A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE NARCOTICS CONTROL ACT, 2018 Submitted by Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk Supervised by Abdullah Al Aman Assistant Professor January 2023 DEPARTMENT OF LAW STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH i CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF DRUG CONTROLLING ACT Submitted by Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk ID: LL.B 06910003 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of LL.B. (Honours) of Law Supervised by Abdullah Al Aman Assistant Professor January 2023 DEPARTMENT OF LAW STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH ii LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL To Abdullah Al Aman Assistant Professor Department of Law Stamford University Bangladesh Subject: Submission of thesis paper. Dear Sir, It is a great pleasure to submit my thesis on ‘Critical Analysis of Drug Controlling Act’ I have given best efforts to finish the thesis with relevant information that I have collected from various sources. I have collected from various sources. I have concentrated my efforts to achieve to objectives of the work and hope that my endeavor will serve the purpose. I shall be grateful and obliged if you kindly accept may thesis and evaluate it. Sincerely yours, ----------------------------Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk ID: LL.B 06910003 Department of Law Stamford University Bangladesh iii DECLARATION I Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk, the student of Law, batch 69 A, bearing ID: LLB 06910003 ‘Critical Analysis of drug controlling Act’ from Stamford University Bangladesh would like to declare here, the declaration on the dissertation report on ‘Critical Analysis of drug controlling Act’ which I have not submitted for any other degree before, The work I have presented dose not breach any copyright. I further undertake to indemnify the university against any loss or damage arising from breach of the foregoing obligations. ……………………........ Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk ID: LL.B 06910003 Department of Law Stamford University Bangladesh iv CERTIFICATION This is to certify that the dissertation on ‘Critical Analysis of Drug Controlling Act’ is done by Md. Ariful Islam Mishuk, Batch 69 A, ID- LLB 06910003 in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of LL.B. (Honours) from Stamford University Bangladesh. The dissertation has been carried out under my guidance and is a record of the bona-fide work carried out successfully. ---------------------------Abdullah Al Aman Assistant Professor Department of Law Stamford University Bangladesh v ABSTRACT This thesis has emphasized on the causation of drug controlling. Abuse of narcotics is a multi-dimensional serious problem across the world. Among the major problems the modern world facing-abuse and illicit trafficking of narcotics is the significant one. Bangladesh is not a drug producing country but suffering from this problem due to its geographical proximities. From the historical point of view, evidence shows the traditional use of drugs in this country. During the Mughal and Re- British era, the use of alcohol, opium and cannabis was common in different festival and religions ceremony. British rulers started opium cultivation as commercial operation to collect revenue. Multicultural social life sometimes inspired the use of drugs in this region. With the rapid development of our economy alongside the digitalization, Bangladesh is encountering a great challenge to save her young generation from the course of drug abuse. The Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh realized the backdrop and enacted the Narcotics Control Act, 1990. This enactment was the principal tool before enacting The Narcotics Control Act, 2018 to control drug menace in the land and provides provisions to create mass awareness and treatment to the drug patient. This paper will attempt to overview the laws for drugs control in Bangladesh. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No Acknowledgement ix Chapter 1 Introduction Introduction 1 Chapter 2 General Concept Alcoholism and Drug 2.1 Concept of Alcoholism 3 2.2 Nature of Alcoholism 3 2.3 Effect of Alcoholism 4 2.4 Alcohol - The Negative and Positive Aspects 5 2.5 Main Causes of Drug Addiction 6 2.6 Classification of Drug 8 Chapter 3 Present Scenario and Government Steps 3.1 Current Scenario of Use of Narcotics in Bangladesh 11 3.2 Narcotics Control Activities in Bangladesh 13 vii Chapter 4 Narcotics Control Act, 2018 and Other Law Relating to Prevention of Alcoholism 4.1 Introduction 17 4.2 Laws to Prevent Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism 17 4.3 Policy and Legislation 18 4.4 Plans and Programs 19 4.5 International Cooperation 20 4.6 Methods of Prevention and Control 21 4.7 Compare with Narcotics Controls Act 2018 and Old Law 27 4.8 Loopholes of Narcotics Control Act 2018 29 4.9 Loopholes of Narcotics Control Act 1990 30 Chapter 5 Program to Prevent Alcoholism and Drug Abuse 5.1 Drug and Alcohol Abuse Prevention Program 32 Chapter 6 Recommendations and Conclusion 6.1 Recommendations 34 6.2 Conclusion 36 REFERENCES 40 viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT First of all, I wish to acknowledge the immeasurable grace and propound kindness of the Almighty God I express my gratitude to my honorable thesis supervisor Abdullah Al Aman, Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Stamford University Bangladesh for giving me the opportunity to complete my thesis report under his supervision. He gave me his valuable time and important information to complete the thesis. I also express my gratefulness to my parents and my family members who encouraged me all the times. Finally I am also grateful to the Department of Law, Stamford University Bangladesh, for providing me such an opportunity to come closer to the real situation. ix viii Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION Bangladesh became independent in 1971. After independence the laws, enacted during British and Pakistan period, remain in force in Bangladesh. So naturally Opium Act, 1857, Opinum Act, 1878, Excise Act, 1909, Dangerous Drugs Act, 1930 and Opium Smoking Act, 1932 are enforced in Bangladesh. But these are not sufficient to make the country free from addiction. That is why “Intoxicant Control Ordinance, 1989” a more effective law, was declared.xvi Subsequently it was passed in the parliament as “The Intoxicant Control Act, 1990. Recently, narcotics addiction has significantly increased in worldwide, especially in the south Asian countries like Bangladesh. In our country, this agent of human devastation has tract its black paw to every nook and cranny. Specially, this drug addiction number is increasing day by day among the young generation. This alarming condition is already reported by the United Nations and World Health Organization (WHO). 1 Alcoholism and drug addiction may be conceptualized as crime without victim. Suppose addict himself is the victim who becomes a prey of its misuse2.This devastating melody is eroding the roots of social, economic and cultural fibred of the 1 Ahmed Siddique, Criminology: Problems and Perspective, 5th ed. (Lucknow: Eastern Book Company. 2005), p. 434. 2 P. Kundram & V.N. Murty, “ drug Abuse And Crime : A Preliminary Study” (1979) 7 Indian Jour Crime 65-68. [www.googlesearch.Com last visited on 29 December 2023]. 1 society. It gives rise to criminality and criminal behaviour which eventually leads to social disorganization.3 Drug abuse is increasing day by day from bottom to top around the country. Though Bangladesh Government has taken hard policy and action against drug abuse but its success depends on implementation of the amended Narcotics Control Act 2018. As per Narcotics Control Act 2018, any person could be sentenced to death for carrying, trading, storing or processing yaba weighing over five grams and any institution, patronizes, individual supplies or invest or colludes in drug crimes. If anyone carries, trades, stores, or processes yaba weighing less than five grams, he or she could be sentenced to five year jail and fined. There also has such serious punishment for other types of drug abuse. However, there are various punishment for carrying, trading, processing, supplying the narcotics and agonist product in the amendment of 2018. 