MANUAL OF REGULATIONS FOR NON-BANK FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS S REGULATIONS (Regulations Governing Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations) TABLE OF CONTENTS PART ONE - ORGANIZATION, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION A. SCOPE OF AUTHORITY SECTION 4101S Scope of Authority of Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations 4101S.1 Membership 4101S.2 Organizational requirements SECTIONS 4102S - 4105S (Reserved) B. CAPITALIZATION SECTION 4106S Capital of NSSLAs 4106S.1 Regulatory treatment of capital contributions of members 4106S.2 - 4106S.6 (Reserved) 4106S.7 SECTIONS Revaluation surplus 4107S - 4110S (Reserved) C. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4111S - 4115S (Reserved) D. CAPITAL-TO-RISK ASSETS RATIO SECTION 4116S Capital-to-Risk Assets Ratio SECTION 4117S Withdrawable Share Reserve SECTION 4118S Surplus Reserve for Ledger Discrepancies ix SECTION 4119S Reserve for Office Premises, Furniture, Fixtures and Equipment SECTION 4120S (Reserved) E. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4121S - 4125S (Reserved) F. NET INCOME DISTRIBUTION SECTION 4126S Limitations on Distribution of Net Income 4126S.1 Reporting and verification 4126S.2 Recording of net income for distribution SECTIONS 4127S - 4140S (Reserved) G. TRUSTEES, OFFICERS, EMPLOYEES AND AGENTS SECTION 4141S Definition; Trustees 4141S.1 4141S.2 4141S.3 4141S.4 4141S.5 Qualifications; Responsibilities and Duties of Definition of trustees Qualifications of trustees Powers/responsibilities and duties of trustees General responsibility of the board of trustees Duties and responsibilities SECTION 4142S Definition and Qualifications of Officers 4142S.1 Definition of officers 4142S.2 Qualifications of officers 4142S.3 Duties and responsibilities of officers SECTION 4143S Disqualification of Trustees and Officers 4143S.1 Persons disqualified to become trustees 4143S.2 Persons disqualified to become officers 4143S.3 Disqualification procedures 4143S.4 Effect of non-possession of qualifications or possession of disqualifications 4143S.5 (Reserved) 4143S.6 Watchlisting SECTION 4144S Compensation of Trustees, Officers and Employees 4144S.1 Compensation increases 4144S.2 Liability for loans contrary to law x SECTION 4145S Bonding of Officers and Employees SECTION 4146S Agents and Representatives SECTION 4147S Bio-data of Trustees and Officers SECTION 4148S Full-Time Manager for NSSLAs SECTIONS 4149S - 4150S (Reserved) H. BRANCHES AND OTHER OFFICES SECTION 4151S Establishment of Branches/Extension Offices 4151S.1 Application 4151S.2 Conditions precluding acceptance/processing of application 4151S.3 Internal control system 4151S.4 Permit to operate SECTIONS 4152S - 4155S (Reserved) I. BUSINESS DAYS AND HOURS SECTION 4156S Business Days and Hours SECTIONS 4157S - 4160S (Reserved) J. REPORTS SECTION SECTION SECTION 4161S 4162S 4163S Records 4161S.1 4161S.2 Reports 4162S.1 4162S.2 4162S.3 Uniform System of Accounts Philippine Financial Reporting Standards/ Philippine Accounting Standards Categories and signatories of reports Manner of filing Sanctions and procedures for filing and payment of fines (Reserved) xi SECTION 4164S Internal Audit Function 4164S.1 Status 4164S.2 Scope 4164S.3 Qualification standards of the internal auditor 4164S.4 Code of Ethics and Internal Auditing Standards SECTIONS 4165S - 4170S (Reserved) K. INTERNAL CONTROL SECTION 4171S External Auditor SECTION 4172S Financial Audit 4172S.1 Audited financial statements of NSSLAs 4172S.2 Posting of audited financial statements SECTION 4173S (Reserved) SECTION 4174S Risk Management Function SECTIONS 4175S - 4179S SECTION 4180S (Reserved) Selection, Appointment, Reporting Requirements and Delisting of External Auditors and/or Auditing Firm; Sanction L. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS SECTION 4181S Publication Requirements SECTION 4182S Business Name SECTION 4183S Prohibitions SECTIONS 4184S - 4189S (Reserved) SECTION 4190S Guidelines on Outsourcing SECTIONS 4191S (Reserved) SECTION 4192S Prompt Corrective Action Framework xii SECTION 4193S Supervision by Risks SECTION 4194S Market Risk Management SECTION 4195S Liquidity Risk Management SECTION 4196S Information Technology Risk Management (ITRM) 4196S.1 Declaration of policy 4196S.2 Purpose and scope 4196S.3 Complexity of IT risk profile 4196S.4 IT rating system 4196S.5 Definition of terms 4196S.6 Description of IT-related risks 4196S.7 IT Risk Management System (ITRMS) 4196S.8 Reports 4196S.9 Sanctions and penalties SECTIONS 4197S - 4198S (Reserved) SECTION 4199S General Provision on Sanctions PART TWO - DEPOSIT AND BORROWING OPERATIONS A. DEMAND DEPOSITS SECTION 4201S Checking Accounts SECTIONS 4202S - 4205S (Reserved) B. SAVINGS DEPOSITS SECTION 4206S Definition SECTION 4207S Minimum Deposit SECTION 4208S Withdrawals SECTION 4209S Dormant Savings Deposits SECTIONS 4210S - 4215S (Reserved) xiii C. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4216S - 4220S (Reserved) D. TIME DEPOSITS SECTION 4221S (Reserved) SECTION 4222S Minimum Term and Size of Time Deposits SECTION 4223S Withdrawals of Time Deposits SECTIONS 4224S - 4230S (Reserved) E. - F. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4231S - 4240S (Reserved) G. INTEREST ON DEPOSITS SECTION 4241S Interest on Savings Deposits SECTION 4242S Interest on Time Deposits 4242S.1 Time of payment 4242S.2 Treatment of matured time deposits SECTIONS 4243S - 4250S (Reserved) H. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4251S - 4260S (Reserved) I. SUNDRY PROVISIONS ON DEPOSIT OPERATIONS SECTION 4261S Opening and Operation of Deposit Accounts 4261S.1 Who may open deposit accounts 4261S.2 Identification of member-depositors 4261S.3 Number of deposit accounts 4261S.4 Signature card 4261S.5 Passbook and certificate of time deposit 4261S.6 Deposits in checks and other cash items SECTIONS 4262S - 4280S (Reserved) xiv J. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4281S - 4285S (Reserved) K. OTHER BORROWINGS SECTION 4286S Borrowings SECTIONS 4287S - 4298S (Reserved) SECTION 4299S General Provision on Sanctions PART THREE - LOANS AND INVESTMENTS A. LOANS IN GENERAL SECTION 4301S Lending Policies 4301S.1 Authority; loan limits; maturity of loans SECTION 4302S Basic Requirements in Granting Loans SECTION 4303S Loan Proceeds SECTION 4304S Loan Repayment SECTION 4305S Interest and Other Charges 4305S.1 - 4305S.2 (Reserved) 4305S.3 Interest in the absence of stipulation 4305S.4 Escalation clause; when allowable 4305S.5 Interest accrual on past due loans 4305S.6 Method of computing interest SECTION 4306S Past Due Accounts 4306S.1 Accounts considered past due 4306S.2 Extension/renewal of loans 4306S.3 Write-off of loans as bad debts 4306S.4 Updating of information provided to credit information bureaus xv SECTION 4307S "Truth in Lending Act" Disclosure Requirements 4307S.1 Definition of terms 4307S.2 Information to be disclosed 4307S.3 Inspection of contracts covering credit transactions 4307S.4 Posters 4307S.5 Sanctions and penal provisions SECTION 4308S Restructured Loans; General Policy SECTION 4309S Renewal of Loans SECTION 4310S Minimum Required Disclosure SECTION 4311S Unfair Collection Practices SECTION 4312S Confidentiality of Information SECTION 4313S Sanctions SECTIONS 4314S - 4320S (Reserved) B. SECURED LOANS SECTION 4321S Kinds of Security SECTIONS 4322S - 4335S (Reserved) C. - D. (RESERVED) SECTION 4336S (Reserved) SECTION 4337S Salary Loans 4337S.1 Definition of terms SECTIONS 4338S - 4355S (Reserved) E. LOANS/CREDIT ACCOMMODATIONS TO TRUSTEES, OFFICERS, STOCKHOLDERS AND THEIR RELATED INTERESTS SECTION 4356S General Policy SECTION 4357S Direct/Indirect Borrowings; Ceilings xvi SECTION 4358S Records; Reports SECTIONS 4359S - 4369S (Reserved) SECTION 4370S Sanctions F. - I. (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4371S - 4390S (Reserved) J. OTHER OPERATIONS SECTION 4391S Fund Investments 4391S.1 - 4391S.2 (Reserved) 4391S.3 Investment in debt and marketable equity securities 4391S.4 - 4391S.10 (Reserved) SECTION 4392S Loan Portfolio and Other Risk Assets Review System SECTIONS 4393S - 4395S (Reserved) K. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS SECTIONS 4396S - 4398S (Reserved) SECTION 4399S PART FOUR - General Provision on Sanctions BSP REGULATIONS ON FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION A. CONSUMER PROTECTION OVERSIGHT FUNCTION SECTION 4401S Consumer Protection Oversight Function 4401S.1 Role and Responsibility of the Board and Senior Management 4401S.2 Consumer Protection Risk Management Syetem (CPRMS) B. CONSUMER PROTECTION STANDARDS OF CONDUCT FOR BSFIS SECTION 4402S Consumer Protection Standards 4402S.1 Disclosure and Transparency 4402S.2 Protection of Client Information xvii 4402S.3 4402S.4 4402S.5 Fair Treatment Effective Recourse Financial Education and Awareness C. ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS SECTION 4403S Enforcement Actions SECTIONS 4404S - 4499S (Reserved) PART FIVE - (RESERVED) SECTIONS 4501S - 4599S (Reserved) PART SIX - MISCELLANEOUS A. OTHER OPERATIONS SECTION 4601S Fines and Other Charges 4601S.1 Guidelines on the imposition of monetary penalties; payment of penalties or fines SECTIONS 4602S - 4630S (Reserved) SECTION 4631S SECTIONS 4632S - 4640S (Reserved) SECTION 4641S Electronic Services SECTION 4642S Issuance and Operations of Electronic Money 4642S.1 Declaration of policy 4642S.2 Definitions 4642S.3 Prior Bangko Sentral approval 4642S.4 Common provisions 4642S.5 Quasi-bank license requirement 4642S.6 Sanctions 4642S.7 Transitory provisions 4642S.8 - 4642S.10 (Reserved) 4642S.11 Outsourcing of services by Electronic Money Issuers (EMIs) to Electronic Money Network Service Providers (EMNSP) Revocation/Suspension of Non-Stock Savings and Loans Association License xviii SECTIONS 4643S - 4649S (Reserved) SECTION 4650S Philippine and Foreign Currency Notes and Coins B. SUNDRY PROVISIONS SECTION 4651S Notice of Dissolution SECTION 4652S Confidential Information SECTION 4653S Examination by the Bangko Sentral SECTION 4654S Applicability of Other Rules SECTION 4655S Annual Supervisory Fees SECTION 4656S Basic Law Governing Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations SECTION 4657S Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations Premises and Other Fixed Assets 4657S.1 Accounting for non-stock savings and loans associations premises; other fixed assets 4657S.2 (Reserved) 4657S.3 Reclassification of real and other properties acquired as non-stock savings and loans association premises 4657S.4 - 4657S.8 (Reserved) 4657S.9 Batas Pambansa Blg. 344 - An Act to Enhance the Mobility of Disabled Persons by Requiring Certain Buildings, Institutions, Establishments and Public Utilities to Install Facilities and Other Devices 4657S.10 Republic Act No. 9994 - An Act Granting Additional Benefits and Privileges to Senior Citizens, Further Amending Republic Act No. 7432 of 1992 As Amended by Republic Act No. 9257 of 2003. SECTIONS 4658S - 4659S (Reserved) xix SECTION 4660S Disclosure of Remittance Charges and Other Relevant Information SECTIONS 4661S - 4690S (Reserved) SECTION 4691S SECTIONS 4692S - 4694S (Reserved) SECTION 4695S SECTIONS 4696S - 4698S (Reserved) SECTION 4699S Anti-Money Laundering Regulations 4691S.1 - 4691S.8 (Reserved) 4691S.9 Sanctions and penalties Valid Identification Cards for Financial Transactions General Provision on Sanctions xx List of Appendices 14.12.31 LIST OF APPENDICES No. SUBJECT MATTER S-1 Safeguards in Bonding of NSSLA Accountable Officers and Employees S-2 List of Reports Required from Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations Annex S-2-a - Reporting Guidelines on Crimes/Losses S-3 Guidelines on Prescribed Reports Signatories and Signatory Authorization Annex S-3-a - Format of Resolution for Signatories of Category A-1 Reports Annex S-3-b - Format of Resolution for Signatories of Category A-2 Reports Annex S-3-c - Format of Resolution for Signatories of Categories A-3 and B Reports S-4 Format of Disclosure Statement on Small Business/Retail/Consumer Credit S-5 Abstract of "Truth in Lending Act" (Republic Act No. 3765) S-6 Anti-Money Laundering Regulations (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) Annex S-6-a - Certification of Compliance with Anti-Money Laundering Regulations (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) Annex S-6-b - Rules on Submission of Covered Transaction Reports and Suspicious Transaction Reports by Covered Institutions (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) S-7 Revised Implementing Rules and Regulations R.A. No. 9160, as amended by R.A. No. 9194 (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) S-8 Guidelines to Govern the Selection, Appointment, Reporting Requirements and Delisting of External Auditors and/or Auditing Firm of Covered Entities xix List of Appendices 14.12.31 LIST OF APPENDICES No. SUBJECT MATTER S-9 Guidelines in Classifying Loans and Other Risk Assets and Setting up Allowance for Probable Losses S - 10 Guidelines and Procedures Governing the Consumer Assistance Management System (CAMS) of BSP-Supervised Financial Institutions xx §§ 4101S - 4101S.2 08.12.31 PART ONE ORGANIZATION, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION A. SCOPE OF AUTHORITY Section 4101S Scope of Authority of Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations (NSSLA). An NSSLA shall include any nonstock, non-profit corporation engaged in the business of accumulating the savings of its members and using such accumulations for loans to members to service the needs of households by providing long-term financing for home building and development and for personal finance. An NSSLA may also engage in a death benefit program meant exclusively for the benefit of its members. An NSSLA shall accept deposits from and grant loans to its members only and shall not transact business with the general public. § 4101S.1 Membership a. NSSLAs shall issue a certificate of membership to every qualified member and shall maintain a registry of their members. b. An NSSLA shall confine its membership to a well-defined group of persons. A well-defined group shall consist of any of the following: (1) Employees, officers, and trustees of one (1) company, including memberretirees; (2) Government employees belonging to the same office, branch, or department, including member-retirees; and (3) Immediate members of the families up to the second degree of consanguinity or affinity of those falling under Items “(1)” and “(2)” above. NSSLAs whose articles of incorporation and by-laws were approved and registered prior to the effectivity of R. A. No. 8367 and which limit and/or allow membership coverage broader or narrower than the 1 foregoing definition, shall be allowed to continue as such. The Monetary Board may, as circumstances warrant, require NSSLAs mentioned in the immediately preceding paragraph to amend their by-laws to comply with the concept of a well-defined group. c. In no case shall the total amount of entrance fees exceed one percent (1%) of the amount to be contributed or otherwise paid-in by the particular member: Provided, That for new members, the fee shall be based on the amount of contributions computed in accordance with the revaluation of the assets of the NSSLA. § 4101S.2 Organizational requirements1 a. Articles of Incorporation; by-laws The articles of incorporation and by-laws of a proposed NSSLA, or any amendment thereto, shall not be registered with the SEC unless accompanied by a certificate of approval from the Monetary Board. b. Application for approval. The articles of incorporation and by-laws of a proposed NSSLA, both accomplished in the prescribed forms, shall be submitted to the Monetary Board through the appropriate department of the SES together with a covering application for the approval thereof, signed by a majority of the board of trustees and verified by one of them. The application shall include: (1) The proposed articles of incorporation and by-laws together with the names and addresses of the incorporators, trustees and officers, with a statement of their character, experience,and general fitness to engage in the non-stock savings and loan business; See SEC Circular No. 3 dated 16 February 2006. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 1 §§ 4101S.2 - 4106S.1 13.12.31 (2) An itemized statement of the estimated receipts and expenditures of the proposed NSSLA for the first year; (3) Filing fee of P1,000; and (4) Such other information as the Monetary Board may require. c. Grounds for disapproval of application. The Monetary Board may deny the application to organize an NSSLA on the basis of a finding that: (1) The NSSLA is being organized for any purpose other than to engage in the business of a legitimate NSSLA; (2) The NSSLA’s financial program is unsound; (3) The proposed members are adequately served by one (1) or more existing NSSLAs; and (4) There exist other reasons which the Monetary Board may consider as sufficient ground for such disapproval. d. Certificate of authority to operate; revocation or suspension thereof. NSSLAs, prior to transacting business, shall procure a certificate of authority to transact business from the Monetary Board. After due notice and hearing, the Monetary Board may revoke or suspend, for such period as it determines, the certificate of authority of any NSSLA, the solvency of which is imperiled by losses or irregularities, or of any NSSLA which willfully violates any provision of R. A. No. 8367, these rules or any pertinent law or regulation. (As amended by CL-2008-078 dated 15 December 2008) Secs. 4102S - 4105S (Reserved) B. CAPITALIZATION Sec. 4106S Capital of NSSLAs. A newly organized NSSLA shall have a minimum initial aggregate capital contribution of P1.0 million. Thereafter, an NSSLA shall maintain a minimum capital that would allow it to comply with the capital adequacy ratio requirement as provided under Sec. 4116S. S Regulations Part I - Page 2 NSSLAs shall adopt policies to encourage their members to increase their capital contributions which shall be classified by the NSSLA as either fixed/nonwithdrawable or withdrawable capital in accordance with the definition provided under Subsec. 4106S.1. Partial withdrawal from the amount paid by a member as withdrawable capital contributions, during his membership, may be allowed unless the by-laws of the NSSLA provide otherwise: Provided, That policies allowing the partial withdrawal by a member of his withdrawable capital contributions shall comply with the provisions of Subsec. 4106S.1. (As amended by Circular Nos.789 dated 28 February 2013 and 573 dated 22 June 2007) § 4106S.1 Regulatory treatment of capital contributions of members. An NSSLA shall ensure that monies received representing capital contributions are duly registered in the books of the Association under the name of the member making such contributions. Capital contributions of members shall be classified by an NSSLA as either fixed/ non-withdrawable or withdrawable as herein defined. a. Fixed/non-withdrawable capital refers to the member’s capital contribution in the NSSLA which he must maintain for the duration of his membership thereon. (1) Minimum Amount - Every member of an NSSLA shall be required to maintain a fixed/non-withdrawable capital contribution of at least P1,000.00 unless a higher minimum is prescribed under the NSSLA’s by-laws. (2) Ceiling. An NSSLA shall encourage all its members to increase their fixed/nonwithdrawable capital over time beyond the minimum amount prescribed under Item “(1)” hereof. However, to ensure that control over the affairs of the NSSLA remains Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4106S.1 - 4116S 13.12.31 broad-based, the total amount that a member and/or his immediate family may contribute as fixed/ non-withdrawable contributions shall be subject to a ceiling which shall be determined by the board of trustees and duly confirmed by the NSSLA’s general assembly. The prescribed ceiling shall be applied uniformly to all members: Provided, That in cases where the NSSLA is unable to comply with the capital adequacy ratio requirement as provided under Sec. 4116S, any deviation from the uniform application of or settingup of aforesaid ceiling may be allowed. b. Withdrawable capital refers to the amount of capital contributions which may be withdrawn by a member pursuant to the terms and conditions prescribed under the NSSLA’s by-laws, or as approved by the board of trustees and duly confirmed by the NSSLA’s general assembly. (1) Ceiling. At no time shall the total withdrawable capital contributions of a member and that of his immediate family, as defined in Subsec. 4101S.1.b(3), exceed ten times (10X) their fixed/non-withdrawable capital contributions. (2) Restrictions on withdrawability. Notwithstanding the capital contributions’ withdrawability, the NSSLA shall establish and prescribe the conditions and/or circumstances when the NSSLA may limit the withdrawal of the members’ withdrawable capital contributions, such as, when the NSSLA is under liquidity stress or is unable to meet the capital adequacy ratio requirement under Sec. 4116S. c. Limit on total capital contributions. NSSLAs shall prescribe a maximum amount on the total amount of fixed and withdrawable capital contributions that a family group [i.e., member and his immediate family as defined under Subsec. 4101S.1.b(3)] may hold in an NSSLA. Transitory provisions. An NSSLA shall have one (1) year period reckoned from 22 March 2013 within which to amend the pertinent provisions of its by-laws and written policies to comply with the foregoing requirements: Provided, That amounts held in excess of the prescribed ceiling under Item “b.(1)” hereof as of 22 March 2013 shall be allowed to continue as such but once reduced shall not thereafter be increased beyond the prescribed ceiling. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) §§ 4106S.2 - 4106S.6 (Reserved) § 4106S.7 Revaluation surplus. In cases of both retiring and new members, a revaluation surplus shall be added to their contributions by imputing their respective proportionate shares in the withdrawable share reserve and the reserve for furniture, fixtures, and furnishings. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Secs. 4107S - 4110S (Reserved) C. (RESERVED) Secs. 4111S - 4115S (Reserved) D. CAPITAL-TO-RISK ASSETS RATIO Sec. 4116S Capital-to-Risk Assets Ratio Capital-to-risk assets ratio (CAR) is an important tool to measure solvency and effectively manage the risk-taking activities of an NSSLA, determine its capacity to absorb unexpected losses, and adequately provide protection to members and creditors. The CAR, expressed as a percentage of total capital accounts to total risk assets shall not be less than ten percent (10%). For purposes of computing CAR, the aggregate amount of withdrawable capital contributions that shall be allowed to form part of an NSSLA’s total capital accounts shall be capped at ten times (10X) the aggregate amount of fixed/non-withdrawable capital contributions. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 3 §§ 4116S - 4118S 13.12.31 The total risk asset is defined as total assets minus the following assets: a. Cash on hand; b. Evidences of indebtedness of the Republic of the Philippines and any other evidences of indebtedness/obligations, the servicing and repayment of which are fully guaranteed by the Republic of the Philippines; c. Loans to the extent covered by holdout on, or assignment of, deposits maintained in the lending NSSLA; d. Office premises, depreciated; e. Furniture, fixtures and equipment, depreciated; f. Real estate mortgage loans guaranteed by the Home Guarantee Corporation to the extent covered by the guarantee; and g. Other non-risk items as the Monetary Board may, from time to time, authorize to be deducted from total assets. The Monetary Board shall prescribe the manner of determining the total assets of such NSSLA for the purpose of this Section, but contingent accounts shall not be included among total assets. Whenever the capital accounts of an NSSLA are deficient with respect to the preceding paragraph, the Monetary Board, after considering the report of the appropriate department of the SES on the state of solvency of the NSSLA concerned, shall limit or prohibit the distribution of net income and shall require that part or all of net income be used to increase the capital accounts of the NSSLA until the minimum requirement has been met. The Monetary Board may, after considering the aforesaid report of the appropriate department of the SES, and if the amount of the deficiency justifies it, restrict or prohibit the making of new investments of any sort by the NSSLA with the exception of the purchases of evidence of indebtedness included under Item “b” of this Section until the minimum required capital ratio has been restored. S Regulations Part I - Page 4 Transitory provisions. An NSSLA which failed to meet the minimum CAR as prescribed above shall have until 30 June 2013 within which to comply. (As amended by Circular Nos. 789 dated 28 February 2013 and 573 dated 22 June 2007) Sec. 4117S Withdrawable Share Reserve NSSLAs shall create a withdrawable share reserve which shall consist of two percent (2%) of the total capital contributions of the members. An amount corresponding to the withdrawable share reserve shall be set up by the NSSLA, such amount invested in bonds or evidences of indebtedness of the Republic of the Philippines or of its subdivisions, agencies or instrumentalities, the servicing and repayment of which are fully guaranteed by the Republic of the Philippines, and evidences of indebtedness of the Bangko Sentral. For a uniform interpretation of the provisions of this Section, the following shall serve as guidelines: a. The withdrawable share reserve shall be set up from the undivided profits of the NSSLA and shall be funded in the form of cash deposited as a separate account and/ or an investment allowed under this Section; b. Should there be an increase in the capital contribution, the reserve shall be correspondingly adjusted at the end of each month from undivided profits, if any; and c. The reserve shall be adjusted first before the NSSLA shall declare and distribute to its members any portion of its net income at any time of the year. (As amended by Circular No. 573 dated 22 June 2007) Sec. 4118S Surplus Reserve for Ledger Discrepancies. Whenever an NSSLA has a discrepancy between its general ledger accounts and their respective subsidiary ledgers, the board of trustees of the NSSLA shall set up from the undivided profits of the NSSLA, if any, a surplus reserve, in an Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4118S - 4126S 13.12.31 amount equivalent to the amount of the discrepancy, and this reserve shall not be available for distribution to members or for any other purpose unless and until the discrepancy is accounted for. The board of trustees shall also direct the employee responsible for the discrepancy to account for said discrepancy: Provided, That the failure of the employee to do so shall constitute as ground for his dismissal if the discrepancy is of serious or recurring nature. (As amended by Circular Nos. 661 dated 01 September 2009 and 573 dated 22 June 2007) Sec. 4119S Reserve for Office Premises, Furniture, Fixtures and Equipment. NSSLAs shall set aside five percent (5%) of their yearly net income until it amount to at least five percent (5%) of the total assets as a reserve for a building fund to cover the cost of construction or acquisition of office premises, and of the purchase of office furniture, fixtures and equipment. An NSSLA which, as determined by its board of trustees, has adequate office premises, furniture, fixtures and equipment necessary for the conduct of its business need not set up the reserve: Provided, That this fact should be certified by its board of trustees in a resolution to be submitted to the appropriate department of the SES for verification and approval: Provided, however, That in case reserves had been set up, the NSSLA so exempted may revert the reserves to free surplus. (As amended by Circular No. 573 dated 22 June 2007) Sec. 4120S (Reserved) E. (RESERVED) Secs. 4121S - 4125S (Reserved) F. NET INCOME DISTRIBUTION Sec. 4126S Limitations on Distribution of Net Income a. Amount available for income distribution. An NSSLA may distribute net income to members out of its adjusted Undivided Profits and the balance of its Surplus Free account as of the calendar yearend or fiscal year-end immediately preceding the date of net income distribution: Provided, That in addition to the requirements as provided in this Section, in no case shall the NSSLA distribute any of its net income and/or surplus to its members if its CAR and capital contributions are below the level required under Secs. 4106S and 4116S , respectively. b. Basis for participation in profits Member-contributors of an NSSLA may participate in the profits of the NSSLA on the basis of the balances of their capital contributions as determined by the board of trustees: Provided, That an NSSLA shall distribute net income to members only once in a calendar or fiscal year adopted by such NSSLA. c. Level of withdrawable share reserve No NSSLA shall distribute any of its net income to its members if the withdrawable share reserve required under Sec. 4117S is less than, or by such distribution would be reduced below, the amount specified in said Section. The reserve shall be adjusted first before the NSSLA shall distribute its net income for the year. d. Discrepancies between the general ledger and subsidiary ledger accounts. The surplus reserves set up as required under Sec. 4118S shall not be reverted to Surplus Free available for distribution to members unless and until the discrepancy between the general ledger accounts and their respective subsidiary ledgers for which the surplus reserve has been set up ceases to exist. e. Other unbooked capital adjustments required by Bangko Sentral, whether or not allowed to be set up on a staggered basis The unbooked loss reserves and other unbooked capital adjustments required by the Bangko Sentral based on the latest approved Report of Examination of the Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 5 §§ 4126S - 4141S.2 13.12.31 NSSLA, whether or not allowed to be set up on a staggered basis, shall be deducted from the amount of net income available for distribution to members. f. Interest and other income earned but not yet collected/received, net of allowance for credit losses. Accrued interest and other income not yet received but already recorded by an NSSLA from financial assets, net of allowance for credit losses, shall be deducted from the amount of net income available for distribution to members. (As amended by Circular Nos. 789 dated 28 February 2013 and 573 dated 22 June 2007) § 4126S.1 Reporting and verification Declaration of income for distribution to members shall be reported by an NSSLA concerned to the appropriate department of the SES in the prescribed form (Revised BSP Form No. 7-26-25H) within ten (10) business days after date of declaration. Pending verification of abovementioned report by the appropriate department of the SES, the NSSLA concerned shall not make any announcement or communication on the intended distribution of net income or shall any actual distribution be made thereon. In any case, the declaration may be announced and the income distributed, if after twenty (20) business days from the date of the report required herein shall have been received by the Bangko Sentral, no advice against such distribution has been received by the NSSLA concerned. (As amended by Circular Nos. 661 dated 01 September 2009 and 573 dated 22 June 2007) § 4126S.2 Recording of net income for distribution. The liability for members’ share in the net income distribution shall be taken up in the books upon receipt of Bangko Sentral approval thereof, or if no such approval is received, after twenty (20) business days from the date the required Report on Distributable Net Income was received by the appropriate department of S Regulations Part I - Page 6 the SES whichever comes earlier. A memorandum entry may be made to trustees and for full disclosure purposes, the amount of income for distribution may be disclosed in the financial statements by means of a footnote which should include a statement to the effect that the distribution is subject to review by the Bangko Sentral. (As amended by Circular No. 573 dated 22 June 2007) Secs. 4127S - 4140S (Reserved) G. TRUSTEES, OFFICERS, EMPLOYEES AND AGENTS Strengthening Corporate Governance. It is the thrust of the Bangko Sentral to continuously strengthen corporate governance in its supervised financial institutions cognizant that this is central in sustaining the resiliency and stability of the financial system. In this light, the Bangko Sentral is aligning its existing regulations with international best practices that promote good corporate governance such as the “Principles for Enhancing Corporate Governance” issued by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. (Circular No. 749 dated 27 February 2012) Sec. 4141S Definition; Qualifications; Responsibilities and Duties of Trustees For purposes of this Section, the following shall be the definition, qualifications, responsibilities and duties of trustees. § 4141S.1 Definition of trustees Trustees shall include: (a) those who are named as such in the articles of incorporation; (b) those duly elected in subsequent meetings of the NSSLA’s members; and (c) those elected to fill vacancies in the board of trustees. § 4141S.2 Qualifications of trustees No person shall be eligible as trustee of an NSSLA unless he is a member of good standing of such NSSLA. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4141S.2 - 4141S.5 13.12.31 In addition, such person shall have the qualifications and none of the disqualifications as provided in pertinent laws and Bangko Sentral rules. A trustee shall have the following minimum qualifications: (1) He shall be at least twenty five (25) years of age at the time of his election or appointment; (2) He shall be at least a college graduate or have at least five (5) years experience in business, or shall have undergone any Bangko Sentral training in NSSLA or banking operations: Provided, however, That an undergraduate eligible to be elected as trustee in the NSSLA’s by-laws may be allowed as may be approved by the Bangko Sentral: Provided, further, That Bangko Sentral approval shall no longer be required for a re-elected college undergraduate who was previously allowed to sit as trustee: Provided, finally, That (1) the previous approval was obtained on or after 01 January 2011; and (2) the trustee has had continuous service within the said NSSLA; (3) He must have attended a special seminar on corporate governance for board of trustees conducted or accredited by the Bangko Sentral; and (4) He must be fit and proper for the position of a trustee of the NSSLA. In determining whether a person is fit and proper for the position of a trustee, the following matters must be considered: integrity/probity, physical/mental fitness, competence, relevant education/financial literacy/training, diligence and knowledge/ experience. The members of the board of trustees shall possess the foregoing qualifications for trustees in addition to those required or prescribed under R.A. No. 8791 and other existing applicable laws and regulations. (As amended by Circular No. 800 dated 21 June 2013) § 4141S.3 Powers/responsibilities and duties of trustees. The corporate powers of an NSSLA shall be exercised, its business conducted and all its property controlled and held by its board of trustees. The powers of the board of trustees as conferred by law are original and cannot be revoked by the members. The trustees hold their office charged with the duty to exercise sound and objective judgment for the best interest of the NSSLA. (As amended by Circular Nos.757 dated 08 May 2012 and 749 dated 27 February 2012) § 4141S.4 General responsibility of the board of trustees. The position of an NSSLA trustee is a position of trust. A trustee assumes certain responsibilities to different constituencies or stakeholders, i.e., the NSSLA itself, member-depositors, its clients and other creditors, its management and employees, the regulators, deposit insurer and the public at large. These constituencies or stakeholders have the right to expect that the institution is being run in a prudent and sound manner. The board of trustees is primarily responsible for approving and overseeing the implementation of the NSSLA’s strategic objectives, risk strategy, corporate governance and corporate values. Further, the board of trustees is also responsible for monitoring and overseein the performance of senior management as the latter manages the day- to- day affairs of the institution. (As amended by Circular Nos. 757 dated 08 May 2012 and 749 dated 27 February 2012) § 4141S.5 Duties and responsibilities a. Board of trustees (1) To approve and monitor the implementation of strategic objectives Consistent with the institution’s strategic objectives, business plans shall be established for the NSSLA including its trust Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 7 § 4141S.5 12.12.31 operations, and initiatives thereto shall be implemented with clearly defined responsibilities and accountabilities. These shall take into account the NSSLA’s longterm financial interests, its level of risk tolerance and its ability to manage risks effectively. The board shall establish a system for measuring performance against plans through regular monitoring and reviews, with corrective action taken as needed. The board shall likewise ensure that the NSSLA has beneficial influence on the economy by continuously providing services and facilities which will be supportive of the national economy. (2) To approve and oversee the implementation of policies governing major areas of NSSLA operations. The board shall approve policies on all major business activities, e.g., investments, loans, asset and liability management, trust, business planning and budgeting. The board shall accordingly define the NSSLA’s level of risk tolerance in respect of said activities. A mechanism to ensure compliance with said policies shall also be provided. The board shall set out matters and authorities reserved to it for decision, which include, among others, major capital expenditures, equity investments and divestments. The board shall also establish the limits of the discretionary powers of each officer, committee, sub-committee and such other groups for purposes of lending, investing or any other financial undertaking that exposes the NSSLA to significant risks. (3) To approve and oversee the implementation of risk management policies. The board of trustees shall be responsible for defining the NSSLA’s level of risk tolerance and for the approval and oversight of the implementation of policies and procedures relating to the management of risks throughout the institution, including S Regulations Part I - Page 8 its trust operations. The risk management policy shall include: (a) a comprehensive risk management approach; (b) a detailed structure of limits, guidelines and other parameters used to govern risk-taking; (c) a clear delineation of lines of responsibilities for managing risk; (d) an adequate system for measuring risk; and (e) effective internal controls and a comprehensive risk-reporting process. The board of trustees shall ensure that a robust internal reporting system is in place that shall enable each employee to contribute to the appreciation of the NSSLA’s overall risk exposures. The board of trustees shall ensure that the risk management function is given adequate resources to enable it to effectively perform its functions. The risk management function shall be afforded with adequate personnel, access to information technology systems and systems development resources, and support and access to internal information. (4) To oversee selection and performance of senior management. It is the primary responsibility of the board of trustees to appoint competent management team at all times, monitor and assess the performance of the management team based on established performance standards that are consistent with the NSSLA’s strategic objectives, and conduct regular review of NSSLA’s policies with the management team. (a) The board of trustees shall apply fit and proper standards on key personnel. Integrity, technical expertise and experience in the institution’s business, either current or planned, shall be the key considerations in the selection process. And because mutual trust and a close working relationship are important, the members of senior management shall uphold the general Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4141S.5 12.12.31 operating philosophy, vision and core values of the institution. The board of trustees shall replace members of senior management, when necessary, and have in place an appropriate plan of succession. (b) The board of trustees shall regularly monitor the actions of senior management and ensure that these are consistent with the policies that it has approved. It shall put in place formal performance standards to be able to effectively assess the performance of senior management. The performance standards shall be consistent with the NSSLA’s strategic objectives and business plans, taking into account the NSSLA’s longterm financial interests. (c) The board of trustees shall regularly meet with senior management to engage in discussions, question and critically review the reports and information provided by the latter. The board of trustees shall set the frequency of meeting with senior management taking into account the size, complexity of operations and risk profile of the NSSLA. (d) The board of trustees shall regularly review policies, internal controls and self assessment functions (e.g., internal audit, risk management and compliance) with senior management to determine areas for improvement as well as to promptly identify and address significant risks and issues. The board of trustees shall set the frequency of review taking into account the size, complexity of operations and risk profile of the NSSLA. The board of trustees shall ensure that senior management’s expertise and knowledge shall remain relevant given the NSSLA’s strategic objectives, complexity of operations and risk profile. (5) To consistently conduct the affairs of the institution with a high degree of integrity. Since reputation is a very valuable asset, it is in the institution’s best interest that in dealings with the public, it observes a high standard of integrity. The board of trustees shall lead in establishing the tone of good governance from the top and in setting corporate values, codes of conduct and other standards of appropriate behavior for itself, the senior management and other employees. The board of trustees shall: (a) Articulate clear policies on the handling of any transaction with directors, officers, stockholders, and their related interests (DOSRI) and other related parties ensuring that there is effective compliance with existing laws, rules and regulations at all times and no stakeholder is unduly disadvantaged. In this regard, the board of trustees shall define “related party transaction”, which is expected to cover a wider definition than DOSRI under existing regulations and a broader spectrum of transactions (i.e., not limited to credit exposures), such that relevant transactions that could pose material risk or potential abuse to the NSSLA and its stakeholders are captured. (b) Require the NSSLA’s members to confirm by majority vote, in the annual members’ meeting, the NSSLA’s significant transactions with its DOSRI and other related parties. (c) Articulate acceptable and unacceptable activities, transactions and behaviors that could result or potentially result in conflict of interest, personal gain at the expense of the institution, or unethical conduct. (d) Articulate policies that will prevent the use of the facilities of the NSSLA in furtherance of criminal and other improper or illegal activities, such as but not limited to financial misreporting, money laundering, fraud, bribery or corruption. (e) Explicitly discourage the taking of excessive risks as defined by internal policies and establish an employees’ compensation scheme effectively aligned with prudent risk taking. The compensation scheme shall be adjusted for all types of risk and sensitive to the time horizon of risk. Further, the grant of compensation in forms other than cash shall be consistent with the overall risk Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 9 § 4141S.5 12.12.31 alignment of the NSSLA. The board of trustees shall regularly monitor and review the compensation scheme to ensure that it operates and achieves the objectives as intended. (f) Ensure that employee pension funds are fully funded or the corresponding liability appropriately recognized in the books of the NSSLA at all times. Further, the board of trustees shall ensure that all transactions involving the pension fund are conducted at arm’s length terms. (g) Allow employees to communicate, with protection from reprisal, legitimate concerns about illegal, unethical or questionable practices directly to the board of trustees or to any independent unit. Policies shall likewise be set on how such concerns shall be investigated and addressed, for example, by an internal control function, an objective external party, senior management and/or the board itself. (h) Articulate policies in communicating corporate values, codes of conduct and other standards in the NSSLA as well as the means to confidentially report concerns or violations to an appropriate body. (6) To define appropriate governance policies and practices for the NSSLA and for its own work and to establish means to ensure that such are followed and periodically reviewed 1 for ongoing improvement. The board of trustees, through policies and its own practices, shall establish and actively promote, communicate and recognize sound governance principles and practices to reflect a culture of strong governance in the NSSLA as seen by both internal and external stakeholders. (a) The board of trustees shall ensure that the NSSLA’s organizational structure facilitates effective decision-making and good governance. This includes clear definition and delineation of the lines of responsibility and accountability, especially between the roles of the Chairman of the board of trustees and Chief Executive Officer/President. (b) The board of trustees shall maintain, and periodically update, organizational rules, by-laws, or other similar documents setting out its organization, rights, responsibilities and key activities. (c) The board of trustees shall restructure itself in a way, including in terms of size, frequency of meetings and the use of committees, so as to promote efficiency, critical discussion of issues and thorough review of matters. It shall meet regularly to properly discharge its functions. It shall also ensure that independent views in board meetings shall be given full consideration and all such meetings shall be duly minuted. (d) The board shall conduct and maintain the affairs of the institution within the scope of its authority as prescribed in its charter and in existing laws, rules and regulations. It shall ensure effective compliance with the latter, which include prudential reporting obligations. Serious weaknesses in adhering to these duties and responsibilities may be considered as unsafe and unsound NSSLA practice. The board shall appoint a compliance officer who shall be responsible for coordinating, monitoring and facilitating compliance with existing laws, rules and regulations. The compliance officer shall be vested with appropriate authority and provided with appropriate support and resources. 