Bevel & Worm Gears Hritik K Mahato (32097) ME(01)-19 • • • • INTRODUCTION APPLICATIONS & TYPES MATERIALS FORCE & STRENGTH ANALYSIS 9/3/20XX 2 Introduction Intersecting Non-Parallel shafts are encountered in many times in mechanical power transmission problems and solutions. Different mechanisms used in such power transmission some of which are; • Bevel Gears • Worm Gears 9/3/20XX 3 Bevel Gears Bevel Gears • Bevel gears are a type of gear with angled teeth that allow them to transmit power and motion between non-parallel shafts. • The shape of a bevel gear is conical or tapered, with teeth extending outward from the base of the cone, and their geometry must be carefully designed for efficient and reliable performance. • The exact geometrics of the bevel gear is determined by its applications depending upon on the factors such as orientation of shaft, pressure angle, desired gear ratio, torque capacity, etc. • General gear ratio of bevel gears are 3:2 to 5:1 5 Types of Bevel Gears Straight bevel Gear Spiral bevel Gear 9/3/20XX Mitre Gears Hypoid Bevel Gear 6 Straight Bevel Gears • Straight bevel gears are the most common and simplest types of bevel gearing. It consists of straight teeth that resemble a spur gear but the exception being that they are conical. • They share similar properties of spur gears due to having similar teeth profiles. 9/3/20XX Fig: Straight bevel gears 7 Pros Cons 1. Ability to transmit power and motion between non-parallel and non-perpendicular shafts. 1. Can be more complex and costly to design and manufacture compared to other types of gears. 2. High efficiency and minimal backlash. 2. Requires careful alignment to ensure optimal performance and minimize wear. 3. Can operate at high speeds and under heavy loads. 4. Low maintenance requirements and long service life. 3. Can generate more noise and vibration than other types of gears when misaligned. 4. Limited load capacity in some applications. 5. Can be designed for high precision and accuracy. 5. Lubrication requirements may be more demanding than other types of gears. 6. Compact size and space-saving design. 6. Limited efficiency when operated at small angles or high ratios. 7. Can be manufactured using a variety of materials, including steel, bronze, and plastic. 8. Offers smooth and quiet operation. 8 Applications of Bevel Gearing 2. Used traditionally by local communities such as the Newari community in mechanism like ‘Pani Ghattas’ and ‘Tel Kothi’ 1. Fig: Differential Power Transmission 3. Fig: Hand-held drill application of Bevel Gear 4. Fig: Application of Bevel gearing in Rotary wing engine 9 Gear Sets Fig : Bevel Gearing with axis intersection at point O 9/3/20XX 10 Terms • Face width • Tooth height • Tooth thickness • Spiral Angle • Pitch diameter • Toe and Heel • Module • Pressure angle • Cone angle • Pitch cone angle 11 Fig: Bevel Gear Terminology 12 • Cone distance: The pitch cone radius is known as cone distance. • Addendum Angle: It is the angle subtended by the addendum of the tooth at the cone center. It is denoted by ‘α’ Mathematically, addendum angle, πΏπ = π‘ππ −1 π ππππ πππ π‘ππππ(π2 ) • Dedendum Angle: It is the angle subtended by the dedendum of the tooth at the cone center . It is denoted by ‘β’ Mathematically, dedendum angle, ππ = π‘ππ−1 9/3/20XX π ππππ πππ π‘ππππ(π2 ) 13 Proportion for bevel gears • Addendum, a = 1 m • Dedendum, d = 1.2 m • Clearance = 0.2 m • Working depth = 2 m • Thickness of tooth = 1.5708 m 9/3/20XX Presentation Title 14 Forces on Bevel Gears 9/3/20XX 15 Force Analysis • Bevel gears are subject to several forces during operation that affect their performance and longevity. • Understanding these forces is essential for designing and selecting bevel gears for various applications. oTypes of forces 1.Tangential Force (Ft): • The force acting along the tangent to the pitch circle of the gear. • Responsible for transmitting torque from the driving gear to the driven gear. • Can cause bending and shear stresses on the gear teeth. 9/3/20XX Presentation Title 16 2.Radial Force (Fr): • The force acting perpendicular to the tangent of the pitch circle. • Results from misalignment or eccentricity of the gears. • Can cause excessive wear and damage to the gear teeth. 