Media & Globalization Copyright Disclaimer No part of this material may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including printing, photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical means without the prior written permission of the authors, except for personal academic use and certain other non-commercial uses permitted by copyright law. LEARNING OUTCOMES: • Identify the evolution of Media. • Compare and contrast different forms of media. • Analyze and evaluate one’s own experience of Media. 1 SELF-ASSESSMENT – Write your answers on a separate piece of paper. True False Statement Social Media is a space for entertainment and nothing more. Examples of media are T.V, radio and your face. Media and Globalization are interconnected concepts. Television and Radio are two-way media. Media literacy among Filipinos are high. 2 Media is everywhere. When you wake up, you probably reached out to your phone either to check any messages or check the time. ‘It’s 6:05 AM!’ and you have a class at 7:30 AM. You hurried to the bathroom, realizing that your parents are already awake and is listening to the news on the television or the radio. Moving out of the restroom, your mom calls you and handed the money that you requested last week. It is for the book that you have to buy for your major subject. While travelling to school, you surf the net and sees a good meme. Knowing yourself, you shared it to your classmates who are also travelling albeit from various places. You arrived at your class exactly 5 minutes before the time. It is lunch time; your friends are eating at your favorite cafeteria while discussing the memes that you all shared earlier in the morning. One of your friends named John, interjected and told the group that one of the memes that your friend shared seems to be normalizing rape culture. He explained that even though the intention is to get a good laugh, the meme is bordering on insensitive, sexist and violent undertone which for him should not be shared altogether. One of your ‘pa-cool’ friend who shared the meme dismiss it and said “Dami mo naman alam, mag-enjoy ka na lang!” You, being a young adult who is 3 about to turn eighteen and supposed to be mature enough to take criticisms and productive discussion, calmly deflected your ‘pa-cool’ friend. “Well, the problem is with people who passively allow these kinds of things. For you it might be simple sharing of memes, but it goes beyond that. Violence in any shape or form should be denounced entirely. The media, or social media for that matter seems to be a simple and innocent undertaking for many of us. It is not always like that!” Your ‘pa-cool friend’ being a mature being and not let his ego get to him, nodded and admitted his mistake. “I should have thought it through before commenting and posting. I’ll do better next time.” No one took things personally – because that is what informed and open-minded individuals do. Your group proceeded to eat and went to your next class. After a while your friends are throwing jokes again. Many treat media (social media) as something you use in connecting with your friends or as someone’s source of entertainment. There is nothing wrong with that. You are right when you said that media is not always a simple lighthearted activity. The things you share in the digital space may be partaking in a much larger problem in the society. Among them being the rape culture and violence. The problem is when we passively sit and allow these things to happen without saying a word or worse partaking on these thoughts and actions ourselves. What we see and hear in the digital space may be slowly influencing on how we perceive the things around us. Therefore, the purpose of this course material is to get a grasp on how media shapes our thinking and our culture under the globalizing forces. 4 Speech and Languages: Evolutionary Advantages Before we arrive on the internet and digital media, media have evolved from the most basic and primitive forms. At the physiological level, humans are endowed with our capacity to communicate in advance signs and codes from hand gestures to languages. This is an important evolutionary advantage as humans alone can’t defend themselves against much larger and more adept predators like tigers, lions and sharks etc. Humans then have to band together and work to hunt down preys. To work in groups, communication is a must. Speech and simple sign language coordinate the activities of the group. For example, a group of early human hunters have to slowly approach their prey. This requires advance sign and gestures that needs efficient collaboration. One miscommunication may allow the unsuspecting prey to notice their presence and immediately escape. Hunters use their hands and face as medium to transfer messages. The main hunter of the group might signal “go” using his hand or a pouted lip to show the direction. Thousands of years past and humans form tribes and later on large civilizations. From hunter-gatherers they settled into one place and cultivate lands. Once a reliable food source is established, humans have more time to find new activities. This resulted to developing new practices that formed their cultures. Unique adornments were made, weapons more elaborate, and varying practices to honor their deities or gods. Humanity’s progress may be slow had it not due to of our capacity to transfer knowledge from one another, even in the next generations. Local myths and