1 NSSLAs shall submit the following to the appropriate department of the SES within 90 calendar days from 17 March 2012: (1) A Secretary’s Certificate attesting the approval of the board of trustees to changes in the policies. (2) Acknowledgement receipt of copies of specific duties and responsibilities of the board of trustees and of a trustee, and certification that they fully understand the same. S Regulations Part I - Page 10 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4141S.5 12.12.31 (e) The board of trustees shall establish a system of checks and balances which applies in the first instance to the board itself. Among the members of the board, an effective system of checks and balances must exist. The system shall also provide a mechanism for effective check and control by the board over the chief executive officer and key managers and by the latter over the line officers of the NSSLA. Checks and balances in the board shall be enhanced by appointing a chairperson who is a nonexecutive, whenever possible. (f) The board of trustees shall assess at least annually its performance and effectiveness as a body, as well as its various committees, the chief executive officer, the individual trustee, and the NSSLA itself, which may be facilitated by the corporate governance committee or external facilitators. The composition of the board shall also be reviewed regularly with the end in view of having a balanced membership. Toward this end, a system and procedure for evaluation shall be adopted which shall include, but not limited to, the setting of benchmark and peer group analysis. (g) The board shall ensure that individual members of the board and the members are accurately and timely informed. It shall provide all its trustees and to the members a comprehensive and understandable assessment of the NSSLA’s performance, financial condition and risk exposures. All trustees shall have reasonable access to any information about the institution at all times. It shall also provide appropriate information that flows internally and to the public. (7) To constitute committees to increase efficiency and allow deeper focus in specific areas. The board of trustees shall create committees, the number and nature of which would depend on the size of the NSSLA and the board, the complexity of operations, long-term strategies and risk tolerance level of the institution. (a) The board of trustees shall approve, review and update periodically, or the respective charters of each committee or other documents that set out its mandate, scope and working procedures. (b) The board of trustees shall appoint members of the committees taking into account the optimal mix of skills and experience to allow the members to fully understand, be critical and objectively evaluate the issues. In order to promote objectivity, the board of trustees, shall appoint independent trustees and nonexecutive members of the board to the greatest extent possible while ensuring that such mix will not impair the collective skills, experience, and effectiveness of the committees. (c) The board of trustees shall ensure that each committee shall maintain appropriate records (e.g., minutes of meetings or summary of matters reviewed and decisions taken) of their deliberations and decisions. Such records shall document the committee’s fulfillment of its responsibilities and facilitate the assessment of the effective dispense of its functions. (d) The board of trustees shall constitute, at a minimum, the audit committee. The audit committee shall be composed of members with accounting, auditing, or related financial management expertise or experience commensurate with the size, complexity of operations and risk profile of the NSSLA. To the greatest extent possible, the audit committee shall be composed of a sufficient number of non-executive board members. Further, the chief executive officer, chief financial officer and/or treasurer shall not be appointed as members of the audit committee. The audit committee provides oversight over the institution’s financial reporting policies, practices and control and internal and external audit functions. It shall be responsible for the setting up of the internal audit department and for the appointment of the internal auditor as well as the independent external auditor who shall both Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 10a § 4141S.5 12.12.31 report directly to the audit committee. In cases of appointment or dismissal of external auditors, it is encouraged that the decision be made only by independent, nonexecutive audit committee members. It shall monitor and evaluate the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system. The audit committee shall review and approve the audit scope and frequency. It shall receive key audit reports, and ensure that senior management is taking necessary corrective actions in a timely manner to address the weaknesses, non-compliance with policies, laws and regulations and other issues identified by auditors. The audit committee shall have explicit authority to investigate any matter within its terms of reference, full access to and cooperation by management and full discretion to invite any trustee or executive officer to attend its meetings, and adequate resources to enable it to effectively discharge its functions. The audit committee shall ensure that a review of the effectiveness of the institution’s internal controls, including financial, operational and compliance controls, and risk management, is conducted at least annually. The audit committee shall establish and maintain mechanisms by which officers and staff shall, in confidence, raise concerns about possible improprieties or malpractices in matters of financial reporting, internal control, auditing or other issues to persons or entities that have the power to take corrective action. It shall ensure that arrangement are in place for the independent investigation, appropriate follow-up action, and subsequent resolution of complaints. (8) To effectively utilize the work conducted by the internal audit and compliance functions and the external auditors. The board of trustees shall recognize and acknowledge the importance of the assessment of the independent, competent and qualified internal and external auditors and compliance officers in ensuring the safety and soundness of the S Regulations Part I - Page 10b operations of an NSSLA on a going-concern basis and communicate the same throughout the NSSLA. This shall be displayed by undertaking timely and effective actions on issues identified. Further, non-executive board members shall meet regularly, other than in meetings of the audit committee, in the absence of senior management, with the external auditor and heads of the internal audit and compliance functions. b. Specific duties and responsibilities of a trustee (1) To remain fit and proper for the position for the duration of his term. A trustee is expected to remain fit and proper for the position for the duration of his term. He should possess unquestionable credibility to make decisions objectively and resist undue influence. He shall treat board trusteeship as a profession and shall have a clear understanding of his duties and responsibilities as well as his role in promoting good governance. Hence, he shall maintain his professional integrity and continuously seek to enhance his skills, knowledge and understanding of the activities that the trustee is engaged in or intends to pursue as well as the developments in the NSSLA industry including regulatory changes through continuing education or training. (2) To conduct fair business transactions with the NSSLA and to ensure that personal interest does not bias board decisions. Trustees should, whenever possible, avoid situations that would give rise to a conflict of interest. If transactions with the institution cannot be avoided, it should be done in the regular course of business and upon terms not less favorable to the institution than those offered to others. The basic principle to be observed is that a trustee should not use his position to make profit or to acquire benefit or advantage for himself and/or his related interests. He should avoid situations that would compromise his impartiality. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4141S.5 - 4142S.1 12.12.31 (3) To act honestly and in good faith, with loyalty and in the best interest of the NSSLA , its members, regardless of the amount of their capital contributions, and other stakeholders such as its depositors, investors, borrowers, other clients and the general public. A trustee must always act in good faith, with the care which an ordinarily prudent man would exercise under similar circumstances. While a trustee should always strive to promote the interest of all members, he should also give due regard to the rights and interests of other stakeholders. (4) To devote time and attention necessary to properly discharge their duties and responsibilities. Trustees should devote sufficient time to familiarize themselves with the institution’s business. They must be constantly aware of the institution’s condition and be knowledgeable enough to contribute meaningfully to the board’s work. They must attend and actively participate in board and committee meetings, request and review meeting materials, ask questions, and request explanations. If a person cannot give sufficient time and attention to the affairs of the institution, he should neither accept his nomination nor run for election as member of the board. (5) To act judiciously. Before deciding on any matter brought before the board of trustees, every trustee should thoroughly evaluate the issues, ask questions and seek clarifications when necessary. (6) To contribute significantly to the decision-making process of the board. Trustees should actively participate and exercise objective independent judgment on corporate affairs requiring the decision or approval of such board. (7) To exercise independent judgment. A trustee should view each problem/ situation objectively. When a disagreement with others occurs, he should carefully evaluate the situation and state his position. He should not be afraid to take a position even though it might be unpopular. Corollarily, he should support plans and ideas that he thinks will be beneficial to the institution. (8) To have a working knowledge of the statutory and regulatory requirements affecting the NSSLA institution, including the content of its articles of incorporation and by-laws, the requirements of the Bangko Sentral and where applicable, the requirements of other regulatory agencies. A trustee should also keep himself informed of the industry developments and business trends in order to safeguard the institution’s competitiveness. (9) To observe confidentiality. Trustees must observe the confidentiality of nonpublic information acquired by reason of their position as trustees. They may not disclose said information to any other person without the authority of the board. (As amended by Circular Nos.757 dated 08 May 2012 and 749 dated 27 February 2012) Sec. 4142S Definition and Qualifications of Officers. Officers shall include the President, Vice-President, General Manager, Corporate Secretary, Treasurer and others mentioned as officers of the NSSLA, or whose duties as such are defined in the bylaws. The minimum qualifications for trustees prescribed in Sec. 4141S are also applicable to officers. § 4142S.1 Definition of officers Officers shall include the president, executive vice president, senior vice president, vice president, general manager, secretary, treasurer, and others mentioned as officers of the NSSLA, or those whose duties as such are defined in the by-laws, or are generally known to be the officers of the NSSLA (or any of its branches and offices other than the head office) either through announcement, representation, publication or any kind of communication made by the NSSLA. A person holding the position of chairman, vice-chairman or any other Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 10c §§ 4142S.1 - 4143S.1 12.12.31 position of the board who also performs functions of management such as those ordinarily performed by regular officers shall also be considered an officer. § 4142S.2 Qualifications of officers An officer shall have the following minimum qualifications: a. He shall be at least twenty-one (21) years of age; b. He shall be at least a college graduate or have at least five (5) years experience in NSSLA or banking operations or related activities or in a field related to his position and responsibilities, or have undergone training in NSSLA or banking operations acceptable to the appropriate department of the SES; c. He must be fit and proper for the position of an officer of the NSSLA. In determining whether a person is fit and proper for the position of an officer, the following matters must be considered: integrity/probity, competence, education, diligence, and experience/training. The foregoing qualifications for officers shall be in addition to those already required or prescribed by R.A. No. 8367, as amended, and other existing applicable laws and regulations. § 4142S.3 Duties and responsibilities of officers (a) To set the tone of good governance from the top. NSSLA officers shall promote the good governance practices within the NSSLA by ensuring that policies on governance as approved by the board of trustees are consistently adopted across the NSSLA. (b) To oversee the day-to-day management of the NSSLA. NSSLA officers shall ensure that NSSLA‘s activities and operations are consistent with the NSSLA’s strategic objectives, risk strategy, corporate values and policies as approved by the board S Regulations Part I - Page10d of trustees. They shall establish a NSSLAwide management system characterized by strategically aligned and mutually reinforcing performance standards across the organization. (c) To ensure that duties are effectively delegated to the staff and to establish a management structure that promotes accountability and transparency. NSSLA officers shall establish measurable standards, initiatives and specific responsibilities and accountabilities for each NSSLA personnel. NSSLA officers shall oversee the performance of these delegated duties and responsibilities and shall ultimately be responsible to the board of trustees for the performance of the NSSLA. (d) To promote and strengthen checks and balances systems in the NSSLA. NSSLA officers shall promote sound internal controls and avoid activities that shall compromise the effective dispensing of their functions. Further, they shall ensure that they give due recognition to the importance of the internal audit, compliance and external audit functions. (Circular Nos.757 dated 08 May 2012 and 749 dated 27 February 2012) Sec. 4143S Disqualification of Trustees and Officers. The following regulations shall govern the disqualification of NSSLAs’ trustees and officers. § 4143S.1 Persons disqualified to become trustees. Without prejudice to specific provisions of law prescribing disqualifications for trustees, the following are disqualified from becoming trustees: a. Permanently disqualified. Trustees/ officers/employees permanently disqualified by the Monetary Board from holding a director/trustee position: (1) Persons who have been convicted by final judgment of a court for offenses involving dishonesty or breach of trust such as but not limited to, estafa, embezzlement, Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4143S.1 12.12.31 extortion, forgery, malversation, swindling, theft, robbery, falsification, bribery, violation of B.P. Blg. 22, violation of Anti- Graft and Corrupt Practices Act and prohibited acts and transactions under Section 7 of R.A. No. 6713 (Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees); (2) Persons who have been convicted by final judgment of a court sentencing them to serve a maximum term of imprisonment of more than six (6) years; (3) Persons who have been convicted by final judgment of the court for violation of banking/quasi-banking/NSSLA laws, rules and regulations; (4) Persons who have been judicially declared insolvent, spendthrift or incapacitated to contract; (5) Trustees, officers or employees of closed banks/QBs/trust entities who were found to be culpable for such institution’s closure as determined by the Monetary Board; (6) Trustees and officers of banks, QBs and trust entities found by the Monetary Board as administratively liable for violation of banking laws, rules and regulations where a penalty of removal from office is imposed, and which finding of the Monetary Board has become final and executory; or (7) Trustees and officers of banks, QBs and trust entities or any person found by the Monetary Board to be unfit for the position of trustees or officers because they were found administratively liable by another government agency for violation of banking laws, rules and regulations or any offense/violation involving dishonesty or breach of trust, and which finding of said government agency has become final and executory. b. Temporarily disqualified. Trustees/ officers/employees disqualified by the Monetary Board from holding a trustee position for a specific/indefinite period of time. Included are: (1) Persons who refuse to fully disclose the extent of their business interest or any material information to the appropriate department of the SES when required pursuant to a provision of law or of a circular, memorandum, rule or regulation of the Bangko Sentral. This disqualification shall be in effect as long as the refusal persists; (2) Trustees who have been absent or who have not participated for whatever reasons in more than fifty percent (50%) of all meetings, both regular and special, of the board of trustees during their incumbency, and trustees who failed to physically attend for whatever reasons in at least twenty-five percent (25%) of all board meetings in any year, except that when a notarized certification executed by the corporate secretary has been submitted attesting that said trustees were given the agenda materials prior to the meeting and that their comments/decisions thereon were submitted for deliberation/discussion and were taken up in the actual board meeting, said trustees shall be considered present in the board meeting. This disqualification applies only for purposes of the immediately succeeding election; (3) Persons who are delinquent in the payment of their obligations as defined hereunder: (a) Delinquency in the payment of obligations means that an obligation of a person with an NSSLA where he/she is a trustee or officer, or at least two (2) obligations with other banks/FIs, under different credit lines or loan contracts, are past due pursuant to existing regulations; (b) Obligations shall include all borrowings from a bank/QB/trust entity/ NSSLA/other FIs obtained by: (i) A trustee or officer for his own account or as the representative or agent of Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 10e § 4143S.1 12.12.31 others or where he/she acts as a guarantor, endorser or surety for loans from such FIs; (ii) The spouse or child under the parental authority of the trustee or officer; (iii) Any person whose borrowings or loan proceeds were credited to the account of, or used for the benefit of a trustee or officer; (iv) A partnership of which a trustee or officer, or his/her spouse is the managing partner or a general partner owning a controlling interest in the partnership; and (v) A corporation, association or firm wholly-owned or majority of the capital of which is owned by any or a group of persons (Next page is Page 11) S Regulations Part I - Page 10f Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4143S.1 08.12.31 mentioned in the foregoing Items “(i)”, “(ii)” and “(iv)”; This disqualification shall be in effect as long as the delinquency persists. (4) Persons who have been convicted by a court for offenses involving dishonesty or breach of trust such as, but not limited to, estafa, embezzlement, extortion, forgery, malversation, swindling, theft, robbery, falsification, bribery, violation of B.P. Blg. 22, violation of Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act and prohibited acts and transactions under Section 7 of R.A. No. 6713 (Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees), violation of banking laws, rules and regulations or those sentenced to serve a maximum term of imprisonment of more than six (6) years but whose conviction has not yet become final and executory; (5) Trustees and officers of closed banks QBs/trust entities/NSSLAs and other FIs under BSP supervision/regulation pending their clearance by the Monetary Board; (6) Trustees disqualified for failure to observe/discharge their duties and responsibilities prescribed under existing regulations. This disqualification applies until the lapse of the specific period of disqualification or upon approval by the Monetary Board on recommendation by the appropriate department of the SES of such trustees’ election/re-election; (7) Trustees who failed to attend the special seminar on corporate governance for board of trustees required by BSP. This disqualification applies until the trustee concerned had attended such seminar; (8) Persons dismissed/terminated from employment for cause. This disqualification shall be in effect until they have cleared themselves of involvement in the alleged irregularity or upon clearance, on their request, from the Monetary Board after showing good and justifiable reasons, or after the lapse of five (5) years from the time they were officially advised by the appropriate department of the SES of their disqualification; (9) Those under preventive suspension; (10) Persons with derogatory records as certified by, or on the official files of, the judiciary, NBI, PNP, quasi-judicial bodies, other government agencies, international police, monetary authorities and similar agencies or authorities of foreign countries for irregularities or violations of any law, rules and regulations that would adversely affect the integrity of the trustee/officer or the ability to effectively discharge his duties. This disqualification applies until they have cleared themselves of the alleged irregularities/violations or after a lapse of five (5) years from the time the complaint, which was the basis of the derogatory record, was initiated; (11) Trustees and officers of banks, QBs and trust entities found by the Monetary Board as administratively liable for violation of banking laws, rules and regulations where a penalty of removal from office is imposed, and which finding of the Monetary Board is pending appeal before the appellate court, unless execution or enforcement thereof is restrained by the court; (12) Trustees and officers of banks, QBs and trust entities or any person found by the Monetary Board to be unfit for the position of trustees or officers because they were found administratively liable by another government agency for violation of banking laws, rules and regulations or any offense violation involving dishonesty or breach of trust, and which finding of said government agency is pending appeal before the appellate court, unless execution or enforcement thereof is restrained by the court; and (13) Trustees and officers of banks, QBs Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 11 §§ 4143S.1 - 4143S.3 10.12.31 and trust entities found by the Monetary Board as administratively liable for violation of banking laws, rules and regulations where a penalty of suspension from office or fine is imposed, regardless whether the finding of the Monetary Board is final and executory or pending appeal before the appellate court, unless execution or enforcement thereof is restrained by the court. The disqualification shall be in effect during the period of suspension or so long as the fine is not fully paid. (As amended by Circular Nos. 584 dated 28 September 2007 and 513 dated 10 February 2006) § 4143S.2 Persons disqualified to become officers a. The disqualifications for trustees mentioned in Subsec. 4143S.1 shall likewise apply to officers, except those stated in Items “b(2)” and “b(7)”. b. The spouses or relatives within the second degree of consanguinity or affinity are prohibited from holding officership positions across the following functional categories within an NSSLA: 1. Decision making and senior management function, e.g., chairman, president, chief executive officer (CEO), chief operating officer (COO), general manager, and chief financial officer (CFO) other than the treasurer or controller; 2. Treasury function, e.g., Treasurer and Vice President – Treasury; 3. Recordkeeping and financial reporting functions, e.g., controller and chief accountant; 4. Safekeeping of assets, e.g., chief cashier; 5. Risk management function, e.g., chief risk officer; 6. Compliance function, e.g., compliance officer; and 7. Internal audit function, e.g., internal auditor. S Regulations Part I - Page 12 The spouse or relative within the second degree of consanguinity or affinity of any person holding the position of manager, cashier, or accountant of a branch or extension office of an NSSLA or their respective equivalent positions is disqualified from holding or being appointed to any of said positions in the same branch or extension office. c. Except as may otherwise be allowed under C.A. No. 108, otherwise known as “The Anti-Dummy Law,” as amended, foreigners cannot be officers or employees of NSSLAs; and d. Any appointive or elective public official, whether full time or part time, except in cases where such service is incident to financial assistance provided by the government or GOCCs or in cases allowed under existing law. (As amended by Circular No. 699 dated 17 November 2010) § 4143S.3 Disqualification procedures a. The board of trustees and management of every NSSLAs shall be responsible for determining the existence of the ground for disqualification of the NSSLA’s trustee/officer or employee and for reporting the same to the BSP. While the concerned NSSLA may conduct its own investigation and impose appropriate sanction/s as are allowable, this shall be without prejudice to the authority of the Monetary Board to disqualify a trustee/ officer/employee from being elected appointed as trustee/officer in any FI under the supervision of the BSP. Grounds for disqualification made known to the NSSLA shall be reported to the appropriate department of the SES within seventy-two (72) hours from knowledge thereof. b. On the basis of knowledge and evidence on the existence of any of the grounds for disqualification mentioned in Subsecs. 4143S.1 and 4143S.2, the trustee Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4143S.3 08.12.31 or officer concerned shall be notified in writing either by personal service or through registered mail with registry return receipt card at his/her last known address by the appropriate department of the SES of the existence of the ground for his/her disqualification and shall be allowed to submit within fifteen (15) calendar days from receipt of such notice an explanation on why he/she should not be disqualified and included in the watchlisted file, together with the evidence in support of his/her position. The head of said department may allow an extension on meritorious ground. c. Upon receipt of the reply/ explanation of the trustee/officer concerned, the appropriate department of the SES shall proceed to evaluate the case. The trustee/officer concerned shall be afforded the opportunity to defend/clear himself/herself. d. If no reply has been received from the trustee/officer concerned upon the (Next Page is Part I - Page 13) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 12a § 4143S.3 08.12.31 expiration of the period prescribed under Item “b” above, said failure to reply shall be deemed a waiver and the appropriate department of the SES shall proceed to evaluate the case based on available records/evidence. e. If the ground for disqualification is delinquency in the payment of obligation, the concerned trustee or officer shall be given a period of thirty (30) calendar days within which to settle said obligation or, restore it to its current status or, to explain why he/she should not be disqualified and included in the watchlisted file, before the evaluation on his disqualification and watchlisting is elevated to the Monetary Board. f. For trustees/officers of closed QBs, trust entities, NSSLAs or other FIs under Bangko Sentral supervision, the concerned department of the SES shall make appropriate recommendation to the Monetary Board clearing said trustees/ officers when there is no pending case/ complaint or evidence against them. When there is evidence that a trustees/officer has committed irregularity, the appropriate department of the SES shall make recommendation to the Monetary Board that his/her case be referred to the OSI for further investigation and that he/she be included in the masterlist of temporarily disqualified persons until the final resolution of his/her case. Trustees/officers with pending cases/complaints shall also be included in said masterlist of temporarily disqualified persons upon approval by the Monetary Board until the final resolution of their cases. If the trustee/officer is cleared from involvement in any irregularity, the appropriate department of the SES shall recommend to the Monetary Board his/her delisting. On the other hand, if the trustee officer concerned is found to be responsible for the closure of the institution, the concerned department of the SES shall recommend to the Monetary Board his/her delisting from the masterlist of temporarily disqualified persons and his/her inclusion in the masterlist of permanently disqualified persons. g. If the disqualification is based on dismissal from employment for cause, the appropriate department of the SES shall, as much as practicable, endeavor to establish the specific acts or omissions constituting the offense or the ultimate facts which resulted in the dismissal to be able to determine if the disqualification of the trustee/officer concerned is warranted or not. The evaluation of the case shall be made for the purpose of determining if disqualification would be appropriate and not for the purpose of passing judgment on the findings and decision of the entity concerned. The appropriate department of the SES may decide to recommend to the Monetary Board a penalty lower than disqualification (e.g., reprimand, suspension, etc.) if, in its judgment the act committed or omitted by the trustee/officer concerned does not warrant disqualification. h. All other cases of disqualification, whether permanent or temporary shall be elevated to the Monetary Board for approval and shall be subject to the procedures provided in paragraphs “a”, “b”, “c” and “d” above. i. Upon approval by the Monetary Board, the concerned trustee/officer shall be informed by the appropriate department of the SES in writing either by personal service or through registered mail with registry return receipt card, at his/her last known address of his/her disqualification from being elected/ appointed as trustee/officer in any FI under the supervision of Bangko Sentral and/or of his/ her inclusion in the masterlist of watchlisted persons so disqualified. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 13 §§ 4143S.3 - 4143S.6 12.12.31 j. The board of trustees of the concerned institution shall be immediately informed of cases of disqualification approved by the Monetary Board and shall be directed to act thereon not later than the following board meeting. Within seventy-two (72) hours thereafter, the corporate secretary shall report to the Governor of the Bangko Sentral through the appropriate department of the SES the action taken by the board on the trustee/ officer involved. k. Persons who are elected or appointed as trustee or officer in any of the Bangko Sentral supervised institutions for the first time but are subject to any of the grounds for disqualification provided for under Subsecs. 4143S.1 and 4143S.2, shall be afforded the procedural due process prescribed above. l. Whenever a trustee/officer is cleared in the process mentioned under Item “c” above or, when the ground for disqualification ceases to exist, he/she would be eligible to become trustee or officer of any bank, QB, trust entity or any institution under the supervision of the Bangko Sentral only upon prior approval by the Monetary Board. It shall be the responsibility of the appropriate department of the SES to elevate to the Monetary Board the lifting of the disqualification of the concerned trustee/ officer and his/her delisting from the masterlist of watchlisted persons. (As amended by Circular No. 584 dated 28 September 2007) § 4143S.4 Effect of non-possession of qualifications or possession of disqualifications. Trustees/officers elected or appointed without possessing the qualifications in Subsecs. 4141S.2/4142S.2 or possessing any of the disqualifications as enumerated in Subsecs.4143S.1/4143S.2, shall vacate their respective positions immediately. S Regulations Part I - Page 14 § 4143S.5 (Reserved) § 4143S.6 Watchlisting. To provide the Bangko Sentral with a central information file to be used as reference in passing upon and reviewing the qualifications of persons elected or appointed as trustee or officer of an NSSLA, the SES shall maintain a watchlist of disqualified NSSLA trustees/officers under the following procedures: a. Watchlist categories. Watchlisting shall be categorized as follows: (1) Disqualification File “A” (Permanent) -Trustees/officers/employees permanently disqualified by the Monetary Board from holding a trustee/officer position in any institution under the supervision/ regulation of Bangko Sentral. (2) Disqualification File “B” (Temporary) -Trustees/officers/employees temporarily disqualified by the Monetary Board from holding a trustee/officer position in any institution under the supervision/ regulation of Bangko Sentral. b. Inclusion of trustees/officers/ employees in the watchlist. Upon recommendation by the appropriate department of the SES, the inclusion of trustees/officers/employees in watchlist disqualification files “A” and “B” on the basis of decisions, actions or reports of the courts, banks, QBs, other NSSLAs and FIs under Bangko Sentral supervision, Bangko Sentral, NBI or any other administrative agencies shall first be approved by the Monetary Board. c. Notification of trustees/officers/ employees. Upon approval by the Monetary Board, the concerned trustee/officer/ employee shall be informed through registered mail, with registry return receipt card at his/her last known address of his/ her inclusion in the masterlist of watchlisted Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4143S.6 - 4144S 12.12.31 persons disqualified to be a trustee/officer in any FI under the supervision of the Bangko Sentral. d. Confidentiality. Watchlist files shall be for internal use only of the Bangko Sentral and may not be accessed or queried upon by outside parties including banks, QBs, trust corporations, NSSLAs, and such institutions under the supervisory and regulatory powers of the Bangko Sentral except with the authority of the person concerned (without prejudice to the authority of the Governor and the Monetary Board to authorize release of the information) and with the approval of the concerned SES Department Head or SES Subsector Head or the Deputy Governor, SES or the Governor, or the Monetary Board. The Bangko Sentral will disclose information on the person included in its watchlist files only upon submission of a duly notarized authorization from the concerned person and approval of such request by the concerned SES Department Head or SES Subsector Head or the Deputy Governor, SES or the Governor or the Monetary Board. The prescribed authorization form to be submitted to the appropriate department of the SES is in Appendix Q-45. NSSLAs can gain access to said information in the said watchlist for the sole purpose of screening their nominees/ applicants for trustees/officers and/or confirming their elected trustees and appointed officers. NSSLAs must obtain the said authorization on an individual basis. e. Delisting. All delistings shall be approved by the Monetary Board upon recommendation of the appropriate department of the SES except in cases of persons known to be dead, where delisting shall be automatic upon proof of death and need not be elevated to the Monetary Board. Delisting may be approved by the Monetary Board in the following cases: (1) Watchlist – Disqualification File “B” (Temporary) – (a) After the lapse of the specific period of disqualification; (b) When the conviction by the court for crimes involving dishonesty, breach of trust and/or violation of banking laws becomes final and executory, in which case the trustee/officer/employee is relisted to Watchlist – Disqualification File “A” (Permanent); (c) Upon favorable decision or clearance by the appropriate body, i.e., court, NBI, bank, QB, trust entity or such other agency/body where the concerned individual had derogatory record. Trustees/ officers/employees delisted from the Watchlist – Disqualification File “B” other than those upgraded to Watchlist – Disqualification File “A” shall be eligible for re-employment with any bank, QB, trust entity, NSSLA or other FI under Bangko Sentral supervision. (As amended by Circular No. 758 dated 11 May 2012, CL-2007001 dated 04 January 2007 and CL-2006-046 dated 21 December 2006) Sec. 4144S Compensation of Trustees, Officers and Employees. No trustee, officer or employee of an NSSLA shall receive from such NSSLA and no NSSLA shall pay to any trustee, officer, or employee of such NSSLA, any commission, emolument, gratuity or reward based on the volume or number of loans made, or based on the interest or fees collected thereon. Nothing in this Section, however, prohibits or limits any of the following: a. Receipt or payment of salaries of trustees, officers and employees; b. Receipt or payment of commissions to agents whether or not based on the Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 15 §§ 4144S - 4146S 08.12.31 volume or number of loans or on the interest and fees collected thereon; or c. Receipt or payment of bonuses of trustees, officers or employees if such bonuses are based on the profits and not on the volume or number of loans made or on the interest or fees collected thereon. To protect the funds of depositors and creditors, the Monetary Board may regulate/restrict the payment by the NSSLA of compensation, allowances, fees, bonuses, and fringe benefits to its trustees and officers in exceptional cases and when the circumstances warrant, such as, but not limited to the following: a. When the NSSLA is found by the Monetary Board to be conducting business in an unsafe or unsound manner; b. When the NSSLA is found by the Monetary Board to be in an unsatisfactory financial condition such as, but not limited to, the following cases: (1) Its capital is impaired; and (2) It has suffered continuous losses from operations for the past three (3) years. In the presence of any one (1) or more of the circumstances mentioned above, the Monetary Board may impose the following restrictions in the compensation and other benefits of trustees and officers: (a) Except for the financial assistance to meet expenses for the medical, maternity, education and other emergency needs of the trustees or officers or their immediate family, other forms of financial assistance may be suspended. (b) When the total compensation package including salaries, allowances, fees and bonuses of trustees and officers are significantly excessive as compared with industry averages, the Monetary Board may order their reduction to reasonable levels. § 4144S.1 Compensation increases.All increases in compensation, in any form, of S Regulations Part I - Page 16 all trustees and trustee-officers in excess of ten percent (10%) thereof per annum shall require the approval of the Bangko Sentral. § 4144S.2 Liability for loans contrary to law. No NSSLA shall make or purchase any loan or investment not authorized or permitted under R.A. No. 8367, and any trustee, officer or employee, who on behalf of any such NSSLA, knowingly makes or purchases any such loan or investment or who knowingly consents thereto shall be personally liable to the NSSLA for the full amount of any such loan or investment. Sec. 4145S Bonding of Officers and Employees. All officers and employees of an NSSLA who, in the regular discharge of their duties have access to money or negotiable securities shall, before entering upon such duties, furnish to the employing NSSLA a good and sufficient bond and providing for indemnity to the NSSLA against the loss of money or securities, by reason of their dishonesty. The bond of the cashier, assistant cashier, treasurer, and other employees having money accountability shall not be less than their average daily accountability. The bond must be issued by a reputable bonding company duly licensed by the Insurance Commission and approved by the Bangko Sentral. Capital contribution or a cash bond deposited with the NSSLA or with a bank, may also be allowed. Sec. 4146S Agents and Representatives No person shall act as an agent or sales representative of an NSSLA or operate an agency without obtaining a license from the Monetary Board. No license is required for a collector of an NSSLA but no person shall hold himself out or act as collector unless he is authorized as a Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4146S - 4151S.1 12.12.31 collector in writing by such NSSLA. Sec. 4147S Bio-data of Trustees and Officers a. NSSLAs shall submit to the appropriate department of the SES a biodata with ID picture of their trustees/ officers with rank of senior vice president (SVP) and above (or equivalent ranks) upon every election/re-election/ appointment/promotion in a prescribed form and for first-time trustees/officers with rank of SVP and above (or equivalent ranks) within a particular NSSLA, the duly notarized authorization form per Appendix Q-45, within ten (10) business days from the date of election/re-election of the trustees/meeting of the board of trustees in which the officers are appointed/promoted in accordance with Appendix S-2. The bio-data shall be updated and submitted in case of change of name due to change in civil status, within ten (10) business days from the date the change occurred. For other officers below the rank of SVP, the NSSLA shall not be required to submit their bio-data to the Bangko Sentral. b. The NSSLA shall, however, keep a complete record of the bio-data of all its trustees and officers and shall maintain a system of updating said records which shall be made available during on-site examination or when required by the Bangko Sentral for submission for offsite verification. c. The NSSLA shall also submit to the appropriate department of the SES a duly notarized list of the incumbent members of the board of trustees and officers (President or equivalent rank, down the S Regulations Part I - Page 16a line, format attached as Appendix Q-57b), within ten (10) business days from the election of the board of trustees as provided in the NSSLA’s by-laws, in accordance with Appendix S-2. (As amended by Circular No. 758 dated 11 May 2012) Sec. 4148S Full-Time Manager for NSSLAs NSSLAs with total assets of at least P5.0 million shall maintain a full-time manager to take charge of the operations of the NSSLA. The manager shall possess all the qualifications and shall not have any disqualification under Subsecs. 