9/3/20XX 3.Axial Force (Fa): • The force acting along the axis of the gear. • Results from the axial thrust generated by the gears during operation. • Can cause axial movement of the gear and affect the alignment of the gears. Fig: Forces acting on a bevel gear 17 If the normal force (Fn) on the tooth is perpendicular to the tooth face and thus making an angle (πΏ) to the pitch circle. Then the normal can be resolved into two components, tangential (Ft) and Radial (Fr). The tangential force here creates bearing reactions, and the radial component creates the thrust in the shaft . Mathematically, πΉπ‘ = πΉπ πππ πΏ, and πΉπ = πΉπ π πππΏ= πΉπ‘ π‘πππΏ Fig: Tooth loads on bevel gears 9/3/20XX 18 Strength Analysis of Bevel Gears • The strength of the Bevel gears can be obtained from the modified Lewis equation for the tangential tooth load πΉπ‘ = ππ × πΆπ£ π. π. π¦ ′ . π πΏ−π πΏ Where ππ = allowable stress ; πΆπ£ = velocity factor ; b = face width; m = module ; y’ = Tooth form factor (Lewis factor); L = Cone distance 9/3/20XX 19 Worm Gears Introduction • A worm gear is a gearing system that consists two major components worm (the screw) and the worm gear • The worm is the driving gear and the worm gear the driven. • Same as Bevel gears, worm gears also transmits power to non-parallel and intersecting shafts. • It is used when low gear ratios are required for operations. • The gear consists of a spiral thread that interferes with a toothed wheel and drives it. • General gear ratio of 3:1 to 100:1 9/3/20XX 21 Gear Sets Fig : Typical Worm Gear Sets 9/3/20XX 22 Types of Worms in Worm Gears Fig : Cone or double enveloping worm. 9/3/20XX Fig :Cylindrical or straight worm 23 Types of Worm Gears in Worm Gears Fig: Straight face worm gear Fig: Hobbed straight face worm gear 9/3/20XX Fig: Concave face worm gear 24 Worm of the gear may be single threaded or two/multi threaded depending on the application of the gear set. 1.Single Thread: A worm gear with a single thread typically has lower efficiency compared to multithreaded worm gears. This is because a singlethreaded worm gear has a larger contact area and higher sliding friction between the worm and worm wheel. The increased sliding friction results in more energy losses due to frictional heating and wear. Single-threaded worm gears are commonly used in low-speed applications where efficiency is not a critical concern. 9/3/20XX 2.Double Thread or Multi-Thread: Worm gears with multiple threads, such as double-threaded or multi-threaded worm gears, generally have higher efficiency compared to single-threaded worm gears. The presence of multiple threads reduces the contact area between the worm and worm wheel, resulting in reduced sliding friction and energy losses. Multi-threaded worm gears are often used in applications where higher efficiency and smoother operation are desired. 25 Why are Worm gears Useful ? 1.High gear ratio: Worm gears can achieve very high gear ratios in a single stage, which can be useful in applications where space is limited, or multiple stages of gearing would be impractical. 2.Self-locking: Worm gears have a self-locking characteristic that prevents backdriving, which can be useful in applications where the load needs to be held in place without the need for a brake or other locking mechanism. 3.Quiet operation: Worm gears can operate with very little noise due to the sliding contact between the worm and gear teeth, which can be useful in applications where noise is a concern. 4.Compact design: Worm gears have a compact design due to their high gear ratio, which can be useful in applications where space is limited. 9/3/20XX Presentation Title 26 Applications of Worm Gear Elevators: Worm gears are commonly used in elevator systems due to their self-locking capabilities and ability to handle heavy loads. Conveyor Systems: Worm gears are used in conveyor systems to transmit power to the conveyor belt and control its speed. Automotive: Worm gears are used in automotive applications such as steering systems and transmissions due to their compact design and high torque transmission. Robotics: Worm gears are used in robotic systems to control the movement of arms and other components due to their accuracy and ability to handle heavy loads. Packaging Machinery: Worm gears are used in packaging machinery such as filling machines, labeling machines, and wrapping machines to control the movement of components and ensure precise positioning. Power Generation: Worm gears are used in power generation applications such as wind turbines and hydroelectric generators due to their ability to handle high torque transmission. Machine Tools: Worm gears are used in machine tools such as lathes, milling machines, and grinding machines to control the movement of the cutting tool and workpiece. 9/3/20XX 27 Applications of Bevel Gearing Fig : Power train of a Conveyer system Fig : Boom Lifter mechanism of a Crane Fig : Worm Gear reducer for mining operations 2. Cranes: Worm gears are used in 1. Conveyer System: cranes to provide high torque, Worm gears are used in precise control, and excellent loadconveyor systems to transmit holding capabilities for heavy lifting power to the conveyor belt and and positioning of loads. control its speed. 