_____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 1 of 94 _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 2 of 94 STANDARDS OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) Annex “A” Promulgated as Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266, known as “The Architecture Act of 2004” and to be known hereinafter as the SPP Documents (replacing the 1979 UAP Docs. 201 through 208 and the UAP Docs 209 and 210) A. GENERAL DEFINITIONS 1. State shall refer solely to the National Government of the Republic of the Philippines. 2. Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) is a required document under Sec. 41 of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR). 3. Commission as used for this SPP and the succeeding SPP documents shall refer only to the Professional Regulation Commission (PRC), duly created under R.A. No. 8981 (The PRC Modernization Act of 2000). 4. Board as used for this SPP and the succeeding SPP documents shall refer only to the Professional Regulatory Board of Architecture (PRBoA), duly created under R.A. No. 9266 and its IRR and under the supervision and administrative control of the Commission. 5. Architect as used for this SPP and the succeeding SPP documents shall refer only to a Registered and Licensed Architect (RLA), a natural person under Philippine law and jurisprudence with a valid certificate of registration and a valid professional identification card (representing the renewable 3-year license) for the lawful practice of the State-regulated profession of architecture. Depending on the SPP, the term Architect may also refer to Architect-of-record (Aor), Architect in charge of construction (Aicc), Consulting Architect (CA) as provided for under R.A. No. 9266. 6. Architectural Firm (AF) as used for this SPP and the succeeding SPP documents shall refer only to a juridical person under Philippine law and jurisprudence, duly registered with the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) as a sole proprietorship for individual architectural practice or registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and with the Professional _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 3 of 94 Regulation Commission (the PRC or hereafter the Commission) as a professional partnership or as an architectural corporation for group architectural practice by RLAs, subject to full compliances with Sec. 37 of R.A. No. 9266 and derivative regulations. 7. Architect and Architectural Firm (AF) may be used interchangeably for some of the succeeding SPP. 8. Professional/s as used for this SPP and the succeeding SPP documents shall refer only to Registered and Licensed Professionals (RLPs), all natural persons under Philippine law and jurisprudence with a valid certificate and a valid professional identification card (representing the renewable license) for the lawful practice of a State-regulated profession other than architecture. 9. Client, Owner and Project Proponent may be used interchangeably for this SPP and some of the succeeding SPP. 10. Contractor and General Contractor shall also mean Constructor or Builder, and may be used interchangeably for this SPP. 11. Bid and Tender shall mean the same. B. ACRONYMS ADR AF ADC Aicc Aor BPO CA CEC DoLE DTI FPCA IAPOA KPO MoP PACS PCA PRC - Alternative Dispute Resolution Architectural Firm Architectural Design Competition Architect in charge of construction Architect-of-record Business Process Outsourcing Consulting Architect Codes of Ethical Conduct Department of Labor and Employment Department of Trade and Industry Filipino Professional Consulting Architects Integrated and Accredited Professional Organization of Architects Knowledge Process Outsourcing Manual of Procedure Professional Architectural Consulting Services Professional Consulting Architect Professional Regulation Commission _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 4 of 94 PRBoA SEC RLA SPP TSP - Professional Regulatory Board of Architecture Securities and Exchange Commission Registered and Licensed Architect Standards of Professional Practice Temporary/ Special Permit C. GENERAL NOTES ON THE SELECTION OF THE ARCHITECT (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266, replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 208) 1. INTRODUCTION There are many ways by which a Client can engage the services of an Architect. The most appropriate method of selecting an Architect will depend on the type and complexity of the project. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES The scope of services will depend on the method by which the Architect is selected. 3. METHODS OF SELECTION 3.1. Direct Selection is used when undertaking a relatively small project. The Client selects his Architect on the basis of: 3.1.1. Reputation 3.1.2. Personal or business acquaintance or recommendation of a friend 3.1.3. Recommendation of the Architect’s former Client 3.1.4. Recommendation of another Architect. 3.2. Comparative Selection may be conducted by committees representing institutions, corporations or public agencies. The selection process involves: 3.2.1. Invitation. The Client issues an invitation which includes the Terms of Reference (ToR) for the project which is based on the Design Brief prepared by another Architect. The selection committee established by the Client may consist of representatives from other State-regulated _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 5 of 94 professions and/or the construction industry, as well as persons with related expertise. 3.2.2. Pre-qualification. Architects and/or PRC-registered Architectural Firms (AFs) submit information regarding their qualification and expertise. 3.2.3. Interview. The Architect explains his methodology in translating the plan/design requirements of the proposed project. 3.2.4. Verification. The selection committee may visit buildings designed by the Architects and check references such as former clients and financial institutions. 3.2.5. Evaluation & Ranking. The selection committee may adopt its own procedure in evaluating the entries and recommending the most capable firm. 3.2.6. Negotiation. The Architect explains to the Client the Scope of Services and the Architect’s Fee as prescribed under the Architect’s Guidelines. 3.3. An Architectural Design Competition (ADC) is used for civic or monumental projects. The competition may either be an idea competition, design or design build competition. Various Architects or architectural firms (AFs) submit plan/design solutions to a particular design problem and are judged on the basis of comparative excellence. 3.3.1. Advantages a. Opportunities will be open only to all PRC-registered and licensed Architects (RLAs) or PRC-registered Architectural Firms (AFs). b. The Client/ Committee will have a wider range of options. 3.3.2. Disadvantages a. Process may be expensive and time consuming b. The time and effort required may discourage qualified firms from participating. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 6 of 94 c. Some potentially unscrupulous prospective Clients will seek free services under the guise of design competition. Architects must always be constantly aware that ownership and copyright issues under Secs. 20 (4) and 33 of R.A. No. 9266 must be fully addressed under all architectural competition rules. 3.3.3. Procedure. Competitions should be conducted: a. With the assistance of the integrated and accredited professional organization of architects (IAPOA) or one of its local chapters, and b. In accordance with the Architect’s Guidelines. 3.3.4. Participants a. Sponsor or Client – a natural or juridical person; b. Competitors – Filipino/ Philippine-Registered and Licensed Architects (RLA) and IAPOA members in good standing. A foreign architect as a competitor must be registered in his/her country of origin and must secure a Temporary Special Permit (TSP) from the Commission (PRC), a work permit form the Department of Labor and Employment (DoLE) and must work in collaboration with a local/Filipino counterpart RLA who will assume the requisite professional responsibilities and civil liabilities, in the case of a design or design-build competition; c. Professional Adviser – Philippine-Registered and Licensed Architects (RLAs) who are IAPOA members in good standing; d. Jury – Composed of at least five (5) members who are known for their integrity, objectivity, impartiality and honesty. d.1 Architect – member in good standing of the IAPOA d.2 Competition Sponsor or Client. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION This will be covered by the respective type of services. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 7 of 94 STANDARDS OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON PRE-DESIGN SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 201 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 201) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1. The basic services provided by the Architect have remained relatively unchanged over the years. However, the Architect must expand his services in response to the increasing demands of his/her Clients, the evolution of new standards of regulated professional practice, the advancement of technology and the enactment of new laws. 1.2. It will be most advantageous to the Client to involve the Architect in the earliest stages of the project since the Architect, if suitably experienced, can provide the Client with objective project analysis, establishing parameters to optimize building needs vis-à-vis available resources and attendant constraints. 2. SCOPE OF PRE-DESIGN SERVICES The Pre- Design Services cover a broad line of architectural services ranging from initial problem identification to activities that would allow the Architect to initially conceptualize an array of architectural and allied solutions. The Pre-Design Services nominally include consultation, pre-feasibility studies, feasibility studies, site selection and analysis, site utilization and land-use studies, architectural research, architectural programming, space planning, space management studies, value management, design brief preparation, promotional services and other related activities. 2.1 Consultation When a Client calls upon the Architect to give oral or written advice and direction, to attend conferences, to make evaluations and appraisals regarding a contemplated project and similar activities, the Architect renders valuable inputs whether or not the Client pursues the project. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 8 of 94 2.2 Pre-Feasibility Studies These preliminary studies involve the procurement, analysis and use of secondary information gathered for the project to aid the Client in early decision-making. They represent the Architect’s initial assessment of a project’s soundness, allowing the Client to promptly explore available/ readily identifiable directions/ options. Researched/ processed/ validated secondary data are generally used for such studies e.g. electronic, print, etc. 2.3 Feasibility Studies Detailed analysis of the project based on pre-feasibility studies will determine the viability of a proposed development. The studies will set the project against present and future trends to forecast how it will perform over time. This requires primary data gathering and analysis. 2.4 Site Selection and Analysis This entails the formulation of site criteria, assistance to the Client in site evaluation as well as analysis to determine the most appropriate site/s for a proposed project or building program. 2.5 Site Utilization and Land-Use Studies The detailed analysis of the site involves the identification of a site’s development potentials through the proper utilization of land. The analysis covers the context of the site as well as that of its surrounding environment and the development controls that apply to the site and its environs. 2.6 Architectural Research Architectural research entails the conduct of primary and secondary researches and assembled facts used as basis for conclusion. 2.7 Architectural Programming This analytical problem-seeking process will lead to the statement and identification of both horizontal and vertical requirements in offering a solution. It incorporates a space program with characterizations of the envisioned spaces such as ambiance, cost range, etc. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 9 of 94 2.8 Space Planning The Architect determines the adequate size and appropriate configuration and assemblage for a proposed project in consideration of the use, allocation and interface of spaces for given activities. Space planning is done mainly through primary data gathering such as interviews, consultations, interfaces, focus group discussions (FGDs), space planning surveys, space audits, etc. and subsequent analyses i.e. spatial layouts with stacking concepts, particularly for multi-storey structures. 2.9 Space Management Studies An analysis of the space requirements of the project based on organizational structure and functional set-up pinpoints linkages and interaction of spaces. The formulation of the space program will serve as the basis for the development of the architectural plan/design. 2.10 Value Management This technique is applied in the cost management process to minimize the negative effect of simplified operations associated with many cost-reduction programs. The goal of value management is to achieve an unimpaired program at minimum cost. Thus, a plan, design or system that has been successfully value-managed will still satisfy the same performance criteria as the costlier alternatives. 2.11 Design Brief Preparation Under design brief preparation, the Architect states the project terms of reference (ToR) including the concept, objectives and other necessary requirements to bid out architectural services (whether public or private). 2.12 Promotional Services Projects may require promotional activities in order to develop and generate financial support and acceptance from governing agencies or from the general public. In such cases, the Architect can act as the agent of the Owner by producing and coordinating the additional activities necessary to complete the services. In all such activities, the Architect must maintain his professional status as the representative of the Owner. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 10 of 94 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES 3.1 After the initial meeting/ conversation/ correspondence with the Client, the Architect must submit his proposal for pre-design services, stating the following: 3.1.1 Scope of Work 3.1.2 Manner of Payment 3.1.3 Owner’s Responsibilities 3.1.4 Other Conditions of Services 3.2 The Architect can render services in any of the following ways: 3.2.1 As an individual Architect he must have special training and be knowledgeable in different fields to supplement his skills. 3.2.2 Architect’s Own Staff It is possible for Architects (as natural persons) working in a single firm to specialize in a variety of ways. Many Architects and firms (juridical persons) specialize without losing the generalist approach of the Architect or firm. 3.2.3 By Association, Consultation or Networking Another common practice is consultation between an Architect and a firm of other disciplines, under the extended terms of the OwnerArchitect Agreement. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION The Architect’s compensation is based on the Architect’s / architectural firm’s talents, skill, experience, imagination, and on the type and level of professional services provided. Compensation for Pre-Design Services may be based on one or more of the following: 4.1 Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses This cost-based method of compensation is applicable only to non-creative work such as accounting, secretarial, research, data gathering, preparation of reports and the like. This method of compensation is based on technical _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 11 of 94 hours spent and does not account for creative work since the value of creative design cannot be measured by the length of time the designer has spent on his work. The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (man hours x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier to cover overhead and profit. The multiplier ranges from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the office set-up, overhead and experience of the Architect and the complexity of the Project. Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants, out-of-town living and housing allowances of the local consultants and the like, are all to be charged to the Client. At the start of the commission, the Architect shall make known to the Client the rate of professionals and personnel who will be assigned to the Project and the multiplier that has to be applied before agreeing on this method of compensation. FORMULA Assume: A= Architect’s rate / hour C= Consultant’s rate / hour T= Rate per hour of Technical Staff, Researchers and others involved in the Project AN, CN, TN = No. of hours spent by Architect, Consultants and Technical Staff M= Multiplier to account for overhead and reasonable profit. The value may range from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the set-up of the Architect’s office and the complexity of the Project. R= Reimbursable expenses such as transportation, housing and living allowance of Consultant, transportation, per diem, housing and living allowance of local consultants and technical staff if assigned to places over 100 km. from the area of operation of the Architect. Cost of printing of extra set of drawings, reports, maps, contract documents, etc. over the five (5) copies submitted to the Client, overseas and long distance calls, technical and laboratory tests, licenses, fees, taxes and similar cost items needed by the Project. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 12 of 94 Direct cost = AN + CN + TN Fee = Direct Cost x M Total Cost of Service charged to Client = Fee + R 4.2 Professional Fee Plus Expenses This method of compensation is frequently used where there is continuing relationship involving a series of Projects. It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. An agreement on the general scope of the work is necessary in order to set an equitable fee. 4.3 Lump Sum or Fixed Fee This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paper work and time-consuming efforts. 4.4 Per Diem, Honorarium Plus Reimbursable Expenses In some cases a Client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time such as: 4.4.1 attending project-related meetings, conferences or trips; 4.4.2 conducting ocular inspection of possible project sites; and 4.4.3 conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like. For these particular activities, the Architect as agent of the Owner may be paid on a per diem and honorarium basis plus out-of-pocket expenses such as but not limited to travel, accommodations and subsistence. 4.5 Mixed Methods of Compensation The SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. Each project should be examined to determine the most appropriate and equitable method of compensation. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 13 of 94 STANDARDS OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON REGULAR DESIGN SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 202 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 202) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Applicability of this Document 1.1.1 While these implementing rules and regulations specifically refer to the “individual” professional practice of the Architect as a natural person, the same may also apply to the Architect’s “group practice” as part of a juridical entity i.e. as a DTI-registered sole proprietorship or as a SEC-registered partnership or corporation, subject to full compliances with Sec. 37 of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its implementing rules and regulations and derivative regulations including resolutions of the Board and the Commission. 1.1.2 Foreign architects offering services under this service are subject to full compliances with Sec. 38 of R.A. No. 9266 and its implementing rules and regulations (including resolutions of the Board which calls for a “local counterpart Architect” for any foreign architect) and other periodic issuances of the Board and the Commission as well as procedures/requirements of the Department of Labor and Employment and the Bureau of Immigration and Deportation governing such foreign architects. Therefore, a foreign architect practicing architecture in the Philippines for projects on Philippine soil must first secure a Temporary/ Special Permit (TSP) and a work permit from the Department of Labor and Employment (DoLE) and must work in collaboration with a local counterpart Architect who is a Registered and Licensed Architect (RLA) under Philippine law. 1.1.3 Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO) firms which have been DTI- or SEC-registered in the Philippines to provide services for overseas clients are not authorized to provide architectural services for projects located on Philippine soil unless they are PRC-registered architectural firms satisfying Sec. 37 of R.A. No. 9266 and its implementing rules and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 14 of 94 regulations (IRR) and its derivative regulations including resolutions of the Board and other periodic issuances of the Board and the Commission. 1.1.4 The Architect’s outputs described / listed under this SPP may be expanded or increased depending on the requirements of the project or the Architect’s experience, capabilities and specialization/s. 1.2 Regular Design Services of an Architect 1.2.1 In regular practice, the Architect acts as the Owner’s/ Client's/ Proponent’s Adviser and/or Representative. He translates the Owner's needs and requirements to spaces and forms in the best manner of professional service. 1.2.2 The Architect’s work starts at the inception of the project when the Owner outlines his requirements to the Architect. The work covers the various aspects of the project, from analysis and study of the needs and requirements, to the preparation of the necessary instruments of service, and finally to the supervision during project implementation. It ends only when the general contractor or builder turns over the completed project to the Owner. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 Project Definition Phase This phase involves the definition of the requirements of the project by the Owner. The Architect in turn informs the Owner of the technical requirements of the project and the concomitant professional fees. In this phase, the Architect: 1.2.1. consults with the Owner to ascertain the conceptual framework and related requirements of the project and confirms such requirements with him. 1.2.2. gathers relevant information and data leading to the definition of the requirements of the project, including the scope of the Architect’s services. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 15 of 94 1.2.3. reviews and refines the owner’s space requirements and translates them into an architectural program. 1.2.4. prepares an initial statement of probable construction cost. 2.2 Schematic Design Phase This phase consists of the preparation of schematic design studies derived from the Project Definition Phase, leading to conceptual plans. The Architect: 2.2.1 evaluates the Owner’s program, schedule, budget, project site and proposes methods of project deliveries. 2.2.2 prepares the initial line drawings representing design studies leading to a recommended solution, including a general description of the project for approval by the Owner. 2.2.3 submits to the Owner a Statement of the Probable Project Construction Cost (SPPCC) based on current cost parameters. 2.3 Design Development Phase Based on approved schematics and conceptual plans, the Architect prepares: 2.3.1 the Design Development documents consisting of plans, elevations, sections and other drawings, 2.3.2 outline specifications to fix and illustrate the size and character of the entire project as to type of materials, type of structural, electrical, mechanical, sanitary, electronic and communications systems. 2.3.3 diagrammatic layout of construction systems, and 2.3.4 an updated SPPCC for submission to the Owner. 2.4 Contract Document Phase Based on the approved Design Development Documents, the Architect: 2.4.1 prepares the complete Contract Documents consisting of detailed _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 16 of 94 designs and construction drawings, setting forth in detail the work required for the architectural, structural, electrical, plumbing/ sanitary, mechanical, electronic and communication works prepared by the Architect and the respective professionals involved. 2.4.2 prepares Technical Specifications describing type and quality of materials, finish, manner of construction and the general conditions under which the project is to be constructed. 2.4.3 submits to the Owner seven (7) sets of all construction drawings and technical specifications for purposes of obtaining a building permit. 2.4.4 updates the SPPCC based on changes in scope, requirements or market conditions. 2.4.5 assists the Owner in filing the required documents to secure approval of government authorities having jurisdiction over the design of the Project. 2.5 Bidding or Negotiation Phase 2.5.1 In this phase, the Architect: a. prepares the Bid Documents such as forms for contract letting, documents for construction, forms for invitation and instruction to bidders, forms for bidders’ proposals, general / specific conditions of contract, etc. b. assists the Owner from the early stage of establishing a list of prospective Contractors to awarding of the construction contract. 2.5.2 For competitive bids / procurements, the Architect: a. furnishes complete sets of the Bid Documents for purposes of bidding in as many sets as may be required to conduct a successful bidding. The said documents are loaned to bidders at an amount sufficient to cover direct and indirect costs attendant to the preparation, packaging, reproduction and delivery of the said documents. The Bid Documents are the intellectual property of the Architect _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 17 of 94 (Sec. 33 of R.A. No. 9266), and must be returned by all entities acquiring bid documents. A bond may be required to assure the return of the Bid Documents. The Architect retains the sole ownership and copyright to the said documents (Sec. 33 of R.A. No. 9266). As such, bidders must not reproduce nor use the documents for unauthorized purposes. The Owner also must not use the documents for any other purpose other than the project for which the Owner and Architect signed an agreement. b. helps in organizing and conducting pre-bid conferences, c. responds to questions from bidders, d. assists the Owner in obtaining proposals from Contractors, analyzes bid results and prepares abstract of bids, notice of award, notice to proceed and other construction contracts. 2.5.3 For negotiated contracts, the Architect performs similar functions as in item 2.5.2 but negotiates with one Contractor instead of many bidders. 2.6 Construction Phase In this phase, the Architect performs the following: 2.6.1 makes decisions on all claims of the Owner and Contractors on all matters relating to the execution and progress of work or the interpretation of the Contract Documents. 2.6.2 prepares change orders, gathers and turns over to the Owner written guarantees required of the Contractor and Sub-Contractors. 2.6.3 makes periodic visits to the project site to familiarize himself with the general progress and quality of work and to ascertain that the work is proceeding in accordance with the Contract Documents. The Architect shall not be required to make exhaustive or continuous 8-hour on-site supervision to check on the quality of the work involved and shall not be held responsible for the Contractor's failure to carry out the Construction work in accordance with the Contract Documents. During _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 18 of 94 such project site visits and on the basis of his observations, he shall report to the Client defects and deficiencies noted in the work of Contractors, and shall condemn work found failing to conform to the Contract Documents. 2.6.4 determines the amount owing and due to the Contractor and issues corresponding Certificates for Payment for such amounts based on his observations and the Contractor's Applications for Payment. These Certificates will constitute a certification to the Client that the work has progressed to the state indicated and that to his best knowledge, the quality of work performed by the Contractor is in accordance with the Contract Documents. The Architect shall conduct the necessary inspection to determine the date of substantial and final completion and issue the final Certificate of Payment to the Contractor. 2.6.5 Should more extensive inspection or full-time (8-hour) construction supervision be required by the Client, a separate full-time supervisor shall be hired and agreed upon by the Owner and the Architect subject to the conditions provided in the SPP Document on Full -Time Supervision. When the Architect is requested by the Owner to do the full time supervision, his services and fees shall be covered separately in conformance with the applicable and appropriate SPP Document. 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES There are two ways by which the Architect may enter into contract with the Owner as the Lead Professional working with other professionals in the engineering and allied professions: 3.1 with a single contract between the Architect and Owner, and sub-consultancy contracts between the Architect and the other professionals working with the Architect. 3.2 with the Architect and the engineering and allied professionals executing separate contracts with the Owner. In both cases, the professional responsibilities and civil liabilities of each Stateregulated professional remains separate. The Architect does not assume any of the responsibilities and liabilities of the other professionals (RLPs). _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 19 of 94 4. PROJECT CLASSIFICATION Professional architectural work is classified in accordance with the degree of complexity and the creative skill required to meet the requirements of the Client within technical, functional, economic and aesthetic constraints. Based on these groupings, the corresponding scale of charges shall be prescribed in the Architect’s Guidelines to determine the fair remuneration to the Architect. 4.1 Group 1 Buildings of the simplest utilization and character which shall include but not be limited to the following: Armories Parking Structures Bakeries Printing Plants Habitable Agricultural Buildings Public Markets Freight Facilities Service Garages Hangars Simple Loft-Type Buildings Industrial Buildings Warehouses Manufacturing/Industrial Plants Packaging and Processing Plants Other similar utilization type buildings 4.2 Group 2 Buildings of moderate complexity of plan / design which shall include but not be limited to the following: Art Galleries Banks, Exchange and other Buildings Financial Institutions Bowlodromes Call Centers Churches and Religious Facilities City/Town Halls & Civic Centers College Buildings Convents, Monasteries & Seminaries Correctional & Detention Facilities Court Houses/Halls of Justice Nursing Homes Office Buildings/ Office Condominium Park, Playground and Open-Air Recreational Facilities Residential Condominiums Police Stations Postal Facilities Private Clubs Publishing Plants Race Tracks Restaurants / Fastfood Stores Retail / Wholesale Stores Schools _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 20 of 94 Dormitories Exhibition Halls & Display Structures Fire Stations Laundries & Cleaning Facilities Libraries Malls/Mall Complexes Motels & Apartels Multi-storey Apartments Showrooms/Service Centers 4.3 Shopping Centers Specialty Shops Supermarkets/ Hyper-marts Serviced Apartments Welfare Buildings Mixed Use Buildings Other buildings of similar nature or use Group 3 Buildings of exceptional character and complexity of plan / design which shall include but not be limited to the following: Aquariums Laboratories/ Testing Facilities Nuclear Facilities Marinas and Resort Complexes Auditoriums Medical Arts Offices & Clinics Airports/Wet & Dry Ports & Terminals Mental Institutions Breweries Mortuaries Cold Storage Facilities Observatories Telecommunication Buildings Public Health Centers Convention Facilities Research Facilities Gymnasiums Stadia Hospitals & Medical Buildings Theaters & Similar Facilities Hotels Veterinary Hospitals Transportation Facilities & Systems Other buildings of similar nature or use 4.4 Group 4 Residences (single-detached, single-attached or duplex; row-houses or shophouses), small apartment houses and townhouses 4.5 Group 5 Monumental buildings and other facilities Exposition & Fair Buildings Mausoleums, Memorials, & Monuments Specialized decorative buildings Museums Buildings of similar nature or use _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 21 of 94 4.6 Group 6 Projects where the plan / design and related Contract Documents are re-used for the repetitive construction of similar buildings without amending the drawing and the specifications 4.7 Group 7 Housing Project involving the construction of several residential units on a single site with the use of one (1) set of plans / design, specifications and related documents 4.8 Group 8 Projects involving extensive detail such as designs for built-in components or elements, built-in equipment, special fittings, screens, counters, architectural interiors (AI), and development planning and/or design 4.9 Group 9 Alterations, renovations, rehabilitations, retrofit and expansion / additions to existing buildings belonging to Groups 1 to 5 4.10 Group 10 The Architect is engaged to render opinion or give advice, clarifications or explanation on technical matters pertaining to architectural works. 5. METHOD OF COMPENSATION The Architect’s compensation is based on the Architect’s / architectural firm’s talents, skill, experience, imagination, and on the type and level of professional services provided. Compensation for Regular Design Services may be based on one or more of the following: 5.1 Percentage (%) of Project Construction Cost (PCC) The Architect’s Fee based on the PPC shall be detailed in the Architect’s Guidelines. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 22 of 94 5.2 Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses This cost-based method of compensation is applicable only to non-creative work such as accounting, secretarial, research, data gathering, preparation of reports and the like. This method of compensation is based on technical hours spent and does not account for creative work since the value of creative design cannot be measured by the length of time the designer has spent on his work. The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (man hours x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier to cover overhead and profit. The multiplier ranges from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the office set-up, overhead and experience of the Architect and the complexity of the Project. Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants, out-of-town living and housing allowances of the local consultants and the like, are all to be charged to the Client. At the start of the commission, the Architect shall make known to the Client the rate of professionals and personnel who will be assigned to the Project and the multiplier that has to be applied before agreeing on this method of compensation. FORMULA Assume: A= Architect’s rate / hour C= Consultant’s rate / hour T= Rate per hour of Technical Staff, Researchers and others involved in the Project AN, CN, TN = No. of hours spent by Architect, Consultants and Technical Staff M= Multiplier to account for overhead and reasonable profit. The value may range from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the set-up of the Architect’s office and the complexity of the Project. R= Reimbursable expenses such as transportation, housing and living allowance of Consultant, transportation, per diem, housing and living allowance of local consultants and technical staff if assigned to places over 100km. from area of operation of the Architect. Cost of printing of extra set of drawings, reports, maps, contract documents, etc. over the seven (7) copies submitted to the Client, overseas and long distance _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 23 of 94 calls, technical and laboratory tests, licenses, fees, taxes and similar cost items needed by the Project. Direct cost = AN + CN + TN Fee = Direct Cost x M Total Cost of Service charged to Client = Fee + R 5.3 Professional Fee Plus Expenses This method of compensation is frequently used where there is continuing relationship involving a series of Projects. It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. An agreement on the general scope of the work is necessary in order to set an equitable fee. 5.4 Lump Sum or Fixed Fee This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paper work and time-consuming efforts. 5.5 Per Diem, Honorarium Plus Reimbursable Expenses In some cases a Client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time such as: 5.5.1 attending project-related meetings, conferences or trips; 5.5.2 conducting ocular inspection of possible project sites; and 5.5.3 conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like. For these particular activities, the Architect as agent of the Owner may be paid on a per diem and honorarium basis plus out-of-pocket expenses such as but not limited to travel, accommodations and subsistence. 5.6 Mixed Methods of Compensation The SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. Each project should be examined to determine the most appropriate method of compensation. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 24 of 94 6. OWNER’S RESPONSIBILITIES 6.1 Provide full information as to his requirements for the Project. 6.2 When necessary, designate a representative authorized to act on his behalf. 6.3 Promptly examine and render decisions pertaining to documents submitted by the Architect to avoid unreasonable delay in the progress of the Architect’s work. The Owner should issue orders to the General Contractor only through the Architect. 6.4 Furnish or direct the Architect to obtain at his expense, a certified survey of the site, giving, as may be required, topographical and/or relocation surveys covering grades and lines of streets, alleys, easements, encroachments and related information, boundaries, with dimensions and complete data pertaining to existing buildings, structures, trees, plants, water bodies, wells, excavations / pits, etc. and other improvements and full information as to the available utility / service lines both public and private; zoning compliances, clearances, deed/s of restrictions, encumbrances and annotations to titles, association guidelines and standards, and soil investigations / tests, borings and test pits necessary for determining soil and sub-soil conditions. 6.5 Promptly pay for architectural and all other engineering and allied services required for the project. 6.6 Pay for the design and consulting services on acoustic, communication, electronic, and other specialty systems which may be required for the project. 6.7 Arrange and pay for such legal, auditing, insurance, counseling and other services as may be required for the project. 6.8 Pay for all reimbursable expenses incurred in the project as called for in Section 7: “Other Conditions on Services” and all taxes including VAT (but not including income tax) that the government may impose on the Architect as a result of the services rendered by the Architect on the project, whether the services were performed as a natural person i.e. an individual practitioner or as a juridical entity i.e. as a sole proprietorship, partnership or corporation. 6.9 If the Owner observes or otherwise becomes aware of anything that may impair the successful implementation of the project, he shall give prompt written notice to the Architect. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 25 of 94 7. OTHER CONDITIONS ON SERVICES 7.1 Conditions for the Architect’s Fee The Architect’s Fee is based on the Project Construction Cost. Where the Architect has to render additional services, additional compensation shall be required. 7.2 Other Services Other services that may be needed in order to complete the project such as services of acoustic and illumination engineers / specialists, mural painters, sculptors, and other service providers are to be recommended by the Architect for the Owner’s approval. Costs for these services are to be paid for separately by the Owner and shall be subject to a coordination fee payable to the Architect. 7.3 Scale Models, 3D Models and Walk-Thru Presentations Should a scale model, 3D models and/or walk-thru presentation of the architect’s design be necessary, they are to be recommended by the Architect for the Owner’s approval. Costs for these services are to be paid for separately by the Owner and shall be subject to a coordination fee payable to the Architect. 7.4 Per Diem and Traveling Expenses A per diem plus traveling and living expenses shall be chargeable to the Owner whenever the Architect or his duly authorized representative is required to perform services at a locality beyond 50.0 kilometers (air, straight line or radial distance) from his established office as it appears in the Architect’s letterhead. 7.5 Extra Sets of Contract Documents The Owner shall pay the Architect for additional sets of Contract Documents. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 26 of 94 7.6 Change/s Ordered by the Owner If the Architect renders additional professional services due to changes ordered by the Owner after approval of the Architect’s outputs, the Owner shall pay the Architect for extra time, resources/ drafting, or other office expenses. 7.7 Work Suspended or Abandoned If the work of the Architect is abandoned or suspended in whole or in part, the Owner shall pay the Architect for the services rendered corresponding to the amount due at the stage of suspension or abandonment of the work. The primary service of the Architect is the preparation of architectural plans/designs, specifications and other building construction documents. These are sets of detailed instructions that shall serve as the basis for the General Contractor to implement the project. Once the Architect has prepared all these documents, the Architect has completed the Detailed Design and Contract Documents Phase of his services, which is equivalent to Ninety percent (90%) of his work. When the Owner therefore fails to implement the plans and documents for construction as prepared by the Architect, the Architect is entitled to receive as compensation the sum corresponding to ninety percent (90%) of the Architect’s fee. 7.8 Different Periods of Construction If portions of the building/s are erected at different periods of time, thus increasing the construction period and Architect’s burden of services, charges pertaining to services rendered during the Construction Phase shall be adjusted proportionately. When the suspension of construction exceeds a period of six (6) months, the fee for the remaining works shall be doubled. 7.9 Services of Specialist Consultants If the Owner requires the services of specialist consultants, they shall be engaged with the consent of the Architect. The cost of their services shall be paid for separately by the Owner and shall not be deducted from the Architect’s fee. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 27 of 94 7.10 Separate Services Should the Owner require the Architect to design movable or fixed pieces of cabinets and other architectural interior (AI) elements, site development plan (SDP) components, urban design elements, and other items of similar nature, the Owner shall pay the Architect in addition to the Architect’s fee. The compensation shall be based on the Project Construction Cost as provided for under SPP Document 203. 7.11 Fulltime Construction Supervision Upon recommendation of the Architect and with the approval of the Owner, full-time construction supervisors as will be deemed necessary shall be engaged and paid by the Owner. If no Project / Construction Manager is present, the full-time construction supervisor shall be under the technical control and supervision of the Architect and shall make periodic reports to the Owner and to the Architect regarding the progress and quality of the work done. 7.12 Estimates Any SPPCC or any Cost Estimate submitted by the Architect can attain only a certain degree of accuracy. As the Architect has no control over the cost of labor and materials, or the many factors that go into competitive bidding, he does not assume any professional responsibility for such cost estimates, unless glaring errors or discrepancies are clearly evident. 7.13 Government Taxes and Services The Architect’s Fee is a net amount. Any tax (exclusive of income tax) that the national and/or local government/s may impose on the Architect as a consequence of the services performed for the project shall be paid by the Owner. 7.14 Ownership of Documents All designs, drawings, models, specifications and other contract documents and copies thereof, prepared, duly signed, stamped and sealed and furnished as instruments of service, are the intellectual property and documents of the Architect, whether the work for which they were made is executed or not, and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 28 of 94 are not to be reproduced or used on other work except with a written agreement with the Architect (Sec. 33 of R.A. No. 9266). 7.15 Cost Records During the progress of work, the Owner shall furnish the Architect a copy of the records of expenses being incurred on the construction. Upon completion of the project, the Owner shall furnish the Architect a copy of the summary of all cost of labor, services, materials, equipment, fixtures and all items used at and for the completion of the construction. 7.16 Design and Placement of Signs All signboards of the General Contractor, sub-contractors, jobbers and dealers that shall be placed at the project site during the progress of construction shall be approved by the Architect as to size, design and contents. After the completion of the project, the Owner or his building lessee shall consult the Architect for the design, size of all signboards, letterings, directories and display boards that will be placed on the exterior or public areas attached to the building project in order to safeguard the Owner’s interest. Nothing should be installed inside or outside of the building that would compromise its safety and aesthetics. 7.17 Project Construction Cost (PCC) Project Construction Cost (PCC) as herein referred to, means the cost of the completed building to the Owner, including the structure, plumbing/sanitary and electrical fixtures, mechanical equipment, elevators, escalators, airconditioning system, fire protection system, alarm and clock system, communications and electronic system, elements attached to the building and all items indicated in the plans, designs, drawings and specifications prepared by the Architect and his consultants. The construction cost of other items planned and designed by the Architect, such as architectural interiors (AI) and site development plan elements and other items of similar nature, additionally planned / designed by the Architect are also part of the PCC. The cost of materials used and the labor for their installation are part of the PCC. If these items are furnished by the Owner below its market cost, the cost of the material and labor shall nonetheless be computed on the basis of the current (and fair market value) costs. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 29 of 94 The PCC does not include any of the fees for the Architect, the Engineer, the Specialist Consultants or the salaries of the construction inspectors. 