A Combination of Plant-Based Activity of Ginger (Zingiber officinale) and Lemon (Citrus limon) as Mosquito Repellent A Research Proposal Presented to the Faculty of Cebu Technological University-Main Campus M.J. Cuenco Ave, Cor R. Palma St., 6000 Cebu City In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Subject Research in Teaching Llena, Mary Gienavell B. Pepito, Jedelyn Perales, Juvy Ruiz, Jamila Alita S. Labiaga, MAT-S Instructor Esperanza Del Fierro M. Sci. Adviser September 2022 APPROVAL SHEET This Research entitled “A Combination of Plant-Based Activity of Ginger (Zingiber officinale) and Lemon (Citrus limon) as Mosquito Repellent” prepared and submitted by MARY GIENAVELL B. LLENA, JEDELYN PEPITO, JUVY PERALES, and JAMILA RUIZ are hereby recommended for approval. RESEARCH ADVISORY COMMITTEE JONATHAN O. ETCUBAN, Ph. D Chairman MARIA SALUD DELOS SANTOS, Ph. D Member ALITA S. LABIAGA, MAT-S Member ESPERANZA DEL FIERRO, M. Sc. Member ESPERANZA DEL FIERRO, M. Sc. Adviser Approved by the Committee on Research Proposal Defense with a grade________. PANEL OF EXAMINERS JONATHAN O. ETCUBAN, Ph. D Chairman MARIA SALUD DELOS SANTOS, Ph. D Member ALITA S. LABIAGA, MAT-S Member ESPERANZA DEL FIERRO, M. Sc. Member ESPERANZA DEL FIERRO, M. Sc. Adviser This research paper is approved in partial fulfillment of the requirements of SCI-M 3215. Research Proposal Defense: Date of Proposal Defense: September 30, 2022 REYLAN G. CAPUNO Ph.D., Dev.Ed.D. Dean, College of Education TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page TITLE PAGE CERTIFICATE OF PANEL APPROVAL TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1: THE PROBLEM AND ITS SCOPE INTRODUCTION Rationale of the Study Theoretical Background Conceptual Framework THE PROBLEM Statement of the Problem Statement of Hypotheses Significance of the Study Scope and Limitations RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Design Research Procedures Gathering of Data Treatment of Data Ethical Considerations DEFINITION OF TERMS REFERENCE CHAPTER 1 THE PROBLEM AND ITS SCOPE INTRODUCTION Rationale of the Study All over the world, people are at risk from mosquito-borne diseases such as malaria, dengue, yellow fever, West Nile virus, and several forms of encephalitis (Gubler 1989, Monath 1989). Dengue fever is a mosquito-borne sickness that can be found in tropical and subtropical regions around the world. High fever and flu-like symptoms characterize dengue fever. Dengue hemorrhagic fever, a severe form of dengue fever, can result in major bleeding, a drop in blood pressure, and death. Mosquitoes can be unwelcome guests on wet days, and they are a serious human bug problem. We have come up with this study because we want to avoid mosquito bites that might carry diseases like dengue fever and malaria, as well as painful or itchy insect bites. Because commercial repellents are harsh and have poisons that are not suitable for children, we don’t know what the side effects of these repellents are. Using natural ingredients such as lemon and ginger, it is an inexpensive alternative to developing a mosquito repellent that is both effective and safe. We don't need poisons to deal with insects. Tropical nations like the Philippines continue to experience serious issues with public health conditions due to diseases spread by mosquitoes. Dengue, the mosquitoborne illness with the fastest global spread, affected 131,827 Filipinos in 2017. (DOH, 2017). Public health in the Philippines has begun to place more emphasis on other emerging and re-emerging mosquito-borne diseases like the Zika virus, Japanese encephalitis, and chikungunya as climate change and global warming, which worsen every year, increase the likelihood and spread of many vector-borne diseases. These new and re-emerging diseases are spread by mosquitoes, which is a common epidemiological characteristic. In the same way that some mosquito vectors are specific to one disease while others are responsible for multiple diseases, some management approaches are more effective against one disease than others. The Research Institute for Tropical Medicine (RITM), the research division of the Philippine Department of Health that focuses on infectious and tropical diseases, is currently leading projects and research in the Philippines on the entomological aspects of mosquito-borne diseases, from the biological study of the vectors to their surveillance and control (Salazar and Gimutao, 2017). Numerous corporate and public institutions across the nation also carry out or fund entomology-related