Uploaded by edogawaranpo098

Critique paper

advertisement
Financial Stress and Well-being of
Filipino Students:
The Moderating Role of
External Locus-of-hope
Allan B. I. Bernardo
University of Macau
Katrina Fernando
Resurreccion De La Salle University
Abstract
One of the core principles of positive psychology is that character strengths buffer
the effects of adverse experiences on well-being. This study investigated whether
external locus-of-hope (LOH) moderates the effects of financial stress on Filipino students’
well-being. Students from various universities answered questionnaires that included
scales for financial stress, internal and external LOH, and satisfaction with life; all the
relevant scales had good psychometric properties with the current sample. As expected,
life satisfaction was negatively predicted by financial stress and positively predicted by
three LOH dimensions. More importantly, external-family LOH moderated the relationship
between financial stress and life satisfaction; there was no negative relationship between
financial stress and life satisfaction among students with high external-family LOH. But
the results also suggest that financial stress moderates the relationship between externalspiritual LOH and life satisfaction; external-spiritual LOH’s positive relationship with life
satisfaction is found only among those who experience low financial stress.
Keywords: financial stress, locus-of-hope, hope theory, well-being, life satisfaction, university students
Critique Paper & Insights
Research corpus concerning the perceived stress (financial, psychological,
emotional, cognitive etc.) among Filipino students has seen a considerable increase in
terms of both quantity and quality for the last few decades. On a much brighter note, the
study at hand attempts to answer the questions and closely analyze the moderating
effects of external locus-of-hope (LOH; external-family LOH and external-spiritual LOH)
on the relationship between financial stress and well-being of students all while
considering the context well within the scope of Filipino Psychology and inside the Filipino
cultural background. Moreover, this research from Bernardo and Fernando (2018) proved
to be a vital contribution to the trend of research that recently emerged following the
trails of a research that investigates the stress felt by higher education students (Michie,
Glachan, & Bray, 2001), also a study understanding the range of factors that causes
students’ stressors (Robotham & Julian, 2006) and as well as the emergence of several
psychological measures that is directly aimed to quantify the amount of stress felt by
college students (Camacho, Cordero, & Perkins, 2016; Chan & Bernardo, 2017).
Conclusively, the research’ results show that the external dimensions (externalfamily & external-spiritual) of LOH significantly affects ‘hope’ positively among students,
thus affecting their way of interacting and reacting to things that happen beyond their
own directive control. With this, we can theoretically implement the findings of this study
to be beneficial for school counselors in mitigating and reducing the perceived feelings of
financial stress among university students. Even so, the researchers also disclaimed the
validity of their produced results because of the representation of their samples. It is
lacking the needed representation for students residing in low-economic profile regions
in the Philippines (see Discussion, p. 29). The results also support the idea that both
internal and external dimensions of LOH should be treated as a complementary
contributing factor to the development of one’s internal strength and/or hope. This notion
can be an indicator of the need for new and emerging research to possibly touch on the
subject of interdependability between internal and external LOH among university
students who are experiencing academic-related stress and financial stress. More
importantly, the study also suggests that university students who show higher levels of
external-family LOH tend to seek help from their family members with regards to their
financial inadequacies. Therefore making them feel more secure when faced against
financial difficulties and the relationship between financial stress and life satisfaction felt
among students can be addressed. Additionally, the body of research also implies that
university students who subscribe to external-spiritual LOH may act differently depending
on their current financial situation. To elaborate, students may feel positive
manifestations of life satisfaction when they do not currently feel burdened by financial
stress while conversely having high external-spiritual LOH. On the other hand, students
that are facing financial adversity do not manifest the positive impacts of external-spiritual
LOH.
The aforementioned results show the positive implications and responsibility of
internal strength (LOH) of students to cope with stress. As mentioned earlier, possible
interventions to be implemented by school counselors that strengthen one’s internal
character can be a beneficial factor in reducing the feelings of financial stress among
students. The advantageous effects of the results of this study is not only limited to the
effective effects of LOH on the relationship between financial stress and life-satisfaction
among students; it can also be extended towards the multi-faceted nature of life
satisfaction and how stress affects it. The objectivity of the research at hand proves to
be beneficial to the target stakeholders. Although that is surely the case, the
representation of the stakeholders are more skewed towards students who reside in more
economically advanced regions in the Philippines where students may have lower
frequency of experiencing financial stress; although we are not invalidating the
experiences of those students who really are experiencing financial hardship in their lives.
The crux of the matter is that the sample should be representative of the population of
students who are indeed affected by financial stress to better grasp the implications of
internal strengths and effects of external locus-of-hope in a much more detailed manner.
Download