3 N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009), p.152 2 Chapter 2 GENERAL CONCEPT ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG 2.1 Concept of Alcoholism Alcoholism, also known as alcohol use disorder (AUD), is a broad term for any drinking of alcohol that results in mental or physical health problems. The disorder was previously divided into two types: alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence. 2.2 Nature of Alcoholism Like Drug addiction alcoholism is also an addiction. Alcohol gets into the bloodstream so the effects can be almost immediate, but it can take hours to wear off depending on size, weight, what is drinking, how strong it is and how much is drink. Alcoholism is present when a person craves alcohol and cannot limit or contain his or her drinking. If someone experiences withdrawal symptoms such as nausea, sweating, shakiness, or anxiety when alcohol consumption has ceased, or if there is a need to drink greater amounts of alcohol in order to feel a high, that person is most likely alcoholic. Some may think that it’s just a matter of having the will to stop drinking, but alcoholism is more complicated than that. An alcoholic’s craving for alcohol is so great that it suppresses their ability to stop drinking. The majority of alcoholics need assistance to stop drinking. With treatment and support from family and friends, many have been able to stop drinking and rebuild their lives. It is a sad fact however that there are still some who are unable to stop in spite of these aids. Alcohol kills more teens annually than all other drugs combined. It is a factor in the three leading causes of death in the 15-24 age groups in the U.S. accidents, 3 homicides and suicides. Binge drinking and chronic alcohol use are also associated with many health problems.4 2.3 Effect of Alcoholism Short-term effects of Alcoholism Slurred speech Vomiting Drowsiness Distorted vision, hearing and coordination Impaired judgment Headaches Breathing difficulties Poor perception and coordination Unconsciousness Coma Long-term effects: 4 Unintentional injury (e.g., car crashes, falls, burns, drowning) Intentional injury (e.g., firearm injuries, sexual assault, domestic violence) Broken relationships High blood pressure and strokes Liver disease Brain and nerve damage Sexual dysfunction Ulcers Gastritis (inflammation of stomach walls) Malnutrition Ibid. p. 192. 4 Cancer of the mouth and throat 2.4 Alcohol - The Negative and Positive Aspects The effects of alcohol, as is generally known, are damaging to the individual as well as to society. As mentioned above, however, positive or negative, the effects of alcohol can be viewed from two angels - from the points of view of effect on the individual consumer and on social groups of individuals. So far as the positive effects on the individual are concerned, alcohol can reduce tension, guilt feelings, anxiety and frustration. As regards the damaging aspect, it can impair physical, moral and mental health. It lowers sensitivity, efficiency and caution in a person. Deterioration of sense of timing and balance may also occur. Inhibitions are reduced when alcohol is consumed but revert back when the person is sober. This gives rise to irregular and erratic behaviour, a phenomenon more dangerous in a complex society since the task of integrating an individual with the group is far more formidable in a complex society than what it was in a relatively simper society. Cirrhosis of liver, ‘alcoholic jealously’ delirium tremens and dimignition in libido are among the more specific troubles which may be caused by heavy drinking. 5 Perhaps the only social good with which alcohol can be credited is that it provides social opportunities, not otherwise available, for inter-personal exchange of ideas, particularly to socially frustrated individuals. Alcohol, in its negatives aspect, has tremendous potentialities. It may give rise, directly or indirectly, to various crimes. An alcoholic may neglect his social and family obligations. Consumption of liquor may lead to financial problems generating a number of family suffering in nonaffluent countries like India. Worst of all, the moral fabric of the family may eventually be damaged beyond redemption. 5 Ahmed Siddique, Criminology: Problems and Perspective, 4th ed. (Lucknow: Eastern Book Company. 2001) p. 435. 5 Scientists say that someone who has alcoholic addiction in his/her family is more likely to develop alcoholism if they choose to drink. Alcoholism can also develop or worsen based on a person’s environment and traumatic experiences in life. These factors may include culture, family, friends, peer pressures, and the way the person lives.6 Alcoholism can lead people into serious trouble, and can be physically and mentally destructive. Currently alcohol use is involved in half of all crimes, murders, accidental deaths, and suicides. 3 There are also many health problems associated with alcohol use such as brain damage, cancer, heart disease, and diseases of the liver. Alcoholics who do not stop drinking reduce life expectancy by 10 to 15 years. Too much alcohol can destroy brain cells, possibly leading to brain damage. Alcohol greatly disturbs the structure and function of the central nervous system, hindering the ability to retrieve, consolidate, and process information. Moderate consumption of alcohol can affect cognitive abilities while large amounts interfere with the oxygen supply of the brain causing a blackout when totally drunk. Alcohol addiction may also inflame the mouth, oesophagus, and stomach, and could cause cancer in these areas, especially in drinkers who also smoke. Splurge drinking may produce irregular heartbeats, and abusers experience a higher risk of high-blood pressure, heart attacks, and other heart damage. Alcohol also can harm vision, damage sexual function, slow circulation, is the grounds for malnutrition, and water retention. It can also lead to skin and pancreatic disorders weaken the bones and muscles, thus, decreasing immunity. 7 2.5 Main Causes of Drug Addiction There are many reasons why you might begin taking drugs. It might be a case of your friends are taking drugs which pressures you to do the same. Ask yourself. are these 6 [http://www.alaboutgod.com/truth/2peter-2.htm, last visited on 29 December 2022]. 7 [http://www.alaboutgod.com/truth/2peter-2.htm, last visited on 29 December 2022]. 6 real friends? Real friends would not put pressure on you to take something that is bad for you. It may be a hard decision to make but the best thing you can do is say no and walk away One of the typical causes of drug addiction is the inability to cope with crisis. Loss, disappointment, feelings of rejection, loneliness, and failure frequently lead to physical and emotional symptoms. As symptoms of headaches, tension, sleeplessness, and depression increase, medications become a solution. Some will get prescriptions from a physician or try to medicate themselves. Not only has that but also had some causes of drug addiction. I am giving a description about it. 1. The lack of parental care and control partly due to working situation of both spouses and disintegration of joint family system are also contributing factors to encourage this vice. It also spread among the middle, upper- middle, and high economic class families. Urban areas seem to be more affected by this vice.8 2. The recent developments of in pharmaceutical and medical sciences have provided scope for production of variety of toxic synthetic substances. This has contributed substantially to drug abuse and addiction. 9 3. People often take drugs for relief from painful illness and ultimately get addicted to it. Besides, there are some addicts whose neurological heritage is such that they find it difficult to survive with out the use of alcohol or narcotic drugs and this ultimately makes them habitual alcoholics or drug addicts.10 4. Frustration and emotional stress due to failures, sorrows miseries of life, diverts people to join the company of addicts. For them drugs or alcohol is a medicine - a blessing disguise11. In course of time they become addicted to this vice.12 8 N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009), p.192. 9 Ibid, p. 192. 10 ibid, p. 193. 11 Jeorge Caltin E.G.: Alcoholism In the Encyclopedia of Social Science (1930) p. 155. 12 N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009), 7 5. Hippie-culture detracts youngsters to drug addiction and they start it as a ‘fun’ or enjoyment. They start consuming drugs or alcohol on an experimental basis out of fun and enjoyment. The frequency of consumption gradually increases due to its narcotic effect and finally a good majority of them turn out to be drug addicts and habitual.13 6. The lack of knowledge of child psychology and communication gap between parents and young addicts are also contributory factors for drug-abuse and alcoholism. people who do manual work often believe that use of drugs such asalcohol, opium, ganja etc. Provides them added strength and vigour to withstand hard labour. This delusion of physical vitality by use of alcohol or narcotic drugs ultimately makes them confirmed addicts.14 7. Social disorganization is also a contributing factor for the menace of drug abuse or misuse. Frequent family strife’s and breakdowns due to poverty, temperamental differences, neighbourhood influences etc. may divert a person to alcohol or drug consumption to overcome his domestic and family problems. This may itself be a cause of tension and quarrel in the family. Such persons ultimately fall a prey to drug abuse.15 Thus the process of alcoholism and drug-addiction sets in when a person knowingly or unknowingly begins to consume alcohol or narcotic drug as a medicine for a sound sleep at night or to get stimulation for work or to get relief from domestic problems or to press depression, resentment, or to get rid of disturbing mental restless and so on. He prefers to remain in the world of imagination rather than facing realities of life. Gradually, he becomes addicted to alcohol or drug consumption and his p. 193 13 Ibid, p. 193. 14 Ibid, p. 193. 15 Ibid, p. 193. 