Critical Appraisal Skills Program
(CASP) on Hot Tea Consumption
and Esophageal Cancer Risk
Validity of the Study
The study conducted a systematic review of case-control and cohort studies to
investigate the potential association between hot tea consumption and the risk of
esophageal cancer (EC). The authors performed extensive searches on several
databases and manually retrieved relevant literature from included studies and recent
reviews. They also adhered to a set of inclusion criteria when selecting studies. These
rigorous measures helped to enhance the credibility of the study.
Study Methods
The researchers behind the study carried out a comprehensive analysis of
observational studies to explore whether there is a correlation between the risk of
esophageal cancer and the consumption of hot tea. They performed extensive searches
on several databases and manually retrieved relevant literature from included studies
and recent reviews. The authors used strict inclusion criteria to select the studies and
assessed their quality using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS), which is a trusted tool
for quality assessment. They conducted sensitivity analysis to test the validity of the
main results using Comprehensive Meta-Analysis (CMA) software.
Quality Assessment
The researchers used the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) to evaluate the studies'
quality. This tool assesses the risk of bias in non-randomized studies and is a reliable
measure. To ensure dependability, two independent reviewers conducted the quality
assessment. Using this approach enhances the study's credibility and reinforces the
validity of its results.
Results
Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) on Hot Tea Consumption and Esophageal Cancer Risk
1
The study analyzed 23 reports with a total of 5,050 cases and 10,609 controls. The
results revealed that drinking hot tea increases the risk of esophageal cancer. More
studies are needed to understand why hot tea consumption raises the risk of
esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) but not esophageal adenocarcinoma
(EAC). The researchers used Comprehensive Meta-Analysis (CMA) software to test the
robustness of the main results and found no significant changes. Although the study has
some limitations, its findings have important implications for esophageal cancer
prevention.
In summary, the study confirms that drinking hot tea increases the risk of esophageal
cancer. Further research is necessary to determine the underlying mechanisms of this
correlation. These findings have significant implications for policymakers and public
health professionals who are working to prevent esophageal cancer.
Relevance
The study is relevant to the field of EC etiology research and EC prevention. The
findings of this meta-analysis have important implications for public health.
Additional References
1. Islami, F., & Kamangar, F. (2008). Surviving esophageal cancer in the 21st century.
Archives of Iranian medicine, 11(2), 222-223.
2. Thrift, A. P., & Whiteman, D. C. (2012). The incidence of esophageal
adenocarcinoma continues to rise: analysis of period and birth cohort effects on
recent trends. Annals of Oncology, 23(12), 3155-3162.
Comments on the Study's Rationale
The study's rationale is clear and relevant to the field. Esophageal cancer is a significant
global health problem, and the potential protective effects of tea consumption have
been studied previously. However, inconsistent or contradictory results were found in
epidemiological studies, especially when drinking tea at higher temperatures. Therefore,
this meta-analysis aimed to evaluate the association between hot tea consumption and
the risk of esophageal cancer more accurately. The authors used a systematic search
strategy and a quality assessment tool to increase the validity of their findings. The
study's limitations were also acknowledged, such as the inability to eliminate
Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) on Hot Tea Consumption and Esophageal Cancer Risk
2
heterogeneity and the lack of precise data on tea temperature in some studies. Overall,
the study's strengths outweigh its limitations, and the findings have important
implications for EC etiology research and prevention.
Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) on Hot Tea Consumption and Esophageal Cancer Risk
3