7.18 Project Development Cost Project Development Cost shall include cost of the construction as well as all professional fees, permits, clearances and utilities and cost of acquiring the project site / lot, cost of money, etc. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 30 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON SPECIALIZED ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 203 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 203) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Time and technology have evolved to a level where specialized architectural services are needed to complete, complement or supplement the necessary work for the totality of a project. 1.2 Apart from the legal definition/s supplied under R.A. No. 9266, Architecture may also be defined as the blending of aesthetics, functions, space, materials and its environment resulting from the application of various technologies and skills in different fields. 1.3 Specialized Architectural Services deals with specific expertise for further enhancement of the architectural interior and exterior components of a project. 1.4 The Architect’s responsibility to man and society is to make sure that both the building and its physical environment enhance the lives of people by strictly adhering to national and international standards with regard to public health, safety and welfare. 1.5 The architectural plan and design of the building properly falls under the Architect’s Regular Design Services (SPP Document No. 202). 1.6 Design services needed within and outside the building which fall under Specialized Architectural Services as listed under the pertinent provisions of R.A. No. 9266 and its 2004 IRR, include but are not limited to the following: 1.6.1 Architectural Interiors (AI) 1.6.2 Acoustic Design 1.6.3 Architectural Lighting Layout and Design 1.6.4 Site Development Planning (SDP) _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 31 of 94 1.6.5 Site and Physical Planning Services (including Master Development Planning, Subdivision Planning and Urban Design) 1.6.6 Comprehensive Development Planning 1.6.7 Historic and Cultural Heritage Conservation and Planning 1.6.8 Security Evaluation and Planning 1.6.9 Building Systems Design 1.6.10 Facilities Maintenance Support 1.6.11 Building Testing and Commissioning 1.6.12 Building Environmental Certification 1.6.13 Forensic Architecture 1.6.14 Building Appraisal 1.6.15 Structural Conceptualization 1.6.16 Preliminary Services 1.6.17 Contract Documentation and Review 1.6.18 Post-Design Services (including Construction Management Services) 1.6.19 Dispute Avoidance and Resolution 1.6.20 Architectural Research Methods 1.6.21 Special Building/ Facility Planning and Design 1.6.22 Building Components 1.6.23 Management of Architectural Practices _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 32 of 94 1.7 The term Consulting Architect (CA) shall refer only to a RLA who may also be a separately Registered and Licensed Professional (RLP) i.e. a natural person under Philippine law and jurisprudence with a valid certificate of registration and a valid professional identification card (representing the renewable license) for the lawful practice of one or more State-regulated profession other than architecture. 1.8 For this SPP, the term Architect refers to the Consulting Architect (CA) who may be the holder of a valid Specialist Certificate that may be issued by the Board and/or the Commission, upon due qualification or accreditation by the IAPoA. 203.1 ARCHITECTURAL INTERIOR (AI) SERVICES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Architectural Interiors (AI), specifically mentioned under Secs. 3 (4) (g) and 14 (3) of R.A. No. 9266, involves the detailed planning and design of the indoor / enclosed areas of any proposed building / structure, including retrofit, renovation, rehabilitation or expansion work which shall cover all architectural and utility aspects, including the architectural lay-outing of all building engineering systems found therein. 1.2 Depending on the complexity of the Project, the Architect undertaking professional AI services must be sufficiently experienced in the planning, design and detailing of AI elements. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 In the design of a building, the Architect works on a development concept. To realize this, the Architect develops the design by determining the size and interrelationship of interior spaces, laying out the furniture, movables, equipment, built-ins and fixtures to support the required activities, thus making both the exterior and interior spaces contribute to the total concept. 2.2 The Architect plans and designs the architectural interiors (AI) of buildings such that they contribute to the physical, visual, intellectual and emotional comforts of the intended end-users. 2.3 As such a specialist, the Architect: _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 33 of 94 2.3.1 Prescribes space plans, stacking diagrams/ sections and computations of areas for the different activities and spaces to be integrated in a building Project. 2.3.2 Lays out and prescribes furniture/ built-ins/ equipment for the project and prepares specifications of AI components including all floor / wall / ceiling finishes, doors and partition systems, hardware, modular or ready-assembled furniture pieces/ systems, equipment, furnishings, built-ins, fixtures, signages and graphic devices, etc. 2.3.3 Assists the Client in conducting bids or negotiations with General Contractors, sub-contractors and suppliers of building materials, furniture, equipment, fixtures, etc. 2.3.4 Checks and approves samples of materials and shop drawings of AI components. 2.3.5 Reviews and approves billings of AI components. 2.3.6 Conducts final inspection and approves installed AI components and related items. 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for AI services. 3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for AI services only. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 4.1 For projects involving extensive detailing of AI components such as custom floor, wall, ceiling construction and finishes, cabinet design, built-in components, equipment and special fittings, the Architect’s Fee shall be a percentage of the cost of the AI work. This excludes the fee of any Engineering and / or Specialist Consultants (SCs) working with the Architect. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 34 of 94 4.2 Should the Client separately hire the services of Specialist Consultants (SCs), their professional fee shall be for the account of the Client. 4.3 For this Specialized Service, the payment of the Architect’s services shall be as stated in the Architect’s Guidelines. 203.2 ACOUSTIC DESIGN SERVICES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Acoustic design services involves the detailed planning and design to control sound transmission for compatibility with the architectural design concept. 1.2 Throughout architectural history, one of the limiting criteria in building design has been the need to control sound in an enclosed space. The continuing evolution of products and techniques in sound management and control has provided a wider flexibility in the design of the interior environment. This allows the Architect to build an environment that answers the acoustical demands of varied activities within an enclosed space. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 The Architect is the prime professional commissioned by the Owner/Client to plan and design the building/structure and all its utilities and to coordinate the works of all allied design professionals involved in the project including all inter-disciplinary and specialized works. He shall make certain that these inputs comply with the requirements of the project and are compatible with the architectural design concept. 2.2 As a specialist for acoustic design, the Architect: 2.2.1 Prepares the drawings and specifications for acoustic design and treatment, sound control and reinforcement, sound absorption, reflectance, insulation, etc. 2.2.2 Assists the Owner/ Client in bidding out the work or in negotiating with a specialty sub-contractor 2.2.3 Checks and approves samples of materials and equipment _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 35 of 94 2.2.4 Conducts final inspection of work and equipment 2.2.5 Assists Owner/ Client in evaluating the amount due the sub-contractor. 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for acoustic design services. 3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for acoustic design services only. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 4.1 The Architect’s Fee for acoustic design services shall depend on the complexity of the works to be undertaken. 4.2 Should the Owner/Client hire separately the services of other Specialist Consultants (SCs), their fee shall be for the account of the Owner/ Client and shall be paid directly to the SC. 4.3 For this Specialized Service, the payment of the Architect’s services shall be as stated in the Architect’s Guidelines. 203.3 ARCHITECTURAL LIGHTING LAYOUT AND DESIGN 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Architectural Lighting Layout and Design Services involves the detailed planning and design of light transmission, timing and control for compatibility with the architectural design concept. 1.2 One of the limiting criteria in building design has been the need to control light in an enclosed or defined space. The continuing evolution of products and techniques in lighting has provided a wider flexibility in the design of the building’s interior and exterior environments. This allows the Architect to build an environment that answers the lighting demands of varied activities within and outside a building. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 36 of 94 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 2.2 The Architect is the prime professional commissioned by the Owner/Client to plan and design the building/ structure and all its utilities and to coordinate the works of all allied design professionals involved in the project including all inter-disciplinary and specialized works. He shall make certain that these inputs comply with the requirements of the project and are compatible with the architectural design concept. As a specialist for lighting layout and design, the Architect : 2.2.1 Prepares the drawings and specifications for lighting design, illumination, fixture placement, efficiency, energy considerations, etc. 2.2.2 Assists the Owner/ Client in bidding out the work or in negotiating with a specialty sub-contractor 2.2.3 Checks and approve samples of materials and fixtures 2.2.4 Conducts final inspection of work and fixtures 2.2.5 Assists Owner/ Client to evaluate the amount due the sub-contractor 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for architectural lighting and layout design services. 3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for architectural lighting and layout design services only. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 4.1 The Architect’s Fee for lighting layout and design services shall depend on the complexity of the works to be undertaken. 4.2 Should the Owner/Client hire separately the services of Specialist Consultants, the fee shall be for the account of the Owner/Client and shall be paid directly to the Consultant. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 37 of 94 4.3 “Cost of the Work” means the total cost of all fixtures and accessories, which were either designed, specified or procured by the Specialist Architect and/or his Specialist Consultants (SCs) for the Owner/ Client, and that were used or installed in the project. 4.4 For this Special Service, the payment of the Architect’s services shall be as stated in the Architect’s Guidelines 203.4 SITE DEVELOPMENT PLANNING (SDP) SERVICES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 The space planning, architectural lay-outing and utilization of spaces within and surrounding a specific building/ structure in relation with the existing natural and/or built environments have to be a well-coordinated effort so that both the building/ structure and the host environment shall act as one. Arising from his concept of the total environment, the Architect is not merely concerned with the building/structure he creates but with the grounds and surrounding space as well. He studies the existing environment in relation to the building/structure and consequently lays out the areas/ grounds immediately surrounding the building/ structure. 1.2 Ordinarily, the landscaping layout of small building projects could be done by the Architect as part of the site development planning (SDP) effort. However, if the project is large in scale, the Architect must hire other State-regulated professionals (RLPs) as qualified Specialist Consultants (SCs). 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 The Architect, upon designing a building/ structure, complements this with the design of the surroundings that will make the space fit for a specific mood and for the required activities. He lays out the open spaces in and around the structure such that they contribute to the totality of the project. 2.2 In order to achieve a well-balanced design of the environment enveloping a specific building/structure, the Specialist Architect: 2.2.1 Conceptualizes the entire site development plan (SDP) including the generic scope of civil works and the general scope of softscape and hardscape requirements. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 38 of 94 2.2.2 Conceptualizes the specifications for the needed civil works and utility lines. 2.2.3 Assists the Owner/Client in bidding out the work or negotiating with landscape, waterscape, rock formation contractors, etc., but mainly when no SC is available. 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for site development planning services. 3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for site development services only. 4. MANNER OF COMPENSATION 4.1 The Architect’s Fee for site development planning (SDP) services shall depend on the estimated cost of the civil works and landscaping works i.e. hardscape and softscape, depending on the magnitude and complexity of the work required by the project. If the Architect is also certified and licensed as a separate RLP e.g. a Landscape Architect, and is suitably experienced, the Architect’s fee shall increase correspondingly, depending on the magnitude and complexity of the work required by the project. 4.2 Should the Owner/ Client separately engage the services of a Landscape Architect, the fee of the said Specialist Consultant shall be for the account of the Owner/Client and paid directly to the SC. 4.3 For this Specialized Service, the payment of the Architect’s services shall be as stated in the Architect’s Guidelines. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 39 of 94 203.5 SITE AND PHYSICAL PLANNING (INCLUDING MASTER DEVELOPMENT PLANNING, SUBDIVISION PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN) SERVICES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Physical planning refers to the orderly arrangement within a piece of land or property on which vertical structures such as buildings, monuments and the like, as well as horizontal developments such as rights-of-way (ROWs), open spaces and activity spaces are to be proposed. 1.2 Planning, as we know it today, started with physical planning, with Architects performing the lead role. The great cities of the world have taken shape mainly through the activities of visionary Architects who actively engaged in physical planning. 1.3 The Architect is concerned not merely with a building/structure but with its immediate surroundings as well. In planning for a building, he studies its interrelationship with other structures, the surrounding environment, and their effect and impact on the neighboring areas. 1.4 If the Architect is commissioned to do physical plans for specific site, he has to go beyond the study of human behavior and activities and must undertake an in-depth study of the host site’s economic systems, its laws and regulations, tax structure, infrastructure, utilities, and all other components that will have a bearing on the project. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 All ideas and concepts have to be translated into physical plans before they can be implemented. It is the Specialist Architect who provides a multidimensional point-of-view to a 2-dimensional physical plan. By virtue of the Architect’s training and experience in coordinating the works of a multidisciplinary team, the Architect becomes the logical Prime Professional responsible for directing team efforts to deal with the required physical planning work. 2.2 Physical planning is concerned with the general quality of the settings for people and their activities, buildings and other natural and man-made phenomenon. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 40 of 94 2.3 The Architect undertakes the site planning of a project that requires a composite arrangement of several buildings/ structures and their requisite amenities, facilities, services and utilities within a natural or built setting. 2.4 Should other services be required by the project, such as environmental studies, feasibility studies, market analysis, access/movement systems, impact analysis and others, said services should be performed by dulyqualified professionals with the Architect acting as the Lead Professional of the physical planning team. 2.5 Depending on the complexity of the project, the Architect may hire additional Specialist Consultants (SCs) whose expert advice may be needed to validate certain features of the physical plan. The fee of any additional SC needed in the project must be paid separately by the Owner/Client. 2.6 When the Architect is commissioned to do physical planning for building sites such as Industrial Estates, Commercial, Religious, Institutional and Government/Civic Centers, Sports Complexes, Tourist Centers/ Tourism Estates/ Resorts, Amusement Parks, Educational Facilities, Residential and Housing Subdivisions and the like, the Architect: 2.6.1 Confers with the Owner/ Client on project requirements, secures sufficient primary and secondary data to generate reliable projections and analyses which are to be used as basis for the preparation of physical plans/designs. 2.6.2 Examines laws, ordinances, rules and regulations affecting the project i.e. code searches, and considers the best industry practices applicable. 2.6.3 Prepares framework and conceptual master development plans (FRDPs and CMDPs) and report/s from relevant information gathered by other disciplines. 2.6.4 Prepares Preliminary up to Detailed Master Development Plans (PMDPs/ DMDPs) showing the physical layout/distribution of areas, road network/s, vehicular and pedestrian movement/ access systems, legal easements, basic utility layouts/ corridors, landscape layouts, lot pad elevations, lot primacy matrices, deed of restrictions (DoR), development standards and guidelines (DSG), lot counts and typology, land use tabulations, building footprints, roof-prints, basement level- _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 41 of 94 prints, view corridors, building cast shadow projections and/or reflected light/heat projections from buildings, etc., and presents the same to the Owner/Client, the Government and at public consultations as needed. 2.6.5 Prepares the SPPCC for the total physical development. 2.6.6 Undertakes modifications, revisions and changes as may be required by the Owner/ Client and the project within the engagement period. 2.6.7 Prepares the finalized plans, reports and specifications needed for approval by Owner/ Client or proper government agencies concerned. 2.6.8 Prepares the phasing of the construction with the concurrence of the Owner/Client. 2.6.9 Prepares Project Cost Estimates (PCE) based on current cost parameters. 1. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 1.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for site and physical planning services. 1.2 Working as Consulting Architect for site and physical planning services only. 2. MANNER OF COMPENSATION The fee structure for Site and Physical Planning Services by the Architect shall be as stated in the Architect’s Guidelines. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 42 of 94 203.6 COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT PLANNING (CDP) SERVICES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) Services are based on the concept of expanded physical planning services to include other activities necessary for the proper handling of the numerous components considered in the formulation, implementation and realization of a Master Development Plan (MDP). Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) covers the range of all services from primary data gathering through the formulation of the MDP and the parallel preparation of the environmental impact assessment/ statement (EIA/S). 1.2 While the planning team is multi-disciplinary, the CDP Services may place heavy emphasis on the non-physical/ non-engineering components of the development plan i.e. financial, economic/market demand/forecast, administrative-political-institutional-legal, socio-cultural, environmental, and the like. In contrast, MDP Services puts a premium on the physical planning and engineering components of the development plan, which are the direct or sequential physical translations of the inputs from the initial stages of the CDP effort. 1.3 If suitably trained and experienced, the Architect’s ability to synthesize and organize into a whole, the various information relating to the user’s needs, perception and expectations, site and climatic conditions, construction technology, materials, cost and other information, qualifies him to take the lead role in an undertaking that cuts across various disciplines. 1.4 The Consulting Architect is concerned with the management and use of land as well as the conservation, preservation and upgrading of the human environment. Since the Architect, particularly if a separate RLP i.e. Environmental Planner (EnP) with suitable training and experience in physical and land use planning, has the social commitment and technical experience as coordinator of several disciplines, he is qualified to lead the multidisciplinary team in offering Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) Services. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 43 of 94 1. SCOPE OF SERVICES 1.1 If the Architect (an RLA) is separately qualified and suitably experienced as an Environmental Planner, the range of all services offered by the Architect from data base gathering, to the preparation of environmental impact assessments/statements (EIA/S), up to the formulation of the Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP), may include the following components: 1.1.1 Physical Component - land use and the changes which occur within the physical environment (within the space where such activities take place), represented mainly by the MDP. 1.1.2 Economic Component - the nation’s assets and its management. 1.1.3 Socio-Cultural Component - the people, their living conditions and the seeking of ways to ameliorate it. 1.1.4 Transport Component - road and transit networks, land-sea-air linkages, the movement of people and goods from one place to another. 1.1.5 Legal and Administrative Component - the relationship of adopted development proposals and policies to existing laws. 1.2 Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) calls for the detailed study of physical, social, economic and administrative components and as such requires the expertise and knowledge of Specialist Consultants (SCs). 1.3 When the Consulting Architect is commissioned to do a Comprehensive Development Planning effort, he performs the following: 1.3.1 Identifies existing land use, resources, social behavior and interaction; 1.3.2 Undertakes environmental analysis, demographic analysis and feasibility studies; 1.3.3 Examines existing laws, ordinances, political/ social constraints; 1.3.4 Prepares the conceptual development plans, policies, implementing strategies to arrive at the desired comprehensive and/or master planning solution/s. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 44 of 94 2. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 2.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for comprehensive development planning services. 2.2 Working as Consulting Architect for comprehensive development planning services only. 3. MANNER OF COMPENSATION Compensation for the foregoing specialized architectural service shall be through man-months i.e. 22 man-days multiplied by 8 man-hours, and multiplied by a factor to cover other direct and indirect costs e.g. overhead, etc. or as prescribed by the Architect’s Guidelines. 203.7 HISTORIC AND HERITAGE CONSERVATION AND PLANNING The suitably trained and experienced Consulting Architect in this area of architectural practice provides research, assessment, recording, management, interpretation and conservation of historical heritage. 203.8 SECURITY EVALUATION AND PLANNING The Consulting Architect in this area of practice arranges and formulates methods of rating and ascertaining the value of structures or facilities which must be fully secured, kept safe, protected, assured, guaranteed and provided sufficient safeguards for the conduct of any work or activity. 203.9 BUILDING SYSTEMS DESIGN The Architect in this area of practice engages in methods of producing building components in a highly engineered, efficient and cost-effective manner, particularly for residential and commercial applications. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 45 of 94 203.10 FACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPPORT The Consulting Architect in this area of practice provides the Owner/Client with means and measures to ensure the proper function and maintenance of the building/structure and site after final inspection. 203.11 BUILDING TESTING AND COMMISSIONING The Architect in this area of practice recommends the systematic process of ensuring that a building/structure’s array of systems is planned, designed, installed and tested to perform according to the design intent and the building’s operational needs. If the building materials, equipment and systems are not installed properly or are not operating as intended, the effectiveness, efficiency, productivity and other benefits of high performance plans/designs will not be achieved. 203.12 BUILDING ENVIRONMENT CERTIFICATION A building environment rating system is needed to evaluate the environmental performance of a building and to encourage market migration towards sustainable design. The rating system must be: credit-based, allowing projects to earn points for environment-friendly use of the building / structure and actions taken during planning, design, construction and occupancy. flexible, such that projects need not meet identical requirements to qualify. consensus-based and market-driven, in order to accelerate the development and implementation of green building practices. The Consulting Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Green Architecture and Environmental and/or Sustainable Design and sufficient knowledge of the governing environmental laws and environmental investigation processes and procedures under international protocols such as the Philippine Solid Waste, Clean Air and Clean Water Acts, DENR administrative issuances and the like. 203.13 FORENSIC ARCHITECTURE The Architect in this area of practice undertakes a scientific study on the built environment’s well-being, which allows the Architect to focus on the ways in which the building/structure can best maintain itself and prolong its life in a cost-efficient _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 46 of 94 manner, and finally provide recommendations to the Owner/ Client. The forensic study may include: determination as to the causes of building, building component and/or building material deterioration the causes of observed building deficiencies e.g., non-compliance with planning and building laws, deviations from original use or function of spaces research on possible faulty activities and operations during the project implementation phase determination of faulty plan/ design and/or construction methodology. 203.14 BUILDING APPRAISAL Appraisal is defined as an act or process of estimating value. The Consulting Architect in this area of practice places value on the building/ structure condition and defects, and on its repair and maintenance, including the required improvements. 203.15 STRUCTURAL CONCEPTUALIZATION The Architect in this area of practice conceives, chooses and develops the type, disposition, arrangement and proportioning of the structural elements of an architectural work, giving due considerations to safety, cost-effectiveness, functionality and aesthetics. 203.16 PRELIMINARY SERVICES The Consulting Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Site Analysis, Space Planning and Management, Architectural Programming, and the other services under SPP Document 201. 203.17 CONTRACT DOCUMENTATION AND REVIEW SERVICES The Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Specification Writing, Estimation and Quantity Survey, Architectural Production, Architectural Software, Architectural Support Services and Contract Document Review. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 47 of 94 203.18 POST-DESIGN SERVICES (INCLUDING CONSTRUCTION SERVICES) The Consulting Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Pre-Construction, Construction, Post-Construction and the other services under SPP Documents 204, 206 and 207. Included under this specialized practice is the preparation of the Fire Safety and Life Assessment Report (FALAR) required by R.A. No. 9514, the 2008 Fire Code of the Philippines and its 2009 IRR. 203.19 DISPUTE AVOIDANCE AND RESOLUTION The Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of the various modes of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) prescribed under R.A. No. 9285, the ADR Act of 2004 and its IRR i.e. Construction Arbitration, Mediation and Conciliation, Negotiation and of Contract Administration, Quality Surveys, Appraisals and Adjustments and Expert Testimony. An Architect specializing in ADR must preferably be State-accredited. 203.20 ARCHITECTURAL RESEARCH METHODS The Consulting Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Research Methods, Philippine Architecture and its History, Architectural Materials and Finishes, Building Types and Standards, Architectural Design Trends, Architectural Writing and Architectural Photography. 203.21 SPECIAL BUILDING/ FACILITY PLANNING AND DESIGN The Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of the Planning and Design Processes required for Housing Developments, Recreational and Tourism Estates, Health Care and Hospitality Facilities, Transportation and Telecommunications Facilities, Production and Extractive Facilities, Utility-related Developments, Secure Facilities, Business and Industrial Parks, Economic Zones and Community Architecture and the like. 203.22 BUILDING COMPONENTS The Consulting Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of Building Materials and Finishes, Construction Methodologies, _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 48 of 94 Building Envelopes including cladding and roofing systems, Fenestrations and Architectural Hardware, Fixtures and Fittings. Architectural 203.23 MANAGEMENT OF ARCHITECTURAL PRACTICES The Architect in this area of practice must have much more than the basic knowledge of the Types of Architectural Office Operations, Architectural Office Management, Accounting / Finance / Taxation / Audit, Labor Code, Architectural Marketing and Project Development, Proposals/ Negotiations/ Contracts, Contract Administration, File Management and Limitations of Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO) Operations. General Notes: METHOD OF COMPENSATION FOR SPECIALIZED ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES Compensation for the foregoing specialized architectural services, all of which may be classified as additional or extra services, shall be through man-months i.e. 22 man-days multiplied by 8 man-hours, and multiplied by a factor to cover other direct and indirect costs e.g. overhead, etc. or any other applicable mode of determination of the Architect’s fee as stated in Doc. 201, Doc. 202 and the Architect’s Guidelines. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 49 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON FULLTIME SUPERVISION SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 204-A (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 204-A) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 For the past 50 years, four principal members were involved in the design and building construction process: 1.1.1 The Owner who orders for the implementation of a project; 1.1.2 The Architect and his Specialist Consultants (SCs) who render plan/design services and limited inspection work; 1.1.3 The Contractor who performs the construction work; 1.1.4 The individual or group of individuals who assist in the supervision and delivery of the work. 1.2 The Architect-in-charge of construction (Aicc) is directly and professionally responsible and liable for the construction supervision of the project. 1.3 When projects were still manageable in size, the Architect was then assisted by a construction inspector, traditionally called Clerk-of-Works. As projects become more complex, it becomes necessary for a construction supervision group to do the full-time inspection at the project site. 1.4 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) is normally recommended by the Architect based on their performance, and hired by the Owner. They are answerable to both the Owner and Architect. 2. SCOPE OF SERVICES 2.1 Quality Control 2.2 Evaluation of Construction Work 2.3 Preparation of Daily Inspection Reports _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 50 of 94 2.4 Filing of documents The detailed tasks shall be as specified under the Architect’s Guidelines. 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES There are two ways by which the Architect may enter into contract with the Owner: 3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for fulltime supervision services or as the Construction Supervision Group (CSG). As the Architect-of-record (Aor) of the project, the Aor is in a better position to interpret his drawings and documents and to assure conformity by the Contractor. He can assign his staff to undertake the fulltime supervisory work to perform the works as enumerated in the Architect’s Guidelines. 3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for fulltime supervision services only or as the CSG. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION The Architect’s compensation is based on the Architect’s / architectural firm’s talents, skill, experience, and on the type and level of professional services provided. Compensation for Fulltime Supervision Services may be based on one or more of the following: 4.1 Percentage (%) of Project Construction Cost (PCC) The Architect’s Fee for Fulltime Supervision as based on the PPC shall be detailed in the Architect’s Guidelines. 4.2 Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses This cost-based method of compensation is applicable only to non-creative work such as accounting, secretarial, research, data gathering, preparation of reports and the like. This method of compensation is based on technical hours spent and does not account for creative work since the value of creative design cannot be measured by the length of time the designer has spent on his work. The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (man hours x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier to cover overhead and profit. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 51 of 94 The multiplier ranges from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the office set-up, overhead and experience of the Architect and the complexity of the Project. Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants, out-of-town living and housing allowances of the local consultants and the like, are all to be charged to the Client. At the start of the commission, the Architect shall make known to the Client the rate of professionals and personnel who will be assigned to the Project and the multiplier that has to be applied before agreeing on this method of compensation. FORMULA Assume: A= Architect’s rate / hour C= Consultant’s rate / hour T= Rate per hour of Technical Staff, Inspectors and others involved in the Project AN, CN, TN = No. of hours spent by Architect, Consultants and Technical Staff M= Multiplier to account for overhead and reasonable profit. The value may range from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the set-up of the Architect’s office and the complexity of the Project. R= Reimbursable expenses such as transportation, housing and living allowance of Consultant, transportation, per diem, housing and living allowance of local consultants and technical staff if assigned to places over 100km. from area of operation of the Architect. Cost of printing of extra set of drawings, reports, maps, contract documents, etc. over the seven (7) copies submitted to the Client, overseas and long distance calls, technical and laboratory tests, licenses, fees, taxes and similar cost items needed by the Project. Direct cost = AN + CN + TN Fee = Direct Cost x M Total Cost of Service charged to Client = Fee + R _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 52 of 94 4.3 Professional Fee Plus Expenses This method of compensation is frequently used where there is continuing relationship involving a series of Projects. It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. An agreement on the general scope of the work is necessary in order to set an equitable fee. 4.4 Lump Sum or Fixed Fee This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paper work and time-consuming efforts. 4.5 Per Diem, Honorarium Plus Reimbursable Expenses In some cases a Client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time such as: 7.18.1 attending project-related meetings, conferences or trips; 7.18.2 conducting ocular inspection of possible project sites; and 7.18.3 conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like. For these particular activities, the Architect as agent of the Owner may be paid on a per diem and honorarium basis plus out-of-pocket expenses such as but not limited to travel, accommodations and subsistence. 4.6 Mixed Methods of Compensation The SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. Each project should be examined to determine the most appropriate method of compensation. 5. LIMITATION OF AUTHORITY 5.1 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG), which may be a qualified architectural firm, or which the Architect is only part of, shall not assume the responsibility of the Contractor’s project superintendent. 5.2 The CSG shall not make decisions on matters that are the sole responsibility of the Architect-of-record (Aor). _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 53 of 94 6. LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY 6.1 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) is responsible to the Owner only for administrative matters. For technical matters, the CSG is responsible to the Architect-of-record (Aor). 6.2 Under Article 1723 of the present Civil Code, the CSG may appear not to have any legal responsibility since the Architect-of-record (Aor) and Engineers-of-record (Eors) are responsible for the design while the Contractor is responsible for the construction. However, a Service Contract / Agreement between the CSG and the Owner may stipulate certain professional responsibilities and civil liabilities of the CSG, particularly if the CSG is party to the review of the Contract Documents and their subsequent evaluation and interpretation during the course of construction. 6.3 If the Aor (and Eors) and the Contractor are sued by an Owner for civil liabilities due to the performance or non-performance of certain acts traceable to the CSG, the Aor and Eors may file cross claims against the CSG. 7. QUALIFICATIONS Inspectors of the Construction Supervision Group (CSG) must have: 7.1 A Bachelor of Science in Architecture (B.S. Arch.) degree 7.2 Extensive experience in design and building construction and must be very knowledgeable in building materials and construction detailing. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 54 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 204-B (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 204-B) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Due to the increasing complexity of construction projects, there is an upward demand for more effective cost control and faster project implementation consistent with high quality of work. Construction Management Services were thus instituted to fill this need in the construction industry. 1.2 The Construction Manager (CM) could either be: 1.2.1 a member of the staff of the Owner, 1.2.2 an independent individual, or 1.2.3 a firm hired by the Owner to manage the construction of a particular project. 1.3 The Architect can serve as the Construction Manager (CM). His training in the coordination of various specialties allows him to supervise and assure proper monitoring of all construction activities with regards to quality, workmanship and cost. 2. FUNCTIONS AND DESCRIPTION OF TASKS 2.1 The responsibilities of the Construction Manager (CM) include the functions of the Construction Supervision Group (CSG). (reference Doc. 204-A and Architect’s Guidelines) 2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.1.4 2.2 Coordination and Supervision Cost and Time Control Quality Control of Work and Keeping of Records The Construction Manager (CM) may hire the CSG to be under his employ or may supervise the CSG hired directly by the Owner. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 55 of 94 3. LIMITATION OF AUTHORITY The Architect as the Construction Manager shall not: 3.1 Involve himself directly with the work of the Contractor such that it may be construed that he is assuming the Contractor’s liability as provided for in Article 1723, etc. of the Civil Code. 3.2 Impose methods, systems or designs that will substantially affect the construction schedule and impair the design concept of the Architect. 4. LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY 4.1 The Architect as the Construction Manager (CM) is directly responsible to the Owner on all aspects of the construction work: programming, coordination, quality and cost control and time management. 4.2 The CM assumes no liability in case equipment fail to function or if a portion of the building collapses: 4.2.1 due to deficiencies in the plan / design, provided the CM did not participate in the plan / design review and approval, or 4.2.2 due to the deficiencies in the manner of construction, provided the CM faithfully discharged his function/s during the construction / project implementation. 5. QUALIFICATIONS The Construction Manager may be an individual or a firm. 5.1 The individual or the principal of the firm must be a State-regulated professional, preferably an Architect with managerial capabilities and extensive experience in the field of construction. The Architect must be a Registered and Licensed Architects (RLA), with an updated professional identification card and must be a member in good standing of the Integrated and Accredited Professional Organization of Architects (IAPOA). 5.2 Architects who are Contractors or who have already been in responsible charge of construction works are usually capable of becoming Construction Managers (CMs). 6. METHOD OF COMPENSATION Since construction management is not part of the regular services of the Architect, the services rendered by the Architect as a Construction Manager (CM) shall be separately compensated. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 56 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON POST-CONSTRUCTION SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 205 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 205) 7. INTRODUCTION 7.3 Building administration and management goes beyond maintenance and upkeep functions. It requires the services of a multi-disciplinary professional who can perform a wide range or functions for the efficient and economical operation and maintenance of a building, facility or a complex. 7.4 In Post-Construction Services, the channels of communication are kept open among the building owners, operators, architects, engineers, builders, manufacturers, building research groups, utility providers, furniture and equipment vendors and building administrators/ property managers to provide access to information regarding the performance and upkeep of buildings. 7.5 The Architect may be engaged as the Building Administrator and/or Property Manager of a commercial, industrial, residential or institutional building, facility or complex to maximize the lifespan of the building/s in order to produce the maximum economic return. 8. SCOPE OF SERVICES 8.1 Building and Facilities Administration 8.1.1 Building Maintenance. The Architect shall: a. See to it that the building and all the parts thereof (structure, plumbing, electrical, partitions, finishes, etc.) are all in good condition. b. Formulate and enforce rules for the proper use of the building and facility, particularly in the common areas and the emergency/ egress/ exit areas. c. Monitor security services, and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 57 of 94 d. Monitor maintenance and upkeep services (cleanliness of corridors, lobbies, stairs and other common areas, exits, parking areas, garbage collection) 2.1.2 Grounds and Landscaping Supervision. The Architect shall: a. Supervise landscape contractors and gardeners for the proper watering, pruning, trimming and maintenance of the landscape (both hardscapes and softscapes); b. Maintain orderly entrances, exits and parking areas; and c. Maintain streets i.e. road rights-of–way (RROWs), walkways, and ramps. 2.1.3 Building Equipment Maintenance. The Architect shall: a. Assist the proper third parties in seeing to it that all equipment (airconditioning, sprinkler system, generators, transformers, tele communications equipment, etc.) are properly maintained and in good working condition 2.1.4 Business Development and Management. The Architect shall: a. Innovate schemes to attain maximum building occupancy b. Bill the tenants for rentals and utilities (electricity, water, telephone, cable, gas and other/ related dues) 2.2 Post-Construction Evaluation 2.2.2 Upon the request of the Owner, the Architect shall: a. evaluate the initial design program vs. the actual use of the facility; b. determine the effectiveness of the various building systems and the materials systems in use; c. assist the proper third parties in evaluating the functional effectiveness of the design and construction process undertaken, and d. study, research, and give solutions to any discovered/ emerging/ evolving defects and failures such as shrinkage, water seepage and other problems in the building. This is referred to as “forensic investigation” of the building’s systems (Reference Doc 203). _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 58 of 94 3. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 3.1. Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for post-construction services. 3.2. Working as Consulting Architect for post-construction services only. 4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 4.1. Percentage of gross rentals, maintenance and security fees; and/or 4.2. Monthly salary/ fee. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 59 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON COMPREHENSIVE ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 206 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 206) 1. INTRODUCTION 8.2 The concept of Comprehensive Architectural Services crystallized through the years in response to the demands of emerging complex building projects. The transition of the architectural profession from providing “basic” and “additional” services to that of a comprehensive nature is due to the realization that continuity of services related to design and construction is necessary for the execution of a completely viable project. 