SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DISCIPLINES AND IDEAS IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES Quarter 2 – Module 1: Institutionalism and Feminist Theory Disciplines and Ideas in the Social Sciences (DISS) Alternative Delivery Mode Quarter 2 – Module 1: Institutionalism and Feminist Theory First Edition, 2020 Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things, impose as a condition the payment of royalties. Borrowed materials (i.e., songs, stories, poems, pictures, photos, brand names, trademarks, etc.) included in this module are owned by their respective copyright holders. Every effort has been exerted to locate and seek permission to use these materials from their respective copyright owners. The publisher and authors do not represent nor claim ownership over them. Published by the Department of Education Secretary: Leonor Magtolis Briones Undersecretary: Diosdado M. San Antonio Development Team of the Module Writer: Ezra May A. Corona MAT-Soc. Sci. Editor: Daisy A. Grafil Reviewer: Ed Vincent A. Cahulugan Illustrator: Layout Artist: Management Team: Bianito Dagatan, Division Schools Superintendent, SDO- Bohol Casiana P. Caberte, PhD, OIC-ASDS Marina S. Salamanca, PhD, CESO VI, ASDS Carmela M. Restificar, EPSvr. Kindergarten, OIC CID Chief Jupiter I. Maboloc, PhD, EPS Araling Panlipunan Josephine D. Eronico, PhD, EPSvr. LRMDS What I Need to Know This module was designed and written with you in mind. It is here to help you master the Institutionalism and Feminist Theory. The scope of this module permits it to be used in many different learning situations. The language used recognizes the diverse vocabulary level of students. The lessons are arranged to follow the standard sequence of the course. But the order in which you read them can be changed to correspond with the textbook you are now using. In this module you will learn about: 1. The basic concepts and principles of Institutionalism and Feminist Theory Lesson 2 Institutionalism and Feminist Theory Institutionalism is a general approach to governance and social science. It concentrates on institutions and studies them using inductive, historical, and comparative methods (Bevir 2009).Institutions, according to AlejandriaGonzalez (2016) are patterns, routines, norms, rules, and schemes that govern and direct social thought and action. It is an approach that aims to understand and analyze how actions, thoughts, and meanings penetrate the social consciousness deeply enough to embed themselves into the social psyche. Institutionalism, at its core, studies how institutions achieve balance and stability as they Photo credit: Word Press manipulate their different regulative, normative, and cognitive functions. The dynamics that happen when these three functions try to meet or comply with environmental and organizational structures is where institutionalism as a theory presents itself as a model for research analysis (AlejandriaGonzalez 2016). Feminism or feminist theory, on the other hand, studies gender and its relation to power, and the dynamics these two concepts play out in economics, politics, sexuality, race, and nationality, among others. It is both a sociological perspective and a philosophy that aims to promotes gen der equality, social justice, and women’s rights (Alejandria-Gonzalez 2016). Feminism is support for equality for women and men. It strives for gender equality. The primary concern that tries to address is the oppression of women in society and the patriarchal structures of most societies. There Photo credit: Clipartkey are various ways to approach this theory, both females and males who identify themselves as feminists may disagree on many things (3G Elearning FZ LLC 2017). What’s New FILL ME UP! Institutions (both formal and informal) control behavior of the society in different aspects. On the list are basic formal and informal institutions. Categorize each institution whether formal or informal, give a specific example and explain briefly how it controls social behavior (PHINMA-Araullo University 2020). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Institution LAWS BELIEFS EDUCATION GOVERNMENT VALUES NORMS Type GIVE ME MEANING! Read the poem below and answer the questions. I Stay at Home by Guy Farmer While I Stay at home Tending to the boiling pot On the stove, scrubbing the Floor to a fine shine, Example Cleaning the streaks off the windows, Dreaming of being in a classroom Traveling to colorful new words. 1. What did you feel after reading the poem? 2. Give the meaning behind the poem. Write at least 4-7 sentences. What is It I. INSTITUTIONALISM Institutions It includes any form of constraint (formal or informal) that human beings devise to shape their interaction (Arthur S. Abulencia 2017) “Institutions are the rules of the game in a society; more formally, they are the humanly devised constraints that shape human Photo credit: EURAC Research interaction. In consequence they structure incentives in exchange whether political, social, or economic” (North 1991) They are also social political, economic, and cultural structures, customs, practices, and mechanisms of social cooperation, order and governance that determine the rules of games that govern the behavior of individuals. Institutions are manifest in both formal organizations and