8 dependence on these intoxicants increases at relatively faster rate. Finally, he reaches a stage when he cannot live without wine or drug since it becomes his life habit.16 2.6 Classification of Drug The international Convention on Drugs to which India to which India is a signatory gas classified drugs fewer than two categories, a) Narcotic Drugs, b) Psychotropic Substances. a) Narcotic Drugs:- The main drugs covered under this head are the following : i) Opium (is generally used as pain killer) and its derives like brown sugar, heroin and codeine. ii) Coco leaf, cocaine. iii) Cannabis (ganja) cannabis resin, extracts and tinctures. iv) Methadone, pethedine, hebaine. b) Psychotropic Substances includes valium, diazepam, tidiest, morphine etc.17 There are three types of drugs available in use in Bangladesh.18 1. Opium a) Heroin b) Phensidyl c)Tidijesic d) Pethidine e) Opium 2. Cannabis a) Ganja b) Chorosh 16 17 18 ibid, p. 193. ibid, p. 197. Drug Addiction and Social Damage, Date of Publishing: 10 March 2001 9 c) Bhang 3. Sleeping pill a) Tranquilizer The intoxicants are also classified in the following manner: A Class Intoxicants- This class includes- Opium, Poppy, any Afim, Opium Derivatives-(viz- Morphine, Codeine, Thebaine, Noscapaine, Norco tine, Papavarine etc), any artificial intoxicants like Afim ( viz- Pethidene, Meperdine, Methadone, Dextromoramide, Dilydrocodeine, Meperdine Fentanyl, Pentaxocaine, Hydrophine, Omnepone, Alphaprodine, Demeral, Oxycodone, Etrophine, Lofentanyl, Alfentynyl, Alphamethy Fentanyl, 3-Methyl Fentanyl, Asscetrophine, Acetylmethadol, Alphacetyl-methadol, Betaprodine), Cocaine, Cocaine derivatives, Tetrahydrocanbinal, Cannabis resin, Charas, Hashish, Acetic anhydride, Mescaline etc. B Class Intoxicants- This class includes- Hemp plant, Herbal cannabis, Vang Vang tree or such other trees used as source of addiction, Alcohol, All types of wine, rectified spirit, Beer, LSD, Barbiturates, Amphetamine, Methyl Amphetamine, Phencyclidine, Psilicybin, Nicocodine, Methaqualone. C Class Intoxicants- This class includes Tare, Pochuie, Denatured spirit, Methylated spirit, Chlordiazepoxied, Diazepam, Oxazepam, Lorazepam, Flurazepam, Clorozepate, Nitrazepam, 10 Chapter 3 PRESENT SCENARIO AND GOVERNMENT STEPS 3.1 Current Scenario of Use of Narcotics in Bangladesh 3.1.1 Yaba The ‘crazy medicine’ called Amphetamine (Yaba) has become the drug of choice among the young generation over the past few years as it is cheap, potent, easy to carry and highly addictive. A densely populated nation of about 160 million people, Bangladesh is now on the front lines of the yaba epidemic. Yaba is mainly smuggled through the Bangladesh-Myanmar border at the extreme South-Eastern area of Cox’s Bazar District. Most of the drugs other than Yaba are smuggled into Bangladesh through the borders of Satkhira,Jessore,Rajshahi, Joypurhat and Dinajpur along the Western region and Cumilla and Brahmanbaria along the Eastern region. According to the recent seizure statistics and reliable data, the major drug market is Dhaka.The seizures of yaba are made 25.73% at Dhaka Zone, 69.22% at Chittagong Zone, 2.20% at Barisal Zone & 0.24% at SylhetZone.More than 69% of the seizure of Yaba is made at Chittagong because border of Cox’s Bazar of Chittagong Zone is the route of smuggling Yaba into Bangladesh. Though the seizure of Yaba at Dhaka is more than 25%,it still remains one of the biggest markets of Yaba in Bangladesh. 3.1.2 Heroin Heroin is a highly addictive illegal drug that belongs to the opioid family. It is synthesized from morphine, which is an opiate chemical deived from the opium poppy. In its purest form, heroin is a fine white powder. But more often, it is found to 11 be rose grey, brown or black in color. Bangladesh is in between the Golden Triangle(Thiland,Myanmar and Loas) and the Golden Crescent (Iran,Pakistan and Afghanistan). This is the major reason that made it epidemic level in Bangladesh. The seizures of Heroin were 15.89% in Dhaka Zone,0.96% in Chattagong Zone, 73.21% in Rajshahi Zone,9.61% in Khulna Zone,0.08% in Barishal Zone and .37% in SylhetZone.Therefore it appears that Rajshahi Zone has the highest prevalence of seizure of Heroin. 3.1.3 Phensedyl One of the largest illicit drugs consumption in Bangladesh is Phensedyl,a codeinebased cough syrup, which is largely smuggled through North-East side of India. Codeine, one of the primary active ingredients in phensedyl, is a strong opiate which is highly addictive and commonly misused. According to the statistics, the seizures of phensedylwas 7.27% in Dhaka Zone,14.36% in Chittagong Zone, 50.35% in Rajshahi Zone,25.82% in Khulna Zone,0.33% in Barishal Zone and 1.87% in Sylhet Zone.The Phensedyl affected areas of the country are Dhaka Metropolitan & the adjacent areas of Dhaka Metropolitan and Mymensingh of Dhaka zone, Jessore&Chuadanga of Khulna Zone, Brahmanbaria of Chittagong Zone and Rajshahi, Bogura, Noagaon, ChapaiNawabgonj and Dinajpur of Rajshahi Zone. Abuse of Phensedyl is now in a decreasing trend. 3.1.4 Alcohol The problen of alcorolism is becoming a threat to the nation's welfare. Although the problem is more serious in urban areas. Alcohol consumption in Bangladesh is greatly lower than the global average and western countries. Local alcoholic beverages called Cholai and Tari are consumed by the lower socio-economiacclasses, while workers drink another distilled beverage called Bangla Mod. The tribal communities of Hill Tract areas and among the Garo community in greater Mymenshing hand the Shaontal community, the labors of tea gardens and 12 some lower castes and low-profession people called Sweeper, Dom, Cobbler, Dhangors and Meth are used to drink home made alcoholic beverage reqularly. The seizure of illicit country liquor & Cholai mod during the year 2016 was 20,036.41 liters and the amount of foreign liquor in that period was 101.02 liters,4837 bottles and 13203 cans of Beer. During the year 2016 the Department of Narcotics Control detected a total of 9773 cases (including cases in Mobile Court) andmade 10465 arrests (including arrests in Mobile Court) of which 1079 (11.04%) cases and 1150 (10.99%) arrests were relaled to offtenes in connection with alcohol. According to the data of drug addiction treatment services, only 1.03% of the treatment seekers have problem with addiction to alcohol. People with alcohol habit very rarely seek treatment because it does not hamper their regular life and consequences of alcohol abuse is not visible like the problem of abuse of Yaba, heroin, Phensedyl or iniecting drugs19. 3.2 Narcotics Control Activities in Bangladesh Bangladesh faces a multitude of drug control challenges for its geographical location. Opiates, cannabis and amphetamine-type stimulants remain the main substances of concern, with record levels of cannabis herb seized in Bangladesh and India during 2017. There has been a thirtyfold increase in seizures of methamphetamine pills known as “yaba” in Bangladesh since 2011, and the amounts of illicitly produced opiates seized throughout the region have been increasing. The diversion of controlled substances, particularly ephedrine and pseudoephedrine, from licit to illicit channels has continued, as has the smuggling of pharmaceutical preparations containing narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, notably codeine-based cough syrups, which remain a considerable challenge in Bangladesh. There is a growing evidence of an emerging modus operandi of drug trafficking in the region that involves the use of the Internet as a marketplace for drugs and precursors, with mail or courier services being used for delivery. A comparatively large number of parcels containing controlled substances have been 19 [<https://anual drug report 2016>visited on 01 January 2023]. 13 seized. However, little is known about the extent of regulations applicable to Internet pharmacies and business-to-business platforms acting as intermediaries between buyers and sellers or about the role that express courier service providers play in the cross border movement of controlled and non-scheduled substances. Illicit cannabis cultivation is an issue of concern in Bangladesh. Illicit cannabis cultivation remains a challenge in the country. It remains the most frequently seized narcotic drug in Bangladesh. Bangladesh eradicated 69,989 illicitly cultivated cannabis plants in 2017, the highest number of such plants eradicated in the last seven years in the country, and almost double the number of plants eradicated in 2013. In order of magnitude, Bangladesh recorded the next-largest quantity of cannabis herb seized in the region, with close to 70 tons seized in 2017. While seizures of cannabis herb have not fallen below 10 tons since the beginning of the decade, the amount seized in 2017was by far the highest since 2010. Following a steady increase since 2014, the amount seized in 2017 was more than triple the amount seized in that year (17 tons in2014, 42 tons in 2015 and 47 tons in 2016). In most cases, cannabis herb is trafficked into Bangladesh from neighboring countries. Bangladesh seized 401 kg of heroin in 2017, the highest amount of heroin seized in the last eight years, following significant year-on-year increases since 2014(30 kg in 2014, 110 kg in 2015 and 267 kg in 2016). The amounts of other illicitly produced opiates seized over the same period were very small. Seizures of pharmaceutical uploads, which caused serious problems at the beginning of the decade (more than 4.1 tons were seized in 2010),have been in decline, with only a nominal amount seizedin 201720. Codeine-based cough syrups sold under different trade names (e.g., Phensedyl and Corex) have continuedto be seized. Codeine is trafficked mainly along the border between India and Bangladesh. These pharmaceutical preparations are mostly produced in India, often transported by road in trucks and trains and then trafficked 20 [<https://gulfnews.com/world/asia/bangladesh-makes-record-drugs-seizure> January 2023]. 