public health research. Mosquitoes are well known for their significance to public health since they can spread dangerous illnesses like malaria. To control malaria and other infections conveyed by mosquitoes, chemical pesticides have been utilized, but this has led to problems with insecticide toxicity, high operating costs, community acceptance, and the emergence of insecticide resistance among vectors. The factors mentioned above-encouraged researchers to hunt for fresh approaches to malaria treatment. Secondary metabolites of plants (plant extracts and essential oils) with mosquitocidal potential are currently acknowledged as workable substitutes for synthetic pesticides in mosquito control programs because of their larvicidal, adulticidal, and repellent properties. Furthermore, plant-based mosquitocide formulations can contribute to effective, cost-efficient, and secure malaria vector control. According to the World Health Organization, WHO (2013), the most significant mosquito-borne disease, malaria, is brought on by Plasmodium parasites by the bite of female Anopheles mosquitoes, according to World Health Organization WHO (2013).In 2010, malaria was blamed for an estimated 660,000 (range 490,000-836,000) fatalities and 219 (range 154-289) million cases worldwide. About 80% of the cases and 90% of the deaths in Africa occur. Each year, malaria claims the lives of almost 70,000 individuals in Ethiopia. Thus, one method of preventing the spread of diseases caused by mosquitoes is to kill them or prevent them from biting people. Over the past seven decades, efforts to eradicate mosquito vectors in tropical areas have not resulted in any appreciable advancement. The search for new and efficient mosquito control techniques has been sparked by mosquito resistance to synthetic mosquitocidal already in use as well as their toxicity to non-target animals. Researchers are looking for novel, ecologically safe, and target-specific insecticides around the world as a result of the aforementioned problems and worries. Additionally, efforts are being made to extract, screen, and produce phytochemicals with insecticidal activity to identify new mechanisms of action and develop new active substances derived from organic plant materials. Therefore, as part of an integrated vector management approach, plant products with demonstrated mosquito control capability can be used in place of synthetic pesticides or conjunction with other insecticides. Mosquitoes are blood-sucking insects that can infect both people and animals with a wide range of diseases. Although they favor wetlands, they can also live in sewers, puddles, and man-made containers. The dengue mosquito, commonly known as Aedes aegypti, is dark in color with recognizable white leg patterns and lyre-shaped markings on the thorax. It is crucial to know how to identify the Aedes aegypti mosquito, which may transmit dengue by biting both humans and animals. As a result, scientists are working to create substitute repellents produced from natural plant sources that are risk-free for consumers and have an efficacy comparable to conventional therapies. Plant-based repellents have been used for generations as a personal protection measure against mosquitoes. Studies on traditional repellant plants are excellent sources of knowledge that can be used to create new natural products. Mosquito repellents have a variety of properties, but they all serve the same purpose: to keep vector/host encounters and the spread of vector-borne diseases away from people and our environment. The researchers had agreed that this was the topic they wanted to investigate and learn more about for their study. The researchers wanted to see if lemon and ginger could work as natural insect repellents. The researchers want to investigate to see what the lemon and ginger might do to mosquitos if they got too close. The researchers sought to investigate this so that people might try natural (plantbased) repellents like lemon and ginger, which are simple to formulate and apply. Mosquito repellents are an efficient way to protect yourself against mosquitos that carry a variety of diseases. Dengue fever is one of the most common diseases spread by mosquitoes. Natural components were to be used by the researchers. The mosquito repellent that the researchers will formulate is more inexpensive and environmentally beneficial because the substance is naturally plant-based. Lemon and ginger will be the ingredients used by the researchers. The finding is relevant to the researchers since mosquito