informal social order and organization (Arthur S. Abulencia 2017). Features of Institutions • Institutions are a structural feature of the society or polity. They are created with the only reason: decrease uncertainty. • Stable over time. • They must pose constraints and affect individual behavior of its members. Institutionalism as defined by Abulencia, et al (2017) is a method by which scholars take institutions as subject of study to find and trace patterns and sequences of social, political, economic behavior and change across time and space. It relies heavily on case studies, and most of these studies rely heavily on the study of formal institutions or formal rules. Moreover, they were highly normative and deterministic, such as the linearity of history as Hegel, Marx and others did. Marx’s arguments relied on “social class”, Weber on “bureaucracy”, Durkheim on “the division of labor”, which identifies it as the sole determination of social changes. Types of Institutionalism 1. Old institutionalism- characterized itself by legalism, structuralism, holism, historicism, and normative analysis (Peters 1999). 2. New institutionalism- avoids the deterministic approaches to history and emphasizes the autonomous role of institutions in shaping human behavior and history. Institutions are treated as “actors” making choices based on some “collective” interests, preferences, goals, alternatives, and expectations. This is referred to as “rationality” Contemporary approaches to Institutionalism 1. Historical Institutionalism- the actors are both determined by and are producers of history. Ellen Immergut (1998) recognizes that institutions operate in environment consisting of other institutions, called institutional environment. Much of the research deals with the influence of institutions on human behavior through rules, norms, and another framework. Moreover, it is path dependence. 2. Rational Choice Institutionalism- explains behavior of individuals by emphasizing how institutions can create situations in which rational choice/collective action paradoxes are resolved. It relies on the assumption of actors will act rationally in response to this structure of costs and benefits, and seek to maximize their utility while minimizing costs (Arthur S. Abulencia 2017). 3. Sociological Institutionalism- behavior can be explained by reference institutions whose form and structure are importantly influenced by culture as well as by function, with “culture” referencing symbols, ceremonies, etc., that are specific to modes of activities not just territorial regions (Arthur S. Abulencia 2017). FORMAL AND INFORMAL INSTITUTIONS Formal organizations, generally identified as “institutions,” may be deliberately and intentionally created by people in society to satisfy basic needs for existence. The development and function of institutions in general may seem universal in all society. Institutions develop and function in a pattern similar of social organizations but cover a more defined Photo credit: Kissclipart and focused goal and have a larger scope of operation, which goes beyond the conscious intentions of the individual humans involved (Myla M. Arcinas 2016). Informal institutions play major roles that affect the formal institutions in society. Examples of these are non-governmental organizations, community organization s, foundations and/or people’s organizations that can affect the political or economic landscape of a given society. Informal institutions have set rules that are also anchored on the formal institutions, but there are informal institutions that aim to challenge rules or norms of formal institutions (Myla M. Arcinas 2016). Photo credit: Matthias Rauterberg INSTITUTIONALISM Institutions are social structures that have attained a high degree of resilience. They are composed of cultural-cognitive, normative, and regulative elements that, together with associated activities and resources, provide stability and meaning to social life. Institutions provide the rules, guidelines, and structure needed to carry out everyday activities. The main job of an institution is to regulate three parts of the society: economy, politics, and ideologies (PHINMA-Araullo University 2020). FORMAL INSTITUTIONS INFORMAL INSTITUTIONS are those officially established in one way or another, often by the uoe government like; Family, Education, Church, Laws, Constitution, Government are not officially established but are practices commonly accepted throughout society. Beliefs, Norms, Values Theorists of Institutionalism David Mitrany Father of Functionalism in international relations which is classified under liberal institutionalism. Functionalism, as applied to the study of states, proposes an alternative territorialism, which is the foundation from which states derive their power of authority from territory. Functionalism explains that a state’s authority lies in function needs, and the ability to provide those needs. It sees scientific knowledge and technological advancements as sources of authority from which the state can derive its power. Territory then becomes negligible and focuses instead on expertise and the Photo credit: Ena Limebeek ability to produce what is needed by the people or other states (Alejandria-Gonzalez 2016). Jean Monnet One of the originators of the European Union, he saw