CANON 2, Propriety Section 26 & Section 27 Mark Harris R. Lim Juris Doctor 1 Section 26. Definition of a Law Firm; choice of firm name. • A law firm is any private office, partnership, or association, exclusively comprised of a lawyer or lawyers engaged to practice law, and who hold themselves out as such to the public. • In the choice of a firm name, no false, misleading, or assumed name shall be used. The continued use of the name of a deceased, incapacitated, or retired partner is permissible provided that the firm indicates in all its communications that said partner is deceased, incapacitated, or retired. Definition of Law Firm Definition of a Law Firm: A law firm is a specific type of professional organization. Upholding ethics and professionalism in the legal field Section 26. Definition of Law Firm; Choice of Firm Name Partners: Honoring Deceased, incapacitated, or retired partners Firm name Selection Rules Firm Name Selection and Restrictions: The name of a law firm is subject to strict regulations to maintain transparency and ethical standards. Definition of Law Firm • A private office, partnership, or association: It can take various legal structures. • Comprised exclusively of lawyers: All members must be licensed to practice law. • Engaged in the practice of law: The primary purpose is to provide legal services. • Holds themselves out as such to the public: They must clearly convey their legal profession to the public. Firm Name Guidelines • No false, misleading, or assumed names allowed: Firm names must accurately reflect their composition and purpose. • Names must accurately represent the firm's composition and practice: This emphasizes the importance of honesty in naming. • Key principle: Honesty and transparency in naming: The primary principle is to maintain the trust of clients and the public. Partners 1.Equity Partner vs. Non-Equity Partner: Within law firms, there can be distinctions between equity partners and non-equity partners. Equity partners have a financial stake in the firm; they share in the profits and losses and often have voting rights in the firm's decision-making processes. Non-equity partners may not have the same financial investment but are recognized as partners due to their contributions to the firm's legal practice. 2.Responsibilities: Partners in a law firm typically have various responsibilities. They may be responsible for managing client relationships, overseeing legal cases, mentoring junior lawyers, and participating in the firm's business decisions. Partners often play a critical role in shaping the direction and reputation of the firm. 3.Use of Partner's Name: It addresses situations where a partner has either retired, become incapacitated, or passed away. Even in these circumstances, the firm may continue to use the partner's name, provided that it clearly indicates the partner's status in all communications. Use of Deceased Partner's Name Use of Incapacitated Partner's Name Use of Retired Partner's Name Permissible to continue using the Similar to deceased partners, name of a deceased partner: This is a continued use is allowed: It respects way to honor their legacy. the partner's contributions. Permissible to keep a retired partner's name in the firm's title Condition: Firm must indicate the partner's status (retired) in all communications Recognizes the partner's contributions while conveying their current role Condition: Firm must indicate the partner's status (deceased) in all communications: This ensures transparency about the partner's status. Condition: Firm must indicate the partner's status (incapacitated) in all communications: This maintains clarity about the partner's capacity to practice. Recognizes the partner's contributions while conveying their current role Upholding ethics and professionalism in the legal field 1.Upholding Ethical Standards: Adhering to guidelines on law firm names is crucial to maintain the ethical standards of the legal profession. It ensures that lawyers operate with honesty and integrity, which are foundational principles in legal practice. Non-compliance can lead to ethical violations and damage a lawyer's professional standing. 2.Building Client Trust: Compliance with these guidelines is essential to establish and preserve trust with clients. It guarantees transparency and honesty in representing the law firm's composition, preventing any misleading information. Failure to comply can erode client trust, resulting in dissatisfaction and potential legal disputes. 3.Safeguarding Reputation: These guidelines help maintain the overall integrity and reputation of lawyers and the legal profession. They reflect the profession's commitment to ethical conduct. Non-compliance can tarnish the reputation of both individual lawyers and the legal field, making it harder to gain trust from clients, judges, and the community. Definition of Law Firm Definition of a Law Firm: A law firm is a specific type of professional organization. Upholding ethics and professionalism in the legal field Section 26. Definition of Law Firm; Choice of Firm Name Partners: Honoring Deceased, incapacitated, or retired partners Firm name Selection Rules Firm Name Selection and Restrictions: The name of a law firm is subject to strict regulations to maintain transparency and ethical standards. SECTION 27. Partner who assumes public office. • When a partner assumes public office, such partner shall withdraw from the firm and such partner's name shall be removed from the firm name, unless allowed by law to practice concurrently. When Partner Assumes Public Office Withdrawal from the Firm & Name Removal Prevents conflicts of interest. Partner must withdraw from the firm. Ensures public duty prioritization. Partner's name is removed from the firm name. Enhances transparency. Legal exceptions may apply. Clarifies representation. Section 27. Partner who assumes public office Concurrent Practice & Upholding Legal Ethics Some jurisdictions allow concurrent practice. Compliance with relevant laws is crucial. Ensures ethical legal practice. Preserves professional integrity. Summary of Section 27 Withdrawal when assuming public office. Partner's name removal. Legal exceptions possible. Situations: • Situation 1 - Compliance with Section 27: Attorney Zalman, a partner in a law firm, is appointed as a commissioner in a government agency tasked with drafting new legislation. Recognizing his ethical obligations, Manuel withdraws from his law firm, and his name is removed from the firm's name. He diligently follows the guidelines in Section 27 and the CPRA, ensuring a clear separation between his public office and private legal practice. This compliance maintains the integrity of the legal profession and upholds the ethical standards set by the CPRA. • Situation 2 - Non-Compliance with Section 27: In another scenario, Attorney Florence Jay is appointed as a judge in a regional trial court. However, she continues to be listed as a partner in her law firm's name and actively participates in the firm's operations. This situation violates Section 27, as Florence Jay has not withdrawn from her firm, and her name has not been removed. Such non-compliance not only disregards ethical guidelines but also risks conflicts of interest and undermines the public's trust in the legal profession, contrary to the principles of the CPRA. Situations: • Exemption Example under CPRA: Attorney Ronel, a seasoned lawyer, is appointed as the head of a government agency responsible for regulating environmental matters. His expertise is crucial to fulfilling the agency's mission. The CPRA acknowledges exemptions that allow lawyers to hold public office and practice law concurrently when the public interest requires their expertise. (Due to existing rules/exigent situation) • In this case, Attorney Ronel can continue his private practice while serving as the agency head. He does so by ensuring that his private clients' interests do not conflict with his public responsibilities. This exemption strikes a balance between contributing legal expertise to the government and maintaining a private practice, in line with the CPRA's principles of upholding the rule of law and public service. Laws that Allow Concurrent Capacities 1.The Code of Professional Responsibility for Attorneys (Section 27) 2.The Local Government Code (Republic Act No. 7160): 1. Section 90 of this law allows lawyers working in local government units (LGUs) to engage in private law practice, provided they do not handle cases adverse to the LGU they serve. 3.The Civil Service Commission (CSC) Rules: 1. The CSC provides guidelines for government employees, including lawyers, who wish to engage in private practice. These rules outline the procedures and limitations for such dual employment. 4.The Government Corporate Counsel Act (Republic Act No. 2327): 1. Lawyers appointed as Government Corporate Counsel are explicitly allowed to continue private practice, subject to certain restrictions.