14 visited on 01 across the border into Bangladesh. In the first six months of 2018, the Department of Narcotics Control seized large number of cough syrup. Amphetamine-type stimulants “Yaba” remain drugs of considerable concern in our country. “Yaba” (methamphetamine)tablets have been seized in increasing numbers. “Yaba” methamphetamine was the second most seized drug in 2017 after cannabis herb, with 3.6 tonsseized. This represents the highest quantity of methamphetamine seized in the past eight years in Bangladesh and a more than tenfold increase over the amount seizedin 2016 (355 kg). In 2016, the Department of Narcotics Control in Bangladesh reported seizing close to 30 million“yaba” pills. “Yaba” tablets, the methamphetamine-caffeine compound associated with the drug abuse crisis in Bangladesh, are entering from Myanmar. Virtually, the non-medical use of pharmaceutical drugs containing controlled substances continues to be prevalent. The preparations in question include codeinebased cough syrups sold under different trade names, such as Corex and Phensedyl. Drug abuse has become a major concern in our country in recent years. Illegal drug use, abuse and addiction are serious problemsinour country. National Survey on Drug Use and Health found that 10 percent of the total population use illegal drugs. It also reported that most of them are struggling with either substance abuse or dependence. They further reported that, among men aged 18 to 35, about 4 per cent were dependent on opioids. The majority of those men (53 per cent) reportedly used heroin, about 33 per cent used opium and some 14 per cent used a variety of pharmaceutical opioids. Since 2017, the Government of Bangladesh has severely restricted the distribution of pseudoephedrine preparations in the country. Pseudoephedrine is the prime precursor for the illicit manufacture of “yaba” and is mainly imported into Bangladesh from India and Myanmar. However, statistics maintained by the Department of Narcotics Control with regard to patients of national treatment centres showed that, in 2016, for the first time in three years, heroin ranked first among the drugs in respect of which treatment had primarily been provided: a little over a third of patients were primarily treated for heroin abuse, about a third of patients for abuse of “yaba” and less than a fifth of patients for cannabis abuse. Figures have fluctuated 15 over the period 2012–2016 in Bangladesh, with only one consistently discernible trend concerning the use of “yaba”: in 2012, close to 6 per cent of patients were treated primarily for methamphetamine abuse, a proportion that had increased fivefold by 2016. In May 2018, Bangladesh declared a “war on drugs”, which has reportedly resulted in the deaths, at the hands of law enforcement officials, of hundreds of people suspected of drug trafficking21. Summary trials of drug offenders through “mobile drug courts”, in which suspects are prosecuted and sentenced on the spot, have been operational for a number of years, with conviction rates of close to 100 per cent (in 2016, for example, there were 6,591 convictions and 1 acquittal). However, targeted drug law enforcement operations with large numbers of suspects reportedly killed as a result is an unprecedented development in the country. Under the international drug control conventions, drug-related crime must be addressed through formal criminal justice responses, including internationally recognized due process standards. In October 2018, Bangladesh extended the application of the death penalty to drug-related offences involving more than 200 g of methamphetamine (“yaba”), which is widely abused in the country, and reclassified the substance as a class-A narcotic drug. 21 [<http://www.dnc.gov.bd> visited on 01 January 2023]. 16 Chapter 4 NARCOTICS CONTROL ACT, 2018 AND OTHER LAW RELATING TO PREVENTION OF ALCOHOLISM 4.1 Introduction Alcohol is psychologically and physically addictive. Frequent drinking can lead to alcoholism. The government tries to prevent alcohol abuse and alcoholism through laws and public awareness. It is important that people recognize the signs of alcoholism at an early stage. A doctor who suspects that a patient is drinking too much should refer the patient quickly to an appropriate care provider. 4.2 Laws to Prevent Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism There are several laws governing alcohol and alcohol consumption. The Licensing and Catering Act sets rules about where alcohol may be sold, and prohibits the sale of alcohol to anyone under the age of 18.Local authorities check compliance with the Licensing and Catering Act. Besides the Licensing and Catering Act, there are other rules and regulations on alcohol use too: The Criminal Code says that it is a criminal offence to be drunk in public and to disturb the public order while intoxicated. The Criminal Code also says that it is a criminal offence to serve alcohol to someone who is obviously drunk. The Road Traffic Act sets limits for alcohol in the blood for drivers. The limit is 0.05% for drivers with a egular driving licence, and 0.02% for new drivers. The Media Act does 17 not allow alcohol commercials to be broadcast on television and radio between 6.00 and 21.00.22 4.3 Policy and Legislation The government of Bangladesh recognizes drug abuse as one of the most serious problems and is firmly committed to supporting international, regional and bilateral efforts aimed at its prevention and control. The national drug enforcement policy is embedded in the Narcotics Control Act 1990. The government took measures to amend the Narcotics Control Act 1990 in line with UN Conventions. The major features of drug abuse prevention and control in this legislation are: 1. Establishment of the National Narcotics Control Board (NNCB) with the task of drug abuse prevention and control, and to encourage foreign and domestic participation in drug control activities; 2. Compulsory treatment of drug addiction; 3. Establishment of drug treatment canters; 4. Obligation of organizations and individuals to supply information on drug abuse; 5. Restrictions and control on prescription of certain drugs which lead to addiction if abused; 6. Control of production, distribution, prescription, sale and use of sedative, hypnotic and tranquillizer drugs; 7. Classification of scheduling of drugs according to control measures and intensity of harmful effects; 8. Different types of punishment for different drug offences according to the severity of their nature and quantity of drugs involved; 9. Financial investigation of drug crimes; 22 [https://www.government.nl/topics/alcohol/preventing-alcohol-abuse-and-alcoholism last visited date on 05.01. 2023]. 18 10. Freezing and forfeiture of assets of drug traffickers; and 11. Establishment of drug testing laboratory to speed up the trial of drug cases. 23 4.4 Plans and Programs With financial and technical support from the United Nations Drug Control Program (UNDCP) the government of Bangladesh undertook a Five Year Master Plan for drug abuse control in Bangladesh. The plan is divided into three sectors - Law Enforcement and Legal Assistance, Preventive Education and Information, and Treatment and Rehabilitation. The implementation of this Master Plan started in 1994. Its major components are: constancy and technical assistance regarding program development, policy formulation, updating laws and regulations; training (overseas and domestic) of personnel of government and non-government organizations; workshops; supply of transport, logistics and equipment; community intervention programs; and social awareness campaigns. The government believes that the fight against drug is a multi-disciplinary task, and it must be accomplished by individuals and organizations from all concerned fields. The organizations entrusted with drug prevention activities in Bangladesh are the Department of Narcotics Control (DNC), Police, Customs, BDR and Coast Guard. The ministries of health and family planning, education, information, social welfare, and youth and sports are also involved in various aspects of drug abuse prevention. DNC is primarily responsible for administration and enforcement of national laws to control psychoactive drugs. Its total manpower is 1,274. It has 34 major offices throughout the country, which includes the headquarter at Dhaka zonal offices at divisional headquarters, 25 regional offices at major district headquarters and zonal intelligence offices. DNC headquarters has four major 23 [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM, last visited on 05.01. 2023]. 19 branches of administration and an Intelligence wing. A director supervises each of the four branches of administration. 