CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL FOOD SAFETY PRACTICES OF STREET FOOD VENDORS A Research Paper Presented to the Subject Specalists of Technical Vocational Livelihood Track Department Cielito Zamora Senior High School In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For Practical Research I Vryanna Chloe M. Adviento Jean A. Adricula Rod Ann R. Acosta Marissa V. Canlas Princess G. Ramo Aubrey S. Ongquit Cedric C. Aguirre Clifford James L. Bukid Cyrone A. Edillor June 2023 1 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL APPROVAL SHEET The research paper attached here, entitled “ Food Hygiene Practices of Street Food Vendors ” submitted by Vryanna Chloe M. Adviento, Jean A. Adricula, Rod Ann R. Acosta, Marissa V. Canlas, Princess G. Ramo, Aubrey S. Ongquit, Cedric C. Aguirre, Clifford James L. Bukid, Cyrone A. Edillor, in partial fulfillment for the completion of Practical Research 1, is hereby accepted. EDNA U. FRONTUNA Research Adviser Accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion of Practical Research 1 of Cielito Zamora Senior High School. 2 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First of all we would like to thank God for giving us knowledge, strength and ability to finish this research. We also like to thank our parents for motivating us so we can finish this research. Second, we benefit from the wisdom of our God which inspired us to finish this research with the help of our subject teacher Mrs. Edna U. Frontuna. We would like to thank her for guiding us, teaching us and her never ending patients to us all the time we need her help for the sake of this research. Lastly, are the co-researchers of the team, for giving their effort, time and energy for the completion of our researcher and our classmates that give their opinions and knowledge about our research. V. C. A J. A R. A. A M. C P. R A. O C. A C. J. B C. E CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 4 DEDICATION The researcher dedicated this to our family who support and give us strength for finishing this research, and also to fellow street vendors who wants to enhance their food hygiene practices. This research will give them ideas for enhancing their food hygiene. We also dedicated this to Cielito Zamora Senior High School for helping us to build ourselves and believing to our skills. V. C. A J. A R. A. A M. C P. R A. O C. A C. J. B C. E CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1: THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND Background of the Study………………………………………………………………..6-8 Research Questions ............................................................................................................. 9 Assumptions........................................................................................................................ 9 Scope and Limitation…………………………………………………………………..9-10 Significance of the Study………………………………………………………………10-11 Definitions of Terms……………………………………………………………………11-12 CHAPTER II: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES Related Literature………………………………………………………………………13-16 Theoretical Framework……………………………………………………………………17 Conceptual Framework……………………………………………………………………18 CHAPTER III: METHODOLOGY Research Design…………………………………………………………………………..19 Source of Data…………………………………………………………………………….19 Data Gathering…………………………………………………………………………….20 Data Analysis………………………………………………………………………………20 APPENDICES................................................................................................................21-22 1.PERMIT TO CONDUCT STUDY 2. INTERVIEW GUIDE REFERENCES………………………………………………………………………………23 CURRICULUM VITAE…………………………………………………………………….24 5 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL CHAPTER 1 THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND Background of the Study Food safety plays a vital role in street food vendors it is a must that every street food vendors must at least practice the right food hygiene practices, sanitation, processes, and maintain the quality of the foods they sell. Street food is a weak link in food safety supervision,. Street food is defined by the Food Agriculture Organization (FAO) as “ready to eat foods and beverages sold and prepared by vendors or hawkers in streets or other public places”. This includes personal hygiene, safe handling of food, preventing-cross contamination, cleaning procedures, allergen control, safe storage of food, and cooking temperature. Implementing appropriate food management systems. This refers to the overarching system that keeps food and the premises safe and hygienic. Also, Food hygiene defined as ‘the measures and conditions necessary to control hazards and to ensure fitness for human consumption of a foodstuff taking into account its intended use, There are also simple keys of food hygiene: keep clean, separate raw and cooked, keep food at safe temperatures, and use safe water and raw materials. Food hygiene is a set of food manufacturing practices that aim to minimize biological food hazards through safe and clean operations to protect public health from foodborne diseases. Sanitation is for preventing food contamination and keeping food safe to eat. Controling the quality of food is important to ensure the customers consume safe food products and safeguard them from risks associated with contaminated foods. for buyers, it also reduces the risks of dealing with fraudulent suppliers and receiving poor goods.The key practices to achieve 6 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL food safety include (1)maintaining cleanliness and personal