the Contractor and its Surety as a guarantee of good faith on the part of the Contractor to execute the Work in accordance with the Contract 1.28 retention sum of money, usually 10% or less of every progress payment to a Contractor which the Owner retains to underwrite future costs of completing the Contractor’s work and/or remedying the defects therein 1.29 Schedule of Materials and Finishes an outline specification enumerating the type or brand names of materials required to be used by the Contractor for the Work 1.30 Special Provisions or Conditions instructions issued prior to bidding to supplement and/or modify the Drawings, Specifications and/or General Conditions of the Contract 1.31 Specifications written or printed description of the Work to be done describing qualities of the material to be used, the equipment to be installed and the mode of construction 1.32 Sub-Contractor a Contractor duly registered and licensed by the Philippine Contractors Accreditation Board having a direct contract with the Contractor and who acts for or in behalf of the Contractor in executing any part of the Contract 23 NOTE: one who furnishes materials without labor is a supplier and not a Sub-Contractor 1.33 Supplementary Specifications additional information which may be issued as an addition to or amendment of the provisions of the Specifications 1.34 Surety person, firm, or corporation which issues the bond required of the Contractor 1.35 Work shall refer to all the Contractor-provided labor or materials or both, as well as equipment transportation or other facilities necessary to commence and complete the construction and to fulfill all its obligations which are called for in the Contract 1.36 written notice information, advice, or notification pertinent to the project delivered in person or sent by registered mail to an individual, firm or corporation at the latter's last known business address Article 2 Execution, Correlation, Meaning of Terms, and Intent of Documents 2.01 Intent of Contract The intent of the Contract is to include all labor and materials, equipment, and transportation necessary for the proper execution of the Work. 2.02 Standard of Conduct Each party to the Contract acknowledges that, in the exercise of each party’s rights and in the performance of his duties, each must act with justice, give the other party its due, and observe honesty and good faith. 2. 03 Interpretation of Contract (a) In case of conflict between the provisions of the Agreement or of any Contract Document, or between the provisions of one of the Contract Documents and the provisions of another Contract Document, or in case of discrepancy, defective description, error or omission in the Contract, the following rules shall be followed: 24 RULE 1: The Agreement and the Contract Documents shall be taken as mutually explanatory of one another. The various provisions of the Contract shall be interpreted together, attributing to the doubtful ones that sense which may result from all of them taken jointly. RULE 2: The provisions of the Civil Code of the Philippines on the interpretation of contracts and of the Rules of Court on the Interpretation of Documents shall be applied. RULE 3: Where the conflict between or among the provisions of the Agreement and/or the Contract Documents cannot be resolved by Rules 1 and 2, it shall be understood that: (a) the Detailed Drawings shall prevail over the General Drawings; (b) words and figures shall prevail over the Drawings; (c) words shall prevail over figures in Contract Documents; and (d) written dimensions shall prevail over measured dimensions. RULE 4: Where the conflict cannot be resolved by applying Rule 3 or where Rule 3 does not apply, the conflict shall be resolved by giving precedence to the Agreement or to provisions of a Contract Document higher in order of priority among the various documents which comprise the Contract. The order of priority among these documents shall be as follows: (a) Agreement as modified by Notice of Award of Contract, if such be the case, and the Contractor’s conformity thereto; (b) Instruction to Bidders and any amendment thereto; (c) Addenda to Bid Documents; (d) Specifications; (e) Special Conditions of Contract; (f) General Conditions of Contract; (g) Drawings; (h) Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof; (i) Contractor’s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof; (j) Other Contract Documents; and 25 (k) Other documents forming part of the Contract attached thereto or incorporated therein by reference. Where the order of precedence is modified in the Agreement, such modified order of precedence shall be followed; however, the mere listing of Contract Documents in the Agreement or any Contract Document shall not be interpreted as establishing an order of precedence among them. RULE 5: Where there is discrepancy, defective description, error or omission in any Contract Document, the Contract Documents shall be interpreted as being complementary to each other. Thus, what is called for in one Contract Document, although not mentioned in another Contract Document where it should have been mentioned, shall be deemed to be called for by the Contract. RULE 6: The apparent silence of the Drawings, Specifications or any other Contract Document as to any detail, or the lack of detailed description concerning any part of the work, shall be understood to mean that good and accepted construction practice in accordance with the usage or custom of the place shall be followed. RULE 7: Rules 1 to 6 shall yield to specific rules of interpretation in this document or in the Contract. (b) The Owner shall resolve the conflict, or interpret or explain such discrepancy, defective description, error or omission with due regard to Article 2.04. (c) The interpretation of or explanation by the Owner shall be issued in the form of instructions to the Contractor. Where the Owner fails to issue the instructions in writing, the execution of that part of work affected by the interpretation or explanation without a timely objection or protest of the Owner shall be deemed to have been executed in accordance with the Owner's explanation or interpretation. (d) In all cases where a device, item, or part of equipment is referred to in the singular number, it is intended that such reference shall apply to as many such devices, items, or parts as are required to complete the work. 2.04 Conformity to the Contract The Work shall be executed in accordance with the Contract. 26 (a) If there be a variance between the Drawings and the Specifications, the provisions of the Specifications shall prevail. In case of conflict between the General Conditions or any modification thereof and the detailed specification requirements, the detailed specification requirements shall prevail. (b) Any discrepancy found between the Drawings and Specifications and site conditions or any error or omission in the Drawings or Specifications shall be immediately reported to the Owner, who shall promptly correct such discrepancy, error, or omission. Any work involving such discrepancies shall be estimated by the Contractor and unit prices or lump sum amounts shall be agreed upon by the parties whenever possible before the work is done. Any work done by the Contractor involving discrepancies found by the Contractor and not reported to and without the knowledge of the Owner shall be considered as having been done at the Contractor's risk. (c) The Owner shall be fully responsible for adequacy of the design and for sufficiency of the Drawings and Specifications. The complete requirements of the Work shall be set forth in Drawings and Specifications to be supplied by the Owner. (d) In the event that any part or whole of the Works, when agreed upon, are designed by the Contractor, then all responsibilities assigned to the Owner for the said design shall automatically be assigned to the Contractor as its responsibility. 2.05 Meaning of Terms (a) The words approved, directed and acceptable, or words of like import shall mean approved by, directed by, or acceptable to the Owner. (b) The word furnish shall be understood to mean to purchase and/or fabricate and deliver to the jobsite or other location when so designated. (c) The word install shall mean to build in, mount in positions, connect or apply any object specified ready for the intended use. (d) The word provide shall be understood to mean to furnish and install. (e) The words required or necessary shall mean as required or necessary for the complete execution of that portion of the Work. 2.06 Timely Exercise of Administrative Responsibilities Whenever under the Contract, the Owner shall exercise its discretion fairly and in a timely manner taking due regard of Completion Time and the approved construction schedule notwithstanding any provision in the Contract requiring the Contractor to notify the Owner when such action is due or when such equipment or materials are due. The Owner shall exercise such discretion by: 27 (a) giving decision, opinion or consent; (b) expressing satisfaction and approval; (c) determining value; (d) providing drawings; (e) supplying equipment or materials, or; (f) otherwise taking action which may affect the Contractor's timely completion of the Work Whenever in the Contract, the Contractor shall give notice, submit data, catalogs, samples, order or import materials or equipment, prepare and submit the construction schedule or notify the Owner that a change has been ordered or an event causing a change has occurred or been discovered. The Contractor shall do so in a timely manner so as to avoid any delay in the completion of the Work. Whenever the Contract or accepted industry practice requires that before any part of the Work is covered, it must be inspected and approved, the Owner shall provide a sufficient number of inspectors at the project site while work is in progress. The failure of the Owner to provide such inspectors shall be understood as a waiver of the Owner to inspect and approve that part of the Work. 2.07 Defective Equipment, Materials, or Work Whenever the Contract or the General Conditions provide that the Owner may require the Contractor to remove or replace defective or inferior materials or equipment or to replace bad or defective work, the Owner, if represented by a professional duly authorized to supervise the Contractor’s work and to exercise the discretion and authority of the Owner, shall condemn such materials, equipment or work in order to minimize the damage or loss of the Contractor. However, where even with the exercise of due diligence, the Owner could not have discovered the use of inferior materials and equipment or the defective work, the Owner may condemn it upon discovery, and the Contractor shall bear all the cost of removing and replacing the defective or inferior material or equipment or the defective work. 2.08 Review of Contract The Contractor shall carefully study and compare the various documents that comprise the Contract and shall report to the Owner any error, inconsistency or omission that may be discovered in its provisions. The Contractor, however, shall not be liable to the Owner for any damage resulting from any such error, inconsistency or omission in the Contract. The Contractor shall follow the Drawings and Specification and all additional detail drawings and 28 instruction issued by the Owner as being in full and strict conformity with the Contract and the requirements of the Work. Except for shop drawings, product data and samples for any portion of the work provided or supplied by a specialty contractor, the Owner's approval thereof shall be construed as the Owner's acknowledgement that the approved shop drawings, product data and sample comply with the Contract. The Contractor shall not be liable to the Owner for undetected error, inconsistency or omission in the Contract or for complying with instructions or following Drawings or Specifications, or for using or following the approved shop drawings, product data or sample. 2.09 Documents and Samples at the Site The Contractor shall maintain in good order at the project site on a current basis one record copy of all Drawings, Specifications, addenda, Change Orders and other modifications, and changes made during construction, including approved shop drawings, product data and samples. These documents and samples shall be available to the Owner for the latter's inspection. The Contractor shall advise the Owner, on a current basis and in writing, of changes in the Work made during construction, except those made in accordance with Change Orders or Owner's instruction. 2.10 Ownership of Contract and Models The Drawings, Specifications and models, including all additional instructions and copies thereof, furnished to the Contractor shall remain the property of the Owner. They are not to be used by the Contractor on any other work, and, with the exception of the signed Contract inclusive of Contract Documents, they shall be returned to the Owner upon completion of the Work before Final Payment to the Contractor is made. Article 3 3.01 Drawings and Specifications Copies of Drawings and Specifications The Owner shall furnish the Contractor, free of charge, three sets of Drawings and Specifications inclusive of the signed Contract. All other copies of Drawings and Specifications as required by the Contractor shall be furnished to it at cost of reproduction. 3.02 Coordination of Drawings and Specifications All Drawings and models are to be read and understood together with the Specifications, to form a part thereof. Where figures are given, these are to be followed in preference to measurements by scale. Anything shown on the Drawings but not mentioned in the 29 Specifications, or vice versa, or anything not expressly set forth in either, but which is reasonably implied, shall be furnished as if specifically shown and mentioned in both. 3.03 Clarification of Meaning of Drawings and Specifications The Owner shall provide the Contractor directions and explanations necessary and proper to make more definite and certain any requirement of the Drawings (including notes thereon) or of the provisions of the Specifications. Upon request of the Contractor, the Owner shall explain: (a) the meaning of the Drawings, (including notes thereon) or of the Specifications; and/or (b) any obscurity as to the wording of the Specifications. 3.04 Discrepancy in Drawings The Contractor shall report to the Owner any discrepancy in the figures in the drawings immediately upon discovery. The Owner shall make the necessary correction. The Contractor shall not be entitled to an adjustment of its Contract Price and Completion Time should its work be ordered re-done if such work was made without notifying the Owner of the discovery of the discrepancy and before the Owner makes the necessary correction. Article 4 4.01 Detail Drawings and Instructions Supplementary Drawings and Instructions The Owner shall furnish additional detail drawings and instructions essential to proper interpretation and proper execution of the Work. All such additional drawings and instructions are to be considered of equal force as those which originally accompany the Specifications. Article 5 5.01 Shop Drawings Conditions in the Preparation of Shop Drawings The Contractor shall prepare, at its own expense, and submit two copies of all shop or setting drawings, templates, patterns and models and the Owner shall pass upon them making desired corrections, if any. The Contractor shall make the corrections in the shop drawings required by the Owner and file with the latter three (3) corrected copies thereof. 30 5.02 Identification Shop drawings, which shall be numbered consecutively, shall represent: (a) all working and erection dimensions; (b) arrangement and sectional views; (c) necessary details, including complete information for making connections with other work; (d) kinds of materials and finishes. Shop drawings shall contain the following: (a) date of approval by the Owner; (b) name of project; (c) descriptive names of equipment, materials, and classified item numbers; and (d) location at which materials or equipment are to be installed in the Work. 5.03 Letter of Transmittal Submission of shop drawings shall be accompanied by a letter of transmittal in duplicate, containing the name of the project, the Contractor’s name, reference drawing number, titles, and other pertinent data. 5.04 Corrections, Changes and Variations The Contractor shall submit three sets of prints of shop drawings to the Owner for approval. Satisfactory shop drawings will be so identified by the Owner, dated, and one copy thereof returned to the Contractor. Should shop drawings be disapproved by the Owner, one set of such shop drawings shall be returned to the Contractor indicating therein the corrections and changes to be made. (a) The Contractor shall make the required corrections and changes and resubmit the shop drawings, in duplicate, until the Owner's approval is obtained. (b) Upon receipt of such approval, the Contractor shall insert the date of approval on the tracings and promptly furnish the Owner with three additional prints of approved drawings. (c) No work called for by the shop drawings shall be executed by the Contractor until the Owner's approval is given. 31 (d) Should the shop drawings show variations from the Contract requirements because of standard shop practice or other reasons, the Contractor shall make specific mention of such variations in its letter of submittal. 5.05 Responsibility for Accuracy Should the Contractor be a specialty contractor or be engaged by the Owner as a specialty contractor, the Owner's approval of shop drawings shall be general. It shall not relieve the Contractor of responsibility for accuracy of such shop drawings, nor for proper fitting and construction of work, nor for furnishing of materials or work required by the Contract and not indicated on the shop drawings. The Owner’s approval of such drawings or schedule shall not relieve the specialty contractor from responsibility for deviations from the Drawings or Specifications, unless the Contractor has, in writing, called the Owner’s attention to such deviations at the time of submission and secured the Owner’s written approval. 5.06 Owner’s Approval Unless specified to the contrary or unless the Contractor’s submission is deficient, shop drawing approval by the Owner shall be made within seven (7) working days of submission by the Contractor. Section II Laws, Regulations, Site Conditions, Permits and Taxes Article 6 Laws and Site Conditions 6.01 Laws and Regulations In general, the Contractor shall comply with all Laws in so far as they are binding upon or affect the parties thereto, or the Work. The Contractor shall also comply with regulations of firms furnishing utilities such as water, gas, telephone and electricity for the project. Should the Contractor perform any work contrary to such Laws or utilities’ regulations, it shall bear all additional costs arising therefrom. 