Critique for Review of Related Literature
Criteria
Purpose
Relevance
Citations
Coherence
Positive
The study does not only focus
on finding the factors and
effects but also on finding
solutions and proposing
recommendations or solutions
to the problem and for the
benefactors. The purpose of the
research can be determined by
reading the statement of the
problem and the background of
the study. One thing about this
research paper is, it sticks to its
objective, thus, it is very
explicit.
The research paper discussed its
relevance to the researcher
itself, learners, teachers,
parents, and future researchers
using the question "How?". It
can be seen before The
significance of the study. The
topic chosen is very timely
therefore, the
recommendations or
supplementary solutions for the
issue are very relevant and
significant in our time.
Citations are present in the
Research Paper. It is written in
APA format. It can be seen on
Page 18, the references. The
research paper observes the
use of proper citations in citing
such quotes and statements in
all parts specifically, the review
of related literature and studies.
The research paper fits all
together, the sequence or flow
of the ideas and the information
are well presented and
organized thus, it maintains
clarity. You can distinguish the
main points and key points of
Negative
No negative review for the
purpose study.
No negative review of the
research paper's relevance.
No negative reviews, for the
citations are observed,
complete and properly used in
the Research Paper.
There is no conceptual
framework in this study.
Observation of Ethics
the study. Information is
supported by facts, which made
the study much more reliable
and true.
The study or the research paper
has ethical report data, results,
methods, and procedures. It
does not fabricate, falsify, or
misrepresent data. Also, the
study includes explanations of
voluntary participation,
informed consent, anonymity,
confidentiality, the potential for
harm, and results
communication. It can be seen
before the Ethical
Considerations part.
No negative reviews about the
Observation of Ethics of the
study.
Reference: Militante, C. P., Dueñas, R. R., Palermo , G. L., & Ornopia, E. D. (2022). Mobile gaming: Its
influence to a senior high school student's academic ... Retrieved April 19, 2023, from
https://ijrp.org/paper-detail/3415