hygiene, (2) properly cooking food to the correct internal temperature, (3) storing foods at a safe temperature(refrigerated temperatures or hot-holding), (4) keeping raw and cooked foods separate, and (5) ensure clean raw. Food sanitation refers to the operations that help create a clean working environment by keeping any equipment, contact surface, and the whole facility clean and free common food hazards.The correct practice of food safety and sanitation can greatly improve efficiency, keep productivity up, workers safe and consumer confidence high, as well as meeting or surpassing standards and thus avoiding untoward incidents such as having not only no-compliance fines or a potential shutdown. Food processing is any method used to turn fresh foods into food products. This can involve one or a combination of various processes including washing, chopping, pasteurising, freezing, fermenting, packaging, cooking and many more.Almost all food is processed in some way before it is eaten.Commercially, the main reasons to process food are to eliminate microorganisms (which may cause disease) and to extend shelf life.Simply cooking or combining a food with other foodstuffs to create a recipe is also considered a form of food processing. The Characteristics of Street Food (1) On-to go:It can easily fit into the consumers other plans for the day. Street food is transportable and can be eaten on the move (2) Accessible: Short, limited menus make choosing easier and faster. Low, affordable prices allow for frequent visits. Street food is in its essence an urban phenomen a and makes premium food experiences accessible. (3) Spontaneous: Street food is a sensory experience, driven by spontaneous cravings.It is deal to try out new tastes in fun, informal and vibrant settings that require no 7 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL reservations or planning ahead of time.(4) Diverse:Defined by its great variety of choice and traditional food s from other cultures, street food is perceived as the destination for explotation of new foods with authentic and home-made feel. (5) Semi-permanent:Strongly associated with summer, it is a seasonal phenomema,where vendors come and go, continuously offering novelty value.Also, street food can liven up misused urban areas with small pop-up stalls. 8 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Research Questions This research aims to know the Food Safety Practices of street vendors. Specially, it soughts to answer the following questions: 1.How can street food vendors ensure that they follow the correct handling of the foods they sell? 1.1 Wearing of PPE’s; and 1.2 Sanitation 2.What are the factors that affect food contamination and food spoilage? 2.1 Wearing of PPE’s; and 2.2 Reusing unsold food Assumptions The following assumptions are formulated by the researchers for this study: 1.That street vendors ensured to follow correct food handling procedure. .2.That there are factors affect food contamination and food spoilage. Scope and Limitation This study will only focus determining the assumption of food safety practices of street food vendors, allowing the sampled respondents to identify wether the food safety practices of street vendors ways process of food handling. Which would serve as the basis for the keys safe food handling. 9 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL The researchers used a phenomenology research design because the goal of this study was to determine the significant assumption of food safety practices of street food vendors ways process of food handling: Key to safe food handling. This study focuses on the effect of food safety practices of street vendors ways process of food handling. Which would serve as the basis for the keys safe food handling. The scope of this study that will serve as the population is limited to the street food vendors at Cielito Homes presently running their business year 2023.However the number of respondents will be limited to 3 street food vendors. The researchers chose a random sampling technique because they randomly selects a subset of participants from a population. Significance of the study The main purpose of this study is to determine the assumption of food hygiene practices of street food vendors at Cielito Homes,which would serve as the basis for the keys to safe food handling.This research finds it important for the following reasons: Business owners. This study is significant to business owners since food safety protocols are established mistakes are reduced,foodborne illnesses are reduced or eliminated profitability increases,employee morale increases, and the company’s reputation remains secure. Consumers. This study is significant to consumers since proper food hygiene practices prevent customers from suffering food poisoning and allergic reactions,help minimize food waste,and boost efficiency Future Researchers.This study will help future researchers gain insight into the research paper and it might help the researcher if their topic is related to the researcher’s paper. 