4142S.2 and 4143S.2, respectively. Secs. 4149S - 4150S (Reserved) H. BRANCHES AND OTHER OFFICES Sec. 4151S Establishment of Branches/ Extension Offices. Prior Bangko Sentral authority shall be obtained before operating a branch or other offices. § 4151S.1 Application.The application shall be prescribed by the appropriate department of the SES and accompanied by the following minimum requirements: a. Sketch of the location of the proposed office which shall be within the compound of the mother firm’s branch office; b. Itemized statement of estimated receipts and expenses of the NSSLA in connection with such branch or extension office; c. Description or enumeration of service facilities that will cater to the deposit and credit needs of members of the NSSLA; d. Financial statements for the year immediately preceding the date of application; Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4151S.1 - 4161S.2 08.12.31 e. Certification as to the actual number of members that will be serviced by the branch/extension office; and f. Undertaking that the branch/ extension office will service only members of the NSSLA. § 4151S.2 Conditions precluding acceptance/processing of application. The application shall not be accepted/processed in any of the following cases: a. The NSSLA’s operation during the year immediately preceding the date of filing of application was unprofitable; b. Total capital accounts of the NSSLA are less than P100 million as of the date of filing of the application; c. Total number of members to be served in the proposed branch/extension office is less than 500; or d. Non-compliance by the NSSLA with any of the pertinent provisions of banking laws, rules, regulations and policies of the BSP. § 4151S.3 Internal control system. The NSSLA shall submit to the appropriate department of the SES a system of internal safeguards and control measures to be adopted for compliance by the staff of the proposed branch/extension office. § 4151S.4 Permit to operate. Actual operation shall commence only after a permit to operate has been issued by the BSP. Secs. 4152S - 4155S (Reserved) except when extraordinary instances caused by unforeseen, unavoidable event directly affect the NSSLA’s ability to open for business. NSSLAs shall post conspicuously at all times in their place of business their schedule of regular business hours and days. Secs. 4157S - 4160S (Reserved) J. REPORTS Sec. 4161S Records. NSSLAs shall have a true and accurate account, record or statement of their daily transactions. The making of any false entry or the willful omission of entries relevant to any transaction is a ground for the Monetary Board for the imposition of administrative sanctions under Section 37 of R.A. No. 7653, without prejudice to the criminal liability of the director or officer responsible therefore under Sections 35 and 36 of R.A. No. 7653 and/or the applicable provisions of the Revised Penal Code. Records shall be up to-date and shall contain sufficient detail so that an audit trail is established. § 4161S.1 Uniform System of Accounts. NSSLAs are required to pattern their charts of accounts and recording systems after the Uniform System of Accounts prescribed for NSSLAs including reportorial and publication requirements. The voucher system of accounting or the ticket system, or such other accounting system acceptable to the BSP as well as the prescribed chart of accounts shall be adopted for use by NSSLAs. I. BUSINESS DAYS AND HOURS Sec. 4156S Business Days and Hours NSSLAs may, with the prior approval of the appropriate department of the SES, adopt such business days and hours as may be convenient for them. NSSLAs shall be open for business during business hours and days § 4161S.2 Philippine Financial Reporting Standards/Philippine Accounting Standards Statement of policy. It is the policy of the Bangko Sentral to promote fairness, transparency and accuracy in financial reporting. It is in this light that the BSP aims Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 17 §§ 4161S.2 - 4162S.1 08.12.31 to adopt all PFRS and PAS issued by the ASC to the greatest extent possible. NSSLAs shall adopt the PFRS and PAS which are in accordance with GAAP in recording transactions and in the preparation of financial statements and reports to BSP. However, in cases where there are differences between BSP regulations and PFRS/PAS as when more than one (1) option are allowed or certain maximum or minimum limits are prescribed by the PFRS/PAS, the option or limit prescribed by BSP regulations shall be adopted by all NSSLA/FIs. For purposes hereof, the PFRS/PAS shall refer to issuances of the ASC and approved by the PRC. Accounting treatment for prudential reporting. For prudential reporting, FIs shall adopt in all respect the PFRS and PAS except as follows: a. In preparing consolidated financial statements, only investments in financial allied subsidiaries except insurance subsidiaries shall be consolidated on a lineby-line basis; while insurance and nonfinancial allied subsidiaries shall be accounted for using the equity method. Financial/non-financial allied/non-allied associates shall be accounted for using the equity method in accordance with the provisions of PAS 28 “Investments in Associates”; b. For purposes of preparing separate financial statements, financial/non-financial allied/non-allied subsidiaries/associates, including insurance subsidiaries/associates, shall also be accounted for using the equity method; and c. FIs shall be required to meet the BSP recommended valuation reserves. Government grants extended in the form of loans bearing nil or low interest rates shall be measured upon initial recognition at its fair value (i.e., the present value of the future cash flows of the financial instrument discounted using the market interest rate). S Regulations Part I - Page 18 The difference between the fair value and the net proceeds of the loan shall be recorded under “Unearned IncomeOthers”, which shall be amortized over the term of the loan using the effective interest method. The provisions on government grants shall be applied retroactively to all outstanding government grants received. NSSLAs that adopted an accounting treatment other than the foregoing shall consider the adjustment as a change in accounting policy, which shall be accounted for in accordance with PAS 8. Notwithstanding the exceptions in Items “a”, “b” and “c”, the audited annual financial statements required to be submitted to the BSP in accordance with Appendix S-2 shall in all respect be PFRS/ PAS compliant: Provided, That FIs shall submit to the BSP adjusting entries reconciling the balances in the financial statements for prudential reporting with that in the audited annual financial statements. (As amended by Circular No. 572 dated 22 June 2007) Sec. 4162S Reports. NSSLAs shall submit to the appropriate department of the SES the reports in prescribed form listed in Appendix S-2. § 4162S.1 Categories and signatories of reports. For purposes of designating the signatories of reports, certain weekly, monthly, quarterly, semi-annual, and annual statements/reports required to be submitted to the BSP are hereby grouped into Category A-1, A-2, A-3 and Category B, as enumerated in Appendix S-3. Category A-1 reports shall be signed by the NSSLA’s chief executive officer (who may be the president or chairman of the board, or designated in the by-laws), or in his absence, by the executive vice president or the officer duly authorized under a resolution approved by the board of Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4162S.1 - 4162S.3 08.12.31 trustees and by the chief finance officer (i.e., controller or chief accountant, who shall likewise be duly authorized by the NSSLA’s board of trustees in a format prescribed in Appendix S-3a. Category A-2 reports of the head office of the NSSLA shall be signed by the NSSLA’s president or senior vicepresident/equivalent position. Offices/units (such as branch) reports in this category shall be signed by their respective managers/officers-in-charge. Likewise, the signing authority in this category shall be contained in a resolution approved by the board of trustees in the format prescribed in Appendix S-3b. Category A-3 and B reports are those required to be submitted to the BSP and are not included in Categories A-1 and A-2. They shall be signed by officers or their alternates, who shall be duly designated by the board of trustees. A copy of the board resolution with format as prescribed in Appendix S-3c, covering the initial designation and subsequent changes in signatories and alternates, shall be submitted to the appropriate department of the SES within three (3) days from the date of resolution. If a report is submitted to the BSP under the signature of an officer who is not listed or included in any of the resolutions mentioned above, the appropriate department of the SES shall refuse to acknowledge the report as valid or consider the report as not having been submitted at all. If such a report is not resubmitted by the NSSLA under the signature of a duly authorized signing officer, administrative sanctions/penalties shall be imposed on the erring NSSLA for the late reporting or failure to submit the required report, as the case may be. § 4162S.2 Manner of filing. The submission of the reports shall be effected by filing them personally with the appropriate department of the SES or with the BSP Regional Offices or by sending them registered mail or special delivery, unless otherwise specified in the circular or memorandum of the Monetary Board or the BSP. § 4162S.3 Sanctions and procedures for filing and payment of fines. Failure to submit the above reports on or before the specified dates shall subject the person responsible or entity concerned to the penalties provided by law. For willful delay in the submission of reports, the following rules shall apply: a. Definition of Terms. The following definitions shall apply: (1) Report shall refer to all written reports/statements required of an NSSLA to be submitted to the BSP periodically or within a specified period. (2) Willful delay in the submission of reports shall refer to the failure of any NSSLA to submit on time the report defined in Item “(1)” above. Failure to submit a report on time due to fortuitous events, such as fire and other natural calamities and public disorders, shall not be considered as willful delay. (3) Examination shall include, but need not be limited to, the verification, review, audit, investigation and inspection of the books and records, business affairs, administration and financial condition of any NSSLA including the reproduction of the records as well as the taking possession of the books and records and keeping them under BSP custody after giving proper receipts therefore. It shall also include the interview of the directors and personnel of any NSSLA. (4) Refusal to permit examination shall mean any act or omission which impedes, delays or obstructs the duly authorized BSP officer/examiner/employee from conducting an examination, including the act of refusing to honor a letter of authority to examine presented by any officer/examiner/ employee of the BSP. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 19 § 4162S.3 08.12.31 b. Fines for willful delay in submission of reports. NSSLAs incurring willful delay in the submission of required reports shall pay a fine in accordance with the following schedule: (1) For Categories A-1, A-2 and A-3 reports Per day of default until the report is filed P180 (2) For Category B reports Per day of default until the report is filed 60 Delay or default shall start to run on the day following the last day required for the submission of reports. However, should the last day of filing fall on a non-working day in the locality where the reporting NSSLA is situated, delay or default shall start to run on the day following the next working day. The due date/deadline for submission of reports to BSP as prescribed under Sec. 4162S governing the frequency and deadlines indicated in Appendix S-2 shall be automatically moved to the next business day whenever a half-day suspension of business operations in government offices is declared due to an emergency such as typhoon, floods, etc. For the purpose of establishing delay or default, the date of acknowledgment by the appropriate department of the SES or the BSP Regional Offices/Units appearing on the copies of such reports filed or submitted or the date of mailing postmarked on the envelope/the date of registry or special delivery receipt, as the case may be, shall be considered as the date of filing. Delayed schedules/attachments and amendments shall be considered late reporting subject to above penalties. c. Sanctions for willful refusal to permit examination/making of false statement (1) Any NSSLA which shall willfully refuse to permit examination shall pay a fine of P3,000 daily from the day of refusal and for as long as such refusal lasts. S Regulations Part I - Page 20 The provisions of Section 34 of R. A. No. 7653 shall apply to any agent, manager, or other officer-in-charge of any NSSLA who willfully refuses any lawful examination into the affairs of such NSSLA. The willful making of a false statement or misleading statement on a material fact to department of the BSP charged with the regulation of NSSLAs or to his examiner shall be punished in accordance with Section 36 of R. A. No. 7653. (2) Procedures in imposing the fine (a) The BSP officer/examiner/employee shall report the refusal of the NSSLA to permit examination to the head of the appropriate department of BSP, who shall forthwith make a written demand upon the NSSLA concerned for such examination. If the NSSLA continues to refuse said examination without any satisfactory explanation therefor, the BSP officer/ examiner/employee concerned shall submit a report to that effect to the appropriate department head. (b) The fine shall be imposed starting on the day following the receipt by the appropriate department of the written report submitted by the BSP officer/ examiner/employee concerned regarding the continued refusal of the NSSLA to permit the desired examination. d. Manner of payment or collection of fines. The regulations embodied in Sec. 4601S shall be observed in the collection of the fines from NSSLAs. e. Appeal to the Monetary Board. NSSLAs may appeal to the Monetary Board a ruling of the appropriate department imposing a fine. f. Other penalties. The foregoing penalties shall not preclude the application of, or shall be without prejudice to, other administrative sanctions as well as to the filing of criminal case as provided for in the other provisions of the law, as may be warranted by the nature of the offense. (As amended by Circular No. 585 dated 15 October 2007) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4163S - 4164S.3 08.12.31 Sec. 4163S (Reserved) Sec. 4164S Internal Audit Function Internal audit is an independent, objective assurance and consulting function established to examine, evaluate and improve the effectiveness of risk management, internal control, and governance processes of an organization. § 4164S.1 Status. The internal audit function must be independent of the activities audited and from day-to-day internal control process. It must be free to report audit results, findings, opinions, appraisals and other information to the appropriate level of management. It shall have authority to directly access and communicate with any officer or employee, to examine any activity or entity of the institution, as well as to access any records, files or data whenever relevant to the exercise of its assignment. The Audit Committee or senior management should take all necessary measures to provide the appropriate resources and staffing that would enable internal audit to achieve its objectives. § 4164S.2 Scope. The scope of internal audit shall include: a. Examination and evaluation of the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control systems; b. Review of the application and effectiveness of risk management procedures and risk assessment methodologies; c Review of the management and financial information systems, including the electronic information system and electronic banking services; d. Assessment of the accuracy and reliability of the accounting system and of the resulting financial reports; e. Review of the systems and procedures of safeguarding assets; f. Review of the system of assessing capital in relation to the estimate of organizational risk; g. Transaction testing and assessment of specific internal control procedures; and h. Review of the compliance system and the implementation of established policies and procedures. § 4164S.3 Qualification standards of the internal auditor. The internal auditor of a UB or a KB must be a CPA and must have at least five (5) years experience in the regular audit (internal or external) of a UB or KB as auditor-in-charge, senior auditor or audit manager. He must possess the knowledge, skills, and other competencies to examine all areas in which the institution operates. Professional competence as well as continuing training and education shall be required to face-up to the increasing complexity and diversity of the institution’s operations. The internal auditor of a TB, QB, trust entity or national Coop Bank must be a CPA with at least five (5) years experience in the regular audit (internal or external) of a TB, QB, trust entity or national Coop Bank as auditor-in-charge, senior auditor or audit manager or, in lieu thereof, at least three (3) years experience in the regular audit (internal or external) of a UB or KB as auditor-in charge, senior auditor or audit manager. The internal auditor of an RB, NSSLA or local Coop Bank must be at least an Accounting graduate with two (2) years experience in external audit or in the regular audit of an RB, NSSLA or local Coop Bank or, in lieu thereof, at least one (1) year experience in the regular audit (internal or external) of a UB, KB, TB, QB, trust entity or national Coop Bank as auditor-in-charge, senior auditor or audit manager. A qualified internal auditor of a UB or a KB shall be qualified to audit TBs, QBs, trust entities, national cooperative banks, RBs, NSSLAs, local cooperative banks, Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 21 §§ 4164S.3 - 4172S 08.12.31 subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities, and other FIs under BSP supervision. A qualified internal auditor of a TB or national cooperative bank shall likewise be qualified to audit QBs, trust entities, RBs, NSSLAs, local cooperative banks, subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities, and other financial institutions under BSP supervision. § 4164S.4 Code of Ethics and Internal Auditing Standards. The internal auditor should conform with the Code of Professional Ethics for CPAs and ensure compliance with sound internal auditing standards, such as the Institute of Internal Auditors’ International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (e-mail: standards@theiia.org; Web: http:// www.theiia.org.) and other supplemental standards issued by regulatory authorities/ government agencies. The Standards address independence and objectivity, professional proficiency, scope of work, performance of audit work, management of internal audit, quality assurance reviews, communication and monitoring of results. Secs. 4165S - 4170S (Reserved) K. INTERNAL CONTROL Sec. 4171S External Auditor. NSSLAs except those with total resources of P10.0 million or less, shall engage the services of an independent Certified Public Accountant to audit their books of accounts at least once a year, or as often as necessary. Sec. 4172S Financial Audit. NSSLAs shall cause an annual financial audit by an external auditor acceptable to the BSP not later than thirty (30) calendar days after the close of the calendar year or the fiscal year adopted by the NSSLA. Report of such audit shall be submitted to the board of directors S Regulations Part I - Page 22 and the appropriate department of the SES not later than 120 calendar days after the close of the calendar year or the fiscal year adopted by the NSSLA. The report to the BSP shall be accompanied by the: (1) certification by the external auditor on the: (a) dates of start and termination of audit; (b) date of submission of the financial audit report and certification under oath stating that no material weakness or breach in the internal control and risk management systems was noted in the course of the audit of the NSSLA to the board of directors; and (c) the absence of any direct or indirect financial interest and other circumstances that may impair the independence of the external auditor; (2) reconciliation statement between the AFS and the balance sheet and income statement for NSSLA submitted to the BSP including copies of adjusting entries on the reconciling items; and (3) other information that may be required by the BSP. In addition, the external auditor shall be required by the NSSLA to submit to the board of directors, a LOC indicating any material weakness or breach in the institution’s internal control and risk management systems within thirty (30) calendar days after submission of the financial audit report. If no material weakness or breach is noted to warrant the issuance of an LOC, a Certification under oath stating that no material weakness or breach in the internal control and risk management systems was noted in the course of the audit of the NSSLA shall be submitted in its stead, together with the financial audit report. Material weakness shall be defined as a significant control deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, that results in more than a remote likelihood that a material misstatement of the financial statements will not be detected or prevented by the entity’s internal control. A material weakness does not mean that a material misstatement has Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4172S 08.12.31 occurred or will occur, but that it could occur. A control deficiency exists when the design or operation of a control does not allow management or employees, in the normal course of performing their assigned functions, to prevent or detect misstatements on a timely basis. A significant deficiency is a control deficiency, or combination of control deficiencies, that adversely affects the entity’s ability to initiate, authorize, record, process, or report financial data reliably in accordance with GAAP. The term more than remote likelihood shall mean that future events are likely to occur or are reasonably possible to occur. The board of directors, in a regular or special meeting, shall consider and act on the financial audit report and the certification under oath submitted in lieu of the LOC and shall submit, within thirty (30) banking days after receipt of the reports, a copy of its resolution to the appropriate department of the SES. The resolution shall show, among other things, the actions(s) taken on the reports and the names of the directors present and absent. The board shall likewise consider and act on the LOC and shall submit, within thirty (30) banking days after receipt thereof, a copy of its resolution together with said LOC to the appropriate department of the SES. The resolution shall show the action(s) taken on the findings and recommendations and, the names of the directors present and absent, among other things. The LOC shall be accompanied by the certification of the external auditor of the date of its submission to the board of directors. NSSLAs under Bangko Sentral supervision which are under the concurrent jurisdiction of the COA shall be exempt from the aforementioned annual financial audit by an acceptable external auditor: Provided, That when warranted by supervisory concern such as material weakness/breach in internal control and/or risk management systems, the Monetary Board may, upon recommendation of the appropriate department of the SES, require the financial audit to be conducted by an external auditor acceptable to the Bangko Sentral, at the expense of the institution concerned: Provided further, That when circumstances such as, but not limited to, loans from multilateral financial institutions, privatization, or public listing warrant, the financial audit of the concerned institution by an acceptable external auditor may also be allowed. NSSLAs under the concurrent jurisdiction of the Bangko Sentral and COA shall, however, submit a copy of the AAR of the COA to the appropriate department of the SES within thirty (30) banking days after receipt of the report by the board of directors. The AAR shall be accompanied by the: (1) certification by the institution concerned on the date of receipt of the AAR by the board of directors; (2) reconciliation statement between the AFS in the AAR and the balance sheet and income statement of the NSSLA submitted to the Bangko Sentral, including copies of adjusting entries on the reconciling items; and (3) other information that may be required by the Bangko Sentral. The board of directors of said institutions, in a regular or special meeting, shall consider and act on the AAR, as well as on the comments and observations and shall submit, within thirty (30) banking days after receipt of the report, a copy of its resolution to the appropriate department of the SES. The resolution shall show the action(s) taken on the report, including the comments and Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 23 §§ 4172S - 4174S 12.12.31 observations and the names of the directors present and absent, among other things. NSSLAs as well as external auditors shall strictly observe the requirements in the submission of the financial audit report and reports required to be submitted under Appendix Q-33. The audited annual financial statements required to be submitted shall in all respect be PFRS/PAS compliant: Provided, That NSSLAs shall submit to the Bangko Sentral adjusting entries reconciling the balances in the financial statements for prudential reporting with that in the audited annual financial statements. The reports and certifications of institutions concerned, schedules and attachments required under this Subsection shall be considered Category B reports, delayed submission of which shall be subject to the penalties under Subsec. 4162S.3 (As amended by Circular Nos. 554 dated 22 December 2006 and 540 dated 09 August 2006) § 4172S.1 Audited Financial Statements of NSSLAs. The following rules shall govern the utilization and submission of AFS of NSSLAs. For purposes of this Section, AFS shall include the balance sheets, income statements, statements of changes in equity, statements of cash flows and notes to financial statements which shall include among other information, disclosure of the volume of past due loans as well as loanloss provisions. On the other hand, financial audit report shall refer to the AFS and the opinion of the auditor. The AFS of NSSLAs with subsidiaries shall be presented side by side on a solo basis (parent) and on a consolidated basis (parent and subsidiaries). (Circular No. 540 dated 09 August 2006) S Regulations Part I - Page 24 § 4172S.2 Posting of audited financial statements. NSSLAs shall post in conspicuous places in their head offices, all their branches and other offices, as well as in their respective websites, their latest financial audit report. (Circular No. 540 dated 09 August 2006) Sec. 4173S (Reserved) Sec. 4174S Risk Management Function. The risk management function is generally responsible for: (a) identifying the key risk exposures and assessing and measuring the extent of risk exposures of the NSSLA and its trust operations; (b) monitoring the risk exposures and determining the corresponding capital requirement in accordance with the Basel capital adequacy framework and based on the NSSLA’s internal capital adequacy assessment on an on-going basis; (c) monitoring and assessing decisions to accept particular risks whether these are consistent with board approved policies on risk tolerance and the effectiveness of the corresponding risk mitigation measures; and (d) reporting on a regular basis to senior management and to the board of directors of the results of assessment and monitoring. Risk management personnel shall possess sufficient experience and qualifications, including knowledge on the NSSLA business, the developments in the market, industry and product lines, as well as mastery of risk disciplines. They shall have the ability and willingness to challenge business lines regarding all aspects of risk arising from the NSSLA’s activities. Chief Risk Officer (CRO). NSSLA may appoint a CRO, or any equivalent position, who shall be independent from executive functions and business line responsibilities, operations and revenue-generating Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4174S - 4180S 12.12.31 functions. This independence shall be displayed in practice at all times as such, the CRO shall report directly to the board of trustees or to the risk oversight committee without any impediment. The CRO shall have sufficient stature, authority and seniority within the NSSLA. This will be assessed based on the ability of the CRO to influence decisions that affect the NSSLA’s exposure to risk. The CRO shall have the ability, without compromising his independence, to engage in discussion with the board of trustees, chief executive officer and other senior management on key risk issues and to access such information as he deems necessary to form his or her judgment. The CRO shall meet with the board of directors/risk oversight committee on a regular basis and such meetings shall be duly minuted and adequately documented. CROs shall be appointed and replaced with prior approval of the board of trustees. In cases, when the CRO will be replaced, the NSSLA shall report the same to the appropriate department of the SES within five (5) days from the time it has been approved by the board of trustees. (Circular Nos.757 dated 08 May 2012 and 749 dated 27 February 2012) Secs. 4175S - 4179S (Reserved) Sec. 4180S Selection, Appointment, Reporting Requirements and Delisting of External Auditors and/or Auditing Firm; Sanction. Pursuant to Section 58, R.A. No. 8791, and the existing provisions of the executed Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) dated 12 August 2009, binding the Bangko Sentral, SEC, PRC - BOA and the IC for a simplified and synchronized accreditation requirements for external auditor and/or auditing firm, following are the revised rules and regulations that shall govern the selection and delisting by the Bangko Sentral of covered institutions which under special laws are subject to Bangko Sentral supervision. Statement of policy. It is the policy of the Bangko Sentral to ensure effective audit and supervision of banks, QBs, trust entities and/or NSSLAs including their subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities and other FIs which under special laws are subject to Bangko Sentral supervision, and to ensure the reliance by Bangko Sentral and the public on the opinion of external auditors and auditing firms by prescribing the rules and regulations that shall govern the selection, appointment, reporting requirements and delisting for external auditors and auditing firms of said institutions, subject to the binding provisions of and implementing regulations pursuant to the aforesaid MOA. a. Rules and regulations. The revised rules and regulations that shall govern the selection and delisting by the Bangko Sentral of covered institutions which under special laws are subject to Bangko Sentral supervision are shown in Appendix S-8. Sanctions. The applicable sanctions/ penalties prescribed under Sections 36 and 37 of R.A. 7653 to the extent applicable shall be imposed on the covered institutions, its audit committee and the directors approving the hiring of external auditor/ auditing firm who/which are not in the Bangko Sentral list of selected auditors for covered institutions or for hiring, and/or retaining the services of the external auditor/ auditing firm in violation of any of the provisions of this Section and for noncompliance with the Monetary Board directive under Item “K” in Appendix S-8. Erring external auditors/auditing firm may also be reported by the Bangko Sentral to the PRC for appropriate disciplinary action. (As amended by Circular Nos. 660 dated 25 August 2009 and 529 dated 11 May 2006) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 25 §§ 4181S - 4191S 12.12.31 L. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS Sec. 4181S Publication Requirements NSSLAs shall, within 120 calendar days after the close of the calendar year or their fiscal year, as the case may be, furnish the Monetary Board and post in any of the NSSLAs’ bulletin boards or in any other conspicuous place a copy of their financial statements showing, in such form and detail as the Monetary Board shall require, the amount and character of the assets and liabilities of the NSSLAs at the end of the preceding fiscal year. The Monetary Board may, in addition to the foregoing, require the disclosure of such other information as it shall deem necessary for the protection of the members of the NSSLA. The consolidated statements of condition of an NSSLA and its subsidiaries and associates shall conform with the guidelines of PAS 27 “Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements”, except that for purposes of consolidated financial statements, only investments in financial allied subsidiaries except insurance subsidiaries shall be consolidated on a line-by-line basis; while insurance and non-financial allied subsidiaries shall be accounted for using the equity method. Financial/non-financial allied/non-allied associates shall be accounted for using the equity method in accordance with the provisions of PAS 28 “Investments in Associates”. For purposes of separate financial statements, investments in financial/non-financial allied/non-allied subsidiaries/associates, including insurance subsidiaries/associates, shall be accounted for using the equity method. (As amended by Circular No. 494 dated 20 September 2005) Sec. 4182S Business Name 1. NSSLAs organized or operating under R.A. No. 8367 and licensed by the Bangko Sentral shall include in their names the words “Savings 1 and Loan Association”. Such NSSLAs shall display in a conspicuous place at their business offices a sign including, among other things, the following words: “Authorized by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas”. (As amended by CL Nos. 2008-053 dated 21 August 2008 and 2008-007 dated 05 February 2008) Sec. 4183S Prohibitions a. No person, association, partnership or corporation shall do business as an NSSLA, or shall use the terms “Savings and Loan Association” or any other title or name tending to give the public impression that it is engaged in the operations and activities of an NSSLA unless so authorized under R.A. No. 8367 and these regulations. b. The use by an NSSLA of any other name or title or combination of names and titles or any other deviation from the requirements of this Section shall not be authorized except upon prior approval of the Monetary Board. c. NSSLAs shall not issue, publish or cause or permit to be issued or published, any advertisement that it is doing or permitted to do business which is prohibited by law to an NSSLA. d. No NSSLA shall advertise or represent itself to its members or to the public as a bank, or as a trust company. Secs. 4184S - 4189S (Reserved) Sec. 4190S Guidelines on Outsourcing The rules on outsourcing of banking functions as shown in Appendix Q-37 shall be adopted insofar as they are applicable to NSSLAs. (As amended by Circular Nos. 764 dated 03 August 2012, 642 dated 30 January 2009, 610 dated 26 May 2008, 596 dated 11 January 2008, 548 dated 25 September 2006 and 543 dated 08 September 2006) Sec. 4191S (Reserved) See SEC Circular Nos. 5 dated 17 July 2008 and 14 dated 24 October 2000 S Regulations Part I - Page 26 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4192S - 4196S 13.12.31 Sec. 4192S Prompt Corrective Action Framework. The framework for the enforcement of PCA on banks which is in Appendix Q-40 shall govern the PCA taken on NSSLAs to the extent applicable, or by analogy. managing market risk are continuously evolving. As such, the guidelines are intended for general application; specific application will depend to some extent on the size, complexity and range of activities undertaken by NSSLAs. (Circular No. 523 dated 31 March 2006, as amended by Circular No. 664 dated 15 September 2009) (Circular No. 544 dated 15 September 2006) Sec. 4193S Supervision by Risks. The guidelines on supervision by risk in Appendix Q-42 which provide guidance on how QBs should identify, measure, monitor and control risks shall govern the supervision by risks of NSSLAs to the extent applicable. The guidelines set forth the expectation of the Bangko Sentral with respect to the management of risks and are intended to provide more consistency in how the riskfocused supervision function is applied to these risks. The Bangko Sentral will review the risks to ensure that an NSSLA’s internal risk management processes are integrated and comprehensive. All NSSLAs should follow the guidance in risk management efforts. (Circular No. 510 dated 03 February 2006) Sec. 4194S Market Risk Management The guidelines on market risk management for QBs as shown in Appendix Q-43 shall govern the market risk management of NSSLAs to the extent applicable. The guidelines set forth the expectations of the Bangko Sentral with respect to the management of market risk and are intended to provide more consistency in how the riskfocused supervision is applied to this risk. NSSLAs are expected to have an integrated approach to risk management to identify, measure, monitor and control risks. Market risk should be reviewed together with other risks to determine overall risk profile. The Bangko Sentral is aware of the increasing diversity of financial products and that industry techniques for measuring and Sec. 4195S Liquidity Risk Management The guidelines on liquidity risk management for QBs as shown in Appendix Q-44 shall govern the liquidity risk management of NSSLAs to the extent applicable. The guidelines set forth the expectations of the Bangko Sentral with respect to the management of liquidity risk and are intended to provide more consistency in how the risk-focused supervision function is applied to this risk. NSSLAs are expected to have an integrated approach to risk management to identify, measure, monitor and control risks. Liquidity risk should be reviewed together with other risks to determine overall risk profile. These guidelines are intended for general application; specific application will depend on the size and sophistication of a particular NSSLA and the nature and complexity of its activities. (Circular No. 545 dated 15 September 2006) Sec. 4196S Information Technology Risk Management (ITRM). The enhanced guidelines on ITRM keep abreast with the aggressive and widespread adoption of technology in the financial service industry and consequently strengthen existing Bangko Sentral framework for IT risk supervision. ITRM should be considered a component and integrated with the institutions’ risk management program. The guidelines likewise provide practical plans to address risks associated with emerging trends in technology and growing concerns on cyber security. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 27 §§ 4196S.1 - 4196S.3 13.12.31 § 4196S.1 Declaration of policy. A growing number of Bangko Sentral supervised institutions (BSIs) employ the advances in technology as leverage to offer innovative products, deliver fast and efficient service at affordable prices, and venture to new markets. Moreover, technology drives the efficiency of operations and financial accounting of these institutions, and improves their decision-making process. As technology becomes an integral part of the business and operations of BSIs, such technology usage and dependence, if not properly managed, may heighten technology risks. The Bangko Sentral expects BSIs to have the knowledge and skills necessary to understand and effectively manage technology risks. These institutions are required to have an integrated approach to risk management to identify, measure, monitor and control risks. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.2 Purpose and scope. The enhanced guidelines aim to provide guidance in managing risks associated with use of technology. The guidelines outlined are based on international standards and recognized principles of international practice for ITRM and shall serve as Bangko Sentral’s baseline requirement for all BSIs. The guidelines shall apply to BSIs which include banks, non-banks with quasibanking function (NBQB), non-bank electronic money issuers and other non-bank institutions which under existing Bangko Sentral rules and regulations and special laws are subject to Bangko Sentral supervision and/or regulation. Moreover, subject guidelines shall also apply to BSIs with offshore data processing as may be appropriate to their situation. The framework covers different facets of ITRM, some of which are supplemented with detailed guidelines in Appendices Q-59a, Q-59b, Q-59c, Q-59d, Q-59e and Q-59f. The Bangko Sentral shall keep the Appendices updated and, in the future, issue S Regulations Part I - Page 28 additional regulations on new and emerging products, services, delivery channels, and other significant applications of technology. Subject guidelines, including the Appendices Q-59a, Q-59b, Q-59c, Q-59d, Q-59e and Q-59f, are not “one-size-fits-all” and implementation of these need to be riskbased and commensurate with size, nature and types of products and services and complexity of IT operations of the individual BSIs. BSIs shall exercise sound judgment in determining applicable provisions relevant to their risk profile. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.3 Complexity of IT risk profile The Bangko Sentral shall risk profile all BSIs and classify them as either “Complex” or “Simple”. The assessment of complexity of IT risk profile is based largely on the degree of adoption of technology and considers size, nature and types of products and services and complexity of IT operations among the risk factors. In assessing IT operations, the nature of IT organization, degree of automation of core processes and applications and extent and reach of online branch network are likewise considered. A BSI with “Complex” IT risk profile is highly dependent on technology. IT components are integral to the core business activities that major weaknesses on IT systems, maintenance and support, if not properly addressed, may cause operational inefficiencies, business disruptions and/or financial losses. On the other hand, a BSI with “Simple” IT risk profile relies or depends less on technology in the operations of its business, thus, is not affected or lowly impacted by IT-related risks. Non-bank institutions which under existing Bangko Sentral rules and regulations and special laws are subject to Bangko Sentral supervision/regulation shall be notified in writing of their classification immediately after 14 September 2013. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions §§ 4196S.4 - 4196S.5 13.12.31 § 4196S.4 IT rating system.The Bangko Sentral, in the course of its on-site examination activities, shall evaluate BSIs’ ITRM system and measure the results based on Bangko Sentral’s IT rating system. A composite rating is assigned based on a “1” to “4” numerical scale, as follows: 4 3 BSIs with this rating exhibit strong performance in every respect. Noted weaknesses in IT are minor in nature and can be easily corrected during the normal course of business. BSIs with this rating exhibit satisfactory performance but may demonstrate modest weaknesses in operating performance, monitoring, management processes or system development. 2 BSIs with this rating exhibit less than satisfactory performance and require considerable degree of supervision due to a combination of weaknesses that may range from moderate to severe. 1 BSIs with this rating exhibit deficient IT environment that may impair the future viability of the entity, thereby requiring immediate remedial action. Terminology Cyberfraud (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.5 Definition of terms. In these guidelines, terms are used with the following meanings: Terminology Definitions Board of The governing body Directors elected by the (Board) stockholders that exercises the corporate powers of a locally incorporated BSI. In case of a BSI Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions Definitions incorporated or established outside the Philippines, this may refer to the functional oversight equivalent such as the Country Head (for foreign banks) or management committee or body empowered with oversight and supervision responsibilities. A deliberate act of omission or commission by any person carried out using the Internet and/ or other electronic channels, in order to communicate false or fraudulent representations to prospective victims, to conduct fraudulent transactions, or to transmit the proceeds of fraud to FIs connected with the perpetrator. Examples of cyberfraud in the financial industry may include, but are not limited to, theft of credit card data, computer hacking, electronic identity theft, phishing scams, ATM skimming and non-delivery of merchandise purhased online, among others. S Regulations Part I - Page 29 § 4196S.5 13.12.31 Terminology Electronic Products and Services EMV (stands for Europay, Mastercard and Visa) S Regulations Part I - Page 30 Definitions The delivery of banking and financial products and services through electronic, interactive communication channels which include automated teller machines (ATMs), point of sales (POS) terminals, internet, mobile phones, touch tone telephones and other similar electronic devices. These encompass electronic banking, electronic payments, electronic money and other electronic products and services offered by BSIs. It is a global standard for credit, debit and prepaid payment cards based on chip card technology. EMV chipbased payment cards, also known as smart cards, contain an embedded microprocessor, a type of small computer. The microprocessor chip contains the information needed to use the card for payment, and is protected by various security features. Chip cards are a more secure alternative to traditional magnetic stripe payment cards. Terminology Encryption Enterprisewide Level Information Asset/ Resources Information Security Definitions A data security technique used to protect information from unauthorized inspection or alteration. Information is encoded so that data appears as meaningless string of letters and symbols during delivery or transmission. Upon receipt, the information is decoded using an encryption key. Extending throughout or involving an entire institution rather than a single business department or function. In this document, the words "enterprise-wide" and "organization-wide" are interchangeably used. Encompass people and organization, IT processes, physical infrastructure (i.e. facilities, equipment), IT infrastructure (including computing hardware, network infrastructure, middleware) and other enterprise architecture components (including information, applications). The protection of information assets from unauthorized access, use, disclosure, disruption, modification or destruction in order to provide confidentiality, integrity and availability. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions § 4196S.5 13.12.31 Terminology Information Security Incident Definitions A single or a series of unwanted or unexpected information security events that have a significant probability of compromising business operations and threatening the confidentiality, integrity or availability of BSI's information or information systems. Information Automated means of Technology originating, processing, (IT) storing and communicating information and covers recording devices, communications network, computer systems (including hardware and software components and data) and other electronic devices. IT Group/ The unit of an Department organization within a BSI responsible for the activities of IT operations control, monitoring of IT services, infrastructure support and a combination of technology, people and processes. IT Operations Encompasses all processes and services that are provisioned by an IT Unit to internal and external clients. IT An arrangement under Outsourcing which another party (either an affiliated entity within a corporate group or an entity external to the corporate group) Terminology Definitions undertakes to provide to a BSI all or part of an IT function or service. A BSI would use IT outsourcing for functions ranging from infrastructure to software development, maintenance and support. The related IT service is integral to the provision by BSI of a financial service and the BSI is dependent on the service on an ongoing basis. IT Risk Any potential adverse outcome, damage, loss, violation, failure or disruption associated with the use of or reliance on computer hardware, software, devices, systems, applications and networks. IT Strategic A long-term plan (i.e., Plan three (3)- to five (5)- year horizon) in which business and IT management cooperatively describe how IT resources will contribute to the institution's strategic objectives. IT Risk Risk management Management system that enables a System BSI to identify, measure, (ITRMS) monitor and control IT-related risks. Management A general term for the Information computer systems in an System (MIS) institution that provide information about its business operations. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 31 §§ 4196S.5- 4196S.6 13.12.31 Terminology Definitions Network Two (2) or more computer systems that are grouped together to share information, software and hardware. Offshore BSIs Have their critical system processing and data located outside of the Philippines. These are usually maintained and operated by organizations within the same business group that the BSIs belong to, such as their head office, subsidiary and/or affiliate. Locallymaintained systems, if any, are limited to noncore supporting applications such as collaboration systems and report processing tools. Project Planning, monitoring Management and controlling an activity. Senior Officers of the Management/ institution given the Management authority by the Board to implement the policies it has laid down in the conduct of the business of the institution. Service Level Establishes mutual Agreement expectations and provide a baseline to measure IT performance. An SLA should contain, among others, the specified level of service, support options, enforcement or penalty provisions for services not provided, S Regulations Part I - Page 32 Terminology Definitions a guaranteed level of system performance as it relates to downtime or uptime, a specified level of customer support and what software or hardware will be provided and for what fee. Triple Data A mode of the DES Encryption encryption algorithm Standard that encrypts data three (3DES) times. Three 64-bit keys are used, instead of one, for an overall key length of 192 bits (the first encryption is encrypted with second key, and the resulting cipher text is again encrypted with a third key) (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.6 Description of IT-related risks. As BSIs increase their reliance on IT to deliver products and services, inappropriate usage of IT resources may have significant risk exposures. While IT does not trigger new types of risks, it brings in new dimensions to traditional banking risks (i.e. strategic risk, credit risk, market risk, liquidity risk and operational risk) that require new or enhanced control activities (e.g. a failure of a credit risk measurement application is an IT failure and, therefore, a systems failure in the sense of operational risk). Moreover, IT is an implied part of any system of internal controls, regardless of the type of risk and, consequently, forms an important element in organization-wide risk management. Among the risks associated with the use of IT are the following: 1. Operational risk is the risk to earnings and capital arising from problems with service or product delivery. This risk is a function of internal controls, IT systems, Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions §§ 4196S.6- 4196S.7 13.12.31 employee integrity and operating processes. Operational risk exists in all products and services; 2. Strategic risk is the risk to earnings and capital arising from adverse business decisions on IT-related investments or improper implementation of those decisions. The risk is a function of the compatibility of an organization’s strategic goals, the business strategies developed to achieve those goals, the resources deployed against these goals and the quality of implementation. The resources needed to carry out business strategies are both tangible and intangible which include communication channels, operating systems, delivery networks and managerial capacities and capabilities; 3. Reputation risk is the risk to earnings and capital arising from negative public opinion. This affects the institution’s ability to establish new relationships or services or continue servicing existing relationships. The risk can expose the institution to litigation, financial loss or damage to its reputation; and 4. Compliance risk is the risk to earnings and capital arising from the violations of, or non-conformance with laws, rules and regulations, prescribed practices or ethical standards. Compliance risk also arises in situations where the laws and rules governing certain products activities of the BSI’s clients may be ambiguous or untested. Compliance risk exposes the institution to monetary penalties, non-monetary sanctions and possibility of contracts being annulled or declared unenforceable. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.7 IT Risk Management System (ITRMS). As BSIs become more dependent on IT systems and processes, technology risks and information security issues have become progressively more complex and pressing in recent years. Information security is just as important as the new technologies being installed by BSIs. As progress in technology shifts to higher gear, the trend in cyber-attacks, intrusions, and other form of incidents on computer systems shows that it will not only persist but will continue to increase in frequency and spread in magnitude. Management of IT risks and information security issues becomes a necessity and an important part of BSIs’ risk management system. BSIs are therefore required to establish a robust ITRM system covering four (4) key components: 1) IT governance, 2) risk identification and assessment, 3) IT controls implementation, and 4) risk measurement and monitoring. 1. IT Governance. This is an integral part of BSIs’ governance framework and consists of the leadership and organizational structures and processes that ensure the alignment of IT strategic plan with BSIs’ business strategy, optimization of resources management, IT value delivery, performance measurement and the effective and efficient use of IT to achieve business objectives and effective IT risk management implementation. BSIs must establish an effective IT governance framework covering the following: a. Oversight and organization of IT functions. Accountability is a key concern of IT governance and this can be obtained with an organizational structure that has well-defined roles for the responsibility of information, business processes, applications, IT infrastructure, etc. The Board of Directors is ultimately responsible for understanding the IT risks confronted by a BSI and ensuring that they are properly managed, whereas the Senior Management is accountable for designing and implementing the ITRMS approved by the Board. For Complex BSIs, the Board may delegate to an IT Steering Committee (ITSC) or its equivalent IT oversight function to cohesively monitor IT performance and institute appropriate actions to ensure Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 33 § 4196S.7 13.12.31 achievement of desired results. The ITSC, at a minimum, should have as members a non-executive Board director who oversees the institution’s IT function, the head of IT group/department, and the highest rank officer who oversees the business user groups. The head of control groups should participate in ITSC meetings in advisory capacity only. A charter should be ratified by the Board to clearly define the roles and responsibilities of the ITSC. Formal minutes of meeting should be maintained to document its discussions and decisions. The ITSC should regularly provide adequate information to the Board regarding IT performance, status of major IT projects or other significant issues to enable the Board to make well-informed decisions about the BSIs’ IT operations. BSIs should develop an IT strategic plan that is aligned with the institution’s business strategy. This should be undertaken to manage and direct all IT resources in line with the business strategy and priorities. IT strategic plan should focus on long term goals covering three (3)- to five (5)- year horizon and should be sufficiently supplemented by tactical IT plans which specify concise objectives, action plans and tasks that are understood and accepted by both business and IT. The IT strategic plan should be formally documented, endorsed by the Board and communicated to all stakeholders. It should be reviewed and updated regularly for new risks or opportunities to maximize the value of IT to the institution. BSIs should also create an organization of IT functions that will effectively deliver IT services to business units. For “Complex” BSIs, a full-time IT Head or equivalent rank should be designated to take the lead in key IT initiatives and oversee the effectiveness of the IT organization. In addition to managing the delivery of day-to-day IT services, the IT Head should also oversee S Regulations Part I - Page 34 the IT budget and maintain responsibility for performance management, IT acquisition oversight, professional development and training. The IT Head should be a member of executive management with direct involvement in key decisions for the BSI and usually reports directly to the President or Chief Executive Officer. A clear description of roles and responsibilities for individual IT functions should be documented and approved by the Board. Proper segregation of duties within and among the various IT functions should be implemented to reduce the possibility for an individual to compromise a critical process. A mechanism should be in place to ensure that personnel are performing only the functions relevant to their respective jobs and positions. In the event that an institution finds it difficult to segregate certain IT control responsibilities, it should put in place adequate compensating controls (e.g. peer reviews) to mitigate the associated risks. b. IT policies, procedures and standards. IT controls, policies, and procedures are the foundation of IT governance structure. It helps articulate the rules and procedures for making IT decisions, and helps to set, attain, and monitor IT objectives. BSIs should adopt and enforce IT-related policies and procedures that are welldefined and frequently communicated to establish and delineate duties and responsibilities of personnel for better coordination, effective and consistent performance of tasks, and quicker training of new employees. Management should ensure that policies, procedures, and systems are current and well-documented. The ITSC should review IT policies, procedures, and standards at least on an annual basis. Any updates and changes should be clearly documented and properly approved. IT policies and procedures should include at least the following areas: • IT Governance/Management; Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions § 4196S.7 13.12.31 • Development and Acquisition; • IT Operations; • Communication networks; • Information security; • Electronic Banking/Electronic Products and Services; and • IT Outsourcing/Vendor Management. For simple BSIs, some of the above areas (i.e. development, electronic banking, etc.) may not be applicable, thus sound judgment should be employed to ensure that the BSI’s IT policies and procedures have adequately covered all applicable areas. c. IT audit. Audit plays a key role in assisting the Board in the discharge of its corporate governance responsibilities by performing an independent assessment of technology risk management process and IT controls. Auditors provide an assurance that important control mechanisms are in place for detecting deficiencies and managing risks in the implementation of IT. They should be qualified to assess the specific risks that arise from specific uses of IT. BSIs should establish effective audit programs that cover IT risk exposures throughout the organization, risk-focused, promote sound IT controls, ensure the timely resolution of audit deficiencies and periodic reporting to the Board on the effectiveness of institution’s IT risk management, internal controls, and IT governance. Regardless of size and complexity, the IT audit program should cover the following: • Independence of the IT audit function and its reporting relationship to the Board or its Audit Committee; • Expertise and size of the audit staff relative to the IT environment; • Identification of the IT audit universe, risk assessment, scope, and frequency of IT audits; • Processes in place to ensure timely tracking and resolution of reported weaknesses; and • Documentation of IT audits, including work papers, audit reports, and follow-up. In case in-house IT audit expertise is not available, such as for a simple BSI, the IT audit support may be performed by external specialists and auditors of other institutions consistent with existing Bangko Sentral rules and regulations on outsourcing. (Detailed guidelines/standards on IT Audit are shown in Appendix Q-59a) d. Staff competence and training. The rapid development in technology demands appropriate, skilled personnel to remain competent and meet the required level of expertise on an ongoing basis. BSIs should have an effective IT human resources management plan that meets the requirements for IT and the business lines it supports. Management should allocate sufficient resources to hire and train employees to ensure that they have the expertise necessary to perform their job and achieve organizational goals and objectives. Management needs to ensure that staffing levels are sufficient to handle present and expected work demands, and to cater reasonably for staff turnover. Appropriate succession and transition strategies for key officers and personnel should be in place to provide for a smooth transition in the event of turnover in vital IT management or operations functions. e. Management Information Systems (MIS). The BSIs’ IT organization often provides an important support role for their MIS. Accurate and timely MIS reports are an essential component of prudent and reasonable business decisions. At the most senior levels, MIS provides the data and information to help the Board and management make strategic decisions. At other levels, MIS allows management to monitor the institution’s activities and distribute information to other employees, customers, and members of management. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 35 § 4196S.7 13.12.31 Advances in technology have increased the volume of information available to management and directors for planning and decision-making. However, if technology is not properly managed, the potential for inaccurate reporting and flawed decision making increases. Because report generation systems can rely on manual data entry or extract data from many different financial and transaction systems, management should establish appropriate control procedures to ensure information is correct, relevant, and adequately protected. Since MIS can originate from multiple equipment platforms and systems, the controls should ensure all information systems have sufficient and appropriate controls to maintain the integrity of the information and the processing environment. Sound fundamental principles for MIS review include proper internal controls, operating procedures, safeguards, and audit coverage. f. IT risk management function. Management of risk is a cornerstone of IT Governance. BSIs should have a policy requiring the conduct of identification, measurement, monitoring and controlling of IT risks for each business function/service on a periodic basis. BSIs should define and assign these critical roles to a risk management unit or to a group of persons from different units collectively performing the tasks defined for this function. The function should have a formal technology risk acknowledgement and acceptance process by the owner of risk to help facilitate the process of reviewing, evaluating and approving any major incidents of non-compliance with IT control policies. The process can be supported by the following: • a description of risk being considered for acknowledgement by owner of risk and an assessment of the risk that is being accepted; • identification of mitigating controls; S Regulations Part I - Page 36 • formulation of a remedial plan to reduce risk; and • approval of risk acknowledgement from the owner of the risk and senior management. ITRM processes should be integrated into the enterprise-wide risk management processes to allow BSIs to make wellinformed decisions involving business plans and strategies, risk responses, risk tolerance levels and capital management, among others. 2. Risk identification and assessment. BSIs should maintain a risk assessment process that drives response selection and controls implementation. An effective IT assessment process begins with the identification of the current and prospective IT risk exposures arising from the institution’s IT environment and related processes. The assessments should identify all information assets, any foreseeable internal and external threats to these assets, the likelihood of the threats, and the adequacy of existing controls to mitigate the identified risks. Management should continually compare its risk exposure to the value of its business activities to determine acceptable risk levels. Once management understands the institution’s IT environment and analyzes the risk, it should rank the risks and prioritize its response. The probability of occurrence and the magnitude of impact provide the foundation for reducing risk exposures or establishing mitigating controls for safe, sound, and efficient IT operations appropriate to the complexity of the organization. Periodic risk assessment process should be done at the enterprisewide level and an effective monitoring program for the risk mitigation activities should be manifested through mitigation or corrective action plans, assignment of responsibilities and accountability and management reporting. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions § 4196S.7 13.12.31 3. IT controls implementation. Controls comprise of policies, procedures, practices and organizational structures designed to provide reasonable assurance that business objectives will be achieved and undesired events will be mitigated. Management should establish an adequate and effective system of internal controls based on the degree of exposure and the potential risk of loss arising from the use of IT. Controls for IT environment generally should address the overall integrity of the environment and should include clear and measurable performance goals, the allocation of specific responsibilities for key project implementation, and independent mechanisms that will both measure risks and minimize excessive risk-taking. BSI Management should implement satisfactory control practices that address the following as part of its overall IT risk mitigation strategy: 1) Information security; 2) Project management/development and acquisition and change management; 3) IT operations; 4) IT outsourcing/Vendor management; and 5) Electronic banking, Electronic payments, Electronic money and other Electronic products and services. a. Information security. Information is a vital asset that must be managed to support BSI management in making decisions. BSIs should have a comprehensive information security program, approved by the Board, to maintain the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of computer systems for reliable and timely information. Unauthorized access, destruction, or disclosure of confidential information can adversely affect earnings and capital. The program should monitor information security function throughout the organization’s business processes and establish clear accountability for carrying out security responsibilities. The Board or Senior Management should appoint an independent information security officer (ISO) who will be responsible and accountable for the organization-wide IS program. The duly appointed ISO should have sufficient knowledge, background, and training, as well as organizational position, to enable him to perform assigned tasks. To ensure appropriate segregation of duties, the ISO should report directly to the Board or senior management and have sufficient independence to perform his mandate. The ISO should perform the tasks of a risk manager and not a production resource assigned to the IT department. In the case of simple BSIs, hiring a personnel to specifically perform the function of an ISO may not be necessary. The ISO function may be assigned to an existing independent officer who meets the requirements mentioned in this Subsection. (Detailed guidelines/standards on Information Security are shown in Appendix Q-59b) b. Project management/development and acquisition and change management. BSIs should establish a framework for management of IT-related projects. The framework should clearly specify the appropriate project management methodology that will govern the process of developing, implementing and maintaining major IT systems. The methodology, on the other hand, should cover allocation of responsibilities, activity breakdown, budgeting of time and resources, milestones, checkpoints, key dependencies, quality assurance, risk assessment and approvals, among others. In the acquisition and/or development of IT solutions, BSIs should ensure that business and regulatory requirements are satisfied. (Detailed guidelines/standards on Project Management/ Development and Acquisition and Change Management are shown in Appendix Q-59c) c. IT operations. IT has become an integral part of the day-to-day business operation, automating and providing support to nearly all of the business processes and functions within the Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 37 § 4196S.7 13.12.31 institution. Therefore, the IT systems should be reliable, secure and available when needed which translates to high levels of service and dependency on IT to operate. One of the primary responsibilities of IT operations management is to ensure the institution’s current and planned infrastructure is sufficient to accomplish its strategic plans. BSI management should ensure that IT operates in a safe, sound, and efficient manner throughout the institution. Given that most IT systems are interconnected and interdependent, failure to adequately supervise any part of the IT environment can heighten potential risks for all elements of IT operations and the performance of the critical business lines of the BSIs. Such scenario necessitates the coordination of IT controls throughout the institution’s operating environment. (Detailed guidelines/standards on IT Operations are shown in Appendix Q-59d) d. IT outsourcing/vendor management program. IT outsourcing refers to any contractual agreement between a BSI and a service provider or vendor for the latter to create, maintain, or reengineer the institution’s IT architecture, systems and related processes on a continuing basis. A BSI may outsource IT systems and processes except those functions expressly prohibited by existing regulations. The decision to outsource should fit into the institution’s overall strategic plan and corporate objectives and said arrangement should comply with the provisions of existing Bangko Sentral rules and regulations on outsourcing. Although the technology needed to support business objectives is often a critical factor in deciding to outsource, managing such relationships should be viewed as an enterprise-wide corporate management issue, rather than a mere IT issue. While IT outsourcing transfers operational responsibility to the service provider, the BSIs retain ultimate S Regulations Part I - Page 38 responsibility for the outsourced activity. Moreover, the risks associated with the outsourced activity may be realized in a different manner than if the functions were inside the institution resulting in the need for controls designed to monitor such risks. BSI management should implement an effective outsourcing oversight program that provides the framework for management to understand, monitor, measure, and control the risks associated with outsourcing. BSIs outsourcing IT services should have a comprehensive outsourcing risk management process which provides guidance on the following areas: 1) risk assessment; 2) selection of service providers; 3) contract review; and 4) monitoring of service providers. Detailed guidelines/standards on IT Outsourcing/ Vendor Management and on the adoption of outsourced cloud computing model are shown in Appendix Q-59e. e. Electronic products and services. The evolution in technology revolutionized the way banking and financial products and services are delivered. Physical barriers were brought down enabling clients to access their accounts, make transactions or gather information on financial products and services anywhere they are, at any time of the day and at their own convenience. As development in technology continues to accelerate, innovative electronic products and services are foreseen to bring more accessibility and efficiency. However, BSIs may be confronted with challenges relating to capacity, availability and reliability of the electronic services. Likewise, fraudulent activities via electronic channels are also rising in number. BSIs should protect customers from fraudulent schemes done electronically. Otherwise, consumer confidence to use electronic channels as safe and reliable method of making transactions will be eroded. To mitigate the impact of cyber fraud, BSIs should adopt aggressive security Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions § 4196S.7 13.12.31 posture such as the following: i. The entire ATM system shall be upgraded/converted to allow adoption of end-to-end Triple DES (3DES) encryption standards by 01 January 2015. The 3DES encryption standards shall cover the whole ATM network which consists of the host processors, switches, host security module (HSM), automated teller machines (ATMs), point-of-sale (POS) terminals and all communication links connected to the network; ii. ATMs to be installed after 14 September 2013 should be 3DES compliant; and iii. ATMs, POS terminals and payment cards are also vulnerable to skimming attacks due to the lack of deployment of globally recognized EMV enabled technology by BSIs. Magnetic stripe only ATMs, POS Terminals and cards are largely defenseless against modern fraud techniques. Therefore, all concerned BSIs should shift from magnetic stripe technology to EMV chip-enabled cards, POS Terminals and ATMs. The entire payment card network should be migrated to EMV by 01 January 2017. This requirement shall cover both issuing and acquiring programs of concerned BSIs. A written and Boardapproved EMV migration plan should be submitted to Bangko Sentral within six (6) months from 22 August 2013. Likewise, the detailed guidelines covering subject EMV requirement shall be issued separately. Detailed guidelines/standards on Electronic Products and Services are shown in Appendix Q-59f. 4. Risk measurement and monitoring. BSI Management should monitor IT risks and the effectiveness of established controls through periodic measurement of IT activities based on internally established standards and industry benchmarks to assess the effectiveness and efficiency of existing operations. Timely, accurate, and complete risk monitoring and assessment reports should be submitted to management to provide assurance that established controls are functioning effectively, resources are operating properly and used efficiently and IT operations are performing within established parameters. Any deviation noted in the process should be evaluated and management should initiate remedial action to address underlying causes. The scope and frequency of these performance measurement activities will depend on the complexity of the BSI’s IT risk profile and should cover, among others, the following: a. Performance vis-à-vis approved IT strategic plan. As part of both planning and monitoring mechanisms, BSI management should periodically assess its uses of IT as part of overall business planning. Such an enterprise-wide and ongoing approach helps to ensure that all major IT projects are consistent with the BSI’s overall strategic goals. Periodic monitoring of IT performance against established plans shall confirm whether IT strategic plans remain in alignment with the business strategy and the IT performance supports the planned strategy. b. Performance benchmarks/service levels. BSIs should establish performance benchmarks or standards for IT functions and monitor them on a regular basis. Such monitoring can identify potential problem areas and provide assurance that IT functions are meeting the objectives. Areas to consider include system and network availability, data center availability, system reruns, out of balance conditions, response time, error rates, data entry volumes, special requests, and problem reports. Management should properly define services and service level agreements (SLA) that must be monitored and measured in terms understandable to the business units. SLA with business units and IT department should be established to provide a baseline to measure IT performance. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 39 §§ 4196S.7- 4196S.9 13.12.31 c. Quality assurance/quality control. BSI should establish quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) procedures for all significant activities, both internal and external, to ensure that IT is delivering value to business in a cost effective manner and promotes continuous improvement through ongoing monitoring. QA activities ensure that product conforms to specification and is fit for use while QC procedures identify weaknesses in work products and to avoid the resource drain and expense of redoing a task. The personnel performing QA and QC reviews should be independent of the product/process being reviewed and use quantifiable indicators to ensure objective assessment of the effectiveness of IT activities in delivering IT capabilities and services. d. Policy compliance. BSIs should develop, implement, and monitor processes to measure IT compliance with their established policies and standards as well as regulatory requirements. In addition to the traditional reliance on internal and third party audit functions, BSIs should perform self-assessments on a periodic basis to gauge performance which often lead to early identification of emerging or changing risks requiring policy changes and updates. e. External assessment program. Complex BSIs may also seek regular assurance that IT assets are appropriately secured and that their IT security risk management framework is effective. This may be executed through a formal external assessment program that facilitates a systematic assessment of the IT security risk and control environment over time. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.8 Reports. To enable the Bangko Sentral to regularly monitor IT risk profile and electronic products, services, delivery channels, processes and other relevant information regarding the use of technology, BSIs are required to submit the S Regulations Part I - Page 40 following: 1. Annual IT Profile, electronically to the Bangko Sentral Supervisory Data Center (SDC) within twenty five (25) days from the end of reference year (Guidelines to be observed in the preparation and submission of this report was issued under Bangko Sentral Memorandum to All Banks No. M-2012-011 dated 17 February 2012); 2. Report on breach in information security, especially incidents involving the use of electronic channels, pursuant to the provisions of Items “a” or “b” of Appendix Q-60 following the guidelines provided in Item “d” thereof. Depending on the nature and seriousness of the incident, Bangko Sentral may require the BSI to provide further information or updates on the reported incident until the matter is finally resolved; and 3. Notification letter to the Core Information Technology Specialist Group (CITSG) of the Bangko Sentral of disruption of IT services/operations that resulted to the activation of disaster recovery and business continuity plan immediately upon activation of the plan. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) § 4196S.9 Sanctions and penalties. BSIs should make available IT policies and procedures on the foregoing and other related documents during the on-site examination as well as provide a copy thereof when written request was made to determine their compliance with this Section. Any violation of the provisions of this Section, its appendices and annexes, shall be subject to the monetary and nonmonetary sanctions provided under Section 37 of R.A. No. 7653. Enforcement actions shall be imposed on the basis of the overall assessment of BSIs’ ITRMS. Whenever a BSI’s ITRMS is rated “1” pursuant to Subsection 4196S.4, the following Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions §§ 4196S.9- 4199S 13.12.31 additional sanctions may be imposed: 1. Suspension/revocation of authority to provide electronic products and services; and 2. Prohibition against offering/ provision of new electronic products and services. (Circular No. 808 dated 22 August 2013) Secs. 4197S - 4198S (Reserved) Sec. 4199S General Provision on Sanctions Unless otherwise provided, any violation of the provisions of this Part shall be subject to the sanctions provided in Sections 34, 35, 36 and 37 of R.A. No. 7653, whenever applicable. Manual of Regulations for Non-Banks Financial Institutions S Regulations Part I - Page 41 §§ 4201S - 4240S 08.12.31 PART TWO DEPOSIT AND BORROWING OPERATIONS A. DEMAND DEPOSITS Section 4201S Checking Accounts. No NSSLA shall have or carry upon its books for any person any demand, commercial or checking account, or any credit to be withdrawn upon the presentation of any negotiable check or draft. Secs. 4202S - 4205S (Reserved) may be charged by the NSSLA for every withdrawal made in excess of the maximum number allowed in any one (1) month. Sec. 4209S Dormant Savings Deposits NSSLAs may charge a fee, the amount of which shall be approved by the BSP for the maintenance of dormant savings deposits. Savings deposit shall be classified as dormant if no deposit or withdrawal has been made for the last two (2) years. B. SAVINGS DEPOSITS Secs. 4210S – 4215S (Reserved) Sec. 4206S Definition. Savings deposits are deposits evidenced by a passbook consisting of funds deposited to the credit of one (1) or more individuals with respect to which the depositor may withdraw anytime, unless prior notice in writing of an intended withdrawal is required by the NSSLA. Sec. 4207S Minimum Deposit. Savings deposits with NSSLAs may be opened with a minimum deposit of P100. Sec. 4208S Withdrawals. Withdrawal from a savings deposit shall be made through the presentation to the NSSLA of a duly accomplished withdrawal slip together with the depositor’s passbook. NSSLAs shall reserve the right to require the depositor to give prior written notice of withdrawal of not more than thirty (30) days. NSSLAs may limit the number of withdrawals that a depositor may make: Provided, That the number of the withdrawals allowed shall not be less than three (3) times a month. A service charge to be determined by the board of trustees of the NSSLA and approved by the BSP, C. (RESERVED) Secs. 4216S - 4220S (Reserved) D. TIME DEPOSITS Sec. 4221S (Reserved) Sec. 4222S Minimum Term and Size of Time Deposits a. Term - No time deposit shall be accepted for a term of less than thirty (30) days. b. Minimum Size - NSSLAs shall not require a minimum amount of time deposit greater than P1,000. Sec. 4223S Withdrawals of Time Deposits. The withdrawal of a time deposit can be made only by presentation of the certificate of time deposit on the day of or after its maturity. Secs. 4224S - 4230S (Reserved) E. - F. (RESERVED) Secs. 4231S - 4240S (Reserved) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part II - Page 1 §§ 4241S - 4261S.5 08.12.31 G. INTEREST ON DEPOSITS Sec. 4241S Interest on Savings Deposits Savings deposits of NSSLAs shall not be subject to any interest rate ceiling. Sec. 4242S Interest on Time Deposits Interest on time deposits shall not be subject to any interest rate ceiling. § 4242S.1 Time of payment. Interest on time deposits may be paid at maturity or upon withdrawal or in advance: Provided, however, That interest paid in advance shall not exceed the interest for one (1) year. § 4242S.2 Treatment of matured time deposits. A time deposit not withdrawn or renewed on its due date shall be treated as a savings deposit and shall earn an interest from maturity to the date of actual withdrawal or renewal at a rate applicable to savings deposits. Secs.4243S - 4250S (Reserved) deposit account for himself, provided he has sufficient discretion. However, he cannot withdraw therefrom, except through, or with the assistance of a guardian authorized to act for him. Parents may deposit for their minor children, and guardians for their wards. Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, the cashier, bookkeeper and their assistants, and other employees of an NSSLA whose duties entail the handling of cash or checks are prohibited from opening savings deposit accounts with the head office or branch of the NSSLA in which they are assigned as such. § 4261S.2 Identification of memberdepositors. NSSLAs shall be responsible for the proper identification of their member-depositors. § 4261S.3 Number of deposit accounts A member-depositor may open and have more than one (1) savings deposit in his own name in the same capacity, and he may open and have various deposits in different capacities such as guardian, agent, or trustee for others. H. (RESERVED) § 4261S.4 Signature card. A signature card bearing at least three (3) specimen signatures of each member-depositor shall be required upon opening of a deposit account. Secs. 4251S – 4260S (Reserved) I. SUNDRY PROVISIONS ON DEPOSIT OPERATIONS Sec. 4261S Opening and Operation of Deposit Accounts. The following are basic provisions on the opening and operation of deposit accounts of NSSLAs. § 4261S.1 Who may open deposit accounts. Only members who have contributed P1,000 or more to the capital of the NSSLA may open deposit accounts with NSSLAs. A natural person, although lacking capacity to contract, may nevertheless open a savings or time S Regulations Part II - Page 2 § 4261S.5 Passbook and certificate of time deposit. A savings deposit passbook, signed by the receiving teller and an authorized officer, shall be issued to a member-depositor showing, among other things, his name and address, account number, date, amount of deposit, interest credits and balance. NSSLAs shall prenumber their savings deposit passbooks. In the case of a time deposit, a certificate of time deposit signed by two (2) authorized officers, shall be issued to the member- Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4261S.5 - 4299S 08.12.31 depositor containing, among other things, his name, amount of deposit, date when the deposit was made, its due date and interest rate. § 4261S.6 Deposits in checks and other cash items. Checks and other cash items may be accepted for deposit by NSSLAs: Provided, That withdrawals from such deposits shall not be made until the check or other cash item is collected. Secs. 4262S - 4280S (Reserved) J. (RESERVED) Secs. 4281S - 4285S (Reserved) K. OTHER BORROWINGS Sec. 4286S Borrowings. An NSSLA may borrow money or incur such obligation up to not more than twenty percent (20%) of the total assets of the NSSLA, from any public lending institution, and from private banking institutions, and such private lending institutions as may be approved by the Monetary Board: Provided, That the proceeds of such loan shall be used exclusively to meet the normal credit requirements of its members. The Monetary Board may, in meritorious cases, raise the ceiling on the borrowing capacity of an NSSLA to not more than thirty percent (30%) of its total assets. NSSLAs organized by employees of an entity or a corporation may borrow funds from said entity or corporation, but not vice-versa. Secs. 4287S - 4298S (Reserved) Sec. 4299S General Provision on Sanctions. Unless otherwise provided, any violation of the provisions of this Part shall be subject to the sanctions provided in Sections 34, 35, 36 and 37 of R.A. No. 7653, whenever applicable. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part II - Page 3 §§ 4301S - 4301S.1 13.12.31 PART THREE LOANS AND INVESTMENTS A. LOANS IN GENERAL Section 4301S Lending Policies. It shall be the responsibility of the board of trustees of NSSLAs to formulate written policies on the extension of credit. Well-defined lending policies and sound credit risk management practices are essential if NSSLAs are to perform their lending function effectively and minimize the risk inherent in any extension of credit. The responsibility should be approached in a way that will provide assurance to the members, other stakeholders and the supervisory authority that timely and adequate action will be taken to maintain the quality of the loan portfolio. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) § 4301S.1 (2012-4301S) Authority; loan limits; maturity of loans. The board of trustees of NSSLAs shall be responsible for the design of appropriate loan products in accordance with the Association’s business strategies and its members’ requirements. The board of trustees shall ensure that they fully understand all the risks attendant to the Association’s lending activities and shall adopt appropriate risk management policies and practices that are commensurate to the risk attendant to their operations, and which, at a minimum, shall comply with the regulations and standards prescribed herein. NSSLAs deemed to be engaged in hazardous lending practices shall be cited as operating in an unsafe and unsound manner. a. Loans products. NSSLAs may grant loans to members to service the needs of households by providing long term financing for home building and development, for personal finance and for agricultural and entrepreneurial projects. The board of trustees of NSSLAs shall consider, among other things, the following in the definition of its loan products: (1) the nature or purpose of the loan; (2) the repayment capacity and circumstances of the member-borrower; (3) terms of the loan; and (4) normal loan collection cycles. The definitions and characterization of all loan products shall be embodied in a product manual approved by the board of trustees. The product manual shall, at a minimum, contain the term of the loan, the maturity of which shall in no case exceed the maximum provided under Item “d” of this Subsection, interest rate, net-take home pay requirement vis-a-vis the type of member-borrower, repayment terms, collection scheme, documentary requirements and applicable work-out strategies. The normal collection period, which refers to the normal period of time within which the Association is able to effect the first periodic amortization/salary deduction for amortization of a loan reckoned from loan release date, shall likewise be set by the NSSLA’s board of trustees and shall be based on the recent historical experience of the NSSLA (e.g., last three years) and/or the remittance period specified in contracts entered into with private companies or department/branch/ office of government employing the NSSLA’s members. The NSSLA’s normal collection period and the manner by which it is established shall be set forth in the NSSLA’s loan policies and considered in its overall risk assets review system in order to reflect the true status of loan accounts and ensure that adequate loss reserves are provided. In no case, however, shall the normal collection period exceed six (6) months from the date of release of the loan. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 1 §§ 4301S.1 - 4302S 13.12.31 b. Loan limit to a single borrower. An NSSLA may grant loans not exceeding the amount deposited and/or contributed by the member-borrower plus his twelve (12) months salary or retirement pension from his employment, or up to seventy percent (70%) of the fair market value of any property acceptable as collateral on first mortgage that he may put up by way of security: Provided, That direct indebtedness to an NSSLA of any member-borrower for money borrowed with the exception of money borrowed against obligations of the Bangko Sentral or of the Philippine Government, or borrowed with the full guarantee of the Philippine Government in the payment of principal and interest, shall not exceed fifteen percent (15%) of the unimpaired capital and surplus of the NSSLA. For purposes of this Section, regular income of persons who are self-employed shall be their average monthly income during the twelve (12)-month period immediately preceding the date of loan application. c. Limitations on lending authority. NSSLAs shall not commit to make any loan for amounts in excess of the total of the following amounts: (1) Amount of cash available for loan purposes; (2) Amount of cash which can be readily realized upon the sale or redemption of permissible investments made by NSSLAs; and (3) Amount of credit available for loan purposes from government or private FIs. d. Maximum loan maturity. No loan granted by NSSLAs shall have a maturity date of more than five (5) years except loans on the security of unencumbered real estate for the purpose of home building and home development which may be granted with S Regulations Part III - Page 2 maturities not exceeding twenty-five (25) years and medium or long-term loans to finance agricultural projects. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Sec. 4302S Basic Requirements in Granting Loans a. Application. A member-borrower applying for a loan must submit an application stating the purpose of the loan and such other information as may be required by the NSSLA. The loan application and other required documents shall form part of credit information file of the member-borrower in the NSSLA. b. Credit investigation. No loan shall be approved unless prior investigation has been made to determine the credit standing of the applicant and/or the fair market value of the property offered as security and the report thereon shall be made part of the loan application: Provided, however, That this requirement may be waived by an NSSLA in the case of permanent employee or wage earner who is borrowing an amount not exceeding his deposit plus his twelve (12) months regular salary or retirement pension. c. Credit information file/collateral file. An NSSLA shall maintain as far as practicable, a credit information file which must contain, among other things, the member-borrower’s application and financial record. Other information relative to the member-borrower, where applicable, shall also be maintained which must contain among other things, the collateral and other documents pertinent to the loan. d. Loan approvals. Loans shall be approved by the NSSLA’s board of trustees or if approved by a body or officer/s duly authorized by the board, such loan must be confirmed by the board of trustees. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4302S - 4305S.5 13.12.31 e. Loan agreements. For each loan granted by an NSSLA, a promissory note must be executed by the member-borrower in favor of the NSSLA expressing such particulars as the amount of the loan, date granted, due date, interest rate and other similar information. f. Inscription of lien. In case of mortgage loans, no release against an approved loan shall be made before the inscription of the mortgage. Sec. 4303S Loan Proceeds. NSSLAs shall in no case require member-borrowers to deposit a portion of the loan proceeds, whether in the form of savings or time deposits. Where, subsequent to the release of the loan proceeds, member-borrowers open deposit accounts or make additional deposits to their existing accounts, no part of such new deposits shall be covered by a stipulation prohibiting or limiting withdrawal while new portion of their loans are outstanding: Provided, however, That this prohibition shall not apply in cases of loans secured by a hold-out on deposits to the extent of the unencumbered amount of the deposit existing at the time of the filing of the above-mentioned loan application. Sec. 4304S Loan Repayment. The treasurer, cashier or paymaster of the firm employing a member-borrower shall be required, pursuant to R.A. No. 8367, to make deductions from the salary, wage, income or retirement pension of the member-borrower in accordance with the terms of his loan, and all other deductions authorized by the member-borrower, to remit such deductions to the NSSLA concerned and to collect such reasonable fee for his services as may be authorized by rules promulgated by the Monetary Board. Sec. 4305S Interest and Other Charges. The following rules shall govern the rates of interest and other charges on loans granted by NSSLAs. §§ 4305S.1 - 4305S.2 (Reserved) § 4305S.3 Interest in the absence of stipulation. The rate of interest for the loan or forbearance of any money, goods or credit and the rate allowed in judgments, in the absence of express contract as to such rate of interest, shall be six percent (6%) per annum. (As amended by Circular No. 799 dated 21 June 2013) § 4305S.4 Escalation clause; when allowable. Parties to an agreement pertaining to a loan or forbearance of money, goods or credits may stipulate that the rate of interest agreed upon may be increased in the event that the applicable maximum rate of interest is increased by the Monetary Board: Provided, That such stipulations are valid only if there is also a stipulation in the agreement that the rate of interest agreed upon shall be reduced in the event that the applicable maximum rate of interest is reduced by law or by the Monetary Board: Provided, further, That the adjustment in the rate of interest agreed upon shall take effect on or after the effectivity of the increase or decrease in the maximum rate of interest. § 4305S.5 Interest accrual on past due loans. NSSLAs shall not accrue interest income on loans which are already past due or on loan installments which are in arrears, regardless of whether the loans are secured or unsecured. Interest on past due loans or loan installments in arrears shall be taken up as income only when actual payments thereon are received. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 3 §§ 4305S.5 - 4306S.3 13.12.31 Interest income on past due loan arising from discount amortization (and not from the contractual interest of the account) shall be accrued as provided in PAS 39. (As amended by Circular No. 494 dated 20 September 2005) § 4305S.6 Method of computing interest. NSSLAs shall only charge interest based on the outstanding balance of a loan at the beginning of an interest period. For a loan where the principal is payable in installments, interest per installment period shall be calculated based on the outstanding balance of the loan at the beginning of each installment period. Towards this end, all loan-related documents shall show repayment schedules in a manner consistent with this provision. Marketing materials and presentations shall likewise be consistent with this provision. (Circular No. 754 dated 17 April 2012) Sec. 4306S Past Due Accounts. Past due accounts of an NSSLA shall, as a general rule, refer to all accounts which are not paid at maturity. § 4306S.1 Accounts considered past due. The following shall be considered as past due: a. For loan or receivable payable on demand not paid upon written demand as required herein or within one (1) year from date of grant or renewal, whichever comes earlier. NSSLAs shall, in case of non-payment of a demand loan, make a written demand within six (6) months following the grant of such loan. The demand shall indicate a period of payment which shall not be later than six (6) months from date of said demand. S Regulations Part III - Page 4 b. For loans or receivables payable on installment, the outstanding balance of the loan if a payment has fallen due and remained unpaid; c. In case of restructured loans as defined in Sec. 4308S, the total outstanding balance of the loan if a payment has fallen due and remained unpaid; and d. All items in litigation as defined in the Manual of Accounts. Past due accounts as defined herein are considered non-performing loans (NPL). (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) § 4306S.2 Extension/renewal of loans (Transferrred to Section 4309S pursuant to Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) §4306S.3 Write-off of loans as bad debts. To maximize the protection of members of NSSLAs against misfeasance and malfeasance of the trustees and officers thereof, the Monetary Board adopted the following regulations on writing-off of loans by NSSLAs. a. The term loan shall include all types of credit accommodations granted to, and advances made by the NSSLA for the account of the borrowers/debtors, including the interest thereon recorded in the books. b. Writing-off of loans by an NSSLA shall be made not more than twice a year by its board of trustees; and c. Notice/application for write-off of loans shall be submitted, in the prescribed form to the appropriate department of the SES at least thirty (30) days prior to the intended date of write-off: Provided, That no such loans with an aggregate outstanding amount of P15,000 or more, as certified in said notice/application, shall be written-off without the prior approval of: Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4306S.3 - 4307S.1 12.12.31 (1) The Monetary Board, in case of loans to trustees and officers of the NSSLA, direct or indirect; or (2) The head of the appropriate department of the SES, subject to confirmation by the Monetary Board, in case of loans other than those mentioned in Item “(1)” above. § 4306S.4 Updating of information provided to credit information bureaus NSSLAs which have provided adverse information, such as the past due or litigation status of loan accounts, to credit information bureaus, or any organization performing similar functions, shall submit monthly reports to these bureaus or organizations on the full payment or settlement of the previously reported accounts within five (5) business days from the end of the month when such full payment was received. For this purpose, it shall be the responsibility of the reporting NSSLAs to ensure that their disclosure of any information about their borrowers/clients is with the consent of borrowers concerned. subsequent to the making of such sale or contract; (3) Any option, demand, lien, pledge, or other claim against, or for delivery of, property or money; (4) Any purchase, or other acquisition of, or any credit upon the security of any obligation or claim arising out of any of the foregoing; and (5) Any transaction or series of transactions having a similar purpose or effect. b. Tra n s a c t i o n s n o t c o v e r e d Considering that the specific purpose of the law is the full disclosure of the true cost of credit, the following categories of credit transactions are outside the scope of the above regulations: (1) Credit transactions which do not involve the payment of any finance charge by the debtor; and (2) Credit transactions in which the debtor is the one specifying a definite and fixed set of credit terms such as bank deposits, insurance contracts, sale of bonds, etc. (Circular No. 589 dated 18 December 2007) Sec. 4307S “Truth in Lending Act” Disclosure Requirements. NSSLAs are required to strictly adhere to the provisions of R. A. No. 3765, otherwise known as the “Truth in Lending Act,” and shall make the true and effective cost of borrowing an integral part of every loan contract. a. Transactions covered (1) Any loan, mortgage, deed of trust, advance and discount; (2) Any conditional sales contract, any contract to sell, or sale or contract of sale of property or services, either for present or future delivery, under which, part or all of the price is payable § 4307S.1 Definition of terms a. Creditor (who shall furnish the information) means any person engaged in the business of extending credit (including any person who as a regular business practice makes loans or sells or rents property or services on a time, credit, or installment basis, either as principal or as agent), who requires as an incident to the extension of credit, the payment of a finance charge. The term creditor shall include, but shall not be limited to, banks and banking institutions, insurance and bonding companies, savings and loan associations, credit unions, financing companies, installment houses, real estate dealers, Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 5 §§ 4307S.1 - 4307S.2 12.12.31 lending investors, pawnshops, and any other person or entity engaged in the business of extending credit who requires as an incident to the extension of credit, the payment of a finance charge. b. Person means any individual, corporation, partnership, NSSLA, or other organized group of persons, or the legal successor or representative of the foregoing, and includes the Philippine Government or any agency thereof, or any other government, or any of its political subdivisions, or any agency of the foregoing. c. Cash price or delivered price (in case of trade transactions) is the amount of money which would constitute full payment upon delivery of the property (except money) or service purchased at the creditor’s place of business. In the case of financial transactions, cash price represents the amount of money received by the debtor upon consummation of the credit transaction, net of finance charges collected at the time the credit is extended (if any). d. Down payment represents the amount paid by the debtor at the time of the transaction in partial payment for the property or service purchased. e. Trade-in represents the value of an asset, agreed upon by the creditor and debtor, given at the time of the transaction in partial payment for the property or service purchased. f. Non-finance charges correspond to the amounts advanced by the creditor for items normally associated with the ownership of the property or of the availment of the service purchased which are not incident to the extension of credit. For example, in the case of the purchase of an automobile on credit, the creditor may advance the insurance premium as well as the registration fee for the account of the debtor. S Regulations Part III - Page 6 g. Amount to be financed consists of the cash price plus non-finance charges less the amount of the down payment and value of the trade-in. h. Finance charge includes interest, fees, service charges, discounts, and such other charges incident to the extension of credit. i. Simple annual rate is the uniform percentage which represents the ratio between the finance charge and the amount to be financed under the assumption that the loan is payable in one (1) year with single payment upon maturity and there are no upfront deductions to principal. For loans with terms different from the above assumptions, the effective annual interest rate shall be calculated and disclosed to the borrower as the relevant true cost of the loan comparable to the concept of simple annual rate. For loans with contractual interest rates stated on monthly basis, the effective interest rate may be expressed as a monthly rate. In accordance with the Philippine Accounting Standards (PAS) definition, effective interest rate is the rate that exactly discounts estimated future cash flows through the life of the loan to the net amount of loan proceeds. For consistency, methodology and standards for discounted cash flow models shall be prescribed to be used for the purpose. (As amended by Circular No. 754 dated April 2012) § 4307S.2 Information to be disclosed The following are the minimum information required to be disclosed to NSSLA borrowers (sample form in Appendix S-4): a. The total amount to be financed; b. The finance charges expressed in terms of pesos and centavos; c. The net proceeds of the loan; and d. The percentage that the finance charge bears to the total amount to be Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4307S.2 - 4308S 13.12.31 financed expressed as a simple annual rate or an effective annual interest rate as described in Item “h” of Subsec. 4307S.1. Effective annual interest rate may also be quoted as a monthly rate in parallel with the quotation of the contractual rate. NSSLAs are required to furnish each borrower a copy of the disclosure statement, prior to the consummation of the transaction. (As amended by Circular No. 754 dated 17 April 2012 and M-2012-018 dated 19 April 2012) § 4307S.3 Inspection of contracts covering credit transactions. NSSLAs shall keep in their office or place of business copies of contracts covering all credit transactions entered into by them which involve the extension of credit to another and the payment of finance charges therefor. Such copies shall be available for inspection or examination by the appropriate department of the SES. § 4307S.4 (2008 – 4309S.4) Posters NSSLAs shall post in conspicuous places in their principal place of business and branches, the information as contained in the revised format of disclosure statement (Appendix S-4). The posters shall include an explicit notification that the disclosure statement is a required attachment to the loan contract and the customer has a right to demand a copy of such disclosure. (As amended by Circular No. 754 dated17 April 2012) §4307S.5 Sanctions and penal provisions. Non-compliance with any of the provisions of this Section shall be regarded at least as a less serious offense, depending on the severity of nondisclosure, number of loans and amount involved in the violation. In addition to sanctions under R.A. No. 3765, the following sanctions may be imposed: a. First offense. Reprimand on the erring officer/s; b. Second offense. Reprimand on the entire board of trustees; and c. Subsequent offense/s: i. Suspension of the erring officer/s and/ or entire board of trustees; and ii. Restriction on lending activities. This is without prejudice to other penalties and sanctions provided under Sections 36 and 37 of R.A. No. 7653. (As amended by Circular No. 754 dated 17 April 2012) Sec. 4308S Restructured Loans; General Policy. Restructured loans are loans the principal terms and conditions of which have been modified for it not to become a problem account, or if already past due, to allow for a better settlement plan to fully pay-off the loan. Restructured loans are supported by a restructuring agreement setting forth a new plan of payment or a schedule of payment on a periodic basis. The modification may include, but is not limited to, change in maturity, installment amortization, interest rate, collateral or increase in the face amount of the debt resulting from the capitalization of accrued interest/accumulated charges. Items in litigation and loans subject of judicially-approved compromise, as well as those covered by petitions for suspensions or for new plans of payment approved by the court or the SEC, shall not be classified as restructured loans. NSSLAs shall have the flexibility to determine the basis for and terms of the loan restructuring, considering, among other things, the paying capacity of the borrowers: Provided, That these shall at all times be consistent with sound credit risk management standards. Loan restructuring shall be subject to the approval of the board of trustees whose Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 7 §§ 4308S - 4310S 13.12.31 resolution shall embody, among other things: 1. basis of or justification for the approval; 2. basis for the determination of the borrower’s capacity to pay; and 3. nature and extent of protection of the exposure. The restructuring of loans granted to trustees and/or officers of an NSSLA should be upon terms not less favorable to the Association than those offered to other members. In case of loans secured by real estate collateral, such security shall be appraised at the time of restructuring to ensure that current market values are being used. A second restructuring of a loan may be allowed only if there are reasonable justifications, and after the borrower has paid at least twenty percent (20%) of the principal obligation and updated the payment of all interest accruing to the loan as first restructured. Restructured loans shall be classified and provided with adequate allowance for probable losses in accordance with Appendix S-9. (Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Sec. 4309S (2012-4306S.2) Renewal of Loans. Loans payable in periodic installments may be renewed for the full or beyond the amount of such loans but within the limit prescribed under Subsec. 4301S.1b S Regulations Part III - Page 8 or the NSSLA by-laws, as applicable: Provided, That at least thirty percent (30%) of the loan shall have been paid. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Sec. 4310S Minimum Required Disclosure NSSLAs shall provide a table of the applicable fees, penalties and interest rates on loan transactions, including the period covered by and the manner of and reason for the imposition of such penalties, fees and interests; fees and applicable conversion reference rates for third currency transactions, in plain sight and language, on materials for marketing loans, such as brochures, flyers, primers and advertising materials, on loan application forms, and on billing statements: Provided, That these disclosures are in addition to the full disclosure of the fees, charges and interest rates in the terms and conditions of the loan agreement found elsewhere on the application form and billing statement: Provided further, That such table of fees, penalties and interest rates shall be printed in plain language and in bold black letters against a light or white background, and using the minimum Arial 12 theme font and size, or its equivalent in readability, and on the first page, if the applicable document has more than one (1) page. Transitory provision: NSSLAs covered in 4312N.12 - shall be given a period of 120 days from 6 January 2011 to fully Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4310S - 4312S 10.12.31 implement the required disclosure requirements. (Circular No. 702 dated 15 December 2010) Sec. 4311S Unfair Collection Practices NSSLAs, collection agencies, counsels and other agents may resort to all reasonable and legally permissible means to collect amounts due them under the loan agreement: Provided, That in the exercise of their rights and performance of duties, they must observe good faith and reasonable conduct and refrain from engaging in unscrupulous or untoward acts. Without limiting the general application of the foregoing, the following conduct is a violation of this Section: a. the use or threat of violence or other criminal means to harm the physical person, reputation, or property of any person; b. the use of obscenities, insults, or profane language which amount to a criminal act or offense under applicable laws; c. disclosure of the names of borrowers who allegedly refuse to pay debts, except as allowed under Subsec. 4312S; d. threat to take any action that cannot legally be taken; e. communicating or threat to communicate to any person credit information which is known to be false, application form and billing statement: Provided further, That such table of fees, penalties and interest rates shall be printed including failure to communicate that a debt is being disputed; f. any false representation or deceptive means to collect or attempt to collect any debt or to obtain information concerning borrower; and g. making contact at unreasonable/ inconvenient times or hours which shall be defined as contact before 6:00 A.M. or after 10:00 P.M., unless the account is past due for more than sixty (60) days or the borrower has given express permission or said times are the only reasonable or convenient opportunities for contact. NSSLAs shall inform their borrower in writing of the endorsement of the collection of their account to a collection agency/agent, or the endorsement of their account from one collection agency/agent to another, at least seven (7) days prior to the actual endorsement. The notification shall include the full name of the collection agency and its contact details: Provided, That the required notification in writing shall be included in the terms and conditions of the loan agreement. NSSLAs shall adopt policies and procedures to ensure that personnel handling the collection of accounts, whether these are in-house collectors, or third-party collection agents, shall disclose his/her full name/true identity to the borrower. (Circular No. 702 dated 15 December 2010) Sec. 4312S Confidentiality of Information NSSLAs shall keep strictly confidential the data on the borrower or consumer, except under the following circumstances: a. disclosure of information is with the consent of the borrower or consumer; b. release, submission or exchange of customer information with other financial institutions, credit information bureaus, lenders, their subsidiaries and affiliates; c. upon orders of court of competent jurisdiction or any government office or agency authorized by law, or under such conditions as may be prescribed by the Monetary Board; d. disclosure to collection agencies, counsels and other agents of the NSSLA to enforce its rights against the borrower; e. disclosure to third party service providers solely for the purpose of assisting or rendering services to the NSSLA in the administration of its lending business; and Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 9 §§ 4312S-4356S 14.12.31 f. disclosure to third parties such as insurance companies, solely for the purpose of insuring the NSSLA from borrower default or other credit loss, and the borrower from fraud or unauthorized charges. (Circular No. 702 dated 15 December 2010) Sec. 4313S Sanctions. Violations of the provisions of Secs. 4310S to 4312S shall be subject to any or all of the following sanctions depending upon their severity: a. First offense. Reprimand for the directors/officers responsible for the violation; b. Second offense. Disqualification of the NSSLA concerned from the credit facilities of the Bangko Sentral except as may be allowed under Section 84 of R. A. No. 7653; c. Subsequent offense/s: i. Prohibition on the NSSLA concerned from the extension of additional credit accommodation against personal security; and ii. Penalties and sanctions provided under Sections 36 and 37 of R. A. No. 7653. (Circular No. 702 dated 15 December 2010) Secs. 4314S – 4320S (Reserved) B. SECURED LOANS Sec. 4321S Kinds of Security. Loans by an NSSLA may be secured by any or all of the following: a. Mortgages on registered real estate; b. Chattel mortgages on harvested or stored crops of non-perishable character; c. Chattel mortgages on livestock, tools, equipment or machinery, supplies or materials, merchandise and other personal properties; d. Assignment of quedans which gives the right of disposal of readily marketable products; e. Time and/or savings deposits and/ or capital contribution; f. Pledge of bonds, stock and other securities of GOCCs and other bonds, stocks S Regulations Part III - Page 10 or securities which are non-speculative in nature; g. Land transfer certificates issued by the government to tenant farmers, under the agrarian reform program to the extent of sixty percent (60%) of the value of the farm holdings: Provided, That a certification shall be first secured from the office of the Registry of Deeds to the effect that the Land Transfer Certificate being presented is valid; and h. Other securities as may be approved by the Monetary Board. Secs. 4322S - 4335S (Reserved) C. - D. (RESERVED) Sec. 4336S (Reserved) Sec. 4337S Salary Loans. The Bangko Sentral shall promote the sustainable development of consumer lending such as salary loans under conditions of fair and sound credit practices. (Circular No. 837 dated 18 June 2014) § 4337S.1 Definition of terms a. Salary Loans. Unsecured loans, granted to individuals on the basis of regular salary, pension or other fixed compensation, where repayment would come from such future remunerations, either through salary deduction, debit from the borrower’s deposit account, over-the-counter payment or other type of payment arrangement agreed upon by the borrower and lender. (Circular No. 837 dated 18 June 2014) Secs. 4338S - 4355S (Reserved) E. LOANS/CREDIT ACCOMMODATIONS TO TRUSTEES, OFFICERS, STOCKHOLDERS AND THEIR RELATED INTERESTS Sec. 4356S General Policy. The transactions of all trustees or officers with the NSSLA shall not be under terms more favorable than those transacted with other members. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4357S - 4391S.3 08.12.31 Sec. 4357S Direct/Indirect Borrowings; Ceilings. No NSSLA shall directly or indirectly make any loan to any trustee or officer of such NSSLA, either for himself or as agent or as partner of another, except with the written approval of the majority of the trustees of the NSSLA, excluding the trustee concerned: Provided, That the aggregate loans to such trustees and officers shall not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the total capital contributions of the NSSLA. Sec. 4358S Records; Reports. In all cases of accommodations granted to trustees and officers under Sec. 4357S, the written approval of the majority of the trustees of the NSSLA, excluding the trustee concerned, shall be entered upon the records of the NSSLA and a copy of such entry shall be transmitted forthwith to the appropriate department of the SES within twenty (20) business days from the date of approval. Secs. 4359S - 4369S (Reserved) Sec. 4370S Sanctions. The office of any trustee or officer of an NSSLA who violates the provisions of these rules on accommodations granted to trustee and officers shall immediately become vacant and said trustees or officer shall be punished by imprisonment of not more than one (1) year nor more than ten (10) years and by a fine of not less than P5,000 nor more than P50,000 pursuant to Section 15 of R.A. No. 8367. F. - I. (RESERVED) Secs. 4371S - 4390S (Reserved) J. OTHER OPERATIONS Sec. 4391S Fund Investments. An NSSLA may invest its funds in any or all of the following: a. In bonds and securities in an aggregate amount not exceeding ten percent(10%) of its total assets; any investment in excess of ten percent (10%) shall require the prior approval of the Bangko Sentral: Provided, That NSSLAs may invest available funds in excess of ten percent (10%) of total assets in sound nonspeculative enterprise, particularly in readily marketable and high grade commercial papers, bonds and securities issued by the Government of the Philippines or any of its political subsidiaries, instrumentalities or corporations including GOCCs, subject to the following conditions: (1) The credit needs of the members shall be served/satisfied first; (2) The investment in any one (1) corporation (excluding the Government of the Philippines, any of its political subdivisions, instrumentalities, or corporations including GOCCs), shall not exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of the NSSLA's combined capital accounts; and (3) The additional investment may be up to another ten percent (10%) of the NSSLA’s total assets; b. In real property, in an aggregate amount not exceeding at any one time five percent (5%) of the total assets of such NSSLA; and c. In furniture, fixtures, furnishings and equipment, and leasehold improvements for its offices, in amount not exceeding at any one time ten percent (10%), of its total capital contribution. §§ 4391S.1 - 4391S.2 (Reserved) § 4391S.3 Investments in debt and marketable equity securities. The classification, accounting procedures, valuation, sales and transfers of investments in debt securities and marketable equity securities shall be in accordance with the guidelines in Appendices Q-20 and Q-20a. Penalties and sanctions. The following penalties and sanctions shall be imposed on FIs and concerned officers found to violate the provisions of these regulations: Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part III - Page 11 §§ 4391S.3-4399S 13.12.31 a. Fines of P2,000/banking day to be imposed on NSSLAs for each violation, reckoned from the date the violation was committed up to the date it was corrected; and b. Sanctions to be imposed on concerned officers: (1) First offense – reprimand the officers responsible for the violation; and (2) Subsequent offenses–suspension- of ninety (90) days without pay for officers responsible for the violation. (Circular No. 476 dated 16 February 2005 as amended by Circular Nos. 628 dated 31 October 2008 and 626 dated 23 October 2008) §§ 4391S.4 - 4391S.10 (Reserved) Sec. 4392S Loan Portfolio and Other Risk Assets Review System. To ensure that timely and adequate management action is taken to maintain the quality of the loan portfolio and other risk assets, and that adequate loss reserves are set-up and maintained at a level sufficient to absorb the loss inherent in the loan accounts and other risk assets, each NSSLA shall establish a system of identifying and monitoring existing or potential problem loans and other risk assets, and of evaluating credit and asset management policies vis-avis prevailing circumstances and emerging portfolio trends. The board of trustees is responsible for ensuring that the NSSLA has, at a minimum: a. A robust risk management that shall S Regulations Part III - Page 12 include, at least, an independent and periodic review of quality of risk assets. b. Controls in place, and policies and procedures to determine the adequacy of booked allowance for probable losses on loans and other risk assets, consistent with the Philippine Accounting Standards and the minimum standards required in Appendix S-9. The allowance for losses required in the said appendix shall likewise be set-up immediately; and c. A robust process to ensure that the board of trustees is informed of the results of independent and periodic reviews, and determination of adequacy of booked loss reserves, and that appropriate actions on such reports are undertaken consistent with the specific duties and responsibilities of the board of trustees as provided under Subsec. 4141S.5.a(7). (Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Secs. 4393S - 4395S (Reserved) K. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS Secs. 4396S - 4398S (Reserved) Sec. 4399S General Provision on Sanctions Unless otherwise provided, any violation of the provisions of this Part shall be subject to the sanctions provided in Sections 34, 35, 36 and 37 of R.A. No. 7653, whenever applicable. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§4401S - 4401S.2 14.12.31 PART FOUR BSP REGULATIONS ON FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION A. CONSUMER PROTECTION OVERSIGHT FUNCTION Section 4401S Consumer Protection Oversight Function. The Board of Directors (Board) of BSFIs is ultimately responsible in ensuring that consumer protection practices are embedded in the BSFI’s business operations. BSFIs must adhere to the highest service standards and embrace a culture of fair and responsible dealings in the conduct of their business through the adoption of a BSFI’s Financial Consumer Protection Framework that is appropriate to the BSFI’s corporate structure, operations, and risk profile. The BSFI’s Financial Consumer Protection Framework shall be embodied in its Board-approved Financial Consumer Protection Manual. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4401S.1 Role and responsibility of the board and senior management. The board and senior management are responsible for developing the BSFI’s consumer protection strategy and establishing an effective oversight over the BSFI’s consumer protection programs. The Board shall be primarily responsible for approving and overseeing the implementation of the BSFI’s consumer protection policies as well as the mechanism to ensure compliance with said policies. While senior management is responsible for the implementation of the consumer protection policies approved by the Board, the latter shall be responsible for monitoring and overseeing the performance of senior management in managing the day to day consumer protection activities of the BSFI. The Board may also delegate other duties and responsibilities to senior management and/or Committees created for the purpose but not the function of overseeing compliance with the BSP-prescribed Consumer Protection Framework and the BSFI’s own Consumer Protection Framework. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4401S.2 Consumer Protection Risk Management System (CPRMS) All BSFIs, regardless of size, should have a CPRMS that is part of the corporate-wide Risk Management System. The CPRMS is a means by which a BSFI identifies, measures, monitors, and controls consumer protection risks inherent in its operations. These include both risks to the financial consumer and the BSFI. The CPRMS should be directly proportionate to the BSFI’s asset size, structure, and complexity of operation. A carefully devised, implemented, and monitored CPRMS provides the foundation for ensuring an BSFI’s adherence to consumer protection standards of conduct and compliance with consumer protection laws, rules and regulations, thus ensuring that the BSFI’s consumer protection practices address and prevent identified risks to the BSFI and associated risk of financial harm or loss to consumers. a. Board and senior management oversight. The Board is responsible for developing and maintaining a sound CPRMS that is integrated into the overall framework for the entire product and service life-cycle. The Board and Senior Management should periodically review the effectiveness of the CPRMS, including how findings are reported and whether the audit mechanisms in place Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 1 § 4401S.2 14.12.31 enable adequate oversight. The quality and timeliness of the information provided to the Board and Senior Management regarding the BSFI’s CPRMS are especially important for assessing the program’s effectiveness. The Board and Senior Management must also ensure that sufficient resources have been devoted to the program. The ability to achieve the consumer protection objectives depends, in large part, on the authority and independence of the individuals directly responsible for implementing the CPRMS and for performing audit/review activities, and the support provided by the Board and Senior Management. The Board and Senior Management must also make certain that CPRMS weaknesses are addressed and corrective actions are taken in a timely manner. b. Compliance program. A Consumer Protection Compliance Program is an essential component of the CPRMS. The BSFIs should establish a formal, written Consumer Protection Compliance Program that is part of the over-all Compliance System and should be in accordance with the Revised Compliance Framework for Banks under Sec. 4180Q. A well planned, implemented, and maintained Consumer Protection Compliance Program should prevent or reduce regulatory violations and protect consumers from non-compliance and associated harms or loss. c. Policies and procedures. An effective CPRMS should have consumer protection policies and procedures in place, approved by the Board. A comprehensive and fully implemented policies help to communicate the board’s and senior management’s commitment to compliance as well as expectations. Overall, policies and procedures should a) be consistent with Consumer Protection policies approved by the Board; b) ensure that consumer protection practices are embedded in the S Regulations Part IV - Page 2 BSFI’s business operations; 3) address compliance with consumer protection laws, rules, and regulations; and 4) reviewed periodically and kept-to-date as it serve as reference for employees in their day-to-day activities. d. Internal audit function Independent of the compliance function, the BSFI’s Audit Function should review its consumer protection practices, adherence to internal policies and procedures, and compliance with existing laws, rules and regulations. The BSFI’s internal audit of the different business units/functions should include the consumer protection audit program. A well-designed and implemented consumer protection audit program ensures that the Board or its designated Committee shall be able to make an assessment on the effectiveness of implementation as well as adequacy of approved policies and standards in meeting the established consumer protection objectives. e. Training. Continuing education of personnel about consumer protection laws, rules and regulations as well as related bank policies and procedures is essential to maintaining a sound consumer protection compliance program. BSFIs should ensure that all relevant personnel, specifically those whose roles and responsibilities have customer interface, receive specific and comprehensive training that reinforces and helps implement written policies and procedures on consumer protection. The BSFI should institute a consumer protection training program that is appropriate to its organization structure and the activities it engages. The training program should be able to address changes in consumer protection laws, rules and regulations and to policies and procedures and should be provided in a timely manner. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§4402S - 4402S.1 14.12.31 B. CONSUMER PROTECTION STANDARDS OF CONDUCT FOR BSFIS Sec. 4402S Consumer Protection Standards. The following consumer protection standards reflect the core principles, which BSFIs are expected to observe at all times in their dealings with financial consumers. These should be embedded into the corporate culture of the BSFI, enhancing further its defined governance framework while addressing conflicts that are inimical to the interests of the financial consumer. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4402S.1 Disclosure and transparency BSFIs must take affirmative action to ensure that their consumers have a reasonable holistic understanding of the products and services, which they may be acquiring or availing. In this context, full disclosure and utmost transparency are the critical elements that empower the consumer to make informed financial decisions. This is made possible by providing the consumer with ready access to information that accurately represents the nature and structure of the product or service, its terms and conditions, as well as its fundamental benefits and risks. The BSFI demonstrates the competencies required of this principle if it complies with the following: a. Key information (1) Ensures that offering documents of products and services contain the information necessary for customers to be able to make an informed judgment of the product or service and, in particular, meet the full disclosure requirements specified under existing laws or regulations. All key features and risks of the products should be highlighted prominently in a succinct manner. Where a product is being offered on a continuous basis, its offering documents should be updated in accordance with the requirements set out in the regulations. (2) Readily and consistently makes available to the customer a written copy of the terms and conditions (T&C) that apply to a product or service. The contents of the T&C must be fully disclosed and explained to financial customers before initiating a transaction. Where and when warranted, reference to the T&C should be made while transacting with the consumer and before consummating the transaction, if such reference is material to the understanding of the consumer of the nature of the product or service, as well as its benefits and risks. As a written document, the T&C must be complete but concise, easily understandable, accurate, and presented in a manner that facilitates the consumer’s comprehension. The latter is taken to mean that the text of the document should be according to Subsec. 4320Q.4 (Amended Regulations to Enhance Consumer Protection in the Credit Card Operations of Banks and Their Subsidiary or Affiliate Credit Card Companies). The T&C should include at least the following: (a) The full price or cost to the customer including all interest, fees, charges, and penalties. The T&C must clearly state whether interest, fees, charges, and penalties can change over time. The method for computing said interest, fees, charges, and penalties shall be presented in accordance with Subsec. 4305S.6; (b) General information about the operation of the products or services including the customer’s obligations and liabilities; (c) Cooling-off period, if applicable; (d) Cancellation, return and exchange policies, and any related cost; (e) The actions and remedies which the BSFI may take in the event of a default by the customer; Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 3 § 4402S.1 14.12.31 (f) Procedures to report unauthorized transactions and other contingencies, as well as the liabilities of parties in such case; and (g) A summary of the BSFI’s complaints handling procedure. (3) Advises customers to read and understand the applicable T&C, when considering a product or service. (4) Ensures that its staff communicates in such a manner that clients can understand the terms of the contract, their rights and obligations. Staff should communicate with techniques that address literacy limitations (e.g., materials are available in local language). (5) Provides customers adequate time to review the T&C of the product or service, asks questions and receives additional information prior to signing contracts or executing the transaction. The staff of the BSFI should be available to answer the questions and clarifications from the financial customer. (6) Ensures that staff assigned to deal directly with customers, or who prepare advertisement materials (or other material of the BSFI for external distribution) or who markets any product or service should be fully knowledgeable about these products and services, including statutory and regulatory requirements, and are able to explain the nuances to the consumer. (7) Uses a variety of communication channels to disclose clear and accurate information. Such communication channels should be available to the public without need for special access requirements, which may entail additional expense. Communication channels should be sufficiently responsive to address the literacy limitations of the financial consumer. Said channels may be written and/or verbal as may be warranted. (8) Discloses pricing information in public domains (e.g., websites). (9) Updates customers with relevant information, free of charge in a clear, S Regulations Part IV - Page 4 understandable, comprehensive, and transparent manner, for the duration of the contract. Such information covers the characteristics and the risks of the products sold by the BSFI and their authorized agents. (10) Imparts targeted information to the specific groups of clients to whom specific products are being marketed, with a particular consideration for vulnerable customers. Communication channels employed for such targeted marketing initiatives may be accordingly calibrated. (11) Offers enhanced disclosure for more complex products, highlighting the costs and risks involved for the customer. For structured investment products, a Product Highlight Sheet (PHS) is required. The PHS should be clear, concise, and easily understandable by individual customers. It should contain information that empowers the customer to appreciate the key features of the product and its risks. It is prepared in a format that facilitates comparison with other products. The PHS should be available at no cost to the public and made available to consumers upon request. Before signing any contract, the BSFI should ensure that the customer has freely signed a statement to the effect that the customer has duly received, read, and understood the PHS. (12) Notifies the customer in writing of any change in: (a) Interest rate to be paid or charged on any account of the customer as soon as possible; and (b) A non-interest charge on any account of the customer within a number of days as provided under existing regulations prior to the effective date of the change. If the revised terms are not acceptable to the customer, he or she should have the right to exit the contract without penalty, provided such right is exercised within a reasonable period. The customer should Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§4402S.1 - 4402S.2 14.12.31 be informed of this right whenever a notice of change is made. (13) Provides customers with a proof of the transaction immediately after the transaction has been completed. The customer should be given a hard copy of each of the documents signed by the clients (including, but not limited to, the contract) with all terms and conditions. The BSFI ensures that documents signed by the customer are completely filled and that there are no blank terms. (14) Regularly provides customers with clear and accurate information regarding their accounts (e.g., Statement of accounts that includes, among others, covering period, opening balance/value of transactions, all kinds of interest, fees and charges, closing balance, inquiries for outstanding balances, proof of payments for loans). (15) Informs customers of their rights and responsibilities including their right to complain and the manner of its submission. b. Advertising and promotional materials (1) Ensures that advertising and marketing materials do not make false, misleading, or deceptive statements that may materially and/or adversely affect the decision of the customer to avail of a service or acquire a product. (2) Ensures that advertising and promotional materials are easily readable and understandable by the general public. It should disclose clear, accurate, updated, and relevant information about the product or service. It should be balanced/ proportional (reflecting both advantages and risks of the product or service); visible/ audible; key information is prominent and not obscured; print is of sufficient size and clearly legible. (3) Ensures that promotional materials are targeted according to the specific groups of consumers to whom products are marketed and the communication channels employed for marketing financial services. (4) Ensures that all advertising and promotional materials disclose the fact that it is a regulated entity and that the name and contact details of the regulator are indicated. c. Conflict of interest (1) Discloses properly to the consumer prior to the execution of the transaction that the BSFI or its staff has an interest in a direct/ cross transaction with a consumer. (2) Discloses the limited availability of products to consumers when the BSFI only recommends products which are issued by their related companies, particularly when commissions or rebates are the primary basis for recommending the particular product to consumers. (3) Discloses the basis on which the BSFI is remunerated at the pre-contractual stage. (4) Ensures that adequate systems and controls are in place to promptly identify issues and matters that may be detrimental to a customer’s interest (e.g., cases in which advice may have been given merely to meet sales targets, or may be driven by financial or other incentives). (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4402S.2 Protection of client information. Financial consumers have the right to expect that their financial transactions, as well as relevant personal information disclosed in the course of a transaction, are kept confidential. Towards this end, BSFIs must ensure that they have well-articulated information security guidelines, well-defined protocols, a secured database, and periodically re-validated procedures in handling the personal information of their financial consumers. This should be an end-to-end process that should cover, among others, the array of information that will be pre-identified and collected, the purpose of gathering each information, how these will be Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 5 § 4402S.2 14.12.31 sourced from the client, the IT-security infrastructure of the BSFI, and the protocols for disclosure, both within the BSFI and especially to third parties. The BSFI demonstrates the ability to protect client information if it is able to: a. Confidentiality and security of client information (1) Have a written privacy policy to safeguard its customers’ personal information. This policy should govern the gathering, processing, use, distribution, storage, and eventual disposal of client information. The BSFI should ensure that privacy policies and sanctions for violations are implemented and strictly enforced. (2) Ensure that privacy policies are regularly communicated throughout the organization. Opportunities include employees’ initial training sessions, regular organization-wide training programs, employee handbooks, posters and posted signs, company intranet and internet websites, and brochures available to clients. (3) Have appropriate systems in place to protect the confidentiality and security of the personal data of its customers against any threat or hazard to the security or integrity of the information and against unauthorized access. This includes a written information security plan that describes its program to protect customer personal information. The plan must be appropriate to its size and complexity, nature and scope of its activities, and the sensitivity of customer information it handles. As part of its plan, the BSFI must: (a) Designate employee accountable to coordinate its Information Security Program. (b) Identify and assess the risks to customer information in each relevant area of the BSFI operation, and evaluate the effectiveness of the current safeguards for controlling these risks. (c) Design and implement a safeguards program, and regularly monitor and test it. S Regulations Part IV - Page 6 (d) Select service providers that can maintain appropriate safeguards. (e) Evaluate and adjust the program in light of relevant circumstances, including changes in the firm’s business or operations, or the results of security testing and monitoring. (4) Have appropriate policies and practices for employee management and training to assess and address the risks to customer information. These include: (a) Checking references and doing background checks before hiring employees who will have access to customer information. (b) Asking new employees to sign an agreement to follow BSFI confidentiality and security standards for handling customer information. (c) Limiting access to customer information to employees who have a business reason to see it. (d) Controlling access to sensitive information by requiring employees to use “strong” passwords that must be changed on a regular basis. (e) Using automatic time-out or log-off controls to lock employee computers after a period of inactivity. (f) Training employees to take basic steps to maintain the security, confidentiality, and integrity of customer information. These may include locking rooms and file cabinets where records are kept; ensuring that employee passwords are not posted in work areas; encrypting sensitive customer information when transmitted electronically via public networks; referring calls or other requests for customer information to designated individuals who have been trained in how BSFI safeguards personal data; and reporting suspicious attempts to obtain customer information to designated personnel. (g) Regularly reminding all employees of company policy to keep customer information secured and confidential. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4402S.2 - 4402S.3 14.12.31 (h) Imposing strong disciplinary measures for security policy violations. (i) Preventing terminated employees from accessing customer information by immediately deactivating their passwords and user names and taking other measures. (5) Have a strong IT System in place to protect the confidentiality, security, accuracy, and integrity of customer’s personal information. This includes network and software design, and information processing, storage, transmission, retrieval, and disposal. Maintaining security throughout the lifecycle of customer information, from data entry to disposal, includes: (a) Knowing where sensitive customer information is stored and storing it securely. Make sure only authorized employees have access. (b) Taking steps to ensure the secure transmission of customer information. (c) Disposing customer information in a secure way. (d) Maintaining up-to-date and appropriate programs and controls to prevent unauthorized access. (e) Using appropriate oversight or audit procedures to detect the improper disclosure or theft of customer information. (f) Having a security breach response plan in the event the BSFI experiences a data breach. b. Sharing of customer information (1) Inform its customers in writing and explain clearly to customers as to how it will use and share the customer’s personal information. (2) Obtain the customers’ written consent, unless in situations allowed as an exception by law or BSP-issued regulations on confidentiality of customer’s information, before sharing customers’ personal information with third parties such as credit bureau, collection agencies, marketing and promotional partners, and other relevant external parties. (3) Provide access to customers to the information shared and should allow customers to challenge the accuracy and completeness of the information and have these amended as appropriate. (4) Appropriate penalties should be imposed by the BSFI to erring employees for exposing or revealing client data to third parties without prior written consent from client. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4402S.3 Fair treatment. Fair treatment ensures that financial consumers are treated fairly, honestly, professionally and are not sold inappropriate and harmful financial products and services. BSFIs should ensure they have the necessary resources and procedures in place, internal monitoring, and control mechanisms, for safeguarding the best interest of their customers. These include general rules, such as those addressing ethical staff behavior, acceptable selling practices as well as regulating products and practices where customers are more likely to be offered services that are inappropriate for their circumstances. The BSFI demonstrates the principle of fair treatment towards financial consumers if it is able to: a. Affordability and suitability of product or service (1) When making a recommendation to a consumer: (a) Gather, file, and record sufficient information from the customer to enable the BSFI to offer an appropriate product or service to the customer. The information gathered should be commensurate to the nature and complexity of the product or service either being proposed to or sought by the customer and should enable the BSFI to provide an appropriate level of Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 7 § 4402S.3 14.12.31 professional service. As a minimum, information includes the customers’ financial knowledge and experience, financial capabilities, investment objectives, time horizons, needs, priorities, risk affordability, and risk profile. (b) Offer products or services that are in line with the needs/risk profile of the consumer. The BSFI should provide for and allow the customer to choose from a range of available products and services that can meet his needs and requirements. Sufficient and right information on the product or service should enable the customer to select the most suitable and affordable product or service. (2) Inform or warn the customers that if they do not provide sufficient information regarding their financial knowledge and experience, the BSFI is not in a position to accurately determine whether the product or service is appropriate to them, given the limited information available. This information or warning may be provided in a standardized format. (3) Ensure that the customer certifies in writing the accuracy of the personal information provided. (4) Ensure to offer market-based pricing. (5) Design products that are appropriate to the varying needs and interests of different types of consumers, particularly the more vulnerable consumers. Adequate product approval should be in place. Processes should be proper to ensure that products and services are fit for the targeted consumer. (6) Do not engage in abusive or deceptive acts or practices. (7) Seek customer feedback for product design and delivery and use this feedback to enhance product development and improve existing products. Likewise, investigate reasons for client drop out. S Regulations Part IV - Page 8 (8) Do not use high pressure/aggressive sales techniques and do not force clients to sign contracts. (9) Have a system in place for approval when selling high-risk instruments to consumers. b. Prevention of over-indebtedness (1) Have appropriate policies for good repayment capacity analysis. The loan approval does not rely solely on guarantees (co-signers or collateral) as a substitute for good capacity analysis. (2) Properly assess the creditworthiness and conduct appropriate client repayment capacity analysis when offering a new credit product or service significantly increasing the amount of debt assumed by the customer. (3) Ensure to have an appropriate system in place for credit analysis and decisions including appropriate criteria to limit the amount of credit. (4) Monitor enforcement of policies to prevent over-indebtedness. The Board and Senior Management of the BSFIs should be aware of and concerned about the risks of over-indebtedness of its customers. (5) Draw the customer’s attention to the consequences of signing a contract that may affect his financial position and his collateral in case of default in payment of a loan/obligation. (6) Prepare and submit appropriate reports (e.g., loan quality, write-offs, restructured loans) to management. (7) Ensure that corrective measures are in place for poor long-term quality of loan portfolio linked to over-indebtedness. (8) Have specific procedures to actively work out solutions (i.e., through workout plan) for restructured loans/refinancing/ writing-off on exceptional basis for clients in default who have the “willingness” but without the capacity to repay, prior to seizing the assets. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions § 4402S.3 14.12.31 c. Cooling-off period (1) As may be appropriate, provide the customer with a “cooling-off” period of a reasonable number of days (at least two (2) banking days) immediately following the signing of any agreement or contract, particularly for financial products or services with a long-term savings component or those subject to high pressure sales contracts. (2) Permit the customer to cancel or treat the agreement as null and void without penalty to the customer of any kind on his or her written notice to the BSFI during the cooling-off period. The BSFI may however collect or recover reasonable amount of processing fees. It is further recognized that there may be a need for some qualification to an automatic right of cooling off. For example, the right should not apply where there has been a drawdown of a credit facility and a BSFI should be able to recover any loss arising from an early withdrawal of a fixed rate term deposit which loss arises because of a difference in interest rates. This would be in addition to any reasonable administrative fees associated with closure of the term deposit. d. Objectivity (1) Deal fairly, honestly, and in good faith with customers and avoid making statements that are untrue or omitting information which are necessary to prevent the statement from being false or misleading. (2) Present a balanced view when selling a product or service. While the BSFI highlights the advantages of a product/ service, the customer’s attention should also be drawn to its disadvantages and downside risks. (3) Ensure that recommendations made to customer are clearly justified and explained to the customer and are properly documented. If the requested products are of higher risk rating than a customer’s risk tolerance assessment results, the BSFI should draw to the customer’s attention that the product may not be suitable for him in view of the risk mismatch. In such instances, there should be a written disclosure of consequences which is accepted by the client. (4) Ensure that the customer’s suitability and affordability are assessed against specific risks of the investment products: (a) Financial Needs Analysis (FNA) and Client Suitability - to assess the customer’s risk profile and suitability of the product. (b) Customer’s Declaration Form - to confirm his acceptance and understanding of the highlighted features of the product. (c) FNA, Client Suitability and Declaration Form should be duly completed to make sure that the product sold is suitable and affordable for the customer. e. Institutional culture of fair and responsible treatment of clients (1) There should be a Code of Conduct (Code) applicable to all staff, spelling out the organizational values and standards of professional conduct that uphold protection of customers. This Code should be reviewed and approved by the Board. The staff signs a document by which they acknowledge that they will abide by the Code and not engage in the behaviors prohibited as provided for in the Code. To ensure adherence to the Code, the BSFI is required to implement measures to determine whether the principles of consumer protection are observed, the clients’ concerns are appropriately addressed and problems are resolved in a timely manner. These may include among others, the regular conduct of customer satisfaction survey. (2) Ensure that recruitment and training policies are aligned around fair and responsible treatment of clients. (3) Ensure that staff, specifically those who interact directly with customers, receive adequate training suitable for the Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV -Page 9 § 4402S.3 - 4402S.4 14.12.31 complexity of the products or services they sell. (4) Ensure that collection practices are covered during the initial training of all staff involved in collections (loan officers, collections staff, and branch managers). In particular, collection staff should receive training in acceptable debt collection practices and loan recovery procedures. (5) Strictly comply with BSP’s existing regulation on what constitutes unfair debt collection practices. The BSFI’s Code of Conduct should clearly spell out the specific standards of professional conduct that are expected of all staff involved in collection (including outsourced staff). (6) Institute policy that guarantees that clients receive a fair price for any foreclosed assets and has procedures to ensure that collateral seizing is respectful of clients’ rights. (7) Ensure that Managers and Supervisors review ethical behavior, professional conduct, and quality of interaction with customers as part of staff performance evaluations. (8) Have a system or internal processes in place to detect and respond to customer mistreatment as well as serious infractions. In case of violation of Code of Conduct (e.g., harassment), sanctions shall be enforced. (9) Inform staff of penalties for noncompliance with Code of Conduct. (10) Perform appropriate due diligence before selecting the authorized agents/ outsourced parties (such as taking into account the agents’ integrity, professionalism, financial soundness, operational capability and capacity, and compatibility with the FI’s corporate culture) and implement controls to monitor the agents’ performance on a continuous basis. The BSFI retains ultimate accountability for outsourced activities. (11) Disseminate the main aspect of the Code of Conduct to clients through printed media or other appropriate means. S Regulations Part IV - Page 10 f. Remuneration Structure (1) Design remuneration structure for staff of BSFI and authorized agents in a manner that encourages responsible business conduct, fair treatment and avoidance/mitigation of conflicts of interest. (2) Disclose to the customers the remuneration structure where appropriate, such as when potential conflicts of interest cannot be managed or avoided. (3) Ensure adequate procedures and controls so that sales staff are not remunerated based solely on sales performance but that other factors, including customer’s satisfaction (in terms of number of customer complaints served/settled) and compliance with regulatory requirements, best practices guidelines, and Code of Conduct in which certain principles are related to best interest of customers, satisfactory audit/compliance review results and complaint investigation results, are taken into account. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4402S.4 Effective Recourse. Financial consumers should be provided with accessible, affordable, independent, fair, accountable, timely, and efficient means for resolving complaints with their financial transactions. BSFIs should have in place mechanisms for complaint handling and redress. The BSFI demonstrates the ability to provide effective recourse if it is able to: a. Establish an effective Consumer Assistance Management System (CAMS). Appendix S-10 provides for the minimum requirements of an effective CAMS. b. Develop internal policies and practices, including time for processing, complaint response, and customer access. c. Maintain an up-to-date log and records of all complaints from customers subject to the complaints procedure. This log must contain the following: (1) Details of each complaint; Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4402S.4 - 4402S.5 14.12.31 (2) The date the complaint was received; (3) A summary of the BSFI’s response; (4) Details of any other relevant correspondence or records; (5) The action taken to resolve each complaint; and (6) The date the complaint was resolved. d. Ensure that information on how to make a complaint is clearly visible in the BSFI’s premises and on their websites. e. Undertake an analysis of the patterns of complaints from customers on a regular basis including investigating whether complaints indicate an isolated issue or a more widespread issue for consumers. This analysis of consumer complaints must be escalated to the BSFI’s compliance/risk management function and senior management. f. Provide for adequate resources to handle financial consumer complaints efficiently and effectively. Staff handling complaints should have appropriate experience, knowledge, and expertise. Depending on the BSFI’s size and complexity of operation, a Senior staff member should be appointed to be in charge of the complaint handling process. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) §4402S.5 Financial education and awareness. Financial education initiatives give consumers the knowledge, skills, and confidence to understand and evaluate the information they receive and empower them to make informed financial decisions. Because BSFIs deal directly with financial consumers, they have the reach, expertise, and established relationships necessary to deliver financial education. Financial education should be integral to the good governance of the BSFIs. The BSFI demonstrates this principle through various means and in particular: a. Have a clear and defined financial education and awareness program as part of a wider financial consumer protection and education strategy and corporate governance. It is an integral component of the BSFI’s ongoing interaction and relationship with clients. Dedicated and adequate resources should be provided for the financial education initiatives. b. Develop financial education and awareness programs, either on their own or in partnership or collaboration with industry associations, which contribute to the improvement of their clients’ knowledge and understanding of their rights and responsibilities, basic information and risks of financial products and services, and ability to make informed financial decisions and participate in economic activities. Financial education programs should be designed to meet the needs and financial literacy level of target audiences, as well as those that will reflect how target audience prefers to receive financial information. These may include: (1) Delivering public awareness campaigns and information resources that would teach consumers on certain aspects of their financial lives particularly, budgeting, financial planning, saving, investing, borrowing, retirement planning, and selfprotection against fraud. (2) Developing financial education tools or information materials that are updated and readily understood and transparent such as customized advice and guidance (face to face training); printed brochures, flyers, posters, training videos (e.g., about money management, debt management, saving), and newsletters; websites, and interactive calculators that deliver key messages and “call to action” concerning better money management (e.g., protect your money, know your product, read and understand the T&C, check your statements, pay credit card bills on time, safeguard your Personal Identification Number, understand fees and charges) and consumer responsibility to ask the right questions. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 11 §§ 4402S.5 - 4403S 14.12.31 (3) Distributing to customers, at the point of sale, a pamphlet on questions, which customers need to ask before accepting a financial product or service. c. Clearly distinguish between financial education from commercial advice. Any financial advice for business purposes should be transparent. Disclose clearly any commercial nature where it is also being promoted as a financial education initiative. It should train staff on financial education and develop codes of conduct for the provision of general advice about investments and borrowings, not linked to the supply of a specific product. d. Provide via the internet or through printed publications unbiased and independent information to consumers through comparative information about the price and other key features, benefits and risks, and associated fees and charges of products and services. e. Regularly track, monitor, and assess campaigns and programs and use the results of the evaluation for continuous improvement. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) C. ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS Section 4403S Enforcement Actions a. Enforcement is the implementation of corrective measures and imposition of sanctions to BSFIs to: (1) Ensure compliance with the BSP regulations on consumer protection and consumer protection laws and regulations; (2) Inform the management of the BSFIs of the consequences of their decisions and actions; (3) Instill discipline to the BSFIs; and (4) Serve as deterrent to the commission of violations. b. The bases for enforcement actions are the results of the: (1) On-site consumer protection framework assessment; (2) Off-site surveillance; S Regulations Part IV - Page 12 (3) Market monitoring; and (4) Bangko Sentral Consumer Assistance Mechanism c. The following enforcement action may be taken depending on: (1) Rating-based enforcement actions for on-site periodic assessment. To implement the foregoing enforcement actions, the following rules shall apply: (a) A Consumer Protection Rating (CPR) of 4 will require no enforcement action. (b) A CPR of 3 will require issuance of a written reminder on consumer protection areas that may lead to weaknesses in the BSFI’s Consumer Protection Framework. (c) A CPR of 2 will require a written Action Plan in response to the written reminder issued by the BSP. The written Action Plan shall be duly approved by the Board. It shall aim to correct the identified weaknesses in the BSFI’s Consumer Protection Framework or the noted violations of the BSP Regulations on Consumer Protection. FCPD shall assess the viability of the plan and shall monitor the BSFI’s performance. (d) A CPR of 1 shall also be considered as poor/grossly inadequate Financial Consumer Protection Framework. For this reason, a written action plan fully executable within ninety (90) days shall be prepared. The action plan shall be duly approved by the Board aimed at instituting immediate and strong measures to restore the BSFI to acceptable consumer protection operating condition, where it does not pose any risk of financial loss or harm to the financial consumers. In the event of non-submission of the written Action Plan within the deadline or failure to implement its action plan, FCPD shall recommend appropriate enforcement actions on the BSFI and its responsible officers including monetary penalties to be computed on a daily basis until improvements are satisfactorily implemented. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4403S - 4499S 14.12.31 Numerical Rating Adjectival Rating Supervisory Approach Enforcement Action 4 Composite Rating 3 Strong Acceptable No cause for supervisory concern Minimal supervisory concern None Written reminder 2 1 Marginal More than normal supervisory concern Written action plan Poor Immediate and close supervisory attention and monitoring Written action plan Suspension of introduction of new products and services or suspension of existing products/services that poses a consumer protection concern or suspension of further distribution or Issuance of consumer products and services Table No. 2. Enforcement Actions for Consumer Protection Ratings d. Enforcement actions for violations of consumer protection regulations Depending on the seriousness and impact of the breaches of Bangko Sentral Regulations on consumer protection and specific consumer protection rules and regulations, the following administrative sanctions shall be imposed: Administrative sanctions Whenever applicable, the following administrative sanctions shall be imposed: · Fines in amount as may be determined by the Monetary Board to be appropriate; ·Stopping/suspending operations/products or restricting approval of new operations/products; ·Requiring the withdrawal/modification of advertising/ marketing materials; and ·Requiring submission of additional reports for monitoring. Table No. 3. Administrative Sanctions for Violations of Consumer Protection Regulations. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) Secs. 4404S - 4499S (Reserved) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part IV - Page 13 §§ 4501S - 4599S 08.12.31 PART FIVE Sections 4501S - 4599S (Reserved) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part V - Page 1 §§ 4601S - 4601S.1 09.12.31 PART SIX MISCELLANEOUS A. OTHER OPERATIONS Section 4601S Fines and Other Charges. The following regulations shall govern imposition of monetary penalties on NSSLAs, their trustees and/or officers and payment of such penalties or fines and other charges by NSSLAs. (As amended by Circualr No. 585 dated 15 October 2007) § 4601S.1 Guidelines on the imposition of monetary penalties; payment of penalties or fines. The following are the guidelines on the imposition of monetary penalties on NSSLAs, their trustees and/or officers and the payment of such penalties or fines and other charges: a. Definition of terms. For purposes of the imposition of monetary penalties, the following definitions are adopted: (1) Continuing offenses/violations are acts, ommisions or transactions entered into, in violation of laws, BSP rules and regulations, Monetary Board directives, and orders of the Governor which persist from the time the particular acts were committed or omitted or the transactions were entered into until the same were corrected/rectified by subsequent acts or transactions. They shall be penalized on a per calendar day basis from the time the acts were committed/omitted or the transactions were effected up to the time they were corrected/rectified. (2) Transactional offenses/violations are acts, omissions or transactions entered into in violation of laws, BSP rules and regulations, Monetary Board directives, and orders of the Governor which cannot be corrected/rectified by subsuquent acts or transactions. They shall be meted with one (1)-time monetary penalty on a per transaction basis. (3) Continuing penalty refers to the monetary penalty imposed on continuing offenses/violations on a per calendar day basis reckoned from the time the offense/ violation occurred or was committed until the same was corrected/rectified. (4) Transactional penalty refers to a one (1)-time penalty imposed on a transactional offense/violation. b. Basis for the computation of the period or duration of penalty. The computation of the period or duration of all penalties shall be based on calendar days. For this purpose the terms “per banking day”, “per business day”, “per day” and/or “a day” as used in this Manual, and other BSP rules and regulations shall mean “per calendar day” and/or “calendar day” as the case may be. c. Additional charge for late payment of monetary penalty. Late payment of monetary penalty shall be subject to an additional charge of six percent (6%) per annum to be reckoned from the business day immediately following the day said penalty becomes due and payable up to the day of actual payment. d. Appeal or request for reconsideration. A one (1)-time appeal or request for reconsideration on the monetary penalty approved by the Governor/Monetary Board to be imposed on the NSSLA, its directors and/or officers shall be allowed: Provided, That the same is filed with the appropriate department of the SES within fifteen (15) calendar days from receipt of the Statement of Account/billing letter. The appropriate department of the SES shall evaluate the appeal or request for reconsideration of Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part VI - Page 1 §§ 4601S.1 - 4631S 09.12.31 the NSSLA/individual and make recommendations thereon within thirty (30) calendar days from receipt thereof. The appeal or request for reconsideration on the monetary penalty approved by the Governor/Monetary Board shall be elevated to the Monetary Board for resolution/ decision. The running of the penalty period in case of continuing penalty and/or the period for computing additonal charge shall be interrupted from the time the appeal or request for reconsideration was received by the appropriate department of the SES up to the time that the notice of the Monetary Board decision was received by the NSSLA/ individual concerned. e. Due date; payment of penalty or fines. The penalty approved by the Governor/MB to be imposed on the NSSLA, its directors and/or officers shall become due and payable fifteen (15) calendar days from receipt of the Statement of Account from the BSP. For NSSLAs which maintain DDA with the BSP, penalties which remain unpaid after the lapse of the fifteen-day period shall be automatically debited against their corresponding DDA on the following business day without additional charge. If the balance of the concerned NSSLA’s DDA is insufficient to cover the amount of the penalty, said penalty shall already be subject to an additional charge of six percent (6%) per annum to be reckoned from the business day immediately following the end of said fifteen (15)-day period up to the day of actual payment. Failure to settle the full amount of the fines within the period or on the day prescribed herein shall, in addition to the additonal penalty as provided in item “c” above, make an NSSLA, its trustees and officers liable to the sanctions imposed under Sec. 4199S. (As amended by Circular Nos. 662 dated 09 September 2009 and 585 dated 15 October 2007) Secs. 4602S - 4630S (Reserved) S Regulations Part VI - Page 2 Sec. 4631S Revocation/Suspension of Non-Stock Savings and Loan Association License. In reference to Section 22 of R.A. No. 8367 or the “Revised Non-Stock Savings and Loan Association Act of 1997”, the Monetary Board, upon due notice and hearing, has the authority to either revoke or suspend the license of any NSSLA for such period as it deems necessary, based on any of the following grounds: a. Suspension of license: (1) Repeated violations [uncorrected similar examination findings for the last two (2) examinations, regular or special] of any of the provisions of R.A. No. 8367, and/or any rules or regulations promulgated to implement said law, or BSP directives and/or instructions; and (2) Paid-up capital is impaired by continuing losses for the last two (2) fiscal years. Lifting of the suspension of license shall be approved by the Monetary Board upon recommendation of the appropriate BSP supervising department. b. Revocation of license: (1) When the solvency of the NSSLA is imperiled by losses and irregularities; (2) When the NSSLA willfully violates any provision of R.A. No. 8367, any rule or regulation promulgated to implement said law and BSP directives and/or instructions; (3) When the NSSLA is conducting business in an unsafe and unsound manner; (4) When it is unable to pay its liabilities as they become due in the ordinary course of business; (5) When it has insufficient realizable assets, as determined by the BSP, to meet its liabilities; (6) When it cannot continue in business without involving probable losses to its members or creditors; and (7) When it has willfully violated a cease and desist order of the Monetary Board involving acts or transactions which amount to fraud or a dissipation of assets of the institution. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4631S - 4642S.2 09.12.31 As to the effects of the revocation/ suspension of license of the NSSLA, the NSSLA is prohibited from engaging in the business of accumulating the savings of its members and using such accumulations for loans to its members, subject to applicable sanctions and penalties provided by law in case of violation thereof. After the cessation of its operations due to revocation of its license, the NSSLA should proceed with its dissolution, in acccordance with the provisions under the Corporation Code. The dissolution of a corporation involves the termination of its corporate existence, at least, as far as the right to go on doing ordinary business is concerned, and the winding up of its affairs, the payments of its debts and distribution of its assets among the members or stakeholders or other persons involved. The board of trustees of the corporation also has the option of adopting a plan for the distribution of its assets, as stated under Section 95 of the Corporation Code. After the revocation/suspension of its license, the Monetary Board may direct the board of trustees of the NSSLA to proceed with the voluntary dissolution of the corporation. In the event that the board of trustees refuses to effectuate such dissolution, the Monetary Board may refer the matter to the Solicitor General for the filing of a quo warranto case against the corporation in accordance with the provisions of the Corporation Code. Secs. 4632S - 4640S (Reserved) Sec. 4641S Electronic Services. The guidelines concerning electronic activities, as may be applicable, are found in Sec. 4701Q and its Subsections. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) Sec. 4642S Issuance and Operations of Electronic Money. The following guidelines shall govern the issuance of electronic money (e-money) and the operations of electronic money issuers (EMIs). (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.1 Declaration of policy. It is the policy of the BSP to foster the development of efficient and convenient retail payment and fund transfer mechanism in the Philippines. The availability and acceptance of e-money as a retail payment medium will be promoted by providing the necessary safeguards and controls to mitigate the risks associated in an e-money business. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.2 Definitions E-money shall mean monetary value as represented by a claim on its issuer, that is a. electronically stored in an instrument or device; b. issued against receipt of funds of an amount not lesser in value than the monetary value issued; c. accepted as a means of payment by persons or entities other than the issuer; d. withdrawable in cash or cash equivalent; and e. issued in accordance with this Section. Electronic money issuer shall be classified as follows: a. Banks (hereinafter called EMIBank); b. NBFI supervised by the BSP (hereinafter called EMI-NBFI); and c. Non-bank institutions registered with the BSP as a money transfer agent under Sec. 4511N of the MORNBFI (hereinafter called EMI-Others). For purposes of this Section: a. Electronic instruments or devices shall mean cash cards, e-wallets accessible via mobile phones or other access device, stored value cards, and other similar products. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part VI - Page 3 §§ 4642S.2 - 4642S.4 09.12.31 b. E-money issued by NSSLAs shall not be considered as deposits. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.3 Prior Bangko Sentral approval NSSLAs planning to be an EMI-NBFI shall comply with the requirements of Sec. 4641S and with Sec. 4190Q, when applicable. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.4 Common provisions. The following provisions are applicable to all EMIs: a. E-money instrument issued shall be subject to aggregate monthly load limit of P100,000 unless a higher amount has been approved by the BSP. In case an EMI issues several e-money instruments to a person (emoney holder), the total amount loaded in all the e-money instruments shall be consolidated in determining compliance with the aggregate monthly load limit; b. EMIs shall put in place a system to maintain accurate and complete record of e-money instruments issued, the identity of e-money holders, and the individual and consolidated balances thereof. The system must have the capability to monitor the movement of e-money transactions and link e-money instruments issued to common e-money holders. The susceptibility of a system to intentional or unintentional misreporting of transaction and balances shall be sufficient ground for imposition by the BSP of sanctions, as may be applicable. c. E-money may only be redeemed at face value. It shall not earn interest nor rewards and other similar incentives convertible to cash, nor be purchased at a discount. E-money is not considered a deposit, hence, it is not insured with the PDIC. d. EMIs shall not ensure that e-money instruments clearly identify the issuer who is ultimately responsible to the e-money holders. This shall be communicated to the client who shall acknowledge the same in writing. S Regulations Part VI - Page 4 e. It is the responsibility of EMIs to ensure that their distributors/e-money agents comply with all applicable requirements of the Anti-Money Laundering laws, rules and regulations. f. EMIs shall provide an acceptable redress mechanism to address the complaints of its customers. g. EMIs shall disclose in writing and its customers shall signify agreement to the information embodied in Item “c” above upon their participation in the e-money system. In addition, it shall provide clear guidance in English and Filipino on consumers’ right of redemption, including conditions and fees for redemption, if any. Information on available redress procedures for complaints together with the address and contact information of the issuer shall also be provided. h. Prior to the issuance of e-money, EMIs should ensure that the following minimum systems and controls are in place: (1) Sound and prudent management, administrative and accounting procedures and adequate internal control mechanisms; (2) Properly-designed computer systems which are thoroughly tested prior to implementation; (3) Appropriate security policies and measures intended to safeguard the integrity, authenticity and confidentiality of data and operating processes; (4) Adequate business continuity and disaster recovery plan; and (5) Effective audit function to provide periodic review of the security control environment and critical systems. i. EMIs shall provide the SDC quarterly statements containing, among others, information on investments, volume of transactions, total outstanding e-money balances, and liquid assets in such forms as may be prescribed later on. j. EMIs shall notify the BSP in writing of any change or enhancement in the e-money facility thirty (30) days prior to implementation. If said change or Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4642S.4 - 4642S.11 10.12.31 enhancement requires prior Bangko Sentral approval, the same shall be evaluated accordingly. Any change or enhancement that shall expand the scope or change the nature of the e-money instrument shall be subject to prior approval of the Deputy Governor, SES. These changes or enhancements may include the following: (1) Additional capabilities of the e-money instrument/s, like access to new channels (e.g., inclusion of internet channel in addition to merchant Point of Sale terminals); (2) Change in technology service providers and other major partners in the e-money business (excluding partner merchants), if any; and (3) Other changes or enhancements. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.5 Quasi-bank license requirement. EMI-NBFIs and EMI-Others that engage in lending activities must secure a quasi-banking license from the Bangko Sentral. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.6 Sanctions. Monetary penalties and other sanctions for the following violations committed by EMINBFIs shall be imposed: Nature of Violation/ Exception 1. Issuing e-money without prior Bangko Sentral approval 2. Violation of any of the provisions of R.A. No. 9160 (AntiMoney Laundering Law of 2001 as amended by R.A. No. 9194) and its implementing rules and regulations Sanction/Penalties Applicable penalties under Sections 36 & 37 of R.A. No. 7653; Watchlisting of owners/partners/ principal officers Applicable penalties prescribed under the Act Nature of Violation/ Exception 3. Violation/s of this Section Sanction/Penalties Penalties and sanctions under the abovementioned laws and other applicable laws, rules and regulations In addition, the susceptibility of a system to intentional or unintentional misreporting of transactions and balances shall be sufficient ground for appropriate Bangko Sentral action or imposition of sanctions, whenever applicable. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) § 4642S.7 Transitory provisions EMI-NBFIs granted authority to issue e-money prior to 26 March 2009 may continue to exercise such authority: Provided, That it shall submit to the Bangko Sentral, within one (1) month from 26 March 2009 a certification signed by the President or Officer with equivalent rank and function that it is in compliance with all the applicable requirements of this Section. Otherwise, they are required to submit within the same period the measures they will undertake, with the corresponding timelines, to conform to the provisions that they have not complied with, subject to Bangko Sentral approval. (Circular No. 649 dated 09 March 2009) §§ 4642S.8 - 4642S.10 (Reserved) § 4642S.11 Outsourcing of services by Electronic Money Issuers (EMIs) to Electronic Money Network Service Providers (EMNSP). The guidelines on outsourcing of services by Electronic Money Issuers (EMIs) to Electronic Money Network Service Providers (EMNSP) are shown in Appendix Q-55. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part VI - Page 5 §§ 4642S.11 - 4655S 14.12.31 Sanctions. Violations committed by EMIs pertaining to outsourcing activities to EMNSP shall be subject to monetary penalties as graduated under Appendix Q-39 and/or other non-monetary sanctions under Section 37 of RA No. 7653. Transitory provisions. EMIs that were granted an authority to outsource their emoney activities to an EMNSP may continue to exercise such authority provided that they have to conform to the provisions of Appendix Q-55 within a six (6)-month period from 20 January 2011. (Circular 704 dated 22 December 2010) Secs. 4643S - 4649S (Reserved) Sec. 4650S Philippine and Foreign Currency Notes and Coins. The rules and regulations that shall govern the treatment and disposition of counterfeit Philippine and foreign currency notes and coins, the reproduction and/or use of facsimiles of legal tender Philippine currency notes and coins, the replacement and redemption of legal tender Philippine currency notes and coins considered mutilated or unfit for circulation, and the treatment and disposition of Philippine currency notes and coins called in for replacement are provided in Section 4950Q. (Circular No. 829 dated 13 March 2014, M-2009-021 dated 16 June 2009) B. SUNDRY PROVISIONS of the Bangko Sentral: Provided, however, That in the case of NSSLAs under examination, the head of the appropriate department of the SES may furnish findings of examination to the office or firm where such NSSLAs do business. All deposits of whatever nature with NSSLAs are considered absolutely confidential in nature, and may not be examined, inquired or looked into by any person, government official, bureau or office, except upon written permission of the depositor, or in cases of impeachment, or upon order of competent court in cases of bribery or dereliction of duty of public officials or in cases where the money deposited or invested is the subject matter of litigation. No official or employee of NSSLAs shall disclose to any person any information concerning said deposits, except in cases mentioned in the preceding paragraph. Any official or employee of NSSLAs who violates this Section shall be punished under R.A. No. 1405, as amended. Sec. 4653S Examination by the Bangko Sentral. The head of the appropriate department of the SES, personally or by deputy, shall make at least once a year and at such other times as he or the Monetary Board may deem necessary and expedient, an examination, inspection or investigation of the books and records, business affairs, administration and financial condition of NSSLAs. Sec. 4651S Notice of Dissolution NSSLAs contemplating to dissolve shall give written notice thereof to the Monetary Board through the appropriate department of the SES at least thirty (30) days before taking steps to effect dissolution. Sec. 4654S Applicability of Other Rules Other rules and regulations applicable to the examination of thrift banks, insofar as they are applicable and not inconsistent with these rules shall apply to NSSLAs. Sec. 4652S Confidential Information No trustee, officer or employee of NSSLAs or of the Bangko Sentral shall disclose any information relating to member-borrowers and their applications or to the operations of the NSSLAs unless permitted by the Monetary Board Sec. 4655S Annual Supervisory Fees The prescribed rate of annual supervisory fees for an NSSLA, beginning assessable year 2012 shall be one-sixty-fifth of one percent (1/65 of 1%) of its Average Assessable Assets (AAA) of the immediately preceding year but shall not exceed the maximum amount provided below: S Regulations Part VI - Page 6 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4655S - 4657S.9 13.12.31 Total AAA of NSSLA >P1.0 billion >P750.0 million - P1.0 billion >P500.0 million P750.0 million >P250.0 million P500.0 million >P100.0 million P250.0 million Up to P100.0 million Maximum Amount of Annual Fees P500,000.00 P400,000.00 P200,000.00 P100,000.00 Sec. 4657S Non-Stock Savings and Loan Associations Premises and Other Fixed Assets. The following rules shall govern the premises and other fixed assets of NSSLAs. § 4657S.1 Accounting for non-stock savings and loans associations premises; other fixed assets. NSSLAs premises, furniture, fixture and equipment shall be accounted for using the cost model under PAS 16 "Property, Plant and Equipment". (Circular No. 494 dated 20 September 2005) P 50,000.00 P 10,000.00 Provided, That the minimum amount of annual fees of NSSLAs with AAA of up to P100.0 million shall be P10,000.00. The annual supervisory fee shall be payable within thirty (30) days from receipt of the billing statement from the Bangko Sentral. Failure to pay the annual fee within the prescribed period shall subject the NSSLA to administrative sanctions. For purposes of computing the annual supervisory fees, AAA shall be the summation of end-of-quarter total assessable assets (end-of-quarter total assets per balance sheet, after deducting cash on hand and amounts due from banks) divided by the number of quarters in operation during the particular assessment period. (As amended by Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Sec. 4656S Basic Law Governing NonStock Savings and Loan Associations R.A. No. 8367, as amended, also known as the "Revised Non-Stock Savings and Loan Association Act of 1997", regulates the organization and operation of NSSLAs. § 4657S.2 (Reserved) § 4657S.3 Reclassification of real and other properties acquired as non-stock savings and loans association premises Real and Other Properties Acquired (ROPA) reclassified either as Real Property- Land or Real Property-Building shall be booked at their ROPA balance, net of any valuation reserves: Provided, That only such acquired asset or a portion thereof that will be immediately used or earmarked for future use may be reclassified and booked as Real Property-Land/Building. NSSLAs, prior to the reclassification of their ROPA accounts to Real Property-Land/ Building, shall first secure prior Bangko Sentral approval before effecting the reclassification and shall submit, in case of future use, justification and plans for expansion/use. §§ 4657S.4 - 4657S.8 (Reserved) § 4657S.9 Batas Pambansa Blg. 344 An Act to Enhance the Mobility of Disabled Persons by Requiring Certain Buildings, Institutions, Establishments and Public Utilities to Install Facilities and Other Devices. In order to promote the realization of the rights of disabled persons to participate fully in the social life and the Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part VI - Page 7 §§ 4657S.9 - 4660S 13.12.31 development of the societies in which they live and the enjoyment of the opportunities available to other citizens, no license or permit for the construction, repair or renovation of public and private buildings for public use, educational institutions, airports, sports and recreation centers and complexes, shopping centers or establishments, public parking places, workplaces, public utilities, shall be granted or issued unless the owner or operator thereof shall install and incorporate in such building, establishment or public utility, such architectural facilities or structural features as shall reasonably enhance the mobility of disabled persons such as sidewalks, ramps, railings, and the like. If feasible, all such existing buildings, institutions, establishments, or public utilities may be renovated or altered to enable the disabled persons to have access to them. § 4657S.10. Republic Act No. 9994 – An Act Granting Additional Benefits and Privileges to Senior Citizens, Further Amending Republic Act No. 7432 of 1992, as Amended by Republic Act No. 9257 of 2003. To be able to give full support to the improvement of the total well-being of the elderly and their full participation in society, and to motivate and encourage them to contribute to nation building, senior citizens shall be provided with express lanes in all branches and offices of NSSLAs. If the provision of express lanes is logistically impossible in any particular branch or office of any NSSLA, said branch or office shall ensure that senior citizens are accorded priority service. The provision of express lanes and/or priority service shall be made known to the general public through a clearly written notice prominently displayed S Regulations Part VI - Page 8 in the transaction counters of all NSSLA branches and/or offices. (Circular No. 805 dated 08 August 2013) Secs. 4658S - 4659S (Reserved) Sec. 4660S Disclosure of Remittance Charges and Other Relevant Information It is the policy of the Bangko Sentral to promote the efficient delivery of competitively-priced remittance services by banks and other remittance service providers by promoting competition and the use of innovative payment systems, strengthening the financial infrastructure, enhancing access to formal remittance channels in the source and destination countries, deepening the financial literacy of consumers, and improving transparency in remittance transactions, consistent with sound practices. Towards this end, NBFIs under Bangko Sentral supervision, including FXDs/MCs and RAs, providing overseas remittance services shall disclose to the remittance sender and to the recipient/beneficiary, the following minimum items of information regarding remittance transactions, as defined herein: a. Transfer/remittance fee - charge for processing/sending the remittance from the country of origin to the country of destination and/or charge for receiving the remittance at the country of destination; b. Exchange rate - rate of conversion from foreign currency to local currency, e.g., peso-dollar rate; c. Exchange rate differential/spread foreign exchange mark-up or the difference between the prevailing Bangko Sentral reference/guiding rate and the exchange/ conversion rate; d. Other currency conversion charges - Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions §§ 4660S - 4699S 13.12.31 commisions or service fees, if any; e. Other related charges - e.g., surcharges, postage, text message or telegram; f. Amount/currency paid out in the recipient country - exact amount of money the recipient should receive in local currency or foreign currency; and g. Delivery time to recipients/ beneficiaries - delivery period of remittance to beneficiary stated in number of days, hours or minutes. Non-bank remittance service providers shall likewise post said information in their respective websites and display them prominently in conspicuous places within their premises and/or remittance/service centers. No. 9160, as amended, or of this Section, the officer(s) or other persons responsible for such violation shall be punished by a fine of not less than P50 thousand nor more than P200 thousand or by imprisonment of not less than two (2) years nor more than ten (10) years, or both, at the discretion of the court pursuant to Section 36 of R.A. No. 7653, otherwise known as “The New Central Bank Act”. b. Without prejudice to the criminal sanctions prescribed above against the culpable persons, the Monetary Board may, at its discretion, impose upon any covered institution, its directors and/or officers for any violation of Section 9 of R.A. No. 9160, as amended, the administrative sanctions provided under Section 37 of R.A. No. 7653. (Circular No. 534 dated 26 June 2006) Secs. 4661S - 4690S (Reserved) Sec. 4691S Anti-Money Laundering Regulations. Covered institutions, including their subsidiaries and affiliates, shall comply with the provisions of Part 8 of Q Regulations, R.A. No. 9160 (Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2001), as amended, and its IRR. (As amended by Circular Nos. 706 dated 05 January 2011, 661 dated 01 September 2009 and 612 dated 13 June 2008) §§ 4691S.1 - 4691S.8 (Reserved) § 4691S.9 Sanctions and penalties a. Whenever a covered institution violates the provisions of Section 9 of R.A. Secs. 4692S - 4694S (Reserved) Sec. 4695S Valid Identification Cards for Financial Transactions. The provisions of Part 8 of the Q Regulations on valid identification documents shall apply. (Circular No. 564 dated 03 April 2007, as amended by Circular Nos. 792 dated 03 May 2013, 706 dated 05 January 2011, 657 dated 16 June 2009 and 608 dated 20 May 2008) Secs. 4696S - 4698S (Reserved) Sec. 4699S General Provision on Sanctions Unless otherwise provided, any violation of the provisions of this Part shall be subject to the sanctions provided in Sections 34, 35, 36 and 37 of R. A. No. 7653, whenever applicable. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Part VI - Page 9 APP. S-1 08.12.31 SAFEGUARDS IN BONDING OF NSSLA ACCOUNTABLE OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES (Appendix to Sec. 4145S) 1. The Teller. He should not be allowed to accumulate more than a specific maximum amount to be determined by the association but in no case to exceed P10,000 in cash at any given time while in the performance of his duties. The procedures in this regard are as follows: a. Cash. All cash in excess of the maximum amount determined by the association shall be turned over to the cashier. When deposits received by a teller will increase his cash in excess of the maximum limit, the teller shall immediately make a cash turn-over of, at least, the excess. Thus, although his transactions during the day may total more than the maximum limit, the amount of money directly in his custody at any given time will never exceed the limit. b. Checks and Other Cash Items (COCIs). All COCIs received by a teller should be stamped as “non-negotiable.” The stamping should be made diagonally on the face of the check. Thus, all checks that are received by the tellers lose their further negotiability. There should, however, be an agreement with the association’s depository banks whereby they will accept for deposit only to the account of the association the COCI previously stamped by the tellers as “nonnegotiable.” Therefore, only the association and nobody else can further negotiate these checks, and only the association’s depository bank will accept them and solely for deposit to its account. Thus, even in the remote possibility that someone presents a COCI stolen from the association to one of its depository banks, it will not be accepted for encashment. 2. The COCIs Clerk. In view of the fact that all COCIs received by the tellers are stamped “non-negotiable” as detailed above, the COCIs clerk who records and processes these checks carries no accountabilities whatsoever. From the moment that a check is received up to the moment that it is deposited to the account of the association with one of its depository banks, that check is just a piece of paper to be processed and recorded. It will only reassume its negotiability upon its receipt by the association’s depository bank. In cases, however, where checks are received by mail, the COCIs clerk shall be charged with the duty of stamping the checks as “non-negotiable.” 3. As an added precautionary measure, the manager/accountant/loan officer should check from time to time whether all COCIs received are stamped “non-negotiable.” In the event that a COCI is not so stamped and it results in financial loss on the part of the association, the employee charged with the duty to stamp and who failed to do so, shall be held personally responsible, together with the manager/accountant/loan officer, for the loss. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-I - Page 1 APP. S-2 14.12.31 LIST OF REPORTS REQUIRED FROM NON-STOCK SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATIONS (Appendix to Sec. 4162S) Category Form No. MOR Ref. Frequency Submission Deadline Submission Procedure A-2 BSP 7-26-02H 4162S (As amended by M-029 dated 09.24.07 and Cir. No. 837 dated 06.18.14) Consolidated Statement of Condition1 Quarterly on or before the end of the immediately following month Original to SDC A-2 Unnumbered 4691S (Rev. May 2002, as amended by Cir. No. 612 dated 06.03.08) Report on Suspicious Transactions As transaction occurs 10th business day from date of occurrence transaction/ knowledge Original and duplicate Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) A-2 Unnumbered 4691S Report on Covered Transactions -do- -do- A-3 BSP 7-26-03H 4162S Consolidated Statement of Income and Expenses1 Quarterly on or before the end of the immediately following month (As amended by M-029 dated 09.24.07 and Cir. No. 837 dated 06.18.14) 1 Report Title Revised reporting templates effective report ending 30 June 2014. Page 1 of 4 -doOriginal to SDC APP. S-2 14.12.31 Category Form No. MOR Ref. A-3 BSP 7-26-18.1H A-3 Unnumbered B B 2 SES II Form 15 (NP08-TB) Report Title Frequency 4358S Copy of entry in NSSLA records of written approval of majority of directors on credit accommodation to directors and officers with accompanying Certification on Loans Granted to Directors/Officers As approved 20th business date of approval day from Original - ISD I 4162S (CL-050 dated 10.04.07 and CL-059 dated 11.28.07) Report on Borrowings of BSP Personnel Quarterly 15th banking day end of reference quarter after Original to SDC 4172S Audited/Unaudited Financial Statements required in Sec. 4181S accompanied by annual report2 (to members, if any) Annually 120th/60th day after end of fiscal year as required in Sec. 4181S Original - ISD I 4147S (As amended by Cir. No. 758 dated 05.11.12 and M-024 dated Biographical Data of Trustees/Officers with rank of SVP and above with ID picture Upon every election/ re-election or appointment/ promotion or if change in name occurs 10th business day from date of election/re-election of the trustees/meeting of the board of trustees in which the officers are appointed/promoted Hard copy to appropriate department of the SES - Updated Bio-data in case of change of name due to change in civil status Required of NSSLAs with total resources of P 10 million or more Page 2 of 4 Submission Deadline Submission Procedure 10th business day from the date the change of name occurred APP. S-2 14.12.31 Category Form No. B MOR Ref. Report Title Frequency Submission Deadline Submission Procedure 07.31.08) - Notarized list of the incumbent members of the board of trustees and officers 4143S (Circular No. 758 dated 05.11.12) Duly accomplished and notarized authorization form for querying the Bangko Sentral watchlist files Upon election/ re-election or appointment/ promotion as first time trustee/ officer within an NSSLA 10th business day from date of election/re-election of the trustees/meeting of the board of trustees in which the officers are appointed/promoted Hard copy to appropriate department of the SES Hard copy to appropriate department of the SES 10th business day from the election of the BOT B Unnumbered 4143S (Circular No. 758 dated 05.11.12) List of Members of the Board of Trustees and Officers Annually 10th business day from the election of the board of trustees B BSP 7-26-20H 4162S Report on Crimes/Losses As crime/ incident occurs See Annex S-2-a for guidelines on reporting crimes and losses -do- B 4306S.3 Notice/Application Loans 30th day prior to intended date of write-off -do- B 4162S Board Resolution on NSSLA's signatories to reports submitted to Bangko Sentral B Page 3 of 4 for General Information Sheet Write-Off of As write-off occurs As authorized Annually the 3rd day from date of resolution Hard copy to appropriate department of the SES 30th day annual meeting Drop Box - SEC Central Receiving Section Original - SEC Duplicate - BSP from date of stockholders' APP. S-2 14.12.31 Category B Form No. Form I Schedule 1 MOR Ref. M-031 dated 09.11.09 and Cir. No. 649 dated 03.09.09 Report Title Report on Transactions Electronic Frequency Money Submission Deadline Quarterly 15 banking days end of reference quarter Quarterly Not later than one (1) month after the end of every quarter Quarterly Statement of E-Money Transactions - Volume and Amount of EMoney Transactions Quarterly Statement of Liquidity Cover Submission Procedure after e-mail sdcothers-emoney@ bsp.gov.ph Hardcopy- SDC Schedules 1 - E-Money Balances B Page 4 of 4 4402S.4 (Cir. No. 857 dated 11.21.14) Complaints Report SDC APP. S-2 08.12.31 Annex S-2-a REPORTING GUIDELINES ON CRIMES/LOSSES 1. NSSLAs shall report on the following matters through the appropriate supervising and examining department: a. Crimes whether consummated, frustrated or attempted against property/ facilities (such as robbery, theft, swindling or estafa, forgery and other deceits) and other crimes involving loss/ destruction of property of the NSSLA when the amount involved in each crime is P20,000 or more. Crimes involving NSSLA personnel, regardless of whether or not such crimes involve the loss/destruction of property of the NSSLA, even if the amount involved is less than those above specified, shall likewise be reported to the BSP. b. Incidents involving material loss, destruction or damage to the institution’s property/facilities, other than arising from S Regulations Appendix S-2 - Page 4 a crime, when the amount involved per incident is P20,000 or more. 2. The following guidelines shall be observed in the preparation and submission of the report. a. The report shall be prepared in two (2) copies and shall be submitted within five (5) business days from knowledge of the crime or incident, the original to the appropriate supervising department and the duplicate to the BSP Security Coordinator, thru the Director, Security Investigation and Transport Department. b. Where a thorough investigation and evaluation of facts is necessary to complete the report, an initial report submitted within the five (5)-business day deadline may be accepted: Provided, That a complete report is submitted not later than fifteen (15) business days from termination of investigation. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-3 08.12.31 GUIDELINES ON PRESCRIBED REPORTS SIGNATORIES AND SIGNATORY AUTHORIZATION (Appendix to Subsec. 4162S.1) Category A-1 reports shall be signed by the chief executive officer, or in his absence, by the executive vice-president, and by the comptroller, or in his absence, by the chief accountant, or by officers holding equivalent positions. The designated signatories in this category, including their specimen signatures, shall be contained in a resolution approved by the board of directors in the format prescribed in Annex S-3-a. managers/officers in-charge. Likewise, the signing authority in this category shall be contained in a resolution approved by the board of directors in the format prescribed in Annex S-3-b. Category A-2 reports of head offices shall be signed by the president, executive vice-presidents, vice-presidents or officers holding equivalent positions. Such reports of other offices/units (such as branches) shall be signed by their respective Copies of the board resolutions on the report signatory designations shall be submitted to the appropriate supervising and examining department of the BSP within three (3) business days from the date of resolution. Categories A-3 and B reports shall be signed by officers or their alternates, who shall be duly designated by the board of directors. A copy of the board resolution, with format as prescribed in Annex S-3-c. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-3 - Page 1 APP. S-3 08.12.31 Annex S-3-a FORMAT OF RESOLUTION FOR SIGNATORIES OF CATEGORY A-1 REPORTS Resolution No. _____ Whereas, it is required under Subsec. 4162S.1 that Category A-1 reports be signed by the Chief Executive Officer, or in his absence, by the Executive Vice-President, and by the Comptroller, or in his absence, by the Chief Accountant, or by officers holding equivalent positions. Whereas, it is also required that aforesaid officers of the institution be authorized under a resolution duly approved by the institution's Board of Directors; (Name of Institution) , Whereas, we, the members of the Board of Directors of are conscious that, in designating the officials who would sign said Category A-1 reports, we are actually empowering and authorizing said officers to represent and act for or in behalf of the Board of Directors in particular and (Name of Institution) in general; Whereas, this Board has full faith and confidence in the institution's Chief Executive Officer, Executive Vice-President, Comptroller and Chief Accountant, as the case may be, and, therefore, assumes responsibility for all the acts which may be performed by aforesaid officers under their delegated authority; Now, therefore, we, the members of the Board of Directors, resolve, as it is hereby resolved that: 1. Mr.____________ President 2. Mr.____________ or Executive Vice-President 3. Mr.____________ and Comptroller 4. Mr.____________ or Chief Accountant _________________ Specimen Signature _________________ Specimen Signature _________________ Specimen Signature _________________ Specimen Signature are hereby authorized to sign Category A-1 reports of (Name of Institution) Done in the City of ________________ Philippines, this ____day of . , 20____. CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR ATTESTED BY: ______________________ CORPORATE SECRETARY S Regulations Appendix S-3 - Page 2 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-3 08.12.31 Annex S-3-b FORMAT OF RESOLUTION FOR SIGNATORIES OF CATEGORY A-2 REPORTS Resolution No. _____ Whereas, it is required under Subsec. 4162S.1 that Category A-2 reports of head offices be signed by the President, Executive Vice-Presidents, Vice-Presidents or officers holding equivalent positions, and that such reports of other offices be signed by the respective managers/officers-in-charge; Whereas, it is also required that aforesaid officers of the institution be authorized under a resolution duly approved by the institution's Board of Directors; Whereas, we, the members of the Board of Directors of (Name of Institution) , are conscious that, in designating the officials who would sign said Category A-2 reports, we are actually empowering and authorizing said officers to represent and act for or in behalf of the Board of Directors in particular and (Name of Institution) in general; Whereas, this Board has full faith and confidence in the institution's President (and/or the Executive Vice-President, etc., as the case may be) and, therefore, assumes responsibility for all the acts which may be performed by aforesaid officers under their delegated authority; Now, therefore, we, the members of the Board of Directors, resolve, as it is hereby resolved that: Name of Officer Specimen Signature Position Title Report No. _____________ ________________ __________ _________ are hereby authorized to sign the Category A-2 reports of (Name of Institution) . Done in the City of ________________ Philippines, this ____day of ____, 20____. _________________________ CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR ATTESTED BY: CORPORATE SECRETARY Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-3 - Page 3 APP. S-3 08.12.31 Annex S-3-c FORMAT OF RESOLUTION FOR SIGNATORIES OF CATEGORIES A-3 AND B REPORTS Resolution No. _____ Whereas, it is required under Subsec. 4162S.1 that Categories A-3 and B reports be signed by officers or their alternates; Whereas, it is also required that aforesaid officers of the institution be authorized under a resolution duly approved by the institution's Board of Directors; Whereas, we the members of the Board of Directors of (Name of Institution) , are conscious that, in designating the officials who would sign said Categories A-3 and B reports, we are actually empowering and authorizing said officers to represent and act for or in (Name of Institution) in general; behalf of the Board of Directors in particular and Whereas, this Board has full faith and confidence in the institution's authorized signatories and, therefore, assumes responsibility for all the acts which may be performed by aforesaid officers under their delegated authority; Now, therefore, we, the members of the Board of Directors, resolve, as it is hereby resolved that: Name of Authorized Signatory/Alternate Specimen Signature Position Title Report 1. Authorized (Alternate) 2. Authorized (Alternate) etc. are hereby authorized to sign the Category A-2 reports of (Name of Institution) . Done in the City of ________________ Philippines, this ____day of ____, 20____. _________________________ CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR DIRECTOR ATTESTED BY: CORPORATE SECRETARY S Regulations Appendix S-3 - Page 4 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-4 12.12.31 FORMAT OF DISCLOSURE STATEMENT ON SMALL BUSINESS/RETAIL/CONSUMER CREDIT [Appendix to Subsec. 4307S.2] _________________________________ (Business Name of Creditor) DISCLOSURE STATEMENT ON LOAN/CREDIT TRANSACTION (As required under R.A. No. 3765, Truth in Lending Act) NAME OF BORROWER ADDRESS 1. LOAN AMOUNT 2. OTHER BANK CHARGES/DEDUCTIONS COLLECTED1 a. Documentary/Science Stamps b. Mandatory Credit Insurance c. Others (Specify) (date) XXX P XXX P XXX P 3. NET PROCEEDS OF LOAN (Item 1 less Item 2) 4. SCHEDULE OF PAYMENTS a. Single payment due on b. Installment Payments P P XXX (Please see attached amortization schedule) 5. EFFECTIVE INTEREST RATE (Interest and Other Charges) XXX% Explanation: The effective interest rate is higher than the contractual interest rate of ___% because of some deductions in Item 2 above. 6. CONDITIONAL CHARGES THAT MAY BE IMPOSED (if applicable). Please specify manner of imposition: a. Late Charge P b. Prepayment (penalty/refund) c. Others (Specify) CERTIFIED CORRECT: _______________________________ (Signature of Creditor/Authorized Representative Over Printed Name) _______________________________ Position I ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF A COPY OF THIS STATEMENT PRIOR TO THE CONSUMMATION OF THE CREDIT TRANSACTION. _______________________________ (Signature of Borrower over Printed Name) _________________________ Date Notes: ¹ Itemize all charges including advance deductions - Small business/Retail/Consumer Loans includes microfinance, auto (motor), salary, personal, medical, educational and other loans of similar nature - This document contains the minimum information required to be disclosed to the borrower and may be enhanced to improve client information Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-4 - Page 1 APP. S-4 12.12.31 AMORTIZATION SCHEDULE (Sample Only) Installment (A) Loan (B) xxx 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Total Principal (C) Interest (D) Total (E) xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx O/S Balance (F) xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx Legends: A B C D E F - Number of installment periods based on loan term Gross amount of loan Installment payment on the principal Installment payment on the interest Total amortization payment for the installment period Outstanding principal balance of the loan (As amended byCircular No. 754 dated 17 April 2012 and M-2012-018 dated 19 April 2012) S Regulations Appendix S-4 - Page 2 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-5 08.12.31 ABSTRACT OF “TRUTH IN LENDING ACT” (Republic Act No. 3765) (Appendix to Subsec. 4307S.4) Section 1. This Act shall be known as the “Truth in Lending Act.” Sec. 2. Declaration of Policy. It is hereby declared to be the policy of the State to protect its citizens from a lack of awareness of the true cost of credit to the user by assuring a full disclosure of such cost with a view of preventing the uninformed use of credit to the detriment of the national economy. xxx xxx xxx Sec. 3. As used in this Act, the term xxx xxx xxx (3) “Finance charge” includes interest, fees, service charges, discounts, and such other charges incident to the extension of credit as the Board may by regulation prescribe. xxx xxx xxx Sec. 4. Any creditor shall furnish to each person to whom credit is extended, prior to the consummation of the transaction a clear statement in writing setting forth, to the extent applicable and in accordance with rules and regulations prescribed by the Board, the following information: (1) the cash price or delivered price of the property or service to be acquired; (2) the amounts, if any, to be credited as down payment and/or trade-in; (3) the difference between the amounts set forth under clauses (1) and (2); (4) the charges, individually itemized, which are paid or to be paid by such person in connection with the transaction but which are not incident to the extension of credit; (5) the total amount to be financed; (6) the finance charge expressed in terms of pesos and centavos; and (7) the percentage that the finance charge bears to the total amount to be financed expressed as a simple annual rate on the outstanding unpaid balance of the obligation. xxx xxx xxx Sec. 6. (a) Any creditor who in connection with any credit transaction fails to disclose to any person any information in violation of this Act or any regulation issued thereunder shall be liable to such person in the amount of P100 or in an amount equal to twice the finance charge required by such creditor in connection with such transaction, whichever is the greater, except that such liability shall not exceed P2,000 on any credit transaction. xxx xxx xxx (c) Any person who willfully violates any provision of this Act or any regulation issued thereunder shall be fined by not less than P1,000 nor more than P5,000 or imprisonment for not less than 6 months nor more than one year or both. xxx xxx xxx (d) Any final judgment hereafter rendered in any criminal proceeding under this Act to the effect that a defendant has willfully violated this Act shall be prima facie evidence against such defendant in an action or proceeding brought by any other party against such defendant under this Act as to all matters respecting which said judgment would be an estoppel as between the parties thereto. Sec. 7. This Act shall become effective upon approval. Approved, 22 June 1963. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-5 - Page 1 APP. S-6 11.12.31 ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING REGULATIONS (Appendix to Section 4691S) (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-6 - Page 1 APP. S-6 11.12.31 Annex S-6-a CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING REGULATIONS (Deleted pursuant Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) S Regulations Appendix S-6 - Page 2 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-6 11.12.31 Annex S-6-b AMLC Resolution No. 292 RULES ON SUBMISSION OF COVERED TRANSACTION REPORTS AND SUSPICIOUS TRANSACTION REPORTS BY COVERED INSTITUTIONS1 (Annex to Appendix S-6) (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-6 - Page 3 APP. S-7 11.12.31 REVISED IMPLEMENTING RULES AND REGULATIONS R.A. NO. 9160, AS AMENDED BY R.A. NO. 9194 (Appendix to Sec. 4691S) (Deleted pursuant to Circular No. 706 dated 05 January 2011) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-7 - Page 1 APP. S-8 09.12.31 GUIDELINES TO GOVERN THE SELECTION, APPOINTMENT, REPORTING REQUIREMENTS AND DELISTING OF EXTERNAL AUDITORS AND/OR AUDITING FIRM OF COVERED ENTITIES (Appendix to Secs. 4180S and 4190S) Pursuant to Section 58 of the Republic Act No. 8791, otherwise known as "The General Banking Law of 2000", and the existing provisions of the executed Memorandum of Agreement (hereinafter referred to as the MOA) dated 12 August 2009, binding the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Professional Regulation Commission (IC) - Board of Accountancy (BOA) and the Insurance Commission (IC) for a simplified and synchronized accreditation requirements for external auditor and/or auditing firm, the Monetary Board, in its Resolution No. 950 dated 02 July 2009, approved the following revised rules and regulations that shall govern the selection and delisting by the BSP of covered institution which under special laws are subject to BSP supervision. A. STATEMENT OF POLICY It is the policy of the BSP to ensure effective audit and supervision of banks, QBs, trust entities and/or NSSLAs including their subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities and other FIs which under special laws are subject to BSP supervision, and to ensure reliance by BSP and the public on the opinion of external auditors and auditing firms by prescribing the rules and regulations that shall govern the selection, appointment, reporting requirements and delisting for external auditors and auditing firms of said institutions, subject to the binding provisions and implementing regulations of the aforesaid MOA. B. COVERED ENTITIES The proposed amendment shall apply to the following supervised institution, as categorized below, and their external auditors: 1. Category A a. UBs/KBs; b. Foreign banks and branches or subsidiaries of foreign banks, regardless of unimpaired capital; and c. Banks, trust department of qualified banks and other trust entities with additional derivatives authority, pursuant to Sec. X611 regardless of classification, category and capital position. 2. Category B a. TBs; b. QBs; c. Trust department of qualified banks and other trust entities; d. National Coop Banks; and e. NBFIs with quasi-banking functions. 3. Category C a. RBs; b. NSSLAs; c. Local Coop Banks; and d. Pawnshops. The above categories include their subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities and other FIs which are subject to BSP risk-based and consolidated supervision: Provided, That an external auditor who has been selected by the BSP to audit covered entities under Category A is automatically qualified to audit entities under Category B and C and if selected by the BSP to audit covered entities under Category B is automatically qualified to audit entities under Category C. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 1 APP. S-8 09.12.31 C. DEFINITION OF TERMS The following terms shall be defined as follows: 1. Audit – an examination of the financial statements of any issuer by an external auditor in compliance with the rules of the BSP or the SEC in accordance with then applicable generally accepted auditing and accounting principles and standards, for the purpose of expressing an opinion on such statements. 2. Non-audit services – any professional services provided to the covered institution by an external auditor, other than those provided to a covered institution in connection with an audit or a review of the financial statements of said covered institution. 3. Professional Standards - includes: (a) accounting principles that are (1) established by the standard setting body; and (2) relevant to audit reports for particular issuers, or dealt with in the quality control system of a particular registered public accounting firm; and (b) auditing standards, standards for attestation engagements, quality control policies and procedures, ethical and competency standards, and independence standards that the BSP or SEC determines (1) relate to the preparation or issuance of audit reports for issuers; and (2) are established or adopted by the BSP or promulgated as SEC rules. 4. Fraud – an intentional act by one (1) or more individuals among management, employees, or third parties that results in a misrepresentation of financial statements, which will reduce the consolidated total assets of the company by five percent (5%). It may involve: a. Manipulation, falsification or alteration of records or documents; b. Misappropriation of assets; c. Suppression or omission of the effects of transactions from records or documents; S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 2 d. Recording of transactions without substance; e. Intentional misapplication of accounting policies; or f. Omission of material information. 5. Error - an intentional mistake in financial statements, which will reduce the consolidated total assets of the company by five percent (5%). It may involve: a. Mathematical or clerical mistakes in the underlying records and accounting data; b. Oversight or misinterpretation of facts; or c. Unintentional misapplication of accounting policies. 6. Gross negligence - wanton or reckless disregard of the duty of due care in complying with generally accepted auditing standards. 7. Material fact/information - any fact/ information that could result in a change in the market price or value of any of the issuer’s securities, or would potentially affect the investment decision of an investor. 8. Subsidiary - a corporation or firm more than fifty percent (50%) of the outstanding voting stock of which is directly or indirectly owned, controlled or held with power to vote by a bank, QB, trust entity or NSSLA. 9. Affiliate - a corporation, not more than fifty percent (50%) but not less than ten percent (10%) of the outstanding voting stock of which is directly or indirectly owned, controlled or held with power to vote by a bank, QB, trust entity or NSSLA and a juridical person that is under common control with the bank, QB, trust entity or NSSLA. 10. Control - exists when the parent owns directly or indirectly more than one half of the voting power of an enterprise unless, in exceptional circumstance, it can be clearly demonstrated that such ownership does not constitute control. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-8 09.12.31 Control may also exist even when ownership is one half or less of the voting power of an enterprise when there is: a. Power over more than one half of the voting rights by virtue of an agreement with other stockholders; b. Power to govern the financial and operating policies of the enterprise under a statute or an agreement; c. Power to appoint or remove the majority of the members of the board of directors or equivalent governing body; or d. Power to cast the majority votes at meetings of the board of directors or equivalent governing body. 11. External auditor - means a single practitioner or a signing partner in an auditing firm. 12. Auditing firm – includes a proprietorship, partnership limited liability company, limited liability partnership, corporation (if any), or other legal entity, including any associated person of any of these entities, that is engaged in the practice of public accounting or preparing or issuing audit reports. 13. Associate – any director, officer, manager or any person occupying a similar status or performing similar functions in the audit firm including employees performing supervisory role in the auditing process. 14. Partner - all partners including those not performing audit engagements. 15. Lead partner – also referred to as engagement partner/partner-in-charge/ managing partner who is responsible for signing the audit report on the consolidated financial statements of the audit client, and where relevant, the individual audit report of any entity whose financial statements form part of the consolidated financial statements. 16. Concurring partner - the partner who is responsible for reviewing the audit report. 17. Auditor-in-charge – refers to the team leader of the audit engagement. D. GENERAL CONSIDERATION AND LIMITATIONS OF THE SELECTION PROCEDURES 1. Subject to mutual recognition provision of the MOA and as implemented in this regulation, only external auditors and auditing firms included in the list of BSP selected external auditors and auditing firms shall be engaged by all the covered institutions detailed in Item "B". The external auditor and/or auditing firm to be hired shall also be in-charge of the audit of the entity’s subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities: Provided, That the external auditor and/or auditing firm shall be changed or the lead and concurring partner shall be rotated every five (5) years or earlier: Provided further, That the rotation of the lead and concurring partner shall have an interval of at least two (2) years. 2. Category A covered entities which have engaged their respective external auditors and/or auditing firm for a consecutive period of five (5) years or more as of 18 September 2009 shall have a one (1)-year period from said date within which to either change their external auditors and/or auditing firm or to rotate the lead and/or concurring partner. 3. The selection of the external auditors and/or auditing firm does not exonerate the covered institution or said auditors from their responsibilities. Financial statements filed with the BSP are still primarily the responsibility of the management of the reporting institution and accordingly, the fairness of the representations made therein is an implicit and integral part of the institution’s responsibility. The independent certified public accountant’s responsibility for the financial statements required to be filed with the BSP is confined to the expression of his opinion, or lack thereof, on such statements which he has audited/examined. 4. The BSP shall not be liable for any damage or loss that may arise from its Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 3 APP. S-8 09.12.31 selection of the external auditors and/or auditing firm to be engaged by banks for regular audit or non-audit services. 5. Pursuant to paragraph (5) of the MOA, SEC, BSP and IC shall mutually recognize the accreditation granted by any of them for external auditors and firms of Group C or D companies under SEC, Category B and C under BSP, and insurance brokers under IC. Once accredited/selected by any one (1) of them, the above-mentioned special requirements shall no longer be prescribed by the other regulators. For corporations which are required to submit financial statements to different regulators and are not covered by the mutual recognition policy of this MOA, the following guidance shall be observed: a. The external auditors of UBs which are listed in the Exchange, should be selected/accredited by both the BSP and SEC, respectively; and b. For insurance companies and banks that are not listed in the Exchange, their external auditors must each be selected/ accredited by BSP or IC, respectively. For purposes of submission to the SEC, the financial statements shall be at least audited by an external auditor registered/accredited with BOA. This mutual recognition policy shall however be subject to the BSP restriction that for banks and its subsidiary and affiliate bank, QBs, trust entities, NSSLAs, their subsidiaries and affiliates engaged in allied activities and other FIs which under special laws are subject to BSP consolidated supervision, the individual and consolidated financial statements thereof shall be audited by only one (1) external auditor/auditing firm. 6. The selection of external auditors and/or auditing firm shall be valid for a period of three (3) years. The SES shall make an annual assessment of the performance of external auditors and/or auditing firm and S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 4 will recommend deletion from the list even prior to the three (3)-year renewal period, if based on assessment, the external auditors’ report did not comply with BSP requirements. E. QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENT The following qualification requirements are required to be met by the individual external auditor and the auditing firm at the time of application and on continuing basis, subject to BSP’s provisions on the delisting and suspension of accreditation: 1. Individual external auditor a. General requirements (1) The individual applicant must be primarily accredited by the BOA. The individual external auditor or partner in-charge of the auditing firm must have at least five (5) years of audit experience. (2) Auditor’s independence. In addition to the basic screening procedures of BOA on evaluating auditor’s independence, the following are required for BSP purposes to be submitted in the form of notarized certification that: (a) No external auditor may be engaged by any of the covered institutions under Item "B" hereof if he or any member of his immediate family had or has committed to acquire any direct or indirect financial interest in the concerned covered institution, or if his independence is considered impaired under the circumstances specified in the Code of Professional Ethics for CPAs. In case of a partnership, this limitation shall apply to the partners, associates and the auditor-in-charge of the engagement and members of their immediate family; (b) The external auditor does not have/ shall not have outstanding loans or any credit accommodations or arranged for the extension of credit or to renew an extension of credit (except credit card obligations which are normally available to other credit card holders and fully secured auto loans Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-8 09.12.31 and housing loans which are not past due) with the covered institutions under Item "B" at the time of signing the engagement and during the engagement. In the case of partnership, this prohibition shall apply to the partners and the auditor-in-charge of the engagement; and (c) It shall be unlawful for an external auditor to provide any audit service to a covered institution if the covered institution’s CEO, CFO, Chief Accounting Officer (CAO), or comptroller was previously employed by the external auditor and participated in any capacity in the audit of the covered institution during the oneyear preceding the date of the initiation of the audit; (3) Individual applications as external auditor of entities under Category A above must have established adequate quality assurance procedures, such consultation policies and stringent quality control, to ensure full compliance with the accounting and regulatory requirements. b. Specific requirements (1) At the time of application, regardless of the covered institution, the external auditor shall have at least five (5) years experience in external audits; (2) The audit experience above refers to experience required as an associate, partner, lead partner, concurring partner or auditor-in-charge; and (3) At the time of application, the applicant must have the following track record: (a) For Category A, he/she must have at least five (5) corporate clients with total assets of at least P50.0 million each. (b) For Category B, he/she must have had at least three (3) corporate clients with total assets of at least P25.0 million each. (c) For Category C, he/she must have had at least three (3) corporate clients with total assets of at least P5.0 million each; 2. Auditing firms a. The auditing firm must be primarily accredited by the BOA and the name of the firm’s applicant partner’s should appear in the attachment to the certificate of accreditation issued by BOA. Additional partners of the firm shall be furnished by BOA to the concerned regulatory agencies (e.g. BSP, SEC and IC) as addendum to the firm’s accreditation by BOA. b. Applicant firms to act as the external auditor of entities under Category A in Item "B" must have established adequate quality assurance procedures, such consultation policies and stringent quality control, to ensure full compliance with the accounting and regulatory requirements. c. At the time of application, the applicant firm must have at least one (1) signing practitioner or partner who is already selected/accredited, or who is already qualified and is applying for selection by BSP. d. A registered accounting/auditing firm may engage in any non-auditing service for an audit client only if such service is approved in advance by the client’s audit committee. Exemptions from the prohibitions may be granted by the Monetary Board on a case-by-case basis to the extent that such exemption is necessary or appropriate in the public interest. Such exemptions are subject to review by the BSP. e. At the time of application, the applicant firm must have the following track record: (1) For Category A, the applicant firm must have had at least twenty (20) corporate clients with total assets of at least P50.0 million each; (2) For Category B, the applicant firm must have had at least five (5) corporate clients with total assets of at least P20.0 million each; (3) For Category C, the applicant firm must have had at least five (5) corporate Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 5 APP. S-8 09.12.31 clients with total assets of at least P5.0 million each. F. APPLICATION FOR AND/OR RENEWAL OF THE SELECTION OF INDIVIDUAL EXTERNAL AUDITOR 1. The initial application for BSP selection shall be signed by the external auditor and shall be submitted to the appropriate department of the SES together with the following documents/information: a. Copy of effective and valid BOA Certificate of Accreditation with the attached list of qualified partner/s of the firm; b. A notarized undertaking of the external auditor that he is in compliance with the qualification requirements under Item "E" and that the external auditor shall keep an audit or review working papers for at least seven (7) years in sufficient detail to support the conclusion in the audit report and making them available to the BSP’s authorized representative/s when required to do so; c. Copy of Audit Work Program which shall include assessment of the audited institution’s compliance with BSP rules and regulations, such as, but not limited to the following: (1) capital adequacy ratio, as currently prescribed by the BSP; (2) AMLA framework; (3) risk management system, particularly liquidity and market risks; and (4) loans and other risk assets review and classification, as currently prescribed by the BSP rules and regulations. d. If the applicant will have clients falling under Category A, copy of the Quality Assurance Manual which, aside from the basic elements as required under the BOA basic quality assurance policies and procedures, specialized quality assurance procedures should be provided consisting of, among other, review asset quality, adequacy of risk-based capital, risk S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 6 management systems and corporate governance framework of the covered entities. e. Copy of the latest AFS of the applicant’s two (2) largest clients in terms of total assets. 