24 4.5 International Cooperation Bangladesh inherited the partnership in the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs 1961. It became a signatory to the Convention on Psychotropic Substances 1971 and the UN Convention against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic substances 1988, and signed the SAARC Convention on Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances in 1990. Bangladesh celebrates international day against drug abuse and its illicit trafficking on 26 June nationwide each year through a variety of programs. Bangladesh entered into a bilateral agreement on technical assistance with the USA in 1993 for drug abuse prevention and control, and received communication equipment. The country has been provided with training facilities by DAP of the Colombo plan Bureau, SAARC, UNESCO, ILO and ESCAP. Bangladesh has hosted a number of SAARC workshops, seminars and symposium during the last few years. DNC has a close contact with the regional office of DEA based in New Delhi. Exchange of information with USA, UK, France, and India is being done through their Drug Liaison Officers posted at Dhaka. The country sends information regularly to the INCB at Vienna and the SDOMD at Colombo. It has also entered into a bilateral agreement with Myanmar for suppression of illicit traffic on drugs. It signed a Memorandum of Understanding with Iran for drug abuse prevention and control. Another bilateral agreement for prevention and control of drug abuse with India is under active consideration by our government. Training programs for all classes of DNC officials on various aspects of drug abuse prevention continue both at home and abroad. The overseas training programs are mainly sponsored by the Colombo Plan Bureau, SAARC, UNDCP, JICA, USLA, DEA and INM of USA, France and the British Government. Domestic training 24 [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM, last visited on 07.01. 2023] 20 programs are mainly sponsored and conducted by DNC itself. All officers from the rank of additional directors down to the rank of inspectors were provided with a number of basic and specialized training courses on various aspects of drug abuse prevention and control, covering the whole range of both demand and supply reduction activities. A core trainer group has also been developed within DNC. UNDCP's Drug Control Project in Bangladesh is also providing extensive training on both demand and supply reduction for DNC and other law enforcement agencies. Special workshops on law enforcement and legal assistance for orientation of judges, magistrates, and prosecutors are being conducted by DNC and UNDCP throughout the country.25 4.6 Methods of Prevention and Control Methods of prevention and control cover a considerable area of both supply and demand reduction. The major supply reduction activities in Bangladesh are: (a) Licensing, (b) Monitoring and Inspection, (c) Intelligence and Enforcement, (d) Crop Eradication and Destruction of Drugs, (e) Investigation, and (f) Prosecution and Sanctions. 4.6.1 Licensing Licensing is used in Bangladesh to control the production, processing, export, import, transport, distribution or sale, use or consumption of alcohol, spirit, alcoholcontaining products, and certain narcotic drugs used for medical purposes. The total number of different kinds of licenses under the control of DNC is 3,765. Licensing is an effective method to control and limit drug-supply facilities, their outlets, locations, types, numbers and activity-hours.26 25 [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM, last visited on 07.01. 2023] 26 Ibid. 21 4.6.2 Monitoring and Inspection Monitoring and inspection of the supply system of drugs is done by DNC through its field offices. Liquor shops are inspected once a month and others once a quarter. Officials above the rank of inspector can inspect any license whenever desired.27 4.6.3 Intelligence and Enforcement DNC directly hits the pipeline of drug supply through its intelligence and enforcement activities. Police, customs authorities, and Bangladesh Rifles are also directly doing this job. DNC carries out its enforcement activities through its 103 circle offices located throughout the country. Each circle has six-member staffs, which includes one inspector, one sub-inspector, one assistant sub-inspector and three sepoys. In spite of its shortage of manpower, scarcity of necessary equipment and training, DNC detects about 3,000 cases of drug abuse each year and recovers huge quantities of different kinds of illicit drugs. During the period between 1993 and 2000, law enforcing agencies arrested 16,792 persons and seized 80 kg of heroin, 10.13 tons of cannabis, 210,766 bottles of phensydyl (codeine), 7.5 kg of cocaine, 21,388 ampules of Buprenorphine injection, 44 kg of charash, (THC), 22,388 ampules of pethidine injection, 86,465 litres of ID liquors, and 30, 850 litres of rectified spirit.28 4.6.4 Crop Eradication, Crop Substitution and Destruction of Drugs Because Bangladesh produces no narcotics drugs, it has no crop eradication or crop substitution programs. However, it seizes and destroys the small amount of cannabis plants cultivated illegally in remote rural areas. Number of cannabis plants eradicated during the last seven years is about 348,000.29 27 Ibid. 28 Ibid. 29 [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM. last visited on 08 January 2023]. 22 4.6.5 Investigation DNC and the police are empowered to investigate drug cases in Bangladesh. Officers above the rank of inspectors are authorized to conduct investigations.30 4.6.6 Prosecution and Sanction DNC and the police carry out prosecution of drug cases in courts. Police has inspectors in each magistrate court in Bangladesh. DNC has 12 prosecutors and 37 assistant prosecutors at 25 regional headquarters. Drug cases are tried in general courts, which are over-burdened because of thousands of pending cases. 31 4.6.7 Demand Reduction The government of Bangladesh believes that drug abuse prevention programs will not succeed unless they consists both of supply and demand reduction programs. Therefore, the government prefers to conduct various demand reduction activities. The activities so far practiced in Bangladesh are: (a) prevention, (b) education, (c) price control and taxation, (d) control and restriction on advertisement of drugs, (e) treatments and (f) rehabilitation. A major role in demand reduction activities in Bangladesh may be played by the ministries of information, education, social-welfare, health, youth and sports, and local government. The drug control activities carried out through various methods of demand reduction in Bangladesh are as follows:32 4.6.8 Preventive Measure DNC and its field offices have programs for public awareness campaigns against drug abuse throughout the country, including organization of rallies, seminars, and 30 ibid 31 ibid 32 [www.Banglapedia.search.com.bd/HT/D_0286.htm, last visited on 10 January 2023] 23 discussion meetings. DNC headquarter publishes Narcotics Control Bulletins and Special Drug Control Souvenirs regularly. DNC has made an 18-minute short film on the consequences of drug abuse. A 60-second TV spot against drug abuse has also been made. DNC is also considering a program for training of imams of Mosques for preaching anti-drug messages. DNC publishes posters, stickers, booklets and brochures on the harmful effects of drug abuse. A series of information booklets on various drugs have also been published under the Master Plan.33 DNC and UNDCP Project office undertook a massive community action program for drug abuse prevention throughout the country involving non-government organizations with financial assistance from UNDCP. DNC field officers conduct public meetings and seminars on various aspects of drug abuse problems. They show cinema slides containing drug awareness messages in local cinema halls. The Youth Development Directorate also takes up these sorts of programs for prevention and public awareness campaigns. Moreover, they hold discussions and debates occasionally. NGOs and social organizations occasionally take prevention programs on drug abuse. The Strategic Plan for Drug Demand Reduction in Bangladesh, prepared under the Master Plan for Drug Abuse Control in Bangladesh by the Department of Narcotics Control and UNDCP, mentions as many as 19 specific strategies. The Master Plan suggests restructuring of DNC to better coordinate drug demand reduction activities. It proposes to establish community coordination committees, develop and disseminate a core package of prevention materials, organize training for community and religious leaders and NGOs, establish a trained cadre of counselors to deliver preventive counseling at appropriate locations, develop adequate youth recreation facilities and programs, and initiate a wide range of employment training programs. The Plan also suggests developing motivation/incentives programs for private sector and business associations, involving law enforcement officials in 33 ibid 24 preventive education in the community, developing a media policy and making amendments to the advertising policy through development of the concept of counteradvertising. The Master Plan gives special emphasis on placement of health warnings on labels/packaging of all tobacco, tobacco products and medicines, establishment of parents forum and organization of training of parents, infusion of preventive education into the formal and non-formal education systems, establishment of a totally drug-free environment in schools, provision of training for educationists, and development and delivery of work place drug prevention programs. The five-year strategic plan lays down specific strategies in the treatment and rehabilitation. Major strategies outlined in the Master Plan are: completion of a community-based needs assessment; development of a client monitoring system; dissemination of inter-agency information; improvement of sources of existing information on drugs; provision for research; monitoring and evaluation; training of personnel; coordination of treatment and rehabilitation services; provision of social