how the needs of the state are to be achieved through the principle of supranationality. As Mitrany argued against territory being the source of authority, Monnet used the argument to erase country borderlines (Alejandria-Gonzalez 2016). Photo credit: CVCE.EU Stephen Krasner Krasner argues that the American government and nongovernment organizations should prioritize the stabilization of weakened states so that American interests would be protected. To address the continued deterioration of weaker states, he suggests creation of institutions that will allow the weaker states to enter a market democracy. Krasner sees the foreign policies and other political objectives of America as a Photo credit: Hoover direct reflection of the US president’s agenda and goals. Institution Krasner also argued that the formal institutions of the US come from the decisions made by the president, but bureaucratic processes convey the idea that many people decided on these matters and not just the president. He holds that the president’s power to control, manipulate, and create policies is seemingly perceived as being dissipated by the bureaucratic machinery (Alejandria-Gonzalez 2016). II. FEMINIST THEORY Photo credit: Sara Nassif Gender Roles are acquired via the process of socialization rather than biologically determined. Gender Ideology- a social belief that supports gender inequality. It is a social divide that establishes perceived roles for men and women and relegating them to specific roles. Some gender ideologies include women staying at home while men go to work, and women being more delicate, emotional, and nurturing compared to men who are more aggressive, assertive, and dominant. Gender Inequality- the actualization or realization of gender ideology. There is gender inequality when the perceived role of women subordination to men reflects hiring procedures and requirements; for example, a secretarial post accepting only female applicants. Salaries are also unequal when it comes to men and women. Feminism can be used to describe a political, cultural, or economic movement aimed at establishing equal rights and legal protection for women. It involves political and sociological theories and philosophies concerned with issues of gender difference, as well as a movement that advocates gender equality for women and campaigns for women’s rights and interests (Arthur S. Abulencia 2017). According to Maggie Humm (1997) and Rebecca Walker (1995), the history of feminism can be divided into three waves. Each movement addressed a particular issue, which women struggles with at that time, thus: 1. The first wave of feminism took place during the 19th and early 20th centuries, which challenged the legal issues concerning women. Women at that time surrendered their properties to their husbands, were not allowed to hold public office, and were not given the rights of suffrage. It was only during the 1920s that women first voted in America. Women also advocated their right to choose their own profession. When World War I went in full swing, men were sent to battlefields, leaving the women to take on factory jobs. This development showed that women were as productive as men in the workforce. 2. The second wave of feminism began during the 1960s up to the 1990s and was born out of the civil rights’ movement. The primary issues that this movement tried to address was of sexual equality and reproductive rights. Unlike the first wave movement, the second wave movement encompassed women of all economic classes, races, and nationalities. With Marxism incorporated in feminism, women were a social class fighting a social conflict. The second wave thus included all women in its advocacy and not just white women of the middle class. This advocacy showed that race, gender, and color were struggles that were interrelated in society. The second wave also distinguished sex (biological) from gender (social construct). Finally, this movement saw “feminine” objects such as bras, lipsticks, and high heels as forms of male oppression and an objectification of women. The advocates of this movement, believing that the objectification of women was most evident in beauty pageants, parodied the Miss America pageant and crowned a sheep as the title holder. 3. The third wave of feminism began in the late 1980’s and continues until today. Feminists from the third wave do not consider “feminine” objects as artifacts of male oppression, but also tools to enrich their femininity. For the movers of this third wave, a woman does not have to pretend like a man or hold herself from putting on makeup just to be treated equals. Women continuously advocate for their right to individuality in whatever form or shape. This advocacy rues the blame-the-victim practice in which sexually harassed women are treated as sex objects and are blamed because of what they wear and because they put on makeup. Feminist Theory Suggests: ➢ Attempts to develop a comprehensive account of the subordination of women, including it supposes essence and origin. ➢ A prerequisite for developing effective strategies to liberate women ➢ Identifies the underlying causes of women subordination ➢ Attempts to describe women’s oppression, explain its causes and consequences Feminist Theory Purposes To understand the power differential in between men and women To