6.02 Site Conditions Before the bidding and the awarding of the Contract, the Contractor is expected to have visited the project site and made its own estimate of the facilities required in and difficulties attending the execution of the Work, on account of local conditions and all other contingencies. The Owner shall, however, furnish the Contractor a geodetic survey and sub-surface exploration which the Contractor may rely upon in the preparation of its Bid. 32 Article 7 7.01 Permits, Taxes and Surveys Permits and Licenses The Owner, with the Contractor’s assistance, shall secure and pay all construction permits and licenses necessary for the execution of the Work or of any temporary work and easements in relation thereto. The Contractor shall secure the final occupancy permit but it shall not be responsible to the Owner if, without its fault, the license is not issued or there was delay in issuance. 7.02 Taxes Wherever the law of the place where the project is located requires sales, consumer use, or other similar tax related or pertinent only to the construction of the project, the Contractor shall pay such tax. 7.03 Construction Stakes and Reference Mark The Owner shall furnish all surveys describing the physical characteristics, legal limitations, and utility locations of the site. It shall also furnish rights-of-way for access to the site. The Owner shall be responsible for the establishment of lot lines, boundary lines, easements and benchmarks which shall be made by a certified surveyor. The Owner may request the Contractor to verify before the start of the construction the result of such surveys, provided the Owner shall pay for the cost of such verification. The Owner shall also pay for any damage or cost to the Contractor brought about by errors in data furnished. All other grade, lines, levels, and benchmarks necessary for the prosecution of the Work shall be established and maintained by the Contractor. The Contractor shall provide and maintain well-built batter boards at all corners. It shall establish benchmarks in not less than two widely separated places. As work progresses, the Contractor shall establish benchmarks at each floor giving exact levels of various floors, and shall lay-out the exact locations of all partitions as a guide to all trades. 7.04 Services of Geodetic Engineer The Contractor shall, at its option or when so required under the Contract, engage the services of a licensed Geodetic Engineer to confirm and certify the location of column centers, piers, walls, pits, trenches, pipe work, utility lines and work of a similar nature. 33 The Geodetic Engineer shall also verify and certify the lines and levels of any part of the Work at any time if so required by the Owner. The certification shall be provided to the Owner and the Contractor. If the Geodetic Engineer finds any deviation from the Drawings in the Work of the Contractor, he/she shall report his/her findings to the Owner within 24 hours from discovery. The Contractor shall be responsible for loss or damage caused by the act or omission of the Geodetic Engineer. However, without exempting the Contractor from liability, but in mitigation of it, the Geodetic Engineer's certification shall be regarded as an independent and disinterested verification of such lay-out. Section III Equipment and Materials Article 8 General All materials and equipment must conform to all Laws now or which may be in force and applicable during the period of construction. The Contractor shall bear all damages by reason of any delay in the Work arising from its failure to comply with this provision. Where any revision or amendment to such Laws is made during the construction period which affects the cost or time of completion of the Contract, a constructive change in the Work shall be recognized and a corresponding Contract Price and Completion Time adjustment shall be made. Article 9 9.01 Equipment Quality of Equipment In order to establish standards of quality, the Owner, in the detailed Specifications may have referred to certain equipment by name and catalog number. This procedure is not to be construed as eliminating from competition other products of equal or better quality by other manufacturers where they are fully suitable in design. 9.02 Equipment Substitution The Contractor shall furnish the complete list of proposed substitutions preferably prior to the signing of the Contract together with such engineering and catalog data as the Owner may require. All requests for substitution of equipment shall be in writing. The Owner will approve or disapprove the request in writing. No substitute equipment shall be used unless approved 34 in writing by the Owner. The Contractor shall abide by the Owner’s judgment as to which proposed substitute items of equipment are judged to be acceptable. Article 10 Materials, Fixtures, Appliances, and Fittings Furnished by the Contractor 10.01 Samples of Materials (a) Unless otherwise specified, three samples shall be submitted, of adequate size to show quality, type, color, range, finish, and texture of material. (b) Each sample shall be labelled, bearing the material’s name and quality, the Contractor’s name, date, project name, and other pertinent data. (c) Where the Specifications require the manufacturer’s printed installation directions, such directions shall accompany the samples submitted for approval. (d) A letter of transmittal in triplicate from the Contractor requesting approval shall accompany all sets of samples. (e) Materials requiring prior approval of the Owner shall not be ordered until such approval in writing is given by the Owner. All materials shall be furnished substantially equal in every respect as the approved samples. 10.02 Brand Name Materials and Substitutes (a) Whenever an item or class of materials is specified exclusively by brand name, manufacturer’s name or catalog reference, only such item shall be used except as provided in paragraph (b) hereof. (b) No substitution shall be made of any material, article, or process required under the Contract unless the substitution is approved in writing by the Owner. (c) The Contractor shall be responsible for materials and articles installed or used without such approval. (d) Samples of materials for use, in reinforced concrete work such as steel bars, cement, and aggregates and their certificates of origin shall be approved by the Owner. 10.03 Testing Samples of Materials The Contractor shall submit to the Owner as many samples as may be needed for purposes of testing. Testing of all samples shall comply with the Specifications and government standards and shall be performed by a competent entity or testing laboratory approved by the Owner. All costs of shipment, delivery, handling, and testing of Contractor-supplied samples are to be paid by the Contractor. 35 10.04 Quality of Materials Unless otherwise specified, all materials shall be new, and their quality shall be of the best grade of their respective kinds taking into account the nature of the project and requirements of the Contract. 10.05 Storage and Stockpiling of Materials (a) The Owner shall provide the Contractor, at or near the project site, sufficient space for the Contractor’s and Sub-Contractors’ use for storage of materials and for erection of sheds and tool houses. (b) All materials affected by moisture (e.g. cement, steel, wood, etc.) shall be stored on platforms and protected from the weather. The materials shall be so stored as to ensure the preservation of their quality and fitness for the Work. Stored materials shall be located so as to facilitate prompt inspection. (c) Should it be necessary at any time to move materials, sheds, or storage platforms, the Contractor shall do so at its own expense. 10.06 Defective Materials All materials different from the Specifications shall be considered non-conforming to the minimum requirements. The Contractor shall remove or replace materials different from the Specifications when ordered to do so by the Owner. Upon the Contractor’s failure to do so, the Owner may remove and replace them and deduct the cost of removal and replacement from any money due or to become due the Contractor. No materials, the defects of which have been subsequently corrected, shall be used until the Owner’s approval is given. Should the Specifications, Drawings, Special Provisions and Supplementary Specifications fail to provide any detail or description concerning the nature and quality of the Work to be performed, it should be understood that generally accepted construction practice shall be followed. 10.07 Imported Materials, Fixtures and Equipment The Contractor, taking into consideration the Completion Time, shall make timely arrangements for the purchase and delivery of all specified imported materials, fixtures, appliances and equipment in order to avoid delay in the completion of the Work. No extension of time shall be allowed if, due to negligence or inadvertence of the Contractor, such imported items arrive late. 36 10.08 Owner’s Approval Unless specified to the contrary or unless the Contractor’s submission is deficient, equipment, samples or materials submissions shall be acted upon by the Owner within seven (7) working days of submission by the Contractor. Article 11 Materials, Equipment, Fixtures, Appliances and Fittings Furnished by the Owner Materials, equipment, fixtures, appliances and fittings specifically indicated in the Contract shall be provided in accordance with the Owner-approved construction schedule. Materials furnished by the Owner shall be deemed acceptable for the purpose intended. The Contractor may continue to use them until otherwise directed in writing by the Owner. No further test shall be required unless the Owner directs otherwise and pays the cost of such test. Should the Contractor discover any defect in materials furnished by the Owner, the Contractor shall advise the Owner in writing. The Contractor shall be responsible for material loss of or damage to any Owner-provided material, equipment, fixture, appliance or fitting in its custody. Unused, Owner-supplied materials, equipment, fixtures, appliances and fittings, the cost of which was not charged to the Contractor and did not form part of the Contract Price, shall belong to the Owner which shall be returned to the Owner by the Contractor upon completion of the Work. Those the cost of which was charged to the Contractor and deducted from its Contract Price shall belong to the Contractor. Article 12 Royalties and Patents The Contractor shall pay all royalties and license fees on all patented materials and processes it furnished. It shall defend all suits or claims corresponding thereto for infringement of any patent rights and shall save the Owner harmless from loss on account thereof. Article 13 Manufacturer’s Directions All manufactured articles, materials, equipment, appliances, fixtures and fittings supplied by the Contractor shall be applied, installed, connected, erected, used, cleaned, and conditioned by the Contractor, in accordance with the manufacturer’s printed directions. Where reference is made to the manufacturer’s directions, the Contractor shall submit the specified number of copies of such directions to the Owner. 37 Section IV Premises and Temporary Structures Article 14 Use of Premises 14.01 Limitation of Use The Contractor shall confine its apparatus, the storage of materials, and the operations of its workers to limits indicated by Law or directions of the Owner and shall not unreasonably encumber the work premises with its materials. 14.02 Safeguard for Structure The Contractor shall not load or permit any part of the structure to be loaded with a weight that will endanger its safety. The Contractor shall enforce the Owner’s safety instructions regarding signs, advertisements, fires and smoking, and any other factors that may cause endangerment to safety. Article 15 Temporary Structures and Facilities 15.01 Temporary Office and Contractor’s Building The Contractor shall at all times, taking into account the location and size of the site, provide and maintain an adequate weather tight temporary office with necessary basic facilities such as water, light, and telephone. When practicable or depending upon the nature and complexity of the project, the Owner may require the Contractor to comply with other requirements for temporary structures and facilities as provided for in the Contract. 15.02 Temporary Housing for Workers The temporary buildings for housing workers, or the erection of tents or other forms of protection shall be at such places the Owner has designated; provided, however, that if no particular area is designated, the Contractor may use its own discretion in determining such areas in consultation with the Owner. The sanitary condition of the grounds in or about such structures at the project site shall at all times be maintained by the Contractor in a manner satisfactory to the Owner. Sleeping and/or cooking shall not be allowed within the building line of the project under construction. 15.03 Safety and Sanitation The Contractor, from the commencement of the Work up to completion, shall: 38 (a) furnish and put up all temporary barricades and guard lights necessary for the protection, proper prosecution and completion of the Work; (b) maintain guard lights at the top of the following, but not limited to, falsework tower, barricades, railings; (c) provide and maintain sufficient sanitary toilet accommodation and other necessary conveniences including, but not limited to, water connections for the use of personnel and laborers on the work properly secluded from public observation in such manner and at such points as shall be approved by the Owner, use shall be strictly enforced; (d) keep such places clean and free from pests; and (e) remove all connections and appliances connected therewith prior to the completion of the Work. 15.04 Temporary Signs Signs or advertisements shall only be displayed upon the approval of the Owner. The Contractor may erect one painted sign indicating the names and addresses of the Owner, the Contractor, and the various Sub-Contractors. The Owner shall approve the size, color, lettering, and location of such temporary signs. 15.05 Temporary or Trial Usage Temporary or trial usage by the Owner of any mechanical device, machinery, apparatus, equipment, or any work or materials supplied by the Contractor before final completion and written acceptance by the Owner shall not be construed that the Owner has accepted it. Such test run shall be made by the Owner for such reasonable length of time, as the Owner shall deem necessary. The Owner shall not be liable for injury to or breaking of any part of such work which may be caused by weakness or inaccuracy of structural parts, defective materials, or workmanship. The Contractor may, at its own expense, make such trial usage with prior notice to and for the benefit of the Owner. 39 Section V Protection of Work and Property Article 16 Protection of Work and Owner’s Property 16.01 Safeguard Measures The Contractor shall: (a) take all reasonable measures to protect from damage: (i) the Works; (ii) the Owner's property, and; (iii)the equipment, materials, appliances and fixtures supplied or paid for by the Owner and shall make good any damage, injury or loss thereto, except such as may be caused by agents or employees of the Owner, or due to causes considered as Acts of God; (b) provide reliable and competent security personnel to guard the site and premises, provide all doorways with locks under the Contractor’s control and lock such doors at the close of each day's work; provided, however, that if the Owner deems the security service inadequate or incompetent, the Contractor shall increase or change the security personnel; (c) prohibit smoking at the site and post signs to this effect at conspicuous places; (d) prohibit fires built on the site except by expressed consent of the Owner; and (e) provide and maintain in good working order an adequate number of fire-fighting equipment and such equipment shall not be used for any other purpose. 16.02 Old Materials All old materials of value as determined through a joint inventory by the Owner and the Contactor found at the work site shall be carefully stored at the place designated by the Owner; and the Contractor shall be responsible for safekeeping until final acceptance of the Work. 16.03 Trees and Other Plants Existing vegetation such as but not limited to trees, plants, and shrubs, identified by the Owner to remain at site shall be boxed and otherwise protected from damage within the site located outside building lines shall not be cut or removed without written approval from the Owner and appropriate authorities. 40 (a) When specifically included in the Contractor's scope of work, all trees and other plants that need to be transplanted elsewhere shall be done by the Contractor in accordance with instructions of the Owner. (b) Any damage to the abovementioned vegetation, streets, and sidewalks, resulting from fault or negligence of the Contractor in connection with the execution of the Work shall be made good and/or replaced or repaired by the Contractor at its own expense. 16.04 Drainage The natural flows of rivers or streams shall not be interrupted or obstructed unless necessary in the prosecution of the Work, and provided that the Contractor shall do so in such a way that no damage shall result to either public or private interests. The Contractor shall be liable for all damages which may result from its neglect to provide other means of drainage for any existing natural or artificial drainage which it obstructed and/or interrupted. Article 17 Protection of Adjacent Property and Existing Utilities 17.01 Contractor's Responsibility The Contractor shall adequately protect adjacent property as provided by Law and the Contract. Any neighboring property or building which may be jeopardized in any manner must be thoroughly and substantially protected against damage during construction at the Contractor’s expense. 17.02 Damages to Adjacent Utilities The Contractor shall be liable for and pay for all damages to adjacent and existing utilities occasioned in any manner by its act or neglect, or by that of its agents, employees, or workers. 17.03 Condition Survey Prior to commencement of the Works, the Contractor shall, insofar as is legally and physically possible, survey and ascertain the condition of any existing adjacent properties or buildings and record the results thereof through photographic record or by any other means. 