8.3 Comprehensive Architectural Services refers to the range of professional services that covers Pre-design Services, Regular Design Services, Specialized Architectural Services, Construction Services and PostConstruction Services. 8.4 In this extended dimension, the Architect is the prime professional. He functions as creator, author, and coordinator of the building design which becomes the basis for the construction of a project. In order for him to be able to properly assist and serve his Client, the Architect has to be knowledgeable in other fields in addition to building design. 8.5 The Architect is not expected to perform all the services. Rather, he is to act as the agent of the Client in procuring and coordinating the necessary services required by a project. 9. SCOPE OF COMPREHENSIVE ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES 9.1 Pre-Design Services (SPP Document 201) 9.1.1 Consultation 9.1.2 Pre-Feasibility Studies 9.1.3 Feasibility Studies _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 60 of 94 9.2 9.3 9.1.4 Site Selection and Analysis 9.1.5 9.1.6 Site Utilization and Land-Use Studies Architectural Research 9.1.7 Architectural Programming 9.1.8 Space Planning 9.1.9 Space Management Studies 9.1.10 Value Management 9.1.11 Design Brief Preparation 9.1.12 Promotional Services Regular Design Services (SPP Document 202) 9.2.1 Project Definition Phase 9.2.2 Schematic Design Phase 9.2.3 Design Development Phase 9.2.4 Contract Documents Phase 9.2.5 Bidding or Negotiation Phase 9.2.6 Construction Phase Specialized Architectural Services (SPP Document 203) 9.3.1 Architectural Interiors (AI) 9.3.2 Acoustic Design 9.3.3 Architectural Lighting Layout and Design 9.3.4 Site Development Planning (SDP) _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 61 of 94 9.4 9.3.5 Site and Physical Planning Services (including Master Development Planning, Subdivision Planning and Urban Design) 9.3.6 Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) 9.3.7 9.3.8 Historic and Cultural Heritage Conservation and Planning Security Evaluation and Planning 9.3.9 Building Systems Design 9.3.10 Facilities Maintenance Support 9.3.11 Building Testing and Commissioning 9.3.12 Building Environmental Certification 9.3.13 Forensic Architecture 9.3.14 Building Appraisal 9.3.15 Preliminary Services 9.3.16 Contract Documentation and Review 9.3.17 Post-Design Services (including Construction Management Services) 9.3.18 Dispute Avoidance and Resolution 9.3.19 Architectural Research Methods 9.3.20 Special Building/ Facility Planning and Design 9.3.21 Building Components 9.3.22 Management of Architectural Practices Construction Services 9.4.1 Fulltime Supervision Services (SPP Document 204-A) _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 62 of 94 9.4.2 9.5 Construction Management Services (SPP Document 204-B) Post-Construction Services (SPP Document 205) 9.5.1 Building and Facilities Administration 9.5.2 Post-Construction Evaluation 10. PROJECT MANAGEMENT (PM) 10.1 By his education and training, the Architect may perform any or all of the services as stipulated under Section 2 above. However, when the Owner hires an Architect or a firm to coordinate the whole range of Comprehensive Architectural Services (CAS), this constitutes Project Management (PM). 10.2 Project Management (PM) involves management activities over and above the normal architectural and engineering (A&E) services carried out during the pre-design, design and construction phase. The over-all objective is to have control over time, cost and quality relative to the construction of a project. 10.3 The presence of a PM does not relieve the designers and contractors of their respective normal duties and responsibilities in the design and construction of the project. The PM complements the functions of the Architects, Engineers and Contractors in meeting the broad and complex requirements of projects. 11. THE PROJECT MANAGER (PM) 11.1 The Project Manager (PM, whether individual or firm) operates as a member of an Owner-Architect-Engineer-Contractor Team. In the Team Approach, each member of the team will have precedence in his own field of operations or expertise. In accordance with this principle: 4.1.1 The Architect and the Specialist Consultants (SCs) will have prime responsibility for the plan/design of the project. 4.1.2 The Engineers will be responsible for their respective engineering plans. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 63 of 94 4.1.3 The Contractor shall be responsible for his men and equipment and the delivery of the project. 4.1.4 The Owner makes decisions on the project and assures that funds are available to complete the project. 4.1.5 The Project Manager (PM)’s primary responsibility is the exercise of overall cost control. He will plan, program and monitor the various activities, and will act as an adviser on material costs and construction methods. 4.2 Scope of Services 4.2.1 Pre-Construction Phase As early as during the design development phase, perhaps even concurrently with the Architect’s commission, the Project Manager (PM) should conduct regular consultations with the Owner and with the Architects and Engineers (for A&E services) on all aspects of planning for the project. 4.2.2 Construction Phase If the Project Manager (PM) also serves as the Construction Manager (CM) to oversee time, cost and quality control during the construction of the project, he shall provide the services detailed under SPP Documents 204-A and/or 204-B. 12. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES 12.1 Normally, the Architect enters into a contract with the Owner to perform comprehensive architectural services. By the very nature of the services, he assumes the dual role of the Project Manager (PM) and the Construction Manager (CM), or effectively the overall coordinator whose functions are outlined under this SPP. 12.2 To perform the variety of services indicated under the Comprehensive Architectural Services, the Architect must make full use of his own capability as well as of services offered by other professionals. He may expand his staff by hiring the experts needed, or he may form a team consisting of professionals such as but not limited to: _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 64 of 94 12.2.1 Architects 12.2.2 Engineers 12.2.3 Market Analysts 12.2.4 Accountants 12.2.5 General Contractors 12.2.6 Real Estate Consultants 12.2.7 Sociologists 12.2.8 Planners 12.2.9 Bankers 12.2.10 Lawyers 12.3 If a Project Manager (PM) is hired by the Owner, it may be the responsibility of the PM to either hire the Construction Manager (CM) to be paid either by him or directly by the Owner on salary, or on the basis of percentage of construction cost or to serve as the CM himself. In like manner, the Fulltime Supervisor can either be a staff member of the PM or hired directly by the Owner. 13. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 13.1 The Project Manager is compensated on a percentage basis, as shall be described in the Architect’s Guidelines. 13.2 If the Architect as Project Manager (PM) performs regular design services for the same project, he shall be compensated separately for these services as stipulated in SPP Document 202. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 65 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON DESIGN-BUILD SERVICES (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 207 (replacing the 1979 UAP Doc. 207) 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 In any building project, there is need to balance the elements of time, quality and cost, which, in many cases, can best be achieved by the Architect performing Design-Build Services. 1.2 The building industry and the architectural profession have devised several methods of project delivery with the ultimate goal of handling projects in the shortest possible time, at the lowest possible cost and at an acceptable quality and performance. 1.3 An Architect with his education, training and expertise qualifies him to take a direct role in the project, from conceptualization to implementation. 1.4 Design-Build Services simplifies and expedites the process of project delivery while providing creative cost-effective solutions. 1.5 The Architect renders professional services in the implementation of his design. In Design-Build Services, he assumes the professional responsibility and civil liability for both the design and the construction of the project. 2. SCOPE OF DESIGN-BUILD SERVICES 2.1 Design-Build Services by Administration The scope of Design-Build Services by Administration includes the Architect’s Regular Design Services (reference SPP Document 202) namely: 2.1.1 Project Definition Phase 2.1.2 Schematic Design Phase 2.1.3 Design Development Phase _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 66 of 94 2.1.4 Contract Document Phase 2.1.5 Construction Phase When the various phases of design services are completed, the Construction Phase goes beyond periodic inspection and assessment to include the following: a. Preparation of schedule of work, program and estimates of materials, labor, transportation, equipment and services as reference for the construction. b. Organization and hiring of construction personnel, designation of duties and remunerations c. Negotiation and entering into contract with piecework contractors and evaluation of work accomplishments d. Procurement of materials, plants and equipment, licenses and permits e. Authorizing and undertaking payments of accounts f. Keeping records and books of accounts g. Negotiation with Government and private agencies having jurisdiction over the project, and h. Management of all other business transactions related to the project construction / implementation. 2.2 Design-Build Services with Guaranteed Maximum Project Construction Cost 2.2.1 This method is essentially the same as Design-Build Services by Administration except that the Owner/ Client is provided a guaranteed maximum project construction cost for the construction of the project. 2.2.2 The Owner/ Client is given an estimate of the project, and upon completion, if there is realized savings from the estimated project _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 67 of 94 construction cost; it is divided equally between the Owner/ Client and the Architect. 2.2.3 The project construction cost is guaranteed by the Architect not to exceed Ten Percent (10%) of the estimated project construction cost. Should the actual cost exceed the estimated project construction cost plus Ten Percent (10%), the Architect shall be liable for the excess amount but only up to the amount of his administration Fee. 2.2.4 Should there be additional expenditures beyond the guaranteed maximum project construction cost which are due to legitimate change/variation orders (CVOs), extra work orders (EWOs), substantial escalation of prices of the costs of materials or labor as evidenced by data certified by a nationally recognized agency such as the National Economic Development Authority (NEDA), or to other causes not attributable to the fault of the Architect, the additional costs shall be borne by the Owner/ Client. 14. MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES 4.5 The Architect may be involved in construction, including that of his own design, by adopting an arrangement different from the general way of bidding out projects to constructors, or from the different modes of Design-Build Services (DBS). Such an arrangement may take the form of any of the following: 4.5.1 The Architect is part of or a member of the entity constructing his design. He works in tandem with or has authorized an entity to construct his design. 4.5.2 The Architect is himself a State-licensed contractor implementing his design (or that of others). 4.6 In adopting any of the above arrangements, or any acceptable variation thereof, the Architect must strictly adhere to the following: : 4.6.1 The Architect must retain his separate / distinct professional identity, prerogatives and integrity as an Architect, and is therefore subject to the standards and tenets of the SPP, particularly Document 200, otherwise known as the Code of Ethical Conduct and SPP Document 202. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 68 of 94 4.6.2 Whatever mode the Architect adopts in being involved in construction, he must strictly adhere to the tenets of the Architects Credo with the pledge that he “shall disclose whenever required, any business investment or venture that may tend to create a conflict of interest, and ensure that such conflict neither compromises the legitimate interest of the Client nor interfere with his duty to render impartial judgment.” 5. METHOD OF COMPENSATION 5.1 The manner of payment to the Architect follows the progress of construction. All costs for labor and materials are paid directly by the Client. The Architect does not advance any money for payment of expenditures connected with the work. Generally, a revolving fund is given to the Architect beforehand and is accounted for and subject to periodic auditing by the Client. 5.2 Cost of all permits, licenses and other incidentals to the work are paid by the Owner/ Client. 5.3 The Architect may appoint, subject to the Owner/ Client’s approval, a construction superintendent, purchasing agent, timekeeper and property clerk aside from the usual labor personnel required. Salaries of such persons are paid by the Owner/ Client and not deductible from the Architect’s Fee under this SPP. 5.4 The method of compensation may be modified by using the relevant alternatives detailed in SPP Doc. 202. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 69 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) on ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN COMPETITION (ADC) (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 208 (replacing the UAP Doc. 209) 1. INTRODUCTION The purpose of this SPP for Architectural Design Competition (ADC) is to state the principles upon which competitions are based and by which Promoters/ Owners should be guided in organizing ADCs. It has been drawn up in the interest of both Project Proponents/ Owners and Competitors. 2. DEFINITIONS 2.1 Owner - The person or organization who undertakes or promotes an ADC with the primary objective of obtaining excellence in design for a project or for a development concept. The Owner issues the invitation to Architects to submit plans/designs in accordance with a program and finances the ADC. 2.2 Jury - The people appointed by the Owner to assess the entries to the competition. The members of the Jury are called Jurors. It consists of a majority of registered and licensed architects (RLAs, hereinafter referred to as “Architect/s”) assisted by a lay Juror to represent and voice the intention of the Owner. They are nominated by the Owner and approved by the integrated and accredited professional organization of architects (IAPOA). 2.3 Professional Advisor – An Architect nominated by the Owner and approved by IAPoA to organize the ADC on behalf of the Owner. 2.4 Technical Advisors – Specialist personnel who may be consulted by the Jurors during the conduct of the ADC to permit them to obtain all necessary relevant information. 2.5 Competition Secretariat – The body formed by the Owner and approved by the Professional Advisor, to assist the Professional Advisor and the Jury in the administrative conduct of the ADC 2.6 Classification of Architectural Design Competitions (ADCs) _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 70 of 94 2.6.1 ADCs shall be classified as follows: a. Project ADCs for actual Projects proposed for implementation. b. Ideas Competition or competition of ideas set as a design and planning exercise to elucidate a problem. 2.6.2 Project ADCs may be conducted in a single stage or two (2)-stage manner. It may either be open or limited by invitation. 2.6.3 Project ADCs shall be further classified according to degree of complexity based on project classification i.e. under SPP Document 202. 3. 2.7 Conditions – The full conditions include the program, instructions on submission of entries, site plans, entry forms and official envelopes and labels. These are drawn up by the Professional Advisor. 2.8 SPP on ADC – refers to the Philippine Standard of Professional Practice (SPP) on Architectural Design Competitions (ADC). 2.9 IAPOA ADC Committee – appointed by the IAPOA National President to oversee all architectural design competitions (ADCs) referred to the IAPOA. IAPOA APPROVAL 3.1 Before any official announcement is made by the Owner, a written approval of the draft Conditions, including the timetable, The ADC registration fee (when required) and membership of the Jury shall have been received in writing by the Owner from the IAPOA through the ADC Committee. 3.2 Notice of a National Architectural Design Competition (ADC) shall be issued by the Owner and/or the IAPOA ADC Committee Secretariat with a request for publication in technical journals or through other media at their disposal, simultaneously if possible to enable those interested to apply for the competition. Such an announcement shall state where and how the ADC documents may be obtained and that the ADC conditions have received the requisite IAPOA approval. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 71 of 94 4. DRAWING UP THE ADC CONDITIONS 4.1 It is essential that the ANONYMITY of competitors should be maintained until the final judgment of the competition. In the interest of the competition system, rigorous measures should be taken to ensure that this principle is adhered to. 4.2 The ADC conditions, including the program of requirements of a National ADC shall be identical for all competitors. 4.3 The conditions for National ADC, whether single or two (2)-stage, upon or limited shall state clearly: 4.3.1 the purpose of the ADC and the intentions of the Owner. 4.3.2 the nature of the problem to be solved. 4.3.3 all the requirements to be met by Competitors. 5. 4.4 A clear distinction shall be made between the mandatory requirements of the Conditions and those which permit the competitor freedom of interpretation, which should be as wide as possible. All competition entries shall be submitted in a manner to be prescribed in the Conditions. 4.5 The information supplied to competitors (social, economic, technical, geographical and topographical, etc.) must be specific and not open to misinterpretation. Supplementary information and instructions approved by the Jury may be issued by the Owner to all Competitors selected to proceed to the second (2nd) stage of a two (2)-stage competition. 4.6 The Conditions shall state the number, nature, scale and dimensions of the documents, plans or models required and the terms of acceptance of such documents or models. Where an estimate of cost is required this must be presented in standard form as set out in the Condition. PROFESSIONAL ADVISOR 5.1 A Professional Advisor should be appointed and paid by the Owner and approved by the IAPOA National Board of Directors (NBD) thru its ADC Committee. His role is the supervision of the conduct of the ADC and the preparation of the Conditions. His function includes insuring that the ADC _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 72 of 94 timetable is adhered to, supervising the receipt of Competitor’s questions, the dispatch of reply to all Competitors and the receipt of competition entries, and safeguarding the anonymity of Competitors at all times. He will assist the Jury and will be present during its deliberations but he will have no vote. His responsibilities will be limited to the organization and the conduct of the competition. 6. THE JURY 6.1 The Jury shall be set up before the official announcement of the competition. Their names and those of the reserve members of the Jury shall be stated in the Conditions. 6.2 The Jurors are appointed by the Owner and approved by the IAPOA, which shall assist the Owner in the selection of the Jury members. 6.3 The Jury shall be composed of the smallest reasonable number of persons and in any event should be an odd number and should not exceed seven (7). The majority of them shall be Architects i.e. 4 out of 7. 6.4 To ensure correct conduct of the competition, at least one of the ArchitectJurors shall represent the IAPOA. 6.5 There should not be more than one (1) representative of the Owner included in the Jury. 6.6 It is essential that all Jurors be present at all meetings of the Jury. 6.7 Each Juror shall see the Conditions before they are made available to Competitors. 6.8 The decisions of the Jury shall be taken by a majority vote, with a separate vote on each competition plan/design submitted. The list of ADC awards including the Jury’s report to the Owner shall be signed by all Jurors before the Jury is dissolved and one copy of this document shall be sent to the IAPOA. 6.9 In a two (2)-stage competition, the same Jury should judge both stages of the competition. In no case may a competition that has received IAPOA approval as a single-stage competition proceed to a second (2nd) stage except with IAPOA approval of the Conditions and the arrangements for payment of _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 73 of 94 honoraria to the Competitors involved, over and above the prize money provided for in the original ADC. In the event of a secondary competition taking place, the Jury appointed for the original competition must be reappointed by the Owner. 6.10 Any drawings, photographs, models or other documents not required under the regulations shall be excluded by the Jury before it examines a Competitor's entry. 6.11 The Jury shall disqualify any design which does not conform to the mandatory requirements, instructions or Conditions for the ADC. 6.12 The Jury must make awards. The awards shall be final and made public by a date agreed on with the IAPOA and stated in the competitions. The Jury, when distributing the awards, shall make full use of the amount set aside for prizes in the ADC Conditions. 6.13 The fees and travel and subsistence expenses of the Jury members shall be paid by the Owner. 7. 8. PERSONS NOT ELIGIBLE FOR ENTRY TO THE ADC 7.1 No member of the Jury will be allowed to take part in the competition, either directly or indirectly, nor be commissioned with work connected with the prizewinning design either directly or indirectly. 7.2 No member of the promoting body nor any associate or employee, nor any person concerned with the preparation or organization of the ADC will be eligible to compete or assist a Competitor. PRIZES, HONORARIA AND MENTIONS 8.1 The Conditions must state the amount and number of prizes. The prizes awarded must be related to the size and complexity of the project, the amount of work involved and the expense incurred by Competitors. 8.2 It is important for the Owner to allot adequate prize money to compensate all the Competitors for their work. For Ideas Competition only, it may be the sole remuneration received by the first (1st) prize winner. 8.3 The Owner undertakes to accept the decisions of the Jury and to pay the _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 74 of 94 prizes allotted within one (1) month of the official announcement of the ADC results. 8.4 Each participant in a limited ADC by invitation shall receive an honorarium in addition to the prizes awarded. 8.5 In two (2)-stage competitions, a reasonable honorarium shall be paid to each of the Competitors selected to take part in the second (2nd) stage. This sum, which is intended to reimburse them for the additional work carried out in the second (2nd) stage, shall be stated in the Conditions and shall be in addition to the prizes awarded. 8.6 The Conditions shall state the use to which the Owner will put the winning plan/design scheme/s. ADC-generated plans/designs may not be used or altered in any way except by agreement with the author. The Owner or his agents are not free to pick out portions of the entries to compose another plan/ design due to applicable ownership and copyright provisions under Secs. 20 (4) and 33 of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and of R.A. No. 8293 (Intellectual property Code of the Philippines) and their respective IRRs. 8.7 In Project ADCs, the award of first prize to a plan/design places the Owner under an obligation to entrust the Author of the plan/design with the commission for the Project. If the winning Competitor is unable to satisfy the Jury of his ability to carry out the plan/ design work, the Jury may require the winner to collaborate with another Architect of the winning Competitor’s choice, duly approved by the Jury and Owner. 8.8 In Project ADCs, provisions shall be made in the ADC Conditions for the first prize winner to receive compensation of a further sum equal to the amount of the first prize, if no contract has been signed within twelve (12) months of the announcement of the Jury’s award. In so compensating the first prize winner, the Owner does not acquire the right to carry out the project except with the collaboration of its Author. 8.9 In an Ideas Competition, if the Owner decides to make use of all or part of the winning scheme, he should do so with the collaboration of the Author. The terms of collaboration must be acceptable to the latter. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 75 of 94 9. COPYRIGHT AND RIGHT OF OWNERSHIP 9.1 The Author of any plan/design shall retain the copyright of his work; no alterations may be made without his written consent. 9.2 The design awarded first prize can only be used by the Owner upon his commissioning the Author to carry out the plan/design preparation for the project. No other plan/design may be used wholly or in part by the Owner except by agreement with the Author concerned. 9.3 As a general rule, the Owner’s right to use the ADC-generated plan/design covers one (1) execution only. However, the Conditions may provide for repetitive work and specify the terms thereof 9.4 In all cases, unless otherwise stated in the Conditions, the Author of any design shall retain the sole right of reproduction by virtue of sole copyright under Secs. 20 (4) and 33 of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its IRR. 10. REGISTRATION OF COMPETITORS 10.1 As soon as they have received details of the architectural design competition (ADC), all Competitors shall register with the Owner. Registration implies acceptance of the Conditions of the ADC. 10.2 The Owner shall issue to all Competitors all the necessary documentation for preparing their plans/designs. Where the furnishing of such documentation is conditional on payment of a deposit, unless otherwise stated, such a deposit shall be returned to Competitors who submit a bona fide plan/ design. 10.3 The names of those Competitors selected to proceed to the second (2nd) stage of a two (2)-stage competition shall be made public only under exceptional conditions to be agreed on by the Jury before the launching of the ADC. 11. INSURANCE 11.1 The Owner shall insure the Competitors’ plans/ designs from the time when he assumes responsibility for them and for the duration of his responsibility. The amount of such insurance shall be stated in the Conditions. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 76 of 94 12. EXHIBITIONS AND ENTRIES 12.1 All designs, including those disqualified by the Jury, shall be exhibited, as a general rule, for at least two (2) weeks, together with a copy of the signed report of the Jury. The exhibition shall be open to the public free of charge. 12.2 The Owner shall notify in a timely manner, all registered Competitors of the date and place of the public exhibition and the results of the ADC, and send them a copy of the Jury's report. He shall similarly inform the IAPOA. Photographs of the prize- winning designs shall be sent to the IAPOA with a view to possible publication. 13. RETURN OF PROJECTS 13.1 All drawings and plans, other than those which have received prizes or have been purchased and are retained by the Owner, shall be destroyed at the end of the public exhibition, unless provisions are made to the contrary in the Conditions for the ADC. Where models are required, these will be returned to the Author/s at the expense of the Owner within a month of the close of the public exhibition. 14. ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR) OR LITIGATION 14.1 Since no regulations, however well drawn up, can preclude the possibility of dispute, provisions for conciliation, mediation and arbitration i.e. ADR modes under R.A. No. 9285, must be included in the ADC Conditions and must precede any form of litigation. 14.2 The Jury members are the sole arbiters at all stages, up to the final prizegiving. 14.3 In the event of a dispute, not related to the adjudication process or awarding of the prizes, the matter shall be settled by an arbitration process approved by the IAPOA, and without initial recourse to any form of litigation. 14.4 The expenses resulting from any conciliation, mediation or arbitration, procedure shall be shared by the two (2) interested parties to the ADR proceeding. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 77 of 94 STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) ON PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL CONSULTING SERVICES (PACS) (Part of the IRR of R.A. No. 9266) SPP Document 209 (replacing the 1981 UAP Doc. 210) 15. FOREWORD 15.1 On March 20, 1980, then President Ferdinand E. Marcos, recognizing the role of the members of accredited professional organizations (APOs) in nation building and in the pursuit of national goals, issued Letter of Instruction (LoI) No. 1000 which directs all government agencies and any of its instrumentalities to give priority to members of the APOs in the hiring of its employees and in the engagement of professional services. This amply demonstrated the President’s confidence in the capabilities of Filipino professionals i.e. registered and licensed professionals (RLPs) 15.2 Consequent to this, the Philippine Federation of Professional Associations (PFPA), the umbrella organization of all professional associations accredited by the Professional Regulation Commission (PRC, hereinafter the “Commission”), and the Philippine Technological Council (PTC), whose membership consisted of fourteen (14) accredited technological APOs at that time, initiated the preparation of a document entitled “Standard Guidelines on Consultancy/Consulting Services”. 15.3 The said document contained a comprehensive coverage of provisions in consonance with national policies and compatible with norms of accepted professional practices, was seen as a much needed vehicle by which the Filipino professionals can accelerate their contribution to national development. 15.4 Three decades hence, it has become urgent to re-visit this document in light of the influx of foreign consultants (FCs) and the proliferation of entities projecting themselves as “consultants” even without the adequate skills, training, and experience required for rendering competent services. This necessity does not spring only from narrow professional needs, but more significantly it underscores the need for utilizing qualified Filipino professionals in the comprehensive development of our country. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 78 of 94 15.5 Considering the foregoing, this amended version of the 1981 Standard Guidelines on Consulting Services, based on the document jointly drafted by PTC and Council for the Built and Natural Environments (CBNE) in accordance with their Joint Resolution No. 2009-01 dated December 11, 2009, embodies relevant provisions of professional regulatory laws (PRLs) governing the various APOs, national policies, principles and rules/regulations/guidelines/manuals of procedure (MoP) governing Stateregulated professional practices, as well as the basic terms and conditions for the engagement of Professional Consultants, such as Consulting Architects defined under R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its 2004 implementing rules and regulations (IRR). 15.6 All national and local government agencies and instrumentalities, government-owned or controlled corporations (GOCCs) and institutions, as well as those in the private sector and other civil society organizations, including the international community, are all encouraged to adopt these “Philippine Standard of Professional Practice (SPP) for Professional Architectural Consulting Services (PACS)” in the selection, commissioning and engagement of Professional Consulting Architects (PCAs) and in the conceptualization, development, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of projects that lend and/or lead to the overall national, regional and local development. 16. RATIONALE 16.1 The Government of the Republic of the Philippines, through its various departments, agencies, instrumentalities, institutions and entities, as well as the private sector and civil society organizations and representatives of the international community (with projects on Philippine soil), regularly select, commission or engage the services of professional consultants to achieve maximum efficiency, economy and expediency in the preparation of program/project concepts, pre-feasibility and feasibility studies, project evaluations, design and plan preparation, management and other related activities. 16.2 Moreover, one important strategy for strengthening national capability in the various fields of consulting services is the full utilization of local expertise, which in turn generates conditions for increased nationally-evolved scientific and technological knowledge _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 79 of 94 16.3 In recognition of the urgent need to set the general guidelines on professional consultancy/ consulting services in the country, to enhance the participation of Filipino professionals in national development and to protect their rights in accordance with existing laws, policies, rules and regulations, the CBNE and the PTC spearheaded the formulation of standard guidelines for the practice of professional consulting services for State-regulated professions represented by the said organizations. 16.4 The full utilization of the services of Filipino Professional Consultants (FPCs) can minimize the importation of foreign expertise which entails considerable expenditure of hard-earned foreign exchange. Such importation also erodes the essence of maintaining an educational system geared towards the expansion of the country’s professional capability. For this reason, the displacement of FPCs by foreign consultants is irrational. 16.5 The inflow of foreign consultants, specifically foreign architects is often justified on the ground of technology transfer. In this sense, technology transfer is based on the assumption that the particular kind of technology involved is not yet available in this country or is inadequate in relation to the need for it. The problem presented by the dominant presence of foreign architects in the Philippines, however, is precisely defined by the fact that the technology they bring in is already available in such adequate proportion that foreign consultants compete in terms adverse to Filipino registered and licensed professionals (RLPs) and in fact displace Filipino Professional Consultants (FPCs) from participation in significant development projects. 16.6 The disproportionate inflow versus outflow of expertise is becoming more and more serious. This means a tremendous loss to the country in terms of educational costs. More significantly, the country is deprived of returning Filipino RLPs’ contributions to the country’s comprehensive development. 16.7 The professional competence of Filipino Professional Consultants (FPCs), specifically Professional Consulting Architects (PCAs) is well established and adequate to meet the country’s requirements. In fact, in many cases, foreign consultants depend largely on the expertise and information furnished by FPCs, specially of PCAs 16.8 The primary purpose of this SPP is to complement existing professional regulatory laws (PRLs) governing the practice of State-regulated professions, specifically architecture, as governed by R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its derivative regulations, and other pertinent laws such as R. A. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 80 of 94 No. 8293 known as the “Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines” and its IRR, R. A. No. 9184 known as “Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA) of 2003” and its IRR (latest as of 2009), or as defined by the Code of Ethical Standard (CES), other Standards of Professional Practice (SPPs) and other related laws, policies, rules and regulations approved and implemented by the Commission and/or other concerned government entities. Therefore, nothing in this SPP on Professional Architectural Consulting Services (PACS) must unduly affect the said laws, policies, rules and regulations, and the CES and SPPs. 17. OBJECTIVES 17.1 By law, Professional Consulting Architects (PCAs) must first be registered and licensed Architects (RLAs). As such, the standards and parameters, to which PCAs who offer and/or make their services available, are adhered to in order to develop and nurture the competencies, credibility and integrity of PCAs in their respective fields/areas of specialization; 17.2 Scope, type and nature of professional architectural consulting services (PACS) that only RLA-PCAs shall be allowed to extend or perform for the Government, for the private sector and CSOs and for members of the international community (with projects on Philippine soil), relative to or in connection with any aspect of comprehensive development at all levels – national, regional and/or local, are defined; 17.3 Full compliance with the applicable advisories and guidelines on the slection, commissioning and engagement of foreign architects and/or foreign consultants (FCs) for projects and services on Philippine soil, promulgated and/or prescribed by the Commission and/or the Professional Regulatory Board of Architecture (PRBoA), through the integrated and accredited professional organization of Architects (IAPoA), as a measure to stimulate the local market for Filipino professional consultants (i.e. RLA-PCAs) and to protect and level the field of professional practice between and among RLAs and FAs/FCs; 17.4 Application by Filipino Architects (i.e. RLA-PCAs) of their familiarity with local physical, social (e.g. educational, health, historical and cultural), economic, business, and institutional (e.g. political, governance, administrative and legal) and environmental conditions in relation to the practice of their profession towards the attainment of a sustainable and comprehensive development; and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 81 of 94 17.5 A nurturing environment that will encourage Filipino professional consultants (i.e. RLA-PCAs) to practice, further develop and/or extend their services in the country rather than abroad, and propel them to the same level as, if not to greater heights than, their counterparts in the global market; 18. DECLARATION OF POLICY 18.1 All accredited professional organizations (APOs) are committed to abide by, advocate, and steadfastly uphold the ideals enunciated under Section 14, Article XII of the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines which states that, “The sustained development of a reservoir of national talents consisting of Filipino scientists, entrepreneurs, professionals, managers, high-level technical manpower and skilled workers and craftsmen in all fields shall be promoted by the State. The State shall encourage appropriate technology and regulate its transfer for the national benefit. The practice of all professions in the Philippines shall be limited to Filipino citizens, save in cases prescribed by law xxx”. (emphases and underscoring supplied) 18.2 It shall be mandatory upon all State-registered and licensed professionals (RLPs) such as RLAs, to strictly adhere to their respective policies and standards of professional practice (SPPs) within the framework and in support of the constitutional provision stated therein, including and most especially within the bounds of the scope of practice of each profession as defined by their respective professional regulatory laws (PRLs) such as R.A. No. 9266 and its derivative regulations. 19. DEFINITION OF TERMS 19.1 Comprehensive Development refers to the holistic and progressive growth and advancement of a community, province, region and nation inclusive of their respective economic, social, physical, environmental and institutional sectors. 19.2 Consortium or Association refers to a coalition of purely Filipino professional consultants (i.e. RLA-PCAs) or consulting firm/s (i.e. SEC- and/or PRC-registered architectural firms/ RAFs); or Filipino professional consultants (i.e. RLA-PCAs) or consulting firm/s (i.e. RAFs) in collaboration with foreign professional consultant/s and/or _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 82 of 94 foreign consulting firm/s authorized to render consulting/ consultancy services, as herein defined; in the Philippine setting, the use of the terms Consortium and Association may carry certain tax and legal implications; 19.3 Consulting Architect (FPCA), Filipino Professional (see Filipino Professional Consulting Architect or FPCA) 19.4 Consultant, Foreign (see Foreign Consultant or FC) 19.5 Consulting Architect (PCA), Professional (see Professional Consulting Architect or PCA) 19.6 Consulting Agreement means a binding covenant or understanding entered into by a professional consulting architect (PCA) and/or consulting firm (i.e. RAF only) with an Owner/ Client, whether in Government, private sector or CSO or the international community (with projects on Philippine soil), that provides such terms and conditions mutually agreed upon by the parties, under which specific work, study or joint venture requiring special or technical skills and expertise, shall be undertaken 19.7 Consulting Architectural Firm (CAF) refers to an architectural corporation, association, group or partnership duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or other concerned government regulatory agency or instrumentality or to a single proprietorship duly registered with the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), and likewise registered with the Commission/ Board to perform Stateregulated architectural services such as professional architectural consulting services (PACS) as herein defined. 19.8 Cost, Total Project (see Project Cost) 19.9 Cost, Salary (see Salary Cost) 19.10 Direct Costs or Reimbursable Expenses _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 83 of 94 refer to expenses in connection or related to the project that may include but not limited to the following: 19.10.1 living and travelling expenses of employees, partners, and principals when away from the home office on business 19.10.2 identifiable communication expenses, such as long-distance telephone, telegraph, internet, short messaging system (SMS), cable, express charge, postage, etc.; 19.10.3 services directly applicable to the contracted architectural consulting work, such as special legal and accounting expenses, computer rental and programming costs, special consultants, borings, laboratory charges, commercial printing and bindings and similar costs that are not applicable to general overhead; 19.10.4 identifiable expenses for supplies and materials charged to the project at hand, as distinguished from such supplies and expenses applicable to two or more projects; 19.10.5 Identifiable reproduction costs applicable to the work, such as blueprinting, mimeographing, printing, etc.; These also include expenses, which seldom can be determined in advance with any invoice costs, plus a service charge as may be mutually agreed upon by the professional consulting architect (PCA) and his Client, and in accordance with the Architect’s Guidelines. 19.11 Filipino Professional Consulting Architect (FPCA) refers to a Filipino citizen, a natural person who possesses the qualifications of a Filipino Professional Consultant (FPC) as hereafter defined; the FPCA must be a Philippine-registered and licensed architect (RLA) and must be a member in good standing of the IAPoA; the FPCA must also be a RLA specializing in any or several branch/es of the State-regulated profession of architecture as defined under R.A. No. 9266 and its derivative regulations; if the FPCA signs and seals architectural documents, he then becomes an Architect-of-record (Aor) for a project and thereby assumes the attendant professional responsibilities and civil liabilities consistent with the provisions under valid and subsisting laws. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 84 of 94 19.12 Foreign Consultant (FC) or Foreign Architect (FA) refers to an individual, not a citizen of the Philippines, who: 19.12.1 satisfies the definition of a Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) as hereafter provided; 19.12.2 has acquired a permit to work and/ or do business in the Philippines in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Commission Guidelines for the Registration of Foreign Professionals (Res. No. 98547); has acquired a temporary/special permit (TSP) to engage in the practice of any branch of architecture for any project on Philippine soil in full accordance with the pertinent Board Resolutions implementing Secs. 37 and 38 of R.A. No. 9266; 19.12.3 is allowed by the Department of Labor and Employment (DoLE), Bureau of Immigration and Deportation (BID) and other concerned regulatory agencies and/or instrumentalities of government to practice the State-regulated profession of architecture in the Philippines, under pertinent laws, rules and regulations; and 19.12.4 is a registered and/or licensed professional architect in his own country of origin (and/or country of residence/practice, as applicable). 19.13 Multiplier refers to a factor which compensates the Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) for the following items: 19.13.1 overhead costs of the office; 19.13.2 fringe benefits and social charges; 19.13.3 fee for contingencies; 19.13.4 interest on capital reserves; and 19.13.5 profit The “multiplier” varies according to the types of architectural consulting work, the organization and experience of the Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) and the geographic area in which his office is located. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 85 of 94 19.14 Overhead refers to the following: 19.14.1 provisions for office, light, air-conditioning, and similar items for working space; 19.14.2 depreciation allowances or rental of furniture, equipment and instruments; 19.14.3 vehicle and travel-related expenses; 19.14.4 office supplies; 19.14.5 taxes and insurances other than those included as salary cost; 19.14.6 library and periodical expenses and other means of keeping abreast with new developments and/or technologies; 19.14.7 executive, administrative, accounting, legal, stenographic, and clerical salaries and expenses, other than those that are identifiable as salaries including reimbursable non-salary expenses, plus salaries or imputed salaries of partners and principals to the extent that they perform general executive and administrative services as distinguished from technical or advisory services directly applicable to particular projects; these services and expenses, essential to the conduct of the business, includes preliminary arrangements for new projects or assignments, and interest on borrowed capital; 19.14.8 business development expenses, including salaries of principals and salary costs of employees so engaged; and 19.14.9 provision for loss of productive time of technical employees between assignments, and for time of principals and employees on public interest assignments 19.15 Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) refers to any person, whether natural or juridical, duly licensed, registered and/or duly accredited by the Commission. This also refers to a person, whether natural or juridical, duly certified/recognized by the concerned APO under the PTC or CBNE as one who possesses the appropriate knowledge _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 86 of 94 and, skills, training, and relevant experience i.e. specialization/s required to perform and/or render the service/s required; the PCA must be a Philippineregistered and licensed Architect (RLA), with a valid registration certification and Commission identification (ID) card and must be a member in good standing of the IAPoA. 