integration and aftercare services; and development and delivery of community-based and target-oriented programs. Other strategies are utilization of existing programs and networks, development of a treatment and rehabilitation model, introduction of appropriate harm reduction models, delivery of work place and outreach programs, and emphasis on HIV/AIDS.34 4.6.9 Education The government introduced drug education in regular school curricula. DNC prevention teams of Regional Narcotics Control offices visit educational institutions regularly and provide classroom lectures on the harmful effects of drug abuse. It can be said that peer network, and school and family environment are important determinants of adolescent behaviour related to substances/drug abuse and demand the attention of program designers for preventive health education and behaviour 34 [www.Banglapedia.search.com.bd/HT/D_0286.htm, last visited on 12 January 2023] 25 modification intervention. Balanced fulfil-ling of the adolescents’ knowledge gap, keeping family in the focus, ‘tobacco-free school’ initiative, strategies to include working adolescents from the poorer section of the society, innovative use of mass media and mainstreaming the problem in textbooks, participatory involvement of adolescents as peer educators, etc. may be some effective components of such an intervention.35 4.6.10 Price Control and Taxation Almost all narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances except a very few for medicinal purposes are restricted in Bangladesh. A taxation system to control and minimize the use of drugs in the country is only applicable on alcohol. A very high rate of duty is imposed on any kinds of alcohol and spirit to keep those beyond the reach of ordinary people. The government controls the import of raw materials and precursor chemicals used in the manufacture of any narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.36 4.6.11 Control and Restriction on Advertising for Drugs The government does not allow any advertisement for drugs in radio and television, though this restriction is not applicable to tobacco products.37 4.6.12 Treatment and Detoxification The Narcotics Control Act 1990 provides provisions for treatment of drug addicts and establishment of drug treatment canters by the government. The expenditure of drug addiction treatment is generally borne by the government. This law also provides provisions for declaring jail hospitals as drug treatment canters. Since 1990, DNC has 35 ibid 36 ibid 37 ibid 26 its own drug treatment centre at Tejgaon in Dhaka. Three other drug treatment canters have been established in Khulna, Rajshahi and Chittagong. There are also a number of private clinics and hospitals to treat drug addicts. The law made it obligatory for physicians and family heads to supply information on drug addiction to law enforcement agencies.38 4.7 Comparison with Narcotics Controls Act 2018 and the Old Law The Narcotics Control Bill 2018 has been passed in parliament with a provision of death sentence or life-term imprisonment as punishment for producing, trading, and using 200 grams or more of yaba, or more than 25 grams of heroin and cocaine. Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal tabled the bill and it was passed by voice vote on Saturday, reports UNB, According to the bill, the punishment for transporting, trading, storing, producing, processing, applying and using 200 grams of yaba or its principal ingredient amphetamine, would be the death penalty or life-term imprisonment. In case of less than 200 grams of yaba, the punishment would be a minimum of one year in jail and a maximum of five years in prison alongside a fine.Yaba and amphetamines were included in the list of Category A narcotics in the proposed law, even though it is not in the existing Narcotics Control Act of 1990.39 The stern punishments were proposed in the new law as yaba has spread across Bangladesh on a massive scale in recent times, government officials said earlier.The punishment for transporting, trading, storing, producing, processing, applying and using more than 25 grams of narcotics originating from heroin, cocaine, and coca, would be the death penalty or life-term imprisonment, while for less than 25 grams Category A narcotics the punishment would be a minimum of two years in prison, and a maximum of 10 years in jail. 38 ibid 39 The Narcotics Control Act, 2018. 27 According to the bill, the maximum punishment for any individual or organization financing or patronizing drug dealing would be the death penalty too.If any individual or organization finances, instigates or patronizes such crimes, they would face similar punishment as per the law. In addition, yaba, shisha, khat, and dope tests were also incorporated in the draft bill as the existing Narcotics Control Act does not address drug testing.The provision of fines was also kept for all the offences.The existing act was creating serious legal complications as it had no provision to bring drug traders, patrons, and drug lords, into the legal net. Officials at the Department of Narcotics Control (DNC) and other law enforcement agencies earlier said there were some loopholes in the existing law, and drug dealers were using them to easily secure bail soon after arrest, and getting away. On October 8, the Cabinet approved the bill in principle. Later, it was placed in parliament and sent to the concerned parliamentary standing committee on October 22 for further vetting.40 The new draft of the 28-year-old law has been adjusted in line with other international anti-narcotics laws. In May this year, the government launched a nationwide anti-narcotic drive that saw arrests of thousands of suspected drug barons and dealers, and deaths of hundreds in alleged gunfights between criminals and law enforcement officials during raids.One could be sentenced to death for carrying, trading, storing or processing yaba weighing over five grams, according to a draft law approved in principle by the cabinet. Death or life imprisonment could be meted out if any institution or individual supplies, patronises or invests or colludes in drug crimes, according to the proposals approved yesterday. If a person carries, trades, stores, or processes yaba weighing less than five grams, he or she could be sentenced to five years in jail and fined, said the draft law placed at the cabinet meeting chaired by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina at the Prime Minister's Office. 40 [<https://dnc.gov.bd.> accessed on 14 January 2023]. 28 About 50 of the methamphetamine pills weigh five grams, according to officials of the Department of Narcotics Control.Briefing reporters after the meeting, Cabinet Secretary ShafiulAlam said the Narcotics Control Act was formulated in 1990 and it was being updated after 28 years in line with UN conventions on drug trafficking and narcotics control, of which Bangladesh is a signatory.41 Shafiul said there was no mention of yaba or shisha in Narcotics Control Act and those have been included in the draft. The draft law also introduces a provision for “dope tests” of suspects, the cabinet secretary said. If anybody is found positive in a “dope test” for banned substances, the person could face five to 15 years in jail. There is also a provision that allows law enforcers to arrest everyone involved from the production to the final destination of drugs for conducting their investigation. All narcotic substances in the world has been included in the proposed law, he claimed, adding that the government could include more in future with gazette notifications. The cabinet secretary said those who carry, trade, store, produce or process narcotics would be considered the offenders. 4.8 Loopholes of Narcotics Control Act 2018 The newly amended law in the Narcotics Control Act 2018 imposes the death penalty or life term imprisonment on drug traders, restricting their release from punishment for such crimes. Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan said drug traders used to get released from jail taking advantage of loopholes in the previous law. The amended law contains no such loopholes. He said this at a workshop on the review of different aspects for enforcing the amended Narcotics Control Act 2018, at the Department of Narcotics Control (DNC) in Segunbagicha of Dhaka on Thursday, reports UNB. "We've already achieved enough success in preventing militancy and terrorism. We'll 41 Shamsul Islam, “The Daily Star”, The Narcotics Control Act 2018. 