stories are passed down orally. Ways on how to 5 effectively farm and domesticate animals are told from fathers and mothers to their off springs. The knowledge that was acquired by the predecessors will live on to the next generation through communication. This becomes the basis of humans ascending on top of ecosystem as the most complex and advance species in the planet. Forms of Communication We established that oral communication had dramatically assisted humans in their everyday life since time immemorial. However, the use of oral communication has its own shortcomings. Oral communication is often unrecorded and sometimes imprecise. Due to the fact that people only have to rely on what others have heard from another. This might be lost in translation as the messages passes from and to different persons. The original message is now distorted, and the receiver might have a totally different message from the original source. Rumors are a good example of this. Before you know it, the people in your streets have been talking about you due to an incident that they might have misinterpreted. Broken Telephone Game or locally known as pass the message game is a good illustration on how oral communication could be imprecise. To solve this inaccuracy, humans used an alternative form of communication – written communication. This form of communication directly supplants what the oral 6 communication is lacking – preciseness and documentation. Your love letter is the same message as you have written it when you give it to your crush. Most importantly, written communication is good in traveling time and space. Your grandparents decades ago might be sending letters even from abroad and still retain the same message. These letters could be revisited in the future as a nostalgic piece! Recipes are like this as well. Your great grandparent may have had a secret recipe with whom it is passed down from generations to generations. The same content might be the same, but it is up to the inheritors if they want to alter some parts of it or retain it. Still, it is recorded, and the main ingredients and techniques therein are still intact. Both oral and written communications are the driving forces to which our civilizations have progressed. However, the effectiveness of these forms is still dependent on the medium through which it is carried out. Media (medium for singular) are the means of communication such as papers, books, radio, television, magazines, internet, etc. through which our messages are used to transfer. However, as we have earlier mentioned your own body could be a medium as well. Your hand gestures, facial expressions, body posture etc., sends signals and messages. 7 Media and Society Media and globalization have worked hand in hand. Alongside new advancements in information communication technologies, the spread of information and ideas are carried out in various platforms in varying degrees throughout history. 8 Paper: Most reliable written medium of communication Early civilizations have developed various written media. One of the most common is writing on a clay which then forms tablets. Archeologists and historians have discovered one of earliest styles of writing in human history – Cuneiform (3200-3000 BCE) found in Mesopotamia which today covers Iraq, parts of Turkey and Syria. This discovery had led to the translation of Epic of Gilgamesh which according to Mark J. (2018): This translation allowed other cuneiform tablets to be interpreted which overturned the traditional understanding of the biblical version of history and made room for scholarly, objective explorations of history to move forward. What this means is we have an idea that the biblical texts which were thought to be original, have actually been in part adapted and referenced into cuneiform stories carved into the stones they have found. Accordingly, biblical events such as The Fall of Man, The Great Flood as well as the Garden of Eden are now understood as myths derived from the Mesopotamian origins.1 Just like in any other local or national myths, stories might have different versions and adaptations from other sources. Cuneiform Writing used in Mesopotamia (3,500 – 3,000 BCE) While stone tablets could withstood the test of time in the right conditions, it is hard to store and carry around. Imagine a king or pharaoh in the ancient times writing to his/her acquaintance and the stone is carried from place to place! In other words, stone tablets are not practical in distance 1 From “Cuneiform” by Mark, J. Retrieved from https://www.ancient.eu/cuneiform/ 9 communication. Therefore, they have to find a way how to easily get around this. In ancient Egypt, the most widely used form of writing material is the papyrus- This is the origin word which the word paper is derived from. It is used as early as 3,000 BC. Papyrus are produced using papyrus plants which grew in Ancient Egypt along the Nile River. While it is produced exclusively by Egypt, ancient Greeks and Romans used it widely as evidenced by the archeological findings. (Left)Papyrus Plants; (Right) How ancient Egyptians make the papyrus into ‘paper’ Many of the Egyptian, Roman, Greek and Arabic cultures have been written in papyrus. However, it ceased to be widely used as it is not pliable enough to be fold and it is too fragile that it could easily wear off due to excessive dryness and moisture. In Europe it was replaced by parchments and vellum which are animal skins or membrane chiefly of goats, sheep and calves. Parchment is stretched, scraped, and dried under tension. The hides are not tanned. This process stretches the fibers of the skin creating a durable, flat material.2 (Left) Stretch parchment; (Right) improvement on the medium to be thinner and durable had occurred over hundreds of years. 