2. Subject to BSP’s provision on early deletion from the list of selected external auditor, the selection may be renewed within two (2) months before the expiration of the three (3)-year effectivity of the selection upon submission of the written application for renewal to the appropriate department of the SES together with the following documents/information: (a) copy of updated BOA Certificate of Accreditation with the attached list of qualified partner/s of the firm; (b) notarized certification of the external auditor that he still possess all qualification required under Item "F.1.b" of this Appendix; (c) list of corporate clients audited during the three (3)-year period of being selected as external auditor by BSP. Such list shall likewise indicate the findings noted by the BSP and other regulatory agencies on said AFS including the action thereon by the external auditor; and (d) written proof that the auditor has attended or participated in trainings for at least thirty (30) hours in addition to the BOA’s prescribed training hours. Such training shall be in subjects like international financial reporting standards, international standards of auditing, corporate governance, taxation, code of ethics, regulatory requirements of SEC, IC and BSP or other government agencies, and other topics relevant to his practice, conducted by any professional organization or association duly recognized/accredited by the BSP, SEC or by the BOA/PRC through a CPE Council which they may set up. The application for initial or renewal accreditation of an external auditor shall be accomplished by a fee of P2,000.00. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-8 09.12.31 G. APPLICATION FOR AND/OR RENEWAL OF THE SELECTION OF AUDITING FIRMS 1. The initial application shall be signed by the managing partner of the auditing firm and shall be submitted to the appropriate department of the SES together with the following documents/ information: a. copy of effective and valid BOA Certificate of Accreditation with attachment listing the names of qualified partners; b. notarized certification that the firm is in compliance with the general qualification requirements under Item "E.2" and that the firm shall keep an audit or review working papers for at least seven (7) years insufficient detail to support the conclusions in the audit report and making them available to the BSP’s authorized representative/s when required to do so; c. copy of audit work program which shall include assessment of the audited institution’s compliance with BSP rules and regulations, such as, but not limited to the following; (1) capital adequacy ratio, as currently prescribed by the BSP; (2) AMLA framework; (3) risk management system, particularly liquidity and market risks; and (4) loans and other risk assets review and classification, as currently prescribed by the BSP rules and regulations. d. If the applicant firm will have clients falling under Category A, copy Quality Assurance Manual where, aside from the basic elements as required under the BOA basic quality assurance policies and procedures, specialized quality assurance procedures should be provided relative to, among others review asset quality, adequacy of risk-based capital, risk management systems and corporate governance framework of covered entities; e. Copy of the latest AFS of the applicant’s two (2) largest clients in terms of total assets; and f. Copy of firm’s AFS for the immediately preceding two (2) years. 2. Subject to BSP’s provision on early deletion from the list of selected auditing firm, the selection may be renewed within two (2) months before the expiration of the three (3)-year effectivity of the selection upon submission of the written application for renewal to the appropriate department of the SES together with the following documents/ information: a. a copy of updated BOA Certificate of Registration with the attached list of qualified partner/s of the firm; b. amendments on Quality Assurance Manual, inclusive of written explanation on such revision, if any; and c. notarized certification that the firm is in compliance with the general qualification requirements under Item "G.1.b" hereof; The application for initial or renewal accreditation of an auditing firm shall be accompanied by a fee of P5,000.00. H. REPORTORIAL REQUIREMENTS 1. To enable the BSP to take timely and appropriate remedial action, the external auditor and/or auditing firm must report to the BSP within thirty (30) calendar days after discovery, the following cases: a. Any material finding involving fraud or dishonesty (including cases that were resolved during the period of audit); b. Any potential losses the aggregate of which amounts to at least one percent (1%) of the capital; c. Any finding to the effect that the consolidated assets of the company, on a going concern basis, are no longer adequate to cover the total claims of creditors; and Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 7 APP. S-8 09.12.31 d. Material internal control weaknesses which may lead to financial reporting problems. 2. The external auditor/auditing firm shall report directly to the BSP within fifteen (15) calendar days from the occurrence of the following: a. Termination or resignation as external auditor and stating the reason therefor; b. Discovery of a material breach of laws or BSP rules and regulations such as, but not limited to: (1) CAR; and (2) Loans and other risk assets review and classification. c. Findings on matters of corporate governance that may require urgent action by the BSP. 3. In case there are no matters to report (e.g. fraud, dishonesty, breach of laws, etc.) the external auditor/auditing firm shall submit directly to BSP within fifteen (15) calendar days after the closing of the audit engagement a notarized certification that there is none to report. The management of the covered institutions, including its subsidiaries and affiliates, shall be informed of the adverse findings and the report of the external auditor/auditing firm to the BSP shall include pertinent explanation and/or corrective action. The management of the covered institutions, including its subsidiaries and affiliates, shall be given the opportunity to be present in the discussions between the BSP and the external auditor/auditing firm regarding the audit findings, except in circumstances where the external auditor believes that the entity’s management is involved in fraudulent conduct. It is, however, understood that the accountability of an external auditor/ auditing firm is based on matters within the normal coverage of an audit conducted in S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 8 accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and identified non-audit services. I. DELISTING AND SUSPENSION OF SELECTED EXTERNAL AUDITOR/ AUDITING FIRM 1. An external auditor’s duly selected pursuant to this regulation shall be suspended or delisted, in a manner provided under this regulation, under any of the following grounds: a. Failure to submit the report under Item "H" of this Appendix or the required reports under Subsec. X190.1; b. Continuous conduct of audit despite loss of independence as provided under Item "E.1" or contrary to the requirements under the Code of Professional Ethics; c. Any willful misrepresentation in the following information/documents; (1) application and renewal for accreditation; (2) report required under Item "H"; and (3) Notarized certification of the external auditor and/or auditing firm. d. The BOA found that, after due notice and hearing, the external auditor committed an act discreditable to the profession as specified in the Code of Professional Ethics for CPAs. In this case, the BOA shall inform the BSP of the results thereof; e. Declaration of conviction by a competent court of a crime involving moral turpitude, fraud (as defined in the Revised Penal Code), or declaration of liability for violation of the banking laws, rules and regulation, the Corporation Code of the Philippines, the Securities Regulation Code (SRC); and the rules and regulations of concerned regulatory authorities; f. Refusal for no valid reason, upon lawful order of the BSP, to submit the requested documents in connection with an ongoing investigation. The external auditor Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-8 09.12.31 should however been made aware of such investigation; g. Gross negligence in the conduct of audits which would result, among others, in non-compliance with generally accepted auditing standards in the Philippines or issuance of an unqualified opinion which is not supported with full compliance by the auditee with generally accepted accounting principles in the Philippines (GAAP). Such negligence shall be determined by the BSP after proper investigation during which the external auditor shall be given due notice and hearing; h. Conduct of any of the non-audit services enumerated under Item "E.1" for his statutory audit clients, if he has not undertaken the safeguards to reduce the threat to his independence; and i. Failure to comply with the Philippine Auditing Standards and Philippine Auditing Practice Statements. 2. An auditing firms; accreditation shall be suspended or delisted, after due notice and hearing, for the following grounds: a. Failure to submit the report under Item "H" or the required reports under Sec. X190.1. b. Continuous conduct of audit despite loss of independence of the firm as provided under this regulation and under the Code of Professional Ethics; c. Any willful misrepresentation in the following information/ documents; (1) Application and renewal for accreditation; (2) Report required under Item "H"; and (3) Notarized certification of the managing partner of the firm. d. Dissolution of the auditing firm/ partnership, as evidenced by an Affidavit of Dissolution submitted to the BOA, or upon findings by the BSP that the firm/ partnership is dissolved. The accreditation of such firm/partnership shall however be reinstated by the BSP upon showing that the said dissolution was solely for the purpose of admitting new partner/s have complied with the requirements of this regulation and thereafter shall be reorganized and reregistered; e. There is a showing that the accreditation of the following number or percentage of external auditors, whichever is lesser, have been suspended or delisted for whatever reason, by the BSP: (1) at least ten (10) signing partners and currently employed selected/accredited external auditors, taken together; or (2) such number of external auditors constituting fifty percent (50%) or more of the total number of the firm’s signing partners and currently selected/accredited auditors, taken together. f. The firm or any one (1) of its auditors has been involved in a major accounting/auditing scam or scandal. The suspension or delisting of the said firm shall depend on the gravity of the offense or the impact of said scam or scandal on the investing public or the securities market, as may be determined by the BSP; g. The firm has failed reasonably to supervise an associated person and employed auditor, relating to the following: (1) auditing or quality control standards, or otherwise, with a view to preventing violations of this regulations; (2) provisions under SRC relating to preparation and issuance of audit reports and the obligations and liabilities of accountants with respect thereto; (3) the rules of the BSP under this Appendix; or (4) professional standards. h. Refusal for no valid reason, upon order of the BSP, to submit requested documents in connection with an ongoing Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 9 APP. S-8 09.12.31 investigation. The firm should however be made aware of such investigation. 3. Pursuant to paragraph 8 of the aforesaid MOA, the SEC, BSP and IC shall inform BOA of any violation by an accredited/selected external auditor which may affect his/her accreditation status as a public practitioner. The imposition of sanction by BOA on an erring practitioner shall be without prejudice to the appropriate penalty that the SEC, IC or BSP may assess or impose on such external auditor pursuant to their respective rules and regulations. In case of revocation of accreditation of a public practitioner by BOA, the accreditation by SEC, BSP and IC shall likewise be automatically revoked/ derecognized. The SEC, BSP and IC shall inform each other of any violation committed by an external auditor who is accredited/selected by any one (1) or all of them. Each agency shall undertake to respond on any referral or endorsement by another agency within ten (10) working days from receipt thereof. 4. Procedure and Effects of Delisting/ Suspension. a. An external auditor/auditing firm shall only be delisted upon prior notice to him/it and after giving him/it the opportunity to be heard and defend himself/itself by presenting witnesses/ evidence in his favor. Delisted external auditor and/or auditing firm may re-apply for BSP selection after the period prescribed by the Monetary Board. b. BSP shall keep a record of its proceeding/investigation. Said proceedings/investigation shall not be public, unless otherwise ordered by the Monetary Board for good cause shown, with the consent of the parties to such proceedings. c. A determination of the Monetary Board to impose a suspension or delisting S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 10 under this section shall be supported by a clear statement setting forth the following: (1) Each act or practice in which the selected/accredited external auditor or auditing firm, or associated entry, if applicable, has engaged or omitted to engage, or that forms a basis for all or part of such suspension/delisting; (2) The specific provision/s of this regulation, the related SEC rules or professional standards which the Monetary Board determined as has been violated; and (3) The imposed suspension or delisting, including a justification for either sanction and the period and other requirements specially required within which the delisted auditing firm or external auditor may apply for re-accreditation. d. The suspension/delisting, including the sanctions/penalties provided in Sec. X189 shall only apply to: (1) Intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, that results in violation or applicable statutory, regulatory or professional standards; or (2) Repeated instances of negligent conduct, each resulting in a violation of the applicable statutory, regulatory or professional standards. e. No associate person or employed auditor of a selected/accredited auditing firm shall be deemed to have failed reasonably to supervise any other person for purpose of Item "I.2.g" above, if: (1) There have been established in and for that firm procedures, and a system for applying such procedures, that comply with applicable rules of BSP and that would reasonably be expected to prevent and detect any such violation by such associated person; and (2) Such person or auditor has reasonably discharged the duties and obligations incumbent upon that person by reason of such procedures and system, and Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-8 09.12.31 had no reasonable cause to believe that such procedures and system were not being complied with. f. The BSP shall discipline any selected external auditor that is suspended or delisted from being associated with any selected auditing firm, or for any selected auditing firm that knew, or in the exercise or reasonable care should have known, of the suspension or delisting of any selected external auditor, to permit such association, without the consent of the Monetary Board. g. The BSP shall discipline any covered institution that knew or in the exercise of reasonable care should have known, of the suspension or delisting of its external auditor or auditing firm, without the consent of the Monetary Board. h. The BSP shall establish for appropriate cases an expedited procedure for consideration and determination of the question of the duration of stay of any such disciplinary action pending review of any disciplinary action of the BSP under this Section. J. SPECIFIC REVIEW When warranted by supervisory concern, the Monetary Board may, at the expense of the covered institution require the external auditor and/or auditing firm to undertake a specific review of a particular aspect of the operations of these institutions. The report shall be submitted to the BSP and the audited institution simultaneously, within thirty (30) calendar days after the conclusion of said review. K. AUDIT BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS Pursuant to Section 58 of RA. No. 8791, otherwise known as “The General Banking Law of 2000” the Monetary Board may also direct the board of directors of a covered institution or the individual members thereof, to conduct, either personally or by a committee created by the board, an annual balance sheet audit of the covered institution to review the internal audit and the internal control system of the concerned entity and to submit a report of such audit to the Monetary Board within thirty (30) calendar days after the conclusion thereof. L. AUDIT ENGAGEMENT Covered institutions shall submit the audit engagement contract between them, their subsidiaries and affiliates and the external auditor/auditing firm to the appropriate department of the SES within fifteen (15) calendar days from signing thereof. Said contract shall include the following provisions: 1. That the covered institution shall be responsible for keeping the auditor fully informed of existing and subsequent changes to prudential regulatory and statutory requirements of the BSP and that both parties shall comply with said requirements; 2. That disclosure of information by the external auditor/auditing firm to the BSP as required under Items “H” and “J” hereof, shall be allowed; and 3. That both parties shall comply with all the requirements under this Appendix. (As amended by Circular No. 660 dated 25 August 2009) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-8 - Page 11 APP. S-9 13.12.31 GUIDELINES IN CLASSIFYING LOANS AND OTHER RISK ASSETS AND SETTING UP OF ALLOWANCE FOR PROBABLE LOSSES (Appendix to Sections 4308S and 4392S) NSSLAs are responsible for the regular review and assessment of the quality of their loan portfolio and other risk assets. It is the duty of the board and senior management of NSSLAs to ensure that the good quality of these assets is maintained, and that adequate loss reserves are set-up at all times. To achieve these objectives, NSSLAs shall adopt and fully document policies and procedures for an effective internal asset review system and monitoring processes which should, at a minimum, comply with the standards prescribed herein. These policies and procedures should be clearly communicated to all relevant parties in the organization to ensure implementation thereof. Adequate measures should be adopted to see to it that asset review policies and procedures remain relevant and appropriate with due consideration of the design and characteristics of their portfolio, and that enough safeguards to ensure that changes where appropriate are adopted. Failure to conduct this regular assessment and set-up adequate loss reserves shall be considered unsafe and unsound practice. I. Classification of loans. Loans shall be qualitatively assessed and grouped as unclassified or classified. A. Unclassified loans. These are loans that do not have a greater-than-normal credit risk and do not possess the characteristics of classified loans as defined. The borrower has the apparent ability to satisfy his obligations in full and therefore no loss in ultimate collection is anticipated. B. Classified loans. Their classification and characteristics are detailed as follows: 1. Loans especially mentioned. These loans have potential weaknesses which, if left uncorrected, may affect the repayment of the loan. Their characteristics include: a. Loans extended to memberborrowers whose paying capacity was not appropriately determined; b. Accounts with defects and deficiencies in documentation which may render the collection of the loan difficult, e.g., loans with unsigned promissory notes; and c. Accounts which are 1-10 days past due based on the established and approved collection cycle indicated in the product manual of an NSSLA. 2. Substandard. These loans have welldefined weakness or weaknesses that jeopardize their repayment/liquidation, including adverse trends or developments that affect willingness or capacity to pay. Basic characteristics include the following: a. For secured loans: (1) There is an imminent possibility of foreclosure or acquisition of the collateral because failure of all collection efforts. b. For unsecured loans: (1) Loans under litigation; and (2) Loans classified as “Loans Especially Mentioned” in the last examination the weaknesses of which remained uncorrected in the current examination. In addition, loans which are 11-30 days past due based on the established and approved collection cycle indicated in the product manual of an NSSLA. 3. Doubtful. These are loans whose characteristics make collection or liquidation highly improbable and from which substantial loss is probable, such as: Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-9 - Page 1 APP. S-9 13.12.31 a. Past due loans secured by real estate mortgage, the title to which is subject to adverse claim or with defect in ownership rendering settlement of the loan through foreclosure doubtful; b. Past due loans secured by collaterals which have declined in value materially without the borrower offering additional collateral for the loans; and c. Loans which are 31-90 days past due based on the established and approved collection cycle indicated in the product manual of an NSSLA. 4. Loss. These are loans considered uncollectible. Their basic characteristics include the following: a. The member-borrower’s whereabouts is unknown, or he has absconded, is dead or his earning power is permanently impaired and his co-makers or guarantors are insolvent or that their guaranty is not financially supported: Provided, That the NSSLA may take into account the outstanding balance of deposits and/or capital contributions of the memberborrower and/or the present realizable value of security offered; b. Where the collaterals securing the loans are without recoverable values and the member-borrower and his co-makers are insolvent; and c. Loans which are past due for ninetyone (91) days and beyond based on the established and approved collection cycle indicated in the product manual of an NSSLA. C. Restructured loans. Upon execution of the restructuring agreement, the classification of a loan prior to restructuring, either “loans especially mentioned”, or “substandard” or “doubtful” shall be retained. The upgrading of the loan’s classification shall only be effective after a satisfactory track record of three (3) consecutive payments of the required S Regulations Appendix S-9 - Page 2 amortization of principal and/or interest has been established and if such loan meets the criteria of the lower loan classification. II. Classification of Other Risk Assets A. Real and Other Properties Acquired (ROPA), Sales Contract Receivable (SCR) and Investments shall be subject to impairment provisions under the Philippine Accounting Standards (PAS) which were adopted by the Bangko Sentral. ROPA exceeding P5.0 million book value shall be appraised by external appraisers acceptable to the Bangko Sentral. An in-house appraisal of all ROPAs shall be made every other year: Provided, That immediate re-appraisal shall be conducted on ROPAs which materially decline in value. While ROPA and SCR are subject to impairment provisions, their classifications status shall be “Substandard”. ROPAs are not sound assets because their nature as non-liquid and non-productive. As such their immediate disposal is highly recommended. On the other hand, SCRs come from conversion of ROPA, hence, they shall initially carry the classification of their predecessor. SCRs which meet all the requirements/conditions enumerated below are considered performing assets and not subject to classification: 1. That there has been a down payment or installment payments on the principal of at least twenty percent (20%) of the agreed selling price. 2. That payment of the principal must be in equal installments or in diminishing amounts and with maximum intervals of one (1) year. 3. That any grace period in the payment of principal shall not be more than one (1) year; and 4. That there is no installment payment in arrear either on principal or interest: Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-9 13.12.31 Provided, That an SCR account shall be automatically classified “substandard” and considered non-performing in case of non-payment of any amortization due: Provided further, That an SCR which has been classified “substandard” may only be upgraded to unclassified/performing status after a satisfactory track record of at least three (3) consecutive payments of the required amortization of principal and/or interest has been established. The Bangko Sentral however, reserves the right to require that specific provisions on ROPA and SCR be made, if based on its assessment, the NSSLA is unable to make necessary impairment provisioning. B. Accounts receivables shall be classified in accordance with age as follows, unless there is good reason for nonclassification: No. of Days Outstanding 61-180 181-360 Beyond 361 Classification Substandard Doubtful Loss The classification according to age of accounts receivable shall be used in classifying other risk assets not covered above. However, their classification should be tempered by favorable information gathered in the review. III. Allowance for Probable Losses. The allowance for losses for classified loans and other risk assets shall be set up immediately in accordance with the following guidelines: A. Specific allowance. Specific minimum allowance shall be immediately set-up based on the qualitative review of loans and accounts receivable, as follows: Classification Unclassified Loans Especially Mentioned (LEM) Substandard Doubtful Loss Minimum Specific Allowance (Percent) Loans Accounts Clean Fully Receivables Secured 0 0 0 10 25 50 100 5 12.5 25 50 N/A 25 50 100 Provided, That prudent level of provisioning should be increased beyond the minimum prescribed depending on the estimated realizable net present value of the collateral less transaction costs of realizing its value: Provided further, That for purposes of comprehensive estimating the minimum required level of provisioning for the loan portfolio, the Bangko Sentral reserves the right to rely on valid sampling techniques and to group loans with similar characteristics. B. General allowance. In addition to the specific allowance for probable losses under Item “1”, a general provision for loan losses shall also be set-up as follows: (a) Two percent (2%) of the outstanding balance of unclassified restructured loans; and (b) One percent (1%) of the outstanding balance of unclassified loans. 3. In addition to the foregoing minimum prudential requirements, NSSLAs are also required to comply with the provisions of the Philippine Accounting Standards (PAS) on the recognition of impairment losses on its financial assets: Provided, That NSSLAs are required to meet the Bangko Sentral minimum allowance for losses or the required provisioning under the PAS, whichever is higher. (Circular No. 789 dated 28 February 2013) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions S Regulations Appendix S-9 - Page 3 APP. S-10 14.12.31 GUIDELINES AND PROCEDURES GOVERNING THE CONSUMER ASSISTANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (CAMS) OF BSP-SUPERVISED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS [Appendix to Subsec. 4402S.4] I. Statement of Policy The Bangko Sentral acknowledges the indispensable role of financial consumers in bringing about a strong and stable financial system, their right to be protected in all stages of their transactions with Bangko Sentral- Supervised Financial Institutions (BSFIs), and be given an avenue to air out their grievances in the products and services of BSFIs. Consumer protection is regarded as a core function complementary to Bangko Sentral's prudential regulation and supervision, financial stability, financial inclusion, and financial education agenda. Towards this end, the Bangko Sentral hereby issues the following minimum guidelines institutionalizing consumer assistance mechanism of BSFIs. II. Applicability and Scope The CAMS requirements and minimum guidelines on receiving, recording, evaluating, resolving, monitoring, reporting, and giving feedback to consumers shall apply to a BSFI and its branches/other offices. The provisions of these guidelines shall, as far as practicable, also apply to inquiries and requests received from clients and potential clients. III. Definition of Terms a. Complaint- is an expression of dissatisfaction relative to a financial product or service in which a response or resolution is expected. b. Simple complaint/request- complaint/ request where frontline staff solution or immediate explanation or action can be rendered. A resolution is immediate if it can be resolved without the need of third-party intervention, such as outsource service providers, external auditors, or other banks. Resolution thereof must be achieved within a 7-day period. c. Complex complaint/requestcomplaint/request which needs assessment, verification, or investigation with third-party intervention. Resolution thereof may ideally be achieved within a 45-day period. d. BSFIs- include banks, quasi-banks, pawnshops, foreign exchange dealers, money changers, remittance agents, electronic money issuers, non-stock savings and loan associations and other Bangko Sentral-Supervised Financial Institutions. e. Consumer- refers to a natural or juridical person who has a complaint, inquiry or request relative to the BSFI's products and services. IV. Role of the Board and Senior Management The board of BSFIs shall be responsible for the delivery of effective recourse to its consumers. Pursuant thereto, the board shall: a. Approve the consumer assistance policies and procedures; b. Approve risk assessment strategies relating to effective recourse by the consumer; c. Ensure compliance with consumer assistance policies and procedures; d. Provide adequate resources devoted to consumer assistance; and e. Review the consumer assistance policies at least annually. The BSFI's senior management shall be responsible for the implementation of the consumer assistance policies and procedures. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions Appendix S-10 - Page 1 APP. S-10 14.12.31 V. Minimum Requirements A. Manual of Consumer Assistance Policies and Procedures A BSFI must have a manual of policies and procedures (Manual) in handling consumer complaints, inquiries, and requests from financial consumers. The Manual, as a minimum, provide for the following: (1) Corporate structure of the group on consumer assistance with specified roles and responsibilities/tasks; (2) Capability building for customer assistance team; (3) Consumer assistance process and timeline; (4) Complaint recording/data management system; (5) Risk assessment strategies; (6) Reporting of complaints data to BSFI's board and senior management and Bangko Sentral; (7) System for evaluating effectiveness of the CAMS; and (8) Glossary of technical components in the Manual. B. Corporate Structure A BSFI shall have a consumer assistance officer/independent business unit or group with defined roles and responsibilities in handling consumer concerns. The corporate structure shall depend on the BSFI's asset size, as follows: Consumer Assistance Group Dedicated Head Consumer Assisstance Officer Head Consumer Assistance Officer BSFIs with total assets of at least P1.0 billion BSFIs with total assets of less than P1.0 billion but more than 100 million BSFIs with total assets of less than 100 million At least one (1) consumer assistance officer per branch, extension office or banking office must be designated to handle consumer concerns. Appendix S-10 - Page 2 (1) Consumer assistance officer. The consumer assistance officer shall have the following responsibilities: (a) Receive and acknowledge consumer concerns; (b) Record concerns in a Register/ Database; (c) Make an initial review and investigation of concerns; (d) Process concerns; (e) Provide official reply to consumer; (f) Request client feedback; and (g) Prepare and submit report to the head consumer assistance officer or consumer assistance group. (2) Consumer assistance group/head consumer assistance officer. The consumer assistance group/head consumer assistance officer shall, as a minimum, perform the following: (a) Monitor consumer assistance process; (b) Keep track, identify, and analyze the nature of complaints and recommend solutions to avoid recurrence; (c) Report to senior management the complaints received on a monthly basis including reasons for such complaints, the recommended solutions to avoid recurrence, and the suggestions for process or personnel competency needing improvement; and (d) Ensure immediate escalation of any significant complaint to concerned unit of the BSFI. C. Capacity building All consumer assistance personnel must be equipped with knowledge on the structure and implementation of the BSFI's consumer assistance mechanism. As a minimum, they shall be provided with periodic trainings on the following: (1) Solid interpersonal skills/customer service; (2) Basic and advanced listening skills; Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-10 14.12.31 (3) Written and verbal communication skills; (4) Handling financial consumer feedback; (5) Dealing with difficult people; (6) Problem solving and conflict resolution; and (7) BSFI's corporate structure and products and services. D. Publication of Consumer Assistance Management System (1) BSFI's shall publish details of their CAMS in a clear and plain language. (2) Publication shall be made through any two of the following means: (a) Posting of summary details of the CAMS in conspicuous places within the premises of BSFIs and their branches/other offices; (b) A leaflet or primer given to all consumers who sign up for new banking service. (c) Terms and Conditions of a BSFI's product or service; (d) Posting in the BSFI's website; and (e) Any analogous manner. E. Consumer Assistance Channels (1) Consumers may lodge their concerns through any reasonable means, such as, a centralized web-portal, walk-in or personal visit, letter, e-mail, telephone, and facsimile. (2) A BSFI must maintain a consumer assistance helpdesk or hotline dedicated for customer concerns and service and manned by a consumer assistance group. (3) A BSFI shall ensure that consumers know how and where to lodge their concerns. (4) A BSFI is encouraged to provide alternative modes of resolution, such as conciliation, mediation and arbitration, in order to achieve settlement of the issues at the BSFI level. 1 F. Consumer Assistance Process and Timelines (1) Complaint/Request SIMPLE1 COMPLEX1 Acknowledgment Within 2 days Within 2 days Processing and Within 7 days Within 45 days resolution (assess, investigate, and resolve) Communication Within 9 days Within 47 days of Resolution (a) Receiving and acknowledging complaints/requests (i) A BSFI shall obtain and record the following data from the consumer: (1) full name and contact details, (2) nature of complaint or request and its details; (3) resolution requested; (4) signature of the complainant/requester; and (5) name of BSFI personnel directly handling/in-charge of the complaint. (ii) The consumer assistance officer must be able to explain the consumer assistance process and timelines. (iii) The acknowledgment shall provide an assurance that the BSFI is dealing with the complaint, request additional documents, if necessary, and that the complainant shall be kept informed of the progress of the measures being taken for the complaint’s resolution (b) Investigating and resolving complaints (i) A BSFI must establish an institutional approach in assessing and investigating complaints/requests and options in resolving them, considering the peculiarities of the complaints/requests and the desired remedies of the party. (ii) If assessment and investigation on complex complaints/requests cannot be completed within the timeframe stated above, complainants shall be informed of all periods are reckoned from receipt of complaint. Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions Appendix S-10 - Page 3 APP. S-10 14.12.31 the: (aa) reason thereof; (bb) need for extended timeframe; and (cc) date on which the complainant may expect the outcome of the BSFI assessment and/or investigation; Provided, however, that the additional period shall not exceed forty-five (45) days. This will afford the complainants opportunity to seek other means to resolve their complaints. (iii) Result of assessment, investigation, and BSFI’s final response shall be communicated to the complainant in writing in simple and clear language. The BSFI shall likewise inform the complainant of the possible remedies available to the party, including resort to Bangko Sentral consumer assistance mechanism and the courts. (2) Inquiries A BFSI must respond to inquiries received, at the latest, by the next business day. G. Confidentiality A BSFI shall not disclose to a third party information acquired from the consumer in all stages of the complaint, except as may be required by the conduct of the BSFI’s investigation. H. Conflict of interest A BSFI shall ensure that complaints are investigated by a consumer assistance officer who is neither directly nor indirectly involved in the matter which is the subject of the complaint. I. Consumer Feedback (1) Subject to the willingness of the consumer, BSFIs shall ask for feedback on the following matters: (a) Overall satisfaction (whether satisfied, somewhat satisfied, or dissatisfied); (b) Processes needing improvement; (c) Personnel needing improvement; and (d) Any suggestions for improvement. (2) Consumer feedback may be obtained through a feedback form/ customer satisfaction survey available for walk-in complainants, in the website, or through a voice logger system. (3) Customer feedbacks shall be recorded and analyzed to improve the system and to enhance personnel capabilities in handling complaints. J. Complaints Recording/Data Management (1) A BSFI and its branches/other offices shall maintain copies of the complaints/requests received, including supporting and other relevant documents thereto, within a period of two (2) years from date of resolution. Microfilms/digital copies of original documents may be maintained by a BSFI in accordance with its management information systems for record keeping. (2) A BSFI and its branches/other offices shall maintain complaints/requests register which contains the following information: (a) Name of the complainant; (b) Subject/nature of the complaint; The subject/nature of complain may be indicated by classification, such as those related to credit cards, deposits, administrative, foreign exchange, remittances, investments, others; (c) Name of the personnel directly handling/in-charge of the complaint and officer supervising the resolution of the complaint; (d) Date of receipt of complaint by the BSFI; (e) Actions taken on the complaint or request; (f) Resolution provided; (g) Date of resolution 1; and (h) Other information such as, log and details of phone calls made or received. (3) The Consumer assistance group/head consumer assistance officer shall maintain: 1 The complaint register must reveal the reason in case the date of resolution falls outside the regulatory deadline. Appendix S-10 - Page 4 Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions APP. S-10 14.12.31 (a) A master register of all complaints received by the BSFIs and its branches/ other offices; and (b) A complaint database to identify the trend of complaints received, potential problems, and risks. K. Risk Assessment Strategies Pursuant to the BSFI’s consumer protection risk management system, the BSFI shall put in place appropriate management controls and take reasonable steps to ensure that in handling complaints/requests, it: (1) identifies and remedies any recurring or systemic problems; and (2) identifies weaknesses in the BSFI’s internal control procedure or process. This may be done by: (a) Analyzing complaints/requests data; (b) Analyzing causes for complaints/ requests; (c) Considering whether such identified weaknesses may also affect other processes or products, including those not directly complained of/requested; and (d) Correcting, whether reasonable to do so, such causes taking into consideration the concomitant costs and other resources. L. Complaint Reporting (1) Internal Reporting (a) The consumer assistance officers in the branches, extensions office and other offices of the BSFI shall submit a complaints report to the consumer assistance group / head consumer assistance officer on a monthly basis. (b) Complaints report shall be submitted on a monthly basis by the consumer assistance group/head consumer assistance officer to the board and senior management. (c) The report shall include, as a minimum: (i) General category of complaints received; (ii) Statistics/frequency of said complaints; (iii) Aging of complaints or requests; (iv) Explanations on deviations, if any, from required resolution period; and (v) General description of resolutions and actions taken to resolve complaints/ requests; (d) The report shall include recommendation on how to avoid recurring complaints and suggestions for process/ personnel competency improvement, as needed. (e) The report of the BSFI’s compliance and internal audit departments concerning the independent review conducted on the complaints report, policy recommendations, and consumer protection compliance, shall be elevated to Board every quarter. (f) The BSFI shall include complaints/ requests statistics in its Annual Report. (2) Reporting to the Bangko Sentral A BSFI shall submit a consolidated Complaints Report to the Supervisory Data Center (SDC) of the Supervision and Examination Sector on a quarterly basis. Such report shall be submitted in the format required by Bangko Sentral. Submission of the report to the SDC shall not be later than one (1) month after the end of every quarter. A Complaints Report is a Category B Report for purposes of applying the appropriate monetary penalty. M. Interface with Bangko Sentral (1) Pursuant to Bangko Sentral’s Consumer Protection Framework, a BSFI shall exhaust all internal remedies available to address the issues raised by the consumers in their complaints/requests. (2) Consumers dissatisfied with BSFI’s response or action may seek assistance with BSP-FCPD (previously FCAG) in accordance with Bangko Sentral Consumer Assistance Mechanism. (3) Allegations of consumers that the BSFI has not properly and efficiently handled, processed, and responded to their concerns shall be validated, and where Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions Appendix S-10 - Page 5 APP. S-10 14.12.31 appropriate, considered in FCPD’s (previously FCAG) assessment of the BSFI’s compliance with Bangko Sentral Consumer Protection regulations. This is without prejudice to the imposition of appropriate enforcement actions. It is presumed that the higher number of complaints received by the Bangko Sentral reflects the noneffectiveness of the BSFI’s CAMS. N. Outsourcing of Handling Consumer Concerns In outsourcing handling of consumer concerns, a BSFI shall: (1) Conduct due diligence in the selection of the outsourced entity/person; (2) Be responsible for the performance thereof in the same manner and to the same extent as if performed by itself; (3) Comply with all laws and regulations governing the consumer assistance activities/services performed by the outsource entity/person in its behalf; and (4) Manage, monitor, and review on an ongoing basis the performance by the Appendix S-10 - Page 6 outsource entity/person of the outsourced consumer assistance activities/services. O. Accountability and Rewards In order to ensure fair treatment and responsible business conduct of personnel engaged in consumer relations, a performance appraisal system which considers the performance of the personnel assigned to manage/handle complaints shall be put in place. The performance appraisal of the personnel shall be linked to their efficiency in handling consumer complaints. This could be done through rewards/ remuneration for excellent behavior. P. Consumer Assistance to Persons with Disabilities (PWDs) and non-English Speakers As far as practicable, a BSFI shall take into account the needs of PWDs, such as, but not limited to those with learning difficulties, people who are deaf or hard of hearing, the visually impaired, and the nonEnglish speakers, in ensuring that they understand the CAMS. (Circular No. 857 dated 21 November 2014) Manual of Regulations for Non-Bank Financial Institutions