41 Article 18 Authorization to Contractor for the Protection of Life, Work and Property During an Emergency In an emergency endangering life, the Work or the adjoining property, the Contractor, even without special instruction or authorization from the Owner, shall act, at its discretion, to prevent or minimize such threatened loss or injury. Emergency work performed by the Contractor shall be treated as one performed under a Change Order unless the emergency was caused or brought about by its fault or negligence. Section VI Labor, Work and Payments Article 19 Labor The Contractor shall employ only competent and duly qualified professionals, technical personnel, foremen, and construction workers to execute the Work. Article 20 Work The purpose of this Article is to ensure that the Contractor is paid for Work completed and for the Owner to retain such portion of the Contract Price, which, together with the Performance Bond, is sufficient to complete the Work without additional cost to the Owner. 20.01 Methods and Appliances The Contractor shall use such methods and appliances for the performance of the Work that shall ensure the completion of the Work of the required quality within the Completion Time. At any time, before the commencement or during the progress of the Work, the Owner may order the Contractor to increase the rate of efficiency or improve the system of operation of such methods or appliances which appear to the Owner to be inefficient or inappropriate for producing the quality of work required or ensuring the required rate of progress. The Contractor shall must comply with such order. Failure, however, of the Owner to demand such increase of efficiency or improvement of the character or methods of work or of the appliances shall not relieve the Contractor from its obligation to turn out such quality of work and rate of progress as are called for in the Contract. 20.02 Laying Out the Work All stakes and benchmarks placed by the Contractor in laying out the Work and approved by the Owner shall be carefully guarded and preserved by the Contractor. Unless such stakes or 42 marks are displaced or rendered useless through the carelessness or neglect of the Owner or of its agents or employees, these shall be replaced by the Contractor at its expense. 20.03 Defective Work Work that does not comply with the Contract shall be considered as defective work. Defective work shall be condemned by the Owner upon discovery, and when such work has been condemned, it shall be immediately removed by the Contractor and replaced in accordance with the Drawings and Specifications. 20.04 Inspection of Work (a) The Owner shall have access, at all times, to the Work. The Owner shall provide a sufficient number of inspectors while Work is in progress to ensure its timely inspection. (b) The Contractor shall furnish without additional charge all reasonable facilities, labor and materials necessary for the convenient inspection and tests that may be required by the inspectors. (c) The Owner shall provide inspectors authorized to witness the pouring of concrete and the absence of the Owner's inspectors at any time during the progress of the work shall be an implicit approval of the quality of the cement mix and the authority to pour it. (d) Should the Specifications, the Owner's instructions, the Laws, or any public authority require any work to be specifically tested or approved, the Contractor shall give timely notice to the Owner and other parties required to conduct or be present at the inspection of the date and time of such inspection. Inspection by the Owner shall be made, where practicable, at the source of supply. (e) Should any work be covered up without timely notice to the Owner, or before the Owner can make a timely inspection thereof, it must, if required by the Owner, be uncovered for examination at the Contractor's expense. However, notwithstanding the failure of the Owner to make a timely inspection of the work before it is covered, its reexamination may be ordered by the Owner and if so ordered, the work must be uncovered by the Contractor at the Owner's expense. However, if such work be found not in accordance with the Contract, the Contractor shall shoulder the cost of uncovering and re-doing the work. (f) Should there be indications that the work done is not in accordance with the Drawings and Specifications, the Owner may at any time before final acceptance of the Work, make an examination of the portion already completed by removing or tearing out the same. The Contractor shall, on request, furnish all necessary facilities, labor, and 43 materials. If such work is found to be defective in any material respect due to fault of the Contractor or its Sub-Contractors, the Contractor shall defray all the costs of such examination and of satisfactory reconstruction. If, however, such work is found to meet the requirements of the Contract, the actual cost of labor and materials necessarily involved in the examination and replacement plus fifteen percent (15%), shall be allowed the Contractor and it shall, in addition, if completion of the work has been delayed thereby, be granted a suitable extension of time on account of the additional work involved. (g) All inspection and tests shall be performed as not to unnecessarily delay the work. 20.05 Work During an Emergency The Contractor shall perform any work and shall furnish and install all materials and equipment necessary during an emergency endangering life or property. In such cases, Article 18.01 shall apply. 20.06 Increased or Decreased Quantities of Work Adjustments in working drawings to suit field conditions which cannot be foreseen at the time of calling for bids, may be necessary during construction. It is the essence of the Contract to recognize such changes in Drawings as normal. The resulting change in quantities or the increase in the scope of work of the Contractor shall be covered by a Change Order. Work done by the Contractor without timely notice to the Owner that an adjustment is required of Contract Price and Completion Time shall be at its own risk and expense. 20.07 Changes in the Work A. Changes Ordered by Owner The Owner may at any time order extra work or make changes by altering, adding to or deducting from the scope of work and within the general scope thereof; provided however that the resulting overruns or underruns from the quantities or costs in the Bid do not exceed twenty-five percent (25%). Such changes shall be ordered by the Owner in writing. The issuance by the Owner of the revised Drawings or Supplemental Specifications changing the nature or work to be performed or of the materials, equipment, appliances or fixtures to be provided, shall be treated as sufficient written instruction of the Owner to the Contractor to execute the change. 44 B. Change of Sub-Surface Conditions Should, during the progress of the work, sub-surface conditions at the site materially different from those shown on the Drawings or indicated in the Specifications or in any Contract Document, be discovered or encountered, the attention of the Owner shall be called to such conditions before these are disturbed. The Owner shall thereupon investigate the conditions, and if it finds that they materially differ from those shown on the Drawings or indicated in the Specifications or in the report of the Owner's geodetic survey and sub-surface exploration, it shall make such changes in the Drawings and Specifications as it may find necessary. Should, as a result of sub-surface conditions, additional or a different type of work be required, although no change in the Drawings or Specifications may be required, a Change Order shall be necessary and issued to the Contractor. C. Adjustment of Contract The Work shall be executed under the conditions of the Contract. If changes under paragraphs A and B shall cause an increase or decrease in the amount due under the Contract, or in the time required for or manner of its performance, an equitable adjustment shall be made, and the Contract modified accordingly. In the event that the Work is increased by such changes, the Contractor shall furnish proportionate additional Performance Bond. In case the Owner initiates a deductive change order for the purpose of transferring certain work items or part of the scope of work to another party or for the Owner to supply certain construction materials, then the Contractor shall be entitled to fifteen percent (15%) of the amount deducted in the change order to recover its overhead and profit. D. Value of Extra Work The value of any extra work or change shall be determined by the Owner in any one or more of the following ways: a. by a lump sum acceptable to the Contractor; b. by unit prices either stipulated in the Contract or subsequently agreed upon, provided the aggregate value of changes does not exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of the original Contract Price of the particular pay item; c. by actual direct cost plus value added tax, if any, plus fifteen percent (15%) for Contractor's profit and overhead. 45 Changes required by the Owner which in the aggregate exceed twenty-five percent (25%) for overruns shall be covered by a supplemental contract. The Contractor shall not be obliged to execute such changes in accordance with the unit rate specified in its Bid, a supplementary contract being treated as one separate from and independent of the Contract. Where the aggregate value of all changes per pay item exceed twenty-five percent (25%) and the Contractor, without demanding the execution of a supplemental contract executes the additional work required with objection or protest, the value of the changes shall be determined in accordance with subparagraph (b) above. Under case (c) above, the Contractor shall keep and present, in such form as the Owner may direct, a correct account of the direct cost together with vouchers and other supporting documents. E. Award of Extra Work to Other Contractors In case any extra work shall be required in the proper performance of the Work, and the Contractor and the Owner shall fail to arrive at any agreement as to the adjustment of Contract Price and/or Completion Time, the Owner may award such extra work to another contractor. 20.08 Claims for Extra Cost Should the Contractor claim that any instructions by the Owner or the Drawings or Specifications issued after submission of the Bid, involve a change, it shall give the Owner written notice thereof within fifteen (15) days after the receipt of such instruction, Drawings or Specifications, as much as possible, before proceeding to execute the work, except in emergency endangering life or property provided for in Article 18.01. In like manner, should the Contractor incur a delay in the mobilization and/or in the progress of its work for reasons attributable to the Owner, such as, but not limited to, Owner-supplied materials not arriving on time, movements or work executed by the Owner which interfere with the progress of the Contractor's work, delayed decisions by the Owner and other matters related thereto, it shall give the Owner written notice thereof within fifteen (15) days after recognition of such delay. The amount due to the Contractor under this article shall be paid by the Owner in the same manner as any other sum to which the Contractor may be entitled under the Contract, particularly under Articles 20.06, 20.07, 22.05 and 22.10. Delay in said payment shall entitle the Contractor to an extension of time and to payment of interest in accordance with Article 46 22.05. Refusal or unreasonable delay by the Owner to pay the amount due shall entitle the Contractor to suspend or terminate the Contract whenever permitted under Article 26. 20.09 Cleaning up at Completion of Work The Contractor shall at all times keep the premises free from accumulations of waste materials or rubbish caused by its employees. Rubbish shall not be thrown from windows or other parts of the structure without the use of rubbish chutes. At the completion of the Work, the Contractor shall remove all temporary work, its rubbish therefrom and all its tools, scaffolding and surplus materials and turn over the Work for occupancy. All dirt, stains, and the like on all finishing of floors, walls and ceilings, decorative work, finishing hardware and fixtures shall be removed. All woodwork, finishing hardware and all metal works shall be cleaned and polished. All glazing, marble and tile work shall be washed and cleaned. The Contractor shall also clean the site as shown in the Drawings and all areas which the Contractor used in the execution of the project. Should the Contractor fail to clean up after due notice at the completion of the Work, the Owner may do so, and the cost thereof charged to the Contractor. Should a dispute arise between the Contractor and separate contractors as to their responsibility for cleaning up, the Owner may clean up the site and charge the cost thereof to the contractors responsible therefor as the Owner shall determine to be just. 20.10 Use of Completed Portions of Work The Owner may take possession of and use any completed or partially completed portion of the Work, although the time for completing it or portions thereof may not have expired; but such taking of possession and use shall not be deemed an acceptance of any work not completed in accordance with the Contract. Neither shall it be deemed a waiver by the Owner of the right to claim damages due to delay in the completion of the Work. Shall such prior use increase the cost or delays the completion of uncompleted work or cause refinishing of completed work, the Contractor shall be entitled to extra compensation or extension of time or both. In the event of the Owner taking over any portion of the Work for its use prior to overall completion, then the Owner shall issue a Certificate of Completion for such portion taken over 47 and release retention as required by the Contract, subject to the provisions of Articles 20.11, 20.12, 20.13, 20.14 and 20.15. 20.11 Substantial Completion and its Effect A. (a) There is substantial completion when the Contractor completes ninety-five percent (95%) of the Work, provided that the remaining work and the performance of the work necessary to complete the Work shall not prevent the normal use of the completed portion. (b) The approval by the Owner of the Contractor’s billing for completing at least ninetyfive percent (95%) of the Work shall be deemed the Owner’s acknowledgment that the Contractor has substantially completed the Work unless the Owner can establish that the unfinished work prevents the normal use of the completed portion. (c) The Owner may also issue to the Contractor a written acknowledgement of substantial completion which may be in the form of a Certificate of Substantial Completion or equivalent document but the date of this document shall not be controlling if substantial completion is shown to have been made at an earlier date, unless the Contractor accepts the certificate without taking exceptions thereto in writing within fifteen (15) days from receipt. B. (a) Notwithstanding paragraph A above, the equipment, fixtures and utilities (collectively referred to as Facility) furnished and/or installed by the Contractor which the Contract requires to be test-run prior to acceptance shall be test-run successfully before the Work can be accepted as substantially completed. (b) The Owner shall, without delay, cause the test-run of the Facility. Should the Contractor be unable to completely install or furnish and test-run the Facility without fault on its part, the Contractor shall automatically be entitled to an extension of Completion Time equal to the period of delay. C. (a) The Owner shall issue to the Contractor one or more lists of defects found or discovered on the completed work, otherwise known as a punch list or lists, which the Contractor must receive from the Owner not later than thirty (30) days from date of substantial completion. (b) The Owner may add to the punch list items but only as to corrective work on the items in the original punch list or lists not later than sixty (60) days from date of substantial completion. 48 A. (a) No liquidated damages for delay beyond the Completion Time shall accrue after the date of substantial completion of the Work. (b) If the targeted date of completion has arrived and the Contractor cannot achieve ninety-five percent (95%) completion of the Work due to the uncompleted Facility caused by the Owner's fault, negligence or delay of the Owner, the Contractor shall be deemed to have achieved substantial completion provided: i. the Contractor has completed at least ninety-five percent (95%) of the Work minus the uncompleted Facility; and ii. the Contractor has completed the work required on the Facility but for that which is directly affected by the Owner’s fault, negligence or delay. The Owner shall release to the Contractor the Contract Price less the cost of the uncompleted portion of the Work and the amounts mentioned in Article 22.03. 20.12 Period of Making Good of Known Defects or Faults Period of Making Good of Known Defects or Faults shall mean a period of not more than thirty (30) days, calculated from the date of receipt by the Contractor of the last item in the punch list submitted during the period stated in Article 20.11 C (b), during which the Contractor shall complete the corrective works. 20.13 Making Good of Known Defects or Faults The Contractor shall execute at its own expense all works necessary for making good of known defects, imperfections or faults (wear and tear excepted) within the period stated in Article 20.12. Should the defect or fault be due to a cause attributable to the Owner, the value of such work shall be ascertained and paid for as if it were additional work. 20.14 Special Test and Inspection Special test, inspection or approval, not otherwise required in the Contract which the Owner instructs the Contractor to perform after the date of substantial completion, shall be treated as a separate work which shall be covered by a supplemental agreement. 20.15 Acceptance of Non-Conforming Work If the Owner accepts defective or non-conforming work, instead of requiring its removal and correction, the Owner shall issue to the Contractor a change order to reflect a reduction in the 49 Contract Price where appropriate by an amount not exceeding the value of the unfinished work as determined in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value. Such adjustment shall be effected whether or not final payment has been made. 20.16 Adjustment of Prices This Article 20.16 shall not apply to an increase or decrease in the cost of materials and services provided or supplied by the Owner. A. There shall be added to or deducted from the Contract Price such sums affecting the execution of the Work caused by any of the following: (a) an event of force majeure including abnormal changes in costs of materials; (b) increases in labor costs mandated by law or wage order; (c) increase in the cost of oil; and (d) the deterioration of peace and order. B. Adjustment of prices due to escalation or reduction of costs of executing the Work shall be made using a parametric formula to be agreed upon by the parties. Such adjustment shall be made to provide equitable relief to both the Owner and the Contractor, allowing neither to gain nor to lose by such fluctuation. Adjustment of the Contract Price due to escalation shall be for the sole purpose of compensating the Contractor for the increase in the direct cost of its labor and materials used for the Work, plus value-added tax. C. The adjustment of prices shall be determined on the basis of the original Contract unit prices of labor and materials and such unit prices in effect during the relevant period of work accomplishment. D. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the Contract Price shall be adjusted, not oftener than once a month, due to increase or decrease of the direct cost of labor and materials of more than five percent (5%) of the original Contract unit prices of the relevant items of work. The adjustment shall include the first five percent (5%). E. In case the project is behind schedule by more than fifteen percent (15%) from the approved construction schedule, not due to excusable delays, the payment for work accomplished shall be made on the basis of the Contract Price as adjusted in accordance with the escalation rate applicable during the period in which it should have been accomplished. 50 20.17 Payment in Legal Tender Payments in money under the Contract shall be made in the currency stipulated. Should it not be legally possible to deliver such currency, payments shall be made in the currency which is legal tender in the Philippines. Article 21 Time of Completion of Work 21.01 Notice to Proceed, When Required A Notice to Proceed shall be issued by the Owner to the Contractor only when the Contract so provides. Premature commencement of construction shall be at the Contractor's risk unless it is due to mutual desire to have the Contractor commence the work early, and the Owner gives the Contractor express or implied authority to do so. 21.02 Completion Time The Contractor shall complete the Work in accordance with the Contract within the period fixed therein and as adjusted due to changes both directed and constructive. If the Contractor is directed to commence the Work after receipt of the Notice to Proceed to be issued by the Owner, such shall begin within seven (7) days from receipt of the Notice to Proceed, unless the Notice to Proceed provides for a later date for commencement of the Work. For projects involving several phases of work with milestones, commencement date shall be reckoned from the time the Contractor receives the Notice to Proceed and/or Possession of Site for each milestone as shall be necessary to enable the Contractor to execute the contract works in accordance with the schedule stipulated in the Contract. 21.03 Schedule of Construction Work A. The Contractor, immediately after the Contract has taken effect, shall submit for approval a construction schedule in a form acceptable to the Owner indicating the approximate date each pay item will be started and completed, the equipment to be used and number of workers to be employed to complete it in accordance with the schedule. The progress of the work shall be at a rate sufficient to complete the Work in an acceptable manner within the Completion Time. B. In case of slippage, the Owner may call for meetings with the Contractor and other contractors involved to determine the possible cause/s contributing to the slow progress of the construction work, and if such slippage is due to the fault or negligence 51 of the Contractor, the Owner may require the Contractor to submit a catch-up schedule which shall be subject to approval by the Owner. C. The Owner may order the acceleration of work to meet a desired completion date. Acceleration of work for the benefit or convenience of the Owner or caused by the fault of or delay by the Owner, shall be treated as extra work for which a Change Order shall be issued, and the Contractor shall be paid for the cost of such acceleration. However, where the reason for acceleration is due to the fault of the Contractor, such additional cost for acceleration shall be borne by the Contractor alone. 21.04 Extension of Time A. The Contractor shall be entitled to an equitable adjustment of Completion Time where the Contractor is obstructed or delayed in the prosecution or completion of the Work by: (a) the act, neglect, delay or fault of the Owner, or any other contractor employed by the Owner on the Work; (b) third-party strikes or lockouts or strikes by employees other than the Contractor's employees or a lockout by an employer other than the Contractor; (c) an act of God or force majeure; (d) unsuitable weather conditions which render the work impracticable or impossible or which slow down the prosecution of the Work; (e) peace and order conditions; (f) changes ordered or authorized by the Owner or authorized under the Contract; and (g) delay authorized by the Owner pending arbitration of an unresolved dispute between the Owner and the Contractor. The Contractor shall be entitled to substantiated prolongation costs only in respect of (a), (f) and (g), and of (d) when Changes or Variations by the Owner caused the works to be executed in a period of inclement weather conditions which is different from that envisaged at the bidding stage. B. For delay caused by paragraphs A(b), (c), (d), (e) and (f) of this Article 21.04, the Contractor shall within fifteen (15) days from the occurrence of the event which caused the delay, notify the Owner and the Owner shall, not later than fifteen (15) days from receipt of such notice, give the Contractor an equitable adjustment of the Completion Time. The failure of the Owner to respond to the Contractor or to give an equitable adjustment of the Completion Time shall be deemed an approval by the Owner of the adjustment requested by the Contractor. 52 C. (a) For delay caused by paragraphs A(a) and (g), and in default of an agreement between the Owner and the Contractor, the Contractor shall be entitled to an adjustment of Completion Time equal to the delay caused by such factor/s. However, the Contractor shall not be entitled to extension of Completion Time due to the alleged failure of the Owner to furnish materials or information or provide drawings, unless in the construction schedule approved by the Owner, these are necessary to prosecute the Work in the order required, and the failure of the Owner to provide these caused a delay in the work of the Contractor. (b) The Owner, taking into account the construction schedule it approved and the progress of the work of the Contractor, is conclusively presumed to know when materials, equipment or supplies or drawings to be provided by the Owner shall be required by the Contractor. The failure of the Contractor to give prior or timely notice to the Owner of the date when such material, equipment or supplies or drawings shall be required, shall not be a ground for denying the Contractor an adjustment of Completion Time. (c) The failure of the Owner to reply to the Contractor's request for adjustment of Completion Time within fifteen (15) days from the date of receipt of the request shall be deemed an approval by the Owner of the adjustment requested by the Contractor. Such request shall be deemed a formality which does not affect the right of the Contractor to an equitable adjustment of Completion Time as provided in this paragraph C. D. Delay in the payment of any progress billing as required in Article 22.05 shall automatically extend the Completion Time by a period equal to the delay. The Contractor shall not be required to give notice to the Owner nor be required to establish that such delay actually delayed the prosecution of the Work or delayed the Contractor to a period equal to the delay in the payment of the billing. 21.05 Delay in Completion of the Work (a) It is understood that time is an essential feature of the Contract. (b) Upon failure of the Contractor to complete the Work within the Completion Time, the Contractor shall pay the Owner liquidated damages in the amount stipulated in the Contract as indemnity. The Owner may deduct from any sum due the Contractor the amount which has accrued as liquidated damages. Liquidated damages shall accrue from the first day of delay in completing the Work within the Completion Time until the date of substantial completion as determined under Article 20.11. 53 (c) The amount of damages for corrective works uncompleted within the Period of Making Good of Known Defects shall be based on the value of such uncompleted corrective work in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value for approved billings. (d) Upon failure of the Owner to pay the Contractor for approved billings, the Contractor shall have the right to suspend performance of the Work under the conditions provided in Article 27(b), (c) and (d) and be entitled to the payment of interest under Article 22.05. Article 22 Payments 22.01 Breakdown of Contract Amount The Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value as approved by the Owner, shall be used as the basis for all Requests for Payment, and for determining the value of uncompleted work or corrective works. Except in cases where unit prices form the basis for payment under the Contract, the Contractor shall, within fifteen (15) days from the receipt of Notice to Proceed, or from commencement of the Work, submit a Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value of the Contract Amount showing the value assigned to each part of the Work. 22.02 Requests for Payment The Contractor may submit periodically but not more than once each month a Request for Payment for work done. The Contractor shall furnish the Owner all reasonable facilities required for obtaining the necessary information relative to the progress and execution of the Work. Each Request for Payment shall be computed from the work completed on all items listed in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value, less a retention of ten percent (10%) of the progress payment to the Contractor. When fifty percent (50%) of the Contract has been accomplished, no further retention shall be made on progress billings for the balance of the Work. In general, and unless the Contract provides otherwise, no payment shall be made for materials or items not incorporated in the work, except where such immediate acquisition is made necessary due to shortages or import or transportation difficulties, in which case, payment shall be made conditioned upon the submission by the Contractor of bills of sale, or upon compliance with such other procedures as will establish the Owner's title to such material or item, or otherwise adequately protect the Owner's interest. 22.03 Authorized Deductions from Value of Completed Work The Owner may deduct the following from any payment due the Contractor: 54 (a) the estimated cost of defective work not remedied; (b) the amount of substantiated and unpaid claims by Sub-Contractors employed in and suppliers of materials and labor for the Work unjustifiably withheld by the Contractor; and (c) the amount which has accrued as liquidated damages. 22.04 Conditions Relative to Payments The Owner shall estimate the value of work accomplished by the Contractor using the schedule stipulated in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value as basis. Such estimate of the Owner of the amount of work performed shall be taken as the basis for the compensation to be received by the Contractor. While such preliminary estimates of amount and quantity shall not be required to be made by strict measurement or with exactness, these must be made as close as possible to the actual percentage of work accomplishment. 22.05 Owner's Action on Requests for Payment Within thirty (30) days after a receipt of Request for Progress Payment from the Contractor, the Owner shall pay the amount as certified. The 30-day period shall be inclusive of the period required in evaluating and certifying the Contractor’s accomplishment. In case the Owner fails to pay on time the amount due, the Owner shall pay, in addition to the amount due, interest thereon computed from the due date in accordance with the 30-day regular loan rate of the Land Bank of the Philippines prevailing on due date. 22.06 Payment of Unpaid Labor, Sub-Contractors and Suppliers The Contractor shall pay punctually all workers it employed on the project at not less than such rates as are provided by existing laws. The Contractor shall also pay promptly all materials it purchased, equipment it used on the project, and all taxes due from it. The Contractor shall remit all amounts required by law to be withheld from the salaries or wages of its employees or workers. 22.07 Payments Over Ninety Percent (90%) No payment shall be made in excess of ninety percent (90%) of the Contract Price, unless a statement sworn to before any officer duly authorized to administer oaths is submitted by the Contractor to the effect that all bills for labor, other than current wages, and all bills for materials have been duly paid by the Contractor and its Sub-Contractor, if any, excepting only such bills as may be enumerated in such sworn statement. The Contractor shall render the 55 Owner free and harmless from any claims and payment of such bills and shall indemnify the Owner the cost of defending itself against such claims. 22.08 Other Requirements Before Final Payment The Contractor shall submit, aside from those which may be provided in the Contract, the following, as applicable, before final payment is made: (a) Certificate of Final Building Occupancy unless such certificate cannot be obtained through no fault of the Contractor; (b) Certificate of Final Inspection of electrical, telephone, sanitary, mechanical, water, gas, safety and other utilities unless such certificate cannot be obtained through no fault of the Contractor; (c) original and three (3) sets of prints of As-Built Drawings of Electrical, Sanitary, Gas, Telephone and Mechanical works, if such works are within the scope of the Contract. AsBuilt Drawings are the working drawings showing the system and actual locations of outlets, fixtures, services and equipment that were installed. (d) three (3) copies of Directory of Panel Boards and list of circuits; (e) three (3) copies of Instructions and Manual for operating and maintaining of fixtures and equipment; (f) three (3) copies of Keying Schedule; and (g) a release of liens arising under the Contract as provided in Article 33.01, and the sworn statements required in Article 22.09 (A) and Article 22.07. 22.09 Acceptance and Final Payment Whenever the Contractor notifies the Owner that the Work under the Contract has been completely performed by the Contractor, the Owner shall proceed to verify the work, make the final estimates, certify to the completion of the work, and accept the same. A. The Owner shall then, except for causes herein specified, pay to the Contractor within the period stated in Article 22.05, the amount which shall be found due, excepting therefrom such sum or sums as may be lawfully retained under any of the provisions of the Contract; provided that final payment on the Contract shall not be made until the Contractor has submitted a statement sworn to before an officer duly authorized to administer oath, showing that all taxes due from it in connection with this Contract have been duly paid. B. In case the Owner has reasonable grounds of belief that the Contractor has not remitted to the appropriate government agency the employer's and employee's 56 contributions or the withholding tax on the employees' wages, the Owner may require evidence of remittance of such contributions or withholding tax in addition to the sworn statement mentioned above, and withholding release of the amount sufficient to cover such payments until the evidence required by the Owner is provided by the Contractor. C. The acceptance by the Contractor of final payment shall constitute a waiver of all its claims against the Owner, except the following: (a) a claim covered by a prior notice to the Owner reserved by the Contractor to be filed in accordance with the Contract; (b) a claim pending before and unresolved by the Owner at the time the request for final payment is made; (c) a dispute referred to arbitration in accordance with Article 33.05; and (d) a claim which the Owner acknowledges with the payment not to be covered by it. 22.10 Corrections of Work Before or After Final Payment A. Acceptance by the Owner of the Work of the Contractor shall relieve the Contractor of liability for any defect in the Work unless: (a) The defect is hidden, and the Owner could not have discovered the defect even with the exercise of reasonable diligence. (b) The Owner accepted the Work with express reservations seasonably made as to the specific portion of the Work which was found defective and which requires replacement or correction. A reservation which fails to specify the portion alleged to be defective and also fails to state in as much detail as possible the nature and extent of the defect shall be considered a general reservation and shall be ineffective. B. Paragraph A shall apply notwithstanding the issuance of the final certificate of completion or of full payment. C. Poor or inferior work or work which does not comply with the Drawings and Specifications which is apparent upon inspection by the Owner or by the technical representatives and inspectors employed by the Owner, shall forthwith be condemned and the Contractor notified thereof to give the Contractor an opportunity, without loss of time and without incurring unnecessary cost, to correct, remove and replace the defective work. Work not so condemned within one year from final payment cannot later be rejected by the Owner. If the Owner instructs the Contractor to remove or replace it thereafter, the instruction shall be treated as a change order. D. The Contractor shall be liable to the Owner for any hidden defect discovered and notified to the Contractor which the Contractor receives from the Owner within the 57 warranty period as provided in the Contract, or in default of any provision fixing the warranty period, within one year from the posting of the Guarantee Bond. E. Nothing herein shall be deemed to limit the liability of the Contractor to third persons due to any loss or damage resulting from the collapse of the Work due to defects in the construction or the use of materials of inferior quality or due to any violation of the terms of the Contract in accordance with Article 1723 of the Civil Code of the Philippines. 