Uploaded by missy ann montillon

EBJ in Psych

advertisement
Angeles University Foundation
Angeles City, Philippines
A.Y. 2022-2023
EVIDENCED-BASED JOURNAL: Acute Psychiatric Unit
Submitted by:
Missy Ann Montillon
Submitted to:
Ms. Cherry Sangcap, RN, MsN
A. TITLE
1. Research Title:
Prevalence and factors associated with anxiety and depression in older
adults: Gender differences in psychosocial indicators
2. Authors:
Emma Curran
Michael Rosato
Finola Ferry
Gerard Leavey
3. Date of Acceptance for Publication:
6 February 2020
4. Date of Submission for the Publication:
19 December 2019
5. Name of the Journal:
Journal of Affective Disorders
6. Journal Details:
Volume 26, Pages 114-122, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2020.02.018
B. INTRODUCTION: Main Problem Tackled in the Journal, Background of the
Problem, Objectives of the Research, and Significance of the Research
As the population ages, the amount of time spent in excellent health provides
significant personal, societal, and economic advantages. Whereas anxiety and
depression may both be adaptive physiological strategies for survival wherein
pathological symptoms can develop when linked pathways are disrupted by
trauma or persistent stress. Comorbid anxiety and depression are common in old
age psychiatry with approximately 90% of patients with anxiety also reported
experiencing symptoms of depression which may lead to lower life expectancy,
health issues, and deaths. It's crucial to distinguish between pathological and
adaptive symptoms in old age as some symptoms may be mistaken for
temporary adaptations to aging. Therefore, the danger of both physical and
mental disorders increases if untreated. Older adults may not achieve adequate
assistance or care without a proper diagnosis, which can also reveal undetected
subthreshold symptoms, excessive levels of adaptive anxiety, or dual diagnoses.
In contrast to adaptive emotions or isolated conditions, comorbid pathological
disorders are more treatment-resistant and have a greater suicide rate. They may
also cause more severe psychological, physical, and social problems. Thus, it is
clinically important for the aging population to understand how these illnesses
occur and the factors that contribute to them. The need for psychosocial
therapies and the administration of pharmacological treatments can both be
considerably improved by taking into consideration symptom profiles and
connections with a variety of social and medical variables in elderly patients.
Nonetheless, this study aims to investigate: the prevalence of anxiety and
depression among older persons who live in communities and to evaluate the
socio demographic traits connected to symptom profiles and connections to a
variety of psychological and clinical indicators.
C.
METHODOLOGY: Research subjects/respondents/participants, Research
design, Appropriateness of the design, Method for data collection, and Data
Analysis used
Using statistics from The Irish Longitudinal Study on Aging, a cross
sectional analysis was conducted. 8175 adults who were fifty years of age or
older and their wives or partners made up the representative sample community
based sample. The latent class analysis identified gender-specific trait patterns
for anxiety and depression. Using logistic regression, the connections between
socio-demographic and social characteristics were examined as correlates of
latent classes and health indicators.
D. RESULT: Results of the study (brief and concise as possible)
Self-reported anxiety and depression are divided into four categories:
"low," "comorbidity," "anxiety and subthreshold depression," and "anxiety only." In
men, 8% had comorbid conditions, 26% had subthreshold conditions, and 26%
had anxiety alone. With females, 12% had comorbid conditions, 27% were below
the threshold, and 29% had anxiety alone. While symptom expression may be
correlated to age-related stress, our data demonstrate distinct gradations of
symptoms linked to a variety of psychological and clinical indicators.
E. DISCUSSION: Relevance of the Evidence-based journal to nursing practice,
education, and research journal (Identify at least 1 strength and 1 weakness of
the journal
These data show different age and gender variations. First, it appears that
all disorder symptoms are most strongly linked to relatively younger persons
(ages 50 to 59), presumably due to difficulties in the transitional life stage around
retirement. The results support the claim that retirement age may be a risk factor
for mental illness and loneliness. Second, although there is a clear correlation
between loneliness and depression (co-morbid or subthreshold), anxiety does not
seem to influence those with loneliness, possibly indicating that anxiety has less
of an impact on social relationships than one might assume. Additionally, those
with co-morbid depression and anxiety have the highest associations for both
male and female loneliness, indicating a gradient across the illness subgroups.