19.16 Professional Organization, Accredited (APO) generally refers to any organization under the umbrellas of the CBNE and PTC; in the case of professional architectural consulting services (PACS), the term shall specifically refer to the IAPOA; 19.17 Professional Architectural Consulting Services (PACS) means the rendering by a professional consulting architect (PCA) or by a consulting firm (i.e. a RAF), of independent advice, extension of technical assistance and services, as well as undertaking of activities, requiring appropriate knowledge, skills, training and experience, recognized competence, integrity, and/or financial and logistical capability. 19.18 Project Cost means the total cost of the project which includes but is not limited to construction cost, fees for professional services, the cost of land, right-of-way (ROW), legal, administrative and other related expenses of the client. 19.19 Reimbursable Expenses (see Direct Costs) 19.20 Salary Cost means the cost of salaries (including sick leave, vacation, holiday and incentive pay applicable thereto) of professional consultants for the time directly chargeable to the projects; plus excise, and payroll taxes as well as all other imposable taxes/duties; and contributions for social security and insurance benefits. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 87 of 94 20. SCOPE OF PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL CONSULTING SERVICES (PACS) The scope of professional architectural consulting services (PACS) shall be defined and determined in accordance with the charter, by-laws, policies, rules and regulations of the Commission and the Board through the IAPOA to which a professional consulting architect (PCA) belongs as a member in good standing. It includes, but shall not be limited to the following: 20.1 program / project conceptualization and development;. 20.2 rendering of technical advice, consultation and/or counselling ; 20.3 preparation of schematic/concept-level through preliminary plans, drawings, designs and technical specifications; 20.4 teaching, lecturing, coaching, mentoring; 20.5 research and development (R&D); 20.6 documentation; 20.7 conduct of pre-investment/pre-feasibility and feasibility studies; 20.8 marketing and promotional studies; 20.9 land use and multi-sectoral development planning, development and management; 20.10 site selection, analyses, evaluation, ranking and development; 20.11 construction; 20.12 Project/ Construction Management and/or Administration; 20.13 post-construction evaluation 20.14 monitoring and evaluation; 20.15 training, capability building and Continuing Professional Education (CPE); and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 88 of 94 20.16 Capital Investment Programming 21. QUALIFICATIONS OF PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING ARCHITECTS (PCAs) A Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) must possess all of the following qualifications: 21.1 if a natural person, must be a citizen of the Philippines who is a duly registered and licensed Architect (RLA), a holder of a valid identification (ID) card-license issued by the Commission and a member in good standing of the IAPOA; 21.2 if a juridical person, a consulting firm that must be a partnership or corporation duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or a sole proprietorship that is a duly registered with the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), respectively and/or any other concerned regulatory agency/ies of government; in addition, the consulting firm must possess a valid Commission certificate to operate as a registered architectural firm (RAF) in full accordanance with R.A. No. 9266 and its derivative regulations; 21.3 Must have the minimum years of active and relevant professional training and experience in the chosen field/s of specialization as may be determined by the IAPOA and the PRBoA/ Commission; 21.4 Endorsed and certified by the IAPOA as a member in good standing; and 21.5 Has never been convicted of any criminal or administrative offense related to deliberate wrongdoing. 22. SELECTION OF PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING ARCHITECTS (PCAs) Clients shall consider the following criteria or general guidelines in the selection of Professional Consulting Architects (PCAs): 22.1 The major consideration in hiring the services of a Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) is his/her qualifications as herein provided such as competence, capabilities and integrity; 22.2 Only duly-qualified Filipino professional consulting Architects (FPCAs) shall render architectural consulting services in areas or fields of architectural _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 89 of 94 specialization performed by members of the CBNE, except where no qualified FPCA is available. Under the said circumstances, where a non-FPCA i.e. a FA or FC is engaged, a minimum of two (2) Filipino RLAs in the same area or field of architectural specialization shall be employed as understudies; and 22.3 For Government projects, the selection of PCAs shall be in accordance with the relevant provisions of R. A. No. 9184, otherwise known as the Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA) of 2003. 23. MANNER OF PROVIDING PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL CONSULTING SERVICES (PACS) A Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) may provide services directly or indirectly to the Client in the manner prescribed, suggested or promulgated by the Commission/Board through the IAPOA. 24. COMPENSATION OF PACS 24.1 The computation of the compensation of fees for professional architectural consulting services (PACS) shall depend on the type of services to be rendered and the conditions under which they are to be performed; 24.2 Compensation for PACS that require only one kind of expertise/specialization or related types of expertise shall be treated differently from those services that require the use of more than one type of expertise; 24.3 Compensation and allowances shall be comparable with foreign consulting service compensation standards; 24.4 For the same scope of work, there shall be no disparity in the compensation between Filipino professional consulting Architects (FPCAs) and their foreign consultant (FC) counterparts; 24.5 Professional Consulting Architects (PCAs) shall adhere to and be governed by the relevant provisions pertaining to compensation as provided for under the Codes of Ethical Conduct (CEC) and the other Standards of Professional Practice (SPP); 24.6 All entities, whether in the Government, private sector or CSOs and the international community (with projects on Philippine soil) shall respect and _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 90 of 94 take cognizance of said CEC and SPPs; 24.7 Compensation of a professional consulting Architect (PCA) may be computed based on one or a combination of the following methods, with modifications applicable to the types of services and/ or specific cases, if and when needed: 24.7.1 Per Diem or Hourly Basis This method is particularly suited to engagements involving intermittent personal service. When such consulting services are furnished, the Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) is compensated for all the time he devotes to the work, including travel time. The per diem charge should be based on the complexity of the work involved and the extent of his experience/specialization. In addition to the compensation based on per diem, his expenses for travel, subsistence, and other out-of-pocket expenses incurred while away from his home/office shall be reimbursed by the Client . 24.7.2 Retainer This method of remuneration is used when the services of a Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) is expected to be required at intervals over a period of time. It is a means of ensuring in advance that his services will be available to the Client when required. Under this method, a stipulated amount is paid at regular intervals for which the PCA is obligated to render a certain service or to spend a certain amount of time on Client’s requirements. The compensation is usually enough to pay for the minimum services required by the Client. All additional services are paid separately. In addition to the retainer, the PCA may be reimbursed for travel, subsistence and other out-of-pocket expenses incurred while away from his home/office. 24.7.3 Salary cost times a multiplier, plus direct cost or reimbursable expenses This method is based on the total basic salaries of all PCAs and their staff multiplied by a factor from 3.0 as a multiplier plus cost of certain items that are reimbursable to the PCA classified under “Direct Cost” _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 91 of 94 or “Reimbursable Expenses”. compute the fee: The following formula is used to Fee = Salary Cost x Multiplier + Reimbursable Expenses This method of remuneration is best suited for Projects for which the costs are difficult to pre-determine, or in cases where it may become necessary to undertake additional experimental or investigative work, the result of which may further alter the scope of the project. The method however, cannot be used as a measure of compensation for services which cannot be measured by the length of time spent on his work. The other part of the remuneration by this method is made up of the reimbursable direct costs. These costs are billed to the Client supported, if required by receipts and other documents. 24.7.4 Fixed/ Lump Sum payment This method of compensation may be used when the scope of PACS required can be clearly and fully defined. Two methods may generally be used to arrive at a lump-sum compensation for the basic PACS. These two methods are frequently used concurrently with one serving as a check on the other. a. computation of a lump-sum as an appropriate percentage of the estimated total cost of the project b. direct development of a fixed amount of compensation by estimating the individual elements of the cost outlines, plus a reasonable margin of profit, all expressed as a single lump-sum Where compensation is given on a lump-sum basis, the agreements should contain a clearly stated time limit during which the service/s will be performed, and a provision for additional compensation for extra time used. In design assignments, these should be a provision for charges required after the approval of preliminary designs, with a clear understanding as to where the final approval authority lies. _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 92 of 94 24.7.5 Percentage of total project cost The remuneration under this method is calculated as an agreed percentage of the ultimate cost of the project/service. The validity of the Percentage of Total Project Cost Method rests upon the assumption that consultancy costs vary in proportion to the total project cost regardless of the type or location of the project. Therefore, this method should be applied only where experience has established some approximate correlations between consultancy costs and project costs. 24.8 Fees for services that require inputs of an artistic, innovative and creative endeavor shall not be determined in the same manner as services that involve purely technical and scientific undertakings 24.9 Criteria for Establishing Method of Compensation The criteria for establishing method/s of compensation shall be promulgated, approved and adopted by the IAPoA. 24.10 Interest Due on Late Payment of Fees The Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) shall be entitled to interest at the prevailing rate set by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) in additional to a percentage as may be determine by the IAPOA unless otherwise mutually agreed upon by the PCA and his Client, on all fees, other charges and reimbursements due and not paid within 30 days from receipt of billing. 25. SEAL AND USE OF SEAL UNDER PACS Where applicable and in full accord with R.A. No. 9266 and its derivative regulations, a Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) shall sign and affix his professional license number and the seal duly-approved by the Commission/ PRBoA and/or the IAPOA on all architectural documents as outputs and other deliverables/materials such as, but not limited to plans, designs, technical drawings and specifications, feasibility studies as well as instruments of service, prepared by him, or under his/her direct supervision, if and only if the CA shall also act as the Architect-of-record (Aor), in which case he must assume all the attendant/pertinent professional responsibilities and civil liabilities for the project. 26. INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS FOR PACS All architectural documentary outputs and materials delivered or rendered by a professional consulting Architect (PCA), such as, but not limited to plans, designs, technical drawings and specifications, pre-feasibility and feasibility studies and other instruments of service, shall be protected under Secs. 20 (4) and 33 of R.A. No. 9266 and its 2004 IRR, whether such outputs and materials are executed or not. No person without the written consent of the professional consulting Architect _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 93 of 94 (PCA) or author of said architectural documents and/or materials shall duplicate or make copies of said documents for use in the repetition of and for other projects, whether executed partly or in its entirety. 27. PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY AND CIVIL LIABILITY FOR PACS 27.1 Any individual, partner, firm/corporation/consortium or joint ventures which engage in the practice of professional architectural consulting services (PACS) is legally responsible i.e. professionally responsible before the State and civilly liable before the State, the general public and the Client, for the conduct and performance of his/her services to their Clients, whether in the Government, private sector or civil society or then international community (with projects on Philippine soil). 27.2 Where applicable, it is imperative that a Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) secures a Professional Liability Insurance Policy, professional indemnity insurance or equivalent in bond form commensurate with the magnitude and scope of project involvement with the corresponding compensation. Such cost shall form part of the total project cost chargeable to the Client. 28. APPLICABILITY This Standard of Professional Practice (SPP) for Professional Architectural Consulting Services (PACS) shall be adopted by the IAPOA, which shall thereafter formulate the covering guidelines and Manual of Procedure (MoP). 29. ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR) In case of any dispute arising from the implementation of these IRR and related derivative regulations, the same shall be resolved by modes of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mandated under R.A. No. 9285 (the ADR Act of 2004 and its IRR) before it is referred to a competent court. The ADR modes must necessarily include negotiation, conciliation, mediation and arbitration. An ADR clause must therefore form part of all PCAS agreements. 30. PENALTY CLAUSE AND SANCTION Any individual, partner, firm/corporation/ consortium who/which engages in professional architectural consulting services (PACS), but are not qualified in accordance with the provisions prescribed by law, particularly under R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its IRR, shall be subject to sanction/s by the appropriate public or private entities, without prejudice to the filing of appropriate criminal, civil administrative or special complaints pursuant to existing laws. Nothing follows _____________________________________________________________________________ The 2010 Standards of Professional Practice (SPP) Approved 27 July 2010 as the Supplemental IRR of R.A. No. 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) 94 of 94 1.4-2010 SPP for PH Architects PROFESSIONAL REHULATOR BOARD OF ARCHITECTURE Resolution No. 03 Series of 2010 PRESCRIBING THE STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE FOR ARCHITECTS AS SUPPLEMENTAL IMPLEMENTING RULES AND REGULATIONS (IRR) OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 9266, KNOWN AS “THE ARCHITECTURAL ACT OF 2004” WHEREAS, Section 7 (g), Art. II of R.A. No. 9266, known as “The Architecture Act pf 2004”, mandates that the Professional Regulatory Board of Architecture (the “Board”) shall “Prescribe and/or adopt the Code of Ethical Conduct and Standard of Professional Practice for Registered and licensed Architect (“Architects”); WHEREAS, the Board has already adopted and promulgated the Code of Ethical Conduct through Resolution No. 02, series of 2006, leaving the matter of the Standards Professional Practice pending: WHEREAS, in mid-2004, the Integrated and Accredited Professional Organization of Architects (IAPOA), with the full assistance of the Board, embarked on an effort to update and amend/repeal the 1979 Standards of Professional Practice, which was known as “UAP Documents 201 through 208”; WHEREAS, under a separate Board Resolution, the said 1979 Standards of Professional Practice became part of the implementing rules and regulations of the repealed architecture law, R.A. No. 545, as amended by R.A. No. 1581; WHEREAS, over the last six (6) years, both the Board and the IAPOA have continued to interdependently, symbiotically, and synergistically collaborate with each other their progressive efforts to amend/repeal the 1979 Standards of Professional Practice, conducting many meetings, conferences, and broad-based consultations in the process, and culminating to the issuance of this resolution with its annex; the new/updated Standards of Professional Practice; and WHEREAS, after 31 years, there is now an urgent and important need to finally prescribe and promulgate the new/updated Standards of Professional Practice for Architects; NOW, THEREFORE; The Boards Resolves, as it is hereby Resolved, by virtue of the powers vested upon the Board to prescribe the new/updated Standards of Professional Practice for Architects as supplemental implementing rules and regulations of R.A. No. 9266 and as integral part of herein resolution as Annex “A” thereto; FURTHER, RESOLVED, that the determination of the corresponding Architect’s Fees be stated in the detail under the Architect’s Guidelines for SPP Compliances (The Architect’s Guidelines), which shall be crafted by the IAPOA, with the Board’s Assistance, and that the said Architect’s Guidelines be an official IAPOA Issuance to be observed by all IAPOS Members; FURTHERMORE, RESOLVED, that, immediately upon completion and subsequent dissemination of the said Architect’s Guidelines, the IAPOA must embark on the crafting of the Manual of Procedure for SPP Compliance (the Manual of Procedure), which shall similarly be an official IAPOA issuance to be observed by all IAPOA Members, FINALLY, RESOLVED, that this Resolution shall take effect after fifteen (15) days following the full and complete publication thereof in the Official Gazette or any major daily newspaper of national circulation in the Philippines. Done in the City of Manila, this 27th day of July 2010. Professional Practice II • Administering the Regular Services of the Architect • Architecture as a profession, ethical norms and office procedures • Designed to provide the basic understanding of the practice of architecture pertaining to the basic services the architect renders within the context of professionalism, ethical conduct and quality service delivery. The Architect (According to RA9266) The Architect and Architecture Profession An architect is a person trained in the planning, design and oversight of the construction of buildings, and licensed to practice architecture To practice architecture means to provide services in connection with the design and construction of a building, a group of buildings and the space within the site surrounding the buildings, that have human occupancy or use as their principal purpose. -Wikipedia Encyclopedia “Architect” means a person professionally and academically qualified, registered and licensed under this Act, with a Certificate of Registration and Professional Identification Card issued by the Professional Regulatory Board of Architecture and Professional Regulation Commission, and who is responsible for advocating the fair and sustainable development, welfare and cultural expression of society’s habitat in terms of space, forms, and historical context. a) b) c) “Architect-of-Record” – responsible for the total design of the project and who shall assume civil liability for the plans, specifications and contract documents he/she has signed and sealed. “Architect-in-Charge of Construction” – responsible and liable for the construction supervision of the project. “Consulting Architect” – with exceptional or recognized expertise or specialization in any branch of architecture. General Practice of Architecture The act of planning and architectural designing, structural conceptualization, specifying, supervising and giving general administration and responsible direction to the erection, enlargement or alterations of buildings and building environments and architectural design in engineering structures or any part thereof; The scientific, aesthetic and orderly coordination of all processes which enter into the production of a complete building or structure performed through the medium of unbiased preliminary studies of plans, consultation, specifications, conferences, evaluations, investigation, contract documents and oral advice and directions… Number of Registered Architects (RAs) and Registered & Licensed Architects (RLAs) as of 2011: ➢ 26,608 RAs ➢ 10, 103 RAs and RLAs (37.97%) To lawfully practice architecture in the Philippines, a RA must be an RLA. (i.e. possessing both the valid PRC Certificate of Registration and the PRC ID card) Brief History Felix Roxas y Arroyo - The first Filipino architect with an academic title to practice in the country. - Studied in London and returned in 1858 - Served as the municipal architect of Manila from 1877-1880 Escuela Practica y Profesional de Artes y Oficios de Manila - The first academic school to train maestros de Obras (master builders), 1890 Academia de Arquitectura y Agrimensura de Filipinas - the first organization for Filipino Maestro de Obras during early 1900 • 1921 – National Assembly passed a law to recognize engineers and architects. 32 architects were officially registered. Tomas Mapua – first Registered Architect • The organization changed into the Philippine Institute of Architects or PIA (post-war) • The PIA once served as the Philippine Section and founding member of the Union Internationale des Architects (International Union of Architects), the international organization for architects from 1950 until 1991 until its membership was then passed on to the United Architects of the Philippines. Important Issues & Concerns • RA 9266 prescribes that ONLY registered and licensed architects (RLAs) shall practice architecture for ALL buildings on the Philippine soil. • In May 2005, the 2004 revised IRR of NBCP (with echoed RA 9266’s requirements that only RLAs can sign and seal architectural documents) took full effect. The ARCHITECT & the LAW The Virtues of an Architect “May the Architect be high-minded; not arrogant, but faithful; just and easy to deal with or without avarice; not let his mind be occupied in receiving gifts, but let him preserve his good name with dignity...” - Marcus Vitruvius Polio The Value of an Architect (from UAP Document Architect’s National Code) • The Architect creates man’s environment through his awareness and sensitive handling of spaces that fit the scale of human experience. The resulting quality of the forming envelope manifested as a structure or building gives rise to man’s appreciation of beauty and order in his physical world. • The Architect’s deliberations determine how people will be placed in relationships with one another, how whole societies will work, play, eat, sleep, recreate, travel, worship, or in short, how people will live following their culture and national aspirations. • His objective is to bring order to man’s environment to cause it to function properly within a safe structure and healthful and to impart to the whole world a beauty and distinction that is appropriate to our time. The Spectrum of the Architect’s Services The Architect's services extend over the entire range of activities that proceed from the time the idea is conceived, transformed into sets of space/ design requirements, translated into the structure through design, building, used and become a permanent feature of the man-made environment. • The Architect's services consist of the necessary conferences, deliberations, discussions, evaluations, investigations, consultations, and advice on matters affecting the scientific, aesthetic, and orderly coordination of all the processes of safeguarding life, health, and property which enter into the production of different levels and sophistication of manmade structures and environment. • The Architect, in the process of translating abstract ideas into meaningful concrete terms, produces documents in the form of a database the report, an architectural program, a feasibility study, a market study, an appraisal report, an impact analysis report, a space organizational set-up the report, a site planning analysis, and evaluation the report, an operational programming report, building programming, and scheduling reports. • A complete and detailed documentation of construction or erection drawings prepared to consist of the architectural plans, the structural plans, the electrical plans, the plumbing/sanitary plans, the mechanical/air-conditioning plans, the civil work plans, the technical specifications, the other bid documents. • Aside from these, the Architect can prepare the post-construction management documents, the operating manual, the maintenance manual, and other forms of written and graphical documentation necessary for the effective and efficient functioning of the man-made structures and environment. An appreciation of this scope of services of the Architect will bring into focus the crucial role that the Architect assumes in the realization of abstract ideas into tangible and meaningful terms. Between abstract ideas and the physical, the world stands the Architect. Philippine Laws on the Preparation of Architectural Documents ➢RA 9266 (The Architecture Act of 2004) & its 2004 IRR ➢PD 1096 (The 1997 National Building Code of the Philippines / NBC) & its 2004 Revised IRR ➢RA 9514 (Fire Code of the Philippines) & its 2009 IRR ➢BP 344 (Law on Accessibility for Disabled Persons) & its IRR ➢RA 386 Civil Code of the Philippines 1949 Wheel of a Building Project Philippine Laws on the Preparation of Architectural Documents Article 1723 of the Civil Code o The engineer or architect who drew up the plans and specifications for the building is liable for damages if, within fifteen (15) years from the completion of the structure, the same should collapse because of a defect in those plans and specifications, or due to the defects in the Ground. o The contractor is likewise responsible for the damages if the edifice falls, within the same period, on account of defects in the construction or the use of materials of inferior quality furnished by him, or due to any violation of the terms of the contract. o If the engineer or architect supervises the construction, he shall be solidarity liable to the contractor. o Acceptance of the building, after completion, which does not imply a waiver of any action because of any defect mentioned in the preceding paragraph. o the action must be brought within ten years following the collapse of the buildings. Architectural Documents ✓Architectural documents pertain to the architect’s specifications and other outputs of an Architect, that only an Architect can consist. ➢ Vicinity Maps ➢ Site Development Plans ➢ Architectural Perspectives ➢ Architectural Floor plans ➢ Elevations ➢ Sections ➢ Ceiling plans ➢ Detailed drawings ➢ Technical specifications ➢ Cost Estimates ✓Architectural documents include architectural research documents and architectural and space programs which are sole bases for the following: ➢ Architectural specifications and estimates ➢ Architectural bid documents ➢ Periodic construction supervision reports ARCHITECT & Society Roles of Architect in the Society ✓To make sure that not the structure alone but also its physical environment can enhance the lives of all people. ✓ Relate not only to purely design and build professions but to allied professions as well, to achieve totality in the design ✓Design buildings that address social needs and attempt to resolve environmental and humanitarian problems through architecture. ✓ Must be a psychologist, sociologist, economist, artist, and engineer ✓Must take into account four basic and closely interrelated necessities: ➢ Technical requirements ➢ Use ➢ Spatial relationship ➢ Content An architect helps to build the evolution of society by physically manifesting items of culture in the form of spatial concepts where representations of culture meet the human mind in a multi-sensory locality. An architect has a physical sensory responsibility to the people who experience the constructed space while also acting as an artist and painting the picture that we call society. Why Hire an Architect? ✓Architects have a lot to offer to a changing world ✓Architects can apply their creative problem-solving skills for wider development benefits in concert with other built environment professionals. ✓ An architect must look at all scales of human interaction, understanding the smallest details to the big picture. ✓Architects take the client’s vision and give it form, explore its possibilities, raise it to new levels, and then integrate it into the building site and the community. ✓Architects bring not only design but solutions. Public Interest and Safety ✓ Architects must ensure the occupants’ health and well-being ✓ Architects should mitigate the effects of natural phenomena ✓ Architects must ensure occupants' safety in case of fire ✓ An Architect’s decisions affect public safety _____________________________________________________________________________ Professional Education and Training of an Architect The Architect’s Education Architectural education should ensure that all graduates have knowledge and ability in architectural design, including technical systems and requirements as well as consideration of health, safety, and ecological balance; that they understand the culture, intellectual, historical, social, economic, and environmental context for architecture; and that they comprehend thoroughly the architect’s role and responsibilities in society, which depend on a cultivated, analytical and creative mind. Apprenticeship and Diversified Training Practical experience / training / internship is a directed and structured activity in the practice of architecture during architectural education and / or following receipt of a professional degree but prior to registration / licensing / certification. To complement academic preparation in order to protect the public, applicants for registration / licensing / certification must integrate their formal education through practical training. Examination, Registration, & Licensure A post-baccalaureate, pre-licensure experienced of two (2) years required of graduate of architecture prior to taking the licensure examination; consisting of variation of experiences in the different phases of architectural services. Qualifications - At least 21 years of age - Filipino citizen or qualified foreigner - Good reputation and moral character - Holder of BS Architecture - Has two years of diversified experience - Not been convicted of any criminal offence involving moral turpitude Subjects of Exam Day 1 Part 1 (30%) - History of Architecture - Theory of Architecture - Architectural Practice - Theory and Principles of Planning Day 1 Part 2 (30%) - Structural Design - Building Materials and Methods of Construction - Building Utilities Day 2 (40%) - Architectural Design and Site Planning Rating GWA of 70%, with no grade lower than 50% in any given subject. - Results out in 30 days - Oath-taking required Role of Professional Bodies Architects, whether self-employed or employees, are generally controlled by a regulating body in charge of ensuring that laws, decrees, and professional standards are applied and observed by all members of the profession. In many countries, professional bodies have also been established for the advancement of architecture, for the promotion of knowledge, and to protect the public interest ensuring that their members perform to a known standard. • Professional Regulatory Commission Professional Board of Architecture (PRBoA): created under to regulate the practice & enhance the architecture profession; and the upgrading, development, and growth of architecture education. • Integrated & Accredited Professional Organization of Architects: mandated the integration of the architecture profession into one national organization. When took effect in 2004, the United Architects of the Philippines (UAP) was the existing duly accredited organization & remains so until today. Obligations: - Annual membership obligations on the Organization or Chapter accredited of UAP - Annual membership accreditation through UAP-IAPOA - Annual fee for Professional Tax Receipt (PTR) Revocation of Certificate - Signed and sealed documents not prepared or supervised by him/her - Paid extra money to secure certificate - Falsely impersonated a practitioner; practiced under fictitious name - Aided in the practice of unauthorized persons - Solicited projects by rendering services without agreements Continuing Professional Development “Continuing Professional Development” or CPD refers to a sustaining and progressive learning process that maintains, enhances, or increases the knowledge and the continuing ability of architects. RA9266 Sec. 28 requires all practicing architects shall maintain a program of continuing professional development to promote public interest and to safeguard life, health, and property Architects must devote time to maintain existing skills, broaden knowledge, and explore new areas. This is increasingly important to keep abreast with new technologies, methods of practice, and changing social and ecological conditions The IAPOA – UAP requires continuing professional development for renewal and continuation of membership. Professional Life & Ethics CODE OF ETHICAL CONDUCT • An architect acts as professional adviser to his/her client and his/her advice must be unprejudiced. • An architect also acts as the middleman between Client and Contractor and must act with entire impartiality • An architect has moral responsibilities to his/her professional associates and subordinates, to his/her contractor, to his/her manufacturers, dealers and supplier, and to the public Architect’s Responsibilities in Relation to People - Responsibilities to Public - Responsibilities to Client - Responsibilities to Contractor - Responsibilities to Manufacturers, Dealers, and Agents - Relation to Colleagues and Subordinates __________________________________________________________________________ GENERAL NOTES ON THE SELECTION OF THE ARCHITECT METHODS OF SELECTION A. Direct Selection ▪ Used when undertaking a relatively small project ▪ The client selects his Architect on the basis of: 1. Reputation 2. Personal or Business Acquaintance (Connections) 3. Recommendation of the Architect’s former Client 4. Recommendation of another Architect B. Comparative Selection ▪ May be conducted by committees representing institutions, corporations, or public agencies. ▪ The selection process involves: a. Invitation b. Pre-qualification c. Interview d. Verification e. Evaluation & Ranking f. Negotiation C. Architectural Design Competition (ADC) ▪ Used for civic or monumental projects. ▪ Advantages: a. Opportunities will be open only to all PRC-RLAs or PRC-Registered Architectural Firms (AFs) b. The Client / Committee will have a wider range of options ▪ Disadvantages: a. Process may be expensive and time-consuming b. The time and effort required may discourage qualified firms from participating METHOD OF COMPENSATION ▪ Method of Compensation will be covered by the respective types of services STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (SPP) What are the STANDARD OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE? Former UAP Documents, are part of the body laws, governing the practice of architecture in the Philippines SSP are required documents under (The Architecture Act of 2004) and its IRR, which states to adopt and promulgate such rules and regulations, Code of Ethical Conduct and Standard of Professional Practice. ❖ SPP 201 : Pre-design Services ❖ SPP 202 : Regular Design Services ❖ SPP 203 : Specialized Allied Services ❖ SPP 204a : Full Time Construction Services ❖ SPP 204b : Construction Management Services ❖ SPP 205 : Post Construction Services ❖ SPP 206 : Comprehensive Architectural Services ❖ SPP 207 : Design-Build Services ❖ SPP 208 : Architectural Design Competition ❖ SPP 209 : Professional Architectural Consulting Services SPP Doc. 201 – PRE-DESIGN SERVICES • Cover a broad line of architectural services ranging from initial problem identification to activities that would allow the Architect to initially conceptualise an array of architectural and allied solutions ✓ Consultation ✓ Pre-Feasibility Studies ✓ Feasibility Studies ✓ Site Selection and Analysis ✓ Site Utilisation and Land-Use Studies ✓ Architectural Research ✓ Architectural Programming ✓ Space Planning ✓ Space Management Studies ✓ Value Management ✓ Design Brief Preparation ✓ Promotional Services Manner of Providing Services • After the initial meeting / conversation / corresponding with the Client, the Architect must submit his proposal for pre-design services: ✓ Scope of Works ✓ Manner of Payment ✓ Owner’s Responsibilities ✓ Other Conditions of Services • The Architect can render services in any ways: ✓ Individual ✓ Architect’s Own Staff ✓ By Association, Consultations, or Networking Method of Compensation a. Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses • Based on technical hours spent and does not account for creative works • The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (manhours x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier to cover overhead and profit. The multiplier ranges from 1.5-2.5 • Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants, outof-town living and housing allowances of the consultants and the like, are all to be charged to the Client. b. Professional Fee Plus Expenses • It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. c. Lump Sum or Fixed Fee • This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paperwork and timeconsuming efforts. d. Per Diem, Honorarium Plus Reimbursable Expenses • In some cases, a client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time such as: ● Attending project-related meetings, conferences or trips; ● Conducting ocular inspection of possible project sites; and ● Conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like • Paid on a Per diem and Honorarium basis + out-of-pocket expenses. e. Mixed Methods of Compensation • This SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. • Each project should be examined to determine the most appropriate and equitable method of compensation Professional Fee • The Architect’s compensation is based on the Architect’s / AFs talents, skill, experience, imagination, and the type and level of professional services provided. • A professional service agreement between the Owner/Client and the Architect is necessary. • The architect should request a five percent (5%) acceptance fee based on the agreed PF upon signing the agreement. • Client shall make progress payments upon request of the Architect within seven (7) calendar days. SPP Doc. 202 – REGULAR DESIGN SERVICES • Applicability of this Document • Individual practice • Group practice • Foreign Architects • The works covers the various aspects of the project • It only ends when the general contractor or builder turns over the completed project to the Owner. • Phases of Services ✓ Project Definition Phase ✓ Schematic Design Phase ✓ Design Development Phase ✓ Contract Document Phase ✓ Bidding or Negotiation Phase ✓ Construction Phase 1. Project Definition Phase ✓ Consults for concepts and related requirements ✓ Gathers information ✓ Reviews owner’s space requirements ✓ Prepares initial statement of probable construction cost 2. Schematic Design Phase ✓ Evaluates project requirements ✓ Prepare schematic studies leading to a recommended solution ✓ Submit probable construction cost based on the current cost parameters 3. Design Development Phase ✓ Prepares DD documents/drawings – plans, elevations, sections, etc. ✓ Outline specification ✓ Diagrammatic layout of construction system ✓ Updated probable construction cost 4. Contract Document Phase ✓ Prepares and furnishes seven (7) sets of contract documents: a. Construction Drawings b. Specifications c. General Conditions d. Informs owner of any adjustment in probable construction cost e. Assists the owner in filling the required documents for permits 5. Bidding or Negotiation Phase ✓ Prepares bid documents ✓ Assists the Owner in establishing list of Contractors 6. Construction Phase ✓ Makes decision on all claims relating to execution of work ✓ Prepares change orders, gives written guarantees ✓ Make periodic visit to site ✓ Issues certificates to contractor MANNER OF PROVIDING SERVICES Two-ways by which the Architect may enter contract with the Owner as the Lead Professional working with other professionals in the engineering and allied professions: ▪ Detailed Architectural and Engineering Design Services (DAEDS) -Single contract between the Architect and Owner, and sub-consultancy contracts between the Architect and the other professionals working with the Architect ▪ Detailed Architectural Design Services (DADS) -Architect and the engineering and allied professionals executing separate contracts with the Owner PROJECT CLASSIFICATION Based on these groupings, the corresponding scale of charges shall be prescribed in the Architect’s Guidelines to determine the fair remuneration to the Architect. Minimum Basic Fee: 5% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 1 Buildings of the simplest utilization and character which shall include but not be limited to the following: ● Armories ● Bakeries ● Habitable Agricultural Buildings ● Freight Facilities ● Hangars ● Industrial Buildings ● Manufacturing/ Industrial Plants Other Similar utilization type buildings: ● Packaging and Processing Plants ● Parking Structures ● Printing Plants ● Public Markets ● Service Garages ● Simple Loft- Type Buildings ● Warehouses Minimum Basic Fee: 6% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 2 Buildings of moderate complexity of plan / design which shall include but not be limited to the following: ● Art Galleries ● Banks, Exchange and other Buildings Financial Institution ● Bowlodromes ● Call Centers ● Churches and Religious Facilities ● City/Town Halls & Civics Centers ● College Buildings ● Convents, Monasteries & Seminaries ● Correctional & Detention Facilities ● Dormitories ● Exhibition Halls & Display Structures ● Fire Stations ● Malls / Mall Complexes ● Motels & Apartels ● Multi-storey Apartments ● Nursing Homes ● Office Building / Office Condominium Park, Playground and Open-Air Recreational Facilities ● Residential Condominiums ● Police Stations ● Postal Facilities ● Private Clubs ● Publishing Plants ● Race Tracks ● Restaurants / Fastfood Stores ● Retail / Wholesale Stores ● Schools ● Serviced Apartments ● Shopping Centers ● Showroom / Service Centers ● Specialty Shops ● Supermarkets / Hyper-marts ● Welfare Buildings ● Mixed use Buildings ● Other buildings of similar nature or use Minimum Basic Fee: 7% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 3 Buildings of exceptional character and complexity of plan. Design which shall include but not limited to the following: ● Airports / Wet & dry ports & terminals ● Aquariums ● Breweries ● Cold storage facilities ● Convention facilities ● Gymnasiums ● Hospitals and medical buildings ● Hotels ● laboratories/ testing facilities ● Marinas and resort complexes ● Medical arts offices and clinic ● Mental institutions ● Mortuaries ● Nuclear facilities ● Observatories ● Public health centers ● Research facilities ● Stadia ● Telecommunication buildings ● Theaters and similar facilities ● Transportation facilities and systems ● Veterinary hospitals ● Other buildings of similar nature or use Minimum Basic Fee: 10% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 4 Residences (Single-detached, single-attached or duplex; row houses or shop houses), small apartment houses and townhouses Minimum Basic Fee: 12% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 5 Monumental Buildings and other facilities ● Exposition and fair buildings ● Mausoleums, memorialss and monuments ● Museums ● Specialized decorative buildings ● Buildings of similar nature or use Group 6 Projects where the plan/design and related contract documents are re-used for the repetitive construction of similar buildings without amending the drawing and the specifications Recommended Professional Fee (RPF) First (1st) Building 100 % RPF for type of Building Second (2nd) Building 50 % RPF for type of Building Third (3rd) building 40 % RPF for type of Building Fourth (4th) and succeeding buildings 30 % RPF for type of Building Group 7 Housing Project involving the construction of several residential units on a single site with the use of one (1) set of plans/ design, specifications and related documents First (1st) unit 10% of PCC From 2 to 10 units Fee for one unit plus 50% RPF for each additional unit 11 to 30 units Fee for 10 unit plus 40% RPF for each additional unit 31 to 50 units Fee for 30 unit plus 25% RPF for each additional unit 51 above Fee for 50 unit plus 15% RPF for each additional unit Minimum Basic Fee: 15% of cost for P50M or less project cost Group 8 Projects involving extensive detail such as designs for built-in components or eletnes, built-in equipment, special fittings, screens, counters, architectural interior (AI), and development planning and/or design. Minimum Basic Fee: Increased to 50% or a total of 150% of the RPF Group 9 Alterations, renovations, rehabilitations, retrofit and expansion/ additions to existing buildings belonging to group 1 to 5 Group 10 The Architect is engaged to render opinion or give advice, clarifications or explanation on technical matters pertaining to Architectural works. Minimum Basic Fee: Not less than 1K per hour Minimum Basic Fee: Not less than 5K per appearance Manner of Payment • Upon signing of the Service Agreement ✓ An amount equivalent to 5% of the agreed Professional Fee shall be paid by the Owner • Upon completion of the Schematic Design Phase ✓ The Owner shall pay the Architect a sum equal to 15%-20% of the Professional Fee • Upon completion of the Design Development Phase ✓ The Owner shall pay the Architect a sum equal to 20%-40% of the Professional Fee • Upon completion of the Contract Document Phase ✓ The Owner shall pay the Architect a sum equal to 50%-90% of the Professional Fee • Bidding and Negotiation Phase ✓ The payment to the Architect shall be adjusted so that it will amount to a sum equivalent to 90% of the Professional Fee, within 15 days after the award to the winning bidder/s • Construction Phase ✓ The remaining 10% of the Professional Fee is broken down as follows: a) 5% of Architect’s Liability under the Civil Code b) 5% for the Periodic Construction Supervision The balance of the Architect shall be paid upon completion of the work (when Certificate of Completion is issued to Contractor) Work Phase Breakdown of PF Cumulative Payments Upon signing of agreement as the mobilization component 5% of the PF 5% of the PF Upon the completion of the schematic design development services 15% of the PF 20% of the PF Upon the development of Design development services 20% of the PF 40% of the PF Upon the completion of the contract document services 50% of the PF 90% of the PF Within 15 days after the awards to the winning constructor Upon completion of the work 90% of the PF 10% of the PF 100% of the PF Sample Computation Approved Architect’s Professional Fee = Php 300,000.00 Work phase eq% payment Upon agreement (down payment) 5% Php 15,000.00 Schematic design services 20% 45,000.00 Design development phase 40% 60,000.00 Contract document phase 90% 150,000.00 retention / completion of work 100% 30,000.00 total Php 300,000.00 PP2_E_SPP 210 Recap: • SPP Docs. 200 – Code of Ethics • SPP Docs. 201 – Pre-Design Services • SPP Docs. 202 – Regular Design Services • SPP Docs. 203 – Specialized Architectural Services • SPP Docs. 204a – Full Time Construction Services • SPP Docs. 204b – Construction Management Services • SPP Docs. 205 – Post Construction Services • SPP Docs. 206 – Comprehensive • SPP Docs. 207 – Design – Build Services • SPP Docs. 208 – Architectural Design Competition • SPP Docs. 209 – Professional Consulting Services SPP Docs. 210 Criteria • The criteria for computing the Architect’s compensation should be based on mutual evaluation of the amount of the Architect’s/Architectural Firm’s talents, skill, experience, effort and time available for, and required by the project. SPP Docs. 210 The following criteria should also be considered: • Time schedule • Studies, programs, and other professional input • Client’s procedure and timing for review and approval of the Architect’s recommendations/designs • Cost administration • Probability of contingencies • Number of third parties or agencies required to be consulted. SPP Docs. 210 • SPP Docs. 210 – Methods of Compensation and Schedule of Fees 1. Percentage-based Fee a. Percentage based on Project Construction Cost b. Unit Cost Method c. Value-based Pricing/Percentage of Gross Rentals 2. Lump-sum or Fixed Fee 3. Time Basis a. Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses b. Professional Fee Plus Expenses c. Per Diem, Honorarium plus Reimbursable Expenses d. Salary cost times a multiplier, plus direct cost or reimbursable expenses. e. Per diem f. Retainer g. Mixed Methods of Compensation SPP Docs. 210 1. Percentage-based Fee a. Percentage based on Project Construction Cost • The most common worldwide • The amount of percentage is related to the size and type of the project • This method is fair to both the Client and the Architect Detailed Architectural and Engineering Design (DAEDS) • The most common type of contract for architectural and engineering design. b. Unit Cost Method • Based on cost per square meter of the project • The computed cost per area may be derived from historical data on the average construction cost per sq.m. of a similar project and using the appropriate percentage for the professional fee based on project construction cost BARE 20,000/SQM FLOOR STANDARD 30,000SQM FLOOR LUXURY 40,000 FLOOR ICONIC 60,000 FLOOR POLISHED CONCRETE WALL TILES WALL TILES TO NATURAL STONE WALL NATURAL STONES WALL CONCRETE PAINT WINDOW WINDOW IMPORTED WALL TILES TO CLADDING WINDOW CLADDING TO NATURAL STONES WINDOW MINIMAL TO STANDARD CEILING STANDARD CEILING BIGGER TO FULL WINDOW CEILING FULL TO DOUBLE GLAZED CEILING NONE/SOFFIT IS OPTIONAL GYPSUM PVC WOOD PANELING c. Value-based Pricing/Percentage of Gross Rentals • Based on the outcome of revenue, cost, and profitability result of a project engagement or based on a measurable profit on specific revenues by the Client. • Renumeration may be based on a certain percentage of gross rentals 2. Lump Sum or Fixed Fee • Used when the scope of services required can be clearly and fully defined at the outset of the project. • The Client and the Architect agree on the details of the scope of the project, schedule for design and approvals, construction schedules, and other variables • Methods: – Lump-sum as an appropriate percentage of the probable project construction cost – Fixed amount of compensation by estimating the individual elements of the cost outline 3. Time Basis • Fees which are charged on an agreed-to-hourly (man-hours) or daily (per diem) or per month rate • Useful when the services are difficult to determine in advance or they are intern in nature and often short in duration. • Typically used for the following: – Services which are not well defined - additional services – Pre-design services - for services as an expert witness – Partial services - specialist expertise (Cont.) 3. Time Basis • Time-based fees are typically used for the following: – Services which are not well defined – Pre-design services – Partial services – Additional services – For services as an expert witness – Specialist expertise or professional architectural consultancy services • Multiple of Direct Personnel Expenses – Applicable to non-creative work such as accounting, secretarial, research, data gathering, preparation of reports and the like – Based on technical hours spent and doesn’t account for creative work – The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (man-hour x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier (1.5 to 2.5) to cover overhead and profit • Professional Fee Plus Expenses – Frequently used where there is continuing relationship on a series of projects. – Establishes and agreed fixed rate or lump sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. • Per Diem, Honorarium plus Reimbursable Expenses – In some cases, a client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time – The Architect as agent of the Owner may be paid on a per diem and honorarium basis plus out-of-pocket expenses • Salary cost times a multiplier, plus direct cost or reimbursable expenses – Based on the total basic salaries (Direct Salary Expenses) of all Professional Consulting Architects (PCA) and their staff, multiplied by a factor from 3.0 as a multiplier plus reimbursable cost – Best suited for projects for which the cost are difficult to predetermine Fee = (Salary Cost x Multiplier) + Reimbursable Expenses • Per Diem or Hourly Basis – Suited to engagements involving intermittent personal services – Hourly fees are well suited for consultation services, testimony in court, or similar work involving miscellaneous personal service • Retainer – Used when the services of a PCA is expected to be required at intervals over a period; means of ensuring in advance that his services will be available to the Client when required. – The employment of Architect on this fee basis is a common practice of clients who wish to be assured to always having available services of an individual architect or architect services SPP Docs. 210 Rule IV GENERAL PROVISION Sec. 15: Collection of Professional Fee Sec. 16: Interest due on late payment of fees Sec. 17: Government Taxes on Services Sec. 18: Professional and Civil Responsibility Sec. 19: Arbitration Sec. 20: Penalty Clause and Sanction Recap: SPP Docs. 202 • Phases of Services ✓ Project Definition Phase ✓ Schematic Design Phase ✓ Design Development Phase ✓ Contract Document Phase ✓ Bidding or Negotiation Phase ✓ Construction Phase ➢Prepares and furnishes seven (7) sets of contract documents: a. Construction Drawings b. Specifications c. General Conditions d. Informs owner of any adjustment in probable construction cost e. Assists the owner in filling the required documents for permits SPP Docs. 301: GENERAL CONDITION SECTION 1: DEFINITIONS Contract Documents – consist of the following: 1. Agreement 2. General Conditions 3. Special Provisions 4. Specifications 5. Drawings Project Representative Full time construction inspector hired by owner assisting in the supervision of the work Contractor Person or firm whose proposal has been accepted & contract awarded Architect Commissioned by the owner Engineer Person so named in contract documents Sub-Contractor Having direct contact with contractor, acts on behalf of the contractor in executing any part of the contract Owner Person ordering the project execution *Agreement – contract between owner and contractor undertaking the project Advertisement / Invitation to Bid – notice or invitation issued to bidders giving information of the magnitude and extent of the project, nature, etc. Instruction to Bidders – list of instructions on preparation & conditions for award of contract *Drawings – graphical representation of work *General Conditions – printed documents stipulating procedural and administrative aspects of the contract *Special Provisions – instructions that supplement or modify drawings, specs, & general conditions of the contract *Specifications – written or printed description of work describing qualities of materials and mode of construction Supplementary Specs. – additional info issued as an addition or amendment to provisions of specifications Schedule of Materials and Finishes– outline specs enumerating type and trade names of materials used Breakdown of Work and Corresponding Values – list of work and corresponding value in materials & labor including profit and overhead allowance. Written Notice– info, advice or notification pertinent to the project Act of God / Force Majeure – catastrophes, phenomena of nature, misfortunes and accidents which human prudence cannot foresee or prevent Time Limits – duration of time allowed by the contract for project completion Local Laws – laws, ordinances, and government regulations applicable to the project Work – includes labor and materials, equipment, transportation, facilities necessary for completion of the project Furnish – purchase and / or fabricate and deliver to the jobsite Install – build in, mount in positions, connect or apply Provide – furnish and install Article 3: Drawings and Specifications • Owner shall furnish contractor 3 sets of drawings and specs for free • Drawings and models must cooperate with specs to form as part of the contract documents. Figures are to followed in preference to measurable and scale Article 4: Detailed Drawings and Instructions • Supplementary drawings and instructions shall be promptly supplied by the architect and must conform to contract documents • Contractor and architect shall prepare a schedule when detailed drawings will be required Article 5: Shop Drawings • Contractor shall prepare at his own expense and submit 2 copies of all shop drawings to the architect • Shop drawings shall represent: - Working and erection dimensions - Arrangements and sectional views - Necessary details - Kinds of materials and finishes • Shop drawings shall be dated and contain: - Name of project - Descriptive names of equipment, materials, and classified item numbers - Location at which materials or equipment are to be installed • • • Drawings shall be accompanied by a letter of transmittal containing name of project, contractor, number of drawings, tittles and other pertinent data. Contractor shall submit 3 sets of prints of shop drawings to the architect for approval. 1 copy shall be returned to the contractor with necessary corrections. Contractor is responsible for accuracy of shop drawings SECTION 2: LAWS, REGULATIONS, & SITE CONDITIONS Article 6: Laws, Regulations, & Site Conditions • Contractor shall comply with all laws and regulations governing the project. • Before bidding, the contractor must visit the site and make estimates of facilities and difficulties attending to the scope of work and its execution Article 7: Permits, Taxes and Surveys • • • • • All permits and licenses necessary shall be secured and fees paid by the contractor Contractor will secure the occupancy permit Contractor will pay taxes pertinent to construction of the project Owner is responsible for establishment of boundaries made by a licensed surveyor. Contractor shall pay the services of the surveyor when so required to confirm location of columns, piers, etc. required by the contract. SECTION 3: EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS Article 8: General • • All materials and equipment must conform to all laws governing the project. Contractor shall obtain necessary permits and pay fees covered within the period of construction Article 9: Equipment • • Architect and engineer must refer to equipment by catalogue number and name Contractor shall furnish 3 copies of complete catalogue data for every item of equipment Article 10: Materials, Fixtures, Appliances and Fittings Furnished by Contractor • • • • • • • Names of proposed manufacturers, material men and dealers shall be submitted to the architect for approval Contractor shall furnish samples specified for approval No substitution for materials be made without architect’s approval Samples for materials to be used for substitution shall be approved by architect Contractor shall submit samples for testing to the architect. Contractor shall provide space for subcontractors’ storage and work force All materials shall be applied and installed following the manufacturer’s directions. SECTION 4: PREMISE AND TEMPORARY STRUCTURE Article 14: Use of Premises Article 15: Temporary Structures • Office and Contractor’s Building • House for workers • Sanitary Fixtures and 1st Aid Station • Temporary Barricades and Guard Lights • Temporary Water, Power, and telephone Facilities • Temporary Signs • Temporary Roadways • Temporary stairs, ladders, ramps, and runways • Temporary elevators and hoists • Temporary enclosure • Temporary or trial usage • Removal of temporary structure SECTION 5: PROTECTION OF WORK & OWNER’S PROPERTY Article 16: Protection of Work and Owner’s Property • • • • The contractor shall maintain and protect owner’s property from damage Old materials of value shall be piled in areas designated by the owner or architect and are in the responsibility of the contractor Existing trees and shrubs are to be boxed and protected from damaged Damaged to trees, etc. shall be made good by the contractor at his own expense. Article 17: Protection of Adjacent Property and Existing Utilities • The contractor shall protect adjacent property and existing utilities as provided by law and contract documents at his own expense. He is liable and must pay for all damages by his acts and negligence or by his employees Article 18: Protection of Life, Work and Property Due to Emergency • In cases of emergency where a life is at stake, the contractor may have the power to act without consultation. Any compensation claimed by the contractor shall be determined by agreement or arbitration SECTION 6: LABOR, WORK AND PAYMENTS Article 19: Labor • • • The contractor must employ competent and efficient workmen The supervisor must be a licensed engineer or architect who will work personally and inspect at least once a week. The contractor shall keep a competent project engineer who will represent the contractor in his absence. Article 20: Work • • • • • • • • • • • • The contractor shall use methods and appliances necessary to complete the work within contract time The owner, architect and representatives shall have access to work for inspection. Contractor shall provide proper facilities for access and inspection Contractor shall perform any work during an emergency. Adjustment of drawings suit field conditions may be necessary during construction The owner may at any time change or alter by adding or deducting from work without invalidating the contract by stating the changes to be made in writing Architect shall have the authority to make minor changes in the work not involving extra cost Owner reserves to right to employ other persons to perform the extra work Contractor shall keep the premises free of waste materials from the accumulation of work Contractor shall complete all the work contracted in the time stated. Computation of the contract time shall commence on the 7th day from receipt of the notice to proceed. Contractor shall submit the schedule of work in CPM form or any form acceptable to the architect, indicating the approximate dates each item will be started and completed, for approval Contractor will be allowed an extension based on different reasons If failure to complete work at the said contract time, the contractor will pay the owner the liquidated damages in the amount stipulated in the contract agreement. Article 22: Payments • • • The contractor shall, within 15 days from receipt of notice to proceed, submit a complete breakdown of work and corresponding value for approval and will be used as basis for all request for payment The contractor shall submit a request for payment for work done, not more than once each month. Each request shall be computed from the work completed on all items listed in the breakdown of work, less 10% retention. 15 days upon receipt of the request for payment, the architect shall either issue a certificate of payment or withhold the request and inform the contractor in writing the reasons for withholding it. • • • • • • • • The architect may recommend withholding of payment on any of the following: o Defective work not remedied o Reasonable evidence indicating probable filing of claims o Failure of contractor to make payments to sub-contractors or for material and labor o Reasonable doubt that the contract can be completed for the balance then unpaid o Damage to another contractor The architect shall estimate the value of work using the breakdown of work. Estimates of the architect are considered final and conclusive evidence of the amount of work performed and shall be basis for the full measure of the compensation of the contractor Within 15 days from the date of approval of a request for payment and issuance of certificate of payment, the owner shall pay the amount as certified. No payments shall be made in excess of 65% of the contract price unless a notarized statement is submitted by the contractor to the effect that all bills for labor, other than current wages, and bills for materials have been paid. The contractor shall submit the following before final payment is made: o Certificate of final building occupancy o Certificate of final inspection of utilities o Original and 3 sets of prints as “as-built-drawings” of electrical, sanitary, gas, telephone, and mechanical works. o 3 copies of directory of panel boards and list of circuits o 3 copies of instructions and manual for operating fixtures and equipment o 3 copies of keying schedule o Guarantee bond equivalent to 30% of the contract priced covering a period of 1 year after the final acceptance of the work The architect shall proceed to verify the work, make estimates, certify the completion of work and accept the same The owner shall give notice of observed defects with reasonable promptness. All questions shall be decided by the architect whose decision shall be subject to arbitration The amount retained by the owner shall be released 3 months after the date of the final payment Reference: • SPP Document 210 • SPP Document 301 SPP Doc. 204a, 204b, & 205 SPP Doc. 204 A – FULL TIME SUPERVISION SERVICES • • The Architect-in-charge of construction (AICC) – directly and professionally responsible and liable for the construction supervision of the project The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) – normally recommended by the Architect and hired by the Owner Scope of Services ✓ Quality Control ✓ Evaluation of Construction Work ✓ Preparation of Daily Inspection Reports ✓ Filing of Documents Manner of Proving Services 1. As AOR and as Consulting Architect for fulltime supervision services; or 2. As the Construction Supervision Group Method of Compensation a. Percentage (%) of Project Construction Cost (PCC) • The Recommended Professional Fee (RPF) for Fulltime Construction Supervision Services is 1% to 1.5% of the Project Construction Cost (PCC) Example: Project Construction Cost: 20M Pesos 1.5% of PCC: 300,000.00 Pesos PF for the Fulltime Supervision (Separate to the Regular Design Services’ Fee) b. Multiple of Direct Personnel Expense • Based on technical hours spent and does not account for creative works • The computation is made by adding all costs of technical services (man- hours x rate) and then multiplying it by a multiplier to cover overhead and profit. The multiplier ranges from 1.5-2.5 • Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants, out-of-town living and housing allowances of the consultants and the like, are all to be charged to the Client. Formula Assume: A= Architect’s rate/hour C=Consultant’s rate/hour T= Rate per hour of Technical Staff, Inspectors and other involved in the Project M= Multiplier (1.5 to 2.5) R = Reimbursable expenses Direct Cost= AN+CN+TN Fee = Direct Cost x M Total Cost of Service charge to Client = Fee + R c. Professional Fee Plus Expenses • It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the Architect’s technical time and overhead. d. Lump Sum or Fixed Fee • This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paperwork and time-consuming efforts. e. Per Diem, Honorarium Plus Reimbursable Expenses. • In some cases, a Client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time such as: • • • Attending project-related meetings, conferences or trips; Conducting ocular inspection of possible project sites; and Conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like • Paid on a Per diem and Honorarium basis + out-of-pocket expenses. f. Mixed Methods of Compensation • This SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. • Each project should be examined to determine the most appropriate and equitable method of compensation Limitation of Authority • The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) shall not assume the responsibility of the Contractor’s project superintendent • The CSG shall not make decisions on matter that are the sole responsibility of the AOR Legal Responsibility • The CSG is responsible to the Owner only for administrative matters • Under Civil Code, the CSG may appear not to have any legal responsibility • However, a Service Contract / Agreement between the CSG and the Owner may stipulate certain professional responsibilities and civil liabilities of the CSG Qualifications Inspectors of the Construction Supervision Group must have the following: • A Bachelor of Science in Architecture degree • Extensive experience in design and building construction and must be very knowledgeable in building materials and construction detailing SPP Doc. 204 B – CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES • The Architect can serve as the Construction Manager (CM). - His training in the coordination of various specialties allows him to supervise and assure proper monitoring of all construction activities with regards to quality, workmanship, and cost. • The CM could either be: - a member of the staff of the Owner - an independent individual - a firm hired by the owner Tasks ✓ Coordination and Supervision ✓ Cost and Time Control ✓ Quality Control of Work ✓ Keeping of Records Limitation of Authority • The Architect as the CM shall not: • Involve himself directly with the work of the Contractor • Impose methods, systems or designs that will substantially affect then construction schedule and impair the design concept of the Architect Legal Responsibility • The CM is directly responsible to the Owner on all aspects of construction work: • Programming • Coordination • Quality and cost control • Time management • The CM assumes no liability in case equipment fail to function or if a portion of the building collapses: • Due to deficiencies in the plan / design • Due to the deficiencies in the manner of construction Qualifications The CM may be an individual or a firm • w/ managerial capabilities and extensive experience in the field of construction SPP Doc. 205 – POST CONSTRUCTION SERVICES • The Architect may be engaged as the Building Administrator and/or Property Manager of a commercial, industrial, residential or institutional building, facility or complex. • Building administration and management goes beyond maintenance and up keep functions • It requires the services of a multi-disciplinary professional who can perform a wide range or functions Scope of Services 1. Building and Facilities Administration 1.1 Building Maintenance 1.2 Grounds and Landscaping Supervision 1.3 Building Equipment Maintenance 1.4 Business Development and Management Manner of Proving Services The Architect may enter contract with the Owner in two possible ways: 1. As AOR and as Consulting Architect for post-construction services; or 2. As the Consulting Architect for post-construction services only Method of Compensation a. Percentage (%) of gross rentals, maintenance and security fees; and/or b. Monthly salary / fee SPP Doc. 206 – COMPREHENSIVE ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES • • It is referring to the range of professional services that covers Pre-design Services, Regular Design Services, Specialized Architectural Services, Construction Services and Post-Construction Services. The Architect is not expected to perform all the services, but to act as the agent of the Client in producing and coordinating the necessary services required by a project Scope of Services – Comprehensive Architectural Services 1. Pre-Design Services (SPP 201) a. Consultation b. Pre-Feasibility Studies c. Feasibility Studies d. Site Selection and Analysis e. Site Utilization and Land-Use Studies f. Architectural Research g. Architectural Programming h. Space Planning i. Space Management Studies j. Value Management k. Design Brief Preparation l. Promotional Services 2. Regular Design Services (SPP 202) a. Project Definition Phase b. Schematic Design Phase c. Design Development Phase d. Contract Document Phase e. Bidding or Negotiation Phase f. Construction Phase 3. Specialized Architectural Services (SPP 203) a. Architectural Interiors (AI) b. Acoustic Design c. Architectural Lighting Layout and Design d. Site Development Planning (SDP) e. Site and Physical Planning Services f. Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP) g. Historic and Cultural Heritage Conversation and Planning h. Security Evaluation and Planning i. Building Systems Design j. Facilities Maintenance Support k. Building Testing and Commissioning j. Facilities Maintenance Support k. Building Testing and Commissioning l. Building Environmental Certification m. Forensic Architecture n. Building Appraisal o. Structural Conceptualization p. Preliminary Services q. Contract Documentation and Review r. Post-Design Services s. Dispute Avoidance and Resolution t. Architectural Research Methods u. Special Building / Facility Planning and Design v. Building Components w. Management of Architectural Practices 4. Construction Services a. Fulltime Supervision Services (SPP 204-A) b. Construction Management Services (SPP 204-B) 5. Post-Construction Services (SPP 205) a. Building and Facilities Administration b. Post-Construction Evaluation Project Management (PM) • • • • When the Owner hires an Architect or a firm to coordinate the whole range of CAS, this constitutes PM. PM involves management activities over and above the normal architectural and engineering (A&E). The over-all objective is to have control over time, cost and quality relative to the construction of a project. PM complements the functions of the Architects, Engineers and Contractors in meeting the broad and complex requirements of projects. Whether individual or firm, operates as a member of an Owner-ArchitectEngineer-Contractor Team. • Each member of the team will have precedence in his own field of operations or expertise. o Architect o Engineers o Contractors o Owner o Project Manager WHAT DO THEY CARE ABOUT? ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Building is technically sound Building meets budget requirements Project delivered on time Project meets budget requirements Providing great leadership Scope of Services – Project Management (PM) 1. Pre-Construction Phase - PM should conduct regular consultations with the Owner and with the Architects and Engineers (for A&E) on all aspects of planning for the project. 2. Construction Phase - If the PM also serves as the CM to oversee time, cost and quality control during the construction of the project, he shall provide the services detailed under SPP Docs 204-A and/or 204-B. Manner of Proving Services – Comprehensive Architectural Services 1. The Architect assumes dual role of the PM and the CM, or effectively the overall coordinator whose functions are outlined under this SPP. 2. He may expand his staff by hiring the experts needed, or he may form a team consisting of professional such as but not limited to: a. Architects b. Engineers c. Market Analysis d. Accountants e. General Contractors f. Real Estate Consultants g. Sociologists h. Planners i. Bankers j. Lawyers Manner of Proving Services – Project Management (PM) • • If a PM is hired by the Owner, it may be the responsibility of the PM to either hire the CM to be paid either by him or directly by the Owner on salary or based on percentage of construction costs or to serve as the CM himself. o Fulltime Supervisor can either be a staff member of the PM or hired directly by the Owner. In the team approach, each member of the team will have precedence in his own field of operations or expertise. PROJECT ORAGANIZATION CHART Method of Compensation a. Percentage (%) of Project Construction Cost - RPF for PM is 2% to 5% of Project Construction Cost b. Multiple of Direct Personnel Expense c. Professional Fee plus Expense d. Lump Sum or Fixed Fee If the Architect as Project Manager performs Regular Design Services for the same project, he is compensated separately for these services (SPP Doc. 202) SPP Doc. 207– DESIGN – BUILD SERVICES • • It simplifies and speeds up project delivery while providing creative cost- effective solutions. The Architect renders professional services in the implementation of his design. ✓ The Architect assumes the professional responsibility and civil liability for both the design and the construction of the project. Scope of Services – Design-Build Services 1. Design-Build Services by Administration a. Project Definition Phase b. Schematic Design Phase c. Design Development Phase d. Contract Document Phase e. Construction Phase - periodic inspection and assessment Construction Phase - periodic inspection and assessment to include the following: a. Preparation of schedule of work, program and estimates of materials, labor, transportation, equipment and services as reference for the construction. b. Organization and hiring of construction personnel, designation of duties and compensations. c. Negotiation and entering contract with piecework contractors and evaluation of work accomplishments. d. Procurement of materials, tools and equipment, licenses and permits e. Authorizing and undertaking payment of accounts. f. Keeping records and books of accounts 2. Design-Build Services with Guaranteed Maximum Project Construction Cost ▪The Architect provides the Owner a guaranteed maximum project construction cost for the construction of the project. ▪The savings from the construction cost is divided equally between the Owner and the Architect. ▪ The Architect shall be liable for the excess amount but only up to the amount of his administration fee. ▪ Additional expenditures beyond the guaranteed maximum project construction costs, or to other causes not attributable to the fault of the Architect, the additional costs shall be borne by the Owner. Manner of Proving Services 1. The Architect is part of or a member of the entity constructing his design. He works in tandem with or has authorized an entity to construct his design. 2. The Architect is himself a State-licensed contractor implementing his design (or that of others). Method of Compensation ▪The manner of payment to the Architect follows the progress of construction. ▪ A revolving fund is given to the Architect beforehand and is accounted for and subject to periodic auditing by the Client ▪ The Owner shall pay for all the cost of all permits, licenses and other incidentals to the work. ▪ The Architect may appoint, subject to the Owner’s approval. Salaries of such persons are paid by the Owner and not deductible from the Architect’s fee. ▪ The method of compensation may be modified using the relevant alternatives detailed in SPP Doc. 202 SPP Doc. 208– ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN COMPETITION (ADC) OWNER - the persons or organization that undertakes or promotes an ADC with the primary objective of obtaining excellence in design for a project or for a development concept - The Owner issues the invitation to Architect to submit plans/designs in accordance with a program and finances the ADC. JURY - the people appointed by the Owner to assess the entries to the competition. - The members of the Jury are called Jurors. - They are nominated by the Owner and approved by IAPOA, to represent and voice the intention of the Owner. PROFESSIONAL ADVISOR - An Architect nominated by the Owner and approved by the IAPOA to organize the ADC on behalf of the Owner. TECHNICAL ADVISORS - Specialist personnel who may be consulted by the Jurors during the conduct of the ADC to permit them to obtain all necessary relevant information. COMPETITION SECRETARIAT - The body formed by the Owner and approved by the Professional Advisor, to assist the Professional Adviser and the Jury in the administrative conduct of the ADC. Classification of Architectural Design Competitions (ADCs) a. Project ADCs for actual Project proposed for implementation b. Ideas Competition or competition of ideas set as a design and planning exercise to elucidate a problem Copyright and Right of Ownership • The Author of any plan / design shall retain the copyright of his work. • The design awarded first prize can only be used by the Owner upon his commissioning the Author to carry out the plan/design preparation for the project. • The Owner’s right to use the ADC-generated plan/design covers one execution only. SPP DOC. 209- ARCHITECTURAL CONSULTING SERVICES The primary purpose of this SPP is to complement existing professional regulatory laws governing the practice of State-regulated profession, specifically architecture Definition of terms: Professional Consulting Architect (PCA) - Refers to any person, whether natural or juridical, duly licensed, registered and/or duly accredited by the commission - The one who possess the appropriate knowledge, skills, training and relevant experiences Professional Architectural Consulting - Means the rendering by a professional consulting architect (PCA) or by a consulting firm, or independent advice, extension of technical assistance and services, as well as undertaking of activities, requiring appropriate knowledge, skills, training and experience, recognized competence, integrity, and/ or financial and logistical capability Foreign Consultant - Refers to an individual, not a citizen of the Philippines, who satisfies the definition of a Professional Consulting (PCA) Filipino Professional Consulting Architect (FPCA) - Refers to a filipino citizen, a natural person who possesses the qualification of a filipino professional consultant (FPC) Scope of Professional Architectural Consulting Services (PACS) 1. Program/ project conceptualization and development 2. Rendering of technical advice, consultation and/ or counseling 3. Preparation of schematic/ concept-level through preliminary plans, drawings, designs and technical specifications 4. Teaching, lecturing, coaching, mentoring 5. Research and development (R&D) 6. Documentation 7. Conduct of pre=investment/ pre-feasibility studies 8. Marketing and promotional studies 9. Land use and multi-sectoral development planning, development and management 10. Site selection, analysis, evaluation, ranking and development 11. Construction 12. project/ construction management and/or administration 13. Post-construction evaluation 14. Monitoring and evaluation 15. Training, capability building and continuing professional education (CPE) 16. Capital investment programming Qualification of professional consulting architects (PACS) 1. If a natural persons: ● Must be a citizen of the Philippines, duly registered and licensed architect (RLA) ● A holder of a valid ID card ● A member in good standing of the IAPOA 2. If a juridical persons: ● A consulting firm: a partnership or corporation duly registered with SEC or sole proprietorship ● Consulting firm must possess a valid commission certificate to operate as registered architectural firm 3. Minimum years of active and relevant professional training and experience in specialization as may be determined by the IAPOA and the PRBoA 4. IAPOA member in good standing 5. Has never been convicted of any criminal or administrative offenses Manner of Proving Services -directly or indirectly to the client Compensation of PACS a. Per diem or hourly basis b. Retainer c. Salary cost times a multiplier, plus direct cost or reimbursable expenses d. fixed/ lump sum e. Percentage of total project cost SPP 201: Pre-design Services SPP 202: Regular Design Services SPP 203: Specialized Allied Services SPP 204a: Full Time Construction Services SPP 204b: Construction Management Services SPP205: Post Construction Services SPP 206: Comprehensive Architectural Services SPP 207: Design-Build Services SPP 208: Architectural Design Competition SPP 209: Professional Architectural Consulting Services SPP Doc. 203- SPECIALIZED ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES ● Time and technology have evolved to a level where this services are needed to complete, complement, or supplement the necessary work for the totality of a project ● Specialized Architectural Services deals with specific expertise for further enhancement of the architectural interior and exterior components of a project ● Design services needed within and outside the building which fall under this SPP, include but are not limited to the following: ○ Architectural Interiors ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ Acoustic Design Architectural Lighting and Design Site Development Planning Site & Physical Planning Services Comprehensive Development Plan Historical and Cultural Heritage Conservation & Planning Security Evaluation and Planning Building System Design Facilities Maintenance Support Building Testing and Commissioning Building Environmental Certification Forensic Architecture Building Appraisal Structural Conceptualization Preliminary Services Contract Documentation and Review Post-design services Disputes Avoidance and Resolution Architectural Research Method Special Building Facilities Building Components Management of Architectural Practice ● Consulting Architect (CA)- refer only to a RLA who may also a separately RLP other than architecture - May be the holder of a valid specialist certificate that may be issued by the board and/or the commission, upon due qualification of accreditation by the IAPOA 1. Architectural Interior (AI) Services - Involves the detailed planning and design of the indoor/ enclosed areas of any proposed building/ structure - Depending on the complexity of the project, AI services must be sufficiently experienced in the planning, design and detailed of AI elements Scope of services: ● Development concept through determining the size and interrelationship of interior spaces, layouting out of furnitures, movables, equipment, built-ins and fixtures ● To contribute to the physical, visual, intellectual and emotional comforts of the intended end-users Manner of Providing Services ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for AI services ● As an consulting architect for AI services only Method of Compensation ● For projects involving extensive detailing of AI components, the architect’s fee shall be a percentage of the cost of the AI work ● Payments: ○ 12-15% of cost ○ 5% as coordinator with ID ○ Preliminary 30% ○ Project Completion 20% 2. Acoustic Design Services - For projects involving extensive detailing of AI components, the Architect’s fee shall be a percentage of the cost of the AI work - Payment: ○ 12-15% of cost ○ 5% as coordinator with ID ○ Preliminary 30% Final 50% Project Completion 20% - Involves the detailed planning and design to control sound transmission for comfortability with the architectural design concept - To build an environment that answers the acoustical demands of varied activities within an enclosed space Scope of Services: ● As a specialist for acoustic design, the architect - Prepares the drawings and specification for acoustic design and treatment, sound control and reinforcement, sound absorption, reflectance, insulation, etc. - Assist the owner/ client in bidding out the work or in negotiation with a speciality contractor - Checks and approves samples of materials and equipment - Conducts final inspection of work and equipment - Assist owner/ client in evaluating the amount due to the sub-contractor Manner of providing services ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for acoustic design services ● As an consulting architect for acoustic design services only’ Method of Compensation ● Shall depend on the complexity of the works to be undertaken ● Payments: ○ 10-15% cost ○ 5% as coordinator with consultant ○ Preliminary 30% Final 50% Project Completion 20% 3. Architectural Lighting Layout and Design’ - Involves the detailed planning and design light transmission, timing and control for compatibility with the architectural design concept - To build an environment that answers the lighting demands of varied activities within and outside a building Scope of Services: ● As a specialist for lighting layout and design, the Architect: - Prepares the drawings and specification for lighting design, illumination, fixture placement, efficiency, energy considerations, etc. - Assists the owner/ client in bidding out the work or in negotiation with a speciality sub-contractor - Checks and approves sample of materials and equipment - Conducts final inspection of work and citures - Assist owner/ client in evaluating the amount due the subcontractor Manner of Providing Services ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for architectural lighting and layout design services ● As an consulting architect for architectural lighting and layout design services only Method of Compensation ● Shall depend on the complexity of the works to be undertaken 4. Site Development Planning (SDP) services - The architect is not merely concerned with the building/ structure he creates but with the grounds and surrounding space as well - Studies the existing environment in relation to the building. Structure and consequently lays out the areas/ grounds immediately surrounding the building/ structure Scope of services ● Lays out the open spaces in and around the structure such that they contribute to the totality of the project ○ Conceptualizes the entire site development plan (SDP) including the generic scope of civil works and the general scope of softscape and hardscape requirements ○ Conceptualizes the specifications for the needed civil works and utility lines ○ Assists owner/ client in bidding out the work or negotiating with landscape, waterscape, rock formation contractors, etc. Manner of providing services ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for site development planning services ● As an consulting architect for site development services only Method of Compensation ● Shall depend on the estimated cost of the civil works and landscaping works ● If the architect is certified and license as a separate RLP. and is suitably experienced, the fee shall increase correspondingly, depending on the magnitude and complexity of the work required by the project 5. Site & physical planning (inc. Master development planning, subdivision planning & urban design) services - Refers to the orderly arrangement within a piece of land or property on which vertical structures and horizontal development, open spaces and activity spaces are to be proposed - Study the human behavior and activities and must undertake an in depth study of the host site’s different components Scope of services ● The architect’s becomes the logical prime professional responsible for directing team efforts to deal with the required planning work ● Physical planning is concerned with the general quality of the settings for people and their activities, buildings and other natural and man-made phenomenon ● Environmental studies, feasibility studies, market analysis, access/ movement systems, impact analysis and others ● When the architect is commissioned to do physical planning sites, he/ she shall: - Confers with the owner/ client on project requirements and data - Examine laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations affecting the project - Prepares framework and conceptual master development plans - Prepares preliminary up to detailed master development plans - Undertakes modifications, revisions and changes - Prepares the finalized plans, reports and specifications needed - Prepares the phasing of the construction - Prepares project cost estimate based on current cost parameters Manner ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for site and physical planning services ● As an consulting architect for site and physical planning services only 6. Comprehensive Development Planning services - Based on the concept of expanded physical planning services to include other activities that necessary - Concerned with the management and use of land as well as the conservation, preservation and upgrading of the human environment Scope of Services ● Architect as an environmental planner may include the following components: ○ Physical component ○ Economic component ○ Socio-cultural component ○ Transport component ○ Legal and administrative component ● Comprehensive Development Planning (CDP)- detailed study of physical, social, economic and administrative components ● The consulting architect to do the CP shall performs the following: ○ Identifies existing land use, resources, social behavior and interaction ○ Undertakes environmental analysis, demographic analysis, and feasibility studies ○ Examines existing laws, ordinances, political/ social constrains ○ Prepares the conceptual development plans, policies, and strategies Manner of Providing Services ● As an architect-of-record and as consulting architect for comprehensive development planning services ● As an consulting architect for comprehensive development planning services only Method of Compensation ● Shall be through man-months basis 7. Historic & heritage conservation & planning - Research, assessment, recording, management, interpretation, and conservation of historical heritage 8. Security Evaluation & planning - Practice arranges and formulates methods of rating and ascertaining the value of structures or facilities 9. Building Systems Design - Practice engages in methods of producing building components in a highly engineered, efficient and cost-effective manner, particularly for residential and commercial applications 10. Facilities maintenance support - Provides the owner/ client with means and measure to ensure the proper function and maintenance of the building/ structure and site after final inspection 11. Building testing & commissioning - Recommends the systematic process of ensuring that a building/ structure’s array of systems is planned, designed, installed and tested to perform according to the design intent and building operational needs 12. Building Environment Certification - To evaluate the environmental performance of a building and to encourage market migration towards sustainable design ● The rating system for the evaluation must be: ○ Credit-based ○ Flexible ○ Consensus-based and market-driven ● The consulting architect must have much more than the basic/ sufficient knowledge of: ○ Green architecture ○ environmental/ sustainable design ○ Governing environmental laws ○ Environmental investigation process and procedure under international protocols 13. Forensic Architecture - Scientific study on the built environment’s well-being, which allows the architect to focus on the ways in which the building/ structure can best maintain itself and prolong its life in a costefficient manner 14. Building appraisal - Defined as an act or process of estimating value - Practice places value on the building/ structure condition and defects, and on its repair and maintenance, including the required improvements 15. Structural conceptualization - Practice conceives, chooses and develops the types, disposition, arrangement and proportioning of the structural elements of an architectural work, giving due considerations to safety, costeffectiveness, functionality and aesthetics 16. Preliminary Services - Have much more than the basic knowledge of site analysis, space planning and management, architectural programming, and other services under SPP Dos 201 17. Contract Documentation and Review services - Have much more than the basic knowledge of specification writing, estimation and quality survey, architectural production, architectural software, architectural support services, and contract document review 18. Post-design services (including construction services) - Have much more than the basic knowledge of pre-construction, construction, post-construction and the other services under SPP docs 2014, 206, and 207 19. Dispute avoidance & resolution - Have much more than the basic knowledge of the various modes of alternative dispute resolution (construction arbitration, mediation and conciliation, negotiation of contract administration, quality surveys, appraisals and adjustments and expert testimony 20. Architectural research methods - Have much more than the basic knowledge of research methods, philippine architecture and its history, architectural materials and finishes, building types and standards, architectural design trends, architectural writing, and architectural photography 21. Special Building/ Facility Planning & Design - Have much more than the basic knowledge of planning and design processes required for housing developments, recreational and tourism estates, health care and hospitality facilities, transportation and telecommunications facilities, business and industrial parks, economic zones and community architecture and the like 22. Building Components - Have much more than the basic knowledge of building materials and finishes, construction methodologies, building envelopes including cladding and roofings systems, architectural fenestrations and architectural hardware, fixtures and fittings 23. Management of architectural practices - Have much more than the basic knowledge of the types of architectural office operations, architectural management, accounting/ finance/ taxation/ audit, labor code, architectural marketing and project development, proposals/ negotiations/ contracts, contract administration, file management and limitations of BPO’s and knowledge process outsourcing operations General Notes: Method of Compensation for Specialized Architectural Service - Shall be through man-months and multiplied by a factor to cover other direct and indirect costs; or - Any applicable mode of determination of the architect’s fee as stated in Doc. 201. 