Post-Mid Assignment 1 SUBMITTED BY TAYYIBA SHAHID MAJOR: ACCOUNTING AND FINANCE SEMESTER: 6 SUBJECT: Islamic Banking & Finance DATE: May 13, 2022 SUBMITTED TO Ma’am Fareeha Waseem 1 Table of Contents Contents Case Scenario: Application Based Financing Mode ................................................................................ 3 Critical Evaluation ...................................................................................................................................... 7 References .................................................................................................................................................. 13 Annexures .................................................................................................................................................. 14 2 Case Scenario: Application Based Financing Mode “Critically discuss in detail the mechanism behind the Faysal Bank Noor Card OR other Islamic Bank offering the card based on the same mode.” Faysal Bank Noor Card: Faysal Bank Noor Card are based on the principles of Islamic Finance i.e. Tawarruq. They are introduced first time in Pakistan. Faysal Bank uses “Musawamah” sales contract to conduct the process of Noor Cards. It can satisfy the liquidity needs of clients (merchants) without the charge of interest (Riba). It is an asset based financing. The process flow is such that on deferred basis customer purchases the products from bank and sell it to the third party on spot to fulfill their liquidity needs immediately, while compliance with Shariah. To be eligible to get Faysal Bank Noor Cards, the person should be above 18. The limit of transaction for the card is Rs. 50,000 to Rs. 3,000,000. Types of Noor Card: As, with conventional bank card types, Faysal Bank has some types of Noor Cards which are: Noor Velocity Card – to provide flexibility in purchasing process. Noor Blaze Card – to provide for the major use in times shopping and travelling. Noor Titanium Card – to provide for offers wither locally or internationally that are not misleading. Noor Platinum Card – it also provides for major use in shopping and travelling; but it has more limit so it provides more ease and good experience. Noor World Card – it offers discounts and offers for travelers and provides protection from fraud. Mechanisms behind Noor Card: The steps for mechanism are as follows: Firstly, individual applies for the Noor Cards. When the individual has applied, they enters into “Musawamah contract” by which he/she agrees to purchase commodities from the bank on deferred basis. 3 Then when goods are bought on deferred basis and customer has their possession, the customer appoints agent to sell them to the third party, on spot basis. When the goods are sold on spot basis, the immediate liquidity needs of customer are fulfilled as the proceeds are transferred to Modaraba account, and the amount can be used/withdraw by using the Noor Card. Transactions are sent to the client through monthly bank statement. For the use of full limit of card, payment should be made within the required time frame. Then the bank demands the “Accrued profit” as per the Musawamah agreement, if the customer doesn’t pay entire amount within the time frame. Benefits of Noor Card: Some benefits/ features of these Noor Cards are: Providence of “DigiMall” service to provide services in case of online shopping. Protection from fraud in experiences of travelling and shopping. No payment/fee is deducted on withdrawals. On some occasions i.e. dining etc., if a card holder pays through these Noor Cards, they can get 40% discount, which is a great incentive to holders. On spend, i.e. by using the card, the customers can redeem rewards and on basis of those rewards, Faysal Bank contributes in the charity, which is a well feature offered. “Evaluate the financing mode and type of banking under which this facility is currently offering by Islamic Banks.” Tawarruq is a commodity Murabaha/Reverse Murabaha contract, which involves Musawamah sales contract. Faysal Bank provides the Noor Cards facility under the Tawarruq principles and the contract is based on Musawamah (similar to Murabaha except the different that cost and profit amounts are not known by the buyer) and the type of banking under which the facility is provided is personal banking. 4 “Compare the difference between the Conventional Banks credit card and Tawarruq based card. Also discuss the role of Mutawarriq in this transaction.” Clauses Conventional Bank Tawarruq Based Card Credit Card Interest Interest is charged on loan No amount and is compounded. interest deferred charged payment on of commodities Basis Process of Working Conventional Rulings Shariah Rulings Customer takes loan from Customer purchases bank and uses it through credit commodities on deferred basis card and has to pay back the by bank and sells to 3rd party loan amount with the interest. on spot basis, and the amount then can be used by credit cards (like Faysal Bank Noor Cards) Zakat Individual Eligible Not deducted from account Deducted from account Any individual who takes loan Mostly the individuals are traders/merchants Insurance Sometimes provided insurance is Yes. Takaful i.e. Islamic form of insurance is provided The role of Mutawarriq (customer) in these transactions is that he buys the commodities from bank on deferred basis (by the process flow the bank has made) and sells those commodities himself or by the help of an agent to the 3rd party on spot basis, in order to fulfill his immediate liquidity needs. “For the above mentioned Islamic Mode, identify the below mentioned major clauses of Tawarruq contract.” 