Third, we identified that, unlike their male partners, women with anxiety manage
to maintain social networks that may be preventive against loneliness and
depression, even though low family income and relationship stress were related
to mental ill health. Females may have developed larger, more protective
networks over the course of their lives than men, who might be too reliant on
smaller family relationships and less safeguarded when these ties break down.
Furthermore, female adolescents (ages 14 to 25) had twice as much depression
as male adolescents, and this ratio decreases gradually as people get older.
However, there is a decline in depression rates for both sexes with a trend
approaching convergence after 65 years. Men and women have different
predictors of psychological problems, but they also differ from one another in a
number of ways. Therefore, while marriage is typically beneficial, it can also
cause stress for some people and is felt differently by men and women.
Additionally, when people become older, their roles and status may alter, which
could have different sociocultural and psychological effects on men and women.
Therefore, the end of childrearing and the start of retirement may have different
effects on men and women. Compared to men, women seem to have built
stronger, non-work-related networks after retirement. As a result, it is possible to
hypothesize that unique loci within the symptoms of depression and anxiety may
be associated with sociocultural distinctions related to role and position.
Weakness of the Journal:
The study does not provide a solution to the question of whether anxiety
precedes a depressed mood or not, serving as a chronic stressor that initiates
depression. However, it does raise questions about social isolation amongst
elderly individuals who suffer from anxiety and depression and its implications. To
decide whether people need a more complete assessment of their depressive or
anxious symptoms, the CES-D and HADS-A can be used as preliminary
screening instruments. However, it must be understood that they are not
standalone diagnostic tools. Every participant whose scores exceeded the
established cutoff points should go through additional diagnostic testing in a
clinical setting. Additional diagnostic tests are particularly necessary to validate a
diagnosis and to differentiate between anxiety and depressive disorders.
Strength of the Journal:
Given these constraints, data from the CES-D and HADS-A are sufficient
for profiling this population and identifying risk factors for worse mental illness,
which is useful for developing specific community-level interventions for this
population, in response to stressors, anxiety frequently precedes depression. By
recognizing persons with different levels of depression, health professionals can
advocate for early community intervention, which may lessen the burden in
clinical settings.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION: Applicability of the journal findings to
Nursing Practice, Education and Research
This research finds a significant frequency of mental illness among the
aging population, emphasizing the significance of accurate diagnosis and therapy
as a significant concern. The most prevalent mental illnesses in primary care are
depression and anxiety, which take up a large portion of health providers'
responsibilities. Therefore, a more detailed understanding of risk variables is
required to aid in early diagnosis. People who are older are more likely to be ill or
disabled and to seek primary care more frequently. Therefore, general medical
visits among the elderly population offer a good chance to evaluate for mental
illness and give prompt care. The results demonstrate that patterns of mental
illness are influenced by demographic and contextual factors; these implications
should be considered when designing the best possible care delivery.
Furthermore, the improvement of older people's mental health care will be a
concern for nurses globally and locally as the world's population ages. Providing
excellent mental health nursing care should be a major and continuing concern.
Administrators, legislators, organized groups, researchers, and clinical nurses
would all devote more attention to the importance of high-quality care as the
number of elderly persons in our society rises. Clinical considerations include the
necessity for nurses to be conscious of the behaviors they consider to be signs of
compassion which makes them more motivated to implement and reinforce
compassionate behaviors and be adaptable in high-stress contexts with shorter
hospital stays, higher levels of acuity, and lower nurse-to-patient ratios.
Furthermore, nurses must be equipped to make a substantial contribution to the
early evaluation and treatment of any mental health issues that older people may
suffer. This entails taking a thorough history and using documentation and
screening tools, behavioral analysis systems, etc. Consequently, nurses would
be in a unique position to put non-pharmacological measures into action and
analyze them in order to decrease the beginning of unnecessary psychiatric
medication.
Download