22.11 Release of Retention Subject to Article 33.01 herein, the amount retained by the Owner under the provision of the Contract shall be released not later than the expiration of the Period of Making Good of Known Defects as provided in Article 20.12 upon the posting of the Contractor's Guarantee Bond. Section VII Contractor—Separate Contractors—Sub-Contractors Relations Article 23 Separate Contracts with Other Contractors The Owner may perform work outside of the Contractor's scope of work or award separate contracts to other contractors. Should the Contractor claim that delay, damage, or additional cost is involved as a result, the Contractor shall make such claim as provided in the Contract. The Owner shall provide for the coordination of the work performed by the Contractor and/or each separate contractor with the Work of the Contractor. Article 24 Contractor and Separate Contractors Relations 24.01 Storage of Materials and Work Coordination The Contractor shall, to the extent possible, afford other contractors reasonable opportunity for the introduction and storage of their materials and the execution of their work, and shall properly connect and cooperate in the Owner's effort to coordinate its work with that of other contractors so as to minimize interference or obstruction in the progress of the work performed by each of them. 24.02 Cutting, Patching and Digging The Contractor shall do all cutting, fitting or patching of its work that may be required to make its several parts come together properly and fit it to receive or be received by work of other contractors shown upon, or reasonably implied by, the Drawings and Specifications for the completed structure. 58 Any cost caused by defective or ill-timed work shall be borne by the party responsible therefor. The Contractor shall not endanger any work by cutting, digging or otherwise and shall not cut or alter the work of any other contractor save with the consent of the Owner. 24.03 Defective Work by Separate Contractors Should any part of the Contractor's work depend for proper execution or results upon the work of any other contractor, the Contractor shall inspect and promptly report it to the Owner. Its failure to inspect and report it shall constitute an acceptance of the other contractor's work as fit and proper for the reception of its work, except as to defects which may develop in the other contractor's work after the execution of the Contractor's work. To insure the proper execution of its subsequent work, the Contractor shall verify work already in place and shall at once report to the Owner any discrepancy noticed between the executed work and the drawings. 24.04 Damage Caused by Contractor to Separate Contractors Should the Contractor cause damage to the work of any separate contractor, the Contractor agrees to relieve the Owner of any liability which may arise therefrom. 24.05 Damage Caused by Separate Contractors to Contractor Should any separate contractor cause damage to the Contractor’s work, then the Owner shall hold harmless the Contractor in respect thereof. Article 25 Sub-Contracts 25.01 General It is understood and agreed that no portion of the Work shall be sublet or sub-contracted without the Owner’s consent. However, any part thereof or any specialty work therein, may be sublet or sub-contracted, subject to the provisions of Articles 25.02 and 33.03. The consent of the Owner to the Contractor’s engagement of a Sub-Contractor, by itself, shall not create any contractual relation between the Sub-Contractor and the Owner. 59 25.02 Contractor's Responsibility The Contractor is as fully responsible to the Owner for the acts and omissions of its SubContractors and the persons either directly or indirectly employed by them, as it is for the acts and omissions of persons it directly employed. Section VIII Suspension of Work and Termination of Contract Article 26 Contractor's Right to Suspend Work or Terminate Contract The Contractor may suspend work or terminate the Contract upon fifteen (15) days' written notice to the Owner for any of the following reasons: (a) Should an order of any court or other public authority caused the work to be stopped or suspended for an aggregate period of ninety (90) days through no act or fault of the Contractor or its employees. (b) Should the Owner fail to pay the Contractor the approved Request for Payment as provided in Article 22.05. (c) Should the Owner fail to pay the Contractor any sum within thirty (30) days after its award by arbitration. (d) Should the Owner suspend the work without just cause for more than an aggregate period of fifteen (15) days without the Contractor's consent. (e) Should the Owner fail to deliver at the construction site Owner- supplied/furnished construction materials and/or equipment, for the scope of work along the critical path, beyond fifteen (15) days after its scheduled date for delivery as provided for in the Contract. (f) Should approval of Variation Orders for additional works along the critical path be delayed beyond fifteen (15) days after submission for approval by the Owner or by its duly designated Representative. Should the suspension be necessary for proper execution of the Work or by reason of weather or other conditions affecting the safety of the works and/or the Contractor’s workers, the Contractor may request the Owner to suspend work in accordance with the applicable provision or provisions of Article 27.02. The Contractor shall be entitled to an equitable adjustment of Completion Time and/or Contract Price for suspension of work due to the above circumstances. 60 Article 27 Owner's Right to Suspend the Work 27.01 Suspension Without Cause The Owner may, at any time and without cause, suspend the work or any portion thereof for a period of not more than the aggregate period of fifteen (15) days by notice in writing to the Contractor and shall fix the date on which work shall be resumed. The Contractor shall resume the Work on the date so fixed. The Contractor will be allowed an adjustment in the Contract Price to include demobilization and remobilization costs and/or stand-by time as applicable as well as adjustment of Completion Time which shall not be less than the period of suspension and shall include the delay due to remobilization of equipment and personnel. The Owner may not suspend the work without just cause for more than an aggregate period of fifteen (15) days without the Contractor's consent. 27.02 Just Causes for Suspension of Work The Owner, by a written order, may direct the Contractor to stop the Work or any portion thereof, in any of the following cases until the cause for such order has been eliminated: (a) unsuitable weather or other conditions considered unfavorable for the prosecution of the work; (b) failure of the Contractor to correct defective work or to correct conditions which constitute a danger to its workers or the general public; (c) failure of the Contractor to carry out valid orders issued by the Owner or to comply with any provision of the Contract, or its persistent failure to carry out the Works in accordance with the Contract; (d) the necessity for adjusting the Drawings to suit site conditions found during construction, or in case of a change in Drawings and Specifications; (e) failure of the Contractor to supply sufficient skilled workers, suitable materials or equipment; (f) failure of the Owner to supply Owner-supplied/furnished materials on time, where such failure is due to causes beyond the reasonable control of the Owner; (g) delay by the Owner in obtaining a right-of-way, where such obligation is assumed by the Owner under the Contract, and the delay is not due to the fault or negligence by the Owner; (h) Force majeure or fortuitous event; (i) peace and order problems; or (j) any condition similar to the above, beyond the control of the Owner. 61 The Contractor shall immediately comply with such order to suspend the Work or any part thereof for such period or periods and in such manner as the Owner may direct, and during such suspension shall properly protect and secure the Work. The Contractor shall be entitled to an equitable adjustment of Completion Time and Contract Price for suspension of work due to items (a), (d), (f), (g), (h), (i) and (j). However, for item (a), no such adjustment shall be allowed if unsuitable weather conditions were taken into account in determining the Completion Time as provided for in the Bid Documents. Should the actual number of days of unsuitable weather exceed the period taken into account in the Bid Documents, the Contractor shall be entitled to an adjustment of Completion Time and Contract Price. Article 28 Owner's Right to Terminate Contract 28.01 Termination with Cause The Owner may immediately terminate the Contract, without prior notice to the Contractor, upon the occurrence of any of the following events: (a) should the Contractor be adjudged bankrupt or insolvent; (b) should the Contractor make a general assignment of its assets for the benefit of its creditors; (c) should a trustee or receiver be appointed for the Contractor or for any of the Contractor's property; or (d) should the Contractor file a petition for suspension of payments, or to reorganize under the bankruptcy or similar Laws. 28.02 Other Grounds for Termination with Cause The Owner may terminate the Contract upon the occurrence of any of the following events: (a) the Contractor repeatedly fails to supply, based on the construction schedule, the sufficient number of skilled workers or suitable materials or equipment; (b) the Contractor repeatedly fails to make, without just cause, prompt payments to SubContractors for labor, materials or equipment, and completion of the Work is being delayed; (c) the Contractor disregards the Laws or orders of any public body having jurisdiction; (d) the Contractor otherwise violates in any substantial way any provision of the Contract; or 62 (e) slippage of the Contractor in excess of twenty-five percent (25%) in the prosecution of Work per agreed construction schedule and/or PERT/CPM including any time adjustment duly granted to the Contractor. The Owner may, after giving Contractor and its Surety 15 days' written notice, terminate the services of the Contractor, exclude the Contractor from the site and take possession of the Work and of all the Contractor's tools, appliances, construction equipment and machinery at the site and use the same and incorporate into the Work all materials and equipment stored at the site including those stored elsewhere for which the Owner has paid the Contractor, and finish the Work as the Owner may deem expedient. In such case the Contractor shall not be entitled to receive any further payment until the Work is finished. 28.03 Termination Without Cause Upon 15 days' written notice to the Contractor, the Owner may, without prejudice to any other right or remedy, elect to abandon the Work and terminate the Contract. In such case, the Contractor shall be paid for all work executed and any expense sustained including reasonable termination costs. Article 29 Owner's Right to Proceed with the Work after Reduction in the Contractor's Scope of Work; Partial Takeover from Contractor 29.01 Owner's Right to Carry Out the Work Should the Contractor: (a) repeatedly fail to supply sufficient skilled workers or suitable materials or equipment; (b) repeatedly fail to make prompt payments to Sub-Contractors for labor, materials or equipment; (c) fail within a mutually agreed time after written notice of the Owner to carry out remedial or repair work; (d) fail despite repeated remedial work to rectify the defects or the result of remedial work does not conform to the specifications; (e) fail to perform the Work in accordance with the Contract, the Owner may, after seven (7) days following receipt by the Contractor of written notice and without prejudice to any other remedy the Owner may have and without terminating the Contract, make good such deficiencies. In such case an appropriate change order shall be issued deducting from the payments then or thereafter due the Contractor the cost of correcting such deficiencies, including compensation of additional services made necessary 63 by such default, neglect or failure. If the payments then or thereafter due the Contractor are not sufficient to cover such amount, the Contractor shall pay the difference to the Owner. 29.02 Use of Materials and Equipment at Site The Contractor, upon receiving notice of termination of the Contract, shall vacate the site and deliver possession of the Work, or the parts thereof specified in the notice, to the Owner. All materials, plant, appliances and other essential equipment as may be needed for the construction of the project, shall, at the option of the Owner, remain on the site until the Work is completed and credit the Contractor a reasonable rental for the use the same. In case such materials and/or equipment do not belong to the Contractor, then the Owner, provided it does not violate the lease contract of the Contractor, shall have the option to retain these for use in the project and pay reasonable rent directly to the lessor for their use, chargeable against the Contractor. 29.03 Owner to Complete Work The Owner shall then take over the Work, and use such tools, appliances and materials of every description as may be found at the site for the purpose of completing the Work. 29.04 Evaluation of Cost of Work Upon such termination of this Contract, the Owner shall ascertain and fix the value of the work completed by the Contractor and not paid for by the Owner and of all usable materials of the Contractor taken over by the Owner at the time of said termination. (a) If the cost to the Owner of completing the Work, inclusive of reasonable administrative and managerial services and the charges against the project prior to termination of the Contract are not in excess of the Contract Price, then the difference between these may be applied to settle claims filed against the Contractor, and the balance, if any, may be paid to the Contractor. No amount in excess of the combined value of the unpaid completed work, retained percentage and usable materials taken over by the Owner at the time of the termination of the Contract shall be paid to the Contractor until the completion of the work. (b) In case of suspension of work, all unpaid work executed including costs incurred during suspension shall be charged to the Owner. 64 29.05 Owner's Right to Recover Damages Neither the taking over by the Owner of the Work for completion by administration nor the re-letting of the same to another contractor shall be construed as a waiver of the Owner's rights to recover damages against the original Contractor and/or its sureties for the failure to complete the work as stipulated. In such case, the full extent of the damages for which the Contractor and/or its sureties shall be liable shall include: (a) Liquidated damages which may have accrued up to and including the day immediately before the date the Owner effectively takes over the Work or the date of substantial completion, whichever occurs earlier; (b) the excess cost incurred by the Owner in the completion of the project over the Contract Price inclusive of re-letting the same; Should the Owner complete the Work by administration, the direct cost of completing the Work shall include the reasonable cost of managerial and administrative services incurred from the time the Owner effectively took over the Work by administration. 29.06 Liquidated Damages 1. Where the Contractor refuses or fails to satisfactorily complete the Work within the specified Contract Time, including any time adjustment duly granted, the Contractor shall pay the Owner liquidated damages in the amount stipulated in the Contract. Liquidated damages shall accrue from the first day of delay in completing the Work until the date of substantial completion as determined under Article 20.11. 2. To be entitled to such liquidated damages, the Owner does not have to prove that it has incurred actual damages. Such amount shall be deducted from any money due or which may become due the Contractor under the Contract. The Owner may collect such liquidated damages from the retention money or other securities posted by the Contractor, whichever is convenient to the Owner. 3. In no case, however, shall the total sum of liquidated damages exceed ten percent (10%) of the total Contract Price. 4. Should, before the completion of the whole of the Work, any part or section of the Work be certified by the Owner’s Engineer or Representative as completed and occupied or used by the Owner, the liquidated damages for delay shall be reduced in the proportion which the value of the part or section so certified bears to the value of the whole of the Work, unless a contrary provision is stipulated in the Contract. 65 Section IX Responsibilities and Liabilities of Contractor and of Owner Article 30 Contractor's Responsibility for Accidents and Damages 30.01 Safeguards to be Undertaken by Contractor The Contractor shall take all necessary precautions for the safety of employees and workers on the Work, and comply with all Laws to prevent injury to persons on, about or adjacent to the premises where the Work is being performed. The Contractor shall erect and properly maintain at all times, as required by the conditions and progress of the Work, such barriers, shoring, supports, braces, lights, danger signs and necessary safeguards, as will protect workers and the public and as will effectively prevent any injury to persons and damage to property in consequence of its work. The Contractor shall designate a responsible member of its organization at the site, whose duty shall be the prevention of accidents and damage to the Work, the Owner's property and adjoining property. The name and position of the person so designated shall be reported by the Contractor in writing to the Owner. The Contractor shall be primarily responsible for all safety measures in prosecuting the Work in accordance with R.A. No. 11058, An Act Strengthening Compliance with Occupational Safety and Health Standards and Providing Penalties for Violations. 30.02 Owner Not to be Responsible The Contractor shall render the Owner free and harmless for the death of, the disease contracted or injury received by the Contractor or any of its employees or laborers, for any damage done by or to Contractor’s plant or materials from any source or cause; and for damages caused by the Contractor or its employees to any property of the Owner and adjoining property. (a) The Contractor shall indemnify and save harmless the Owner from and against all losses and all claims, demands, payments, suits, actions, recoveries, and judgement of every nature and description brought or recovered against the Owner, for any act or omission of said Contractor, or of its agents or employees, in the execution of the Work or the guarding of it. (b) Claims for payment and repairs for damages for which the Contractor is liable shall be settled by the Contractor at its own expense. In the event of failure of the Contractor to repair such damages, and pay other claims, the Owner may repair the same and pay the 66 claims, and deduct the entire cost of such repairs and claims from the payments due the Contractor. 