bites are causing an increase in mortality, even though there are alternate remedies. Theoretical Background There are around 3,500 different species of mosquitoes around the globe. The female mosquito bites both humans and animals because she needs the blood's protein to help her eggs develop. Mosquitoes are drawn to people by their skin smells and carbon dioxide breath emissions (Bowen 1991). By rendering a person undesirable to a mosquito for mating, repellents deter mosquitoes. The most popular insect repellent products on the market include a synthetic substance called N, N-diethyl-3-methylbenzamide (DEET). The United States invented and patented it. Army in 1946 for use by soldiers in places with a lot of insects. One of the few products known to be effective against mosquitoes and biting insects is DEET. In the United States, it was authorized for public usage in 1957. (EPA 1980). Numerous studies have demonstrated that DEET has great mosquito repellency and is effective in providing long-lasting protection against a wide range of mosquito species. (Roberts and Reigart 2004; Fradin and Day 2002; Schreck and McGovern 1989). Although DEET works well to keep mosquitoes away, there are risks involved in using it. Mucosal membranes are irritated, and concentrated formulas break down plastic. DEET applications have been linked to some mild to severe harmful effects on humans (Briassoulis et al. 2001; Bell and Veltri 2002). Research on repellents made from plant extracts is required because of these unfavorable side effects to identify safer but equally effective substitutes. The researchers' study is validated and reinforced by research on the impact of lemon (Citrus Limon L.) extract on Aedes sp. mortality. Citrus limon L. is a plant with a peel type that contains phytochemical components, particularly flavonoids, terpenoids, tannins, and limonenes, that can be utilized as plant-based insecticides. In the studies Potential as Repellent by Sutanto & Rohmah (2020) and Citrus limon L, these chemical compounds' components have the power to kill mosquitoes and serve as stomach and respiratory toxins. In addition, several plant species contain insecticidal and/or insect-repellent substances. A study conducted by Bukar and Tukur (2019), this work reviewed the adulticidal activities of some plants extracts and oils­­:Lemongrass (Cymbopogon citratus), spearmint (Mentha piperita), lemon basil (Ocimum citriodorum), coffee senna (Senna occidentalis), purple dead-nettle (Lamium purpurium), and ginger (Zingiber officinale), have been proven to be effective bio-insecticides against various genera and species of mosquito. Some plant species contain insecticidal and/or insect-repellent substances. A review by Sukumar (1991) highlighted the potential of plants for use in mosquito control, either as repellents, larvicides, or insecticides. Extracts of several plants—neem (Azadirachta indica), basil (Ocimum basilicum), (Mentha piperata), and lemon eucalyptus (Corymbia citriodora)—have been studied as possible mosquito repellents and have demonstrated a good efficacy against some mosquito species (Sharma et al. 1993; Ansari et al. 2000; Trigg and Hill 1996). Before the advent of synthetic insecticides, the mosquito-repelling abilities of plants were well known. In the past, people have utilized organic substances to ward off insect bites. Some plant species have compounds that are insecticidal and/or repellent, which can be used to make a mosquito repellent that is both inexpensive and efficient. Conceptual Framework Figure 1. Schematic diagram of the study Statement of the Problem This study aims to investigate the efficacy effect of plant-based repellents against mosquitoes. It specifically seeks to respond to the following: 1. Is a plant-based repellent effective in repelling mosquitoes? 2. How long does the effectiveness of the combined plant-based repellent last? 3. Do lemon and ginger oil extract as a mosquito repellant; 3.1 Affordable? 3.2 Easy to make Statement of Hypothesis Null Hypothesis H0: There is no significant effect of the combined plant-based extracts of lemon and ginger in repelling mosquitoes. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY A study will be conducted to determine if the combined extracts of lemon and ginger are effective in repelling mosquitoes. The result of the study is relevant to the following: Society: This will give them knowledge about the importance of mosquito repellent and may use this study to implement awareness on how to prevent numerous mosquito-borne diseases like dengue, malaria, and filariasis that affect each individual. ● SDG 3: Ensure healthy living conditions and promote well-being for all people of all ages Students: This study will help them understand the significance of lemon and ginger as the main ingredient for creating mosquito repellent. Parents: This study will serve as a guide that mosquito repellent is safe to use, natural, and environment-friendly, which protects the children from mosquito bites both inside and outside of the house. Schools: The knowledge they may get from this study can be used as a reference in ways to reduce mosquito activity and prevent mosquito bites. Future Researchers: This study gives information and ideas that will serve as the basis and guide for future research. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research Design An experimental design will be used in this study to test the effectiveness of the combined lemon and ginger extracts in repelling. In conducting experiments on mosquitos, this research hopes to show the efficacy of lemon and ginger as mosquito repellents. It strictly follows the methods, measurements, and analysis of the experiment. Research Subject The mosquitoes are the research subjects to be observed and experimented with. The mosquitoes were chosen because they would bite the exposed skin of a human if it was not applied with any mosquito repellent product. Since the goal of this research is to test and prove the efficacy of the combined plant-based extracts as a natural mosquito repellent, mosquitoes are suitable as the subject because the use of repellents makes a person unattractive for biting and therefore repels the mosquito (Maibach et al. 1966). Research Instrument The data obtained for this study will be gathered from the series of experiments conducted. The research of this study will use improvised extraction tools for the extraction process such as clean plastic bottles, water pumps, transparent hoses, makeshift alcohol lamps Research Procedures Gathering of Data MATERIALS ● Lemon ● Ginger A. TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT ● Candle ● Gasulette ● Binding wire ● 2 Plastic bottles ● 5 m transparent hose ● Wooden stand 30 cm ● Water pump ● 2 Flask ● Syringe ● Pot ● Grater ● 3 Empty Spray Bottle ● Welded wire (screen mesh) ● Mosquito net ● Screen cage ● Aquarium B. PREPARATION In this process, the materials and equipment are gathered and collected by the researchers. The materials that will be used for this experiment must be clean and the extracts of lemon and ginger that will be collected will be stored in their respective bottles. C. EXTRACTION PROCESS 1. Collect and prepare the needed materials (lemon and ginger). For lemons, prepare 10-15 lemons and grate the peel only. Weigh 100 grams of grated peel and put it in the flask (Sikdar, 2017). For ginger, prepare 10-15 gingers, slice into small pieces (2 cm), and sun-dried. After being sun-dried, the dried gingers were ground and screened with a (100 mesh) screen, and then they were kept tightly in plastic bags at room temperature (27-30 °C). It was ready to extract the ginger oil by using steam distillation methods (KhairuAizam Bin Ibrahim, 2006). 2. Execute the improvised steam distillation set-up based on the study of Galiga’s 2019 with their research about the development of improvised steam distillation and the researchers will make a few modifications. ● The first thing to do is heat one end of the thick binding wire on a candle flame for about 20 seconds. Use the heated end of the wire to make a hole at the center of the bottle cap and at the bottom (center) of the plastic bottle. ● Enlarge the holes using scissors just enough to fit the transparent hose. Insert the transparent hose into the holes of the plastic bottle. ● Make a hole in the designated areas in the second plastic bottle and insert the transparent hose. Fill the plastic bottle with distilled water. ● Set up the water pump and connect the hose to the plastic bottle with distilled water. ● Connect the flask with the grated lemon peel to the hose of the first bottle. ● Fill the pot with water, turn on the gasulette to make the water boil, and place the flask in the boiling water. ● Turn on the water pump to start the distillation and place an empty bottle on the connected hose from the flask to collect the extracts of lemon. ● Repeat the steam distillation process for collecting the extracts of ginger. E. Formulation of Mosquito Repellent Prepare an empty spray bottle for the mixture of lemon and ginger extracts. The concentrations of each extract with a treatment of 3 times, namely the concentration of: 1. Lemon and Ginger 25% each concentration extracts 2. Lemon and Ginger 50% each concentration extracts 3. Lemon and Ginger 100% each concentration extracts Below shows the procedure for making mosquito repellent out of lemon and ginger extracts: 1. Mix the lemon and ginger in each extract 2. Pour the mixture into a spray bottle F. CULTURING OF MOSQUITO The researchers will adopt the procedure from the study (Sritabutra & Soonwera, 2013) in rearing mosquitoes. 