understand women’s oppression- how it evolved, how it changes over time, how it is related to other forms of oppression How to overcome oppression Goals of Feminism 1. Complete equality of men and women a. Social equality b. Economic equality c. Political equality 2. Complete equality regardless of actual or perceived sexual orientation or sexual identity a. Social equality b. Economic equality c. Political equality 3. Elimination of all forms of established Photo credit:Fly Clipart hierarchy, particularly mandatory and enforced Patriarchy. This may include the following: a. Capitalism b. Oppressive aspects religion c. Racial supremacy and all racism d. The current public education system e. Dominionism f. All government that does not recognized equal voting rights to all its people g. Other oppression such as ageism and lookism h. Oppression of non-human animals and the destruction of the earth i. All authoritarianism Types of Feminism 1. Gender Differences It examines how women’s location in, and experience of, social institutions differ from men. For example, cultural feminists look to the different values associated with womanhood and femininity as a reason why men and women experience the social world differently (3G Elearning FZ LLC 2017). 2. Gender Oppression Gender oppression is the individual acts of abuse and violence, patterns of power and control, and systems of abuse and violence perpetrated against women and girls due to their gender. This includes state-sponsored violence, the effects of imperialism and capitalism on our material, social, and spiritual conditions; corporate violence; media violence; workplace violence; and violence at the level of family and intimate relations (Gender Oppression, Abuse, Violence 2005). Photo credit: PNGkit Theories of gender oppression go further than theories of gender differences and gender inequality by arguing that not only are women different from or unequal to men, but that they are actively oppressed, subordinated, and even abused by men (3G Elearning FZ LLC 2017). 3. Structural Oppression It postulates that women’s oppression and inequality are a result of capitalism, patriarchy, and racism (3G Elearning FZ LLC 2017). 4. Feminism and Multiculturalism Though the feminist perspective focuses on diversity and liberation, it has been accused of being incompatible with multiculturalist policy. Multiculturalism aims to allow cultures to reside together, as district enclaves within extensively Western societies with national borders. One possible consequence of multiculturalism is that certain religious or traditional practices are objectionable to human rights and ought to be criminalized on those grounds (3G Elearning FZ LLC 2017). Thinkers of Feminism Jane Flax in Women Do Theory and Thinking Fragments (1990) “Within Feminist theory is a commitment to change oppressive structures and to connect abstract ideas with concrete problems for political action. There has to be a commitment to do something about the situation of women” The goal of feminist theories is to analyze gender: how gender is constituted and experienced and how we think-or equally important-do not think about it. Marilyn Frye in The Possibility of Feminist Theory (1996) Connects feminist generalizing to hearing each other into speech. “The experiences of each woman and of the women collectively generate a new web of meaning.” Frye’s feminist method is recognizing and naming patterns, identifying schemas. A pattern for instance is male dominance in conversations The task of feminist theory is to write a new encyclopedia entitled “The World According to Women” Bettina Aptheker in Tapestries of Life (1989) A bottom up approach that look for the meanings of the daily activities of women’s lives By discovering and connecting meanings, feminists develop a “map” of women’s reality from women’s point of view, a women’s standpoint. Women’s live are fragmented, dispersed, episodic and often determined by events outside of women’s control. Charlotte Bunch in Feminism and Education: Not By Degrees (1979) “Theory enables us to see immediate needs in terms of long-range goals and an overall perspective on the world. It thus gives us a framework for evaluating various strategies in both the long and the short run for seeing the types of changes that they are likely to produce. Theory is not just a body of facts or a set of personal opinions. Theory is not just a body of facts or a set of opinions. It involves hypotheses that are based on available knowledge and experience. It is also dependent on conjecture and insight about how to interpret those facts and experiences and their significance” Mary Wollstonecraft in Vindication of the Rights of Women (2008) She advocated that the human rights written by John Locke also be accorded to women. Although Locke’s human rights did not discriminate sexes, their application during that time was relegated only to men. Wollstonecraft thus argued that women should have the right to life, property, pursuit of happiness, and suffrage. Adrienne Rich in Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Existence (1980) Rich defined how heterosexuality becomes an alienating and oppressing concept that only lends to the establishment of male dominance over women. Rich defined being a lesbian as more than a sexual preference, but a