Assessment of Municipal Solid Waste Management (MSWM) in Kuwait Submitted By ٍ Sadeq H. Muqeem Arabian Gulf University College of Graduate Studies Environmental Management Program Supervised By Dr. Lamya F. Mohammed Contents Presentation Outline 1. Introduction 2. Literature Review 3. Methodology 4. Results of Analysis 4.1 Results of DPSIR Analysis 4.2 Results of General Data Analysis 5. Findings and Recommendations Introduction Preface Due to: The continuous increase in population, Urbanization, and Socio-economic factors (lifestyle and unsustainable pattern of consumption), Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) quantities has been increasing and its composition changing Introduction Study material (MSW) Types MSW consists of household solid waste including construction and demolition debris, slaughterhouses’ wastes, sanitation residue, and waste from streets Sources Mainly from residential areas, and Non hazardous solid waste that is generated from commercial complexes, and industrial sectors. Introduction Problem Definition The continuous increase in MSW that followed by: The increase in SWM services cost. Negative landfills impacts. Challenges in land scarcity. Introduction Study Significant Provide insights on effective options for the MSW, and boundary the targeted challenges to avoid the escalation of the solid waste problem in Kuwait. Prioritize the main MSWM gaps in Kuwait for future effective management. Increase workforce and public awareness on handling the different types of MSW. Provide a baseline for futuristic studies regarding solid waste in Kuwait. Introduction Study Objectives 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Review the general MSW issues in Kuwait. Understand the key MSWM stakeholders and their roles. Document the current MSWM practices in Kuwait. Analyze the current MSWM situation in Kuwait to identify any gaps and highlight the negative and positive conducts. Provide recommendation Literature Review Literature Review A. Solid Waste Management and Recycling Practices 1. Definitions and Types of Solid Waste 2. General Solid Waste Management Issues (Barlaz and others, 2003), (Shehata and others, 2004) 3. Legislation Related to Waste Management (Skumatz, 2002) 4. Recycling Technologies (2004 ،)الهاجري 5. Solid Waste Recycling Practices in GCC Countries (1998 ،)أبوعشي, (Alhumoud, 2005) B. Municipal Solid Waste Management (MSWM) in Kuwait 1. General Management Issues (1995 ،)بلدية الكويت, (1998 ،)العازمي, (2000 ،)بلدية الكويت 2. Landfill Management and Rehabilitation (EPA, 2005), (2005 ،)الفرج Methodology Methodology Data Collection (descriptive overview) 1. Literature Review. 2. Official environmental documents regarding municipal and/or household solid waste issued by governmental and related institutions in Kuwait. 3. Field visits and Interviews. Analysis (analytical approach) 1. Driving Forces, Pressures, State, Impacts, and Responses (DPSIR) 2. General Data Analysis Methodology DPSIR Framework Source: Http://reports.eea.europa.eu, and (Arendse and Godfrey, 2001) Results of Analysis Results of DPSIR Analysis Driving Forces Average Population Growth Rate (2.8%) from 1.85 millions (1997) to 2.45 (2005) Demand on land for housing Lack of awareness (workforce and Public) Socioeconomics (lifestyle and consumption pattern, family size and income) Driving Forces Changing in Household Solid Waste Composition Glass 5% Metals 5% Other 7% Plastics 13% Food & Vegetables 52% Paper 18% Source: 1995 ،بلدية الكويت Driving Forces Family Income Vs Quantity of Solid Waste in Kuwait 15 Ab 00 ov e 15 00 0 0- 0- 90 0 70 0- 70 0 50 030 90 Le ss th an 30 50 0 Quantity of Solid Waste (Kgm / Day) 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Family Income (K.D/Month) Source: Koushki and Al-Khaleefi, 1998 Driving Forces Family Size Vs Quantity of Solid Waste in Kuwait Quantity of Solid Waste (Kgm / Day) 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 1 2 3 to 5 6 to 8 9 to 11 Above 11 Family Members Source: Koushki and Al-Khaleefi, 1998 Results of Analysis Results of DPSIR Analysis Pressures Increase in MSW Lack of effective SWM (still most of MSW is land filled). There no regulatory requirements for any of the 3R’s practices in Kuwait. Lack of landfill design and operation (criteria, landfill site lifespan, data collection system, ..,etc). There is no enforcement for the available landfill regulations. Increase in required areas for housing State of Environment The Increase Rate of Total MSW in Kuwait from 1999 to 2005 8000000 6000000 Tons 4000000 2000000 