10 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Society. This study is significant to society since reduce waste. Food products that have been proven to have food safety issue may be subjected to disposal. Through use of proper food safety practices, a food business can cut waste as a result of a better food production process. Food safety management systems are also designed to detect and control food hazard even before they enter production which can lead to move waste if processed further. Definition of Terms Allergen Control . This a systematic method for identifying and controlling allergens, from the icoming ingredients to the final packaged product in any food processing plant. Food borne illnesses. This caused by consuming contaminated food, beverages, or water and can be a variety of bacteria, parasites, viruses and/or toxins. Food contamination. This foods that are spoiled or tainted because they either contain microorganisms, such as bacteria or parasites, or toxic substances that make them unfit for consumption. Food hygiene. This defined as the measures and conditions necessary to control hazards and to ensure fitness for human consumption of a foodstuff taking into account its intended use. Food practices. This is a scientific discipline describing the safe processes and practices to grow, harvest, store, transport, handle,prepare and serve food and food ingredients to prevent foodborne illnesses Food processes. This is any method used to turn fresh foods into food products. 11 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Food sanitation. This is the creation and maintenance of conditions that will prevent food contamination or food borne illnesses and lower levels of disease-causing microorganisms to a safe level Food spoilage. This is the process leading to a product becoming either undesirable or unacceptable for human consumption Human consumption. This means to ingest, generally through the mouth, food , drink or other substances such that the substance enters the human body but does not include the inhalation Personal hygiene. This includes cleaning your body everyday. Washing your hands with soap. Brushing your teeth twice a day. In short personal hygiene means taking care of yourself and keeping yourself clean Quality control. This is a procedure or set of procedures intended to ensure that aa manufactured product or performed service adheres to defned setb of quality criteria or meets the requirements of the client or customers. Street food. This refers to food or drinks sold by a hawker or vendor on a street or at the other places, such as markets, fairs, and parks. 12 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL CHAPTER 2 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE Related Literature Food Hygiene Food hygiene is an important public health issue that affects all population groups regardless of socio-demographics. Street foods are convenient, inexpensive, and easily available to consumers, but vendors are often unlicensed, untrained, unsupervised, and operate under unsanitary conditions. Vending locations near busy roads with heavy automobile traffic contribute to contamination. Street-vended foods pose a significant health risk to consumers, and have been linked to the rise of global foodborne illnesses Furthermore, Gold nanoclusters (AuNCs) are a versatile class with attractive photoluminescence and optoelectronic properties, revealing huge potential in food safety. With the increased globalization of food supply, the need for stringent food regulations and safety measures has taken a prime position among health concerns. This review focuses on the development of AuNCs optical sensors to facilitate food safety assurance. It describes the expected synthesis principle, sensing mechanism, and recent progress of AuNCs as optical biosensors. Additionally, it stated the application of AuNCs biosensors in food safety along with their sensing mechanism and challenges associated with the application of AuNCs (Khan, 2023). Due to the risk of foodborne illnesses, eating street food is a serious public health hazard, especially in poor nations, these foodborne illnesses are caused by eating food 13 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL contaminated with pathogenic bacteria like Salmonella typhi, Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Vibrio cholera, Campylobacter jejuni, and/or their toxins (Amare & Shiningeni 2019). In addition, according to Manko (2023) food vendors did not exhibit healthy food handling habits. To increase the degree of food safety, a comprehensive food safety policy and guidelines, regular training programmes and effective m The World Health Organization estimates that 600 million cases of foodborne diseases and 420,000 deaths are caused by foodborne illness, with Africa and Southeast Asia having the highest occurrence and death rates. In sub-Saharan Africa, foodborne disease outbreaks are associated with inadequate hygiene of street food vendors and food handlers, as well as lack of basic facilities and services (Hassan, 2020). According to Food and Agriculture Organization (2022) of the United Nation, street foods are ready-to-eat foods and beverages prepared and/or sold by vendors or hawkers especially in the streets and other similar places. Street food plays a significant role in developing countries, especially in meeting the food demands of urban dwellers. Street food feeds millions of low- and middle-income people daily, and its wide variety of relatively cheap and easily accessible foods makes it popular among the consuming public. This industry offers a significant amount of employment especially for people with little or no education. 