29 surely succeed in controlling drugs, Inshallah," the home minister said. On October 27, the Narcotics Control Bill was passed in Parliament with a provision of either death sentence or life-term imprisonment as punishment for producing, trading, and using 200 grams or more of yaba, or more than 25 grams of heroin and cocaine. According to the new law, the punishment for transporting, trading, storing, producing, processing, applying, and using 200 grams of yaba, or its principal ingredient amphetamine, is death penalty or life-term imprisonment. Yaba and amphetamines were included in the list of Category A narcotics in the new law, even though they are not there in the existing Narcotics Control Act of 1990. The new law will come into effect on December 27. The home minister said they formulated the new law bringing necessary amendments to the Narcotics Control Act 1990. All departments concerned, including law enforcement agencies and the DNC, can work jointly from December 27 as per the new law. Describing young people as the country's assets, he said drugs stand in the way of millions of young educated youths to change the country. "This youth society loses their ability to work, service attitude, and creativity, due to drug addiction and they become a burden for the nation in the process." He said godfathers of yaba peddling will be punished under the Money Laundering Act while the DNC can take action under the new law, in case any new drug emerges. Security Services Division Secretary under the Home Ministry, Farid Uddin Ahmed Chowdhury, and DNC Director General, Md Jamal Uddin Ahmed, also addressed the program.42 4.9 Loopholes of Narcotics Control Act 1990 The Narcotics Control Act of 1990 needs preventive strategy to control over a considerable area of both supply and demand reduction of drugs. The major supply reduction activities in Bangladesh may be prevented by Licensing, Monitoring and 42 [https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2018/12/21/revised-narcotics-control-law-getstough-with-drug-traders, last visited date on 14 January 2023]. 30 Inspection, Intelligence and Enforcement, Crop Eradication and Destruction of Drugs, Investigation, and Prosecution and Sanctions. Licensing should be used in Bangladesh to control the production, processing, export, import, transport, distribution or sale, use or consumption of alcohol, spirit, alcohol-containing products, and certain narcotic drugs used for medical purposes. It should be more strict to control and limit drug-supply facilities. Monitoring and inspection of the supply system of drugs need to be more regular and transparent without any corruption. Intelligence and enforcement agency should be more concern directly engaged in the pipeline of drug supply through its intelligence and enforcement activities. There should have system of Crop eradication, crop substitution and destruction of drugs Because Bangladesh produces no narcotics drugs, it has no crop eradication or crop substitution programmes. However, it seizes and destroys the small amount of cannabis plants cultivated illegally in remote rural areas. Prosecution and sanction need to be carried out prosecution of drug cases in courts. There should have a special court to deal with drug and drug related offences for speedy disposal. Demand reduction is another aspect of preventive strategy. The drug abuse prevention programmes will not succeed unless they consists both of supply and demand reduction programmes. Therefore, the government needs to conduct various demand reduction activities. A major role in demand reduction activities in Bangladesh may be played by the ministries of information, education, social-welfare, health, youth and sports, and local government. The drug control activities carried out through various methods of demand reduction in Bangladesh may be by- programmes for public awareness campaigns against drug abuse throughout the country, including organization of rallies, seminars, and discussion meetings. The government may introduce drug education in regular school curricula. Control and restriction on advertising for drugs may be effective means to prevent wide spread of drug.43 43 Drug traffickers linked to Myanmar, India". The Daily Star. 4 March 2017. Retrieved 20 April 2017. 31 Chapter 5 PROGRAM TO PREVENT ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ABUSE 5.1 Drug and Alcohol Abuse Prevention Program The abuse of narcotics drugs has increased manifold in Bangladesh including its production and involvement of terrorists groups with this trade. Due to the location of Bangladesh in between the golden triangle and golden crescent, trafficking of illicit drugs and psychotropic substances getting increased by taking the advantage of weak law enforcing agencies or their indirect collaboration with the trade. Besides, heroin, cocaine and dangerous precursors and chemicals are also getting routes of trafficking through Bangladesh territory, produced in Afghanistan or Pakistan and even products of South and Central America are getting routes in Bangladesh. Such transnational crime is conducted by organised crime groups and getting stronger gradually. This is the reason for which the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) has emphasised for a political declaration and plan of actions on international cooperation towards an integrated and balanced strategy to counter such serious drug problems. According to UNODC, about 200 Million people are using illicit drugs such as cocaine, cannabis, hallucinogens, opiates and seductive hypnotics. Considering all these threats and possible public health disasters, on December 7, 1987, the United Nations General Assembly Special Session decided to observe June 26 every year as the ‘International Day against Drug Abuse and Illicit Trafficking’. Since 1988, it is observed everywhere including Bangladesh especially after the establishment of Narcotics Control Department in Bangladesh on January 2, 1990 to raise awareness against drug abuse and about dangers of illicit drug. 32 There should be massive motivational campaign about bad effects of drug abuse. All guardians and parents, teachers and nearest relatives must keep constant vigilance so that a youth cannot be derailed with the influence of bad companions. Preventive education, treatment and rehabilitation are priority issues to make a country drug abuse free. These are reasons for which government is firm to create a strong public opinion against the drug abuse and reconstituted the National Narcotics Control Board with this vision. There should be some changes in the rules governing the drug use, production and distribution. The following quick actions are also suggested. Recreational facilities and diversion programmes to be encouraged that prevent vulnerable populations from becoming substance dependents. Development and implementation of multi-disciplinary and multi-modal protocols and practices for integrated diagnosis and treatment of substance dependence and co-occurring disorders and for funding such diagnosis and treatment. Harmonisation and enforcement of laws and policies to facilitate effective governance of the alcohol and drug supply chain. Avoid torture to addicts which is unacceptable. Torture is also a crime and makes a person vindictive.44 44 https://www.thedailystar.net/health/health-alert/control-drug-abuse-must-1515874, last visited date on 15 January 2023]. 33 Chapter 6 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSION 6.1 Recommendations It has been witnessed that through implementing strict law and through extrajudicial killings of drug abusers, Bangladesh has not achieved apical success in drug demand reduction. Though the new law seeks to punish any individual or organisation financing or patronising drug dealing with death penalty, apart from the legal initiatives, still there are many issues untouched by the government which should be included within the master plan of prevention of substance abuse in Bangladesh. 6.1.1 Adopting a Holistic Approach The consumption of illegal drugs, and the associated prevention strategy, should not be considered in isolation of larger social issues, since it is intricately linked to other social problems. For an example, a noteworthy extent of the young populace in Bangladesh is influenced by chronic drug use, likewise being engaged with any gang culture is known to incredibly expand the likelihood of drug addiction. Therefore, a uniform approach needs to be taken by combining different strategies which would focus on demand, supply and harm reduction factors. On the demand side of the framework, substance abuse is addressed through poverty reduction strategies, initiating education and communication, fostering socio-economic security and development and advancing anti-substance abuse social programmes and participation. On the supply side, the key areas are concerned with controlling manufacturing, sale, marketing and distribution of harmful substances. It includes law enforcement and punishment against harmful substance abuses and supplies. Harm 34 reduction is about providing treatment, care and reintegration of abusers or dependents on illegal drugs. It has to be noted that the issue of substance abuse in many countries has been considered as public health issue which is more likely to contribute to prevent drugs abuse. The new law of 2018 in Bangladesh gives discretion to the courts dealing with drugs offence to offer rehabilitation to a person addicted to drug (if the court is satisfied that he has not been involved with any other offence related with drugs); however, in practice, this provision is not implemented properly. 