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Year 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 Household SW 910,3 852,9 1,006, 1,059, 976,1 1,107, 1,113, Total MSW 3,973, 4,983, 5,274, 6,050, 5,072, 5,247, 5,779, Source: Kuwait Municipality, Landfill Sites Management Department State of Environment The Increase Rate of Household SW in Kuwait from 1995 to 2005 Household SW in Tons 1,200,000 1,000,000 800,000 600,000 400,000 200,000 0 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 Year Source: Kuwait Municipality, Landfill Sites Management Department Pressures Improper Land Filling Operation Source: Researcher, 2006 Pressure / State of Environment The Main MSW Landfill Sites in Kuwait Landfill Site Type of Waste Area Km2 Status Period Al-Gurain Household 0.7 Closed Closed 1984 Jelieb Al-Sheukh Household + Constructional Debris 5.49 Closed 1970 - 1992 Subhan Constructional Debris 0.49 Closed 1980 - 1986 Failaka Household + Constructional Debris - Open - Sulaibiyah Household + Constructional Debris + Wastewater 2.7 Closed 1982 - 2005 Al-Maseela Household+ Constructional Debris 1.79 Closed 1984 - 1992 Mena'a Abdu'ALLAH Household + Constructional Debris + Wastewater 1.14 Open Since 1991 Southern 7th Ring Road Household 4.2 Open Since 1992 Northern 7th Ring Road Constructional Debris (Closed in 2005) + Wastewater (Open) 4.8 - Since 1986 Kabd Poultry + Cattle wastes ( Partially Open) 0.37 Closed 1999 - 2001 Al-Jahra Constructional Debris + Wastewater 1.72 Open Since 1986 Al-Wafra Household + Constructional Debris - Closed - Al-Ogaila Household + Constructional Debris 0.11 Closed - Al-Yarmouk Constructional Debris 0.5 Closed - Al-Shuaibah Constructional Debris - Closed 1986 - 1992 Eastern Sulaibiyah Constructional Debris 0.17 Closed Closed 1987 Source: Kuwait Municipality, Landfill Sites Management Department Results of Analysis Results of DPSIR Analysis State or State of Environment (SoE) MSW Generation (the Average Rate for the Total MSW for last five years was 5 millions of tons / year, and Per Capita household is 1.4 Kg / day) Increase in required areas for land filling (current estimation for exploited area for land filling is about 25 square Km) Landfill sites proximity to residential areas State of Environment Average per Capita Household/MSW (Kg / Day) in GCC and Some Arabian Countries Country Per Capita Household Solid Waste (Kg / Day) Kuwait 1.4 Saudi Arabia 1.4 Qatar 1.3 UAE 1.2 Bahrain 1.3 Oman 0.7 Average 1.2 Country Per Capita Household Solid Waste (Kg / Day) Egypt 0.81 Syria 0.33 Tunis 0.41 Morocco 0.33 Jordan 0.6 Yemen 0.6 Average 0.5 Source: 2005 ،الفرج Pressure / State of Environment Main MSW Landfill Sites Location Spotted on Kuwait Map Source: www.greenline.com.kw Results of Analysis Results of DPSIR Analysis Impacts Effects on health & Env. (Undesirable odors, waste self-burning, insects, rodents, strayed dogs, .. , etc) Increase in SWM services cost From 17 millions KD (1995) to 20 millions KD (2000) Total cost of collection & transportation from 2002 to 2005 was 34.6 millions KD Cost of the current three years contract of 1.24 million KD for only land filling operations by a monthly billing payment of 34.500 KD Challenges in land scarcity issue (167,000 square meters used for land filling back in 1997 = a residential area of more than 200 houses of 400 square meters each) Increase in Landfill Gases (LFG) CH4, CO2, NOx, H2S, Dioxin, .. Impacts The Total Annual Gaseous Emission from Household Solid Waste Imported to Landfills in Kuwait (1994 - 2003) Year Household Solid Waste (Ton) Annual Gaseous Emissions / M3 1994 895,125 116,366,250 1995 715,750 93,047,500 1996 501,325 65,172,250 1997 746,585 97,056,050 1998 802,500 104,325,000 1999 910,320 118,341,600 2000 852,995 110,889,350 2001 1,006,135 130,797,550 2002 1,059,880 137,784,400 2003 976,185 126,904,050 Source: 2005 ،الفرج Results of Analysis Results of DPSIR Analysis Responses Collection & Transportation Services are highly efficient Land filling most of generated MSW Small-scaled recycling practices Environmental Preservation Industrial Co. (EPIC) for construction waste and demolition debris Closed Landfill sites rehabilitation (reactive response) Policies + new programs and/or strategies (still not enforced) Responses Solid Waste Recycling Practices in Kuwait Enterprise Activity Recycling Capacity (Tons) Scale Status Gulf Co. (Paper) Paper 3000 Large Licensed Aluminum 4 Iron 20 Med. Licensed Paper 400 Paper 1500 Med. Licensed Aluminum 2 Iron 10 Small Not-Licensed Paper 450 Aluminum 20 Med. Licensed Iron 40 Iron 450 Large