2 From “Parchment” by Sigunik Studio. Retrieved from www.sigunik.com/about_parchment.html 10 Parchment was used for 2,000 years around the Mediterranean basin due to its inherent durability. However, problem in the mass production arouse as it would require hundreds of goats and the like to be skinned in order to produce hundreds of ‘pages’. Therefore, parchments are scarce and may be limited in production. The paper that we know today could traced in China. In 105 C.E, a more advance and durable plant-based paper product was invented by Cai Lun. He presented his invention before the Emperor of Han Dynasty who are needing documentation. The emperor adapted his technique in paper-making due to the demand in the civil-service officials who needed a lot of paper. Hence, it is only logical to mass produce it. 3 Unlike parchments, Chinese papers are more practical to produce as plants and trees could be easily planted and harvested (provided that there is an immense land to do so). As such the process of ancient paper-making is done below: From ‘Chinese Paper-Making’ by Dorling Kindersley. Retrieved from https://www.dkfindout.com/us/history/ancient-china/chinese-paper-making/ 3 11 Silk Road: It’s not always about Silk! As China ramps up its production of paper. It became a highly sought commodity. This together with Chinese products like the porcelain, tea, and of course silk. In fact, the diffusion of paper occurred westward as Chinese papers are slowly becoming priced possessions by Arabs, Persians, Greeks, Romans due to “because of its durability and convenience” 4 While blank papers travel around the silk road, so does the commercial, religious and scholarly texts. This led to the spread not only of the medium but ideas in the silk road. In fact, the Chinese paper-making technique is caught on by the Islamic world whom they adopted and improved on – In fact, as one scholar noted – “Only after the Muslim world started to adopt paper did paper start to take on its modern bleach-white form”5 When the Muslim region and empires made their own paper, it led to different intellectual and contributions in the world. Many of the Muslim scholars translated the classical antiquity works written in Greek, Chinese, Egyptian, Persian, Indian and Phoenician. They translated these to Arabic and Persian which had preserved the contents. Had it not for this, the works from classical antiquity may have been lost forever. This era saw the development of Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, Calculus with which today’s students love so much! ;) . Many 4 5 From “The Silk Road: A New History” By Hansen, V. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), 137. From “Paper before Print” by Bloom, J. (Yale University Press, 2001) 12 advancements in Astronomy, Physics, Chemistry and Biology had also occurred and the findings are all documented in the papers by the Muslims that was later on used by Europeans. Printing Press and the Information Revolution It is important to note that while ideas and information spread amongst the empires and civilizations, only few people have access to such. This is only limited to the local leaders and families, nobles, rich merchants and most importantly religious groups and leaders. In fact, the ability to read and write is only reserved to these rich and well-acquainted groups. In Europe, writing and reading has mostly been a religious activity (except on some commercial undertakings). The Catholic priests shapes the discourse – what to talk, what not to talk about. This is in middle ages, where the church reign supreme. Where the rules of kings and queens are based on the power of vested to them by the God in heaven. (Recall Divine Rights of Kings and Queens). However, as we have discussed in the history of globalization, the church power and dominance is slowly ebbing. The bubonic plague (black death) had killed hundreds of millions of people in Europe. Distrust and frustration against the Catholic church is all time high. To worsen the situation, growing corruption among church officials have been clear. For hundreds of years, none have dared to question the church. Not until Martin Luther nailed his 95 Theses to the door of Wittenberg Castle Church in 1517. Accordingly, The 95 Theses, which would later become the foundation of the Protestant Reformation, were written in a remarkably humble and academic tone, questioning rather than accusing. The overall thrust of the document was nonetheless quite provocative. The first two of the theses contained Luther’s central idea, that God intended believers to seek repentance and that faith alone, and not deeds, would lead to salvation. The other 93 theses, a number of them directly criticizing the practice of indulgences. Martin Luther quickly gains supporters across Germany and Europe. However, this does not happen because people are well-aware of the corruption. Someone or something have to inform them about the gross situation. Martin Luther is in the perfect time to do so. Less than 70 years ago, Printing press was invented by Johannes Gutenberg in 1440. In those decades, the new 13 technology