30.03 Contractor's Default The Owner shall have the right to undertake reasonable safety and protection measures in case of Contractor's default, and charge the cost of such measures to the Contractor. Article 31 Contractor's Insurance and Bonds 31.01 Contractor's Liability Insurance The Contractor shall secure and maintain insurance coverage from an insurance company acceptable to the Owner as will protect itself, its Sub-Contractors, and the Owner from claims for bodily injury, death or property damage which may arise from work under the Contract. The Contractor shall not commence work under the Contract until it has obtained the insurance coverage required and shall have filed the insurance policy or the certified copy of the insurance policy with the Owner. Such insurance policy shall contain a clause providing that it shall not be cancelled by the insurance company without written notice to and approval of the Owner. The nature, extent and amount of such insurance coverage shall be as agreed upon between the Owner and the Contractor. The Contractor shall ensure that such insurance policy is effective during the execution of the Work. 31.02 Accident Insurance for Workers The Contractor shall, in addition to compulsory coverage of workers under the workers’ compensation law, obtain insurance coverage for accidental death or injury of its officers, employees and laborers without regard to tenure of employment as permanent or regular workers, project workers or casual employees performing work at the project site. The premiums to be paid on the insurance policy shall be paid by the Contractor and without cost to those covered by the policy. 31.03 Contractor's Fire Insurance In addition to such Fire Insurance as the Contractor elects to carry for its work, it shall secure and maintain the policies upon such structures and materials and in such amounts as shall be designated in the joint names of the Contractor and the Owner as their respective interests may appear. These policies shall be secured from a company which is satisfactory to the Owner and delivered to the Owner. A Contractor's All Risk Policy or any insurance for third party liability of the Contractor shall not include the Owner as co-insured but as a third party. 67 31.04 Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds The Contractor, prior to signing the Contract, shall furnish a Performance Bond equal to fifteen percent (15%) of the Contract amount for the faithful performance of its Work and fifteen percent (15%) bond covering Contractor’s obligations arising from the Contract to its workers, Sub-Contractors and suppliers. Such bonds shall be in the form of surety bond as approved by the Owner, and shall remain in effect until replaced by the Contractor’s Guarantee Bond. 31.05 Contractor’s Guarantee Bond The Performance and Payment Bonds will be released by the Owner upon posting by the Contractor of a Guarantee Bond equivalent to the amount of the retention released to the Contractor. The Guarantee Bond shall be for a period of one (1) year commencing from the date of posting as a guarantee that all materials and workmanship installed under the Contract are of acceptable quality. 31.06 Contractor’s Guarantee-Warranty (a) The Contractor shall, in case of work performed by its Sub-Contractors and where guarantees are required, secure guarantees from said Sub-Contractors and deliver copies of same to the Owner upon completion of work. The term guarantee shall include warranty. (b) The Contractor shall and thereby guarantees all work performed by it directly and for which guarantees are required. (c) The Contractor shall guarantee for a period of one year, or for a longer period where so provided in the Specifications, all materials and workmanship installed under the Contract to be of acceptable quality in every respect and to remain so during the guarantee period. (d) Should any defect develop in aforesaid work, within the guarantee period due to fault in material and/or workmanship, the Contractor shall make all repairs and do all necessary work to correct defective work to the Owner's satisfaction. Such repairs and corrective works shall be done by the Contractor at its exclusive expense and shall be commenced within five (5) days after receipt of written notice by the Owner. (e) In case the Contractor fails to commence or do the Work so ordered, the Owner may have the Work done by another contractor and charge the cost thereof against monies retained as provided for in the Contract and/or against its sureties. (f) The foregoing remedies shall be without prejudice to the rights of the Owner under the New Civil Code and other laws now or hereafter that may be applicable. 68 31.07 Mandatory Conditions of Bonds The bonds required of the Contractor shall be subject to mandatory conditions which shall form part of said bonds. A Surety issuing any bond called for in the Contract is deemed conclusively to have accepted the following mandatory conditions: (a) The Surety agrees in advance to future novation/s of the bond either by adjusting the scope of the Work of the Contractor caused by directed or constructive changes, the Completion Time or the Contract Price. Where the Contract provides that the Contractor shall obtain the approval of the Surety to any such adjustment, the required approval shall be deemed to be a mere formality, the absence of which shall not affect the obligation and liability of the Surety under the bond. (b) The bond issued by Surety under the Contract shall continue to have force and effect beyond the effectivity period stated in the bond if the Work or the obligation for which it was issued has not been completely performed. This is without prejudice to the right of the Surety to demand from the Contractor the payment of the premium on the bond or to the right of the Owner to pay such unpaid premium for the Contractor. The additional premium on the bond for an extension of the Contract time due to reasons other than the fault or negligence of the Contractor shall be billed at cost to the Owner. The bond may not be cancelled or otherwise terminated by the Surety without the express written consent of both the Owner and the Contractor. The right of the Surety shall be limited to demand the payment of unpaid premium. (c) The Owner shall have a right of recourse against the Surety on the bond until: i. it is cancelled by the Owner and returned to the Contractor; ii. it is replaced by another bond unless the Owner reserves the right to recover against the former bond due to default of the Contractor; iii. the Owner issues to the Contractor an unconditional Certificate of Acceptance of the Work. (d) Until the Owner takes over the Work (not only a part thereof) or otherwise terminates the Contract, the Contractor shall not be deemed in default, notwithstanding the reduction of the Contractor's scope of work and any assistance provided by the Owner to enable the Contractor to catch up and complete the remaining work. The Owner's assistance to the Contractor shall not prejudice nor limit the right of the Owner to have a later recourse against the bond. 69 Any provision in the bond thereby issued or in any document made prior to, concurrent with, or after the issuance of the bond which tends to nullify, modify, or limit by time or otherwise, any right of the Owner shall be void and shall not prevail over the above mandatory conditions. Article 32 Owner’s Responsibilities and Liabilities 32.01 Advance Payment An advance payment in an amount to be mutually agreed upon shall be paid by the Owner to the Contractor, provided that the Contractor shall post a surety bond of equivalent amount callable on demand and acceptable to the Owner to guarantee its repayment. The Contractor shall use the advance payment for mobilization, purchase of materials, and the like for the project. This shall be recouped pro rata in the progress billings. 32.02 Protection of Employees and Professionals Performing Services for the Owner The Owner shall be responsible for and shall maintain such insurance as will protect it from liability for personal injury including disease and death of persons under its employ or service whether as temporary or permanent in status that are assigned to the project. 32.03 Owner's Optional Insurance The Owner may maintain such insurance as will protect it from its contingent liability for damages, for personal injury, including death, which may arise from the Work under the Contract. 32.04 Additional Information and Services Required of the Owner The Owner shall, at the request of the Contractor, at the time of the execution of the Contract, furnish to the Contractor reasonable evidence that the Owner can fulfill its obligations under the Contract. Unless such reasonable evidence is furnished, the Contractor may not be required to execute the Contract or to commence or continue the Work. Article 33 Liens, Disputes and Arbitration 33.01 Liens As a condition to final payment and/or the release of the retention, the Contractor shall release the Work from any legal liens attaching therewith as a result of unpaid claims of Sub70 Contractors and/or suppliers for the supply of materials and/or equipment to the Contractor for the project in the form of a sworn statement by the Contractor or a duly authorized officer of the Contractor stating that all such claims have been fully paid; and furnishing the Owner, when required, with receipts or acknowledgments of payment issued by the Sub-Contractors and/or suppliers. Should any of such claims remain unpaid as of the time of executing the sworn statement, or if the Contractor is unable to furnish the Owner with proof of full payment to any Sub-Contractor or supplier, the Contractor shall furnish the Owner with an indemnity bond equal to the amount of the claims still unpaid. The indemnity bond may be issued by the Surety which previously issued the Contractor's Performance Bond or any other bond required under the Contract or by any other Surety acceptable to the Owner. The Owner may recover against the Contractor and/or the Surety, on the latter's indemnity bond, any amount paid by the Owner to discharge such liens, including costs incurred incident thereto and a reasonable amount of attorney's fees. 33.02 Assignment A. The Contract may not be assigned in whole or in part. Any purported assignment made of the Contract or any part thereof without the consent of either party shall be void and ineffective. B. The Owner may nevertheless exact full compliance from both the Contractor and its assignee without waiving the Owner's right at any time thereafter to reduce the Contractor's scope of Work by removing from the Contractor the part of the Work which was assigned and giving it to any other contractor and/or terminating the Contract in either case, without any further cause than the assignment. C. Any contract, agreement or binding written commitment entered into by the Contractor either before or after the execution of the Contract, with any other person as cooperator, consortium member, joint venture member, or supplier of equipment, technology, materials or services for the joint execution of the Work, shall be provided to the Owner at the latter's request. Should the Owner find that the contract, agreement or binding written commitment is a disguised assignment of the Contract, the Owner shall so notify the Contractor and shall have the rights under paragraph B above. 33.03 Subcontracting The Contractor may subcontract any part of the Contract with the approval of the Owner. The Owner may require the Contractor as a condition for the approval of the subcontract that: 71 (a) the subcontract shall be submitted to the Owner and the subcontract must require the Sub-Contractor to obtain the same bonds and insurance coverage as are required of the Contractor under the Contract; and (b) the Contractor furnish the Owner copies of these insurance policies and bonds. 33.04 Disputes A. All matters which under the Contract shall be accepted, approved or decided by the Owner may be entrusted by the Owner to its authorized representative for determination within a period of fifteen (15) days. The latter shall in all such matters act as agent of the Owner whose determination binds the Owner. B. Should the Contractor disagree with the determination by the Owner or by its authorized representative, both parties shall attempt to settle the dispute amicably before the commencement of arbitration, otherwise, such shall be deemed a dispute which may be submitted to arbitration. However, unless both parties agree otherwise, the Contractor shall move to commence arbitration even if no attempt at an amicable settlement has been made. 33.05 Settlement of Disputes A. Dispute or Disagreement Submitted to Arbitration Any person who undertakes to do construction work for a project in the Philippines agrees to abide by and be bound by relevant Philippine laws and to settle construction disputes by arbitration. Any dispute arising out of or in connection with the Contract including any question regarding its existence, validity or termination not resolved as provided above shall be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration under the Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration promulgated pursuant to Executive Order No. 1008 (Construction Industry Arbitration Law), as amended by R.A. 9285 or the ADR Act of 2004, by either a panel of three (3) arbitrators or a Sole Arbitrator as may be agreed upon by the parties and appointed in accordance with such Rules. The place of arbitration shall be in Metro Manila, Philippines. B. Delivery of Notice A party to the Contract shall, by entering into the same, be deemed to be submitting itself to the jurisdiction of the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission with regard to any dispute arising out or in connection with the Contract as provided in Article 33.05, paragraph A above. 72 Such party shall be notified of the claim referred to in Article 33.05, paragraph A and other notices and processes incident thereto. Notifications or communications from the CIAC Secretariat and/or the Arbitrator(s) shall be validly made if they are delivered personally by an authorized representative of CIAC, by private courier, by registered mail to the address(es) or last known address(es) of the party(ies) for whom the same are intended appearing in the record, and/or by email sent to the email addresses of the party(ies) on record, at the option of the Secretariat/Arbitrator(s). Delivery of initial and subsequent communications from CIAC or from the arbitral tribunal to a party which has moved out of its address of record to an unknown address, may be made electronically or by some form of communication, approved by CIAC, to the latter’s last known address. It shall not be necessary to send more than one communication for this purpose. In case of a foreign corporation, notice may be given electronically or by registered air mail or by some form of communication to the latter’s last known address. If the foreign corporation cannot be given prompt and proper notice to that address, notice shall be given to its resident agent in the Philippines or to the Securities and Exchange Commission in accordance with the Corporation Code. The address of record of a party or the address in the Philippines given in the contract it signs shall be treated as its last known address unless later, it has given due notice to the parties to the contract of its change of address in which case, the latter address should be regarded as its last known address. Additionally, the address of record of the resident agent of a foreign corporation appearing in the record of appointment as resident agent in the Securities and Exchange Commission shall also be recognized as the address of record of the foreign corporation in the Philippines. Section X Owner's Representative The Owner’s Representative shall either be the Architect, the Engineer, Construction Manager or other person designated by the Owner as the Owner's Representative. The Owner's Representative shall have the full authority to act for and on behalf of the Owner in all matters which under the Contract the Owner shall give its consent, approval or decision. The Owner shall give the Contractor at the time of the Notice to Proceed or any time thereafter the notice of appointment of the Owner's Representative. Unless the Contractor is notified in writing by the Owner of the limits of authority of the Owner's Representative, it shall be 73 understood that the authority of the latter to act for and on behalf of the Owner is full and unqualified. In the absence of a written communication by the Owner to the Contractor notifying the latter of the designation of a particular person as Owner’s Representative, the Architect shall perform the functions and have the authority of the Owner's Representative if the project or Work involves the construction of a building; but if the project or Work involves the construction of an engineering structure, other than a building, or the construction of a building if such constitutes only a minor portion of the project, the Engineer shall perform the functions and have the authority of an Owner’s Representative. The Owner’s Representative shall also perform the function of Construction Manager unless the Owner designates another person as Construction Manager. If the Owner shall designate a Construction Manager and define its functions, those functions of a Construction Manager not delegated to the latter shall be performed by the Owner’s Representative. Notwithstanding the designation by the Owner of an Architect, Engineer and/or Construction Manager, communications between the Contractor and the Owner shall be made only through the Owner’s Representative. 74 Section XI Schedule of Time Limits The Contractor shall perform its Work subject to certain Time Limits. This indexed section, as based on the entire General Conditions, is provided in order to facilitate the execution of its Work. Title Time Limit Reference Article No. 1. Contract Time 1.1 Contract Time Reckoning The Contractor shall commence the Work within seven (7) days from receipt of Notice to Proceed (NTP) unless NTP provides for a later date. 21.02 1.2 Request for Time To be filed within fifteen (15) days from occurrence of event which caused delay. 21.04 (par. B) 2. Contract Sum 2.1 Breakdown of Work & Corresponding Value To be submitted within fifteen days from receipt of the Notice to Proceed 22.01 2.2 Claim for Extra Cost Notice to be given to Owner within fifteen (15) days 20.08 (1) after receipt of instruction involving extra cost, or (2) after recognition of delay due to Owner’s fault. 