cumulative lived experience of women and their history. Photo credit: Phillweb Jane Flax Photo credit: Nick Romanenko Charlotte Bunch Photo credit: Alchetron Photo credit: PeoplePill Marilyn Frye Bettina Aptheker Photo credit: DEA PICTURE LIBRARY Photo credit: The Journal Mary Wollstonecraft Adrienne Rich National and Local Organization Advocates 1. The General Assembly Binding Women for Reforms, Integrity, Equality, Leadership, and Action (GABRIELA)- an organization that advocates for women's issues. It is a nationwide network of grassroots organizations, institutions, Photo credit: Wikipedia and programs that address issues such as human rights, poverty, globalization, militarism, violence, rape culture, health, sex trafficking, censorship and other issues affecting women 2. Junior Chamber International (JCI) Boholana Kisses is an all women-LGBTQ chapter of JCI Philippines. Its’ mission is to contribute to the advancement of the global community by providing young people the opportunity to develop the leadership skills, social responsibility, entrepreneurship, and fellowship necessary to create positive change (Global NonProfit Organization n.d.). Photo credit: JCI Boholana Kisses 3. Baji Arts Collective- is an all-Boholana multigenre, multi-discipline arts alliance advocating for the creation of positive spaces for women to nurture their creative expressions and aspirations. Photo credit: Baji Arts Collective What I Have Learned Directions: Answer the following: A. Place each keyword below in its right category (PHINMA-Araullo University 2020). FORMAL INSTITUTIONS INFORMAL INSTITUTIONS Established by the government commonly accepted universal in function challenge rule deliberately created larger in scope Defined and focused goal non-government orgs rules anchored on formal institutions B. Cite as many instances as possible or situations showing discrimination against women (or men). At Home In School Community What I Can Do Task: Apply It in Real Life A. Direction: Imagine yourself as someone who has a position in the society, your task to help a failing livelihood in your community due to the Global Pandemic. Your goal is to study the marketing strategies of the most popular livelihood you know and develop a marketing campaign for your client that could help it boost its sales. Your campaign proposal could be presented in whichever medium (audiovisual, collage, print, advertisement) you deem relevant. Your work will be evaluated based on its feasibility and creativity. Rubrics: Relevance Presentation Creativity Feasibility - 25 20 30 25 100Pts B. As a student, how can we stop Gender-based abuse that is happening in our community? Photo credit: US Embassy in Cyprus Assessment Multiple Choice. Choose the letter of the best answer. Write the chosen letter on a separate sheet of paper. 1. What is new about the new institutionalism? A. It sees institutions as autonomous actors. B. It emphasizes that institutions are not value-neutral. C. It includes informal norms or rules as well as formal institutions. D. All of the these 2. Which type of new institutionalism focuses on the costs, opportunities, and constraints that institutions create for actors? A. Historical Institutionalism C. Sociological Institutionalism B. Rational Choice Institutionalism D. All of these 3. Which form of new institutionalism is path dependence associated with? A. Historical Choice Institutionalism C. Sociological Institutionalism B. Rational Choice Institutionalism D. All of these 4. ___________________ suggests the creation of institutions that will allow the weaker states to enter a market democracy. A. David Mitrany C. Jane Flax B. Jean Monnet D. Stephen Krasner 5. The following are examples of Formal Institution, except: A. Beliefs B. Constitution C. Education D. Laws 6. Which of the following are purposes of Feminist Theory? I. How to overcome oppression. II. To understand that there is no power differential in between men and women. III. To understand women’s oppression- how it evolved, how it changes over time, how it is related to other forms of oppression. IV. Identifies the underlying causes of women subordination. A. I & II only B. I & III only C. I,II, III only D. II, III, IV only 7. This includes state-sponsored violence, the effects of imperialism and capitalism on our material, social, and spiritual conditions; corporate violence; media violence; workplace violence; and violence at the level of family and intimate relations. A. Gender-Biased C. Gender Oppression B. Gender Differences D. Structural Oppression 8. It is a bottom up approach that look for the meanings of the daily activities of women’s lives. A. Tapestries of Life B. The Possibility of Feminist Theory C. Feminism and Education: Not by Degrees D. Women Do Theory and Thinking Fragments 9. The main goal of feminism is to: A. Change voting behavior. B. Influence the government. C. Protect women from alienation. D. Change the patriarchal nature of society. 10. What wave does not consider “feminine” objects as artifacts of male oppression, but also tools to enrich their femininity? A. First Wave B. Second Wave C. Third Wave D. Fourth Wave Answer Key Assessment 1. D 2. B 3. A 4. D 5. A 6. B 7. C 8. A 9. D 10.C What’s New 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Formal Informal Formal Formal Informal Informal