9/3/20XX 3. Gear Reducer: Worm gears are used as gear reducers due to their high gear ratio, resulting in a significant reduction in motor speed while increasing torque for efficient and precise control of 28 machinery. Terms of Worm Gears 9/3/20XX 29 Terms • Axial Pitch • Lead • Lead angle • Tooth pressure angle • Normal Pitch • Helix angle 9/3/20XX 30 Forces on Worm Gears 9/3/20XX 31 Fig: Forces acting on operating Worm gears Force analysis 9/3/20XX 32 1.Axial force: Due to the helical angle of the worm gear, an axial force is generated that tends to push the worm away from the gear. This force can be reduced by using a thrust bearing or a double-enveloping worm gear. πΉπ‘ 2 × πππππ’π ππ π‘βπ π€πππ πΊπππ πΉπ = = tan π πππ‘πβ ππππππ πππ. ππ ππππ ππππ(π·πΊ ) 9/3/20XX 33 2.Tangential force: The tangential force is the force that drives the gear in rotation. It is dependent on the torque applied to the worm and the radius of the gear. 2 × πππππ’π ππ π‘βπ π€πππ πΉπ‘ = πππ‘πβ ππππππ πππ. ππ π€πππ(π·π€ ) 3.Radial force: Separating force on the worm, The radial or separating force tends to force the worm and worm gear out of mesh. This force also bends the worm in the vertical plane. πΉπ = πΉπ . tan π = π πππππ ππ π ππππππ‘πππ πππππ ππ π‘βπ π€πππ ππππ 4.Frictional force: Frictional forces are generated due to the contact between the worm and the gear. These forces can be reduced by using high-quality materials, lubrication, and proper alignment. 9/3/20XX 34 Strength of Worm Gear The strength of the Bevel gears can be obtained from the modified Lewis equation for the tangential tooth load πΉπ‘ = ππ × πΆπ£ π. ππ. π¦ Where, Ft = Permissible tangential tooth load or beam strength of gear tooth, ππ = Allowable static stress, πΆπ£ = velocity factor, b = Face width, m = Module, and y = Tooth form factor or Lewis's factor. 9/3/20XX Presentation Title 35 Efficiency of Worm Gears π Mathematically, the efficiency of worm gearing is given by • When worm drives the worm wheel; πππ π − ππ‘πππΎ π= πππ π + ππππ‘πΎ • When the worm gear drives the worm; πππ π − ππππ‘πΎ π= πππ π + ππ‘πππΎ 9/3/20XX 36 Efficiency Vs Number of threads Fig: Efficiency of worm gear based on no. of threads and loading and speed 9/3/20XX 37 Drawbacks ! 1.Lower efficiency: Worm gears can have lower efficiency compared to other types of gearing due to the sliding contact between the worm and gear teeth, which can lead to higher frictional losses. 2.Limited load capacity: Worm gears are generally not as strong as other types of gearing, which can limit their load carrying capacity. The worm and gear must be designed carefully to ensure that they can handle the applied loads without failure. 3.High heat generation: The sliding contact between the worm and gear teeth can also lead to high levels of heat generation, which can be problematic in certain applications. 4.Difficult to manufacture: The manufacture of worm gears can be more complex and expensive compared to other types of gearing, due to the need for precise cutting and grinding of the worm and gear teeth. 9/3/20XX 38 The Big Difference ? So, since both Bevel and Worm Gear used for intersecting and non-parallel shafts when to use which gearing? 9/3/20XX 39 Choices 1.Load capacity: If the application requires a high load capacity, bevel gears may be a better choice due to their ability to transmit higher torque. Worm gears, on the other hand, may be more suitable for lighter duty applications. 2.Efficiency: Bevel gears generally have higher efficiency compared to worm gears due to the rolling contact between the gear teeth, which reduces frictional losses. If efficiency is a critical factor in the application, bevel gears may be preferred. 3.Operating angle: Bevel gears are well-suited for applications where the input and output shafts are at a 90-degree angle, while worm gears can be used for shaft angles up to 30 degrees or more. 4.Noise: Bevel gears can be noisier compared to worm gears due to the rolling contact between the gear teeth. If noise is a concern in the application, worm gears may be preferred. 9/3/20XX 40 References [1] “Advantages of worm gears - gear motions, Precision Gear Manufacturer,” Gear Motions, https://gearmotions.com/advantages-of-worm-gears/ (accessed May 29, 2023). [2] “Worm Gears explained,” Machinery Lubrication, https://www.machinerylubrication.com/Read/1080/worm-gears (accessed May 29, 2023). [3] K. Mahadevan and K. B. Reddy, Design Data Handbook: For Mechanical Engineers (in Si and Metric Units). New Delhi: CBS Publishers & Distributors, 2013. [4] Zhy Gear, https://www.zhygear.com/the-history-of-spiral-bevel-gear/ (accessed May 29, 2023). [5] “Worm gear reducers,” Worm Gear Reducers | Bearing Service, https://www.bearingservice.com/products/power-transmission/worm-gearreducers#:~:text=Worm%20Gear%20reducers%20are%20utilized%20in%20power%20transmission%2 0applications%20requiring,and%20smoothest%20form%20of%20gearing. (accessed May 29, 2023). 9/3/20XX 41 [6] “Top,” KHK Gear Manufacturer, https://khkgears.net/new/gear_knowledge/introduction_to_gears/types_of_gears.html (accessed May 29, 2023). [7] R. S. Khurmi and J. K. Gupta, A Text Book of Machine Design. New Delhi: Eurasia, 1990. 9/3/20XX 42 The End 9/3/20XX 43