3. Progress/Final Payment 3.1 Owner’s Action on Payment Request To be made within thirty (30) days after receipt of request for payment. 3.2 Owner’s Action on Final Payment Request To act within thirty (30) days from receipt of the request for payment. 3.3 Delayed Payment Delay in payment of the amount due shall entitle the Contractor to interest from due date based on the thirty (30) day loan rate of the Land Bank of the Philippines 75 22.05 22.05 3.4 Release of Retention 4. Substantial Completion and its Effects To be released not later than sixty (60) days from substantial completion upon posting of Contractor’s Guarantee Bond. 22.11 Substantial Completion is attained if the Contractor completes ninety-five percent (95%) of the works; or the Owner approves the Contractor’s billing for completing at least 95% of the works unless the Owner can establish that the unfinished portion prevents the normal use of the completed portion. [pars. A(a) & (b)] 20.11 The Owner may issue a Certificate of Substantial Completion or equivalent document, but the date of document is not controlling if substantial completion is shown to have been attained earlier, unless the Contractor accepts the certificate without taking any exceptions thereto in writing within fifteen (15) days from receipt of the certificate. [par. A(c)] 5. Correction of Work 5.1 Issuance of Punch List The Owner shall issue the punch list/s which the Contractor must receive not later than thirty (30) days from date of substantial completion [par. C (a)]. 20.11 The Owner may add to the punch list items but only as to corrective work in the original punch list/s not later than sixty (60) days from substantial completion [par. C(b)]. 5.2 Correction Before or After Final Payment 5.3 Making Good of Known Defects 6. Contractor’s Right to Suspend Work or Terminate Contract Poor or inferior work, apparent upon inspection to be condemned & Contractor notified to enable him to correct, remove & replace the same. Owner has one year from date of final payment to condemn poor or inferior work, otherwise, instructions to remove or replace such shall be treated as change order. 22.10 Thirty (30) days from receipt by the Contractor of the last item in the punch list. 20.12 & 20.13 Contractor may suspend work or terminate Contract upon 15 days’ written notice to Owner, for any of the following reasons: 26 (a) Should an order of any court or other public authority caused the work to be stopped or 76 suspended for a period of ninety (90) days through no act or fault of the Contractor or its employees. (b) Should the Owner fail to pay the Contractor the approved Request for Payment within thirty (30) days from receipt. (c) Should the Owner fail to pay the Contractor any sum within thirty (30) days after its award by arbitrators. (d) Should the Owner suspend the work without just cause for more than a period of fifteen (15) days without the Contractor's consent. (e) Should the Owner fail to deliver at the construction site Owner-supplied/furnished construction materials and/or equipment, for the scope of work along the critical path, beyond fifteen (15) days after its scheduled date for delivery as provided for in the Contract. (f) Should approval of Variation Orders for additional works along the critical path be delayed beyond fifteen (15) days after submission for approval by the Owner or by its duly designated Representative. 7. Owner’s Right to Terminate Contract May be done immediately and without notice: 28.01 Should the Contractor declare bankruptcy, become insolvent or assigns its assets for the benefit of its creditors or appointment of trustee/ receiver for Contractor or any of its property. May be done after giving fifteen (15) days written notice to Contractor or to its Surety should the Contractor: (1) Disregard or violate provisions of the Contract Documents or Owner’s instructions; (2) Fail to provide skilled superintendent, workers or suitable materials or equipment; (3) Fail to make prompt payment to SubContractors, for labor or materials or equipment; (4) Disregard the authority of the Owner’s Representative; (5) Violate in any substantial way any provisions of the Contract Documents; 77 28.02 (6) Repeatedly delays prosecution of work per agreed Construction Schedule and/or time extension duly PERT/CPM plus any granted the Contractor. 8. Disputes The Owner or its representative shall act within a period of fifteen (15) days on all matters under the Contract requiring the Owner’s approval, acceptance or decision. 33.04 & 33.05 Should the Contractor disagree with the determination by the Owner or by its authorized representative, both parties shall attempt to settle the dispute amicably before the commencement of arbitration, otherwise, such shall be deemed a dispute which may be submitted to arbitration. However, unless both parties agree otherwise, the Contractor shall move to commence arbitration even if no attempt at an amicable settlement has been made. 9. Guarantee Bond 9.1 Contractor’s Guarantee Bond To be furnished the Owner upon release of retention and shall be effective for a period of one year commencing from the date of acceptance as a guarantee that all materials and workmanship installed are of acceptable quality. 78 31.05 APPENDIX 79 Appendix “A”. Amendments to CIAP Document 102 Minor change in the format and changes in the language used pertaining to gender, whereby sexist language such as he/him/his/workmen were changed to gender-fair language in compliance with the directive of the Civil Service Commission (CSC) (CSC Memo Circular No. 12-2005), encouraging the use of non-sexist language in all communications, issuances, and official documents, were among the amendments made in the 2004 Edition of CIAP Document 102, including updates and improvement on the following provisions, which are incorporated in the 2022 version: PROVISION CHANGES MADE Scope This document specifies general conditions of contract between a private owner and contractor applicable for the construction of any type of structure or works as contemplated in the Republic Act No. 4566 otherwise known as Contractors’ License Law. ART. 1: DEFINITIONS 1.06 BID DOCUMENTS 1.03 ADVERTISEMENT or INVITATION TO BID Article 1. Definitions For the purposes of this document, the following definitions apply: 1.02 advance payment down payment the money given by the Owner to the Contractor to help the latter underwrite significant start up or procurement costs that may have to be incurred before construction begins 1.04 As-Built drawings drawings showing the structure as actually constructed including system and actual locations of outlets, fixtures, services and equipment that were installed 1.08 Bid Documents collectively refer to all documents provided or made available to prospective bidders which include the Invitation to Bid, drawings and technical specifications and a copy of the Contract which the winning bidders would be required to sign with the Owner 1.21 Invitation to Bid the notice or advertisement published by the Owner or the invitation issued to prospective bidders, giving information as to the nature of the proposed project, conditions for the issuance of Contract documents, date of bidding, and information that would give the Contractor a general idea of the magnitude and extent of the project 1.22 last known address of a party refers to the address in the Philippines given by a party in the Contract. 80 New provision to define the scope and coverage of CIAP Document 102 Inserted to describe Art. 1 New item Lifted from Art. 22.08, item (c) -Other Requirements Before Final Payment Inserted “drawings and technical specifications” Deleted the word “Advertisement” in the title New item under definition of terms 1.28 retention is a sum on money, usually 10% or less of every progress payment to a Contractor which the Owner retains to underwrite future costs of completing the Contractor’s work and/or remedying the defects therein 1.13 CONTRACT DOCUMENTS documents attached to the Agreement identified therein as Contract Documents, including all additions, deletions and modifications incorporated therein. These generally include the following documents which shall form part of this Contract and constitute integral parts hereof: Inserted phrase “which shall form part of this Contract and constitute integral parts hereof”. Special Provisions or Conditions; General Conditions; Specifications; Drawings; Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof; Contractor`s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof; and other Bid Documents Inserted “Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof” and “Contractor`s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof” as items (e) and (f) (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) 2.03 INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACT (a) RULE 4 New item under definition of terms RULE 4: Where the conflict cannot be resolved by applying Rule 3 or where Rule 3 does not apply, the conflict shall be resolved by giving precedence to the Agreement or to provisions of a Contract Document higher in order of priority among the various documents which comprise the Contract. The order of priority among these documents shall be as follows: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (h)(j) (i)(k) Agreement as modified by Notice of Award of Contract, if such be the case, and the Contractor's conformity thereto; Instruction to Bidders and any amendment thereto; Addenda to Bid Documents; Specifications; Drawings; Special Conditions of Contract; General Conditions of Contract; Drawings; Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof; Contractor`s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof; Other Contract Documents; and Other documents forming part of the Contract attached thereto or incorporated therein by reference. Where the order of precedence is modified in the Agreement, such modified order of precedence shall be followed; however, the mere listing of Contract Documents in the Agreement or any Contract Document shall not be interpreted as establishing an order of precedence among them. 81 Changed the order and moved “Drawings” after the “General Conditions of Contract”. Inserted “Contractor’s Performance and Payment Bonds contemplated in Clause 31.04 hereof” and Contractor`s Guarantee Bond contemplated in Clause 31.05 hereof” as items H and I. 2.04 CONFORMITY TO THE CONTRACT 2.05 a. MEANING OF TERMS 2.05 b. 2.05 c. 2.05 d. A. If there be a variance between the Drawings and the Specifications, the provisions of the Specifications shall control prevail. In case of conflict between the General Conditions or any modification thereof and the detailed specification requirements, the detailed specification requirements shall control prevail. 2.05 Meaning of Terms (a) The words approved, directed and acceptable, or words of like shall mean approved by, directed by, or acceptable to the Owner. (b) The word furnish shall be understood to mean to purchase and/or fabricate and deliver to the jobsite or other location when so designated. (c) The word install shall mean to build in, mount in positions, connect or apply any object specified ready for the intended use. (d) The word provide shall be understood to mean to furnish and install. 2.05 e. (e) The words required or necessary shall mean as required or necessary for the complete execution of that portion of the Work. 5.03 LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL: 5.03 Letter of Transmittal Submission of shop drawings shall be accompanied by a letter of transmittal in duplicate, containing the name of the project, the Contractor's name, reference drawing number, titles, and other pertinent data. 10.02 Brand Name Materials and Substitutes (a) Whenever an item or class of materials is specified exclusively by brand name, manufacturer’s name or catalog reference, only such item shall be used except as provided in paragraph (b) hereof. 10.06 Defective Materials 10.02 TRADE NAME MATERIALS AND SUBSTITUTES: 10.06 DEFECTIVE MATERIALS: All materials different from the Specifications shall be considered non-conforming to the minimum requirements. The Contractor shall remove or replace materials different from the Specifications when ordered to do so by the Owner. Upon the Contractor’s failure to do so, the Owner may remove and replace them and deduct the cost of removal and replacement from any money due or to become due the Contractor. No materials, the defects of which have been subsequently corrected, shall be used until the Owner’s approval is given. Changed the word “control” to “prevail” Deleted the subtitle “approved, directed and acceptable” and “import” Deleted the subtitle “furnish” Deleted the subtitle “install” Deleted the subtitle “provide” Deleted the subtitle “required or necessary” Inserted the “reference” word Changed the word “trade” into “brand” Inserted the word “different from” and “non-conforming to the minimum requirements” Should the Specifications, Drawings, Special Provisions and Supplementary Specifications fail to provide any detail or description concerning the nature and quality of the Work to be performed, it should be understood that generally accepted construction practice shall be followed. ART. 11: MATERIALS, EQUIPMENT, FIXTURES, APPLIANCES AND FITTINGS FURNISHED BY THE OWNER Article 11 Materials, Equipment, Fixtures, Appliances and Fittings Furnished by the Owner Materials, equipment, fixtures, appliances and fittings specifically indicated in the Contract shall be provided in accordance with the Ownerapproved construction schedule. Materials furnished by the Owner shall be deemed acceptable for the purpose intended. The 82 Added as new 3rd paragraph Contractor may continue to use them until otherwise directed in writing by the Owner. No further test shall be required unless the Owner directs otherwise and pays the cost of such test. Should the Contractor discover any defect in materials furnished by the Owner, the Contractor shall advise the Owner in writing. The Contractor shall be responsible for material loss of or damage to any Owner-provided material, equipment, fixture, appliance or fitting in its custody. 14.02 SAFEGUARD FOR STRUCTURE: 15.03 SAFETY AND SANITATION: 15.04 TEMPORARY SIGN 16.01 SAFEGUARD MEASURES: Unused Owner-supplied materials, equipment, fixtures, appliances and fittings, the cost of which was not charged to the Contractor and did not form part of the Contract Price, shall belong to the Owner which shall be returned to the Owner by the Contractor upon completion of the Work. Those the cost of which was charged to the Contractor and deducted from its Contract Price shall belong to the Contractor. 14.02 Safeguard for Structure The Contractor shall not load or permit any part of the structure to be loaded with a weight that will endanger its safety. The Contractor shall enforce the Owner’s safety instructions regarding signs, advertisements, fires and smoking, and any other factors that may cause endangerment to safety. 15.03 Safety and Sanitation The Contractor, from the commencement of the Work up to completion, shall: a) furnish and put up all temporary barricades and guard lights necessary for the protection, proper prosecution and completion of the Work; b) maintain guard lights at the top of the following, but not limited to: falsework tower, barricades, railings; c) provide and maintain sufficient sanitary toilet accommodation and other necessary conveniences including but not limited to water connections for the use of personnel and laborers on the work properly secluded from public observation in such manner and at such points as shall be approved by the Owner, use shall be strictly enforced; d) keep such places clean and free from pests; and e) remove all connections and appliances connected therewith prior to the completion of the Work. 15.04 Temporary Signs Signs or advertisements shall only be displayed upon the approval of the Owner. The Contractor may erect one painted sign indicating the names and addresses of the Owner, the Contractor, and the various SubContractors. The Owner shall approve the size, color, lettering, and location of such temporary signs. 16.01 Safeguard Measures The Contractor shall: a) take all reasonable measures to protect from damage: - the Works; - the Owner's property, and; 83 Added the phrase “and any other factors that may cause endangerment to safety” Reword “until its” to “up to” and added the word “shall” Added in item (b) the phrase “but not limited to” For item (c), changed the word “ample sanitary” into “sufficient” and added the phrase “conveniences including but not limited to” Changed the word “flies” into “pests” in item (d) Rephrased paragraph changed the “giving” “indicating” this and word into Changed “watchmen” into “security personnel” 16.03 TREES AND OTHER PLANTS: 16.03 b. ART. 18: PROTECTION OF LIFE, WORK AND PROPERTY DURING AN EMERGENCY 18.01 AUTHORIZATION TO CONTRACTOR: ART. 19: LABOR - the equipment, materials, appliances and fixtures supplied or paid for by the Owner; - and shall make good any damage, injury or loss thereto, except such as may be caused by agents or employees of the Owner, or due to causes considered as Acts of God; b) provide reliable and competent security personnel to guard the site and premises, provide all doorways with locks under the Contractor’s control and lock such doors at the close of each day's work; provided, however, that if the Owner deems the security service inadequate or incompetent, the Contractor shall increase or change the security personnel; c) prohibit smoking at the site and post signs to this effect at conspicuous places; d) prohibit fires built on the site except by expressed consent of the Owner; and (e) provide and maintain in good working order an adequate number of fire-fighting equipment and such equipment shall not be used for any other purpose. 16.03 Trees and Other Plants Existing vegetation such as but not limited to trees, plants, and shrubs, identified by the owner to remain at site shall be boxed and otherwise protected from damage. Trees within the site located outside building lines shall not be cut or removed without written approval from the Owner and appropriate authorities. (b) Any damage to the abovementioned vegetation, streets, and sidewalks, resulting from fault or negligence of the Contractor in connection with the execution of the Work shall be made good and/or replaced or repaired by, at the contractor’s own expense. Article 18 Authorization to Contractor for the Protection of Life, Work and Property During an Emergency In an emergency endangering life, the Work or the adjoining property, the Contractor, even without special instruction or authorization from the Owner, shall act, at its discretion, to prevent or minimize such threatened loss or injury. Emergency work performed by the Contractor shall be treated as one performed under a Change Order unless the emergency was caused or brought about by its fault or negligence. Article 19 Labor The Contractor shall employ only competent and duly qualified professionals, technical personnel, foremen, and construction workers to execute the Work. 84 Inserted the phrases “vegetation such as but not limited to” and “identified by the owner”. Reworded the second sentence, and added the highlighted words “written” and “and appropriate authorities.” Reworded the phrase “Damage to trees, plants, shrubs” Modified original title from “ Authorization to Contractor” to “Authorization to Contractor for the Protection of Life, Work and Property During an Emergency” Modified text under Art. 19.01 and moved Art. 19. Labor. 