202 and the Architect’s Guidelines OFFICE ORGANIZATION Completion of registration as an architect seems to inspire the new architect into considering a practice of his own. In many cases he may have been employed by a firm for several years, and while having been periodically promoted, may not entirely be satisfied with the prospects of his future. He may have been offered a commission to do a project on a "moonlighting" basis or the office in which he works may have passed along a small project which they could not handle for some reason. Probably everyone dreams of someday being "the boss" and young architects are no exception. In addition, the actual cash or equipment required to start an office for the practice of architecture or engineering is quite minimal. For young people, the starting of an office should not be too difficult, considering the possible workload that may be available. The young architect has, by this time, been an employee of a larger firm and should been able to observe quite a bit of the requirements. He should be familiar with most of the operations necessary for the production of contract documents. He may not be too familiar with the business end, the cash flow, or the process of finding clients. One of the biggest surprises may be the number of hours that are worked per week. As an employee he probably worked a standard 40-hour week and had vacation or sick- time leave. With a beginning practice, and perhaps for quite a while after starting, the 40-hour week will be a forfeited pleasure, and the new architect will work days, nights, and weekends to keep his office open. EXPERIENCE OR NOT General experience may be difficult to come by in the larger office, but any experience is better than none at all. Fortunately, the two years required between college graduation and possible registration allows for the gain of much experience. Some people will have been project architects in the larger offices and will have actually run jobs from client contacts and conferences, handling the design, supervising the preparation of contract documents, and all of the details of construction. Others may not have been so fortunate in having a varied background, but may have been excellent in one of perhaps two phases of the complete process. Too often this is just not enough. Quite often also, two people, working side by side or in different offices, decide to start together. If both these individuals have the same expertise or specialty the joint arrangement is almost predoomed to failure unless one or the other changes. A union of two designers quite often results in both wanting to design but neither "keeping the store open" by handling the business or production end. The same situation may result when the expertise or experience is in some other area of the business. Perhaps the best preparation for successful office where employees customarily are continually exposed to most all phases of the business. By this exposure they may develop a special interest or ability which could be most helpful. In a good many cases the person with limited experience is restless enough to try his own office, but after a few months or years find that the business 'end is not for him and returns to working for someone else. Others may team up with someone else to handle the portion of the work that they don't like or can't do. Perhaps one of the best activities in which the budding architect can engage is a quick course in business methods at a local college, if they have not previously had that opportunity. Despite the feeling that architecture is an art, it also is a business and must show a profit if the architect expects to continue a practice. 254 FIVE PRIMARY TYPES OF OFFICE ORGANIZATION 1. SINGLE PROPRIETOR The individual owner or single proprietorship type of operation is still alive and going well in many cases. The Primary advantage, of course, is that the proprietor is his own boss and can accept or reject any clients as he feels inclined. This may be good or bad. If there are enough clients with the right kind of projects, the new firm should not have much trouble. However, if the proprietor is a little particular about the type of work he does, and there isn't enough of that available, the going may be a bit more difficult. There is a con- siderable satisfaction in doing only the interesting and challenging projects, but many young offices find that some compromise is usually necessary. The disadvantages seem to outweigh the advantages. While the architect may be a good designer and like to do this part of the total work, someone must be out finding more work to keep the office alive. The same is of course true of all other phases of the project. Finances to operate the offices are available through only one source - the owner. When the architect is out of the office, too often the office is closed, with the possibility of missing important telephone calls manufacturer's representatives, or prospective clients. A small office usually does small work-perhaps better quality, but nonetheless small in size or peso value. If draftsmen are employed, there is always the problem of keeping them busy if projects are not available, and the additional lack of ability to do all phases of the project may cause some problems. Smaller offices seem to employ less experienced draftsmen, probably because salary outlay is lower, so the draftsmen may not be as thoroughly trained or able to make decisions without approval from the "boss". And certainly, if any trouble arises on a project or a court decision is given against the office, the single pro- prietor is the one who assumes the entire load-perhaps to bankruptcy. For those who like to have the entire responsibility, and can handle the financial and other aspects that go with it, single proprietorship is certainly rewarding. There is a pride in being able to feel that you, and you alone, operate a successful business doing quality work. There is also a responsibility to any employees to keep them happily employed and of course to the architect's family. The latter can be a major problems since many more hours, nights, and weekends will be used in finding work and processing it properly. Until a single-proprietor office really develops, there is usually a minimal chance that multi-million pesos projects will be offered, due strictly to office size, but as the office continues to grow this deterrent may be gradually eliminated. The principal disadvantage of the small office is the simple fact that the office is small. Work that requires more facilities than are available in this size office may go elsewhere simply because of this fact. One method that may be used is, of course, to increase the office force as occasion warrants. This means violent changes in operation and additional paper work. Joint-ventures with other offices may also be the answer, but limit the freedom experienced by the single proprietor. The fact that an office is led by a single proprietor also does not necessarily mean that it has to be small. Quite a few large offices started as a small single-owner operations, but grew by good management and still maintained the single-owner status by employing the expertise necessary. 2. THE PARTNERSHIP This form of office organization may be considered in two major styles: two or more equal active partners, or a senior or a junior partner. Each condition may also involve associates. Partnerships exist where all partners are registered architects, where partners are architect or engineers, or even where only one person is a registered architect but other partners are contractors, lawyers, or good businessman in related fields. Which is best depends greatly upon the qualifications, financial status, capabilities and interest of those concerned. The most obvious advantage of a partnership is the fact that more than one practitioner means more cash-backing more actual hands or bodies to do the work, more minds to think out the problems, and more client contacts that may be made. In a well-developed partnership, the various phases of the work are as equally divided as is possible, each responsible of the portion delegated to him. The partners may be equal by virtue of equal investments in the business, or may be unequal due to unequal investment. Regardless of the amount of investment, unless special responsibility is agreed upon, all partners are responsible for the debts of the partnership, and a contractual agreement by one partner binds all partners. Certainly without a good agreement or confidence in partners, it might be an undesirable situation at times. In a good working partnership someone needs to be the business-getter, the "front-man" someone to handle the cash flow and general business phases. Different persons need the ability to design, and to supervise the production work and field construction. Each partner could belong to a different club or service organization in order to have diverse contacts for possible business and probably should live in a different suburban area for the same reason. These things may require some adjustment but probably will benefit the partnership in the end. Now let's take a look at the possibilities of senior-junior partnership. This type of arrangement usually starts when an older, established architect begins to feel that he is working too hard, that he has a bright energetic employee, or that he would like to retire in a few years. Most often the younger partner is a long-time office employee who supposedly knows the operation of the office, complements the architect's abilities, and is "itchy" to be on his own. The senior partner is the one with the investment. Agreement regarding returns may be varied, but the senior partner will retain control. If the idea is to provide for ultimate retirement of the older partner, there may be a gradual increase in percentage for the younger partner with a corresponding decrease in the percentage for the one, until, at ultimate retirement, the office belongs to the younger. This may take a considerable period of time of course. While this is often an arrangement between only two men, there is no reason that more than one junior partner cannot be included. So partnership sounds better than most single proprietorships. The advantages are that, when properly constituted, the partners expertise complements each of the others. The financial base may be more broad and in greater depth as each partner has some money. The partners will probably live in different client contacts. And what more partners to share the required work necessary for best operation, the amount of extra work time, beyond a normal week, may be shortened. The primary disadvantage is that partners may not agree about business after an initial period of "togetherness." The one who attends meetings, play golf, has client oriented lunches, may be considered by the others as having too enjoyable a time. Unless strict control over contract signatures and cash flow is maintained, it is possible that unwelcome work situations may result. Several partners may want to work on design with no one interested in production documents or contract administration. In the senior junior partnership, the older partner may be very set in this methods, design criteria, or type of projects. He may not be interested in change and, since he has majority control, may not agree with his junior partner. A major disadvantage if full partnership is that each partner is professionally and financially responsible for any or all business actions of other partners. 3. ASSOCIATES The term associates may mean something or relatively nothing. When younger employees reach an advanced stage of value to the office, they may consider their own office. They may have skills to replace and not really want to leave. They may simply want recognition. Enter the associate status, name on the door and letterhead, with no change in financial situation, or office responsibility may be the answer. If this arrangement continued, an additional raise in pay or a part of the profits may result. In larger firms there may be quite as many associates as numbers of partners. Associates firm members expect to ultimately become partners and usually do or they use that status symbol to negotiate for a better situation elsewhere. Generally speaking, however, the office gets the better of the deal as the associate feels a greater responsibility since he is now a part of management and perhaps someday may become a partner. As a result he often takes on additional responsibility and works more diligently. It's not really bad for the employee either since it inflates his ego and indicates to the public that his firm considers him a cut above some others in the office by such recognition. Some firms avoid the word associate but create directors of this or that, which usually amounts to the same as associate. 4. THE CORPORATION In many cities a corporation may be formed by architects. Simply explained, the corporation is a theoretical employer organization and all members (stockholders) are employees with financial responsibility limited by the amount of their investment. When a partnership becomes so large or unwieldy that efficient operation becomes difficult, the partners may decide that a corporation type office with its benefits, would be very interesting. A corporation is formed by obtaining approval of articles of incorporation, a charter from the city, establishing a board of directors, and electing a slate of controlling officers. A stock issue is provided and may be common stock or preferred stock, the latter having priority or preference when dividends are declared. Stock may have an initial par value or no value and the investors either buy shares, or acquire them by their monetary interest in the of- fice. This cash inflow provides the starting finances for the corporation. The board of directors and elected officers are responsible for the efficient operation of the corporation and all persons work for the corporation as employees and receives a salary, plus stock dividends, plus a bonus, if profits are more than those expected. Market value of stock fluctuates up or down from issue price depending upon amount of dividend or other indications of profitable operation and may or may not be indicated in stock market quotations. Financial and size advantages are more rather obvious. With a greater number of stockholders there is more money with which to work. As a large organization, it is possible to have more employees and more or bigger work. Diversification of skills or abilities is also more possible. Departmentalization may also result, again bringing larger and more varied types of projects. Proper business methods may bring a good return on any investment. All of this larger work, larger office, and less personal in-office contact may lead to a feeling of "factory workers and stifled ambitious younger people. With a larger group of principals it generally works out that individuals develop considerable personal skills in a particular area rather than improving over the entire field, and while some people do not object to a human boss they do not like to be supervised by a corporation. Bigness as related to a corporation, has its advantage and its disadvantage. From the standpoint of the client, the large corporate office generally has the advantage of being able to provide expert knowledge in a number of fields, a client wishing to build a special manufacturing plant probably will have better results with a large office with specialized interests, and most such offices are organized a corporations. From the standpoint of the employee, exposure in a large corporate office will give him a much different feel for projects than is generally possible in a smaller office. This may be good or bad depending upon the individual. A by-product of a large corporate office may be the better understanding of business as it relates to the design professions. 257 5. JOINT-VENTURES AND OTHERS Regardless of the basic structure of a professional office, there are times when it may become expedient to combine offices or reorganize to better advantage. When several small offices feel that it may be advantageous to combine forces they may joint-venture the same as many other groups. This usually results in a form of partnership since each office functions as an individual, so joint-venture is to continue for a rather extended period of time, a corporation agreement may be best for the participants. Sooner or later most architectural offices consider inclusion of full services (structural, mechanical, and electrical) within their organization. Depending upon the amount or work in these specialized fields, this may be an advantage, but in many cases the amount of architectural work is far greater than the engineering work. This immediately poses the question of separate but interlocked offices, one for architecture, and another for engineering. In most of such cases the corporation form or limited partnership is more desirable. The developer has appeared on the construction scene in the past few years. This is usually a corporation-type organization or a conglomerate of several corporations. Unlike the architectural office or that of the consulting engineer, the developer office includes real estate purchase (and possible resale of raw land), development of plans, construction of buildings, roads, and other facilities, sales, and perhaps management. Any one of these activities could "go sour", even with the most expert advice, so participants need to protect themselves as well as the interlocked activities. When we consider formation of an architectural office we normally consider only registered architects. There are many other combinations that may be considered, however, present day development and construction practices indicate the serious con- sideration should be given to association in one form or another with contractors, land developers, or others in near-related fields. The old taboo on architects also operating as contractors for the same client has been removed. Assistance in profitable development of vacant land or urban reconstruction is also a possibility. Project management in cooperation with other businessman is an area of increasing interest. Most city laws relating to use of the title "Architect", in any of these associations require that a clear indication be made as to exactly who is the architect. Where architect-engineer combinations are arranged, each professional must usually sign or take responsibility for the entire project. Each type of arrangement should be carefully investigated before starting a new office and the one which seems to present the most advantages and fewest disadvantages considered. OFFICE LOCATION One of the first questions that arises in starting any type of business is the one of location. This is as true for the prospective A/E office as any other. There are a number of major issues that influence the consideration of locations; some that are made or controlled by the proprietor, and some that are by-product of the society in which we live and work. In this chapter we will con- sider the major reasons involved but since every case, and every location has advantages or disadvantages the owner must evaluate them himself. What will be acceptable or satisfactory in one case, may not be in another. Size of the office, type of work done, convenience of access, parking, services, as well as rent and utility costs, all contribute to consideration of any location. 1. BEFORE Most every architect or engineer, ready to open his own office has work in another office before feeling the urge to be on his own. While working in that other office he must also have had some feeling in regard to the location, its availability to clients, proximity to supply sources, parking facilities, cost per square meter of space, utilization, and many other factors. A great many times actual cost information may not be available, but physical size, parking, and other conditions directly related to personal employment may provide some ideas. In addition, the budding architect probably has visited other offices on one occasion or another and can mentally note items that he thinks are advantageous or disadvantageous. He undoubtedly knows other people in other offices and obtains some "feed- back" when they discuss a new feature in their offices or "gripe" about some conditions that they feel, could be battered. Every draftsman has his own ideas of the relationship between his drafting table and layout space, amount of drawer or shelf space desired, lighting conditions, convenience of various office services, and the desirability of conference rooms, library, print room, and clerical area. These bits and pieces of stored information plus good common senses will go a long way in helping the new architects to select a good location. 2. THE "AT HOME" OFFICE Before we consider the separate office, perhaps just a few words in regard to the at home office may be in order. Many young architects "moonlight" after office hours, using a space room as an office. This may be a temporary expendiency to make a little extra money, but as a starting point for a full-blown business it is not very good. First, the dwelling is a residence used to bring up a family, with all of the children, the TV, the telephone ringing, cooking. Those distractions are not conducive to architectural thinking or creative work. Very few manufacturer's representatives will call at a residential address, so probably the architect will not be able to build up a library or perhaps even know the representatives. There may be some clients who will not object to coming to the "office" in the rear bedroom at a residence, but a great many more will probably not be enthusiastic about it. And even if all of these reasons may not be sufficient, city regulations and business license rules may prevent this type of operation. Judgment of appropriate costs is also a big factor in the home office. Telephone companies questions the use of a residential phone indicated as a business phone and the rates for use are considerably different. The Internal Revenue Service may make some embarrassing inquiries about rent, utilities, and other items charged off a residence as business. Most residences are not on main streets or may not be a neighborhood easy to find, so additional searching for addresses may be an inconvenience. All-in-all, the residential or "at home office is not the best solution and may tend to create a negative feeling that a separate office does not. 3. SPACE REQUIREMENTS If we can then consider other arrangement than the family residence, we first should try to determine the floor space desirably. Rented areas will have a direct relationship upon the number of people that are expected to occupy it. Depending upon the physical arrangement of the drafting table and layout board, the average space is two by three meters: six square meters. Additional space for circulation, conference, storage, and other desirable areas brings this up to approximately 15 square meters per person. A recent survey indicated that about one-half the total floor area is devoted to administration: about 20% to production, 12% to storage, and 10% to service. With a minimum-sized office these figure do not mean much, however, a 55 to 60 square meters are minimum for a one- man office and about 100 square meters for the average office of seven or eight persons. The area requirements may vary but their functions may be divided into the following groups: Administration Reception area and waiting room. Principal's office Conference room. (Room for at least a six-person conference) Secretarial space, bookkeeping. Production Area Drafting space, project managers Office space for specifications, engineers. Model making space (Optional) Library and sample room. Estimating (Optional) Storage area. Dead project storage. Correspondence storage. Vault (Optional) Service. Toilet area. Janitor Staff lounge (Optional) Items followed by (Optional) may not be needed in the smaller office or may be in combination with other spaces. In the larger offices, separation office accomplishes the division by simply defining the areas in a great many cases. Careful consideration in regard to noise and traffic is essential. Clerical work sets up a chatter from typewriters; reproduction equipment is often noisy but doesn't generate a uniform background sound; telephones and related conversations are distracting; and the simple passage of people causes an undesirable pause in the work schedule. Certain background sound may be desirable, however. Radio or piped music, playing at low volume and without news breaks, tends to aid in working pleasures. Even steady outside. traffic noises are not distracting. In trying to layout the office, however, it may be necessary to fully consider separation of noise sources in order to have best operation. Another item that may want to be considered when planning for required space is the attitude toward the client. Some offices have no objection to the client wandering into the production drafting area ''to see what you're doing on my project. This could be an embarrassment if the production crew is not working on the particular client's work and usually disrupts the draftsman's train of concentration. Physical space may be such that the addition of the client's body prevents desired circulation or interferes with other draftsmen. A majority of offices prefer that the client does not circulate in the drafting room but instead all reviews of documents are made in an office or conference room. 4. YOUR OFFICE One of the most influential public relations devices that an architect can have is an office that reflects his interest and feeling toward certain types of architecture or materials. Clients form an opinion of the ability of the architect from his surroundings and often even select an idea due to those office and quite often this is achieved by his arrangement and decoration of it. Employees also react to this. A warm atmosphere that reflects the interest in a project. In most cases the architect will have generated a particular channel or design concept that he likes, and this should be a major factor in selection of new office location. 5. THE CITY LOCATION Location in a downtown area has a number of advantages for a new office, as well as a number of disadvantages that should also be considered. If the past employment has been in a city location, a natural tendency may be to consider a downtown location as being the best for the new office. Some idea of available space and cost may be available from the old office. At any rate, the square meter cost will, in all probability, be higher than in most other areas. Another readily apparent consideration will be availability and cost of parking, both for office personnel and clients. Does parking space come with the office lease covered, or an open lot? All of these questions need good answers to be used to advantage. How about proximity for supplies? Are suppliers and blueprinting firms near? And of course there is the question of the client. If the new office expects to be doing a great of residential work perhaps city location will not be so advantageous to clients as one located out of the business district. On the other hand, many industrial and commercial clients will have their office in business districts. With some types of clients the office location will not matter, since the architect will go to them for conferences and discussions. There is a certain amount of prestige connected with a downtown office, also. People who have offices in the central business district are expected to somehow have better offices, better knowledge, better employees, better projects, and to do a better job overall. Mere location cannot and does not provide automatic skill, but the location may provide better clients. Larger offices tend to have larger projects, which in turn attracts better employees and probably better expertise in many areas. These accumulated factors do not in themselves make a better office but location just may be a help. 6. THE SUBURBAN LOCATION A suburban location doesn't mean that the office is "out in the sticks." It is true that it isn't downtown but most cities have shopping centers or neighborhood business districts that may be very suitable for location of an architectural office, so let's consider a few reasons for such a move. To do this, perhaps we can parallel some of the reasons for a city location. In a neighborhood business district, there are often fairsized office buildings as well as many smaller one. Due to the location away from the central business district, rental rates are generally lower and there are more spaces available. There may also be a better selection of related business tenants such as contractors, real estate offices, engineers, or others who may be of some assistance. And the fact that the location is away from the crowded areas also means that more, and perhaps less expensive, parking will also be available. Quite often this parking is very convenient and at no additional cost to office personnel or clients. Suburban business districts usually have stores able to pro- vide office supplies and if a blueprinting firm is not in the immediate area, they may often have delivery service. As far as the client is concerned, a great deal depends upon the type of business expected. A Suburban location may relate better to residential work and clients may be less reluctant to come into a less busy area. It office client-prospects are not close by, or if they are of the type where the architect meets them in their own offices, the location of the architects' office is of little consequence. In an earlier paragraph, reference was made to related-business tenants in the same building. In a good many cases clients of real-estate firms may be referred to architects by them. This also holds true for contractors, engineers, and others. An additional advantage may be that the office may be nearer the architect's home and that of his employees, thereby shortening driving time and freeway traffic. Office prestige may also be achieved in this type of location but perhaps by a different route. Smaller or separated office buildings provide an opportunity to redesign some structures to more advantageously display the office ability. In many areas there are vacant lots upon which an office may be built. Also in some areas, the gradual changeover from residential houses that may be remodeled into interesting office space. In these cases, the public may have the opportunity to judge the ability and evaluate prestige by the exterior appearance of the office. Many interesting projects may come to the suburban office that the big downtown office doesn't even hear about or isn't organize to handle properly. Personnel may be a little different because in many cases the employees are more interested in "doing everything" in a smaller office. 7. THE SMALL TOWN OFFICE With all of the crowing, higher costs, ecological problems, and inconveniences of the city, a great many people, including architects, are leaving the urban sprawl for the smaller towns. Such move may change the entire picture. Office space may again be more reasonable, but may also be less available, particularly space that reflects previous architecture. If the architect is fairly confident of success in his move he may want to design and build perhaps even with a rental space or two. Such action would allow him to demonstrate his design concepts and show the people what can he do. His residence will also be nearer the office. Parking nearby is usually readily available and at low cost or perhaps free. Supplies may be a bit of a problem, particularly reproduction work so some additional expense for duplicating equipment may be necessary and supply may have to be ordered in larger quantities. An entirely different approach for clients may be developed. A move to a smaller town most often means that any earlier contacts probably are lost. Local clientele will develop as the architect takes part in the community activities, and demonstrate his ability in the design of his own office or building. Practice may include considerable work of a residential nature, some commercial work of smaller size, a bit of governmental work, and con- siderable promotional work. This promotional work includes reworking of run-down areas, new or remodeling work, retail stores, and occasional school bond-determined work. Chances to be selected for the multi-million dollar new industrial plant will be very remote as this work will go to the city firm nearest the industrial owner. All of this change may have a nonapparent factor in reducing tension, providing a more relaxed work atmosphere, and a smaller office staff. After a session in a big office such change may be very desirable. 8. THE RURAL OFFICE The strictly rural location is really not very practical for a full-time architectural office, and even less so far a consulting engineer's office. Office spaces as such may be nonexistent, so remodeled barns or addition to residences may be the answer. Again such design and construction may be regarded as a demonstration of ability. Parking will usually be plentiful and free. Supplies must be carefully purchased in quantity, and duplicating equipment must be a part of office furnishings. In general, the work coming into the office will be small and probably infrequent. A few locations may provide desirable work in cooperation with large land development, but the strictly rural office must be considered as a part-time operation in most cases. 9. COMPARISON Now that we have investigated the various general areas in which an office may be focated, let us look at a closer comparison of them. The ratings may differ in different parts of the country, but the general idea will remain about the same. From a casual review of the accompanying chart, it would seem that the city office has all of the advan- tages. For the large office. 262 Space available Rental Cost Parking Transportation City Good High Good Good Suburban Good Medium Good Fair Small Town Fair Low Fair Strictly Local Rural Poor Very Low ---None Mfg. reps. Supplies Duplicating service Residential clients Indust./Comm. Clients Governmental clients Good Good Good Poor Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair Poor Fair Poor Poor Poor Poor None Fair Very Poor Very Poor This certainly is true, but for the beginning smaller office the suburban-type location may be more desirable. Again the individual preference for surroundings must be considered when the office personnel is limited to two or three or even a one-man office. In these cases some very successful operations are carried on in small town situations and even a few in rural areas. 10. PERSONAL PREFERENCE Despite any comparison of locations or other considerations, the location of an office depends a great deal upon the individual. Each person has some feeling toward the type or work he would like to do and this in turn influences location. After working in a city office, many young architects want to get away from the hustle and bustle when they get on their own. This means that they will migrate to the suburbs or smaller towns. On the other hand, some people like the feeling of being in the mainstream of city business or have some initial project which is best processed in a downtown location. A similar preference seems to be a prevalent in suburban and small-town offices. People who have put in an in- ternship in office in these locations often have done so to avoid the rigors of the city, and have a tendency to try to continue in a similar area. As in most everything else, there is no stock answer best locations. 11. THE OTHER CITY Up to now we have only considered relocation in a definite area in which the architect may have already been working, but what about new city? Occasionally the old location, city- wise, may not seem to present the best opportunities for a new office. This i a big step since, in most cases, it means practically starting over. The architect loses all previous contacts, both with prospective clients and with contractors, suppliers and even manufacturers' representatives. A good review of construction starts, possible future pro- jects, the existing competition or any new offices, supply of qualified personnel, and many other things, including additional finance arrangements, needs to be made. A leisurely survey of the proposed new area should be made and if possible congenial contacts formed with some of the firms operating in the area. Another important factor may be search for proper housing, markets, schools, and other living facilities. Supply, or lack of such facilities, may indicate some prospective clients overlooked by the local firms who have taken existing conditions in stride without thinking about them. In any case, change to another city is a major step and should be thoroughly considered in all of its aspects. 12. YOUR OWN BUILDING Perhaps not strictly a location, but certainly closely related to location and definitely influenced by location, is the question of the A/E's own building. Sooner or later the question of rent, lease, or ownership arise and the A/E must determine in which he is most interested for the present as well as the future. If the general location is right, the next question is to buy and remodel an existing building, or to design and build a new building from scratch. Existing buildings may not be properly arranged for the use intended, and may require considerable time and money to rearrange. They may be obsolete also in regard to code requirements for plumbing and electrical fixtures, or may be structurally unsound. Remodeling work on old houses can be risky but if a good results, it can also be one of the best advertisements or public relations items possible. A new building is really a challenge. The A/E is not only designing a project which must be within the budget but must function 100% for its intended operation and must be esthetically pleasing to the public. The shape, material, and appearance of the city will generally indicate some favoritism by the A/E in one way or another. If this appearance is pleasing to the general public, it is likely that business may be a bit easier to obtain. If the building is outstanding either as a great building or as a monstrosity, the public will also know about it and will have varied opinions. In a number of cases an A/E may determine to build his own office, plus rental space, to help carry the load. Under these circumstances, it is probably a good ideas to plan for related organizations such as realtors, insurance or engineering firms, and to keep in mind the possibility of future expansion. Your own building is a major investment and a visible advertisement that should be carefully considered from all angles. OFFICE PERSONNEL Large office have some of the same problems regarding the personnel required. Each must have a leader or manager, and a number of others to produce the work. Not all offices have the same titles for their employees, and not all with the same titles have the same job. A great deal depends upon the size of the office which in turn depends upon the clientele of the office. In the next few pages let us consider the position, education required, responsibilities, and relative remuneration, for the several possible positions. Positions are not necessarily listed in the order of importance in an office as we shall see later. As an example, we must consider the positions in an office of perhaps twentyfive persons. In the smaller office many of the positions may be combined or nonexistent. In the very large offices there may be a number of persons with the same titles and the same responsibilities. From a salary position the Architect is, or at least should be, the top of the pile. The project manager, specifications writer, chief designer, and contract administrator are next in line with approximately the same salary expectations. The titles of other positions, plus the chart in this chapter, indicate the relationship of the remainder. 1. THE ARCHITECT - ENGINEER The architect-engineer is usually the boss. He is normally college educated in the field of architecture and registered by examination in the country in which his office does business. He has at least four or five years experience in other offices, and may have been in his own office for many years. He has the ability to meet and talk to clients as well as others in the community, and probably belongs to one or more clubs, primarily for possible client contacts. Despite the fact that he is essentially a businessman, he knows his profession and can probably "double" in any position in the office. Although most of the principals in an office have had a formal education in their particular field, there still seem to be quite a few whose formal education may have been in a related field. A number of architects have education in planning, construction management, industrial science, and a few in chemistry or other sciences. The same is true of engineers. There are also quite a few "mustangs", people who have little formal education but years of experience, who have taken and passed the registration examination. Additionally, some have multiple degrees in design, business administration, and an increasing number have law degrees. While the architectural or engineering graduate usually starts out in his chosen field, it is certainly an advantage to have additional education or experience in a business field when the principal becomes involved in the management or administration of an office. In partnerships or corporations organizations, there may be many combinations or expertise included in the abilities of the principals. Not all architects are good designers or good production people. In these situation it may be very advisable to have persons in charge of design, production or field work, as well as business or office management. What is interesting and challenging to one person may not have the same appeal for another, and a good combination may spell the success of the office. The actual arrangement of duties also other office personnel to know who is the boss in certain areas and this is particularly important for smooth office operation. 2. PROJECT MANAGER A person with experience in all aspects of architecture and engineering and project management, the project manager may be registered as an architect or engineer, or it may be simply a title, to forestall any question of registration. Experience is relative, but would probably be in the area of five to twenty years in various positions. He manages the total project, and typical responsibilities normally include: obtaining and analyzing client requirements, establishing concepts for structural, mechanical and electrical systems, developing design concepts, checking project development against budgeted time, representing the client at public hearings and/or governmental agencies, and the general supervision of progress of the entire project. He may be a partner or associate in the firm. In a larger offices, the project manager handles almost all of the phases of a project after the owner-architect contract is signed. In most cases the project manager, then, is the leader of a team composed of design, production, and field personnel and directs all consultants who may be needed. In some cases the project manager may even "sit-in" on these contract negotiations. Under his supervision the schematics are prepared, preliminary documents and design concepts are produced, and, after client approvals, all of the construction documents (drawings, cost estimates, and specifications) are provided. Also under his general supervision, the bidding procedure is carried out and all of the field observation. A possible ego-building item is the fact that, in addition to the office name, the name of the project manager is often also prominently displayed on job signs and in project promotion items in newspapers or magazines. 3. JOB CAPTAIN The job captain may or may not exist in many offices. In the smaller offices this position may roughly correspond to that of project manager while in larger offices he is an assistant to the project manager. As an assistant to the project manager, the duties of the job captain are primarily concerned with the production of the working drawings. While the project manager handles the general affairs to a project, the job captains plans the sheet arrangement, assigns the various forms of drafting to the crew, helps coordination with consultants, and compiles notes and other information for the specifications department. In some offices he may be termed a chief draftsman although his position is more than. that of a lead draftsman. As with many others in an A/E office, the education of the job captain may be formal or based upon years of experience and he may or may not be registered. 