6.1.2 Identifying the High Profile Drug Traders and Keeping them under Surveillance It has been evident that most of the persons arrested and killed throughout war against drugs are low profile suppliers and influential drug mafias have remained unscathed. The groups involved transcend borders with godfathers having their networks even in neighbouring countries and it is estimated that they make a net profit of more than TK 10 million in a week. Many media reports project that political leaders, officials of the drugs control directorate, members of the law enforcement, professional criminals and others are involved in this racket. The ruling government as well must be very proactive to cleanse individuals of their own party to get a hold of the yaba dealers as it has been witnessed that the 2014 list prepared by the Department of Narcotic Control includes the names of 87 leaders of the ruling party and its front organizations who back the yaba traders in Dhaka. Without prosecuting the yaba high-up traders and dealers, it would not be possible to prevent substance abuse in Bangladesh. Executing evidenced-based prevention programs: school, family and community involvement. In Bangladesh different awareness programs are often organised by the Department of Narcotics Control through electronic and print media; however there has been very limited initiative taken in school, family and community settings. In pursuit of safeguarding drug abuse prevention strategy, the programs implemented in the strategy must be evidence-based, preferably inspired by works 35 which have taken place in similar socio-cultural settings to find closer rates of success. The prevention programmes of drug use must include four types of approaches in a broad sense: awareness-raising campaigns, interventions in schools, programs with families, and community-based interventions. There should be a master plan focusing on different types of interventions in institutional settings specially providing information to potential users about the risks associated with drug use, reinforcing the skills that can make it possible to resist the social pressure associated with drug use, correcting the false impression that using drugs is the norm for young people. 6.1.3 Drug Decriminalization Drug decriminalization is the process for reduced control and penalties compared to existing drug laws. Proponents of drug decriminalization usually support the use of fines or other punishments to replace prison terms.This approach often proposes systems whereby illegal drug users who are caught would be fined, but would not receive a permanent criminal record as a result. A central feature of drug decriminalization is the concept of harm reduction. Decriminalization supports a structure that would ensure healthcare and rehabilitation for the addicted if the person is not guilty of any serious crime.According to the Decriminalization of Drug Use and Possession in Australia- a briefing note published by the National Drug and Alcohol Research centre of the University of New South Wales - decriminalization does not necessarily mean legalization, but rather removes criminal penalties for use or possession either by law (de jure) or by practice (de facto). 6.2 Conclusion Bangladesh is not a drug producing country but due to the transit facilities and neighboring countries adherence to spread out of narcotics, it is increasing the availability of narcotics throughout the countries. Bangladesh’s zero tolerance campaign against narcotics has stirred up a lot controversy around the abuse of power 36 by the police, the RAB, and the government. Social media is buzzing with condemnation of alleged entrapments and killings of political and business rivals of the powerful. Writers and critics have also expressed concern over the hypocritical nature of the campaign, claiming that it is sparing the politically influential and cracking down on the powerless. While most of these critiques hold merit, they still miss a very central problem of the war on drugs: Even when it’s done correctly, it doesn’t work. The war on drugs model was copied by various Asian countries with similar results. In the Philippines alone, more than 12,000 people accused of using or dealing drugs have been killed over the last two years. Thailand has killed 2,800 people since 2003, Singapore had killed 408 people between 1991 and 2000, and Malaysia has killed 479 people since 1996. However, evidence suggests that these state executions didn’t deter drug use or crimes anywhere. The prime example of this is Indonesia, where the number of addicts increased from 3.6 million in 2011 to 5.9 million in 2015 according to the government itself. There is mounting evidence that executions have failed as an anti-drug strategy and many Asian governments have begun to retreat from them. But just when countries around the world have realized that the war on drugs is an ineffective policy, why did the Bangladesh government decide to pick it up.It is hard for me to believe that the government doesn’t have anyone in its erudite advisory group. What I presume is that the party has still decided to go forward with this plan because of the short-term political benefits rather than long time social benefits. If we take a deeper look at the news reports of the deaths by crossfire, especially at the deaths that are represented by numbers and not names, a prominent trend emerges. Slums, borderlands, refugee camps, and remote villages pop up again and again as the spots of these shootouts and the victims seem to belong to the same social strata of our society: The lowest one. Most of them don’t get access to any health care, education, or infrastructure. Many are environmental migrants who have lost everything to river erosion, many have been victims of ethnic cleansing who have 37 had to forsake their homeland, many are doubly stateless who have been denied structures of citizenship by both Bangladesh and Pakistan. Many of them are legally barred from entering honest trades in the country and most of them are structurally barred from a life of solvency. To most of them, the only way to break out of their poverty is to operate outside of the law. Therefore, killing a bunch of them would not necessarily stop the others from joining the trade, because there is an endless supply of structurally deprived humans in Bangladesh who are ready to meet the needs of those who are dependent on drugs. So long as drugs are demanded and the state fails to exist for the stateless, the supply of desperate drug traffickers would never deplete. I say this not to mean that the crimes these people commit should go unpunished. I say this with the hope that those in our country who believe that these drug dealers don’t deserve to be treated humanely would see the human story of those who live in inhumane conditions and understand how they resort to illegal activities to get access to basic amenities, like clean running water, three hot meals a day, and a house that wouldn’t flood during the monsoon, that most of us take for granted. These people deserve their day in court and the court should decide whether or not some exceptions to the law may be applied based on the circumstances of the criminal. After all, that is why we have a judicial branch outside of the legislative and executive. Also, skipping the judiciary and directly implementing the laws through the executive’s strong arm doesn’t simply deny justice for the accused it also erodes the rule of law in the republic. State executions, even when they are inflicted upon nameless humans who allegedly operate outside of the law, are ineffective, inhumane, unlawful, and unjust. Killing the structurally deprived without addressing the unjust structures that force them into crime would not win us the war on drugs it would only cleanse the market of the few slumlords who had risen to solvency through the trade of drugs and hand an oligopoly market to the politically influential. If the government is really willing to solve the drug crisis, it has to invest in infrastructure, education, and public health so that those who are addicted can be cured, and those who are involved can switch to better trades. These measures may not be as flashy as the death counts for the 38 purposes of election manifestos, but they are the only way to eventually improve the conditions of our drug epidemic. However, this is a hope for us that till now any government does not take any initiative to control the narcotics use throughout the country. For the announcement of war against narcotics will be more or less effective as we are the nation who are not obeying the rules without punitive action. 39 REFERENCES Books 1. Ahmed Siddique, Criminology: Problems and Perspective, 5th ed. (Lucknow: Eastern Book Company. 2005). 2. P. Kundram & V.N. Murty, “ drug Abuse And Crime : A Preliminary Study” (1979) 7 Indian Jour Crime 65-68. 3. N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009), p.191. 4. Ahmed Siddique, Criminology: Problems and Perspective, 4th ed. (Lucknow: Eastern Book Company. 2001). 5. N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009). 6. Jeorge Caltin E.G.: Alcoholism In the Encyclopedia of Social Science (1930). 7. N.V. Paranjape, Criminology and Penology, 14th ed. (Allahbad: Central Law Publication, 2009). Website 1. [http://www.alaboutgod.com/truth/2peter-2.htm]. 2. [http://www.alaboutgod.com/truth/2peter-2.htm]. 3. [Drug Addiction and Social Damage]. 4. [<https://anual drug report 2016]. 5. [<https://gulfnews.com/world/asia/bangladesh-makes-record-drugs-seizure]. 6. [<http://www.dnc.gov.bd]. 7. [https://www.government.nl/topics/alcohol/preventing-alcohol-abuse-andalcoholism]. 8. [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM] 40 9. [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM] 10. [www.banglapedia.org/httpdocs/HT/D_0286.HTM] 11. [www.Banglapedia.search.com.bd/HT/D_0286.htm] . 12. [<https://dnc.gov.bd.>]. 13. [https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2018/12/21/revised-narcotics-controllaw-gets-tough-with-drug-traders] 14. [Drug traffickers linked to Myanmar, India". The Daily Star. 4 March 2017. Retrieved 20 April 2017.] 15. [https://www.thedailystar.net/health/health-alert/control-drug-abuse-must1515874]. 41