19.01 CHARACTER OF WORKMEN: Deleted the rest of the sentence which says:“ Upon written request of the Owner, the Contractor shall remove from the site an employee who is careless or incompetent or obstructs the progress of the work or acts contrary to instructions or conducts himself improperly.” Removed “Character Workmen” ART. 20: WORK 20.13 MAKING GOOD OF KNOWN DEFECTS OR FAULTS: Article 20 Work The purpose of this Article is to ensure that the Contractor is paid for Work completed and for the Owner to retain such portion of the Contract Price, which, together with the Performance Bond, is sufficient to complete the Work without additional cost to the Owner. 20.13 Making Good of Known Defects or Faults The Contractor shall execute at its own expense all works necessary for making good of known defects, imperfections or faults (wear and tear excepted) within the period stated in Article 20.12. Should the defect or fault be due to a cause attributable to the Owner, the value of such work shall be ascertained and paid for as if it were additional work. 20.16 ADJUSTMENT OF PRICES: 20.16 Adjustment of Prices This Article 20.16 shall not apply to an increase or decrease in the cost of materials and services provided or supplied by the Owner. A. There shall be added to or deducted from the Contract Price such sums affecting the execution of the Work caused by any of the following: a) an event of force majeure including abnormal changes in costs of materials; b) increases in labor costs mandated by law or wage order; 85 subtitle of Originally 20.11 E 2nd paragraph was rephrased as shown. Deleted the subsequent paragraph which says: “If the Contractor shall fail to do any such corrective work, the Owner shall, upon written notice to the Contractor, be entitled to carry out such work by his own workmen or by other contractors, and charge the cost thereof to the Contractor. The Owner may withhold an amount not exceeding the Contract cost of executing such work from the payment to the Contractor.” Highlighted portion was originally item F of same article (Art. 20.16) 20.16 B. 22.04 CONDITIONS RELATIVE TO PAYMENTS: 22.09 ACCEPTANCE AND FINAL PAYMENT: c) increase in the cost of oil, and; d) the deterioration of peace and order. B. Adjustment of prices due to escalation or reduction of costs of executing the work shall be made using a parametric formula to be agreed upon by the parties. Such adjustment shall be made to provide equitable relief to both the Owner and the Contractor, allowing neither to gain nor to lose by such fluctuation. Adjustment of the Contract Price due to escalation shall be for the sole purpose of compensating the Contractor for the increase in the direct cost of its labor and materials used for the Work, plus value-added tax. 22.04 Conditions Relative to Payments The Owner shall estimate the value of work accomplished by the Contractor using the schedule stipulated in the Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Value as basis. Such estimate of the Owner of the amount of work performed shall be taken as the basis for the compensation to be received by the Contractor. While such preliminary estimates of amount and quantity shall not be required to be made by strict measurement or with exactness, these must be made as close as possible to the actual percentage of work accomplishment. 22.09 Acceptance and Final Payment Whenever the Contractor notifies the Owner that the Work under the Contract has been completely performed by the Contractor, the Owner shall proceed to verify the work, make the final estimates, certify to the completion of the work, and accept the same. D. The Owner shall then, except for causes herein specified, pay to the Contractor within the period stated in Article 22.05, the amount which shall be found due, excepting therefrom such sum or sums as may be lawfully retained under any of the provisions of the Contract; provided that final payment on the Contract shall not be made until the Contractor has submitted a statement sworn to before an officer duly authorized to administer oath, showing that all taxes due from it in connection with this Contract have been duly paid. E. In case the Owner has reasonable grounds of belief that the Contractor has not remitted to the appropriate government agency the employer's and employee's contributions to the Social Security System or to Medicare or the withholding tax on the employees' wages, the Owner may require evidence of remittance of such contributions or withholding tax in addition to the sworn statement mentioned above, and withholding release of the amount sufficient to cover such payments until the evidence required by the Owner is provided by the Contractor. F. The acceptance by the Contractor of final payment shall constitute a waiver of all its 86 The TWG approved the deletion of the phrase “In default of such agreement, the parametric formula under applicable laws shall be applied.” Inserted the phrase “as basis” Deleted the phrase “to the Social Security System or to Medicare” claims against the Owner, except the following: (a) a claim covered by a prior notice to the Owner reserved by the Contractor to be filed in accordance with the Contract; (b) a claim pending before and unresolved by the Owner at the time the request for final payment is made; (c) a dispute referred to arbitration in accordance with Article 33.05; and (d) a claim which the Owner acknowledges with the payment not to be covered by it. 22.10 CORRECTIONS OF WORK BEFORE OR AFTER FINAL PAYMENT: 22.10 Corrections of Work Before or After Final Payment A. Acceptance by the Owner of the Work of the Contractor shall relieve the Contractor of liability for any defect in the Work unless: a) The defect is hidden and the Owner could not have discovered the defect even with the exercise of reasonable diligence. b) The Owner accepted the Work with express reservations seasonably made as to the specific portion of the Work which was found defective and which requires replacement or correction. A reservation which fails to specify the portion alleged to be defective and also fails to state in as much detail as possible the nature and extent of the defect shall be considered a general reservation and shall be ineffective. Added phrase “also fails” B. Paragraph A shall apply notwithstanding the issuance of the final certificate of completion or of full payment. ART. 24: CONTRACTORSEPARATE CONTRACTORS RELATIONS 30.01 SAFEGUARDS TO BE UNDERTAKEN BY CONTRACTOR: Article 24 Contractor and Separate Contractors Relations Added “and” in the title of the article 30.01 Safeguards to be Undertaken by Contractor Modified last part “in accordance with the safety manual approved by the Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines (CIAP)” into “R.A. No. 11058, An Act Strengthening Compliance with Occupational Safety and Health Standards and Providing Penalties for Violations.” The Contractor shall take all necessary precautions for the safety of employees and workers on the Work, and comply with all Laws to prevent injury to persons on, about or adjacent to the premises where the Work is being performed. The Contractor shall erect and properly maintain at all times, as required by the conditions and progress of the Work, such barriers, shoring, supports, braces, lights, danger signs and necessary safeguards, as will protect workers and the public and as will effectively prevent any injury to persons and damage to property in consequence of its work. The Contractor shall designate a responsible member of its organization at the site, whose duty shall be the prevention of accidents and damage to the Work, the Owner's property and adjoining property. The name and position of the person so designated shall be reported by the Contractor in writing to the Owner. 87 The Contractor shall be primarily responsible for all safety measures in prosecuting the Work in accordance with R.A. No. 11058, An Act Strengthening Compliance with Occupational Safety and Health Standards and Providing Penalties for Violations. 31.02 ACCIDENT INSURANCE FOR WORKERS: 31.07 MANDATORY CONDITIONS OF BONDS 31.02 Accident Insurance for Workers The Contractor shall, in addition to coverage of workers under applicable statutory and regulatory requirements on workers’ compensation, obtain insurance coverage for accidental death or injury of its officers, employees and laborers without regard to tenure of employment as permanent or regular workers, project workers or casual employees performing work at the project site in an amount of not less than P100,000.00 per officer, employee or laborer. The premiums to be paid on the insurance policy shall be paid by the Contractor and without cost to those covered by the policy. 31.07 Mandatory Conditions of Bonds The bonds required of the Contractor shall be subject to mandatory conditions which shall form part of said bonds. A surety issuing any bond called for in the Contract is deemed conclusively to have accepted the following conditions: a) The Surety or bondsman agrees in advance to future novation/s of the bond either by adjusting the scope of the Work of the Contractor caused by directed or constructive changes, the Completion Time or the Contract Price. Where the Contract provides that the Contractor shall obtain the approval of the surety to any such adjustment, the required approval shall be deemed to be a mere formality, the absence of which shall not affect the obligation and liability of the Surety under the bond. b) The bond issued by Surety or bondsman under the Contract shall continue to have force and effect beyond the effectivity period stated in the bond if the Work or the obligation for which it was issued has not been completely performed. This is without prejudice to the right of the Surety to demand from the Contractor the payment of the premium on the bond or to the right of the Owner to pay such unpaid premium for the Contractor. The additional premium on the bond for an extension of the Contract time due to reasons other than the fault or negligence of the Contractor shall be billed at cost to the Owner. The bond may not be cancelled or otherwise terminated by the Surety without the express written consent of both the Owner and the Contractor. The right of the Surety shall be limited to demand the payment of unpaid premium. c) The Owner shall have a right of recourse against the Surety on the bond until: • it is cancelled by the Owner and returned to the Contractor; 88 Deleted the phrase “in an amount of not less than P100,000.00 per officer, employee or laborer” Deleted the word “bondsman • • it is replaced by another bond unless the Owner reserves the right to recover against the former bond due to default of the Contractor; the Owner issues to the Contractor an unconditional Certificate of Acceptance of the Work. Until the Owner takes over the Work (not only a part thereof) or otherwise terminates the Contract, the Contractor shall not be deemed in default, notwithstanding the reduction of the Contractor's scope of work and any assistance provided by the Owner to enable the Contractor to catch up and complete the remaining work. The Owner's assistance to the Contractor shall not prejudice nor limit the right of the Owner to have a later recourse against the bond. 33.04 DISPUTES: A. Any provision in the bond thereby issued or in any document made prior to, concurrent with, or after the issuance of the bond which tends to nullify, modify, or limit by time or otherwise, any right of the Owner shall be void and shall not prevail over the above conditions. 33.04 Disputes A. All matters which under the Contract shall be accepted, approved or decided by the Owner may be entrusted by the Owner to its authorized representative for determination within a period of fifteen (15) days. The latter shall in all such matters act as agent of the Owner whose determination binds the Owner. B. B. Should the Contractor disagree with the determination by the Owner or by its authorized representative, both parties shall attempt to settle the dispute amicably before the commencement of arbitration, otherwise, such shall be deemed a dispute which may be submitted to arbitration. However, unless both parties agree otherwise, the Contractor shall move to commence arbitration even if no attempt at an amicable settlement has been made. 33.05 Settlement of Disputes 33.05 Settlement of Disputes A. A. Dispute arbitration DISPUTE OR DISAGREEMENT SUBMITTED TO ARBITRATION or disagreement submitted to A. Dispute or Disagreement Submitted to Arbitration Any person who undertakes to do construction work for a project in the Philippines agrees to abide by and be bound by relevant Philippine laws and to settle construction disputes by arbitration. 89 Original paragraph states: “… such disagreement shall be brought before an adjudicator, who shall be jointly engaged by the Owner and the Contractor, not later than fifteen (15) days before the commencement of the Work to resolve conflicts arising from the foregoing determination by the Owner or by his representative. If either of the party disagrees with the resolution of the adjudicator, such shall be deemed as a dispute which may be submitted to arbitration.” xxx Inserted new paragraph “Any person who undertakes to do construction work for a project in the Philippines agrees to abide by and be bound by relevant Philippine laws and to settle construction Any dispute arising out of or in connection with the Contract including any question regarding its existence, validity or termination not resolved as provided above shall be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration under the Rules of Procedure Governing Construction Arbitration promulgated pursuant to Executive Order No. 1008 (Construction Industry Arbitration Law), by panel of three (3) arbitrators appointed in accordance with such Rules as amended by R.A. 9285 or the ADR Act of 2004, by either a panel of three (3) arbitrators or a Sole Arbitrator as may be agreed upon by the parties and appointed in accordance with such Rules. The place of arbitration shall be in Metro Manila, Philippines. Resort to arbitration shall be made by filing a claim with the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission. B. SUBSTITUTED SERVICE B. Substituted Service Delivery of Notice A party to the Contract shall, by entering into the same, be deemed to be submitting itself to the jurisdiction of the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission with regard to any dispute arising out or in connection with the Contract as provided in Article 33.05, paragraph A above. Such party shall be notified served with of the claim referred to in Article 34.05 33.05, paragraph A and other notices and processes incident thereto upon such claim being served upon or filed with his co-venturer, partner or authorized representative, notwithstanding any statement to the contrary in the Agreement, Contract Documents, or any other communication to the other party or after entering into the Contract, unless he has filed with the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission an irrevocable special power of attorney authorizing another person or entity to receive by personal service at a definite address in Metro Manila, Philippines, such claim, notice and processes. In case a party, his co-venturer, or authorized representative declines service of such claim, notice or process or cannot be found at his given address such service shall be made upon the said party by filing the same with the Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines (CIAP) at its 54 office address, and filing the claim, notice or process shall complete the service upon the party concerned. 90 disputes arbitration.” by Deleted phrase “by panel of three (3) arbitrators appointed in accordance with such Rules” and inserted “as amended by R.A. 9285 or the ADR Act of 2004, by either a panel of three (3) arbitrators or a Sole Arbitrator as may be agreed upon by the parties and appointed in accordance with such Rules”. Deleted the sentence: “Resort to arbitration shall be made by filing a claim with the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission.” Changed title of clause to “Delivery of Notice”. Modified 2nd paragraph, see deletions. Add new paragraphs #3-6. Notifications or communications from the CIAC Secretariat and/or the Arbitrator(s) shall be validly made if they are delivered personally by an authorized representative of CIAC, by private courier, by registered mail to the address(es) or last known address(es) of the party(ies) for whom the same are intended appearing in the record, and/or by email sent to the email addresses of the party(ies) on record, at the option of the Secretariat/Arbitrator(s). Delivery of initial and subsequent communications from CIAC or from the arbitral tribunal to a party which has moved out of its address of record to an unknown address, may be made electronically or by some form of communication, approved by CIAC, to the latter’s last known address. It shall not be necessary to send more than one communication for this purpose. In case of a foreign corporation, notice may be given electronically or by registered air mail or by some form of communication to the latter’s last known address. If the foreign corporation cannot be given prompt and proper notice to that address, notice shall be given to its resident agent in the Philippines or to the Securities and Exchange Commission in accordance with the Corporation Code. The address of record of a party or the address in the Philippines given in the contract it signs shall be treated as its last known address unless later, it has given due notice to the parties to the contract of its change of address in which case, the latter address should be regarded as its last known address. Additionally, the address of record of the resident agent of a foreign corporation appearing in the record of appointment as resident agent in the Securities and Exchange Commission shall also be recognized as the address of record of the foreign corporation in the Philippines. 91 92