Licensed Aluminum 5 Small Not-Licensed Iron 18 Aluminum 3 Small Not-Licensed Iron 23 Aluminum 7 Small Not-Licensed Iron 10 Gulf Co. (Glass) Glass 2000 Large Licensed Al-Arabiyah (Metals) Aluminum 400 Large Licensed Kuwait Aluminum Aluminum 600 Large Licensed Al-Arfaj AL-Wataniyah (Paper) Anwar Al-Funaitees Al-Wataniyah (Metals) Al-Sakb Abbas Mohammed Mohammed and Nasari Merza and Sardar Source: 2004 ،الهاجري Responses Percentage of Wastes Recycled in Kuwait Waste Recycled Annual Waste Quantity in Tons Annual Recycled Quantity in Tons Recycled Percentage Paper 186,000 115,000 85% Aluminum 400 - 600 - - Glass 30,000 600 - 1800 5 – 15% Plastics - - - Source: 2004 ،الهاجري Responses Reactive Response Landfill Rehabilitation Degassing the site and leachate collection for most closed landfills Self-Producing electricity for the surrounding area for couples of landfills The free electricity would also pump water which will be used to help transform the area into green parks for public recreation Bio- Gas Transformer Technology (Researcher, 2006) Responses Reactive Response Example on Landfill Rehabilitation AlGurain Rehabilitated Landfill Site (Researcher, 2006) Results of Analysis General Data Analysis MSW Stakeholders and their role in MSWM in Kuwait Stakeholder Role Government (Council of Ministries) Environmental Laws and Policies (Divide Responsibilities) Law 21/1995 amended by law 16/1996 Kuwait Municipality Regulations, Guidelines, and supervision Kuwait EPA Landfill Sites Monitoring and Rehabilitation Public Waste Generation and unofficial sorting Waste Transporters Collection and Transportation Small-Scaled Firms Segregation , Recycling, and Reuse Landfill Contractors Disposal activities, Landfill Site Operation, and Maintenances Environmental Preservation Industrial Company (EPIC) Large-scaled Construction Wastes and Demolition Debris Recycling Facility Source: Submitted by the researcher Results of Analysis General Data Analysis Types of Total MSW in Kuwait Household SW 19% Construction Debris 76% Large Waste 5% Results of Analysis General Data Analysis Per Capita Household SW (Kg / day) Per Capita Household Solid Waste In Kuwait (1995 – 2005) 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 Results of Analysis HSW Increasing Rate to Population Growth Rate General Data Analysis HSW Increasing Rate to Population Growth Rate 15 10 5 0 -5 19951996 19961997 19971998 19981999 19992000 20002001 Year 20012002 20022003 20032004 20042005 Results of Analysis General Data Analysis Per Capita MSW (Kg / Day) Per Capita MSW In Kuwait (1999 – 2005) 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Results of Analysis General Data Analysis MSW Increasing Rate to Population Growth Rate MSW Increasing Rate to Population Growth Rate 6 4 2 0 -2 1999-2000 2000-2001 2001-2002 2002-2003 2003-2004 2004-2005 -4 -6 -8 Year Results of Analysis General Data Analysis Inverted Waste Pyramid Source: http://www.gdrc.org Findings and Recommendations Findings The only applied study conducted regarding the actual composition and quantities of the daily household solid waste in Kuwait was done by Kuwait Municipality in 1995. Deficiency in solid waste data collection in Kuwait. Solid waste data collection process in Kuwait is still conventional and insufficient. There are no specific regulatory requirements for at-source segregation, reuse, and recycling. Findings and Recommendations Findings Cont. There are no firms for recycling or composting food (organic) wastes. Most of closed landfill sites (10 out of 16) are in close proximity to residential areas. Open Landfill sites are still operated improperly. The most recycled materials are paper and cartoons, Glass recycled materials, and small quantities of metals. Findings and Recommendations Recommendations 1. Further studies to be conducted in order to update information related to types, and quantities of MSW, and cost of SWM. 2. MSW inventory control system (Data collection that based on modern systems and recording technologies shall be provided). 3. EPIC for construction waste and demolition debris should be well organized and effectively operated. Findings and Recommendations Recommendations Cont. 4. Establishment of household solid waste reception/storage centers especially for food wastes (organic matters) in order to utilize them for recycling. 5. Effective regulatory regulations regarding atsource segregation. 6. Since most of MSW is land filled in Kuwait, enforcement of landfill regulations and effective landfill management is considered an essential issue. Thank You