1. In a plastic container, fill the container with tap water and place it outside the house in order for the female mosquitoes to enter and lay eggs. 2. Check the container every day to see if there is an egg already. 3. Collecting of eggs were hatched in plastic trays (24 cm×33 cm×5.5 cm), which contained tap water. The hatched larvae were held in plastic trays and a larval diet with fish food was added to each tray. 4. Newly emerged pupae were transferred to a screen cage (size 30 cm×30 cm×30 cm) and emerged as adults. 5. Adults are continuously provided with 5% glucose solution in water soaked on cotton pads. In this study, 5 to 7-day-old female mosquitoes were starved only by provided them water for 8 h. Testing Process The screen cage is concealed with transparent nets for easy observation and also to keep mosquitoes inside the cage. The cage measurement for efficacy testing of mosquito repellent is in the range of 35-40 cm per side (WHO 1996). According to WHO (WHO 1996) conventional standards, the cage needs to be filled with 200 mosquitoes that have been starved overnight and only supplied with sucrose solution. In preparation for the improvised material that will be used, which is a cloth, it must be used cloth or unwashed because mosquitoes are attracted to the scent of sweat, particularly the scent of lactic acid in sweat (Rji and DeGennaro, 2017). This helps the researchers to investigate how the mosquitoes might react to the different study methods. Treatment of Data For the repellent test, the cloth will be applied with treatment mosquito repellent and placed into the cage, and exposed for 3 minutes at 1-hour intervals for 6 hours. Observe the death of the mosquito for 6 hours with an interval of 1 hour. There are three tests to determine the effectivity of the concentration. The first test will be the combination of 25% of lemon and 25% of ginger concentration. The second test will be the combination of 50% lemon and 50% ginger concentration. The third test will be the combination of 100% of lemon and 100% of ginger concentration. The tests that contain high effectiveness will be compared to the commercial repellent. Perform this test carefully and calculate the number of dead mosquitoes. The number of mosquitoes that land on the cloth is recorded every hour. The results can be given in data tables and narrative summaries as quantitative in analyzing the effectiveness of the formulated mosquito repellents under conditions. The researchers plan and carry out experiments to test their hypothesis. The researchers will use one-way ANOVA in analyzing the result. The researchers will use SPSS software to compute the results. Ethical consideration To conduct this study, the researchers sought approval to use lemon and ginger as plant-based mosquito repellents from the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) to ensure that the researchers will not use endangered plants for this research study. Definition of Terms Plant-based- consisting or made completely of plants. Repellent- the output made from plant-based oil. Ginger extract- a preparation containing the active ingredients of dried knobby-shaped rhizome of the plant Zingiber officinale (scientific name). Lemon extract- a preparation containing the active ingredient of yellow citrus fruit that is a source of citric acid and ascorbic acid. Mosquito- A mosquito is a tiny stinging insect that leaves an itchy welt on your skin. Between its annoying bites and its ability to spread disease, the mosquito is not the most popular of insects (unlike the fair ladybug). References: Amraoui, F., Pain, A., Piorkowski, G., Vazeille, M., Couto-Lima, D., de Lamballerie, X.,et al. (2018). Experimental adaptation of the yellow fever virus to the mosquito aedes albopictus and potential risk of urban epidemics in Brazil. South America. Sci. Rep. 8:14337. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-32198-32194 Baker, B. P., Grant, J. A., Malakar, K. R. (2018). "Peppermint & Peppermint Oil Profile".Minimum Risk Pesticide. Bukar, A., & Tukur, Z. (2019). Plant extracts as a source of bio-insecticide for mosquito control, review. International Journal of Mosquito Research, 6(6), 81-84. ECDC (2018). Aedes Albopictus. Current Known Distribution: June 2018 European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Encarnacion, C., (2019). "The Effect of Acidic Lemon, Ginger, Peppermint, and Vinegar Extracts on the Relative Rate of Repellency of Culex pipiens". South Carolina Junior Academy of Science. 176. Khaleel, R. I. (2019). BIO-TOXICITY STUDY OF SOME SELECTED PLANT BY ARTEMIA SALINA (LEACH) TEST. Plant Archives, 19(2), 2847-2850. Mohiuddin, A. K. (2019). Dengue protection and cure: Bangladesh perspective. European Journal of Sustainable Development Research, 4(1), em0104. Olotuah, O. F. (2021). The Use of Botanicals in the Control of Insect Pests in Agriculture. Biopesticides: Botanicals and Microorganisms for Improving Agriculture and Human Health, 83 Pak. J. Biol. Sci., 23 (2): 126-131, 2020 Reinhold, J. M., Lazzari, C. R., and Lahondère, C. (2018). Effects of the environmental temperature on aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus mosquitoes: a review. Insects 9:158. doi: 10.3390/insects9040158 Singh, V. K. ., R. K. . Singh, B. . Mishra, and D. . Singh. “Formulation and Evaluation of Eco-Friendly Handmade Herbal Mosquito Repellent Cone”. International Journal of Pharmaceutics and Drug Analysis, vol. 9, no. 4, Dec. 2021, pp. 230-5, doi:10.47957/ijpda.v9i4.488. Sheikh., Zaveriya K., & Mate, P. C. (2020). Review on: "Herbal Mosquito Repellent". International Journal of Pharmacy & Life Sciences, vol. 11 Issue 7, July 2020, p60-60. 1p. Spyriounis, M., Weng, K., & Cohen, J. I.(2020). Mosquito Repellents-A Systematic Review. Ukoroije, R. B., &Otayor, R. A. (2020). Review on the bio-insecticidal properties of some plant secondary metabolites: types, formulations, modes of action, advantages and limitations. Asian J. Res. Zool, 3, 27-60. Venturi, G., Luca, M. D., Fortuna, C., Remoli, M. E., Riccardo, F., Severini, F., et al. (2017). Detection of a chikungunya outbreak in Central Italy, August to September 2017. Eurosurveillance 22, 17–00646. doi: 10.2807/15607917.ES.2017.22.39.17-00646 Zen, S., Sutanto, A., &Rohmah, A. (2020). "The Effect Of Lemon (Citrus Limon L.) Extract On Mortality Of Aedes Sp. and Potential As Repellent". PENBIOS: JURNAL PENDIDIKAN BIOLOGI DAN SAINS, 5(02), 39-45. Anuar, A.A., Yusof, N. Methods of imparting mosquito repellent agents and the assessing mosquito repellency on textile. Fash Text 3, 12 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40691-016-0064-y Jong Kwang Yoon, Kang-Chang Kim, Yeon Dong Cho, Han Sam Cho, Yang-Won Lee, Mijeong Kim, Bo-Kyung Choi, Yu-Kyoung Oh, Young Bong Kim, Development and Evaluation of a Semifield Test for Repellent Efficacy Testing, Journal of Medical Entomology, Volume 51, Issue 1, 1 January 2014, Pages 182–188, https://doi.org/10.1603/ME13081 Orkin. (2022, June 9). Orkin. Retrieved September 25, 2022, from https://www.orkin.com/pests/mosquitoes/mosquito-life-cycle-facts Sritabutra, D., & Soonwera, M. (2013, August). Repellent activity of herbal essential oils against Aedes aegypti (Linn.) and Culex quinquefasciatus (Say.). Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Disease, 3(4), 271–276. https://doi.org/10.1016/s2222-1808(13)60069-9 Sikdar, R, D. C., Nikila. (2017 B.C.E., April). EXTRACTION OF CITRUS OIL FROM LEMON (CITRUS LIMON) PEELS BY STEAM DISTILLATION AND ITS CHARACTERIZATIONS. International Journal of Technical Research and Applications e-ISSN: 2320-8163, www.ijtra.com, Volume 5, Issue 2 (March - April 2017), PP. 29-33. Retrieved September 22, 2022, from https://www.ijtra.com/view/extraction-of-citrus-oil-from-lemon-citrus-limonpeels-by-steam-distillation-and-its-characterizations.pdf Nguyen, S., Vo, P., Nguyen, T., Do, N., Le, B., Dinh, D., Truong, K., & Pham, P. (2019). Ethanol extract of Ginger Zingiber officinale Roscoe by Soxhlet method induces apoptosis in human hepatocellular carcinoma cell line. Biomedical Research and Therapy, 6(11), 3433-3442. https://doi.org/10.15419/bmrat.v6i11.572 Galiga, H. F. (2019, January 14). Development of an improvised convertible distillation apparatus for teaching http://www.palawanscientist.org/. and Retrieved learning March 31, chemistry. 2019, http://www.palawanscientist.org/tps/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/InPress_HFGaliga_Distillation_V_1.pdf?fbclid=IwAR33bA4wjgYljkJV8NGeI2uLbQnsK-VkfTZdtex3kRIYGMxAl1-j4TgkXQ from