14 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Street Foods Street foods play an important role in the lives of urban population members in developing countries. This study aimed to assess the food safety knowledge, attitudes and practices of vendors and the most significant influencing factors of these aspects with the help of cluster analysis. The results of the study indicated that street vendors are significantly differentiated on the basis of qualifications, knowledge, attitude and practices. Awareness and training programs should be implemented to improve the food safety knowledge, attitudes and practices among vendors. Once food safety standards are acceptable, it will be critical to ensure that poor people in developed cities such as Lucknow can earn a living through a "convenient" enterprise such as street food vending (Verma & Patel, 2023). Moreover, street foods are cooked and served by vendors in streets or public places and consumed directly without further cooking. They are popular and consumed all around the world, and the presence of street food stalls is an ancient phenomenon that has recently drawn increased interest. The street food vending business is an important economic activity in developing countries, providing diverse employment opportunities for local workforce (Adeosun & Forné, 2021). According to Abranhale (2019), it attracts foreign tourists to experience the unique culture that different food menus provide. Street foods are comprised of different ingredients that are subjected to diverse processing condition such as fresh-cut fruits and vegetables, simply cooked foods, packed beverages, and snacks (Sseguya et al., 2020). 15 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Food Safety Food security, nutrition, and safety are all closely linked. Malnutrition and disease are caused by unclean and bad food, which disproportionately affects small children, the old, and the sick. Foodborne illnesses obstruct socioeconomic progress by taxing healthcare systems, harming trade, tourism, and national and international economies. Poor food handling procedures result in 600 million foodborne illnesses and 420,000 fatalities each year, and unhealthy food costs low- and middle-income nations close to US$ 110 billion annually in lost productivity and medical costs. Food-borne illnesses have increased recently (Devleesschauwer et al., 2018). Unhygienic Foods Unhygienic food is a serious issue that affects all members of the food industry, from producers to retailers. Poor food preparation and handling practices can lead to a variety of issues, such as inadequate hand washing between raw and cooked foods, unclean surfaces, and the spread of bacteria. Many street foods in India are served with a side of hands, which can make people sick due to unhygienic conditions. Many vendors lack the necessary refrigeration to keep food items at room temperature for an extended period of time, which can cause food poisoning due to bacteria. It is important to be aware of the risks associated with unhygienic food and to practice safe eating habits when eating street food in India. Look out for signs of poor hygiene and keep a close eye on food safety standards to reduce the risk of food-related illnesses (Tan, 2022). 16 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Theoretical Framework According to Okpala C.(2021) there are numerous food safety aspects that must be taken into consideration by organic food producers and processors to ensure the safety and quality of their products. The application of Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) principles, together with the implementation of good hygiene practices (GHP), ensures that food safety and process hygiene criteria are met. This study was based on a survey conducted among 316 producers and processors representing the organic food sector in five European countries (Croatia, Estonia, Germany, Italy and Poland). The knowledge and experience of organic food operators with HACCP systems were evaluated. Moreover, their needs and expectations towards assistance (training, guidance materials) that could improve the level of knowledge and compliance with respective food safety rules and regulations were assessed. The need for support on a number of issues related to food safety and guidance documents on the application of HACCP principles were also identified. This study provides highlights of the application of HACCP principles, with particular focus on identifying priorities and needs for two types of food operators (food producers and food processors) . Although most of the surveyed food operators were confirmed to have basic knowledge regarding the HACCP system, there was a lack of understanding of the system principles. The needs and expectations varied among the studied countries and types of organic operators. Recognition of the full potential of the HACCP system requires assistance, particularly in the preparation of documents and records. Further research is needed to understand the implications of these findings and to identify effective strategies to improve the HACCP knowledge of food operator. 17 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Conceptual Framework INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT INPUT 1.How can street food vendors ensure that they follow the correct handling of the foods they sell? 1.1 Wearing of PPE’s; and 1.2 Sanitation 2.What are thefactors that affect food contamination and food spoilage? 