had spread across Europe and had enabled people to became literate (The ability to read and write). For the first time in human history, knowledge and information is not only accessible to the elite but to the masses as well. Before, books are so expensive due to the production. It would require days of handwriting a single copy. The reason that it is only available to the elite. Because it is easier to produce, mass production is possible. This made books cheaper that even lower economic class could have access to the very same materials. This led to the information revolution. Teachings and messages from the antiquity and news from other parts of the country is now accessible. The people does not have to rely solely on what the government says or the what church tells them to believe. They can think and assess the merits of their claims based on other sources – books and newspapers. (Left) Writing copies of books take a while. This meant that extensive labor comes at a high price. (Right) Printing press had enabled copies to be produced hundreds and even thousands in short span of time. High supply, lower price. To go back to what Luther did, copies of 95 theses circulated around Europe. Many people were awoken by the fact that the Catholic Church at the time has been abusing its powers for economic gains. This led to many countries to convert into Protestants, and denounce the Catholic teachings altogether. In the end, the information revolution had larger consequences. This inspires freer thinking, critical assessments devoid of any religious restraints that middle ages church impose. As you may have guessed it, the invention of printing press had made it easier for ideas and information to travel. This succeeded Renaissance, Age of Enlightenment, Scientific Revolution and the Industrial Revolution – a paradigm shift had occurred! 14 Paradigm Shift: Free Thinking to Secularization As we have previously discussed, the process of changing the attitudes and thoughts of the people has been gradual, but impactful. The disassociation of many people from the church teachings as the center of their lives had prompted them to go find new frontiers. Find new interests and endeavors. This is known as secularization – “the process by which religious thinking, practices and institutions lose social significance.” 6 The place of religion has then replaced by scientific pursuits. Albeit, existing and practiced for thousands of years. Scientific practice has never been free and recognized. This led to the creation of new machines and inventions that had later own contributed to the integration of people around the world. Electronic Age: The Rise of Energy-powered Communications Technology Telegraph and Telephone As noted by many observers, The electric telegraph did not burst suddenly upon the scene but rather resulted from a scientific evolution that had been taking place since the 18th century in the field of electricity.7 The steam engine and later on advance forms of power, particularly electricity had enabled people to undertake more complicated technologies of the time. Rapid transmission of information started in a form of morse code developed Samuel Morse. Each short dots or dashes and its permutations represents different letters and numbers in the alphabet. This code was used primarily to transmit messages through telegraph, a contemporary invention alongside the morse code. The telegraph send electrical signals from one station to another using the morse code. From ‘What is Secularization?’ by ReviseSociology. Retrieved from https://revisesociology.com/2018/08/21/what-is-secularization/ 7 From ‘Telegraph’ by McGillem, C. Retreived from https://www.britannica.com/technology/telegraph 6 15 Telegraph enabled quicker transfer of message from long distances, compared to postal mails or letters. Industrializing societies with much wider reach needed faster ways of transmitting ideas. Due to fast-changing landscape and new inventions and innovations coming up from here and there, telegraph was later replaced with a much better medium of communication – Telephone. The famous Alexander Graham Bell is credited on devising telephone, however, earlier prototypes much the same as his were invented. He was recognized as the one who popularized and commercialized telephone. In a span of decades, telephone access grew immensely. “By 1900 there were nearly 600,000 phones in Bell's telephone system; that number shot up to 2.2 million phones by 1905, and 5.8 million by 1910...” Additionally, “By 1948, the 30 millionth phone was connected in the United States; by the 1960s, there were more than 80 million phone hookups in the U.S. and 160 million in the world.” More than ever, communication has been simpler and reachable from across the globe. We can now easily communicate with others from far flung places, from the West to East and vice versa. Television and Radio: Audio-Visual Medium Out of all the media inventions, none have as much as impact as the radio and television. Both mediums had enabled mass communication. Communicating to thousands and millions of people at times. While telephone was increasingly becoming accessible, the invention of radio by Guglielmo Marconi and Nikola Tesla, both of whom are still debated on who ‘invented’ radio. Nonetheless, both are key figures in the early conception and invention of this medium. Unlike telephone, radios are like newspaper – delivering messages and information to a