4. SENIOR DRAFTSMAN A person with substantial knowledge and experience or in younger men, a college graduate, may be a senior draftsman, but older men may be from the school of hard knocks." Usually this person has at least eight to ten years experience. Major responsibility for him is in coordinating details and dimensions: checking working drawings for omissions or conflicts prior to bid time; checking for code compliance; controlling design continuity in detailing; and in smaller offices he does major drafting such as floor plans and elevations. In architectural offices this person is fully capable of interpreting any sketches from the design department completely through the finished drawing stage. The designer seldom sketches all door or window details, roof flashings, railing details, and similar parts. The senior draftsman is able to select proper details or draw them from experience. In a similar manner, the senior draftsman in an engineering office should be capable of also detailing structure; connections, piping layouts, electrical circuits, and other required details. With proper experience many senior draftsman in architectural offices are also capable of doing a limited amount of engineering drafting from rough sketches by the engineer. His experience also makes him a good advisor and supervisor for less qualified or younger draftsmen in the crew. 5. INTERMEDIATE DRAFTSMEN Education for an intermediate draftsman probably includes graduation from a college of architecture or engineering plus three to five years of progressive experience. If not already registered this employee may be nearly ready for the final examination for registration. With less experience than the senior draftsmen, the intermediate draftsman prepares working drawings, coordinates details with plans or elevations, and works with the senior draftsman. In some cases the intermediate draftsman is proficient in executing presentation drawings, graphics, or renderings. 6. BEGINNING DRAFTSMAN A person with limited experience in architectural drafting, normally less than two years experience, and without a degree in architecture, is a beginning draftsman. He helps to prepare working drawings, helps prepare presentation drawings, does more correcting of drawings under supervision of others, and traces details. In small offices he may replace a trainee in this work. 7. TRAINEE With little or no architectural education or experience beyond high school, a trainee often starts as the blueprint machine operator. In addition, he files drawings, delivers office material and drawings, and is generally "handy" around the office. He may do some basic drawings or tracing of details with supervision. 8. CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATOR With a major position in the firms, the construction administrator should have a total knowledge of construction methods, codes and contracts. He may be a graduate of college with a degree in architecture, construction engineering, construction management, or may have come from the ranks of construction superintendents. His responsibility includes actual administration of all projects under construction, periodic inspections of the onsite work, review and decision on shop drawings, communication with the contractor regarding change orders and payment requests, some contact with manufacturers representatives regarding proper materials and supervision of field inspectors in larger offices. This individual may also act as the checker of contracts, plus the fact that he has not worked on the drawings or specifications, makes it easier for him to spot errors or omis- sions. He is also a ready source for information regarding qualification or ability of general contractors and subcontractors and by his field contacts usually knows about availability of materials. In small offices this position may be filled by the principal, and in other offices it may be a combination with the project manager spot. 9. SPECIFICATIONS WRITER The specifications writer must have substantial knowledge of the use of materials and construction methods and may or may not be registered as an architect or engineer. Responsibilities include preparation of preliminary and final specifications, checking working drawings for compliance with specifications, evaluating and recommending new materials and construction methods, dealing with manufacturer's representatives, and advising other office personnel on materials or methods. This person may also be in general charge of the library and sample room. Great literary ability is not a requirements but the "spec" writer must be able to clearly and concisely describe materials and methods to be used in the project. Sound knowledge of actual construction methods is a must, and with a bit of experience a better-than- average idea of labor and union procedures will become second nature. The "spec" writer will be a major office contact for most manufacturer's representatives and must have, or develop, the ability to compare equal products to determine if they are indeed essentially equal. Through his constant contact with producers, the "spec" writer is in a good posi- tion also to advise the designer in regard to availability of materials and their relative costs. Many designers do not consider this possible help, and costly revision of design sometimes results due to poorly selected materials or difficult and expensive installation methods. 10. THE DESIGNER Location of the designer in this discussion order does not imply that the designer holds a less important position than others in the office. In fact, this position is one of the most important and quite often is held by one of the principals of the office. College education is normal, and registration may or may not be coincidental but is not mandatory. The designer is responsible for the layout and appearance factors of the project and works with the project manager to provide proper facilities for the client. Work includes preparation of schematics, preliminary layouts, renderings, and sometimes interiors or special phases of the work. In an engineering office, the designer works out the system to be used, makes the major calculations required, and roughsout diagrammatic sketches to be further developed by the draftsmen. While the percentage of the design personnel in an office is quite small, 3% to 5% of all projects begin here. Those covered by the designer is not simply to provide a pretty picture, as is quite often suggested, but to carefully and accurately plan the work in accordance with applicable code requirements and the client's needs. Most designers are not completely trained. adept, or interested in structural or other engineering systems, and may be limited in their knowledge of materials available. Once the basic idea has materialized into some form, experts in the engineering and materials field should be used to redesign any portions that may be impossible to provide or that may be excessively expensive and will exceed the project budget. If a project cannot be constructed within the budget, the design stage is a good place to start revising or even stopping. 11. LIBRARIAN The librarian does not formally exist in most offices with less than fifty to seventy-five employers, but is very important when an extensive library has been acquired and a large drafting force is continually using reference material. In smaller offices, the "library" is often scattered throughout the office in several different bookcases and most employees know the general whereabouts of specific material or will ask a fellow employee. The A/E librarian does not have formal library training. In fact such training may be a detriment. Filing and retrieval of A/E reference consists almost entirely of arranging catalogs and other material in proper areas (preferably in the sixteen Divisions of the Uniform System) and in dating and updating new materials. A simple check-out system helps keep track of references and a limited ability to type is helpful in writing to manufacturers for literature. Some prior exposure to building products via manufacturer, distributor, or contractor is helpful. The librarian's position, in a number of cases, has been the starting spot for specifications writers since constant handling of catalogs and samples often creates an interest in specifications. Split-job responsibility such as secretary-librarian, or office traineelibrarian, do not usually work out so an office should arrange for a full-time position in most cases, or none at all. 12. ENGINEERS-ARCHITECTS In some larger offices the special fields of mechanical and electrical design for projects is done "in-house", that is in the A/E office rather than being "farmed-out" to consultants. This then requires education and registered engineers to design the various system, and different levels of draftsman to produce their working drawings. These engineering positions parallel the architectural positions very closely. The same is true of those responsible for the structural design of a project. An increasing number of engineering offices are including some architectural work and reverse of the above is obviously true. Contractors also employ design personnel and a drafting force, so some positions may be comparable in the larger contracting offices. As with the A/E office, some public organizations such as large school districts, federal, state, and citycounty governments also maintain A/E departments and their operation and personnel may be similar, even if called by other names to suit civil service requirements. 13. NON-ARCHITECTURAL PERSONNEL Almost all offices require the normal complement of secretaries office accountants, file checks, receptionists, and other nonarchitectural personnel. The customary requirements for taking dictation, typing, filing, etc. are necessary and a great variety of education and experience may need to be considered. Smaller offices may need a combination-type person who can handle reception typing, filing, and perhaps even the accounting. In larger organizations, a number of very specialized positions may be needed: typists with training on special machines, accountants with special tax, knowledge, and private secretaries with good organizational ability. And in some large offices even people trained in food handling or processing may be necessary. 14. OFFICE ORGANIZATION Most offices are not organized with only one project manager, one designer, and one production group. Such a singular arrangement would mean that, in general, only one project would be processed at a time and this would not be economical or feasible except in very small offices. Therefore, two principal systems may be used. The following Figure indicates an office with two or more project managers. The specialty personnel (design, consultants, specifications, and construction manager) each contribute their skills to each group as needed. This allows the office to operate properly with a minimum number of specialty people who may work only part of their time on one project and can therefore spread their skills. 268 Many offices operate with some combination of either possibility. The average office employee approximately 3% to 5% of its entire force in a design capacity. The production force of production manager and the various draftsmen may total approximately 70%, with the remaining 25% to 27% serving as specialty or supporting personnel. Common Production Crew Organizational Chart Sr. Architect Jr. Architect Project Manager Production Crew ● Job Captain ● Designer ● Sr. Draftsman ● Jr. Draftsman ● Trainee Specifications Cost Estimator Consultants ● Structural ● Mechanical ● Electrical Contract Administrator Inspectors Parallel Type Arrangement Organization Chart Sr. Architect Sr. Architect Jr. Architect partner Jr. Architect partner Job Captain Job Captain Sr. Draftsman Sr. Draftsman Sr. Architect Jr. Architect partner Job Captain Sr. Draftsman Intermediate Draftsman Beginner Draftsman Trainee Designer Specifications Cost Estimator Consultants Contract Administrator Inspectors Intermediate Draftsman Beginner Draftsman Trainee Designer Specifications Cost Estimator Consultants Contract Administrator Inspectors Intermediate Draftsman Beginner Draftsman Trainee Designer Specifications Cost Estimator Consultants Contract Administrator Inspectors CONSULTANTS Very few architectural-engineering office have the personnel capabilities or other facilities to handle all phases of a project within their own organization. There is no stigma attached to this inability since it simply stems from differences in education of personnel, size of office, type of projects usually worked on, specialization if any, and many other things. The average small to medium-sized architectural office therefore employee consultants to fill out where their own facilities or personnel do not cover. The fields covered by consultants are wide, and few or many may be used by an office. Usually about at least two types of consultants are used by most offices: structural and mechanical electrical. The latter may be two separate consultants: one for mechanical work and one for electrical work. Cost estimating services are also most commonly used where that capability is not present in an office. In fairly recent years another consultant has appeared the specifications consultant or material researcher. Consultants may also be used to provide information regarding required for good preparation and equipment; for product handling of all types; for fire protection and sprinkler systems for a miscellany of special items, materials, or processes. In an engineering office where architectural work is not normally done, the architectural work is not normally done, the architectural firm may be employed as a consultant. Infrequently, experts in finance, real estate, planning, or similar fields may be employed but are not usually considered as consultants. Most consultants require a fee for their services and the amounts of such fees are included in the architect's fee. Some consultants provide services without charge, but these depends a great deal upon local conditions and customs. Fees may be arranged in the same manner upon local conditions and customs. Fees may be arranged in the same manner upon which the fees of the project A/E are: Fee arrangement might include percentage of work provided, hourly rate, time or material agreement, lump sum, or any other method that is mutually agreeable. Services provided by various consultants very nearly as much as do the consultants themselves. Basic engineering services may be limited to structural, mechanical, or electrical calculations providing only minimum rough sketches. This arrangement requires that the employer of the consultant does all of the finished drafting and other detailing. Probably a more satisfactory agreement is one in which the consultant provides finished drawings as well as presentation calculations and proper specifications section. With this type of agreement, there must be good cooperation between the two parties in order to assure that the drawings are on the same type sheets, that specifications are provided with proper typing, section indicators, and on the same type mesters. RESPONSIBILITY The architect normally directly employs his own consultants, in which case he also assumed major responsibility for their work as his own. In some cases, various consultants are engaged by the owner and directed to work with the architect, and vice versa. This condition leads to some confusion and perhaps some difficulty. Most of the time the owner employed consultant is not a structural, mechanical, or electrical engineer doing a major portion of the object work. The consultant is more often an investigator, researcher, or advisor who makes surveys regard- ing site, placement, traffic patterns, or other feasibility-type requirements. In connection with industrial projects, the owner's consultant maybe the plant engineer who may be a great help to the E/E unless he tries to become the designer of the project. With this type of consultant the responsibility must be clearly defined as some ideas or recommendations of the consultant may not mesh with the overall plans of the A/E. The project development is a team effort requiring the best talent within the least time. Many offices feel that their own staff is fully capable of doing all of the work required, and perhaps they may be - but can they do as good a job in the same time or less than the expert specialized consultant? It's doubtful the architect's office must be aware of the capabilities of both its own staff and the consultants and must cooperate fully to benefit by the employment of out- side assistance. In the smaller office, there is usually a shortage of time for the few employees to do all of the architectural, structural, mechanical, and eletrical work involved in producing a project, even if they had the capabilities. In the larger office, the tendency to have specialists, or at least those specifically assigned certain portions of a project, is greater. With the increase in types of materials, methods of installation, environmental qualifications, code requirements, and the hundreds of other factors, it may be expected that we will continue to require more and more specialist or consultants. DIFFERENT TYPES OF CONSULTANTS 1. STRUCTURAL CONSULTANTS Structural consultants to an architect are most always registered civil or structural engineers. Their training and experience have been slanted toward calculating requirements for size and strength of beams, columns, footings, walls, etc. In some areas where earthquakes occur, structural engineers also will do all seismic calculations for the proposed project. The same general arrangement holds for areas where hurricanes, tornadoes, or cyclones and prevalent. The engineer also generally has a staff of draftsmen who are capable of providing working drawings for the structural work. Few engineer's offices however are staffed to provide properly organized structural specifications. This is an unfortunate situation which may be the end result of inadequate instruction, or none at all, in the education of the engineer. When the agreement for services only includes rough sketches from the engineer, they may or may not be provided to scale and usually are on various types of paper and not very coordinated. The architect then needs to arrange these sketches in proper order, affix designators, coordinate them with his other drawings, and of course provide specifications from the engineer's notes. Calculations are normally provided on sheets that may be duplicated and passed on to building review departments. When the structural engineer is required to provide the working structural drawings, there is an additional burden on the architect to supply information materials. Initially the architect must supply "dummies" of the floor plans upon which the structural columns and beams will indicated. In some cases only the standard bordered sheets are supplied and the engineer makes the "dummies" from a line print supplied by the Architect. Along with the other drawings the engineer usually provides standard details in several forms. Quite often these standards are assembled on a single sheet and may be repeated over and over on different projects. Structural sections of the construction, special details, and copious notes relating to the strength of the materials are a part of the structural drawings. The engineer is also responsible for providing the calculations by which the structural members are designed. Each portion of the building must be properdesigned to meet the building codes and the total structure must be designed for earthquakes, hurricanes, and other acts of God. These calculations must be in producible form in order to make copies for the building department review, as well as review by the architect. The specifications may or may not be developed by the engineer. The format for the specifications is established by the architect. The architect also determined the proper section numbers for the structural sections of the specifications. The actual information, the words and phrases, may be types in the engineers office and incorporated into the final specifications by the architect's specifications writer, or the engineer may supply adequate notes and the actual writing is done in the office of the architect. The latter is perhaps more satisfac- tory as the architectural specifications writer can separate structural concrete from miscellaneous concrete (walks, gutters, fence foundations, machinery bases) and perhaps structural steel from ornamental metals. Uniformity of appearance and paragraphing is easier also since the same team of writer and typist work together. 2. MECHANICAL ELECTRICAL CONSULTANTS Consultants for mechanical work and electrical work may be from separate offices or may be from one office which has facilities to perform both. Before we go further let's be sure or what we mean by mechanical. This term usually includes plumbing work, heating systems, ventilating air conditioning, and perhaps some more specialized phases such as special piping, solar systems, or even nuclear work. Any of these must be designed specifically for the project and requires a thorough knowledge of the requirements as well as a thorough knowledge of materials available, codes, and the project area temperatures, rainfall, solar conditions, etc. The electrical consultant must have approximately the same qualifications, oriented toward electrical work, of course. He knows the utility company rules and the local conditions, as well as suppliers and electrical contractors. The same requirements for drawings, calculations and specifications holds for mechanical or electrical consultants. However, education and experience here seem to favor the engineer's personnel. For the most part, architectural people are not trained adequately in mechanical or electrical working drawings and probably would normally not be able to properly transfer rough diagrams, often partially indicated, to finished working drawings. A pipe or wire shown incorrectly connected may give some interesting results. Specifications written for mechanical or electrical work also are different. Since these installations operate a system most engineers write their project specifications as a system rather than as separate materials plus installations. To do this they must be familiar with the assumed operation of their systems, something the average architect doesn't know about. 3. COST ESTIMATING If the project cannot be built within the budget, the designer is in trouble. One of the methods to avoid this trouble is to do cost-estimating before the project goes to the con- tractor for a bid. Only larger offices normally have in-house cost estimators so consultants are regularly used. These consultants often do work for contractors as well, so are familiar with material and labor costs. Cost estimates are quite often provided at the preliminary stage, partway through the working document stage, and a final estimate is made just prior to the distribution of documents. The competent consultant can give a reasonable estimate even at the preliminary stage since his experience allows him a very good idea of the amount of reinforcement required in concrete work, average in-place costs for various items, and the going rate for labor and profit. When drawings are more complete, the estimator of course, can make an accurate quantity take-off and price estimate. Close cooperation is as necessary with this consultant as it is with any other. A change in size, or quality usually means a change in costs. Adequate drawings, including structural, mechanical, and electrical are required. In some cases the cost estimates for mechanical electrical work may be provided by the engineer consultants who have designed that work. When this happens, the cost consultant needs this information to incorporate into his work. Estimates are usually provided for the architect as a series of pages of calculations with a final recap. There is no reason for this information to be duplicated, but it should be provided in a form intelligible to the architect. A review with the estimator. should be a part of the agreement. 4. HARDWARE CONSULTANT The specification of the finishing hardware is as specialized as most any other part of a project. Finishing hardware includes all of the locks, latches, butts, hinges, pulls, closers, stops and other metal, wood, plastic, or combinations of materials and products that are necessary to operate doors, windows, and cabinet work. In some cases the additional items of medicine cabinets, toilet and bath accessories, or specialized hardwares are also included. While not often registered or licensed, hardware consultants most generally are certified members of the American Society of Architectural Hardware Consultants. This society has a training and certificate program which qualifies its members to specify almost every type of finishing hardware that may be required. These consultants know the code requirements for openings of all types and may eliminate costly errors of all types and may eliminate costly errors or omissions. In many cases these consultants are employed by a hardware supplier or manufacturer and provide free services. In other in- stances the consultant is free lance, and works for a free similar to other consultants. One of the often-voiced objections to the use of an employee of a hardware distributor or manufacturer is that this sets up a closed specification in favor of the brands carried by the employer. There may be some slight advantage to the consultant's firm but this is really not as great as it might seem since each consultant firm but this is really not as great as it might seem since each consultant is thoroughly familiar with the products and stock numbers of his competitors. The use of a definite series of identifications or brand is the easiest and the best way to small out requirements, and is readily transposed by other hardware consultants consist of a review of the drawings and the provision of a typed listing of hardware required. Final inclusions in the list, together with other specifications information, are the responsibility of the architect. 5. SPECIFICATIONS CONSULTANT The specifications consultant is a relatively new addition to the list of specialists. In the early days of architecture and construction a small variety of well-known materials and methods of installation were in common use. Today the variety of materials reaches into the hundreds of thousands and the architect simply cannot keep up with all of them in addition to his other work. The specifications consultants, by virtue of his specialization, is able to know more about the qualities of materials, advantages, or disadvantages of use, availability, and some idea of cost. By working from the architect's drawings and attending conferences, he is able to develop a better specifications. In large offices the normal specifications writing force may become overloaded and can be assisted by a freelance "spec" writer. In many cases this consultant is employed as a researcher or materials for certain uses and does little or no writing other than material reports. 6. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS The landscape architect is another specialist that may be retained as a consultant by the architect. In a few cases, the normal situation, the landscape architect is usually the consultant and provides drawings and specification for his specialty. Arrangements for this work should include all of the requirements discussed earlier. Layout for planting locations may be provided in sketch for final inclusion by the architect or may be completed by the landscape architect. Specification, specially when they include the botanical names of the plants are perhaps best produced by the landscape architect is the fact that he knows, or certainly should know, exactly which plants grow best and provide the best appearance for a given location. Some exotic varieties of plants look good initially, but are not com- patible with the soil or climate. 7. SPECIALIZED CONSULTANTS Sooner or later, nearly every office has a project which includes a condition or installation almost completely foreign to the general practice. Special requirements for food service, cooking, serving; storage, or handling, may require the expertise of a consultant who knows food handling methods and the equipment required. Transportation or conveying equipment is rather commonly used in industrial and manufacturing plants and usually requires a consultant familiar with this type of equipment. Water proofing, acoustics and lighting are two very common specialized fields in connection with theatres, TV installations, and similar projects, and most often require a consultant's service. There are many others that we could consider (surveyors, finance people, insurance consultants, fire controllers, video-audio experts) who may be necessary when the project is too complicated or the in-house force may have to spend too much research and development time to be economical. 8. ARCHITECT CONSULTANT Up to now in this chapter, the consultant has not been the architect. This is becoming less true as the construction business rapidly changes. In a number of cases there may be a construction management identity employed by the owner to provide all required services from purchase of land to completion of construction. Another process is the employment of a general contractor who contracts for all of the design and construction- a "turn-key" job. In either of these cases, the architect may be employed as the consultant and provide his specialty, design, working drawings, and specifications to the construction manager or contractor. As noted in another chapter of this book, the architect may act as consultant to an engineer who may, under other circumstances, be consultant to the architect. If this seems a little confusing let's consider a situation where a mechanical engineer is com- missioned to redesign a power plant or refinery. The major portion of the work will be pip- ing and machinery, but there may be some changes of floor plan, exterior elevations, finishes, and other more architectural items. In case of this kind, the architect may easily be the consultant. REFERENCES AND SAMPLES Even the smallest office must at some time or other rely upon books, catalogs, magazines, or some other form of reference material. Seldom does an office become so specialized that similar projects are worked on without some changes, hopefully changes for the better. Reference material appears and may be retained in many forms, but information sources for architectural offices may be categorized into the following major groups: architectural or construction-type magazines, manufacturers or materials catalogs, codes of various kinds, association "how-to-do-it" manuals, and reference texts. Each of these references sources should be readily available to all members of the office staff but the factor of filing and retrieval is one of utmost importance. In the very small or one-man office, the problem may not be very acute but as the office force grows, so does the difficulty of proper filing and accessibility of reference material. In the small office, storage may be a relatively easy matter accomplished by the use of bookcase located at ends of drafting tables or at the side or behind the draftsman. With an increase of office personnel, the probability that reference material will be misfiled and therefore lost is apparent. With an office of ten or more this often becomes a major problem. At this point it becomes almost imperative that the office organize a library. 1. THE LIBRARY Libraries are varied in size, operation, and personnel required. One of the most simple organizational methods is to use the sixteen divisions, all materials related to the same general subject may be filed together. A major problem arises, however, in how to place individual pieces of informational material within each major division. Two ways present themselves: to file alphabetically within the division, or to file by subtitle of the division title. In the first case, it means that library users must have some general knowledge of the scope of the division and may have to look at several pieces of reference. In the second case, it means that some catalogs may have to be dismembered in order to separate various related subsections. In many cases the first condition serves best for bound or loose-leaf catalogs installed on shelving, while the second condition may be used for file- drawer systems where catalogs are single sheets or small booklets. A librarian may be employed to oversee the library operation. Since for office employees will know the exact information source they need when they can come to the library, it is recommended that they be allowed to inspect the material much as in public library stacks section. once a selection has been made, the material should be checked-out to the individual by the librarian, using standard library-type cards or by notations in a book kept by the librarian. Retrieval is a bit more difficult. By retrieval we must include all phases necessary to return the information material to its proper place on the shelf or in the file. The librarian alone should do this! A box or basket at the librarian's station should receive all returned material. If it has been properly marked originally for division etc., the librarian should have little or no trouble in replacing it properly. A book or catalog replaced on a wrong shelf, or in a wrong division, by an office member is a lost reference until acciden- tally found at some later date. Reference information in a lost category is of no value to the office and simply takes up valuable space. All shelf-filed catalogs of books should have a readable division number fixed to their ex- posed bound edge. Self-adhesive plastic strip numbers in contrasting color will do the job but some individual offices may find that the figures are a bit small for easy reading. For larger size figures it may be wise to consider contact pressuretransfer types which can be purchased in sizes up to several inches high. A disadvantage with either of these is the possibility that darker plastic strips or black transfer letters may not show up well on dark bindings. In this case, it may be necessary or desirable to provide a white or light-colored gummed label first, with the identification applied to it. Quite often it is necessary to provide binders for loose material or that information which is separated from a larger catalog. This brings up a real problem since there usually are a number of different types of different manufacturers that will be represented in the accumulated collection. The binder may be a post-type or ringtype, but the latter is more adaptable to changes that need to be made. Each binder needs a table of contents and some identifying tag on the exposed edge of the binder, indicating the manufacturers contained therein. Another method for quick identification of filing divisions is the use of separators between divisions. These may be made of fiberboard or similar material and should prominently display the division number, possibly the adjacent numbers on opposite faces, and perhaps the tiles of the divisions. To also help, it may be desirable to apply labels of some replaceable material on the edges of the shelves. Another time saver in the hunt for a proper catalog is the prominent display of the Uniform System or other filing system. 2. CABINET-DRAWER FILING All literature saved for reference will not be supplied in hard-backed binders for shelf storage. Many manufacturers with good products, but limited in number, will have catalogs of only a few pages, usually unbound. Again these should be filed using the sixteen Divisions of the Uniform System with possible subdivisions or sections. If the offices uses a master system for writing specifications, the identifications used for each specification section will serve ideally for establishing subdivisions or sections. If no master system is used, it is suggested that the five-digit separation of the Uniform System be used. In either case, the small catalog or single sheets should be properly identified with division and section number for easy refiling. 276 L Standard vertical cabinets with pull-out drawers are used in most offices and provide considerable storage space with minimum floor space at the line. Five-drawer-high cabinets have the disadvantage that the top drawer may be too high to provide easy visibility or access to its contents. Some offices have used side-opening file cabinets where the entire length of the file is exposed when the side is opened. This type allows more free access to the frames and metaledge folders. Each office will have a preference but in the process of establishing a workable system they should not overlook methods with which they have not been familiar before. 3. GENERAL SAMPLES Every office and uses samples of materials of construction. When the number is few they may be easily located on a desk, in a bookcase, in a box, or even in a small pile in the "back room". If the office customarily uses the same materials over and over, minimum labeling is required to keep track of various items. In many cases small samples of ceramic tile, resilient flooring, and similars are boxed by the manufacturer so labels are not necessary. As the office business and personnel grow, so do the number of different samples. When the products of one producer were adequate for a smaller project, now a number of similar or equal products may need to be considered. No longer can samples be piled on the desk or in a box for one project. Comparison is required for other materials for other projects and a system must be devised. Again, call the Divisions of the Uniform System into play. Provide boxes, bins, or some other convenient containers for each product or similar products. Into the same box file all samples of resilient flooring for example. If there are too samples divide them into similar categories, i.e., asphalt tile, vinyl, cork, rubber, etc. Boxes should be sturdy and not too large to be difficult to handle when loaded. Upon the exposed end or side, put a large division number and a list of the contents by material and supplier. Label each box, carton, or individual sample contained in the file box, with division number, manufacturer's representative might also be inscribed to make communications with him more rapid if needed. Sizes of individual samples sometimes pose a problem. Full size ceramic tile samples may be 1% x 4%, or miniature (about 1½ x 1½) depending on the manufacturer's choice. Most other samples may originally be larger, and consequently harder to store. A good size for almost any sample is 6" x 6". Pesilient flooring (usually 9" or 12" square), acoustical material (usually 12" sq. or larger), and many other materials supplied in standard sizes should be cut down to fit the storage module. It is obvious that full-size samples of doors, windows, skylights, and similar products cannot be expected to be properly stored. A 6" x 6" corner sample will usually indicate all of the construction adequately. Bricks, stone, structural steel shapes, roofing, generally may be treated in like manner. When a larger sample is required it is normally for a particular project and is not a general office sample. Label each sample properly before storing it in the correct box or bin. 4. PROJECT SAMPLES Project samples are acquired and used for one particular project and may be discarded after the project is completed or may be stored in the general sample file. Selection of proposed materials is generally made from general samples but the actual color, pattern, or other feature may be slightly different for project installation. These variations come about due to batch differences, changes in manufacturing techniques, natural changes in stone or wood, dropped patterns of colors, and other processing problems. Samples may be most any size, especially those that are token or small general samples. Upon receipt of project samples, they should be checked for proper labeling. Labels describing the material, project identification, supplier, and other data are usually affixed by the provider of the sample, and project samples are customarily supplied in from two to six or eight identical units. While only one sample unit may be retained by the office project manager, the others are needed for the general contractor, his field superintendent, subcontractor, material supplier, and possibly the architectural field man. Project samples, if approved for installation, should be plainly marked as APPROVED and should have the date and name or initials of the person as approving the unit retained by the project manager. When the project has been completed, and the project samples are no longer needed, they may end up in one of two places: the general sample storage, or in a completed project storage. Ultimate storage will depend a great deal upon space available. If project samples go to the general sample storage, it is suggested that an additional label be attached indicating date of completion for future reference. If space is available, and the office practice is to retain project samples for a period of time, they are essentially dead unless, or until, they need to be dug out for remodel matching of the project or some similar reason. A good label, indicating the project and the various samples enclosed in the box, may save a lot of time if a search is made at a later date for a particular sample. 5. BUSINESS CARDS Almost every manufacture's representative engineer, consultant, and many others have business cards which list company name, representative's name address, and phone number. These are left with architects or engineers to provide a ready reference. Cards simply thrown in a drawer have a little or no use and may just as well be thrown in the wastebasket. Filing of business cards for easy reference is quite easy. Most cards are of fairly uniform size, usually about 2" x 2%", and may be filed in the empty boxes that the A/E office cards come in. Separator cards made from light cardboard and indicating the sixteen Divisions of the Uniform System are ideal for providing easy card references. Cards kept by the librarian in this manner are much more usable than when kept by individual project managers or in books or other manner. 6. DATE THE INFORMATION One of the most important details necessary for library information and related samples is the date received. This also holds true for most all literature that is to be retained, including business cards of manufacturer's representatives. Put a date on it when it is received. This may be a simple but legible scribble with a pen on the outside of a catalog or upon a business card or may be a standard date stamp. Some offices will even have a catalog register in which all incoming material is listed before it is filed. This may be overdoing it just a bit, but serves as a good and rapid guide to check any material that may be lost and if organized in the Uniform System makes it easier to find information by divisions. If more than one copy of a piece of literature is carried, each should have a number to facilitate keeping track of it. Nothing is more useless than out-of-date information unless it is material without any date. 7. OBSOLETE MATERIAL When does informational literature or general samples become obsolete? Generally, when they are superseded by newer or revised and up-to-date replacements. The normal urge is to junk the obsolete material but in many cases, this may be the wrong thing to do in an A/E office. In some cases, remodeling, or additions to a project, may be made easier if original material is available, especially samples. With the present situation in regard to responsibility of a project for years after its completion and use, an A/E may want to, or have to, prove materials were installed as approved by samples. Space, required to main- tain this storage properly may be an important factor. Many companies carry older copies of Sweet's catalog file in reserve for several years beyond their current dates. Old copies of the thousands of separate manufacturer's catalogs would be a virtual impossibility, Old specifications are usually stored on shelving and provide an easy reference for both materials and style. They should be used as a reference however and not used to copy "cold" as changes may have occured in manufacturing or during construction. Depending upon the volume if work done by the A/E these old "specs" may take up little or lot of shelf room. Filing of drawings of completed projects is another matter. A good clear set, preferably "asbuilt" set with all job changes, nine locations and inverts, and other deviations marked, may be stored in rolls and racks or stored flat in drawers. Each should bear a tag indicating project, date, type of construction, and other useful data. Rack storage needs to be organized by type of project of year of construction and a good index kept up to date. A similar index is needed if drawer storage is used and each drawer should bear a label of its contents. Project manager's notes, changes orders, etc., are usually stored in file cabinets along with financial information or design criteria and general correspondence relating to the project. 8. MAGAZINES Magazines of all types relating to design and construction will sooner or later become another problem for storage and retrieval. Current or newly late copies are usually available in reception rooms, then at project manager's or designers' desk, then at dratsman's boards, and finally in the "coffee room". Some may disappear as various office personnel feel that they need a certain copy more than the office does. After a period of time some offices gather up the old magazines, together with old catalogs, and give them to schools for student references. Other offices file magazines. Normal filing of magazines by title and month of issue is practically a standard procedure. Contents may be indexed by duplicating the issue table of contents and keeping these in a binder for easy reference. This method minimizes the labor involved, but has the disadvantage (perhaps) of including all of the advertising in the magazine. One possible solution is to periodically tear the various magazines apart, separate interesting articles into categories (churches, hospitals, methods, business), bind these into booklets, and junk the remainder. If properly done this will, for a time, provide good reference material for design and other areas. The principal fault seems to be in the fact that the selected material eventually becomes too old for the value of preparation and storage. 9. OTHER MATERIAL A considerable amount of other material will gradually gather which requires proper filing to be useful. This information comes in the form of building codes, mechanical or electrical codes, ASTM files, specification guides of various types, "how-to-do-it" manuals, and trade association standards. Standards reference books on many subjects may also form part of the reference library and should be available for checkout the same as catalogs or other material. Control over all reference materials must be maintained, as misfiled or missing unit are lost units. FINANCES AND INSURANCE How much money does it take to start a new business? There is no firm answer to this question since one business may start off with a flourish and another start with practically nothing. One rule-of-thumb indicates there should be enough cash available to sustain a business for six months to a year without further income. If we accept this rule, how much does it take in dollars? or in Pesos? Hopefully, the operators of the new office have a little "nest egg" and a client or two with whom they are currently working. Until those first projects are complete, however, the cash flow is going out and there may be some slack times in the future when there is little or no income. 