2.1 Wearing of PPE’s; and 2.2 Reusing unsold food Phenomenoligi cal research design Structured Gathering Data Thematic Analysis Assessed Food Safety Practices Of Street Food Vendors 18 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY This chapter deals with the procedures and techniques used by the researchers in completing the study. It includes research design, data gathering procedure, sources of data and data analysis. Research Design This study used phenomenology approach in order to gain better qualitative understanding of food hygiene practices of street food vendors. The researchers conducted an interview around Cielito Homes, Camarin Caloocan City to use as a basis to further elaborate the insights about food hygiene practices. Sample and Sampling Procedure The researchers used convenience sampling to investigate the food safety practices of street food vendors . The researchers focused on street food vendors in Cielito Homes Subdivision with street food businesses. The sample size will be 3 participants from Barangay 177 Caloocan City. Sources of Data This data will use an interview questionnaire consists of five questions pertaining about food hygiene practices and processes. 19 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Data Gathering Procedures The researchers secured a content letter to the respondents to be part of the study. Then they will be interviewed using the five interview questionnaire made by the researchers. After the interview session all data gathered will be tabulated and themed for data analysis. Data Analysis After gathering data from the respondents who are follow food hygiene techniques, the data will be tabulated, coded, and themed for data analysis. 20 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL APPENDICES Appendix A Letter of Consent June 5, 2023 Dear Respondents: Greetings! We, the TVL/Home Economics Strand students are currently conducting a research entitled,“Food Safety Practices of Street Food Vendors” as part of our academic requirements for the subject Practical Research 1. In line with this, we are asking you to be part of the study and provide us with all the necessary information needed to complete the research. Rest assured that all the data gathered from you will be kept with the highest level of confidentiality. Your participation will be highly appreciated. Thank you very much. Respectfully yours, VRYANNA CHLOE M. ADVIENTO Researcher ROD ANN R. ACOSTA Researcher CLIFFORD JAMES L. BUKID Researcher JEAN A. ADRICULA Researcher MARISSA V. CANLAS Reseacher CYRONE A. EDILLOR Reseacher Noted by: EDNA U. FRONTUNA Research Adviser PRINCESS G. RAMO Reseacher CEDRIC C. AGUIRRE Reseacher AUBREY S. ONGQUIT Reseacher 21 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL Appendix B Name (optional): Age: Name of Business: Food Sold: 1.What are the food handling practices do you follow? Kindly elaborate them one by one. 2.Do you ensure the quality of the foods you sell?, If no why? 3.Do you wear proper PPE when handling foods? 4.How do you prevent cross-contamination during your preparation? 5.What are you ways to prevent the spoilage of the food you sell? 22 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL References Negassa, B., Anbese, A. T., Worku, G., Areba, A. S., Seboka, B. T., Debela, B. G., ... & Soboksa, N. E. (2023). Food Hygiene Practices and Associated Factors Among Street Food Vendors in Urban Areas of Gedeo Zone, Southern Ethiopia. Environmental Health Insights, 17, 11786302231168531. Khan, I. M., Niazi, S., Akhtar, W., Yue, L., Pasha, I., Khan, M. K. I., ... & Wang, Z. (2023). Surface functionalized AuNCs optical biosensor as an emerging food safety indicator: Fundamental mechanism to future prospects. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 474, 214842. Wickrematilake, M. S. K., Arnold, S. M., Karthikeyan, P., & Jayathilake, A. D. N. (2022). Improving knowledge of street food vendors through an educational intervention in Kandy district, Sri Lanka. International Journal of Research in Medical Sciences, 10(2), 331 Bakouny, Z., Labaki, C., Grover, P., Awosika, J., Gulati, S., Hsu, C. Y., ... & Saliby, R. M. (2023). Interplay of immunosuppression and immunotherapy among patients with cancer and COVID-19. JAMA oncology, 9(1), 128-134. Rakha, A., Fatima, M., Bano, Y., Khan, M. A., Chaudhary, N., & Aadil, R. M. (2022). Safety and quality perspective of street vended foods in developing countries. Food Control, 109001. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1356336X211036574?icid=int.sj-full-text.similararticles.2 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29510783/ Kamboj, S., Gupta, N., Bandral, J. D., Gandotra, G., & Anjum, N. (2020). Food safety and hygiene: a review. International Journal of Chemical Studies, 8(2), 358-368. Okpala, C. O. R., & Korzeniowska, M. (2021). Understanding the relevance of quality management in agro-food product industry: From ethical considerations to assuring food hygiene quality safety standards and its associated processes. Food Reviews International, 1-74. Addo-Tham, R., Appiah-Brempong, E., Vampere, H., Acquah-Gyan, E., & Gyimah Akwasi, A. (2020). Knowledge on food safety and food-handling practices of street food vendors in Ejisu-Juaben Municipality of Ghana. Advances in Public Health, 2020, 1-7. kNamukwambi, R. N., Tuhadeleni, O., & Van Neel, R. (2022). The Knowledge and Practices of Handwashing Among Street Food Vendors in the Keetmanshoop Municipal Area: none. Journal of Medical Research and Health Sciences, 5(4), 1860-1865. 23 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 24 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 25 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 26 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 27 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 28 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 29 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 30 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 31 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 32 CIELITO ZAMORA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 33