lot of people all at once. News had now entered into the waves where it was only available in the newspapers before. This is crucial as the world wars had made people tuned in and are equally well-aware of the happenings around the world. Television like radio and telephone are all product of industrial revolution. In a span of decades, radio quickly became an alternative news medium. Television had a lot of improvements from dozens of inventors across the world. But, its impact is wide and far-reaching. While television 16 and radio relied heavily on oral forms of communication. Television brings visual experience to the masses. We cannot only hear but also see what is going on to far reaches of the world. The people could now experience the views of the people on the ground without ever going to such places. Without ever going out to the comfort of their homes. Television was mainly treated for its entertainment value. A medium where people could check on their favorite celebrities, new released movies, songs and fashion trends. However, television had also become a medium for education – people are seeing the gravity of the situation on areas unknown to them. The wars in the Vietnam, in Africa, in Asia. Worsening environmental disasters due to rapid industrialization. As such, many movements have emerged. The development of the media throughout history coincided with the spread of globalization. Recall that when Manfred Staeger defined globalization as the expansion and intensification of social relations and consciousness across world-time and world-space, he is pertaining to how the world has increasingly become interconnected by becoming well-aware of their surroundings, even from places away from them. 17 The Digital Age: The Internet and Smart Devices As we have all discussed, World War II had inspired many states to invent technologically advanced devices that could assist them in the war efforts. The Electronic Numerical Integrator Analyzer and Computer (ENIAC), was built to do ballistic calculations for the US Military during World War II.8 It was solely accessible by the military and is humongous compared to the sizes of computers today. ENIAC, and the earliest succeeding computers since 1950s is huge that it could occupy entire rooms and needed dozens of individuals to operate it. Just like how the earliest computers where built, the internet was intended for military use particularly the United States as a weapon in the Cold War. The United States being alarmed with the potential destruction and disconnection of telephone lines to communicate on the entire nation in an event that the Soviet Union nuclear attacks. One scientist from MIT and ARPA named J.C.R Licklider proposed a workaround on this problem: A galactic network of computers From ‘Invention of PC’ by History.com Editors. Retrieved from https://www.history.com/topics/inventions/invention-of-the-pc?li_source=LI&li_medium=m2m-rcw-history 8 18 that could talk to one another. 9 This network will be able to allow government to communicate even if the telephone lines were to be disrupted. From the military to research centers, another scientist in the name of Tim Berners-Lee wrote a proposal for the World Wide Web. By the end of 1990, Tim Berners-Lee had the first Web server and browser up and running at CERN, which is an advanced research institute working on physics and engineering in Geneva, Switzerland 10 This invention enabled CERN-affiliated researchers from around the world to share information regardless of their locations. The diffusion of technology from military, to research centers to the people is fast. The personal computer started to roll out when “three preassembled mass-produced personal computers were introduced: Apple Computer, Inc.’s (now Apple Inc.) Apple II, the Tandy Radio Shack TRS-80, and the Commodore Business Machines Personal Electronic Transactor (PET). 11 Since then, succeeding companies emerged to developed and innovate from the existing technologies, going breakthroughs after breakthroughs – until we have devices that could fit on our pockets. From Personal Computers to Personalized Contents in the Digital Media As personal computers started to be a household essential, traditional media such as television, radio, books, magazines and newspapers remain the main media for communication, education and entertainment. We know this because we grew up idolizing the Power Rangers, Naruto, Katniss Everdeen, Harry Potter etc.. Some of you had imagine yourselves on the shoes of the characters you read on the books or you watched on the television. Up until this point, the content creation is linear – from producers to consumers. The producers of the traditional companies such as ABS-CBN, GMA, Viva Entertainment, Star Magic, 20th From ‘The Invention of Internet’ by History.com Editors. Retrieved from https://www.history.com/topics/inventions/invention-of-the-internet?li_source=LI&li_medium=m2m-rcwhistory 10 From ‘A Short History of Web’ by CERN Editors. Retrieved from https://home.cern/science/computing/birth-web/short-history-web 11 From ‘Personal Computer’ by The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/technology/personal-computer 9 19 Century Fox, CNN etc. These media companies decides which contents to be produced and published. The audiences are treated as consumers, and are unable to make their own content. The emergence of social media had changed this traditional format. The rise of