5 Clauses Description Financing Need and Nature of Goods It is for meeting immediate liquidity needs of the customer. Any kind of commodity i.e. liquid can be a subject matter in this mode, which can be sold to 3rd part easily on spot basis. Ownership of Goods and Possession of Goods In start, bank will have both physical and constructive ownership. But when the customer buys on deferred and goods are transferred to him, the ownership (constructive) would be with the bank; however customer would have physical possession. But when the commodities are sold to 3rd party on spot, both the ownership and possession would become of that 3rd party. Asset side v/s Liability side Financing Collateral/Security Required Part of Asset side financing As, Tawarruq financing mode is to fulfill the immediate liquidity needs of customer. The commodities bought om deferred are sold on spot to 3rd party. So it means if commodities can be sold easily their value isn’t too much. So no collateral/security is required by the bank. Transfer of Wealth (Maal) The price of goods is the wealth here. Firstly, when goods are sold on spot, wealth is transferred from 3rd party to customer. Then they are transferred from customer to the bank. 6 Critical Evaluation Part 1: Critically evaluate the difference among the modes of IMPORT FINANCING. Discuss the practical procedure and process flows of these financing modes. State one example of these modes that Islamic banks are currently offering. Import Financing: Banks facilitate its customer not only in the form of taking deposits and lending loans, bank helps the customer to do their business and trade, internationally. In import financing, bank plays a critical and crucial role, mainly in the form of providing guarantee to the exporter i.e. if bank will not be there as a body to provide guarantee that in case the importer defaults, the issuing bank will be liable to make payment, then the exporters will be reluctant to trade internationally. Either it is conventional bank or Islamic Bank, Letter of Credit is opened. Conventional bank charges interest for opening it, but the Islamic banks don’t and it charges for other fees related with the account opening i.e. assessment fee, monitoring fee, documentation and processing fee. Four parties are involved in import financing i.e. importer, exporter, importer’s bank and exporter’s bank. In conventional banking, the lender is not faced with any risk; while in Islamic banking, the banks share both the risk and rewards. An example of such financing could be that suppose a Pakistani resident customer wants to import goods from USA and he approaches a conventional bank (Bank al Habib Ltd.) for opening of Letter of Credit. The bank will charge fee for opening L/C. The customer/importer will get loan and the customer has to pay back the loan with interest to the bank and if customer faces a loss bank will not be faced by that loss. If the customer has approached the Islamic window of Bank al Habib Ltd. Then the importer wouldn’t have to pay back the money with interest and as well as in case of loss if importer, the bank would be faced by the loss also as Islamic banks are faced by both risk and rewards in this facility. Mode of Import Financing offered by Islamic Banks: Three modes of financing are provided, which are discussed below with their details: 7 Clauses Type of Contract Murabaha Musharakah Sales Contract Ijarah Partnership contract Lease/ rental contract Asset v/s Liability For importer, it is the It is for both i.e. asset For importer, it is Side of Financing asset side financing of side and liability side the bank Purpose financing activities of working importer to capital finance are products the selling type at form of fixed commodities prices) needs of importer of No collateral In form of rental Mortgage/Hypothecation Bank’s Role is needs of importers equipment or such (who In side financing of bank Purpose is to fulfill the Purpose is to satisfy Purpose trading Collateral asset payments Bank (seller) Bank and importer Bank (Lessor) Importer (buyer) are partners. Importer (Lessee) The customer is lessee until makes he full payment. Ownership/Possession Ownership of Goods i.e. Both are partners and Ownership constructive is own assets in the with transferred to bank when proportionate the lies bank until the importer the goods are delivered (random). So pays for all rentals by exporter (supplier) to ownership doesn’t and payments of the importer (customer). transfers except in the asset. Thus at this point when the cases where one goods are transferred to