A. For Reflection Paper / Essay
Criterion
Excellent
(20pts)
Good
(15pts)
Exemption
(10pts)
1) Focus
Clearly states the purpose of the
activity.
Implies but does not clearly state the
purpose of the activity
Does not state the purpose of the
activity
2) Content
Demonstrates a thorough selfreflective analysis including a summary
of the activity supported by specific and
illustrative details
Demonstrates a reflective analysis
including a summary of the activity
supported by details.
Lacks development and selfreflection.
Does not include a summary of the
activity or has insufficient details.
3) Organization
Presents the reflection in a compelling,
highly-organized manner.
Presents the reflection in wellorganized matter
Presents the reflection in a poorly
organized manner.
4) Conventions
Uses articulate and appropriate
language, sophisticated word choice,
and sentence structure. (0-1 error in
grammar, punctuation, mechanics)
Uses appropriate language, word
choice, sentence structure. (2-3 errors
in grammar, punctuation, mechanics)
Uses slang and unsophisticated
word choice (4 or more errors in
grammar, punctuation, mechanics)