Facebook in 2004, YouTube in 2005 and Twitter in 2006 had ushered an era of self-made content. According to Castells (2007), this gave rise to what he called as mass self-communication which he defined as self-generated in content, self-directed in emission, and self-selected in reception by many that communicate with many.12 Social Media had enabled people to become their own artist, their own model, their own celebrity. People who would not be in the limelight had it not due to social media. The past years saw the rise of Social Media ‘Influencers’ Social media influencers like Mimiyuuuh and Cong popularity is a testament of the changing media landscape. Both of these influencers were not recruited nor featured to any of large media companies who previously had the sole power on who should become ‘celebrity’ or ‘famous.’ Unlike the one-way linear format of traditional media, social media is a two-way format. The people are both consumers and producers. Anyone could post their cover of a famous song, a trending dance, or any antics in the social media. You could become your own model – posting fierce pose in the Instagram, showcasing your own talent in Tiktok. 12 From ‘Communication, Power and Counter-Power in the Network Society’ by Castells, M. (2007) 20 This what scholars termed as creative autonomy. People have control over what they want to post or share. Accordingly, this autonomy was enabled by advancements in Information Communication Technologies (ICT). Castells (2007) echoed “the development of the technology of self-communication is also the product of our culture, a culture that emphasizes individual autonomy, and the selfconstruction of the project of the social actor.”13 The recent Vogue Trend of using the vogue frame to be the face and cover of vogue magazine is one great example. Many individuals may not be “models” in the traditional sense of the world, but they produce and publish their own contents as if they are one! The idea of creative autonomy in Social Media may not always result to positive impacts. Since virtually anyone could publish their own content, some people could also Images courtesy of Deanne Meneses and Rhyven Franco from Youtube. post and share fabricated and/or misleading information. Many Filipinos have become victim of manufactured information known as Fake News. The ‘tuob’ or Steam Inhalation had gained traction as the solution to Covid-19. Many medical experts debunked this, however, many Filipinos insist that it is in fact working. The social media is also used to revise history as we know it. Many so called ‘self-proclaimed historians or experts’ try to dismiss former president Marcos’ corruption and human rights violations, instead try to give him a good positive image. Historical revisionist try to twists the facts of the matter by posting news which are completely fabricated, or misleading. Adding information that are too good to be true, fake news which are pleasing to the eyes and music to the ears. Civilizations rise and fall, media however evolved with it. From the use of stone tablets, to paper to radio then social media, we have come a long way. The contemporary world now is filled with information – too much information. The challenge is how are you going to discern a fact from fiction. 13 Ibid. 21 ACTIVITY INSTRUCTION: Answer the question in one MS word file. Kindly rename the file as – Lastname_FirstName_Section_Media. The format would be 1” all sides / 12 font size / Cambria or Times New Roman / 500 – 900 words. Do not forget to include at least one reference which is properly cited. • Rank the top three media (Paper, Printing Press, Telephone, Radio, Television, Social Media) which made biggest impact in the world, and compare why. • How did media influence you? What media content (story, series, songs, movie, poem, etc.) made a huge impact on your life, your views and opinions? Give one example and elaborate. 22 REFERENCES: Bloom, J. (2001). Paper Before Print: The History and Impact of Paper in the Islamic World. Yale University Press. Castells, M. (2007). Communication, Culture and Power and Counter-Power in Network Society. International Journal of Communication, 238 – 266. CERN Editors (n.d.). A Short History Web. In home.cern. Retrieved July 2020 https://home.cern/science/computing/birth-web/short-history-web Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica (n.d.). The Invention of Internet. In Britannica.com. Retrieved July 2020 https://www.history.com/topics/inventions/invention-of-theinternet?li_source=LI&li_medium=m2m-rcw-history Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica (n.d.) Personal Computer. In Britannica.com. Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/technology/personal-computer Hansen, V. (2012). The Silk Road: A New History. Oxford University Press. History.com Editors (n.d.) Invention of PC. In History.com Retrieved July 2020 https://www.history.com/topics/inventions/invention-of-thepc?li_source=LI&li_medium=m2m-rcw-history Mark, J. (2018). Cuneiform. In Ancient.eu. Retrieved July 2020 https://www.ancient.eu/cuneiform/ McGillem (n.d.) Telegraph. In Britannica.com. Retrieved July 2020 https://www.britannica.com/technology/telegraph Revise Sociology (n.d.). What is Secularization. In revisesociology.com. Retrieved July 2020 https://revisesociology.com/2018/08/21/what-is-secularization/ Sigunik Studio. (n.d.). Parchment. In Sigunik.com. Retrieved July 2020 www.sigunik.com/about_parchment.html 23