partner customer, he’ll wants to have leave. physical ownership 8 Examples Import Murabaha Import Musharakah Riba financing is provided by financing Dubai Islamic Bank is Free also Financing Car by provided by Dubai Meezan Bank Islamic Bank Practical Procedures and Process Flows: The practical procedures of these three modes along with their process flow is as follows: 1. Murabaha: Importer approaches the bank for the funds need for trading Murabaha agreement between importer and the importer’s will be signed. Then bank will require the importer to specify the goods that he wants. Agency agreement between importer and the bank will be signed, in which bank will appoint importer his agent to buy the goods. L/C account will be opened and the exporter’s bank will send the goods along with the related documents. The cost + profit will be known by the importer as well/ Murabaha contract will be executed when goods are delivered to customer and Bill of Lading is received by importer/importer’s bank. Then the importer has to pay the bank at certain date, already decided. 9 2. Musharakah: Importer approaches the bank for the funds need for trading. Musharakah agreement between importer and the importer’s bank will be signed. The bank and importer will be partners and profit ratio will be decided among them by mutual consent. Importer will make payment of his share. L/C account will be opened and the exporter’s bank will send the goods along with the related documents. Payment will be made by importer’s to exporter’s bank and then the documents will be released to the importer by the importer’s bank. Then the selling of those goods in local market will take place and both the importer’s bank and the importer will receive the profit as per agreed ratio. 3. Ijarah: Importer approaches the bank for the commodity (equipment etc.) need for trading. Agency agreement between importer and the importer’s bank will be signed as importer’s bank will appoint the customer as an agent to import goods on its behalf. Rental payments of that asset will be determined. 10 L/C account will be opened and the exporter’s bank will send the goods along with the related documents i.e. Bill of Lading. Then the delivery of goods will be accepted by importer. At this point of time, the Ijarah Agreement will be signed because at this time, the importer will receive the asset and will start using it. After the use of assets over a specified time and along with paying the rental payments decided in the contract, the asset will be the sole property of the importer as it will be sold to him by his bank. Part 2: SBP ISLAMIC EXPORT REFINANCE SCHEME: Currently State Bank of Pakistan is providing the Islamic Exports Refinance Scheme by entering into different agreements with Islamic Banks. Mention this facility along with this detailed mechanism based on Shariah Compliant products. SBP launched this new concept of Islamic export refinance scheme, in order to provide smooth flow of exports in the country under the Shariah rules and regulations. The objective of this scheme is to increase the number of exports of commodities with high value. Liquidity is also ensured for 11 exporters through this scheme. This scheme involves a “negative list” which includes the names of those commodities against which this scheme will not work. Mechanism of Export Refinancing Scheme: The scheme is based on the Musharkah agreement between SBP and Islamic Banks, so there is profit and loss sharing among the two partners. Musharkah pool is a term used in this scheme, which is a pool formed by minimum 10 blue chip companies and with maximum exposure of 50%. The process flow is as follows: Islamic banks and SBP signs Musharakah agreement, in which both pool funds. Exporters will get financing through this pool. Importer will give the Islamic banks and SBP the proceeds, which will be divided as per agreed ratio. Parts of Scheme: The scheme has two parts: 1. Part 1— It is a transaction-based instrument that allows for 100% refinancing of export contracts through banks. This service is accessible for direct exporters for 180 days and indirect exporters for 120 days. 2. Part 2—It is a limited based facility which is provided after monitoring the export performance of exporter for previous financial year. This facility is available for 180 days and can be rolled over again if it met 70% shipment requirement of financing, the user has availed. Eligibility Criteria: The exporters should have following criteria, to be a part of this scheme: Should have good track in stock exchange Credit rating of atleast B+ Should not have adverse Credit Information Bureau report Should have ROE higher than markup rate which are mentioned in this scheme. 12 References Faysal Islami Noor Card. (n.d.). Faysal Bank. https://www.faysalbank.com/en/islamic/islami-noor-cards/ SBP’s Incentive Schemes. (n.d.). SBP. https://www.sbp.org.pk/Incen/index.asp Import Financing. (n.d.). Islamic Markets. https://islamicmarkets.com/education/importfinancing EXPORT REFINANCE SCHEME. (n.d.). SBP. https://www.sbp.org.pk/sbp_bsc/apr/chap_11.pdf 13 Annexures 14 15 16 17