1. YOUR FINANCIAL "GUESSTIMATE" Even before opening the principal(s) should sit down and thoughtfully and carefully consider all possible aspects of the present and future financial conditions. Known factor are the present income, house or car payments, food, utilities, and other living expenses. How will a personal business affect medical insurance, is there an existing bank loan, what amount of savings, stock, or bonds are available, and what about family recreation? On the minus side of the new business venture, there is office rent, utilities, furniture, insurance, office supplies, and a big contingency item. Perhaps on the plus side there is a project commissions. Make a budget and do not forget that your former check/paycheck will be a thing of the past. You are now the boss and regular income may no longer be so regular. Considerable thought should be given to the matter of office size and personnel since these are two of the most expensive items the budget may show. Most A/E offices start small, often with only the principal as the sole employee. If this will be the case for the new office, it is very probable that physical space may also be small, but what may happen if another person is employed? Even a one-man office may need, and want, space for several positions in the drafting area as well as reception and conference rooms. How much will the additional space cost over a period of time as compared to the cost of moving each time the office grows? If the new office is to be a partnership, how much cash or other resources does each of the partners have, what income are they expecting do the additional person or persons increase required office space and expense? Make a comprehensive study and a realistic budget before you quit your present job to start your own practice. 2. THE ACCOUNTING SYSTEM In order to know if the office is profiting, the new principal must establish some sort of accounting system: a bookkeeping method which he personally may maintain or at least of which he knows the rudiments. It is entirely possible that the expense accounting used for home and Internal Revenue may suffice for the Office system to a more complex one may be devised. The most simple is the day journal in which all daily transactions of expense and incomes are recorded on the same page but in different columns. This method may work for a time but has a several disadvantages the principal one being the difficulty of determining the relationship of income versus expense on any one project, except with much searching and scratch paper calculations. A second major disadvantage is one that probably is important to any system; posting of accounting items needs to be done when they happen or are reported. Unless only checks are used to pay expenses, "chits" or notes should be made out for every transaction. 280 The next step from the day journal is some form of double-entry system. Here the day journal may still be used for initial entry of an item and as a quick reference for day-to-day activities, but is expanded to allow separation of accounts, and information. In addition to the journal pages, there are pages for a number of accounts such as rent, utilities, equipment, payrolls, and for each client. Operation is relatively simple. As payment for rent is made, it is noted in the journal for general information and on the page for rent as a specific item. As time on the Jones project is noted as an expense in the journal, it is also noted in the pages for the Jones account as expense. If a payment is received from Jones it is recorded similarly, except as income. Properly kept, this allows a quick check for items in a day journal and an idea of expense versus income for client accounts. Beyond these two simple systems the principal(s) may want to consult a qualified and experienced accounting firm. There are several reasons for this suggestion. By the time this point is reached, the principal no longer has time to actually do the bookkeeping, nor the time to properly review the work of someone else doing it. In addition, there are probably items of depreciation on equipment, notes or accounts payable, accounts past due, con- vention or educational accounts, payroll deduction of various sorts, insurance (property) as well as medical, and a host of others. The accounting firm may set up a different method or may expand the existing one, may handle the actual book entries or instruct office personnel, and may also act as tax consultants or financial advisors. In any case, it may be to the advantage of the principal to thoroughly understand the system, even though he may not do the work, since he, partners, banks, or Internal Revenue, may want to know what it's all about some day. 3. CREDIT AND LOANS Credit is the early advancement of money or services against payment at a future date. There has almost always been credit advanced by someone to someone else but present day business operated about 90 on credit. Credit-charge-cards, banks notes mortgages, all are credit originated. Sooner or later the A/F will reach a situation in which he needs more money to operate than he has and will need credit. In many cases this is not even a matter of having the available money, but one of convenience. Few offices pay-day-to-day bills for office supplies, blueprinting, automobile fuel, or even utilities on a cash basis as they occur. When major expenditures are contemplated, it is often necessary to obtain credit from a lending agency and this process requires certain declarations of financial solvency by the applicant. One of the most common declarations of such conditions is the financial statement which shows assets and liabilities of the applicant. Along with any discussion of credit we might also consider the matter of loans. Loans are a bit different from credit in that loans are secured by some collateral owned by the applicant. Usually a loans arranged through a bank and the bank may accept stocks, bonds, mortgage, even an unpaid for car, as security for loan. The bank will probably not lend full value of the security, and quite often may require collateral in the amount of two or three times the loan amount. Loans have a time factor for payment, and may or may not be renewed. If the loan is not repaid, the lending agency may sell the collateral and keep their loan and expenses, all as agreed upon by the person receiving the loan. Any remaining money is returned to the defaulter. 4. PROJECT BUDGETS In order to determine if an A/E is making a profit, or working at a loss, it is necessary to first have some information or estimate of costs of the project. Larger or older offices have a basis for costs that they can apply if they actually make up a budget or not. For the new office a great deal may depend upon an educated guess. The proper budget includes all of the direct expenses such as design, working drawings, specifications, consultants if any, and perhaps blueprinting. If possible, the cost of securing the commission is also con- sidered as a direct expense, and an estimate of administrative and field observance costs needs to be included. In other words all items that can be estimated from previous work and have a direct bearing on the project need consideration. Indirect expenses includes variable amounts of the rent, utilities, furniture, secretaries' pay, office supplies, and similar items that cannot be totally charged to any one project. It should be fairly obvious that each of these is necessary, but how to charge their costs equitably is the problem. The total cost of each item is calculated per year or per month and then the total of all indirect costs calculated. This amount is then developed into either a percentage or project costs, or an hourly rate figure which can be applied to direct costs. This total indirect cost varies from as low as 40% to as high as 90%, however, 60% to 70% is more normal. An additional factor needs to be considered. This is the item of reserves, or money put aside for a time when business may not be so good and the A/E needs a savings account to fall back on. The actual amount to be included in a project budget is determined by the A/E, less the total of direct and indirect costs. When the total budget is calculated; the A/E may find that his hourly rate is very low or that he may even be operating at a loss. Some economic writers and some professionals advocate that young, or beginning, A/E's accept projects which indicate a loss, with the idea that such clients will help to build up goodwill. This may be advisable if the client has other large project, for which the A/E is fairly certain to be retained, few successful businesses have ever existed that continue to operate at a loss. 5. PAYROLL RECORDS One of the most important records that the A/E needs is the record of time expended to produce the construction documents. This cards for draftsmen, as well as the principal, are useful for cost accounting, budget planning, performance of employees, as well as for payroll, purposes. The time card needs to coincide with the pay period and may be weekly, biweekly, or monthly. A time card need not have an excessive amount of information, but certainly needs the employee's name, space for project names, space each day for time worked, pay rate (although this may be entered by the payroll clerk), and in some offices a space for a work code. Work codes clarify the type of work done by the employee and more than one office uses the following symbols. C – Securing commissions, conferences, correspondence P – Preliminary work of all types, drafting, estimates D – Design development, drafting, estimates, renderings W – Working drawings of all types, some offices subdivide this category by number into structural, architectural, landscape, heating, ventilating, etc. S – Specifications, combinations with P or D may be used for preliminary or design development phases. F - Field work of all types M or A – Management or administration For the accounting department this allows separation of each work activity for each project. This, of course, is vitally important if an accurate account of profit or loss is to be determined of each project. For the A/E principal, these time cards provide a background for later project budgets. The cards also may indicate, to some extent, the ability of the employee, either compared with other employees or against some office standard. Ability, in this case, can only be a judgment of the speed with which the employee works, and can hardly indicate his skill, which may be more important than speed. 6. INVESTMENTS As the office begins to show a profit, there may be consideration to expand or to put the money into some sort of investment. There are several types of investment that may be interesting but some have built-in chances that the A/E should realize. Except in extreme national financial depressions, or embezzlement, savings account in banks or saving in-loan organizations are safe, guaranteed by the government, and draw interest at a stipulated rate agreed upon in advance. Stocks and bonds represent a possibility for investment. Company stocks are issued to initial investors and sold or resold as the company prospers. A stock may be originally valued (par value) at say, one dollar. The company may then develop a process or product, make a good profit and the value of the stock goes up and a dividend and a dividend stock is declared. As the company prospers, non initial investors are willing to pay more than the par value of the stock and as more demand is generated, the price of the stock also increases. Stock buying is a gamble. There is no guarantee that the price one day will be more or less than the next day, nor that there will be a dividend. The A/E who invests in stock expects to hold those securities until the market price increases to that he may make a substantial profit by resale. Should the market price drop, the holder may sell at a loss or hold the stocks until they again rise, maybe tomorrow or maybe in a year or two. Preferred stocks have first call on company dividends. Bonds are pledges of a company against their property or equipment, or for payment of principal and interest. Instead of issuing stock or obtaining a bank loan, companies, cities, the federal government, and another organizations issue bonds. Bonds are bought or sold in units determined by their face value and usually are in amounts of P1,000. Most bonds are some sort of coupon attached, each of which represents, and is negotiable for, certain periods of interest. Discounted bonds are sold at less than face value and are redeemable with the holder's name, some are not. Nonregistered bonds are transferable and may be cashed by anyone. Real estate offers several opportunities for investment. Outright purchase of land or a building appreciate enough for a number of reasons, but tie up money in rather large sums, even if loans have been arranged. Other properties, in need of loans, may secure these loans by mortgages which bear interest and have a due date. Mortgages usually carry rather high interest and often are arranged through realty or savings-and-loan companies. Occasionally an opportunity may arise in which an A/E may agree to accept part of his fee as an investment or part-ownership in a project he design. In general, real estate offers long-term, large sum investment possibilities that may not be advantageous to the A/E. 7. PROFIT SHARING Profit sharing is one form of reward often used in the A/E office to encourage better efficiency and reduce costs of operation. The theory is quite simple: a profit budget is set up, the employees work a little harder and faster and complete the construction documents at less than budget estimate, and additional profit shows on the accounting books, and a distribution of the savings for part of them) is made to the employees. The theory is great, but the practical application is a bit more complicated. To begin with, there must be a reasonable and proven basis upon which to establish the production standards. This may be determine by reference to similar projects if adequate work records have been kept. The next problem is to decide who gets what part of the excess profit. In most cases a substantial portion is retained as office reserve, with the remainder divided among employees and principal(s) in proportion to their positions or salaries. In many cases there is a recruitment for minimum years of employment within the office, and the payment may be made at intervals of months or upon the final accounting of a project. In addition to the added money for participating employees, this method tends to promote interest in the office and an effort to reduce production costs. 8. RETIREMENT PROGRAMS Retirement benefits are very common in our present business world and many A/E offices have such plans. Most have requirements for a minimum length of employment in the office plus a retirement age to be reached by the dependable employee. Two major types of retirement programs are in operation: total participation by the office alone, and a plan of wages which are matched in some manner by the employer. Either condition needs to be thoroughly investigated with a good tax counsel and accountant as income tax situations differ in the manner in which the money is saved and paid. Retirement funds are usually deposited in a trust funds or similar account, or may not be invested for their interest earn- ings. Considerable bookkeeping is likely to be involved, but the system tends to create longevity in employees and a feeling of belonging that is beneficial to office operation. 9. WITHHOLDING More and more the burden or withholding portions of wages for various taxes has become the problem of the businessman and the A/E is no exception. Major items withheld are for income tax, social security, medical or health benefits, and possibly for retirement. The A/E should investigate these requirements as soon as he considers hiring any employees as there are stiff penalties for failure to comply. Philippine income tax deductions begin when an employee's pay reaches P6250 and, depending upon marital status and number of dependence, ranges from 17% to approximately 6% of the gross pay. All of these deductions must be accounted for in the name of the person involved, and very careful records must be kept. In addition, the employer is obligated to provide matching funds for some types of benefits so the best advice is to consult with the proper authorities before becoming involved, especially since the methods and amounts are continually being changed. 10. MISCELLANEOUS There are several other, but overlooked, minor expenses that are continually required of the A/E in business. First probably is the registration fee to practice Architecture or Engineering. The professional's identification card must be renewed every three years with the professional Regulation Commission, in accordance with Republic Act. No. 6511. The fee will run up to Seventy five pesos (P75.00) for three years. Most cities require a business license to be paid by any form of profit-making enterprise within the City borders. Such a license is normally subscribed to annually and the fee is Seventy Five (P75.00) pesos for one year. This is normally called the PTR or Professional Tax Receipt and is written in the Professional's Plan and Specifications. Membership in professional organizations seems almost a must in our current society, and may be very well helpful to the A/E in a number of ways. The UAP, which is the accredited Architects organization usually charges one hundred fifty pesos (P150.00) per year. Similar fees are charged by PICE, PAMEE, PIEE, AMIEP, ASEP and others engineering organizations. Professionals should also register his receipts with the Bureau of Internal Revenue and secure a tax account number. At the beginning of the year, he shall secure also a residence certificate A and B. There are many benefits that a professional can get in joining professional organizations. Social as well as professional benefits through regular meetings, exchange of ideas, and educational programs are gained. Most often than not, the large or main distributors or manufacturers of important materials promote their products through product presentations. The professional gets a first hand information of the latest products where brochures and samples are give free. 11. GENERAL INSURANCE Insurance is defined as coverage ty contract whereby a company agrees to guarantee a customer against loss under specified conditions. Public liability and property damage (PL and PD) are perhaps the most common of insurance policies, excepting life insurance, and provide protection against liability for injury or death of a person or property damage incurred in an accident. Accidents do occur in the office, in connection with automobile operation, at conferences and construction sites, and are not always limited to office personnel. Even though a claim against the A/E may not be granted, the cost of defense may be considerable, so adequate insurance should be provided. The A/E should also consider other general forms of insurance to minimize loss. Fire insurance of furniture and equipment is relatively inexpensive, but may mean the difference between continuing or closing a business if a fire occurs. Along with normal coverage of furniture and equipment, the A/E may want to consider a special policy or "rider" which would compensate for loss of drawings and other office records by firewater damage. The ideal protection is duplication and remote storage, but this is expensive, time consuming, and very convenient. Office storage in fire proof safe or vauit may also be an answer, but such devices are also expensive, may not be available, and are worthless in any pro- longed or intense fire. 12. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION Workmen's compensation insurance protects the A/E against claims resulting from the injury or death of employees through industrial accidents. In most accidents cases there must be negligence shown by someone in order for the injured party to benefit. This is not true in industrial accidents. Many states now have compulsary workmen's compensation insurance, either carried by employers or through companies on the approved list of state. Along with this type of insurance, a number of states also have systems for unemploy ment payments or disability compensation, paid fully or partially by the employer. Since each state have different requirements, it would be impractical to list all conditions here but the A/E has records to keep and, in most cases, money to pay out, so thorough investigation should not be amiss. PUBLIC RELATIONS Almost every business considers means by which they can create a good impression on the general public or influence special groups of individuals to patronize their businesses. Architects and engineers are no different than any other businessman. By the use of public relationship the A/E may promote his own business and increase the stature of his profession in general. To be effective in any public relation to public needs, and to communicating the office position to the public. The evaluation of the position of the firm should include what the firm currently has that the public needs, or can provide, if or when a new service is wanted. This opinions in regard to community activities. To communicate the office position requires a good interpretation of services available and an effective way to present the information to the public. Selection of the proper medium is most important as well as proper timing. Quite often the anticipated public relations release or activity is almost literally canceled due to poor timing although considerable money and effort may have been spent to produce it. The A/E must choose a proper medium, time, and content for any public relations program. A very great deal of the profession of architecture or engineering involves public relations of one sort or another. Professional services must be "sold" to clients the same as any other product or service. This may not be the idealistic way to look upon a profession, but it is the truth nonetheless. Public relations includes advertising, and although the major architectural society in the United States and in the Philippines frowns on advertising as such, there are a number of ways to obtain this advertising in the guise of public relations also includes membership in various organizations, public speeches, project signs, magazine or newspaper stories, architectural competitions, office brochures, entertainment, and a variety of similar approaches. Public recognition of the architect or engineer and his work is a natural desire. 1. ORGANIZATIONS Architects or engineers belong to organizations, professionals, social, or civic, for a number of reasons. They belong to professional organizations for the prestige involved for interchange of professional ideas, and perhaps for a few contacts that may be made. Membership in social or civic organizations may provide direct contact possibilities to become influential committee members while diligently working for worthwhile projects. In the case of civic organizations. These contacts may be the supervisors, attorneys, and others who are important in determining who is considered for architectural or engineering work for the city or other political body. In the case of service organizations, the self-satisfaction gained by working on club projects is complemented by some business contacts that may lead directly or indirectly to architectural work. Strictly social clubs, yacht clubs, tennis clubs, and the like, serve a dual purpose in providing recreational facilities in addition to possible contacts with future clients. Social clubs also provide opportunities and comfortable accommodation for entertainment of clients or prospects. Personal activity in professional organizations often adds prestige to the image of the A/E. Holding the office of president, or other administrative office, indicates to the general public that the person is held in rather high esteem by his fellow and that they look to him for leadership. On a national basis the same is true except that local opinion is now greatly reinforced by the support of members in other areas, some of whom know the person only by his local reputation as a good leader. A similar but less important status may be achieved by elected leadership in service or social organizations. A certain amount of prestige is provided by being an officer of one of these clubs and interchange of club activities may provide contacts that could be advantageous. A word of advice at this point may also provide valuable. Do not be carried away by the honor of being elected an officer of any organization to the extent that it threatens the business operation or the A/E's fami- ly life. In a number of cases, especially if the individual operates one-man office, the amount of effort, time, and money used to attend to responsibilities of club office, drains the professional office of required leadership and creates problems with the family. Money expended may be directly out of the A/E's pocket since most organizations have only token reimbursement for expense incurred for attending meetings and other activities. Time away from the office is another major consideration. If the principal in a small office is gone a great deal of the time, client contacts, as well as office supervision usually suffers. Continued absence from the family, due to club activities held at night, weekends, or in a distant city, also may be a cause for discord. The A/E should consider all of the advantages as well as the disadvantages of being an officer of a club before he accepts nomination. 2. PUBLIC SPEAKING Architecture and engineering are interesting subjects to the general public and of special interest to certain groups. Opportunities continually occur to speak before organizations of all types and the accomplished speaker is invited on more and more occasions. Each speech not only reaches the immediate audience, but may be picked up as newsworthy by newspapers, magazines, radio reports, or television. The latter may also develop into additional public appearances for the speaker. Speeches must be organized to be informative and interesting to the audience and should be well enough rehearsed to eliminate reading of a text, although infrequent reference to notes is acceptable. At project-opening ceremonies or dedication activities, the architect may not be called upon to speak but this visible appearance probably would seldom hurt him. In many areas the local schools have career days involving various occupation, and this is also an opportunity for the architect or engineer to speak to be seen. Both architecture and engineering expose the practitioners to more direct contact with a questioning public than most any other professions. There is a continuous quest for new clients that is not present in the medical field, and in many businesses the client or customer returns again and again due to economic rather than professional reasons. Each A/E will be expected to represent that group at 'pulsefeeling" meetings of city, county or planning commissions and should be able to express himself adequately, without the presence of stage fright, is a bid advantage in doing business and influencing others. 3. PROJECT SIGNS Project signs are one of the most inexpensive yet most effective means of advertising or public relations. These project signs may be single units indicating the name of the architect responsible for the project, or may be billboard size with colored rendering of the project, names of owner, architect, consultants of various kinds, contractor and list of subcontractors, financial lender, and other related information. Most offices have an established format and original for project signs: usually one for wood or metal signs 'which may be fastened to the building or support and one made on paper by printing or blueprint process to be attached to the glass in windows on stores or remodeling work. Some communities or clients have special requirements regarding project signs, so care must be exercised to avoid complications. Project signs should be large enough to be easily read at a little distance usually from the adjacent street. They should be well designed with a good clear indication of the name of the architect, the word architect, and office location. Fancy backgrounds, intricate lettering or office logos, or clashing color combination should be avoided. If billboard type projects signs are to be used, the size, name sizes and arrangement, colors and other design detailing should be done by the architect and a component sign painter engaged to do the work. Quite often the contractor and several sub-contractors also will want to put up their project signs on the job so instead of a clutter of individual mismatched signs, the architect may specify a billboard project sign as a part of the contract. 4. MAGAZINE - NEWSPAPER ARTICLES This type of public relations or office publicity has certainly had its ups-anddowns over the years and probably will continue to have them in the future. In either case a published article accompanied by photo reproductions is good public relations, but there are both policy and personal problems connected with each attempt. In order to be publishable a building designed by an architect or engineer must solve a community problem, be an award winner, be timely in regard to a new trend or method, or have some unusual qualities of size, shape or location. Publication may occur at the start of a project, at the completion years after because of special conditions or interest, upon receiving an award, or at some extraordinary point during the construction. Newspapers are interested in what is happening now and therefore have a different interest in the work of an architect or engineer. Newspapers are interested in projects affecting the community, the environment, or other current events. Often the A/E may prepare good copy for an article about his project, describing the solution for a particular problem, or the introduction of a new concept. Most newspapers are eager to have such news articles, but occasionally a paper adopts the attitude that since architects do not advertise, the newspapers will not give them free advertising by printing their articles, their names in the article or even their names on delineations. While this attitude may be quite rare, it is also a challenge to the A/E to prove to new editors, via lunches, professional meetings, invitations to "open house' activities, that A/E's do have newsworthy projects for publica- tion. The A/E who desires newspaper publicity must remember that time is of the essence for newspaper stories, so delay of article preparation, wrong size or type of photographs, or similar factors missing a deadline by a day or an hour, may mean no publication at all. Magazines operate in a different manner than newspapers, so a different approach is necessary. Most magazine articles are placed through professional public relations firms or professional photographers with magazine contacts. Occasionally, a magazine special features editor will seek the architect or engineer, but this is not the most common procedure. The A/E provides the information, but the actual story is most often written by a reporter or staff writer. Good professional photographs may be edited from the final article due to space requirements or timeliness. The matter of timing is import in magazine articles also, but not in the same manner as for newspapers. Two types of articles require different time consideration. The feature article may need several months advance planning and writing in order to appear at a certain appropriate date. Articles about winter in- insulation are not common in midsummer; articles about construction or design of exhibitions needs to coincide with openings; some special issue of magazine may need planning far in advance. Another type of magazine publicity is with "filler" information supplied by A/E's. These are usually short descriptions of a special feature, photographs of a special details, or combinations that are not time-dated. Such material is filed by the magazine until some occurrence prompts publication of such material from several sources, some seasonal reason is apparent, or perhaps simply to fill out a page or column. Both newspapers and magazines can be a source of good public relations. 5. ARCHITECTURAL COMPETITIONS Most architectural competitions fall into one of two categories: those that search for good ideas by a board of trustees or similar body with no intent or consideration for compensation to the entrance, or competitions organized to include a selected entry list and to provide equitable pay for each entry, and a contract to the finalist chosen. Young architects are usually the ones involved in the first type and occasionally gain a contract, but the basic idea is one of putting one office against another and then selecting the most desirable aspects of each entry. Quite often the parameters are poorly defined and the judging done by inexperienced amateurs. In the second type, the requirements are fully defined, each entrant receives some remuneration for time spent, judging is done by architectural professionals with some lay help, and a contract is awarded. With a well-organized competition, it is possible to obtain news media exposure before and during the event, and the possibility of good follow-up during construction or at completion. 294 Competitions require time to prepare and this is one of the greatest drawbacks when an office is busy. A considerable amount of advanced planning is also necessary as most competitors is usually made through professional, or trade magazines, by mailed flyers or invitations, and in many cases by manufacturers on a yearly basis. Submittals normally require several plans and elevations, often in color, properly coordinated, and on standard sized boards. Judging is generally by a selected jury and contestants are not present at the critique. Announcement of award is generally by the same media as the original an- nouncement of the proposed competition, and submittals are returned to contestants who supply shipping facilities and expenses. 6. OFFICE BROCHURES Almost every commercial organization of any kind has a brochure which they use as a public relations document. Many of these firms distribute these brochures is advocated but some ideas are suggested. Brochures should be up-to-date showing good samples of the work that the office has done. In addition, the brochure should contain a complete resume of office personnel. Quite often photographs and individuals resumes of principals are included. Two methods are used to include photos of completed projects. For general use and without specialization, an office will include work as many different varieties as possible. In some cases a large office will include only office buildings; if a laboratory building is anticipated, only photos of laboratories will be shows; or if a church is to be considered, only churches are included. This procedures is not possible where an office has had considerable experience and a variety of project types. Copies of award citations, publicity' clippings, and other data favorable to the office, may also be contained in the brochure. Cover and binding should be well designed. Brochures should present the best picture of the office but should not be self-laudatory or bragging in nature. Financial consideration is a big factor in preparation and use of office brochures. Black- and-white printing or four-color printing command a considerable difference in cost, but both may be used successfully. Many brochures are fairly simple resumes of an A/E office, designed to be left with a prospective client, and cost can be reduced by using black-and- white reproduction. More impressive and more expensive, brochures include may photographs, color logos or other embellishments, high-quality paper stock, and are pro- vided for display only at conferences or other meetings. Generally, these more expensive brochures are kept by the A/E for multiple showing. While not strictly a brochure, many offices maintain a file of 35 mm color slides showing the office, personnel, and projects for brochures or other presentation material and have rather limited or special use. When used in the home office of the A/E, it is possible to have a projector and other equipment set up and seating arranged for easy viewing. If the file and equipment are to be used at the client's office, the A/E should be sure to obtain prior approval, determine if the equipment can be set up without undue inconvenience, provide a screen, extension, cords and related gear, and do everything possible to make the presentation interesting and convenient. Slide shows should be carefully organized to include only pertinent information, should be long enough to prevent boredom, and should have good accompanying narration. 7. ENTERTAINMENT Entertainment is a perfectly legal and logical method to publicize the office. Lunches, dinners, theatre parties, yachting cruises, and similar entertainment allows and semi-social exchange between the A/E and the prospective client. In a relaxed atmosphere it is often possible to "talk shop" while playing golf, or at some other entertainment. All such entertainment needs to show customary good taste in its proposal and should have the possibility of producing business. In a good many cases the A/E may find that he, consciously or unconsciously, selects the same golf foursome to continue this entertainment even after initial contact has accomplished its purpose. While this may be good for his golf game or card game, it does not materially increase his number of business contacts. Entertainment like most anything else, can be overdone. While a certain amount of productive entertainment is perfectly legal, for tax purposes you must be able to prove with whom you were, what was the business reason for the entertainment and a reasonable cost. 8. THE OFFICE Perhaps one of the most influential factors in public relations takes place in the office. By this term we mean the actual office location and appearance, as well as the quality of work produce and the personnel employed. Each professional, of course, has his own idea of what a good office is, but a hard to find space in a run-down industrial area of a city is not likely to impress prospective clients. The rent may be cheap and the space adequate, the location may be near the center of town, there may be ample parking and all other desirable qualities, but the overall picture would not tend to indicate a successful professional practice. Perhaps a smaller space in a newer office-type building, with the possibilities of good street exposure and ease of location would be a better solution. Often a small building housing, real estate offices, contractors or engineers, or others related to construction is available, and a certain amount of remodeling of decorating may be advantageous. The interior of the office itself, especially reception and conference should reflect the general attitude of the office. Natural wood paneling and natural wood trim may indicate that the architect likes the feel and appearance of wood and uses it in his design work. A more modern atmosphere of stainless steel or chrome furniture with lots of glass, may indicate a feeling for more industrialized design. Photos of renderings of completed work are almost a must, and should be periodically changed to offset any feeling that only a few projects turned out well enough to display proudly. Cheerful, courteous, well-groomed personnel also reflect the office feeling and prompt attention to phone calls, mailings, and similar work strengthens the public's feeling of competency. 9. OTHER APPROACHES A number of more minor public relations activities may bring new contacts or retain con- tacts with former clients. Attendance at openings by a principal of the office is a must and quite often is accompanied with appropriate flowers or card of congratulations. Keep up a good relationship with contractors, real estate people, manufacturer's representatives and other who may have contracts through their businesses or social groups that the architects does not have. Christmas card and birthday or anniversary cards also serves as a reminder, to past or possible clients, that you are still in business and available if needed. Other opportunities will present themselves from time to time and the A/E should be able to work out methods depending upon type of client, type of project, and his own desire or ability to perform. Remember however, that in the long run, the well-designed building and the pleased client are the two important public relations devices that any professional may have. BUSINESS ASPECTS OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE 1. ARCHITECT'S CAPITAL In order to engage in the practice of architecture, one must have some tools and equipments before the practice has been established long. Also some money presumably will been earned. Some of this earnings may not be due, some may be due but not collected in lieu of cash. If services are paid in cash, a part of the cash may be left in the treasury of the firm. It is also convenient to use credit with firms from whom purchases are made. 2. ASSETS Anything owned that has exchange value: a) Cash – may be changed for something else at any time. b) Accounts Receivable – consist of sums of money owned by the business and which are due. c) Prepaid – some of the income of the business may be earned but not yet due. As an example, accrued income, if working drawing is done halfway, it is accrued while the preliminary sketches are accounts receivable. 3. INVESTMENTS These are usually securities, but might include real property owned by the firm but not used for its practice. The purpose is to enable the firm to earn some income on the money which has been set up in reserve funds. 4. PHYSICAL PLANTS a) Automobiles - The most sellable item. In any Architectural practice, one automobile for use at least part of the time is necessity. b) Library - the second most sellable item is an up to date Library, which is essential for progressive, intelligent practice. c) Models and Art Objects - As an aid to developing an impressive atmosphere. This may help to stimulate business. d) Furniture and Appliances - More essential part. These may have somewhat the same as art object, but the use is mainly necessary to carry on the work of the firm. e) Alterations of Leased Property - If office space is rented, it is often necessary for alterations as to make it more suitable. f) Building - If the firm own the building it occupies, its value would be called asset entitled building. 5. LIABILITIES There are items of indebtedness of a business a) Vouchers Payable - payable items among liabilities. The most urgent are current bills. b) Notes Payable - money is from the bank or a loan from an individual or business, a written promise called the note is usually given bearing interest and due at a stated time. c) Prepaid Income - it may happen in practice that a client will pay in advance for services to be rendered. If this is done, the architect owes the client the service. d) Accrued Expense - such as the salary of an employee which is earned but not yet due. e) Long Term Indebtedness it might be that a firm would find it wise to buy or build a building or any additional equipment which would be paid for over a period of more than a year. This is a liability. 6. NET WORTH a) Capital Investment - when assets are purchased for the conduct of a business, part of the money may be borrowed and part furnished by the owners of the business. b) Reserve for Slack Periods - The probability that some time in the near future there will be a period during which the volume of the work in the office is insufficient to operate the business at a profit provided for by the establishment of a fund. c) Surplus - Any profit left in the business in addition to reserve funds. 7. PROFIT AND LOSS SYSTEM If a man produces more of anything than he and his family wish to consume, he may: a) Trade it to someone who has surplus of something he may want. b) He may save it for future use. Accumulation of money by an individual may mean a) that more value has been produced by him than he has consumed. b) that by assuming risks, he made profits. c) That he has loaned part of his accumulation to others with interest. 8. ARCHITECT INCOME & EXPENSE An architectural office, operating successfully under our present economic system should make profit where conditions are normal. To accomplish this, the total income should exceed the total expense. If a firm is to avoid bankruptcy, when losses results from its operations, it is necessary that a reserve fund be accomplished from profits during periods which are normal. When responsibility, such as that assumed by an architect, must be carried, risks of loss goes with it. Some risks can be recovered by insurance but every enterpriser must carry the principal risks of his business. Possible current uses, therefore, often are provided for by a reserve funds which may be called reserved for emergency. Payments for service rendered by architects should be in proportion to their professional ability. Salaries should be large enough to serve as recognition of the long years of training and the high caliber of native ability required. Since an architect may usually be more valuable to his own firm than another, the salaries of the principals of a firm should be somewhat higher than could be earned by some individuals as employees of another architectural firm. The income from the operation of an architectural practice comes mostly from fees from clients. Income is really earned at the times the service is rendered rather than when the service is paid for. An architectural firm might possible be successful therefore, during a period when more money is being paid out than received. If a firm has accumulated earnings for reserve funds, and surplus, this should be invested. This produces more income in form of interest or dividends from the investments. Such income is called non-operating income. Non-operating expense is usually small, being limited principally to the actual expense of managing investments, including payment for time devoted to his activity. 9. OPERATING EXPENSE INCLUDES 1) Direct expense - includes all items which are incurred in connection with definite building projects. a. Job development b. Production c. Administration *Ex: salaries of technical personnel cost of consulting service cost of blueprints & reproductions traveling and living expenses outside of agreed local area. Long distance and telegraphic message cost of expendable drafting materials. 2) Overhead Expenses - includes all items which continue whether or not there are many jobs in the office. Ex: telephone and telegraph charges, photographs, use of office and drafting equipments, office supplies, salaries of non-technical personnel use of library, transportation, management salaries, taxes licenses, contributions, gifts. Formula: Profit = income – expense 10. SALARY, PROFIT AND OVERHEAD It is worthwhile for an architect to establish his own practice, that practice should pay him a salary at least as large as the salary he would receive where he is employed by another firm. If the work of the Architectural Office is being carried on from the home, a charge should be made for lights, heat and janitor service. Also a portion of the telephone bills, a portion of automobile expense and a portion of depreciation of automobile should be charge against the business. NOTES ON PRACTICE MANAGEMENT: MARKETING (By: Eduardo L. Roberto, Ph.D.) ● What is Marketing in the Practice of the Architectural Profession? If Architecture is the art and science of building then Marketing is the art and science of satisfying building needs better than now or better than others. ● What is Marketing as a Management Area? It is one of the management functions carried out through the four management processes. MANAGEMENT FUNCTIONS 1. MARKETING 2. OPERATIONS 3. FINANCE PLANNING What are the Management Processes? ● What is Planning? ○ Deciding what to do now to improve the future. ● What is Organizing? ○ Deciding who will do what with and under whom. ● What is Implementing? ○ Deciding how to do what, when and by whom. ● What is Controlling? ○ Deciding how well plans were organized and implemented so that the next planning, organizing and implementing will be better ● What are the management functions? ○ Look at your income statement: Pro forma with ratios ITEMS (Under marketing) Income: Architectural Service Fees Miscellaneous (Under Operations) EXPENSES: Salaries Professional Fees Communication Transportation and travel Depreciation Materials and supplies Rentals Utilities Light Water Telephone Amortization of Pre Operating Expenses Repairs and Maintenance Insurance Taxes and Licenses Representation and entertainment Interest and bank charges Miscellaneous (Under finance) Expenses of income over expenses YEARS 100% 99.1 0.9 99.2% 34.2 17.3 5.7 12.7 7.8 6.3 3.0 3.2 0.9 1.2 0.9 0.6 4.0 0.3 1.1 0.8%